What do you think?
Rate this book
Girl Under Glass
Girl Under Glass is the story of a rootless, rebellious young girl sinking deeper into juvenile delinquency. Given one more chance to avoid juvenile hall, a judge assigns her to community service with a cranky botanist studying plant communication. When he is beaten and left for dead, Kelsey must convince the lead detective that an entire greenhouse full of plants is witness to the crime, and she knows how to prove it.
Girl Under Glass builds on the intriguing science behind The Secret Life of Plants, What Plants Know, The Hidden Life of Trees, and Finding the Mother Tree, all dealing with the cutting-edge research being conducted into the ability of plants to warn other plants of invasions of predatory beetles and certain diseases, and to alter their chemistry from tasty to toxic.
Girl Under Glass builds on the intriguing science behind The Secret Life of Plants, What Plants Know, The Hidden Life of Trees, and Finding the Mother Tree, all dealing with the cutting-edge research being conducted into the ability of plants to warn other plants of invasions of predatory beetles and certain diseases, and to alter their chemistry from tasty to toxic.
257 pages, Paperback
First published May 29, 2024
About the author
Ginny Rorby
18 books146 followersGinny Rorby was raised in Winter Park, Florida, and lived in Miami during her career as a Pan American flight attendant. Midway through that career, she enrolled in the University of Miami to pursue an undergraduate degree in biology, graduated and changed direction again. She went on to receive an MFA in Creative Writing from Florida International University. Her goal, after wrapping up her flying career and her graduate studies, was to move someplace where she would never be hot again. She now lives on the chilly coast of northern California. Ginny is the author 6 novels for Middle Grade and Young Adults readers: Freeing Finch, How to Speak Dolphin, Lost in the River of Grass, winner of the 2012 / 2013 Sunshine State Young Readers Award; Hurt Go Happy, winner of the 2008 American Library Association’s Schneider Family Book Award. The Outside of a Horse and Dolphin Sky. Ginny is a past director of the Mendocino Coast Writers’ Conference.
Her most recent novel, Like Dust, I Rise, is a Coming of Age novel set in Texas during the Dust Bowl.
Her most recent novel, Like Dust, I Rise, is a Coming of Age novel set in Texas during the Dust Bowl.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
May 16, 2024
Superb fiction for 8/9 years and up to the oldest of readers. I needed hankies at the end of this ultimately feel good story. Kelsey, 13, has been let down badly by her mother, and finds herself in trouble with the law. Because of this she ends up very reluctantly having to help an eccentric Botanist, and finds out plants can do much more than just look pretty. Over time, in tragedy and laughter, she finds the commitment and care she has been lacking throughout her life. Thank you to Black Rose Writing (who have so many good books to shout about) and NetGalley for the ARC. The views expressed are all mine, freely given.
April 28, 2024
I always knew plants could communicate. Now I know they can help solve crimes. Girl Under Glass introduces us to Kelsey, a troubled teen living in a small town in Northern California. Kelsey got herself in a little bit of trouble with the law. To avoid time in juvenile hall, she’s given the chance to do community service by being a helper to a crotchety old botanist. Kelsey hates her life. She must take care of her alcoholic mother while trying to manage school and find her place with her squad of friends. Then the worst happens, and juvie seems like the better deal. With the help of the caring botanist, an understanding detective, an adorable cat, and a sensitive plant, Kelsey saves the day AND finds her way. Ginny Rorby has crafted a captivating mystery while providing the reader with a little science knowledge.
November 1, 2025
Lots going on in this middle grade/young adult novel that I enjoyed as an older adult. The plant experiments were very interesting too. Great characters. I hope there is a sequel!
January 29, 2026
This story plucked a lot of nerves, having grown up with an alcoholic father and having been caught shoplifting once. I thought back to all the twists and turns growing up. Some were happenstance. But most were people God/The Universe brought into my life (like Hobby, in this story) who helped me grow up to be someone very different from my father. I have tried to be a Hobby to other kids throughout my adult life and hope and pray I did well. And that’s the point: pay it forward. Thanks, Ginny, for your good work in writing this story.
June 9, 2024
Excellent read!
I'm 72, and still enjoy YA novels. The premise of this one really intrigued me. I'm a nature photographer, and the idea that plants could be witnesses to a crime sounded a bit far-fetched but grabbed my attention. Of course the title has a double-meaning: a girl working in a greenhouse who is also "under the glass" of local law enforcement. Kelsey has basically raised herself, as well as taking care of her alcoholic mother, who has told her that her father died. She manages money, goes grocery shopping, worries about her Mom's drinking and smoking, goes to school, and does some shoplifting on the side. Given the chance by a judge to work with an eccentric botanist, she gradually begins to realize that there might be a different person inside her shell. This book is well-written, has good insight into alcoholism and teenage angst. The idea that plants can actually "feel" and respond--based on research--adds scientific interest to the story. YA or not, readers should give this one a try. I found it hard to put down.
