What do you think?
Rate this book
The Archangel Chronicles #1
Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown
His obsession began from the shadows.
Her nightmare began there too.
Kyra was known to the world as Therian's Thief. She spent her mornings stealing and her afternoons studying a world most denied. She was going to leave this place one day, take her brother and run.
But there was something dark lurking in the shadows. Something that whispered her name, beckoned her.
Her mother hadn't touched her brother yet, perhaps there was time. Time to investigate what this thing made of shadows and nightmares truly was.
Would she regret it or fall right into his obsession?
Would her fear take over or would it shift into something more...intoxicating?
Her nightmare began there too.
Kyra was known to the world as Therian's Thief. She spent her mornings stealing and her afternoons studying a world most denied. She was going to leave this place one day, take her brother and run.
But there was something dark lurking in the shadows. Something that whispered her name, beckoned her.
Her mother hadn't touched her brother yet, perhaps there was time. Time to investigate what this thing made of shadows and nightmares truly was.
Would she regret it or fall right into his obsession?
Would her fear take over or would it shift into something more...intoxicating?
499 pages, Kindle Edition
Published March 1, 2024
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews
January 3, 2024
ARC Review
Rating: 4/5
Spice: 4/5
The book started out a bit confusing, there were a lot of characters introduced early on and naturally world building that needs to be done for a series like this, as well as many switches of P.O.V. throughout the chapters. The further into it I got, however, the plot began falling into place and definitely brings you in.
I'd definitely suggest making sure you acknowledge the trigger warnings at the beginning to ensure it's a suitable read for you as it deals with pretty deep and significant topics.
The book features enemies to lovers, found family, and some slow burn.
I look forward to reading the rest in the series!
Rating: 4/5
Spice: 4/5
The book started out a bit confusing, there were a lot of characters introduced early on and naturally world building that needs to be done for a series like this, as well as many switches of P.O.V. throughout the chapters. The further into it I got, however, the plot began falling into place and definitely brings you in.
I'd definitely suggest making sure you acknowledge the trigger warnings at the beginning to ensure it's a suitable read for you as it deals with pretty deep and significant topics.
The book features enemies to lovers, found family, and some slow burn.
I look forward to reading the rest in the series!
January 3, 2024
Actual Rating: 4. 5 Stars
"𝙎𝙤𝙢𝙚𝙩𝙞𝙢𝙚𝙨 𝙝𝙪𝙧𝙩 𝙥𝙚𝙤𝙥𝙡𝙚 𝙙𝙤𝙣'𝙩 𝙝𝙤𝙬 𝙚𝙡𝙨𝙚 𝙩𝙤 𝙨𝙝𝙤𝙬 𝙥𝙚𝙤𝙥𝙡𝙚 𝙩𝙝𝙚𝙮'𝙧𝙚 𝙝𝙪𝙧𝙩 𝙩𝙝𝙖𝙣 𝙩𝙤 𝙖𝙘𝙩 𝙤𝙪𝙩."
Wow, wow, wow, what a start to a series.
I loved this book, I truly did. I loved how every character was multi-layered, and that no one was truly how they seemed. The story had me on the edge of my seat, and I found myself wanting to keep reading because I couldn't wait to find out what was happening next. It had everything I loved in a book, mystery, romance, unlikely friendships. There were bonds formed and bonds that were broken.
The world-building was initially a little confusing. There was a lot of information thrown at me in the beginning, and I know that's necessary for the first book in a series, but I was a little overwhelmed. Once I understood the creatures, geography, and politics, it was smooth sailing and I found myself falling in love with the world and everything in it.
Now, let's talk about Trick Michael because he is the blueprint for boy-obsessed. And when I say obsessed, I mean he was OBSESSED. Trick was the morally gray character I had been craving to read about for WEEKS! He owned his title as god of nightmares because at some points even I was flinching at what he was doing. You want to hate him for his actions, but when you learn the motives, it makes it hard to do so. He is so multi-layered and we only scratched the surface in this book, I can't wait to learn more about his character throughout the series.
Kyra is one of the most beautifully broken, complex, and loving characters I have ever read about. She takes sisterly love to a whole new level. Everything she does is for the benefit of her brother. Thieving, lying, everything is to protect him. She deprives herself of necessities to make sure he is cared for. Risks her life for it. She is one of the most admirable fictional characters I've ever read. Strong, and resilient, she's everything I love in a FMC.
Trick and Kyra's relationship is complex, and we only get to see a sliver of them connecting, I can't wait to see where their relationship grows further on in the series. I have a feeling they're going to be unstoppable.
Overall, this was a solid start to the series, and I anxiously await the next installments.
*Please cheek the trigger warnings in the beginning of the book and take them seriously*
*I was sent an ARC in exchange for a review, thank you H.G. Johnston for the opportunity!*
"𝙎𝙤𝙢𝙚𝙩𝙞𝙢𝙚𝙨 𝙝𝙪𝙧𝙩 𝙥𝙚𝙤𝙥𝙡𝙚 𝙙𝙤𝙣'𝙩 𝙝𝙤𝙬 𝙚𝙡𝙨𝙚 𝙩𝙤 𝙨𝙝𝙤𝙬 𝙥𝙚𝙤𝙥𝙡𝙚 𝙩𝙝𝙚𝙮'𝙧𝙚 𝙝𝙪𝙧𝙩 𝙩𝙝𝙖𝙣 𝙩𝙤 𝙖𝙘𝙩 𝙤𝙪𝙩."
Wow, wow, wow, what a start to a series.
I loved this book, I truly did. I loved how every character was multi-layered, and that no one was truly how they seemed. The story had me on the edge of my seat, and I found myself wanting to keep reading because I couldn't wait to find out what was happening next. It had everything I loved in a book, mystery, romance, unlikely friendships. There were bonds formed and bonds that were broken.
The world-building was initially a little confusing. There was a lot of information thrown at me in the beginning, and I know that's necessary for the first book in a series, but I was a little overwhelmed. Once I understood the creatures, geography, and politics, it was smooth sailing and I found myself falling in love with the world and everything in it.
