”You may be normal, but you’re special to me.”
Valentine’s Day rears its dramatic head once more, this time fuelled by Manbagi’s intention to confess to Tadano when she hands over her chocolate. But can you get what you want and still come out on the losing end of it?
Sometimes this manga is okay, sometimes it is very good, and, when it truly needs to be, it can be utterly brilliant. And when it comes to the climax of shredding poor Manbagi’s dreams of Tadano, it handles the situation with more aplomb than I would have granted it capable of.
The poor girl’s confession is dragged over several chapters of Valentine’s Day antics, including another heartbreaker of a moment between Naruse and Ase (hammer well deserved). I liked how they can’t seem to find a traditional confession spot because they’re all in use too.
What I really loved about this is that it gives Manbagi exactly what she wants, but she’s mature enough to know that it’s not, truly, what Tadano wants and she gently pushes him to confront that, even if it crushes her dreams in the process. It was an out that I didn’t see coming, plus it gives her that line I opened the review with, which is just so… perfectly put.
This results in Tadano forcing Komi’s hand, who was too nervous herself, and this leads to a very, very sweet series of panels as the coupling officially begins. Which also pays off later when the two are now dating but can barely maintain eye contact without melting down in a great series of short chapters.
And it turns out that being as boisterous (read: loud) as she is, Manbagi’s pain does not exist in a vacuum. Her support group is amazing and she gets closure with both Tadano and Komi (the latter section gives the mangaka an excuse for a boob shot that I appreciate the story at least literally admits he just wanted to draw).
Toss in a hilarious section where Tadano’s sister completely mis-deduces who gave her brother which chocolates, plus an ancient proverb that sums up Najimi’s character in one fell swoop and you have basically the perfect volume of this series.
Almost.
Please be advised that my usual rant about Yamai will now occur, so you can avoid the next couple paragraphs if you feel you’ve gotten the gist with the last dozen or more volumes.
I’ve never seen a manga so quickly burn through an incredible amount of accumulated goodwill as this one does with the Yamai chapters. I’m sorry, jokes about date rape drugs are NOT funny and, exaggerated for effect or no, I just cannot even.
It’s even more annoying because this is perilously close to being a great chapter itself, as Komi tries to acknowledge Yamai while also letting her down gently. As usual, the latter is written with the grace of a mud-spattered hog on a freshly made bed and it deftly soured me far more than was necessary.
Sigh. Anyway, adjust your ratings based on your tolerance. I think it’s fair to say that Yamai is one of my most-loathed characters in manga history just because she often ruins an otherwise great series, case in point. She’s just a walking sexual assault joke and, well, no thanks. It’s even worse when the surrounding material is so incredibly strong.
4 stars - it is really, really annoying that the whole love triangle got resolved in a way that I unreservedly enjoyed with some of the best writing this story has done, and it’s funny to boot, then it just has to bring in the black fly in the Chardonnay. Sadly, that dragged me totally out of the story, but, if you do not care about such things, I think the manga’s rarely been better.