The German Wife is the eleventh novel by best-selling Australian author, Kelly Rimmer. In 1950, after five years apart, Sofie von Meyer Rhodes and two of her three surviving children have departed Berlin to be reunited with her husband, rocket scientist Jurgen Rhodes, in Huntsville, Alabama.
There’s a mixed welcome: her husband is ecstatic about their arrival, but she notices that not all the German wives are friendly, and wonders what they know about Jurgen’s role during the war. And while the manager of the program for which Jurgen works encourages the American wives to make their German counterparts welcome, many can’t reconcile themselves to being friendly with a race of people who may have been responsible for the atrocities they have all heard about.
One of those American wives is Lizzie Miller, from a hardscrabble farming family which lost everything in a debt spiral during the prolonged drought of the 1930s. Her brother, Henry has seen first-hand what the Nazis did, resulting in mental distress termed combat fatigue. To the dismay of the hosts of the welcome party, Lizzie takes a stand and harsh words fly between her and Sofie.
Lizzie’s husband, Calvin is the General Manager of the fledgling space program, dubbed Operation Paperclip, and he has been assured that none of his talented German scientists were Party members. He’s not entirely convinced, but the chance to have these brilliant men working for America overrides his personal misgivings.
The depth of the two wives’ animosity, and the impetus for the harassment that follows, with potentially tragic consequences, is a feeling can be better understood from the events in their lives that led up to their current situation.
In this dual-timeline narrative, Rimmer even-handedly presents events from two very diverse perspectives. Parallels between Sofie’s and Lizzie’s lives, while not necessarily obvious to them, become more apparent as the story progresses.
As the details of Sofie and Jurgen’s lives in the build up to the war are revealed, Rimmer powerfully demonstrates just how effective fear for the safety of loved ones can be in forcing people to set aside their core values and act out of character.
Subject to persecution both subtle and overt, their children brainwashed, indoctrinated, even parents in prestigious positions are powerless to prevent it happening. Friendship with Jews gradually becomes something that will attract punishment, being made an example of. “We had so long been afraid of the consequences of dissent that even as the nation descended into madness, any moral call to rise up against the chaos went unheeded.”
Eventually, Jurgen faces an unenviable dilemma “I’m trapped on this path where my work is building to something heinous.” Their family under threat, they conclude: “The cost of anything but perfect compliance would simply be too high.”
Once they become aware of the atrocities to which they are party, do Sofie and Jurgen become two of those good people who allow evil to triumph by doing nothing? This story shows that perhaps it’s not always so simple. Should loyalty to country outweigh loyalty to family and friends?
Ultimately, Sofie hopes the American community might accept that: “we were more than just the mistakes of our past.”
Rimmer’s extensive research is apparent on every page, and she also demonstrates that misinformation, fake news, is really nothing new. Readers familiar with Rimmer’s work know to expect moving and thought-provoking, but this time she adds in controversial: this one is likely to prompt plenty of lively book-club discussion. Outstanding historical fiction.
This unbiased review is from a copy provided by Hachette Australia.