I'm 72, and still enjoy YA novels. The premise of this one really intrigued me. I'm a nature photographer, and the idea that plants could be witnesses to a crime sounded a bit far-fetched but grabbed my attention. Of course the title has a double-meaning: a girl working in a greenhouse who is also "under the glass" of local law enforcement. Kelsey has basically raised herself, as well as taking care of her alcoholic mother, who has told her that her father died. She manages money, goes grocery shopping, worries about her Mom's drinking and smoking, goes to school, and does some shoplifting on the side. Given the chance by a judge to work with an eccentric botanist, she gradually begins to realize that there might be a different person inside her shell. This book is well-written, has good insight into alcoholism and teenage angst. The idea that plants can actually "feel" and respond--based on research--adds scientific interest to the story. YA or not, readers should give this one a try. I found it hard to put down.
April 9, 2024
Thank you Netgalley and Black Rose Writing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
"Girl Under Glass" by Ginny Rorby delivers an engaging story that blends elements of science and suspense, all centered around a girl experiencing kindness and compassion when she has lived a life largely lacking in those experiences. At its core, it's a story of redemption and unlikely alliances, such as with a quirky botanist and a kind-hearted detective, set against the backdrop of groundbreaking research into plant communication. Plus, this book has a prominent, adorable cat throughout, which definitely made me enjoy the book even more. While the main character, Kelsey, is pretty young (only 13 years old) and the writing itself makes the book seem more MG than YA, the book also focuses on heavy themes, such as alcoholism and child neglect; there is also a scene involving drunk driving and the death of a minor, so be aware of these themes before reading, especially if the book is for a younger reader.
The protagonist, Kelsey, is a rebellious young girl on the brink of trouble. However, when she's given a chance to avoid juvenile hall through community service, she finds herself entangled in a high-stakes mystery involving a botanist and a brutal crime. Rorby is able to create a story that redeems Kelsey’s character as you are able to see her grow as a person due to the “seeds” that are planted from those around her – the “seeds” in this case being love and compassion (this book just demands plant-themed metaphors). Kelsey has lived a challenging life due to her mother’s alcoholism, and Kelsey herself is definitely a flawed character. There were some times when I actually disliked Kelsey due to certain things she said to the botanist. However, I found myself invested in Kelsey’s character as I wanted to see her learn from her mistakes and begin to appreciate those around her. After all, she is a good person (as determined by Gen, the cat, as well as the plants within the greenhouse).
Besides the strong character development within the book, what sets "Girl Under Glass" apart from other YA contemporary/mystery books is its incorporation of cutting-edge science surrounding plant communication. In the story, Rorby explores the intriguing concept of plants as witnesses to crime, adding an intriguing layer of complexity to the plot. I really enjoyed the science aspect of the book with the different experiments. I found the idea of a plant being hooked up to a lie detector test to be absolutely fascinating. The science parts in the book were informative without being too information-dumping and dense for the reader to enjoy; the science was also broken down for a younger reader to understand (the layout of this information would probably be more suitable for MG readers or younger YA readers).
Readers will find themselves drawn into Rorby's richly imagined world, where characters and plants alike come to life with authenticity and depth. It’s rare for a book to actually make me invested in plants, but Rorby was actually able to give a plant, Phil, a personality. The writing style is engaging and accessible; I think this book would work well with reluctant readers who are interested in science.
Overall, "Girl Under Glass" is a compelling read that balances science, suspense, and heartfelt storytelling with finesse. The mystery itself wasn’t too much of a focus in the book, and while the plot was a bit predictable at times, I really enjoyed the characters of Kelsey, the botanist, and Phil the plant (and I definitely can’t forget about Gen the cat).
"Girl Under Glass" by Ginny Rorby delivers an engaging story that blends elements of science and suspense, all centered around a girl experiencing kindness and compassion when she has lived a life largely lacking in those experiences. At its core, it's a story of redemption and unlikely alliances, such as with a quirky botanist and a kind-hearted detective, set against the backdrop of groundbreaking research into plant communication. Plus, this book has a prominent, adorable cat throughout, which definitely made me enjoy the book even more. While the main character, Kelsey, is pretty young (only 13 years old) and the writing itself makes the book seem more MG than YA, the book also focuses on heavy themes, such as alcoholism and child neglect; there is also a scene involving drunk driving and the death of a minor, so be aware of these themes before reading, especially if the book is for a younger reader.
The protagonist, Kelsey, is a rebellious young girl on the brink of trouble. However, when she's given a chance to avoid juvenile hall through community service, she finds herself entangled in a high-stakes mystery involving a botanist and a brutal crime. Rorby is able to create a story that redeems Kelsey’s character as you are able to see her grow as a person due to the “seeds” that are planted from those around her – the “seeds” in this case being love and compassion (this book just demands plant-themed metaphors). Kelsey has lived a challenging life due to her mother’s alcoholism, and Kelsey herself is definitely a flawed character. There were some times when I actually disliked Kelsey due to certain things she said to the botanist. However, I found myself invested in Kelsey’s character as I wanted to see her learn from her mistakes and begin to appreciate those around her. After all, she is a good person (as determined by Gen, the cat, as well as the plants within the greenhouse).
Besides the strong character development within the book, what sets "Girl Under Glass" apart from other YA contemporary/mystery books is its incorporation of cutting-edge science surrounding plant communication. In the story, Rorby explores the intriguing concept of plants as witnesses to crime, adding an intriguing layer of complexity to the plot. I really enjoyed the science aspect of the book with the different experiments. I found the idea of a plant being hooked up to a lie detector test to be absolutely fascinating. The science parts in the book were informative without being too information-dumping and dense for the reader to enjoy; the science was also broken down for a younger reader to understand (the layout of this information would probably be more suitable for MG readers or younger YA readers).
Readers will find themselves drawn into Rorby's richly imagined world, where characters and plants alike come to life with authenticity and depth. It’s rare for a book to actually make me invested in plants, but Rorby was actually able to give a plant, Phil, a personality. The writing style is engaging and accessible; I think this book would work well with reluctant readers who are interested in science.
Overall, "Girl Under Glass" is a compelling read that balances science, suspense, and heartfelt storytelling with finesse. The mystery itself wasn’t too much of a focus in the book, and while the plot was a bit predictable at times, I really enjoyed the characters of Kelsey, the botanist, and Phil the plant (and I definitely can’t forget about Gen the cat).
May 15, 2024
If plants could bear witness to crimes and expose the culprits, what shocking tales might they tell? Discover the enchanting story of Girl Under Glass by Ginny Rorby where plants play a central role.
Thirteen-year-old Kelsey McCully leads a life overshadowed by her alcoholic mother's neglect and the absence of her long-lost father. After Kelsey got arrested for shoplifting, she got assigned community service at the greenhouse of Dr. Jonathan "Hobby" Hobbes, an eccentric botanist. Here, Kelsey forms a bond with Hobby's cat, Gen, and is introduced to Hobby's unconventional experiments on plant communication and consciousness. When Hobby is brutally attacked and left in a coma, Kelsey makes a startling discovery – his beloved philodendron, Phil, may have witnessed the crime. Guided by the books on controversial theories of plant perception, Kelsey becomes convinced that Phil and the other plants in the greenhouse hold the key to identifying Hobby's attackers.
Kelsey's life takes an unexpected turn when her long-lost father, David, finds her after reading about the attack on Hobbes. Kelsey learns that her mother lied about her father abandoning them and his supposed death. Torn between her newfound father and her dysfunctional mother, Kelsey tries to motivate Lydia to quit drinking. Meanwhile, with the help of Detective Hannah Moran, Kelsey hatches a daring plan to catch the culprits – two troublemakers named Will and Ryan – by using the plants as secret witnesses in an elaborate sting operation.
Girl Under Glass by Ginny Rorby blends elements of mystery, family drama, and scientific exploration into a narrative suitable for readers of all ages. Despite exploring mature themes such as addiction, trauma, and abandonment, the writing style makes for an accessible and easy read. Kelsey's transformation from a disillusioned delinquent to a compassionate, resilient young woman is a joy to witness. Hobby, with his endearing eccentricities and unwavering belief in Kelsey's potential, serves as a powerful father figure and mentor, guiding her on a journey of self-discovery and growth. Even the supporting characters, such as the steadfast Detective Moran and Kelsey's friend Josh, contribute depth and emotional resonance to the narrative.
While the concept of plant consciousness may seem far-fetched, Rorby grounds her story in scientific theories, making the fantastical elements feel plausible. With an accessible writing style, the author's vivid descriptions of the greenhouse and its botanical inhabitants imbue the setting with a sense of magic and wonder, inviting readers to ponder the boundaries between the natural and the extraordinary. With its blend of genres, Girl Under Glass is a testament to the power of empathy, resilience, and the unexpected connections that can bloom in the most unlikely of places.
Quill says: Girl Under Glass is an enchanting and accessible story that celebrates the resilience of the human spirit and the wonders of the natural world.
Thirteen-year-old Kelsey McCully leads a life overshadowed by her alcoholic mother's neglect and the absence of her long-lost father. After Kelsey got arrested for shoplifting, she got assigned community service at the greenhouse of Dr. Jonathan "Hobby" Hobbes, an eccentric botanist. Here, Kelsey forms a bond with Hobby's cat, Gen, and is introduced to Hobby's unconventional experiments on plant communication and consciousness. When Hobby is brutally attacked and left in a coma, Kelsey makes a startling discovery – his beloved philodendron, Phil, may have witnessed the crime. Guided by the books on controversial theories of plant perception, Kelsey becomes convinced that Phil and the other plants in the greenhouse hold the key to identifying Hobby's attackers.
Kelsey's life takes an unexpected turn when her long-lost father, David, finds her after reading about the attack on Hobbes. Kelsey learns that her mother lied about her father abandoning them and his supposed death. Torn between her newfound father and her dysfunctional mother, Kelsey tries to motivate Lydia to quit drinking. Meanwhile, with the help of Detective Hannah Moran, Kelsey hatches a daring plan to catch the culprits – two troublemakers named Will and Ryan – by using the plants as secret witnesses in an elaborate sting operation.
Girl Under Glass by Ginny Rorby blends elements of mystery, family drama, and scientific exploration into a narrative suitable for readers of all ages. Despite exploring mature themes such as addiction, trauma, and abandonment, the writing style makes for an accessible and easy read. Kelsey's transformation from a disillusioned delinquent to a compassionate, resilient young woman is a joy to witness. Hobby, with his endearing eccentricities and unwavering belief in Kelsey's potential, serves as a powerful father figure and mentor, guiding her on a journey of self-discovery and growth. Even the supporting characters, such as the steadfast Detective Moran and Kelsey's friend Josh, contribute depth and emotional resonance to the narrative.
While the concept of plant consciousness may seem far-fetched, Rorby grounds her story in scientific theories, making the fantastical elements feel plausible. With an accessible writing style, the author's vivid descriptions of the greenhouse and its botanical inhabitants imbue the setting with a sense of magic and wonder, inviting readers to ponder the boundaries between the natural and the extraordinary. With its blend of genres, Girl Under Glass is a testament to the power of empathy, resilience, and the unexpected connections that can bloom in the most unlikely of places.
Quill says: Girl Under Glass is an enchanting and accessible story that celebrates the resilience of the human spirit and the wonders of the natural world.
May 30, 2024
Ginny Rorby's "Girl Under Glass" is a captivating novel that delves into the complexities of human relationships, the struggles of adolescence, and the resilience of the human spirit. Set against the backdrop of a small town, the story follows the life of a young girl named Iris, who is grappling with the challenges of her dysfunctional family and her own identity. Iris lives with her mother and her mother's abusive boyfriend, making her life filled with turmoil and uncertainty, often feeling like a prisoner in her own home. The glass in the title symbolizes the fragility of Iris's world and her sense of entrapment. As she navigates the treacherous waters of her adolescence, Iris finds solace in unexpected places and forms bonds that help her endure her hardships.
Rorby masterfully crafts her characters, making them deeply relatable and authentic. Iris is a compelling character whose inner strength and determination shine through despite her circumstances. Her journey is heart-wrenching yet inspiring, as she learns to stand up for herself and seek out a better life. The supporting characters, including Iris's mother and her boyfriend, are well-developed, adding depth and realism to the story.
It tackles several important themes, such as abuse, resilience, and the search for identity. Rorby does not shy away from portraying the harsh realities of Iris's life, but she balances this with moments of hope and beauty. The novel also explores the importance of friendship and support systems in overcoming adversity. Through Iris's eyes, readers are reminded of the strength that can be found within oneself and the impact of kindness and compassion from others.
Ginny Rorby's writing is poignant and evocative, drawing readers into Iris's world with vivid descriptions and emotional depth. Her prose is both lyrical and accessible, making the novel a compelling read for both young adults and adult readers. Rorby's ability to convey the raw emotions of her characters ensures that readers are fully invested in their journeys.
"Girl Under Glass" is a powerful and moving novel that will stay with readers long after they turn the last page. Ginny Rorby's storytelling prowess and her empathetic portrayal of a young girl's struggle make this book a must-read. It is a testament to the human spirit's ability to persevere and find light in the darkest of times. Highly recommended for those who appreciate heartfelt, character-driven stories that tackle difficult subjects with grace and sensitivity.
Rorby masterfully crafts her characters, making them deeply relatable and authentic. Iris is a compelling character whose inner strength and determination shine through despite her circumstances. Her journey is heart-wrenching yet inspiring, as she learns to stand up for herself and seek out a better life. The supporting characters, including Iris's mother and her boyfriend, are well-developed, adding depth and realism to the story.
It tackles several important themes, such as abuse, resilience, and the search for identity. Rorby does not shy away from portraying the harsh realities of Iris's life, but she balances this with moments of hope and beauty. The novel also explores the importance of friendship and support systems in overcoming adversity. Through Iris's eyes, readers are reminded of the strength that can be found within oneself and the impact of kindness and compassion from others.
Ginny Rorby's writing is poignant and evocative, drawing readers into Iris's world with vivid descriptions and emotional depth. Her prose is both lyrical and accessible, making the novel a compelling read for both young adults and adult readers. Rorby's ability to convey the raw emotions of her characters ensures that readers are fully invested in their journeys.
"Girl Under Glass" is a powerful and moving novel that will stay with readers long after they turn the last page. Ginny Rorby's storytelling prowess and her empathetic portrayal of a young girl's struggle make this book a must-read. It is a testament to the human spirit's ability to persevere and find light in the darkest of times. Highly recommended for those who appreciate heartfelt, character-driven stories that tackle difficult subjects with grace and sensitivity.
September 9, 2024
First of all, Ginny, you need an editor! There are spelling mistakes, repeated words, misuse of words (does not mean what you seem to think it means), occasional clumsy phrasing, missed "new speaker, new line" paragraphs, many misplaced commas, occasional tense inconsistencies, and other spelling, grammar and punctuation errors.
Usually, these errors would earn a book 1 star from me, but this was such an engaging and interesting story, I'm going to rate and recommend this book in spite of the errors. And that's saying something!
Issues:
Alcoholism
Narcissism
Child neglect
Underage drinking
Drink driving and death of a friend
Delinquency (shoplifting, character traits)
Peer pressure
Poverty
Self-actualisation
Taking opportunities kind people present us to better ourselves.
I loved the characters of Hobby, Gen, Phil, and not just incorporating plant experiments and imparting knowledge, but also including the history of those experiments and the related books. I HIGHLY recommend librarians place this book alongside The Botany of Desire Young Readers Edition: Our Surprising Relationship with Plants in displays.
Kelsey's relationship to her alcoholic (and very narcissistic) mother was well written. It gave a realistic representation of a child growing up in neglect, who take on the adult responsibilities, and feel "responsible" for their parent. An abusive child-parent relationship is very complex, with the child struggling between the innate feeling that their parent is supposed to love them and care for them, and the reality that they don't.
The way co-dependency was discussed with the analogy of the parasitic plant and Kelsey's realisation that she was actually enabling her mother's drinking was an excellent inclusion.
Usually, these errors would earn a book 1 star from me, but this was such an engaging and interesting story, I'm going to rate and recommend this book in spite of the errors. And that's saying something!
Issues:
Alcoholism
Narcissism
Child neglect
Underage drinking
Drink driving and death of a friend
Delinquency (shoplifting, character traits)
Peer pressure
Poverty
Self-actualisation
Taking opportunities kind people present us to better ourselves.
I loved the characters of Hobby, Gen, Phil, and not just incorporating plant experiments and imparting knowledge, but also including the history of those experiments and the related books. I HIGHLY recommend librarians place this book alongside The Botany of Desire Young Readers Edition: Our Surprising Relationship with Plants in displays.
Kelsey's relationship to her alcoholic (and very narcissistic) mother was well written. It gave a realistic representation of a child growing up in neglect, who take on the adult responsibilities, and feel "responsible" for their parent. An abusive child-parent relationship is very complex, with the child struggling between the innate feeling that their parent is supposed to love them and care for them, and the reality that they don't.
The way co-dependency was discussed with the analogy of the parasitic plant and Kelsey's realisation that she was actually enabling her mother's drinking was an excellent inclusion.
April 23, 2024
When I was a kid, I saw a documentary in which a scientist hooked a plant up to a machine like a lie detector and then threatened to burn one of its leaves with a match & the needle on the detector went crazy. I was fascinated and never forgot it (and now I know the title! I was very little when I saw it). So when I read what this book was about...I couldn't wait to read it. Kelsey hooked me from the beginning (just like Joey did in the author's "Hurt Go Happy") a girl struggling to grow up in difficult circumstances. Kelsey is caregiver for her alcoholic mother...and she gets in trouble with the law...earns herself community service with a crotchety old botanist. She hates it at first, but Hobbie and his cat Gen win her over...and...well, I'm not going to say more...you are going to have to read it and enjoy as it becomes a page-turning thriller. I loved it and will hand-sell it to tweens as soon as I can get it in the library.
Full disclosure: I am biased, but I came about that bias honestly. In 2006 when I was on the Newbery Committee, I nominated "Hurt Go Happy" for the award. It didn't win, but it still sports some well-deserved metal on its cover. I loved "Outside of a Horse" and it will never leave my library shelves. When 2011 rolled around...I was on the Newbery Committee again. I couldn't pass up reading "Lost in the River of Grass" but I never thought I would nominate it too for the award (I have never been a fan of survival in the wild fiction)--She made me do it again. I wish I'd fought harder, it's as good as the books we picked. I loved "How to Speak Dolphin" and "Freeing Finch" (don't believe Finch's detractors) and I really enjoyed "Dolphin Sky" and "Like Dust I Rise" So as I said, if this is your first encounter with Rorby, do yourself a favor and try the others. They are full of heart (and hurt) and the love of animals and the Earth. Really good stuff.
Full disclosure: I am biased, but I came about that bias honestly. In 2006 when I was on the Newbery Committee, I nominated "Hurt Go Happy" for the award. It didn't win, but it still sports some well-deserved metal on its cover. I loved "Outside of a Horse" and it will never leave my library shelves. When 2011 rolled around...I was on the Newbery Committee again. I couldn't pass up reading "Lost in the River of Grass" but I never thought I would nominate it too for the award (I have never been a fan of survival in the wild fiction)--She made me do it again. I wish I'd fought harder, it's as good as the books we picked. I loved "How to Speak Dolphin" and "Freeing Finch" (don't believe Finch's detractors) and I really enjoyed "Dolphin Sky" and "Like Dust I Rise" So as I said, if this is your first encounter with Rorby, do yourself a favor and try the others. They are full of heart (and hurt) and the love of animals and the Earth. Really good stuff.
April 27, 2024
Girl Under Glass by Ginny Rorby
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Out 30.05.24
YA Fiction
Oh boy! This story pulled at my heart strings all the way through. I found myself choking back the tears at the end. What an absolute gem of a book. This is a YA story that is written incredibly well, It didn't feel like I was reading a book meant for a young teen. I was fully immersed in Kelsey's life, from start to finish. Her character development throughout the book is admirable. Fighting between living in poverty and having the responsibility of caring for her alcoholic mother, constantly making wrong choices, and wanting to be a better person so she didn't follow the same route her mother took. It was such a mixture of so many emotions, and I felt every one of them through Rorby's narrative.
I love to grow plants and nurture them, so this side of the story was fascinating. Talking about the science of plants sensing their surroundings and adapting to dangers around them was explained in such an easy way to follow. It's not heavy with the science parts or overly complicated.
This story is an emotional roller coaster of a ride. It does tackle some heavy subject matters for a younger reader, but they are tackled in a way that's understanding. Kelsey will forever hold a place in my heart. I'm so glad I read this book. It is unique storytelling done exceptionally well.
Synopsis
Kelsey, a young teen, living a life of self-destruction, finds herself in deep water when she uses up her last chance. Taken pity upon, she gets given community service with Dr. Hobbes, a botanist. When he gets beaten, Kelsey tries to find a way to explain how Hobbes' plants bore witness to the attack.
Thank you, Netgalley, and Black Rose Writing
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Out 30.05.24
YA Fiction
Oh boy! This story pulled at my heart strings all the way through. I found myself choking back the tears at the end. What an absolute gem of a book. This is a YA story that is written incredibly well, It didn't feel like I was reading a book meant for a young teen. I was fully immersed in Kelsey's life, from start to finish. Her character development throughout the book is admirable. Fighting between living in poverty and having the responsibility of caring for her alcoholic mother, constantly making wrong choices, and wanting to be a better person so she didn't follow the same route her mother took. It was such a mixture of so many emotions, and I felt every one of them through Rorby's narrative.
I love to grow plants and nurture them, so this side of the story was fascinating. Talking about the science of plants sensing their surroundings and adapting to dangers around them was explained in such an easy way to follow. It's not heavy with the science parts or overly complicated.
This story is an emotional roller coaster of a ride. It does tackle some heavy subject matters for a younger reader, but they are tackled in a way that's understanding. Kelsey will forever hold a place in my heart. I'm so glad I read this book. It is unique storytelling done exceptionally well.
Synopsis
Kelsey, a young teen, living a life of self-destruction, finds herself in deep water when she uses up her last chance. Taken pity upon, she gets given community service with Dr. Hobbes, a botanist. When he gets beaten, Kelsey tries to find a way to explain how Hobbes' plants bore witness to the attack.
Thank you, Netgalley, and Black Rose Writing
September 8, 2025
This was an enjoyable book. Yet, it's also a book that discusses a lot of serious topics, including
While this book was written for teenagers, it doesn't feel childish or like it's only applicable to a teenage audience. It's often easy to forget that our main character, Kelsey, is a middle schooler (13 years old). Life has forced her into an adult role in many ways far sooner than she should have had to take on certain responsibilities.
This book contains some swearing. There's no sexual content. While a character is attacked and left for dead, the actual attack happens off the page. The violence on the page is mild.
I would say that this book doesn't exactly have a "happily ever after" ending. I would say that it's hopeful bittersweet.
Overall, I would give this book 4.5 stars. I've rounded up because it was a very enjoyable book, and most of the issues with it were minor issues that could be resolved with another editing readthrough. I got an ARC from BookSirens, and I left a voluntary review.
While this book was written for teenagers, it doesn't feel childish or like it's only applicable to a teenage audience. It's often easy to forget that our main character, Kelsey, is a middle schooler (13 years old). Life has forced her into an adult role in many ways far sooner than she should have had to take on certain responsibilities.
This book contains some swearing. There's no sexual content. While a character is attacked and left for dead, the actual attack happens off the page. The violence on the page is mild.
I would say that this book doesn't exactly have a "happily ever after" ending. I would say that it's hopeful bittersweet.
Overall, I would give this book 4.5 stars. I've rounded up because it was a very enjoyable book, and most of the issues with it were minor issues that could be resolved with another editing readthrough. I got an ARC from BookSirens, and I left a voluntary review.
October 16, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4.5 rounded up)
Wow! What a book. I absolutely adored Girl Under Glass. The creativity and heartfelt emotion come through right from the start, and I can see exactly why this book has such amazing ratings.
It begins with Kelsey, a young girl stuck in a rough situation — an alcoholic mom, a dumpy home life, and what feels like endless “bad luck.” (Or maybe just survival.) The whole town seems to know her business, and juvie seems almost inevitable. But when she gets assigned community service with a botanist, things start to shift.
The story that unfolds with Hobby and GEN (and the cat — who doesn’t love a cat that hugs you right away? ❤️) is so full of warmth and depth. The side characters — Detective Hannah, Lauren 💔, Josh, Will, Ryan, and her dad — each add something meaningful. The book touches on loss of friendship, betrayal, heartbreak, loneliness, tragedy, and even the power of commitment. You truly get to experience it all.
My only small critique: around the 75–82% mark, the pacing felt a bit rushed. Everything suddenly started happening at once, but then it settled back into that wonderful detailed, funny, immersive rhythm that made me love the first part so much.
All in all, Girl Under Glass is a beautifully written, emotional, and deeply human story. I’ll absolutely be recommending it.
Wow! What a book. I absolutely adored Girl Under Glass. The creativity and heartfelt emotion come through right from the start, and I can see exactly why this book has such amazing ratings.
It begins with Kelsey, a young girl stuck in a rough situation — an alcoholic mom, a dumpy home life, and what feels like endless “bad luck.” (Or maybe just survival.) The whole town seems to know her business, and juvie seems almost inevitable. But when she gets assigned community service with a botanist, things start to shift.
The story that unfolds with Hobby and GEN (and the cat — who doesn’t love a cat that hugs you right away? ❤️) is so full of warmth and depth. The side characters — Detective Hannah, Lauren 💔, Josh, Will, Ryan, and her dad — each add something meaningful. The book touches on loss of friendship, betrayal, heartbreak, loneliness, tragedy, and even the power of commitment. You truly get to experience it all.
My only small critique: around the 75–82% mark, the pacing felt a bit rushed. Everything suddenly started happening at once, but then it settled back into that wonderful detailed, funny, immersive rhythm that made me love the first part so much.
All in all, Girl Under Glass is a beautifully written, emotional, and deeply human story. I’ll absolutely be recommending it.
April 16, 2024
Ginny Rorby’s Girl Under Glass is one of the most creative books I’ve read lately. Take one juvenile delinquent, add a grumpy botanist with unconventional ideas and mix well with the magic of Secret Life of Plants and you’ve got this delightful book. The characters are so real and nuanced, and Rorby’s skill as a writer so well honed, that I was willing to go along on their sometimes tough journey and was rooting for Kelsey right away. It’s a compelling mystery as well as a story of resilience and growth (not just for the plants, which play a central and fascinating role). I won’t be surprised if this is a best-seller and hope it becomes a movie! It’s cliché to say I couldn’t put it down, but I truly couldn’t.
June 13, 2024
One thing that makes a book wonderful is when it sends you to another book, when it makes you ask new questions. Girl Under Glass does that and much more. It doesn’t take long to get you on 13 year old Kelsey’s side as she tries to imitate a stable home life despite a seriously alcoholic mother. When she’s picked up for shoplifting a second time, she’s sent to a community service assignment with Hobby, a retired scientist learning to read what his plants are trying to tell him. Their bond is slow in coming, but it is the heart of a story about love, learning and our connections to all living things from a plant named Phil, a spider named Carlotta, and a bossy cat named Gen.
And finally how we find our way to each other. I hope you will love this book as much as I do.
And finally how we find our way to each other. I hope you will love this book as much as I do.
April 17, 2024
I got this book from my school library and oh my gosh it was so good. I've read books from Ginny Rorby before (Freeing Finch is also an amazing one) so I was going into this with high hopes and it lived up to everything I was expecting. Girl Under Glass really resonated with me as this year I've spent most of my time trying to change and improve how I live, and this novel gives me hope and shows that with perserverence it is it is possible. I also grew up surrounded by plants and talking to them and never knew my father so those things also make it pretty familiar lol.
Overall probably one of the best books I've read in 2024, and in a while. I totally recommend this book.
Overall probably one of the best books I've read in 2024, and in a while. I totally recommend this book.
June 3, 2024
Girl Under Glass is another great YA read by author Ginny Rorby. Once again, Rorby gives us a character to root for in spite of her character flaws and rebellious teenage behavior. Kelsey's misguided actions bring her to the attention of authorities, and she's threatened with juvenile hall. Instead, a sympathetic judge assigns her to community service under the tutelage of a gruff, no-nonsense botanist who studies plant communication. Yes, it's a real science as Kelsey and the reader discover. Like Rorby's previous books, this one tells a good story and educates the reader as well as the protagonist. A satisfying, fascinating read.
April 16, 2024
Open a Ginny Rorby book and you can’t put it down. A character you care about, in this case Kelsey, is in trouble. She keeps getting in deeper while trying to do good. At the last possible moment, she’s saved by a nutty botanist, but the sentence (of community service) leaves her feeling more condemned. Another Rorby certainty, an adorable animal, in this case the botanist’s cat. I won’t give away what happens, but troubles mount, at home and at the greenhouse. A plant and a sympathetic detective come to the rescue. Another gripping winner by this talented writer
April 22, 2024
Read through NetGalley. For the first few chapters of this book I really didn't like the main character, Kelsey. As the story progressed and you got to know her better and what her back story was so you realize what makes her the way she is, you begin to warm up to her. And as she becomes more open to the influence of Hobbie, she is even more likeable. Definitely an interesting story.
June 25, 2025
Fascinating and hopeful read about Kelsey, a young girl taking care of her alcoholic mother. When I read the synopsis about how plants helped solve a crime, I thought this would be a fantasy novel of sorts. I was so delighted to learn that this was based on real theories and research. I will now be adding the reference books mentioned to my TBR!
June 19, 2024
This book was so interesting and engaging, I would have given it 5 stars if not for the TERRIBLE editing. There were grammatical errors on every single page. That may not bother some, but for me it was highly annoying. Whoever read this for the author should be fired.
March 18, 2026
Good story
The story line was good, but the main character should have been a bit older. 13 felt too young. The writing was pretty rough at times grammatically. Also, the story was took a while to get rolling, but it was good once it got going.
The story line was good, but the main character should have been a bit older. 13 felt too young. The writing was pretty rough at times grammatically. Also, the story was took a while to get rolling, but it was good once it got going.
May 14, 2025
Heart warming story of a young girl just trying to make ends meet in her troubled world. Loved her character development and the crazy botanist who talks to the plants.
September 9, 2025
Written by a local North Coast author and a gift from my friend. A feel good YA story inclusive of botany and a happy ending.
June 5, 2026
Amazing
The outcome of the story was amazing. I was bewildered by the story of the plants and how they have reactions to different situations. I liked the story.
The outcome of the story was amazing. I was bewildered by the story of the plants and how they have reactions to different situations. I liked the story.
August 15, 2026
Just not my genre. I could not finish.
September 4, 2026
Down to earth and very uplifting
The story is disheartening and joyful. Reading gave me hope that even the worst situation can be a silver lining.
The story is disheartening and joyful. Reading gave me hope that even the worst situation can be a silver lining.
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews