What do you think?
Rate this book
The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph
A compelling historical retelling of the first great scandal to shake America.
Victim? Temptress? Murderer?
October 1792. At Glentivar Plantation, Virginia, enslaved workers find the body of a white baby hidden amongst logs.
Judy and Richard Randolph along with Nancy, Judy’s eighteen year old sister, are staying at the plantation. The Randolphs are one of America’s most wealthy and influential families.
Screams were heard coming from Nancy’s room during the night.
Gossip quickly spreads throughout Virginia society: Nancy Randolph had given birth to a child by Richard, people whisper. Together they murdered the child to protect their reputation.
Richard is tried for murder and the sensational trial shakes the new American nation to its core.
The events of that night ripple down the years.
Who was Nancy Randolph?
A calculating seductress and murderer? Or an unwilling victim, groomed and manipulated by her devious brother-in-law?
In this retelling of one of America’s greatest scandals, Kate Braithwaite brings Nancy Randolph’s extraordinary story to vivid and memorable life.
Victim? Temptress? Murderer?
October 1792. At Glentivar Plantation, Virginia, enslaved workers find the body of a white baby hidden amongst logs.
Judy and Richard Randolph along with Nancy, Judy’s eighteen year old sister, are staying at the plantation. The Randolphs are one of America’s most wealthy and influential families.
Screams were heard coming from Nancy’s room during the night.
Gossip quickly spreads throughout Virginia society: Nancy Randolph had given birth to a child by Richard, people whisper. Together they murdered the child to protect their reputation.
Richard is tried for murder and the sensational trial shakes the new American nation to its core.
The events of that night ripple down the years.
Who was Nancy Randolph?
A calculating seductress and murderer? Or an unwilling victim, groomed and manipulated by her devious brother-in-law?
In this retelling of one of America’s greatest scandals, Kate Braithwaite brings Nancy Randolph’s extraordinary story to vivid and memorable life.
361 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 2, 2024
852 people are currently reading
1228 people want to read
About the author
Kate Braithwaite
7 books139 followersKate Braithwaite is the author of four historical novels based on true but overlooked events. “Charlatan” tells the story of Madame de Montespan and the Affair of the Poisons in 17th Century Paris. “The Plot” features Titus Oates’ Popish Plot, a scandal that earns him a place as one of Britain’s top 10 villains. “The Puzzle of Nellie Bly” explores the exploits of a ground-breaking female journalist going undercover in a 19th Century New York lunatic asylum. “The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph” reveals a shocking rupture between two very different sisters in late 18th century Virginia.
Originally from Scotland, Kate studied English at Leeds University and has subsequently lived in Canada and the US. She is the author of Sis-Stories, a Substack publication all about sisters in history and fiction, and an editor for the Historical Novel Society. Kate and her family live in Chester County, Pennsylvania.
Originally from Scotland, Kate studied English at Leeds University and has subsequently lived in Canada and the US. She is the author of Sis-Stories, a Substack publication all about sisters in history and fiction, and an editor for the Historical Novel Society. Kate and her family live in Chester County, Pennsylvania.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 72 reviews
April 17, 2024
My Reviews Can Also Be Found On:
The Book Review Crew Blog
4.5 Stars
I enjoyed this historical book very much. Braithwaite's writing was so easy to read, considering the dialogue was close to the time (late 18th/early 19th century) and her research was meticulous. It had to be...because this is a retelling of a true story. I was fascinated by these sisters, their bond and relationship. They may have come from wealth but they did not have easy lives, always depending on the men in their family to support them...father, husband, brother. My we ladies have come a long way in the time since.
I loved being in late 18th/early 19th century America while reading this novel, it was such a fascinating time in history especially in the South. It was wonderful getting snippets of thoughts from Nancy's slave, Phebe. It was amazing how close Phebe and Nancy were and how they cared for each other. Phebe knew a lot more than she was letting on but kept her mistress's secrets.
I was impressed with the author's knowledge of the story as very little information is available. This was an amazing historical fiction book about a true life story I had never heard of before. This was an adventurous read with a twist of mystery...What did Nancy really do?
The only reason I am not giving this five stars is the two time hops in the story. I would have loved to have read about what happened during those time frames especially while Nancy was supposibly pregnant. And the other time hop was ten years with nothing really said about what happened during that decade.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the Advance Readers Copy.
The Book Review Crew Blog
4.5 Stars
I enjoyed this historical book very much. Braithwaite's writing was so easy to read, considering the dialogue was close to the time (late 18th/early 19th century) and her research was meticulous. It had to be...because this is a retelling of a true story. I was fascinated by these sisters, their bond and relationship. They may have come from wealth but they did not have easy lives, always depending on the men in their family to support them...father, husband, brother. My we ladies have come a long way in the time since.
I loved being in late 18th/early 19th century America while reading this novel, it was such a fascinating time in history especially in the South. It was wonderful getting snippets of thoughts from Nancy's slave, Phebe. It was amazing how close Phebe and Nancy were and how they cared for each other. Phebe knew a lot more than she was letting on but kept her mistress's secrets.
I was impressed with the author's knowledge of the story as very little information is available. This was an amazing historical fiction book about a true life story I had never heard of before. This was an adventurous read with a twist of mystery...What did Nancy really do?
The only reason I am not giving this five stars is the two time hops in the story. I would have loved to have read about what happened during those time frames especially while Nancy was supposibly pregnant. And the other time hop was ten years with nothing really said about what happened during that decade.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the Advance Readers Copy.
May 1, 2024
I was attracted by the beautiful cover - and the name Randolph. I didn't immediately recognise the name Nancy - her nickname -, because I was familiar with her by her real name, but I had some knowledge from my studies of who the Randolphs were. [one of Virginia's wealthiest and most prosperous First Families - red]
This true-to-life, if somewhat romanticised, story gives a snapshot of 18th century Virginia - ("Scandal at Bizarre"), in which the reader enters a world of slave owners and plantations.
A list of characters can be found at the beginning of the novel. I do regret that an abridged family tree is not included in the book, but for those interested, it can also be found digitally, should you be interested in the Randolphs after reading this book.
The Randolphs were lineally descended from "Pocahontas", and through intermarriage also related to the Jeffersons. (Nancy wanted to stay with her family at Monticello [plantation].
We are introduced to patriarchal Virginia, a world of (tobacco) plantations and slavery.
For example, Nancy Randolph is given Phebe as property when she moves to Bizarre after her sister Judy's marriage. I felt very uncomfortable about this.
Her sister Judy Randolph marries her cousin Dick (Richard) Randolph. The marriage is unhappy and Dick suggests that her sister Nancy (Ann Cary) move in with them.
(women were not allowed to run their own households when unmarried, they were maintained by married family members until they married themselves, so they were considered a liability to the household finances. Basically, you didn't have many rights as an unmarried woman, nor was there much privacy for a married couple. This, of course, created all sorts of tensions. The author focuses on this in this book very well.
Nancy falls in love with one of her brothers-in-law (Theo) but he dies young.
She becomes pregnant and anxiously tries to hide the pregnancy, indicating that she has abdominal cramps when labour arrives.
Dick is later suspected of infanticide, and his reputation and the family name/honour are at stake. Eventually, a trial even ensues (Randolph Trail 1793), which exonerates him, but the persistent gossip that he would be the father of this child is unstoppable, and despite being acquitted, his good name and honour are forever tarnished.
I was pleasantly surprised by this engaging story about this period in American history. The author does a good job of keeping the reader involved in the story and sharing the ups and downs of this family. There is a lot going on.
From the quarrels between family members to the grief of the parents, who often had to bury several children in a short period of time. Despite their privileged position, it is clear that even the Randolphs cannot escape disaster: Judy loses a child, then has a boy who is deaf and dumb, a later-born son - her darling - dies before the age of 20.
Nancy's reputation is compromised and after Dick's death she is summoned to 'get lost’ because Jack does not want to see her again. Does Nancy manage to make a life for herself, despite being despised by everyone and having no means of support?
And then for a second time, rumours appear to be swirling around Nancy and a man….
This is obviously a period piece, but I felt very uneasy about Phebe and the slavery part; it is through her that we read the story of 'Miss Nancy'. Nancy's father gave her away as property when she went to live with her sister and brother-in-law. At the end of the book we read that Phebe's mother was sold. It broke my heart.
Quite a few people die in the book, but that too was part of the times. For example, 'Jack' loses two of his brothers in a very short time. I found the part about St George where he learns to sign rather moving.
The ups and downs of this family kept me glued to my Kindle, and I kept up late to finish it. A wonderful writing style and a really captivating family history. I will probably buy the paperback too and keep it as a reference in my library at home. A very compelling family history and period view of this period of America.
Highly recommended. 5 stars!
This true-to-life, if somewhat romanticised, story gives a snapshot of 18th century Virginia - ("Scandal at Bizarre"), in which the reader enters a world of slave owners and plantations.
A list of characters can be found at the beginning of the novel. I do regret that an abridged family tree is not included in the book, but for those interested, it can also be found digitally, should you be interested in the Randolphs after reading this book.
The Randolphs were lineally descended from "Pocahontas", and through intermarriage also related to the Jeffersons. (Nancy wanted to stay with her family at Monticello [plantation].
We are introduced to patriarchal Virginia, a world of (tobacco) plantations and slavery.
For example, Nancy Randolph is given Phebe as property when she moves to Bizarre after her sister Judy's marriage. I felt very uncomfortable about this.
Her sister Judy Randolph marries her cousin Dick (Richard) Randolph. The marriage is unhappy and Dick suggests that her sister Nancy (Ann Cary) move in with them.
(women were not allowed to run their own households when unmarried, they were maintained by married family members until they married themselves, so they were considered a liability to the household finances. Basically, you didn't have many rights as an unmarried woman, nor was there much privacy for a married couple. This, of course, created all sorts of tensions. The author focuses on this in this book very well.
Nancy falls in love with one of her brothers-in-law (Theo) but he dies young.
She becomes pregnant and anxiously tries to hide the pregnancy, indicating that she has abdominal cramps when labour arrives.
Dick is later suspected of infanticide, and his reputation and the family name/honour are at stake. Eventually, a trial even ensues (Randolph Trail 1793), which exonerates him, but the persistent gossip that he would be the father of this child is unstoppable, and despite being acquitted, his good name and honour are forever tarnished.
I was pleasantly surprised by this engaging story about this period in American history. The author does a good job of keeping the reader involved in the story and sharing the ups and downs of this family. There is a lot going on.
From the quarrels between family members to the grief of the parents, who often had to bury several children in a short period of time. Despite their privileged position, it is clear that even the Randolphs cannot escape disaster: Judy loses a child, then has a boy who is deaf and dumb, a later-born son - her darling - dies before the age of 20.
Nancy's reputation is compromised and after Dick's death she is summoned to 'get lost’ because Jack does not want to see her again. Does Nancy manage to make a life for herself, despite being despised by everyone and having no means of support?
And then for a second time, rumours appear to be swirling around Nancy and a man….
This is obviously a period piece, but I felt very uneasy about Phebe and the slavery part; it is through her that we read the story of 'Miss Nancy'. Nancy's father gave her away as property when she went to live with her sister and brother-in-law. At the end of the book we read that Phebe's mother was sold. It broke my heart.
Quite a few people die in the book, but that too was part of the times. For example, 'Jack' loses two of his brothers in a very short time. I found the part about St George where he learns to sign rather moving.
The ups and downs of this family kept me glued to my Kindle, and I kept up late to finish it. A wonderful writing style and a really captivating family history. I will probably buy the paperback too and keep it as a reference in my library at home. A very compelling family history and period view of this period of America.
Highly recommended. 5 stars!
July 24, 2024
Gripping. Having lived near Williamsburg, VA for over we 30 years, I am familiar with the settings and families in this book. It is amazing how quickly a person’s reputation could be ruined in the late 1700’s. My heart went out to Nancy. So glad she had a happy ending.
July 2, 2024
The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph by Kate Braithwaite
Rating: 4.5/5
"The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph" by Kate Braithwaite is a captivating historical novel that has rekindled my appreciation for the genre. This riveting retelling of one of America's earliest scandals is a masterful blend of fact and fiction that kept me engrossed from start to finish.
Set in October 1792 at Glentivar Plantation, Virginia, the story revolves around a shocking discovery: the body of a white infant hidden among logs. At the heart of the ensuing scandal are Judy and Richard Randolph, along with Judy's 18-year-old sister, Nancy. The Randolphs, a family of immense wealth and influence in early America, find themselves embroiled in a trial that shakes the foundations of the young nation.
Braithwaite's narrative skilfully weaves together known historical facts with imaginative storytelling, giving voice to perspectives that have been historically overlooked or undocumented. This approach adds depth and complexity to the characters, particularly Nancy Randolph, who is portrayed as a multifaceted individual rather than simply a seductress or murderer.
The novel excels in its moral ambiguity, challenging readers to question the motivations and true feelings of each character. This nuanced portrayal creates a rich, thought-provoking reading experience that resists easy judgments or prescriptive interpretations.
While the book's realistic depiction of historical events and attitudes can be shocking at times, it serves to highlight the harsh realities of the era. Potential readers should be aware of trigger warnings, as the novel contains language and events that may be disturbing to some.
The pacing, particularly in the first part of the book, is well-executed, maintaining interest throughout the complex narrative. The author thoughtfully includes a detailed character list, which proves invaluable in navigating the intricate family relationships.
A standout feature of the novel is its gripping courtroom scenes. These passages offer a fascinating glimpse into the early American legal system and its sensational trials, detailing the strategies of both defence and prosecution, as well as societal reactions.
In conclusion, "The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph" is a compelling work of historical fiction that brings to life a pivotal moment in early American history. Its blend of meticulous research, imaginative storytelling, and complex characterisation makes it a must-read for fans of the genre and newcomers alike.
Thank you so much to Joffe Books, and the author, Kate Braithwaite, for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest and fair review.
Rating: 4.5/5
"The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph" by Kate Braithwaite is a captivating historical novel that has rekindled my appreciation for the genre. This riveting retelling of one of America's earliest scandals is a masterful blend of fact and fiction that kept me engrossed from start to finish.
Set in October 1792 at Glentivar Plantation, Virginia, the story revolves around a shocking discovery: the body of a white infant hidden among logs. At the heart of the ensuing scandal are Judy and Richard Randolph, along with Judy's 18-year-old sister, Nancy. The Randolphs, a family of immense wealth and influence in early America, find themselves embroiled in a trial that shakes the foundations of the young nation.
Braithwaite's narrative skilfully weaves together known historical facts with imaginative storytelling, giving voice to perspectives that have been historically overlooked or undocumented. This approach adds depth and complexity to the characters, particularly Nancy Randolph, who is portrayed as a multifaceted individual rather than simply a seductress or murderer.
The novel excels in its moral ambiguity, challenging readers to question the motivations and true feelings of each character. This nuanced portrayal creates a rich, thought-provoking reading experience that resists easy judgments or prescriptive interpretations.
While the book's realistic depiction of historical events and attitudes can be shocking at times, it serves to highlight the harsh realities of the era. Potential readers should be aware of trigger warnings, as the novel contains language and events that may be disturbing to some.
The pacing, particularly in the first part of the book, is well-executed, maintaining interest throughout the complex narrative. The author thoughtfully includes a detailed character list, which proves invaluable in navigating the intricate family relationships.
A standout feature of the novel is its gripping courtroom scenes. These passages offer a fascinating glimpse into the early American legal system and its sensational trials, detailing the strategies of both defence and prosecution, as well as societal reactions.
In conclusion, "The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph" is a compelling work of historical fiction that brings to life a pivotal moment in early American history. Its blend of meticulous research, imaginative storytelling, and complex characterisation makes it a must-read for fans of the genre and newcomers alike.
Thank you so much to Joffe Books, and the author, Kate Braithwaite, for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest and fair review.
August 14, 2024
I stumbled across the story of Nancy Randolph and had to immediately know more. So I picked up and devoured a nonfiction account titled Unwise Passions by Alan Pell Crawford with a subtitle that says it all: “A true story of a remarkable woman and the first scandal of eighteenth-century America.”
Then it just so happened this scandal was the basis the amazing Kate Braithwaite's next novel. Her fictional rendering of this stunner of a real life tale is masterly crafted and truly amazing.
Braithwaite plunges the reader into this late eighteenth century American milieu that captures the uppermost social strata of the period with the Randolph family. This family mixed with the likes of the movers and shakers of the day; the Jeffersons, Patrick Henry, John Marshall among others in Virginian early colonial society and beyond.
There is a Jane Austen-esque quality to the author’s characterization as an overlay to this plot which unfurls with perfect timing. Braithwaite’s treatment of the mystery at the center of this scandal (a secret baby whose fate was unknown) is so clever in weaving in and out the possibilities until the very end when all is revealed. In the strangest of twists, the real life plantation where the scandal is centered was named….“Bizarre ”.
Kate Braithwaite has taken an unbelievable tale from early American history to create a compelling work of fiction. This should sweep the awards as a winner in historical fiction. Hats off to the author for this achievement!
Then it just so happened this scandal was the basis the amazing Kate Braithwaite's next novel. Her fictional rendering of this stunner of a real life tale is masterly crafted and truly amazing.
Braithwaite plunges the reader into this late eighteenth century American milieu that captures the uppermost social strata of the period with the Randolph family. This family mixed with the likes of the movers and shakers of the day; the Jeffersons, Patrick Henry, John Marshall among others in Virginian early colonial society and beyond.
There is a Jane Austen-esque quality to the author’s characterization as an overlay to this plot which unfurls with perfect timing. Braithwaite’s treatment of the mystery at the center of this scandal (a secret baby whose fate was unknown) is so clever in weaving in and out the possibilities until the very end when all is revealed. In the strangest of twists, the real life plantation where the scandal is centered was named….“Bizarre ”.
Kate Braithwaite has taken an unbelievable tale from early American history to create a compelling work of fiction. This should sweep the awards as a winner in historical fiction. Hats off to the author for this achievement!
June 23, 2024
Well researched! I could not put it down!!
February 27, 2025
A retelling of the story of Ann Cary Randolph, a scandalous figure in early American history. Poor Nancy had such a difficult time, probably because she was young and pretty. Her older sister Judy takes her to live with her and her husband Dick Randolph who seduces her. As the story unfolds we do not know exactly what happened until the very end of the book The family are invited to overnight at a relative’s house where Nancy is very ill. She claimed it was colic but the slave servants noticed blood on the stairs and stained sheets. They started to chatter and rumours spread quickly. The rumour was that Nancy had given birth and that Dick had killed the baby. They tried hard to quash the rumour but it would not go away. In order to clear his name Dick went to the courts and asked them to try him. After an embarrassing hearing he was cleared but the stain on Nancys character just would not go away. Nancy tried to live a quiet life looking after her sisters two children, one of whom was profoundly deaf. She continued in place even after Dick died It is likely that she could have lived this way but Dicks brother Jack was not having it. He kept fstirring things up and making life difficult if not impossible. She left the house of her sister and tried to find a quiet boarding house and work to support her. But Jack always followed her and spread untruths about her. Eventually she moved to New York where she met Gouvernor Morrison who fell in love with her and wanted to protect her. She finally agreed to marry him and they had a son. Jack of course followed them but this did not destroy their marriage and they continued their happiness together. The story was at times difficult to follow with so many families named Randolph. It would have been useful to have a family tree. At times it was so far fetched to make you think that it was all fabricated. But no, this was a fairly tru history. What a horrible life women had in the late 1700s
June 8, 2024
Another well researched and written book by this wonderful author.
May 17, 2025
Based on a true story with information gleaned from historical records, this is the story of Nancy Randolph, her sister and her brother-in-law. The basis of the story is a rumour that begins to circulate that Nancy gave birth to a baby fathered by Dick, her brother-in-law, and the baby was either stillborn or left to die on a woodpile.
I found this book frustrating. Most of the action seems to take place off the page. The supposed love affair between Nancy and Dick is only coyly alluded to and then the book skips forward several months to Nancy's maid Phebe telling her she's pregnant. And then it skips again to months after Nancy may or may not have given birth. Parts of the story are revealed later on in the book, but I found it a frustratingly bland way to tell what could have been a spicy story. It stripped all the drama out of it.
The characters were hard to like, too. In this telling, Nancy is seduced by her brother-in-law, but she's almost saint-like in keeping to the story she and Dick concocted to hide the truth. Even when she's vilified and in dire straits because of the rumours about her, she doesn't fight back or speak up. She never erupts with anger.
Dick is the kind of man who wants his cake and wants to eat it, too. He's unhappy in his marriage and attracted to his sister-in-law, so he acts on that attraction. He's a weak man, who gets caught up in a scandal of his own making, forcing a trial to try to clear his name.
Nancy's sister, Judy, is a cold woman, unable to love her deaf son because he's not perfect and mollycoddling her second son. She also blames her sister for all her woes. That's partially fair because Nancy did sleep with her husband, but Judy doesn't know that. During the trial, the only thing she seems bothered about is how hard it all is for her and that nobody seems to appreciate her suffering.
And then there's Jack, Dick's vindictive brother. In their youth, he fancied Nancy, but she didn't reciprocate the feeling. That seems to be the basis of his enduring hatred for her. Even when she's not around and hasn't been in his life for months or even years, he blames her for all manner of things.
There's a good story in here, but it could have been told so much better.
I found this book frustrating. Most of the action seems to take place off the page. The supposed love affair between Nancy and Dick is only coyly alluded to and then the book skips forward several months to Nancy's maid Phebe telling her she's pregnant. And then it skips again to months after Nancy may or may not have given birth. Parts of the story are revealed later on in the book, but I found it a frustratingly bland way to tell what could have been a spicy story. It stripped all the drama out of it.
The characters were hard to like, too. In this telling, Nancy is seduced by her brother-in-law, but she's almost saint-like in keeping to the story she and Dick concocted to hide the truth. Even when she's vilified and in dire straits because of the rumours about her, she doesn't fight back or speak up. She never erupts with anger.
Dick is the kind of man who wants his cake and wants to eat it, too. He's unhappy in his marriage and attracted to his sister-in-law, so he acts on that attraction. He's a weak man, who gets caught up in a scandal of his own making, forcing a trial to try to clear his name.
Nancy's sister, Judy, is a cold woman, unable to love her deaf son because he's not perfect and mollycoddling her second son. She also blames her sister for all her woes. That's partially fair because Nancy did sleep with her husband, but Judy doesn't know that. During the trial, the only thing she seems bothered about is how hard it all is for her and that nobody seems to appreciate her suffering.
And then there's Jack, Dick's vindictive brother. In their youth, he fancied Nancy, but she didn't reciprocate the feeling. That seems to be the basis of his enduring hatred for her. Even when she's not around and hasn't been in his life for months or even years, he blames her for all manner of things.
There's a good story in here, but it could have been told so much better.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 22, 2024
In "The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph," author Kate Braithwaite skillfully blends meticulous research with vivid storytelling, bringing to life the fascinating era in which Nancy Randolph and her contemporaries lived. I esp loved the brief mentions of Jefferson, Burr, & Thomas Nelson.
In this historical fiction novel, readers are introduced to Nancy Randolph, a woman whose life is shrouded in mystery and adventure. Set against a backdrop of the past, the narrative delves into the intriguing twists and turns of Nancy's journey, leaving readers eager to uncover the truth behind her actions.
I took away one star for this: although Nancy serves as the central figure, I found myself grappling with her passive approach to life's challenges. Despite facing adversity and experiencing a tarnished reputation, Nancy's lack of agency may leave readers questioning her decisions and motivations.
However, the narrative does offer a unique perspective by weaving in the voice of Phebe, Nancy's slave, whose presence adds depth and complexity to the storyline. Phebe emerges as a fascinating character in her own right, offering readers a glimpse into a perspective often overlooked in historical fiction.
Yet, despite the rich cast of characters and the captivating plot, some aspects of the novel may leave readers wanting more. The sporadic and brief shifts in point of view may leave certain characters feeling underdeveloped, particularly Nancy, whose perspective could have been further explored.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
In this historical fiction novel, readers are introduced to Nancy Randolph, a woman whose life is shrouded in mystery and adventure. Set against a backdrop of the past, the narrative delves into the intriguing twists and turns of Nancy's journey, leaving readers eager to uncover the truth behind her actions.
I took away one star for this: although Nancy serves as the central figure, I found myself grappling with her passive approach to life's challenges. Despite facing adversity and experiencing a tarnished reputation, Nancy's lack of agency may leave readers questioning her decisions and motivations.
However, the narrative does offer a unique perspective by weaving in the voice of Phebe, Nancy's slave, whose presence adds depth and complexity to the storyline. Phebe emerges as a fascinating character in her own right, offering readers a glimpse into a perspective often overlooked in historical fiction.
Yet, despite the rich cast of characters and the captivating plot, some aspects of the novel may leave readers wanting more. The sporadic and brief shifts in point of view may leave certain characters feeling underdeveloped, particularly Nancy, whose perspective could have been further explored.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
April 30, 2024
Sisterly devotion and love, or deceit and betrayal skillfully portrayed?
Every family has secrets, but the ones kept by the historical characters in Kate Braithwaite’s new novel, The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph, have ruinous consequences for the illustrious Colonial Virginia family’s fate.
Beautifully constructed from personal letters and historical documents that follow real events, this story of rumors, inuendo and interpretations about what occurred at the Randolph plantation is told alternately through the eyes of Nancy Randolph, her sister Judy, with the occasional injection of the recollections from Nancy’s slave Phebe.
This story left me thinking about the shading each of us puts to events, and how difficult knowing the truth about another person often can be, even if you are close. While you read, the plausibility of each character’s perspective gains traction, making you certain of what occurred, while Braithewaite masterfully keep you turning the page, only to find yourself questioning your assumptions again.
The consequences of decisions made by each person - driven by social constraints, self-inflicted misinterpretations, and the pernicious nature of notoriety – stifled more lives than those of Nancy, Judy, and Phebe, cutting a wide swath across generations, but ultimately making the entire Randolph family’s story sympathetic, believable and tragic. A well written account of a once infamous event, relegated to the shadows in the passage of time.
I received an Advance Readers Copy of this work.
Every family has secrets, but the ones kept by the historical characters in Kate Braithwaite’s new novel, The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph, have ruinous consequences for the illustrious Colonial Virginia family’s fate.
Beautifully constructed from personal letters and historical documents that follow real events, this story of rumors, inuendo and interpretations about what occurred at the Randolph plantation is told alternately through the eyes of Nancy Randolph, her sister Judy, with the occasional injection of the recollections from Nancy’s slave Phebe.
This story left me thinking about the shading each of us puts to events, and how difficult knowing the truth about another person often can be, even if you are close. While you read, the plausibility of each character’s perspective gains traction, making you certain of what occurred, while Braithewaite masterfully keep you turning the page, only to find yourself questioning your assumptions again.
The consequences of decisions made by each person - driven by social constraints, self-inflicted misinterpretations, and the pernicious nature of notoriety – stifled more lives than those of Nancy, Judy, and Phebe, cutting a wide swath across generations, but ultimately making the entire Randolph family’s story sympathetic, believable and tragic. A well written account of a once infamous event, relegated to the shadows in the passage of time.
I received an Advance Readers Copy of this work.
May 2, 2024
Location: Tuckahoe, VA, USA 🇺🇸
Conclusion: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This book was very interesting from an historical perspective. The way Nancy was perceived by her family and society just because rumours arose around her having an affair with her brother in law was unjust. The story was well developed and had me invested even though it felt slow paced at times. The writing style was good and it felt modern to me while sustaining the feeling of reading a book set the 1700s.
Characters:
- Nancy: is strong at heart, but society prevents her from showing this strength to the outside. She has rather modern values for the time and the way she supports her nephew and treats her maid is impressive considering the time.
- Phebe: is Nancy's rock and even though she is not free she supports and cares for her not only as her mistress but also on a human level which I find displays a lot of strength.
- Judy & Family: is Nancy's sister and is quite dislikable along with the rest of the family.
What I liked: how the book feels quite historically accurate.
What I disliked: the pace was too slow at times.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC in exchange for an honest review (AD-PRODUCT).
Conclusion: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This book was very interesting from an historical perspective. The way Nancy was perceived by her family and society just because rumours arose around her having an affair with her brother in law was unjust. The story was well developed and had me invested even though it felt slow paced at times. The writing style was good and it felt modern to me while sustaining the feeling of reading a book set the 1700s.
Characters:
- Nancy: is strong at heart, but society prevents her from showing this strength to the outside. She has rather modern values for the time and the way she supports her nephew and treats her maid is impressive considering the time.
- Phebe: is Nancy's rock and even though she is not free she supports and cares for her not only as her mistress but also on a human level which I find displays a lot of strength.
- Judy & Family: is Nancy's sister and is quite dislikable along with the rest of the family.
What I liked: how the book feels quite historically accurate.
What I disliked: the pace was too slow at times.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC in exchange for an honest review (AD-PRODUCT).
May 27, 2024
Jean38no
A great historical novel. Based on real people . A true story of families during the 1800’s . The story of Nancy Randolph. The author sweeps you into the era of the Randolph’s a prominent Virginia slave owing family. Nancy’s mother died. Her dad remarried . She was sent to live with her married sister who was two years older than her. That’s where the scandal started. Nancy accused of sleeping with her brother in law , having a baby and getting rid of it. She was ostracized . There are many real life famous people involved with the families of both the husband Dick Randolph and the wife’s family.
The rumor grew so big there was a trial . The husband was found not guilty. One of his defense attorneys was Patrick Henry.
The author weaves you in this tale of rumor, complicity, cruelty, jealousy so you just can’t put it down!
A great historical novel. Based on real people . A true story of families during the 1800’s . The story of Nancy Randolph. The author sweeps you into the era of the Randolph’s a prominent Virginia slave owing family. Nancy’s mother died. Her dad remarried . She was sent to live with her married sister who was two years older than her. That’s where the scandal started. Nancy accused of sleeping with her brother in law , having a baby and getting rid of it. She was ostracized . There are many real life famous people involved with the families of both the husband Dick Randolph and the wife’s family.
The rumor grew so big there was a trial . The husband was found not guilty. One of his defense attorneys was Patrick Henry.
The author weaves you in this tale of rumor, complicity, cruelty, jealousy so you just can’t put it down!
April 15, 2024
This story is a very gripping and emotional read surrounding a truly unfortunate set of events. I appreciated that this story was based on historical events of well-known people in early America, and it was a story I didn’t know existed before. The author details the experience from the point of view of Nancy, Judy, and Nancy’s slave, Phebe. I appreciated the added context of Phebe’s point of view, as it made me aware of a new complex perspective.
My only critique was that the first few chapters didn’t feel as detailed or cohesive as the rest of the book. Everything seemed to move blindingly fast and at times it was difficult to keep up. The author clearly has the ability to write in a lovely descriptive and colorful way, as shown through the rest of the novel.
My only critique was that the first few chapters didn’t feel as detailed or cohesive as the rest of the book. Everything seemed to move blindingly fast and at times it was difficult to keep up. The author clearly has the ability to write in a lovely descriptive and colorful way, as shown through the rest of the novel.
April 19, 2024
The Scandalous Life of Nancy Rudolph by Kate Braithwaite is an interesting Historical Fiction Mystery. It is based on the true story of Nancy Rudolph.
While reading this book, I felt as if I was there, watching the interactions of Nancy, her family, and her staff in the late 1700s in Virginia. This story clearly defines how women had no real voice, rights, or control of their own lives, and how stifling the societal norms were. This book takes you in- and the story and mystery will surprise you all the way to the end.
I recommend this book as an enjoyable read, especially to historical fiction fans.
It is published by Joffe books. Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC of this book.
While reading this book, I felt as if I was there, watching the interactions of Nancy, her family, and her staff in the late 1700s in Virginia. This story clearly defines how women had no real voice, rights, or control of their own lives, and how stifling the societal norms were. This book takes you in- and the story and mystery will surprise you all the way to the end.
I recommend this book as an enjoyable read, especially to historical fiction fans.
It is published by Joffe books. Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC of this book.
Read
January 30, 2025I thought author Kate Braithwaite did an obvious amount of detailed research into the lives of the women and era that “The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph” revolved around. I found this work of historical fiction to not only clearly paint a picture of the times these women lived but also showed how truly resilient and strong women are. They continuously endure hard times, traumatic happenings and yet they keep pushing forward. I enjoyed this book and would recommend it to anyone who can appreciate a book based on a true story with many twists and turns, many of which they won’t see coming.
May 9, 2024
Excellent historical fiction that created a well rounded look into a family severed by scandal and gossip in early America. As a descendant to the Randolph's of VA, the author did her research and brought these real people to life again. The story was told in multiple perspectives, which will give you pause on who really was the victim of this supposed crime? Highly recommend to lovers of history and Revolutionary-era America. #thescandalouslifeofnancyrandolph #katebraithwaite #netgalley #goodreads
May 28, 2024
Congratulations Kate. Outstanding job—the research and writing are top notch. I love colonial history and a special interest in VA. I most often read history, bios, nonfiction event explanations and the like. Late one night, out of town and sleepless, i selected this book. Far from the mindless romance novel i expected, it is a rich read. I believe the careful faithfulness to actual events contributed mightily to the spellbinding story Kate has written. Well-spun, excellent style and hard to put down!
July 21, 2024
On the fence? Read it.
I knew nothing of this situation until I read the description for this book. A brief Google search gave me some vague information about a scandal from the 1800s involving adultery, betrayal, and suspected murder.....
Kate Braithwaite did an honorable job creating the fascinating "behind the scenes" on this situation. I devoured this book, forcing myself to put it away after reading for six straight hours and realizing I hadn't slept and had to be up in two hours.
I knew nothing of this situation until I read the description for this book. A brief Google search gave me some vague information about a scandal from the 1800s involving adultery, betrayal, and suspected murder.....
Kate Braithwaite did an honorable job creating the fascinating "behind the scenes" on this situation. I devoured this book, forcing myself to put it away after reading for six straight hours and realizing I hadn't slept and had to be up in two hours.
May 8, 2024
I enjoyed this book, historical fiction isn't usually my go to genre and the history in this book isn't one I have any prior knowledge of but it was very interesting to get a look into life in such a different time. The fiction weaved into real events was compelling and I did find myself wanting to know what the resolution would be. Knowing the resolution is a work of fiction does make me curious as to the factual history that we will never know the answers to. A good read.
June 30, 2024
A well researched book about a person I knew very little about. I knew some of the Randolph family from reading books about Patsy Jefferson but had not heard about the scandal surrounding Nancy's life. A very entertaining read. Very highly recommended!
June 23, 2024
Title: The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph
Author: Kate Braithwaite Genre:
Historical Fiction
Rating: 4.5 Stars
WOW, oh wow, I did not expect to be so captivated by this as I was!
"The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph," is a riveting historical retelling of one of America’s first great scandals and oh my….. what a read!
October 1792, at Glentivar Plantation, Virginia: the body of a white baby is found hidden amongst logs, and whispers of scandal spread like wildfire. At the centre of it all are Judy and Richard Randolph, and Judy’s eighteen-year-old sister, Nancy.
The Randolphs, one of America’s wealthiest and most influential families, find themselves at the heart of a shocking trial that rocks the young nation.
Nancy Randolph, rumoured to have given birth to a child by her brother-in-law Richard, is accused of being a seductress and murderer. As Richard is tried for murder, society is left to wonder: is Nancy a calculating temptress or an unwilling victim?
What I Loved:
1. Gripping Historical Retelling: Braithwaite brilliantly brings to life the scandal that shook early America. The attention to historical detail and the vivid portrayal of 18th-century Virginia immerse you in the era.
2. Complex Characters: Nancy Randolph is a fascinating character. Her portrayal as either a victim or a villain is skillfully ambiguous, keeping readers engaged and questioning her true nature. Richard Randolph’s character adds further depth and intrigue, making for a compelling cast.
3. Atmospheric Setting: The descriptions of Glentivar Plantation and the societal norms of the time are richly detailed. You can almost feel the tension and scandal in the air, making the setting a character in its own right.
4. Engaging Narrative: The book’s pacing is perfect, with suspense building steadily as the trial unfolds. The mix of courtroom drama, societal gossip, and personal tragedy creates a captivating read.
5. Themes of Power and Reputation: The novel explores themes of power, reputation, and the lengths to which people will go to protect their standing in society. These themes are just as relevant today, adding a layer of modern resonance to the historical tale.
The novel’s courtroom scenes are particularly gripping. The detailed accounts of the trial, the strategies of the defence and prosecution, and the societal reactions provide a fascinating glimpse into the early American legal system and its sensational trials.
"The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph" is a masterful blend of historical fiction and mystery That had me hooked from beginning to end! Kate Braithwaite’s retelling of this infamous scandal is both enlightening and entertaining, providing a fresh perspective on a pivotal moment in American history.
Whether Nancy Randolph was a seductress or a victim, her story is one that demands to be told and remembered.
This book will appeal to history buffs, mystery lovers, and anyone who enjoys a well-crafted, thought-provoking tale. Prepare to be transported back in time and to question everything you think you know about Nancy Randolph and the scandal that defined her life.
Thank you to The Publisher Joffe Books & The Author Kate Braithwaite for an advanced reader copy (ARC) in exchange for my honest review.
August 13, 2024
Book Review: The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph by Kate Braithwaite
Rating: 4 Stars
First off, can we just take a moment to appreciate the gorgeous cover of this book? It's so eye-catching!
Now onto my review...
The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph is a gripping historical retelling that dives into one of America's first great scandals that rocked the nation in October 1792. The story begins at Glentivar Plantation in Virginia, where enslaved workers discover the body of a white baby hidden among logs. This shocking discovery leads to whispers and rumors that sweep through Virginia society, particularly surrounding young Nancy Randolph, who is believed to have had an affair with her brother-in-law Dick. The gossip escalates, suggesting that Nancy and Dick murdered the child to protect their family’s reputation.
As the tale unfolds, we are plunged into a world of intrigue, betrayal, and complex family dynamics. The trial that follows Dick's arrest becomes a sensational event that not only captures the public's attention but also shakes the very foundations of the fledgling American nation. The question lingers: Who is Nancy Randolph? Is she a calculating seductress and murderer, or merely an unwilling victim caught in a web of familial manipulation?
I went into this book knowing absolutely nothing about the history surrounding these people and events, but I was pleasantly surprised by how engaging the story turned out to be. Kate Braithwaite does an excellent job of immersing readers in this tumultuous period, weaving together the ups and downs of the Randolph family with skill and finesse. My heart truly went out to Nancy, and I found myself rooting for her throughout the book.
One aspect I particularly appreciated was the pacing—especially in the first part of the narrative. Braithwaite keeps the reader invested with well-executed tension and drama. Plus, she thoughtfully includes a detailed character list at the beginning, which proves invaluable when navigating the intricate family relationships. It’s a clever touch that I wish more historical fiction authors would consider.
Overall, The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph is another well-researched and beautifully written book by Kate Braithwaite. Whether you're a history buff or just looking for a compelling story filled with scandal and intrigue, this book is sure to deliver an unforgettable experience.
⚠️This review was written based on personal opinions and experiences with the book. Individual preferences may vary⚠️
Rating: 4 Stars
First off, can we just take a moment to appreciate the gorgeous cover of this book? It's so eye-catching!
Now onto my review...
The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph is a gripping historical retelling that dives into one of America's first great scandals that rocked the nation in October 1792. The story begins at Glentivar Plantation in Virginia, where enslaved workers discover the body of a white baby hidden among logs. This shocking discovery leads to whispers and rumors that sweep through Virginia society, particularly surrounding young Nancy Randolph, who is believed to have had an affair with her brother-in-law Dick. The gossip escalates, suggesting that Nancy and Dick murdered the child to protect their family’s reputation.
As the tale unfolds, we are plunged into a world of intrigue, betrayal, and complex family dynamics. The trial that follows Dick's arrest becomes a sensational event that not only captures the public's attention but also shakes the very foundations of the fledgling American nation. The question lingers: Who is Nancy Randolph? Is she a calculating seductress and murderer, or merely an unwilling victim caught in a web of familial manipulation?
I went into this book knowing absolutely nothing about the history surrounding these people and events, but I was pleasantly surprised by how engaging the story turned out to be. Kate Braithwaite does an excellent job of immersing readers in this tumultuous period, weaving together the ups and downs of the Randolph family with skill and finesse. My heart truly went out to Nancy, and I found myself rooting for her throughout the book.
One aspect I particularly appreciated was the pacing—especially in the first part of the narrative. Braithwaite keeps the reader invested with well-executed tension and drama. Plus, she thoughtfully includes a detailed character list at the beginning, which proves invaluable when navigating the intricate family relationships. It’s a clever touch that I wish more historical fiction authors would consider.
Overall, The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph is another well-researched and beautifully written book by Kate Braithwaite. Whether you're a history buff or just looking for a compelling story filled with scandal and intrigue, this book is sure to deliver an unforgettable experience.
⚠️This review was written based on personal opinions and experiences with the book. Individual preferences may vary⚠️
May 7, 2024
My review for The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph by Kate Braithwaite (4 stars): A great historical fiction novel
Thank you Joffe Books for sharing an advanced reader’s copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I truly enjoyed this epic family drama set in the late 18th and early 19th century US. The story follows the lives of two Randolph sisters, Judy and Nancy. Their love for each other and close friendship are uncanny, though they could not be more opposite in character. Practical and thoughtful Judy is so different from the passionate and fun Nancy. In their younger years their differences seem to complement their relationship, but as the events of their lives unfold these exact differences are the cause of the shocking dramatic events of the Randolph family.
The story is loosely based on true events, though Kate Braithwaite included new untold perspectives of those whose voices haven’t historically been heard or documented. As the strain in the Randolph family begins (it’s impossible to share more details without spoiling anything), as a reader we’re faced with questioning our characters’ motivations, true thoughts and feelings. If you like an open-ended novel that isn’t prescriptive of whether you should like the characters or not, you’ll enjoy this novel. This is moral greyness at it’s best.
It is sometimes shocking to read realistic historical fiction because of the harsh realities of the times, and this novel is no exception. I strongly recommend you check your trigger and content warnings before going into this one, as the novel has some language and events that might affect the reader negatively.
I enjoyed the pacing of the first part of the book and found the events and the story extremely interesting. I’m glad the author has included a detailed list of all the characters, which I had to go back to a few times before I got the gist of the complicated family trees. Once you get on board with all the characters, the story is easy to follow. I did struggle with the second half of the book as I thought the pacing slowed down quite a bit, hence why I reduced my rating to 4 stars.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and would recommend it to those who like historical fiction.
Thank you Joffe Books for sharing an advanced reader’s copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I truly enjoyed this epic family drama set in the late 18th and early 19th century US. The story follows the lives of two Randolph sisters, Judy and Nancy. Their love for each other and close friendship are uncanny, though they could not be more opposite in character. Practical and thoughtful Judy is so different from the passionate and fun Nancy. In their younger years their differences seem to complement their relationship, but as the events of their lives unfold these exact differences are the cause of the shocking dramatic events of the Randolph family.
The story is loosely based on true events, though Kate Braithwaite included new untold perspectives of those whose voices haven’t historically been heard or documented. As the strain in the Randolph family begins (it’s impossible to share more details without spoiling anything), as a reader we’re faced with questioning our characters’ motivations, true thoughts and feelings. If you like an open-ended novel that isn’t prescriptive of whether you should like the characters or not, you’ll enjoy this novel. This is moral greyness at it’s best.
It is sometimes shocking to read realistic historical fiction because of the harsh realities of the times, and this novel is no exception. I strongly recommend you check your trigger and content warnings before going into this one, as the novel has some language and events that might affect the reader negatively.
I enjoyed the pacing of the first part of the book and found the events and the story extremely interesting. I’m glad the author has included a detailed list of all the characters, which I had to go back to a few times before I got the gist of the complicated family trees. Once you get on board with all the characters, the story is easy to follow. I did struggle with the second half of the book as I thought the pacing slowed down quite a bit, hence why I reduced my rating to 4 stars.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and would recommend it to those who like historical fiction.
April 17, 2024
What a superb read! This is a work of historical fiction but based around a true story and the author has done a fantastic job of taking the bare bone details of somebody’s life that are available through the archives and creating a credible and engrossing story.
Nancy Rudolph lived in Virginia in the 18th century, growing up on a plantation and involved in her youth in a major scandal surrounding the possible birth and death of a baby to her brother-in-law. The family, closely connected to the Jeffersons, are important enough in society for this to have consequences for her and those around her for the rest of their lives. Of course, the exact details of what happened are impossible to know but Kate Braithwaite has obviously looked closely at the stories that were around at the time, at the court case, at the ensuing lives of those involved and pieced together an excellent version of what may have been.
The sense of time and place is perfectly done, and there’s a real sense of the stifling lives they lead, judged constantly by those around them and how fragile everything is (of course their position is in no way analogous to the slaves on the plantation but this story centres more on the family in the house rather than the politics of the time). The story focuses mostly on the women, particularly Nancy and her sister Judy, and their lack of control over their own lives. Both are sympathetic but have their own flaws and are very believable as people. It’s so frustrating to see what happens to them and how little they can do about it, yet they are both also products of their time and accept it as just what happens. The central mystery over the birth is handled beautifully and I read the book in one sitting as I was so eager to find out what was going to happen to everyone.
I will definitely read more of Kate Braithwaite’s work – I loved her style of writing and, as historical fiction, it was especially good to see how detailed her research into the story and era was.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an advance copy in return for an honest review.
Nancy Rudolph lived in Virginia in the 18th century, growing up on a plantation and involved in her youth in a major scandal surrounding the possible birth and death of a baby to her brother-in-law. The family, closely connected to the Jeffersons, are important enough in society for this to have consequences for her and those around her for the rest of their lives. Of course, the exact details of what happened are impossible to know but Kate Braithwaite has obviously looked closely at the stories that were around at the time, at the court case, at the ensuing lives of those involved and pieced together an excellent version of what may have been.
The sense of time and place is perfectly done, and there’s a real sense of the stifling lives they lead, judged constantly by those around them and how fragile everything is (of course their position is in no way analogous to the slaves on the plantation but this story centres more on the family in the house rather than the politics of the time). The story focuses mostly on the women, particularly Nancy and her sister Judy, and their lack of control over their own lives. Both are sympathetic but have their own flaws and are very believable as people. It’s so frustrating to see what happens to them and how little they can do about it, yet they are both also products of their time and accept it as just what happens. The central mystery over the birth is handled beautifully and I read the book in one sitting as I was so eager to find out what was going to happen to everyone.
I will definitely read more of Kate Braithwaite’s work – I loved her style of writing and, as historical fiction, it was especially good to see how detailed her research into the story and era was.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an advance copy in return for an honest review.
April 16, 2024
The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph by Kate Braithwaite is a historical novel centering around the Randolph family and their dramatic life. Nancy is a girl who goes to live with her sister, Judy, and Judy’s new husband, Dick Randolph. She gets wrapped up in a lots of drama, really with no fault to her own.
There really is no other way to describe the plot of the book without spoiling everything. I would call this a slow to medium paced book. It has a good writing style and the plot pulled me in. It is definitely unique in plot and characters. It is also fully of historical drama and gossip. I do like the actual historical background of the novel and the little chapter that the author places at the end describing it.
Nancy Randolph is the protagonist. I do struggle a bit with her because she doesn’t really take control of her one life at all. She kind of just floats along and takes all the things that come to her. When something bad happens halfways through the book that ruins her reputation, she just decides she will never be able to get married and have children and she accepts that. I also feel like I don’t know much about her as a person. The story revolves around what other people think of her. We also get the POV of Nancy’s slave, Phebe, who is a very interesting character. I wish we got to know more about her. The POVs are few and far between and short. There are a variety of background characters that are well characterized.
Overall, I would give this book 3/5 stars. The plot of unique and did pull me in, but I didn’t really like the protagonist and her reactions to things that happened in her life. All the other characters were more interesting. I would have loved to have a bit more of Phebe’s perspective.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
There really is no other way to describe the plot of the book without spoiling everything. I would call this a slow to medium paced book. It has a good writing style and the plot pulled me in. It is definitely unique in plot and characters. It is also fully of historical drama and gossip. I do like the actual historical background of the novel and the little chapter that the author places at the end describing it.
Nancy Randolph is the protagonist. I do struggle a bit with her because she doesn’t really take control of her one life at all. She kind of just floats along and takes all the things that come to her. When something bad happens halfways through the book that ruins her reputation, she just decides she will never be able to get married and have children and she accepts that. I also feel like I don’t know much about her as a person. The story revolves around what other people think of her. We also get the POV of Nancy’s slave, Phebe, who is a very interesting character. I wish we got to know more about her. The POVs are few and far between and short. There are a variety of background characters that are well characterized.
Overall, I would give this book 3/5 stars. The plot of unique and did pull me in, but I didn’t really like the protagonist and her reactions to things that happened in her life. All the other characters were more interesting. I would have loved to have a bit more of Phebe’s perspective.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
December 30, 2024
This is a good retelling of the life of Nancy Randolph. It talks about how one family can affect the outcome of your life and one man. Nancy Randolph has circumstances beyond her control After the death of her mother at 15, her father remarries and sends her off to live with her sister and her new husband, William (Dick) Randolph who is a playboy and is unhappy in his marriage and gets both girls pregnant. The whole family is judmental and termpermantal. There is jealosy and scandal. The trial of Dick Randolph of killing a baby and hiding it at Gentivar. The expectation that girl should be married and temptation are huge part of this family. The Randolph family is a cursed family with status but not a lot of money. In the 18th century, there is drinking and sex and early deaths. All of those play a role in this family. Nancy does get pregant out of wedlock and is ruined, she is always being pressured to get married but ends up with a jealous sister and vindictive brother in law. Dick Randolph is acquitted but the scandal never goes far away. There are rumors and there is a trial that and honor is very precious. The trial is of Dick Randolph with lawyers, Patrick Henry and John Marshall, family members. Dick dies a few years after this but Nancy is stuck with Judy her sister and Jack Randolph. She is treated badly for at least 20 years afterwards and ends up in New England. She is shunned by all family members and regarded as wicked and a witch. She ends up with kind people but her reputation is stained. The Randolph family curse. This is well written and the dialouge is good. The story is at the end. It is on kindle unlimited.
Read
April 19, 20243.5/5, rounding up ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thank you to NetGalley for the advanced reader copy of this novel!
The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph by Kate Braithwaite is a fictional retelling of the first great scandal in early America. Seventeen year old Nancy Rudolph, living on a plantation in 18th century Virginia, seeks refuge from her new stepmother with her closest sister, Judy, and brother-in-law, Richard (Dick) Randolph. Shortly thereafter, rumors begin to circulate that Nancy, unwed, has given birth to a baby said to be fathered by none other than her brother-in-law Dick. Was the baby stillborn or murdered? Was a baby even born at all? Is Nancy a victim? A Temptress? A murderer? Braithwaite explores this scandal and the consequences it has on the Randolph family. This book alternates between Nancy’s & Judy’s perspectives.
This book is very well written. Braithwaite’s writing paints this true story in beautiful and descriptive color. I enjoyed how obviously well researched this book is, and how closely Braithwaite kept to the real story. I really liked her addition of Phebe, Nancy’s enslaved maid. Phebe’s omniscient perspective added color to the sister’s stories.
This book features a lot of characters, many of which are different families but share the same last name. While there is a character guide, I often wished some characters were better introduced within the text. I also found this to be a slow paced book. I’m usually a quick reader but it took me a few days to finish.
Overall I found reading this book to be pleasant.
Thank you to NetGalley for the advanced reader copy of this novel!
The Scandalous Life of Nancy Randolph by Kate Braithwaite is a fictional retelling of the first great scandal in early America. Seventeen year old Nancy Rudolph, living on a plantation in 18th century Virginia, seeks refuge from her new stepmother with her closest sister, Judy, and brother-in-law, Richard (Dick) Randolph. Shortly thereafter, rumors begin to circulate that Nancy, unwed, has given birth to a baby said to be fathered by none other than her brother-in-law Dick. Was the baby stillborn or murdered? Was a baby even born at all? Is Nancy a victim? A Temptress? A murderer? Braithwaite explores this scandal and the consequences it has on the Randolph family. This book alternates between Nancy’s & Judy’s perspectives.
This book is very well written. Braithwaite’s writing paints this true story in beautiful and descriptive color. I enjoyed how obviously well researched this book is, and how closely Braithwaite kept to the real story. I really liked her addition of Phebe, Nancy’s enslaved maid. Phebe’s omniscient perspective added color to the sister’s stories.
This book features a lot of characters, many of which are different families but share the same last name. While there is a character guide, I often wished some characters were better introduced within the text. I also found this to be a slow paced book. I’m usually a quick reader but it took me a few days to finish.
Overall I found reading this book to be pleasant.
May 5, 2024
An intriguing story that is hampered by a confusing multitude of characters with the same or similar name, time jumps that and major events not always placed clearly in the timeline, and slow pacing. From the synopsis, I was anticipating a true crime-ish story – but all that sensational events are complete within the first half of the book. The remainder of the book is effects and aftermath. This makes for interesting reading, but it was not what I anticipated and hoped it would be. Still, this is solid historical fiction, told in an easily-accessible manner, detailing a piece of American history I knew nothing about – but of which I would like to learn more.
By telling this story through the eyes of Nancy and her sister Judy, the author does a great job of illustrating early American society – in particular highlighting the role of women and their lack of agency and complete dependency on family (particularly the men). It weaves together their lives and experiences inside the strict social norms and realities of the time. And is further enriched by the inclusion of the voice and perspective of Phebe, Nancy’s slave (an admittedly fictionalized account added to an otherwise well-researched telling of actual events). All together, a good read.
This book is now available, but I read a copy thanks to NetGalley and Joffe Books.
By telling this story through the eyes of Nancy and her sister Judy, the author does a great job of illustrating early American society – in particular highlighting the role of women and their lack of agency and complete dependency on family (particularly the men). It weaves together their lives and experiences inside the strict social norms and realities of the time. And is further enriched by the inclusion of the voice and perspective of Phebe, Nancy’s slave (an admittedly fictionalized account added to an otherwise well-researched telling of actual events). All together, a good read.
This book is now available, but I read a copy thanks to NetGalley and Joffe Books.
August 12, 2025
I listened to this book and don't necessarily recommend that. I would have done much better with a hard cover book. There were many characters, locations, and details that I found difficult to keep track of, and I would have appreciated the ability to flip back and forth to review. I understand the book has a list of characters at the beginning, which would have been very helpful.
Having said that, I found myself getting drawn into the story. The main characters were young, and marriages were prescribed by custom, so it's not surprising there would be infidelity such as the ones suggested here. The scandal was started by gossip...a woman gave birth to a child fathered by her step brother, but there was no real evidence. Was the baby born dead? killed? given away? What happened to the child and who actually was the father? The courts acquitted all, but the stories lingered.
The story certainly shows the short comings of the time, especially the poor treatment of women. It's is interesting to consider that our forefathers and mothers were subject to the same foibles of human nature that are exhibited today.
Having said that, I found myself getting drawn into the story. The main characters were young, and marriages were prescribed by custom, so it's not surprising there would be infidelity such as the ones suggested here. The scandal was started by gossip...a woman gave birth to a child fathered by her step brother, but there was no real evidence. Was the baby born dead? killed? given away? What happened to the child and who actually was the father? The courts acquitted all, but the stories lingered.
The story certainly shows the short comings of the time, especially the poor treatment of women. It's is interesting to consider that our forefathers and mothers were subject to the same foibles of human nature that are exhibited today.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 72 reviews