I was given an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review and that's exactly what I'm gonna give. Luckily for me, I loved this book, so that saves me having to write something awkward. Amato has obviously done an enormous amount of research (he mentions Carolyne Larrington and Tom Shippey in the credits) but he hasn't just reproduced or imitated Norse myths. He's not drinking from the Eagle-as-Odin ass drippings of the mead imbibed by those who settle for adequacy. He's reaching for real inspiration here (even while his protagonist Ansgar wisely is wary of Odin's gifts). A student of Norse, Germanic and Finnish mythology and religion will recognise the various source material but it's woven into a truly original story here. I really appreciate his depictions of seidr and galdrar.
Many second books in a series suffer a bit of a lag but not here. I think both the writing and story have gotten even better (and I really liked the first book a lot).
Rune to Ruin continues Ansgar's journey as a young Skald with the crew of the Sea Squirrel. It picks up not long after the end of the first book. The pacing of the story is really well done- just enough tension and action, interspersed with the larger mystery of Ansgar's prophetic dreams and own life story he's trying to solve. I was drawn in and invested in the story immediately.
The characters are wonderfully written- Innstein and Utsteinn might be my favourite side characters but I have a special fondness for Svipul, Ansgar's fylgja and Huld the volva. All of them have their own distinct voices and motivations, which makes for a richly woven story. His female characters, of which there are several, are written with as much diversity, agency and depth as his male characters.
Like the first book, there's a lot of humour, (and not just with Humour the raven), wonderful riddles, puns and heiti. But also a lot of grief which is sensitively and thoughtfully written. A lot of times in fantasy, especially heroic or Norse inspired, the consequences really aren't fully felt by the main protagonist. But here, the story hinges precisely on Ansgar feeling the full brunt of everything, especially in only seeing afterwards what a prophecy was hinting at. Tragic and truly unfair. Or is it? Do we change our fate or make it come about because we tried to? How much of our fate is immutable and how much rests in us heeding a warning in time? All of this humour and grief (and sometimes the lines blur between the two) is very Norse. You'd die laughing, I suppose.
Amato has become one of my favourite authors. I expect he'll become famous, or at least achieve "word-fame" with a certain subset of fantasy readers. I think he does Norse styled fantasy better than just about any writer today and that's really saying something. I'm really looking forward to the 3rd and final book in the series!
Highly recommend.