What do you think?
Rate this book
The Stone of Destiny & The Scots
In December 2020, it was announced that the Stone of Destiny was to be returned to Perth to be the centrepiece of the new Perth Museum. In this location, the Stone of Destiny is as near as it is possible to be to its historical location in Scone Abbey. This is as it should be. It is where the Stone of Destiny belongs.
This book tells the story of the Stone of Destiny and The Scots, an ancient wandering people, referred to in the Declaration of Arbroath. The chronicles record that they brought the stone from Spain to Ireland and then to Argyll, but these accounts have been dismissed by most experts as, ‘nothing by myth and fantasy’. The book, however, reports new evidence from DNA, archaeological and linguistic sources, which suggests that there may be more than a kernel of truth in that legendary claim.
Dr. Hulbert argues that there must be two Stones of Destiny – the ancient ‘Irish’ one which is now lost, and the Stone of Scone, quarried from Kincarrathie, located about a mile from Scone Abbey. The ‘Irish’ Stone may have been discarded by MacAlpin in favour of a local Pictish icon in 843, or, more likely, it may have been substituted by the monks of Scone Abbey to deceive Edward I in 1296. The book speculates about the ultimate fate of that ‘Irish’ Stone.
Meanwhile the Stone of Scone was exiled to Westminster Abbey, where it remained for 700 years. Its history before this exile, and possible previous uses, are explored, as is the political manoeuvring which led to its return to Scotland in 1996. Its journey from Westminster Abbey to Edinburgh Castle, and the elaborate ceremony of its handover (akin to that afforded to a visiting Head of State) are described, along with the conversion of Perth’s century-old City Hall to a prestigious museum fit for such an important national icon.
This book tells the story of the Stone of Destiny and The Scots, an ancient wandering people, referred to in the Declaration of Arbroath. The chronicles record that they brought the stone from Spain to Ireland and then to Argyll, but these accounts have been dismissed by most experts as, ‘nothing by myth and fantasy’. The book, however, reports new evidence from DNA, archaeological and linguistic sources, which suggests that there may be more than a kernel of truth in that legendary claim.
Dr. Hulbert argues that there must be two Stones of Destiny – the ancient ‘Irish’ one which is now lost, and the Stone of Scone, quarried from Kincarrathie, located about a mile from Scone Abbey. The ‘Irish’ Stone may have been discarded by MacAlpin in favour of a local Pictish icon in 843, or, more likely, it may have been substituted by the monks of Scone Abbey to deceive Edward I in 1296. The book speculates about the ultimate fate of that ‘Irish’ Stone.
Meanwhile the Stone of Scone was exiled to Westminster Abbey, where it remained for 700 years. Its history before this exile, and possible previous uses, are explored, as is the political manoeuvring which led to its return to Scotland in 1996. Its journey from Westminster Abbey to Edinburgh Castle, and the elaborate ceremony of its handover (akin to that afforded to a visiting Head of State) are described, along with the conversion of Perth’s century-old City Hall to a prestigious museum fit for such an important national icon.
Paperback
First published January 1, 2024
1 person want to read
About the author
John Hulbert
10 booksDr. John Hulbert was brought up in St. Andrews and is a graduate of Edinburgh University. He lectured in Bacteriology at Aberdeen and Dundee Universities and was a general practitioner in Dundee.
In the 1970s, Hulbert was a member of the SNP Housing Policy Group.
Elected to Perth & Kinross Council in 1995, he served as Provost from 2007 to 2012. As Provost he coordinated Perth’s 800th anniversary celebrations, and led the successful campaign to restore City Status, which had been unceremoniously removed in 1975.
In the 1970s, Hulbert was a member of the SNP Housing Policy Group.
Elected to Perth & Kinross Council in 1995, he served as Provost from 2007 to 2012. As Provost he coordinated Perth’s 800th anniversary celebrations, and led the successful campaign to restore City Status, which had been unceremoniously removed in 1975.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 of 1 review
January 6, 2025
A nice and fairly comprehensive book that was clearly written with a lot of love for Scotland, Perth and of course the Stone. I found the structure a little bit odd (a literature review in the middle for example) and struggled to fully hold my attention for some bits. That said, I knew a lot about the Stone and now I know even more and I'm looking forward to visiting it again in Perth.
I also found a few books that I've added to my to read which is a plus :)
I also found a few books that I've added to my to read which is a plus :)
Displaying 1 of 1 review