Now, let's talk about Trick Michael because he is the blueprint for boy-obsessed. And when I say obsessed, I mean he was OBSESSED. Trick was the morally gray character I had been craving to read about for WEEKS! He owned his title as god of nightmares because at some points even I was flinching at what he was doing. You want to hate him for his actions, but when you learn the motives, it makes it hard to do so. He is so multi-layered and we only scratched the surface in this book, I can't wait to learn more about his character throughout the series.
Kyra is one of the most beautifully broken, complex, and loving characters I have ever read about. She takes sisterly love to a whole new level. Everything she does is for the benefit of her brother. Thieving, lying, everything is to protect him. She deprives herself of necessities to make sure he is cared for. Risks her life for it. She is one of the most admirable fictional characters I've ever read. Strong, and resilient, she's everything I love in a FMC.
Trick and Kyra's relationship is complex, and we only get to see a sliver of them connecting, I can't wait to see where their relationship grows further on in the series. I have a feeling they're going to be unstoppable.
Overall, this was a solid start to the series, and I anxiously await the next installments.
*Please cheek the trigger warnings in the beginning of the book and take them seriously*
*I was sent an ARC in exchange for a review, thank you H.G. Johnston for the opportunity!*
January 6, 2024
ARC Review
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶🌶🌶🌶
"You are the fire I want to die in, a craving I can’t satiate. You are every throb of my hardening c*ck, every beat of my blackened heart, every breath of my immortal life. You are a goddess among f*cking men. And you. Are. Mine.”
This is a dark fantasy romance, as it is a dark book please check the trigger warnings before reading.
I absolutely loved this book! The story and the characters really captivated me and had me wanting to learn more about them and to see how everything was going to unfold. It really kept me on the edge of my seat!
I felt the characters were very well written and had a lot of depth, I found myself really relating to the main female character Kyra at times. Trick is the possessive, stalker, touch her and 💀, dark shadow daddy of any dark romance readers dreams.
There is a lot of world building and characters introduced as this is the first book, it was a little confusing at first. However I caught on pretty quickly as the story unfolded and I found myself fully invested and captivated by the characters, world and story that the author was bringing to life.
I definitely recommend this book to other readers and I'm absolutely looking forward to reading future books in the series!
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶🌶🌶🌶
"You are the fire I want to die in, a craving I can’t satiate. You are every throb of my hardening c*ck, every beat of my blackened heart, every breath of my immortal life. You are a goddess among f*cking men. And you. Are. Mine.”
This is a dark fantasy romance, as it is a dark book please check the trigger warnings before reading.
I absolutely loved this book! The story and the characters really captivated me and had me wanting to learn more about them and to see how everything was going to unfold. It really kept me on the edge of my seat!
I felt the characters were very well written and had a lot of depth, I found myself really relating to the main female character Kyra at times. Trick is the possessive, stalker, touch her and 💀, dark shadow daddy of any dark romance readers dreams.
There is a lot of world building and characters introduced as this is the first book, it was a little confusing at first. However I caught on pretty quickly as the story unfolded and I found myself fully invested and captivated by the characters, world and story that the author was bringing to life.
I definitely recommend this book to other readers and I'm absolutely looking forward to reading future books in the series!
December 25, 2023
ARC reader here!! I will try to avoid spoilers but be warned there may be a few…
Make sure to check out the trigger warnings before reading as this is a dark fantasy that contains topics such as: r@pe, self h@rm, su**ide, etc.
As someone who reads 100+ books a year and loves all things dark and fantasy, I absolutely LOVED this book. I found the beginning a little confusing trying to keep up with all the history that’s talked about but it all works itself out. The author did a great job with the world building and lore. I love Kyra’s outlook on the world and I think it’s a refreshing change from what I’ve read in so many other books. I’m looking forward to reading upcoming books that come out for this series and I will definitely be recommending it all my friends & book group!
Trick is a st@lking, possessive, touch her you 💀, filthy mouthed, shadow daddy and I want ALL of him lol.
My favorite quote that I hope sets the tone for any books come. “We’ve tried everything else. We’ve tried the bargains, the meetings, the bribes, but what we haven’t tried, is letting the world succumb to it. To the anger and hatred and rage. Sometimes, people just need someone who will kill you if you step out of line. A true monster”.
Make sure to check out the trigger warnings before reading as this is a dark fantasy that contains topics such as: r@pe, self h@rm, su**ide, etc.
As someone who reads 100+ books a year and loves all things dark and fantasy, I absolutely LOVED this book. I found the beginning a little confusing trying to keep up with all the history that’s talked about but it all works itself out. The author did a great job with the world building and lore. I love Kyra’s outlook on the world and I think it’s a refreshing change from what I’ve read in so many other books. I’m looking forward to reading upcoming books that come out for this series and I will definitely be recommending it all my friends & book group!
Trick is a st@lking, possessive, touch her you 💀, filthy mouthed, shadow daddy and I want ALL of him lol.
My favorite quote that I hope sets the tone for any books come. “We’ve tried everything else. We’ve tried the bargains, the meetings, the bribes, but what we haven’t tried, is letting the world succumb to it. To the anger and hatred and rage. Sometimes, people just need someone who will kill you if you step out of line. A true monster”.
January 17, 2024
I’ve heard it said that Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown is a combination of Haunting Adeleine and ACOTAR and there is no better description for this book. With dark romance, heavy themes, perfect pacing, and a complex fantasy setting, Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown is a novel that should be entered carefully because once you’ve turned the first page, you’ll be completely hooked.
The main reason this novel was so engaging was the main character. Kyra balanced strength and vulnerability perfectly, and all of her actions were consistent with who she was. She never violated her moral code for the love interest and I adored that she saw the value in humanity (or non-humans) despite all odds. Her power came from hope, and even when the world did its best to destroy her, she refused to let herself hate. Yet that didn’t prevent Kyra from going through the trials of mental illness. The author was careful in her descriptions of self-harm, depression, and suicidal intentions (please check trigger warnings), portraying them in a way that felt raw and honest. Kyra’s mental health wasn’t added for the sake of the plot or the romance, nor was it used only in certain scenes and forgotten about when it was inconvenient to the external plot. Mental illness was part of who Kyra was, but I loved that the author didn’t let it define her. Mental illness wasn’t glamorized in any way, but Kyra wasn’t villainized for not being perfect. The romance genre—especially dark romance—needs more honest portrayals of mental illness and Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown does an excellent job of setting the standard.
