What do you think?
Rate this book
西方人文经典讲演录
本书分为四册《西方的起源》《帝国的兴衰》《自由的黎明》《现代的诞生》，为读者提供西方人文经典阅读的必要知识，挑选在社会文化变革之际显示思想力量的文本，进行深入浅出的导读，引导出更为广阔深入的思考。所涉经典贯串三千年西方思想演变史，从影响西方世界最为深远的古希腊，一路走过罗马帝国的兴衰、早期基督教的兴起，穿过并不完全黑暗的中世纪、璀璨丰富的文艺复兴，最终抵达我们生活的现代。通过本书，可以与柏拉图、但丁、莎士比亚、卢梭等七十余位人类历史上的智者，《奥德赛》《理想国》《堂吉诃德》等九十余部西方最重要的经典著作展开对话。作者认为，人文经典阅读贵在自己独立的思考，阅读是必须的准备，思考才是真正目标。
2372 pages, Hardcover
Published January 1, 2024
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 of 1 review
March 8, 2025
The first book review from me.
I. The Core Spirit of Ancient Greek Classics
1. Humanism and Self-Criticism
• The core of Greek thought lies in the reflection on the darker side of human nature (such as arrogance, tyranny, and the fragility of justice), emphasizing the enhancement of civic virtue through reason and morality.
• Key texts: Homer’s epics Odyssey and Iliad, Hesiod’s Theogony and Works and Days.
2. The Duality of Heroism
• Heroes in Homeric epics (such as Odysseus) embody both wisdom and human weaknesses, representing the conflict between public pressure in a “shame culture” and individual free will.
• Insight: Modern democratic systems must recognize the limitations of human nature and constrain power through institutions rather than relying solely on moral ideals.
II. Tragedy and the Dilemmas of Human Nature
1. Fate and Free Will
• Aeschylus’ Oresteia replaces blood feud with judicial judgment, marking the transition of humanity from violence to the rule of law.
• Sophocles’ Oedipus Rex explores the boundary between “knowledge” and “wisdom,” with tragic wisdom lying in accepting the harsh truth.
2. The Collectivity of Violence
• Euripides’ The Bacchae reveals the roots of collective frenzy and violence in human nature, hinting at the loss of individual reason in totalitarian societies.
III. History and Political Philosophy
1. Herodotus and Thucydides’ Views on History
• Herodotus’ Histories: Emphasizes a multicultural perspective, recording the struggle between freedom and despotism in the Greco-Persian wars, highlighting “human stories” over “the will of the gods.”
• Thucydides’ History of the Peloponnesian War: Analyzes the moral decay caused by the expansion of power and introduces the “Thucydides Trap” (the inevitability of conflict between rising and established powers).
2. Forms of Government and Human Nature
• Plato’s Republic: Critiques both democracy and despotism, advocating for philosopher-kings, but acknowledging that institutional evil corrupts human nature.
• Aristotle’s Politics: Argues that the form of government shapes the character of citizens, with democracy requiring equal participation, and despotism creating servility and fear.
IV. Philosophy and Civic Enlightenment
1. Socrates’ Critical Spirit
• Through the method of questioning (elenchus), Socrates exposes moral hypocrisy, maintaining that “the unexamined life is not worth living,” ultimately defending intellectual freedom with his death.
• Insight: Civil disobedience must be based on reason and justice, with vigilance against the tyranny of the majority.
2. Enlightenment and Skepticism
• Xenophon’s Hiero analyzes the psychology of tyrants: fear, isolation, and reliance on informants, showing how institutional evil leads to moral decay.
• Milton’s Areopagitica: Advocates for the “free marketplace of ideas,” opposing censorship and emphasizing the capacity for rational self-correction.
V. Modern Insights
1. The Fragility of Democracy
• The failure of Athenian democracy serves as a warning: the tyranny of the majority, populist leaders stirring up passions, and political apathy can all destroy a free system.
• Thucydides on the corruption of language: In extreme conditions, words like “justice” and “freedom” are twisted into tools of power.
2. The Psychological Mechanism of Totalitarianism
• Both Plato and Aristotle pointed out that despotism maintains control by creating fear, poverty, and isolation, while citizen unity is key to resistance.
3. The Significance of Humanistic Education
• Xu Bin emphasizes that reading classics should “activate a sense of questioning,” drawing inspiration from ancient Greek thought to fuel modern enlightenment and institutional reform.
Conclusion: The Timeless Value of Humanistic Spirit
• The core of the ancient Greek classics is not the answer but the ability to ask questions and engage in critical thinking.
• Xu Bin calls for cultivating an “intuition for distinguishing right from wrong” through reading, in order to resist blind obedience, lies, and the alienation of power in contemporary society, becoming a citizen with independent judgment.
Keywords: Heroism, Rule of law replacing violence, Forms of government and human nature, Civic unity, Rational skepticism, Freedom of the press, Enlightenment critique.
I. The Core Spirit of Ancient Greek Classics
1. Humanism and Self-Criticism
• The core of Greek thought lies in the reflection on the darker side of human nature (such as arrogance, tyranny, and the fragility of justice), emphasizing the enhancement of civic virtue through reason and morality.
• Key texts: Homer’s epics Odyssey and Iliad, Hesiod’s Theogony and Works and Days.
2. The Duality of Heroism
• Heroes in Homeric epics (such as Odysseus) embody both wisdom and human weaknesses, representing the conflict between public pressure in a “shame culture” and individual free will.
• Insight: Modern democratic systems must recognize the limitations of human nature and constrain power through institutions rather than relying solely on moral ideals.
II. Tragedy and the Dilemmas of Human Nature
1. Fate and Free Will
• Aeschylus’ Oresteia replaces blood feud with judicial judgment, marking the transition of humanity from violence to the rule of law.
• Sophocles’ Oedipus Rex explores the boundary between “knowledge” and “wisdom,” with tragic wisdom lying in accepting the harsh truth.
2. The Collectivity of Violence
• Euripides’ The Bacchae reveals the roots of collective frenzy and violence in human nature, hinting at the loss of individual reason in totalitarian societies.
III. History and Political Philosophy
1. Herodotus and Thucydides’ Views on History
• Herodotus’ Histories: Emphasizes a multicultural perspective, recording the struggle between freedom and despotism in the Greco-Persian wars, highlighting “human stories” over “the will of the gods.”
• Thucydides’ History of the Peloponnesian War: Analyzes the moral decay caused by the expansion of power and introduces the “Thucydides Trap” (the inevitability of conflict between rising and established powers).
2. Forms of Government and Human Nature
• Plato’s Republic: Critiques both democracy and despotism, advocating for philosopher-kings, but acknowledging that institutional evil corrupts human nature.
• Aristotle’s Politics: Argues that the form of government shapes the character of citizens, with democracy requiring equal participation, and despotism creating servility and fear.
IV. Philosophy and Civic Enlightenment
1. Socrates’ Critical Spirit
• Through the method of questioning (elenchus), Socrates exposes moral hypocrisy, maintaining that “the unexamined life is not worth living,” ultimately defending intellectual freedom with his death.
• Insight: Civil disobedience must be based on reason and justice, with vigilance against the tyranny of the majority.
2. Enlightenment and Skepticism
• Xenophon’s Hiero analyzes the psychology of tyrants: fear, isolation, and reliance on informants, showing how institutional evil leads to moral decay.
• Milton’s Areopagitica: Advocates for the “free marketplace of ideas,” opposing censorship and emphasizing the capacity for rational self-correction.
V. Modern Insights
1. The Fragility of Democracy
• The failure of Athenian democracy serves as a warning: the tyranny of the majority, populist leaders stirring up passions, and political apathy can all destroy a free system.
• Thucydides on the corruption of language: In extreme conditions, words like “justice” and “freedom” are twisted into tools of power.
2. The Psychological Mechanism of Totalitarianism
• Both Plato and Aristotle pointed out that despotism maintains control by creating fear, poverty, and isolation, while citizen unity is key to resistance.
3. The Significance of Humanistic Education
• Xu Bin emphasizes that reading classics should “activate a sense of questioning,” drawing inspiration from ancient Greek thought to fuel modern enlightenment and institutional reform.
Conclusion: The Timeless Value of Humanistic Spirit
• The core of the ancient Greek classics is not the answer but the ability to ask questions and engage in critical thinking.
• Xu Bin calls for cultivating an “intuition for distinguishing right from wrong” through reading, in order to resist blind obedience, lies, and the alienation of power in contemporary society, becoming a citizen with independent judgment.
Keywords: Heroism, Rule of law replacing violence, Forms of government and human nature, Civic unity, Rational skepticism, Freedom of the press, Enlightenment critique.
Displaying 1 of 1 review