Stuck in his role as a former model, Aia actually harbours dreams of doing makeup on others. When he’s picked to represent his class during a school fashion contest, the withdrawn Jun is set to do his makeup. But when they swap roles, they might both find what they’ve been looking for all this time…
While not a home run, per se, this certainly manages to at least load the bases with a couple of minor errors and, no, I don’t know why I am using a sports analogy for a fashion manga.
This story has a great hook and a tried and true message of not being afraid to chase your dreams and believing in yourself. That it involves a popular boy who wants to do makeup and an unconventional looking girl who wants to model is the perfect bait for said hook.
Aia’s dreams are nothing more than that, his success leaving his opinions largely ignored in favour of him standing there and looking good. Jun lives hunched over and embarrassed of her many freckles - she is not conventionally ‘manga attractive’ in any way and I love that they give her that little tweak. It makes a difference.
Everybody sees Jun’s freckles as detriment and encourages her to conceal the heck out of them. You can see where this is going, but man, the school show that results is one of the best examples of a Mark Manga Moment (tm) that I have seen in ages. This thing doesn’t kill; it slays.
What’s even more impressive is that the revelation of the class entry and Jun’s outfit is absolutely one of the dumbest images I’ve seen (I have no time for this sort of thing, so your mileage may vary). So seeing it change and explode the way it does into something amazing is absolutely jaw-dropping. I completely recommend the volume just on how fun this whole part is.
Is there romance in the air? Probably, but while these two join themselves at the hip pretty quickly there’s a real issue that’s being floated in the background about an aspiring make-up artist using only one model for his art. That’s a big ask in an industry like this one and I hope it gets more page time going forward.
Despite a bit of chemistry, the writing is a little stiff at times, more on that in a second, but the seeds are certainly being sown. Nobody who disagrees vehemently, in unison, that they are not a couple has ever managed platonic relations in the history of manga.
Now, when I say it isn’t perfect, I mean it is not perfect. Even by manga standards, some of the reactions to events by Aia are really weird. I mean, I get he’s scared of Jun moving beyond his own efforts, but his reaction to it all is a bit exaggerated (this is probably why I am not in fashion school and never will be unless jeans and hoodies become haute couture).
And there is some serious jank to the dialogue that’s either bad writing, awkward translation, or both. There’s an argument Aia has with his new job partner for an assignment and I read it about five times and could not figure out what they were trying to hash out. For as good as parts of this are, there are some real frustrations.
When it’s on, though? Man, this is a fantastic tale. Even the later photo session with Jun had a vibrancy to it and this whole industry has struggle built into it, even if some of it is being used to just show that our leads work better together than apart.
Sure, it’s a romance and competition manga, that partner turns into a non-romantic rival and you can see it all coming a mile away, but it has flare and flourish and a good heart to cover over some of those aspects. It’s not a perfect concealment, but I would always rather something trying and not getting there than just another rote story.
3.5 stars - my score is going to reflect some issues I think need work before we can call this a masterpiece, but despite what I have ultimately given it here I believe it is 100% worth a look if you think it sounds interesting.