Trick (our shadow-wielding dark angel who may or may not commit murder for fun) fits the dark romance antihero archetype perfectly. Twisted and broken in the best possible way (or the worst, depending on who you ask), his perspective was interesting to read from, if not a bit terrifying (but then again, that’s kind of the point of the genre). On that note, this novel delivers on its promise of being a dark romance. The interactions between Kyra and Trick are not traditionally romantic, but safe words are respected.
The main thing that sets Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown apart from the rest of the genre is that the side characters are engaging and well-developed. From the loyal best friend to the sweet younger brother, there were people I cared about outside of the main couple and healthy, loving relationships to balance out the darkness of the romance. I’m excited for book two because I can’t wait to see more friendships develop and watch as the dynamics between some of the secondary characters are revealed in greater depth.
Though I enjoyed every minute I spent reading, what prevented Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown from becoming a five-star novel was worldbuilding. The construction of the fantasy setting is intricate and detailed; it’s very clear that the author understands the world she has created. That being said, so much space was given over to the worldbuilding that I often found myself struggling to find clarity. As an experienced fantasy reader who adores complexity in worldbuilding, it’s not that I didn’t enjoy the detailed setting, it’s only that I wish it had been woven into the plot a little more rather than being dumped into various chapters. Extra worldbuilding is the curse of the first book, so I’m eagerly awaiting exploring the world in the rest of the series now that it has been so heavily established.
Beyond worldbuilding, the pacing and writing of Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown was intoxicating. I often found myself swept away into the story, only to find that hours had passed the next time I glanced up at the clock. If you’re looking for your next dark romantasy read that will hold you captive until the very last page, I can’t recommend a better book.
An e-ARC was provided by the author in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions remain my own.
The main reason this novel was so engaging was the main character. Kyra balanced strength and vulnerability perfectly, and all of her actions were consistent with who she was. She never violated her moral code for the love interest and I adored that she saw the value in humanity (or non-humans) despite all odds. Her power came from hope, and even when the world did its best to destroy her, she refused to let herself hate. Yet that didn’t prevent Kyra from going through the trials of mental illness. The author was careful in her descriptions of self-harm, depression, and suicidal intentions (please check trigger warnings), portraying them in a way that felt raw and honest. Kyra’s mental health wasn’t added for the sake of the plot or the romance, nor was it used only in certain scenes and forgotten about when it was inconvenient to the external plot. Mental illness was part of who Kyra was, but I loved that the author didn’t let it define her. Mental illness wasn’t glamorized in any way, but Kyra wasn’t villainized for not being perfect. The romance genre—especially dark romance—needs more honest portrayals of mental illness and Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown does an excellent job of setting the standard.
Trick (our shadow-wielding dark angel who may or may not commit murder for fun) fits the dark romance antihero archetype perfectly. Twisted and broken in the best possible way (or the worst, depending on who you ask), his perspective was interesting to read from, if not a bit terrifying (but then again, that’s kind of the point of the genre). On that note, this novel delivers on its promise of being a dark romance. The interactions between Kyra and Trick are not traditionally romantic, but safe words are respected.
The main thing that sets Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown apart from the rest of the genre is that the side characters are engaging and well-developed. From the loyal best friend to the sweet younger brother, there were people I cared about outside of the main couple and healthy, loving relationships to balance out the darkness of the romance. I’m excited for book two because I can’t wait to see more friendships develop and watch as the dynamics between some of the secondary characters are revealed in greater depth.
Though I enjoyed every minute I spent reading, what prevented Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown from becoming a five-star novel was worldbuilding. The construction of the fantasy setting is intricate and detailed; it’s very clear that the author understands the world she has created. That being said, so much space was given over to the worldbuilding that I often found myself struggling to find clarity. As an experienced fantasy reader who adores complexity in worldbuilding, it’s not that I didn’t enjoy the detailed setting, it’s only that I wish it had been woven into the plot a little more rather than being dumped into various chapters. Extra worldbuilding is the curse of the first book, so I’m eagerly awaiting exploring the world in the rest of the series now that it has been so heavily established.
Beyond worldbuilding, the pacing and writing of Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown was intoxicating. I often found myself swept away into the story, only to find that hours had passed the next time I glanced up at the clock. If you’re looking for your next dark romantasy read that will hold you captive until the very last page, I can’t recommend a better book.
An e-ARC was provided by the author in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions remain my own.
December 23, 2023
"It started out as a curiosity, but the more I watched you, the more I realized how terribly you wanted to be seen. Now I see you. Now you're mine. My little plaything, my toy. My Angel. My little addiction."
I really can't find the words to describe this book. The world building is amazing and beautiful, I felt fully submerged in it within the first 10 pages. H.G. intertwined mythology, lore, and religion so beautifully and perfectly that it just made sense.
Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown has slow/medium burn, enemies to lovers, touch her and💀, and a little bit of stalker and praise sprinkled in.
Did I mention that Trick is a possessive Shadow Daddy?
I've already started recommending it to my friends. This book has easily become one of my best reads this year, and I honestly can't wait for everyone else to read it when it comes out in February!
Be mindful of your triggers while reading. There is talk of self-harm/suicide, CNC, and breath play. I received this copy as an ARC.
I really can't find the words to describe this book. The world building is amazing and beautiful, I felt fully submerged in it within the first 10 pages. H.G. intertwined mythology, lore, and religion so beautifully and perfectly that it just made sense.
Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown has slow/medium burn, enemies to lovers, touch her and💀, and a little bit of stalker and praise sprinkled in.
Did I mention that Trick is a possessive Shadow Daddy?
I've already started recommending it to my friends. This book has easily become one of my best reads this year, and I honestly can't wait for everyone else to read it when it comes out in February!
Be mindful of your triggers while reading. There is talk of self-harm/suicide, CNC, and breath play. I received this copy as an ARC.
January 6, 2024
This book is a wild ride. My mind is SPINNING. She pulled me right in. Her writing style is like a mix of clear and concise, and personal inner monologue. The language is witty and fun, intelligent and lively. This storyline is incredible and I am already sending out manifestations of a new book soon!
The trigger warnings are there for your health and well being, so read them and take them to heart. You matter and and make sure you take care of your mental health ❤️
As an ARC reader, I would just like to say thank you to the author and let the girlies, the gays, the theys, and everyone outside and in between, READ THIS BOOK. It is soooooo worth the emotional damage
SPOILERS AHEAD…..
.
.
.
.
.
.
okay so I may need to add Trick to my list of Shadow Daddies that could ruin my life. By may need to add, I mean sir sign HERE. He could ruin my life and I would say thank you. The wings? Kill me. Stunning. The ol’ wing king himself. Honorary mention to the baddie that is Cole. I’d probably get myself into some minor legal trouble with you too. Also he reads smut books now and honestly what a good journey begin. I feel like he would go FERAL for the 2 story Barnes and Nobles. But I digress (see what I did there?). ANYWAYS lil Marky baby deserves all the love and ice cream in the world. BUT MISS THING WHERE IS HE. You cannot just leave it there. Let’s get this next book in these hands ASAP PLEASE I AM BEGGING YOU
Fair discussion is the absolute complexity of creating a new world from scratch in a new series that someone’s brain made up and communicating that to unknown amount of people and absolutely NAILING IT? It was complicated and confusing at first, which is the standard when starting new fantasy series. But after some time it was easier to grasp and the crazy way she thought to bring the information in a more digestible way by having Kyra be a Knowledge Queen? Love. Creative and new.
My only slight negatives that took the last star away is the chapters are sooooo long and I’m someone who only stops at the next chapter and I am deeply sleep deprived because why can’t we just have the POV change and start a new chapter? And also all of that heat and NO PICKLE? THE AUDACITY FOR THE AMOUNT OF TENSION. THAT SHOULD BE A TRIGGER WARNING!! Great googily moogily that was tense as hell girl. Like yes the writing is phenomenal and I’m going to obsess over these now, but please girl let her get laid by Zaddy Trick plz 😰
The cover design, by the way, the vibes are good. The mood is set. LOVE. Color choice is impeccable and I want my hands on a paperback as soon as they get released because she’s getting a place of honor.
Much love ❤️
The trigger warnings are there for your health and well being, so read them and take them to heart. You matter and and make sure you take care of your mental health ❤️
As an ARC reader, I would just like to say thank you to the author and let the girlies, the gays, the theys, and everyone outside and in between, READ THIS BOOK. It is soooooo worth the emotional damage
SPOILERS AHEAD…..
.
.
.
.
.
.
okay so I may need to add Trick to my list of Shadow Daddies that could ruin my life. By may need to add, I mean sir sign HERE. He could ruin my life and I would say thank you. The wings? Kill me. Stunning. The ol’ wing king himself. Honorary mention to the baddie that is Cole. I’d probably get myself into some minor legal trouble with you too. Also he reads smut books now and honestly what a good journey begin. I feel like he would go FERAL for the 2 story Barnes and Nobles. But I digress (see what I did there?). ANYWAYS lil Marky baby deserves all the love and ice cream in the world. BUT MISS THING WHERE IS HE. You cannot just leave it there. Let’s get this next book in these hands ASAP PLEASE I AM BEGGING YOU
Fair discussion is the absolute complexity of creating a new world from scratch in a new series that someone’s brain made up and communicating that to unknown amount of people and absolutely NAILING IT? It was complicated and confusing at first, which is the standard when starting new fantasy series. But after some time it was easier to grasp and the crazy way she thought to bring the information in a more digestible way by having Kyra be a Knowledge Queen? Love. Creative and new.
My only slight negatives that took the last star away is the chapters are sooooo long and I’m someone who only stops at the next chapter and I am deeply sleep deprived because why can’t we just have the POV change and start a new chapter? And also all of that heat and NO PICKLE? THE AUDACITY FOR THE AMOUNT OF TENSION. THAT SHOULD BE A TRIGGER WARNING!! Great googily moogily that was tense as hell girl. Like yes the writing is phenomenal and I’m going to obsess over these now, but please girl let her get laid by Zaddy Trick plz 😰
The cover design, by the way, the vibes are good. The mood is set. LOVE. Color choice is impeccable and I want my hands on a paperback as soon as they get released because she’s getting a place of honor.
Much love ❤️
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 29, 2023
Overall rating: 5/5
Spice rating: 4/5
"Give my thanks to whoever runs hell."
I was chosen as an ARC reader, and for this to be my first ARC book, it was AMAZING. It is a dark romance fantasy that will just drag you in and make you not want to put the book down. The world building is amazing. In the beginning, it was a tad bit confusing for me to keep up with the characters POVs, but everything started to come together and make so much sense. Kyra, Trick, Cole, Mark, just all of the characters make you really feel like you are apart of their world. The lore, mythology, touch of religion. The spice. Just everything is perfect. Trick is definitely the morally grey book boyfriend that you will fall in love with, despite not wanting to at first. I cannot wait for the rest of the series.
Spice rating: 4/5
"Give my thanks to whoever runs hell."
I was chosen as an ARC reader, and for this to be my first ARC book, it was AMAZING. It is a dark romance fantasy that will just drag you in and make you not want to put the book down. The world building is amazing. In the beginning, it was a tad bit confusing for me to keep up with the characters POVs, but everything started to come together and make so much sense. Kyra, Trick, Cole, Mark, just all of the characters make you really feel like you are apart of their world. The lore, mythology, touch of religion. The spice. Just everything is perfect. Trick is definitely the morally grey book boyfriend that you will fall in love with, despite not wanting to at first. I cannot wait for the rest of the series.
January 2, 2024
Check trigger warnings before reading. Started out a little confusing with so much information in the beginning but i could not stop reading! This book has a little bit of everything that fantasy lovers look for in a book. I can't wait for the next book.
January 5, 2024
Wow this book was good!
I received an arc of this book
There was a lot of world building in this book which I loved. At first it was a little hard to follow but by the end of it I understood completely. I love that Kyra is so strong for her brother and doesn’t back down when it comes to him. I don’t really know how I feel about Cole and I know he’s trying to look out for her but I can’t really stand him. He gives me Tamlin and Dain vibes (iykyk)
Trick is the typical morally grey character and I’m obsessed with him. I can’t wait until the next book to learn more about him and his past.
This book left me with a lot of unanswered questions that I hope will be answered in the next book. The magic system is really complex and a little hard to follow at times. I wish we had more details about that little bit about Ket! They shocked me to my core. I loved learning about the Demons and how they are just misunderstood. I love that Kyra sees the good in them even when no one else does. The ending was a brutal cliffhanger and I’m desperate for more answers. All in all i really enjoyed reading this book.
I received an arc of this book
There was a lot of world building in this book which I loved. At first it was a little hard to follow but by the end of it I understood completely. I love that Kyra is so strong for her brother and doesn’t back down when it comes to him. I don’t really know how I feel about Cole and I know he’s trying to look out for her but I can’t really stand him. He gives me Tamlin and Dain vibes (iykyk)
Trick is the typical morally grey character and I’m obsessed with him. I can’t wait until the next book to learn more about him and his past.
This book left me with a lot of unanswered questions that I hope will be answered in the next book. The magic system is really complex and a little hard to follow at times. I wish we had more details about that little bit about Ket! They shocked me to my core. I loved learning about the Demons and how they are just misunderstood. I love that Kyra sees the good in them even when no one else does. The ending was a brutal cliffhanger and I’m desperate for more answers. All in all i really enjoyed reading this book.
July 2, 2024
I'd give this 20 stars if I could I don't know if there are truly enough words to describe how freaking fantastic this book was . The story telling with God's , fates , wars , magical beings of demons, witches, fae , the fallen and so much more typically books with such a dynamic plot can leave you confused but this author makes it work so magically.
There's so many twist and turns at moments you'll laugh than cry have anger , some embarrassment and feel very spicy.
The female lead Kyra is amazing I love an amazing strong female character I felt truly close to kyras story and what's she been through , her undying love for her brother while handling so much abuse to keep him safe .
Trick is every bit of shadow daddy that is what I call him . I cannot wait to see more of his and Kyra's story unfold. The book leaves on a cliff hanger but lucky for you the second story is out . Now remember this is a cannot put down read kept me up til 3 in the morning you know how usually you hit 80 percent and the book takes off nah this one's like that from page one.
There's so many twist and turns at moments you'll laugh than cry have anger , some embarrassment and feel very spicy.
The female lead Kyra is amazing I love an amazing strong female character I felt truly close to kyras story and what's she been through , her undying love for her brother while handling so much abuse to keep him safe .
Trick is every bit of shadow daddy that is what I call him . I cannot wait to see more of his and Kyra's story unfold. The book leaves on a cliff hanger but lucky for you the second story is out . Now remember this is a cannot put down read kept me up til 3 in the morning you know how usually you hit 80 percent and the book takes off nah this one's like that from page one.
March 20, 2024
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶🌶🌶
Plot: 📚📚📚
Pacing: 👟👟👟
Tropes: Enemies to Lovers, Slow Burn, Found Family.
Triggers: Talk of S*ic¡d€/Self H@rm, n0n/c0n dub c0n, st@l*ing.
"All I wanted was to shatter her in every way a person could be shattered, and then take those pieces and swallow them whole until there was no me and no her, just us."
This is a dark fantasy romance, and it does end on a cliffhanger. The world building is massive, and admittedly I was definitely confused and overwhelmed with the information sometimes. There is a helpful glossary of terms in the back that helped me understand a lot of it.
The characters have great dialogue and witty banter. There aren't any flat characters. These characters have dark, somewhat broken minds due to trauma, but it felt realistic. It made it easier to relate the the characters and care about them. For being a slow burn, the spicy scenes are pretty hot too.
"Be brave in the face of all monsters, not just some of them."
The ending had me shook! It definitely embodied this quote. Kyra will definitely need strength like this to survive her own mind come the next book.
All in all, it was a great fantasy read, and I'm looking forward to seeing how the story progresses from here.
I received an ARC copy to review.
Spice: 🌶🌶🌶
Plot: 📚📚📚
Pacing: 👟👟👟
Tropes: Enemies to Lovers, Slow Burn, Found Family.
Triggers: Talk of S*ic¡d€/Self H@rm, n0n/c0n dub c0n, st@l*ing.
"All I wanted was to shatter her in every way a person could be shattered, and then take those pieces and swallow them whole until there was no me and no her, just us."
This is a dark fantasy romance, and it does end on a cliffhanger. The world building is massive, and admittedly I was definitely confused and overwhelmed with the information sometimes. There is a helpful glossary of terms in the back that helped me understand a lot of it.
The characters have great dialogue and witty banter. There aren't any flat characters. These characters have dark, somewhat broken minds due to trauma, but it felt realistic. It made it easier to relate the the characters and care about them. For being a slow burn, the spicy scenes are pretty hot too.
"Be brave in the face of all monsters, not just some of them."
The ending had me shook! It definitely embodied this quote. Kyra will definitely need strength like this to survive her own mind come the next book.
All in all, it was a great fantasy read, and I'm looking forward to seeing how the story progresses from here.
I received an ARC copy to review.
October 17, 2024
⭐️4.5 🌶️3.5
✨This novel had me on the edge of my seat the whole way through! In the beginning the world building was so captivating, it felt more like she created a whole universe.
✨The characters are to d!e for, they feel real and relatable which I love while reading. Kyra is such a bada$$ and Trick is… well EVERYTHING 🥵. He is my new favorite book boyfriend.
✨If you love mythology, lore, magic, and morally grey MCs , I highly suggest giving this a read!
✨This is book one of the Archangle Chronicles and I promise you once you read it you will absolutely be ready for book two. When you dive into this story make sure you have your highlighters, tabs, and pens ready because you won’t want to miss a single detail!
✨There are TW listed in the beginning so please make sure to look those over before hand.
✨This novel had me on the edge of my seat the whole way through! In the beginning the world building was so captivating, it felt more like she created a whole universe.
✨The characters are to d!e for, they feel real and relatable which I love while reading. Kyra is such a bada$$ and Trick is… well EVERYTHING 🥵. He is my new favorite book boyfriend.
✨If you love mythology, lore, magic, and morally grey MCs , I highly suggest giving this a read!
✨This is book one of the Archangle Chronicles and I promise you once you read it you will absolutely be ready for book two. When you dive into this story make sure you have your highlighters, tabs, and pens ready because you won’t want to miss a single detail!
✨There are TW listed in the beginning so please make sure to look those over before hand.
January 6, 2024
Absolutely obsessed! Definitely give this baby a 5 star 🌟. The suspense and never knowing what was coming next!
Highly recommend reading TW's before reading as this is a dark fantasy romance. Including r@pe, self h@rm etc.
Spice is on par 4/5 🌶🌶🌶🌶
"I keep telling you that you are mine. In the same respect, Angel , I am yours. Mind, body and spirit."
Highly recommend reading TW's before reading as this is a dark fantasy romance. Including r@pe, self h@rm etc.
Spice is on par 4/5 🌶🌶🌶🌶
"I keep telling you that you are mine. In the same respect, Angel , I am yours. Mind, body and spirit."
January 1, 2024
Really enjoyed this book! Check trigger warnings before reading. This book is spicy but it’s mixed with the plot and not the WHOLE plot. The FMC was pretty relatable most of the time. The world building is lovely! There’s a lot of complex information that’s presented in an understandable way. The beginning was slightly overwhelming with all the information but it was explained throughout the book. For me, this story was like if ACOTAR, Haunting Adeline, and The Golden Compass had a threesome and this was the result! Really excited for the next book!
December 31, 2023
“If you follow these rules, you will be rewarded. Your one and true God”
Yall are in for a true ride with this one. The mix of adventure, spice, drama, loooveee, incredible creatures 🫣
Following a human thief Kyra who’s battling an abusive mother, poverty, keeping her little brother safe, and suddenly the obsession of one High King who sends none other than his second in command to keep an eye on her and learn more about other fae. Will Kyra be able to save her brother? Or will higher forces intervene. .?
Stars: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice:🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Yall are in for a true ride with this one. The mix of adventure, spice, drama, loooveee, incredible creatures 🫣
Following a human thief Kyra who’s battling an abusive mother, poverty, keeping her little brother safe, and suddenly the obsession of one High King who sends none other than his second in command to keep an eye on her and learn more about other fae. Will Kyra be able to save her brother? Or will higher forces intervene. .?
Stars: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice:🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
April 8, 2024
"You have always been mine, and you will be mine until the last star goes out. That will never change. No matter how hard you pray or beg or scream, it will never change."
Where to begin? I devoured this book!! Trick Micheal 🤤😍🔥
The world building was phenomenal!! Fantasy books have a lot of world building but H.G. did such a wonderful job with building it as the plot grew.
Each character and their little quirks has you totally in love with little Mark, crushing on Cole, thieving with Kyra, learning about the demons, and falling for Trick Micheal.
I can’t wait to read the next book in the series!
Thank you H.G. Johnston for bringing us this incredible story!!
Where to begin? I devoured this book!! Trick Micheal 🤤😍🔥
The world building was phenomenal!! Fantasy books have a lot of world building but H.G. did such a wonderful job with building it as the plot grew.
Each character and their little quirks has you totally in love with little Mark, crushing on Cole, thieving with Kyra, learning about the demons, and falling for Trick Micheal.
I can’t wait to read the next book in the series!
Thank you H.G. Johnston for bringing us this incredible story!!
December 29, 2023
*Arc Review* I am wholeheartedly invested and can’t wait for the next book! The whole time reading this my brain was flipping! The way it was beautifully written, with incredible depth and details of the world helped create an effortless visualization. It’s suspenseful and mysterious. It had a bit of a slow burn but *chefs kiss* it’s just perfection!
🌶️ 3/5 Spice
🌶️ 3/5 Spice
February 13, 2024
"You have always been mine, and you will be mine until the last star goes
out. That will never change. No matter how hard you pray or beg or scream, it will never change."
When I tell you I side eyed my husband after I found myself head over heels for this absolute Shadow Daddy Mmc 🤤
If you like your men a little assholish and a lot of dark, then Trick is your new book boyfriend... I don't make the rules.
In the beginning, be prepared for a lot of world building! I mean, it's a fantasy series starter, for the gods sake. You gotta set the scene! But let me tell you, the transition of incorporating everything you learn early on into the main plot of the story is seamless, making the world building top tier.
Getting to know the characters and the demons will have you stealthily traversing the woods right along with the Kyra, learning about the world with Mark, crushing on Cole, and wanting to cuddle a Narg. It's written so immersively that I was able to see the world, hear the conversations, taste the antler... yes, I said antler.
If you liked books like ACOTAR and Haunting and Hunting Adeline, you'll love this book as well.
And a friendly reminder... Check the triggers. This book deals in some sensitive subject matters, and your mental health is important ❤️
Happy Reading!
out. That will never change. No matter how hard you pray or beg or scream, it will never change."
When I tell you I side eyed my husband after I found myself head over heels for this absolute Shadow Daddy Mmc 🤤
If you like your men a little assholish and a lot of dark, then Trick is your new book boyfriend... I don't make the rules.
In the beginning, be prepared for a lot of world building! I mean, it's a fantasy series starter, for the gods sake. You gotta set the scene! But let me tell you, the transition of incorporating everything you learn early on into the main plot of the story is seamless, making the world building top tier.
Getting to know the characters and the demons will have you stealthily traversing the woods right along with the Kyra, learning about the world with Mark, crushing on Cole, and wanting to cuddle a Narg. It's written so immersively that I was able to see the world, hear the conversations, taste the antler... yes, I said antler.
If you liked books like ACOTAR and Haunting and Hunting Adeline, you'll love this book as well.
And a friendly reminder... Check the triggers. This book deals in some sensitive subject matters, and your mental health is important ❤️
Happy Reading!
February 14, 2024
Holy sh!t. I’ll never understand how authors can be so creative with the world building and all the different creatures. I knew I’d love Trick before I started this but I want more! The cliffhanger was half what I was expecting but also half shocking. I’m sad in a way that this book isn’t even out yet since that means I’ll have to wait who knows how long to get more of this captivating story.
Below are certain quotes that if you’re like me will make you want to read this immediately!
“I have never been consumed like this before. You are mine and you will be consumed by me in every way a person can be consumed, however long that takes.”
“I’m your God now.”
“My Bible, Chapter 4, Verse 76, Every piece of you, every ounce of blood, every particle of bone, belongs to your new god. Relish in the fact that you will never be alone again. Relish in the fact that I own you.”
Below are certain quotes that if you’re like me will make you want to read this immediately!
“I have never been consumed like this before. You are mine and you will be consumed by me in every way a person can be consumed, however long that takes.”
“I’m your God now.”
“My Bible, Chapter 4, Verse 76, Every piece of you, every ounce of blood, every particle of bone, belongs to your new god. Relish in the fact that you will never be alone again. Relish in the fact that I own you.”
May 30, 2024
Starkeeper of The Fractured Crown follows Kyra as she fights her way through a divided world full of hatred, demons, and Nightcrawlers. It is a multi POV, first person, spicy, dark fantasy.
I loved this book so much. Although multi pov isn't my style, I found it worked really well in creating an in-depth understanding and provided extra information about the world. I enjoyed the world building. However, it was quite heavy at points with Kyra reciting all that she knows. I liked that she collected all of the information and would keep records of everything. It meant she could actually give information and theories with background, without it just "coming" to her in order to advance the plot.
I loved the different demons. It was fun learning about them and definitely different from a lot of other demons in books. The love between Kyra and Mark was so palpable. It was so well written and felt real.
This book is super steamy and fairly kinky. The writing didn't feel weird or cringey, and there were no unusual words for body parts. Definitely not for the faint of hearts, but it's not the craziest. I did really like the fact that Myra battled with herself about what turned her on.
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this book and can not wait for the second!
I loved this book so much. Although multi pov isn't my style, I found it worked really well in creating an in-depth understanding and provided extra information about the world. I enjoyed the world building. However, it was quite heavy at points with Kyra reciting all that she knows. I liked that she collected all of the information and would keep records of everything. It meant she could actually give information and theories with background, without it just "coming" to her in order to advance the plot.
I loved the different demons. It was fun learning about them and definitely different from a lot of other demons in books. The love between Kyra and Mark was so palpable. It was so well written and felt real.
This book is super steamy and fairly kinky. The writing didn't feel weird or cringey, and there were no unusual words for body parts. Definitely not for the faint of hearts, but it's not the craziest. I did really like the fact that Myra battled with herself about what turned her on.
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this book and can not wait for the second!
February 13, 2024
Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown by H.G Johnston
“To the darkest minds and the sinful hearts of this world. The corruption is horrific, let’s show them how much scarier we can be.”
Let’s give this one the hype it deserves!!
“My little plaything, my toy. My Angel. My little addiction.”
I have heard this book described as a cross between The Cat and Mouse duet as well as ACOTAR. I loved every second of it!! It was dark, vengeful, and heartwarming. This is the first book in the series so there are still a lot of unanswered questions! I am DYING for the next book!
We have the MMC that has touch her and d1e vibes, soulmate, N0N/C0N, and St@lker Romance. Check your tr1gger warnings this one is DARK.
“Call me, and I will come. Say my name, Angel, and I will find you. That is a promise and a threat.”
It was spicy and dark and everything I was looking for in a dark romance fantasy novel! The character development was well crafted and I was obsessed with every character.
“You like his darkness because it sings with yours,” the irrational part of me whispered.”
PRE ORDER NOW - FEB. 13th 2024!!
“To the darkest minds and the sinful hearts of this world. The corruption is horrific, let’s show them how much scarier we can be.”
Let’s give this one the hype it deserves!!
“My little plaything, my toy. My Angel. My little addiction.”
I have heard this book described as a cross between The Cat and Mouse duet as well as ACOTAR. I loved every second of it!! It was dark, vengeful, and heartwarming. This is the first book in the series so there are still a lot of unanswered questions! I am DYING for the next book!
We have the MMC that has touch her and d1e vibes, soulmate, N0N/C0N, and St@lker Romance. Check your tr1gger warnings this one is DARK.
“Call me, and I will come. Say my name, Angel, and I will find you. That is a promise and a threat.”
It was spicy and dark and everything I was looking for in a dark romance fantasy novel! The character development was well crafted and I was obsessed with every character.
“You like his darkness because it sings with yours,” the irrational part of me whispered.”
PRE ORDER NOW - FEB. 13th 2024!!
June 9, 2024
Check the trigger warnings before starting this book, this is a darker fantasy romance, but if the triggers don’t scare you away then read this book!!!
Kyra is a character with so much depth and pain, who is so incredibly easy to connect with and love. She is fighting for a better life for her and her brother against all odds and is constantly challenged. She is incredibly feisty and fiery and you root for her from the very beginning.
The world building is overwhelming at first because there is sooo much info to take in, but once you get the hang of it, it’s beautiful and wonderful!
Trick is obsessive and knows what he likes and he is not afraid to go after it! Oh and did I mention he’s a stalker, enough said.
There are twists and turns throughout this book and I shed so many tears, I cannot wait to see where this series goes!!
This is a slow build, enemies to lovers, stalker, definitely toxic at first fantasy dark romance book.
You absolutely wont regret starting this series, I can promise you that! This author doesn’t miss with her books, start this series and thank me later.
Kyra is a character with so much depth and pain, who is so incredibly easy to connect with and love. She is fighting for a better life for her and her brother against all odds and is constantly challenged. She is incredibly feisty and fiery and you root for her from the very beginning.
The world building is overwhelming at first because there is sooo much info to take in, but once you get the hang of it, it’s beautiful and wonderful!
Trick is obsessive and knows what he likes and he is not afraid to go after it! Oh and did I mention he’s a stalker, enough said.
There are twists and turns throughout this book and I shed so many tears, I cannot wait to see where this series goes!!
This is a slow build, enemies to lovers, stalker, definitely toxic at first fantasy dark romance book.
You absolutely wont regret starting this series, I can promise you that! This author doesn’t miss with her books, start this series and thank me later.
February 19, 2024
This book was amazing! I absolutely loved it! I am so proud that you executed this book, not a lot of people can write a book as compact and as complex as you did, literally screaming and hoping that your book gets noticed and fast! This is book one and there is a lot of information you must read before it gets into it. Which makes sense with how complexed and compacted this book is. Hold on tight because this book has a little bit of EVERYTHING fantasy wise
with thriller, mystery and romance all wrapped into a bow for this book. This book was amazing and I loved the characters. Cole is a great friend and he popped up when she really needed someone. Therian is the High King of the fallen and oh boyyyy. Is it really an obsession or it is love? It’s love I think but I’m dark and twisted. Hannah I’m literally loving how well you did this book. Don’t ever give up on writing and the way you have with words would have me dripping 🫠🤣 but this book was worth it. Rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ spice 🌶️🌶️🌶️
with thriller, mystery and romance all wrapped into a bow for this book. This book was amazing and I loved the characters. Cole is a great friend and he popped up when she really needed someone. Therian is the High King of the fallen and oh boyyyy. Is it really an obsession or it is love? It’s love I think but I’m dark and twisted. Hannah I’m literally loving how well you did this book. Don’t ever give up on writing and the way you have with words would have me dripping 🫠🤣 but this book was worth it. Rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ spice 🌶️🌶️🌶️
February 13, 2024
I didn’t want it to end.
Where is book 2?
The panic that came from the depths of my stomach when I realized I had finished it, I’ll never forget.
It took me a week to read this only because I didn’t want it to end.
H.G. Johnston has given us a world unlike anything and I’m telling you this it it! THIS IS THE NEW BOOK TO READ IN 2024!
Trick will make you hate him, love him, and hate that you love him so much.
Kyra is such a strong lead even through all of the battles she faces and has faced throughout her life.
I wanted to crawl into these pages and live with the characters.
The world building is top notch and so are the character.
We cannot forget Cole either because he is just as delicious as Trick is. Who else loves a dark hero?
Favorite quotes:
“Your darkest thoughts are my deepest desires, Kyra. Never look away from me when you speak them.”
Until the last star goes out – T.M.
Have I asked where is book 2 yet? I might just have to read this again!
Where is book 2?
The panic that came from the depths of my stomach when I realized I had finished it, I’ll never forget.
It took me a week to read this only because I didn’t want it to end.
H.G. Johnston has given us a world unlike anything and I’m telling you this it it! THIS IS THE NEW BOOK TO READ IN 2024!
Trick will make you hate him, love him, and hate that you love him so much.
Kyra is such a strong lead even through all of the battles she faces and has faced throughout her life.
I wanted to crawl into these pages and live with the characters.
The world building is top notch and so are the character.
We cannot forget Cole either because he is just as delicious as Trick is. Who else loves a dark hero?
Favorite quotes:
“Your darkest thoughts are my deepest desires, Kyra. Never look away from me when you speak them.”
Until the last star goes out – T.M.
Have I asked where is book 2 yet? I might just have to read this again!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 5, 2024
This has been so far the best book I've read this year. I'm looking forward to the development of this story. I really like both the female and the male lead which is very rare lately.
It's 4.5/5 for me, because at some moments I felt a little bit lost as to what was happening. But overall I enjoyed it a lot.
It's 4.5/5 for me, because at some moments I felt a little bit lost as to what was happening. But overall I enjoyed it a lot.
March 15, 2024
Well damn. I am so sad I have finished this one..
A book filled with Humans, Fae, Werewolves.. literally just the perfect DARK fantasy book!
Every turn had another twist and another moment that had you not wanting, but needing more.
Feisty FMC with a devilish MMC, every character was beautifully portrayed and you was fully immersed into the life they were living.
The ending... I'm heartbroken. Completely lost after reading this. I felt like my heart had been ripped out, I had grown to love the characters. So that cliff-hanger? Ooh that was a sore one. I wasn't prepared and I am not sure how I am going to survive waiting for book 2.
If you love a dark romance but with the element of fantasy, this is one for you!!
* Copied from my review on Amazon.
A book filled with Humans, Fae, Werewolves.. literally just the perfect DARK fantasy book!
Every turn had another twist and another moment that had you not wanting, but needing more.
Feisty FMC with a devilish MMC, every character was beautifully portrayed and you was fully immersed into the life they were living.
The ending... I'm heartbroken. Completely lost after reading this. I felt like my heart had been ripped out, I had grown to love the characters. So that cliff-hanger? Ooh that was a sore one. I wasn't prepared and I am not sure how I am going to survive waiting for book 2.
If you love a dark romance but with the element of fantasy, this is one for you!!
* Copied from my review on Amazon.
May 22, 2024
I loved everything about this book and cannot wait for this story to continue!
As always, PLEASE make sure you check the trigger warnings in this book.
Your mental health matters. 🫶
“You are the fire I want to die in, a craving I can’t satiate. You are every throb of my hardening c*ck, every beat of my blackened heart, every breath of my immortal life. You are a goddess among fucking men. And you. Are. Mine.”
Trick Micheal is my newest shadow daddy obsession. His obsession for Kyra is on another level and I can't wait to see how far they go.
Kyra is such a relatable character to anyone who has experienced depression or has had a loved one experience it. The way she moves through love is inspiring.
This book does end on a cliffhanger, but book #2 is releasing this year!
As always, PLEASE make sure you check the trigger warnings in this book.
Your mental health matters. 🫶
“You are the fire I want to die in, a craving I can’t satiate. You are every throb of my hardening c*ck, every beat of my blackened heart, every breath of my immortal life. You are a goddess among fucking men. And you. Are. Mine.”
Trick Micheal is my newest shadow daddy obsession. His obsession for Kyra is on another level and I can't wait to see how far they go.
Kyra is such a relatable character to anyone who has experienced depression or has had a loved one experience it. The way she moves through love is inspiring.
This book does end on a cliffhanger, but book #2 is releasing this year!
February 14, 2024
If the rest of the series is anything like this book, then we're in for a wild ride! There was so much happening in this book, but it flowed perfectly. H.G. Johnston was able to write multiple POVs, have fantastic world building, and have amazing relatable characters all in one fantastic dark slow burn romance 🖤❤️🔥 The plot was easy to understand, and the book in general was easy to read despite having multiple POVs, and that takes talent to pull off! Starkeeper of the Fractured Crown is perfect for fans of Haunting Adeline or ACOTAR😍❣️ This book has a lot of darker aspects so check TW if need be🖤✨
February 13, 2024
I absolutely loved this book!! Trick is by far my new favorite shadow boyfriend. (Sorry Xaden). The story and world building is amazing and I fell in love with every character from the beginning. I cannot wait for the next book!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews