Thanks to NetGalley and Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op for the eARC! Here is my honest review.
In this novel, Nicole Bailey retells the Epic of Gilgamesh and brings mythohistoric Ancient Sumer to life. In the cradle of civilization, gods fight for worship and adoration, monsters lurk in cedar forests, and kings and warriors strive to forge a legacy worth remembering.
In the Midst of Omens was everything I dreamed of while learning Mesopotamian mythology in ancient civilization classes in high school and university. I feel like this mythology has been slept on by authors for so long during an age where mythology retellings are more popular than ever, and Bailey skillfully shines a light on the mythology which is as old as human civilization itself. It’s apparent that Bailey researched culture, clothing, and religion during the writing of this novel, and brought all of that to the table in In the Midst of Omens. It is also apparent that Bailey has closely read the Epic of Gilgamesh (I can only imagine how many times!), and holds the original text in high regard while crafting a unique and original version of it.
There are certainly aspects of the original Epic which Bailey has altered in this retelling, but the alterations are made in such a way that still nods to the original text, rather than ignoring it, which I find deeply endearing, and given that story-telling conventions have somewhat changed in the last thousands of years, I think some changes were necessary in order to make the audience eager to spend time with and route for Gilgamesh as a character. Bailey artfully walks this tightrope, and succeeds in spades, as far as I’m concerned,.
There’s a peculiar kind of dramatic irony that comes inherent with skillfully told myth retellings, where the reader knows the ending, and finds themselves drawn through the narrative regardless, watching the inevitable destiny of the characters unfold and being unable to stop it or to look away. Bailey evokes this feeling beautifully in this novel.
With lovely prose, an evident love for the source text, a charming cast of characters, and the fated chemistry between Gilgamesh and Enkidu, In the Midst of Omens is perfect for fans of Madeline Miller and Sarah Underwood. You don’t need to have familiarity with the Epic of Gilgamesh or Mesopotamian mythology to enjoy In the Midst of Omens, but if you do, you’ll appreciate Bailey’s attention to detail and original flair.
If you’re looking for a sometimes-spicy, entirely heart felt mythological read, with throughlines of impending grief, the endurance of the human spirit and the human heart, and the deeply human need to leave something behind worth remembering, then you won’t in any way be disappointed with this novel. I, for one, eagerly await Bailey’s next novel and the continuation of her retelling of this most ancient of tales.