(I read the updated and expanded version, “2084 and the AI Revolution”)
I have an interest in and use AI on a daily basis, I work within the AI space and I am a Christian, so this was a really enjoyable read for me. Lennox is also my favourite Christian scientist and apologist, which probably adds a bit to my bias.
Despite its title, the book isn’t an imagined dystopia in the Orwellian sense. After setting the scene with the bigger questions, Lennox systematically outlines the current state of AI, with its positives (e.g., advances in medicine and diagnostics, efficiency gains, affective AI) and negatives (e.g., job losses, erosion of privacy, surveillance, and increased state control). I found it super helpful to see this horizontal overview of how deeply AI now reaches into every area of life, from banking to medicine, gaming to politics.
Lennox also highlights the likely future developments of AI, both good and bad. In particular, he distinguishes between narrow AI and AGI (artificial general intelligence). The latter refers to a hypothetical intelligence equal to or surpassing human cognition in all its aspects, which might be a potential technological “springboard” for transhumanism, where humans might merge with or even be replaced by intelligent machines.
Unsurprisingly, Lennox argues that “machines may simulate intelligence, but simulation is not the same as consciousness,” and remains overall sceptical of AGI. Still, he engages at length with its philosophical and theological implications. He frequently references Harari’s Homo Deus (literally, “humanity as god”), drawing parallels between its vision and the temptation in Genesis 3: “You shall be like God.”
“The dream of Homo Deus is as old as Eden. What is new is the technology that makes it seem almost plausible.”
As expected, there’s a rich discussion on the theology of the imago Dei, and what it means to be human in the Christian worldview. Lennox also preaches the Gospel throughout, which I love:
“Harari offers humanity as its own saviour. Christianity offers humanity a Saviour.”
This book is substantial, and there’s much more I could say about it (not least his interesting perspective on the book of Revelation!). But I’ll end on a more personal note. As someone working in AI, the book was a timely and crucial reminder that we need Christians in the AI space! We need believers in God, “men and women with strong moral convictions and (…) professional insiders to sit at the ethics table when it comes to the all-important moral questions raised by AI.” It reminded me that I need to do my part, in my small area of influence, to ensure that the research I produce is ethical and advocates for the human being and their unique value in a world that increasingly prizes efficiency over humanity.
Even reading the goodreads reviews, people are split on this book. And I understand why. Lennox is a Christian and that shines through, especially in the second half of the book. If you’re not open to the teaching of Christianity, you might find aspects of this book a little irksome. I recommend it regardless — shouldn’t we engage with different viewpoints?