4.5 stars ~ [8.90/10]
Never in my wildest dreams did I ever see a time where a big chunk of the original cast would reprise their roles for a new Buffyverse story (especially Emma Caulfield!) Not just because it is difficult to reprise certain roles where characters do not age but also because of the rocky path this property has navigated in recent years. This show was never just about the creator (and his subsequent fall from grace) but the general perception was often that he was the mastermind behind everything that made it good. Yet, any hardcore fan will tell you that this show (and the spin-off) never would've achieved the things it achieved without the full ensemble, including: cast, crew and a stacked writer's room. So it really warms my heart to see Christopher Golden and Amber Benson pick up the mantle. Golden because he wrote some of my favourite BtVS novelisations back in the day and Benson because she's always been listening and acknowledging the voices of fans.
And, this is definitely one for the fans. The universe has matured along with its core audience, whilst still keeping it fresh and maintaining the DNA. There are so many easter eggs for fans to pick up on, even down to the way that inflections are used on certain phrases. Juliet Landau really excels at this and it's clear she knows deep in her bones what her most iconic lines are from the show, Drusilla is the role she was born to play. The show was always the most exciting to me when we had female antagonists so it was super exciting to see that Drusilla was the main villain.
However, I think it's greatest success is the focus on giving "justice" to female characters that were a little hard done by when it came to early 2000s media literacy: Cordelia, Tara and Anya. AU Cordy is wonderful, she embodies what it means to be a slayer so well because there were never that many degrees of separation between her personality and Buffy's personality. AtS proved that Cordy was a champion and Charisma Carpenter was able to bring in those aspects of how her character evolved whilst also making it really easy to believe that, in another life, Cordelia could have been the chosen one. (It's extra meta when you think about how CC and SMG were both going up for the role of Buffy during auditions.) Cordelia's send-off in AtS has to be one of the most frustrating things that these shows ever did and now that we know the BTS context of why that happened it sticks in the teeth even more, so it was absolutely wonderful to see a reimagining of a beloved character given the respect that she deserves. Tara got a chance to be a character outside of her relationship with Willow, she was given an edge and a struggle that was purely her own to overcome. In season 6 of BtVS the writers attempted to develop Tara's friendship with Buffy, but most of the time, when her storyline did not revolve around Willow, she was off-screen... until Seeing Red went the way that it did. Tara's role in this production also allows for a better understanding as why she is not featured on the cover art, she's supposed to be a reveal. Anya was and is a fan favourite and although she made it to the finale, rumour has it that Emma wasn't planning to return if the show got an 8th season because they weren't really giving her much to do. Season 7 struggled in a lot of ways, but the potential slayers storyline meant that it was veering away from what made the show excellent... the core cast. We were lucky to get more than one line from Anya in a regular episode, so I wouldn't have blamed her if she was done. In Slayers we get both Anya and Anyanka and it's a treat to listen to Emma deliver these characters as if she'd never stopped embodying them. One of the missteps that the show made with her character was not realising how interesting a 1000 year old ex-demon was and how that gave them so much fruitful ground to mine. I get that it was Buffy's story though so I'm pleased that this new incarnation of the universe allows a lot of breathing room to explore side characters on a deeper level.
Spike is a draw for a lot of us as well. James Marsters will always be associated with this character because he was a little bit method about how he approached it. And since both BtVS and AtS ended he's one of the stars who has really helped to keep the fandom alive - he embraced it instead of trying to distance himself from it. Spike has always been an interesting character because of the way he existed in the grey, how he became a foil for both Buffy and Angel and how he was never meant to exist in this universe in the way that he ended up existing. His character is an embodiment of how JW was never the mastermind because Spike, arguably the most popular Buffyverse character, existed in spite of the creator. Kinda poetic. In Slayers he still gets to live in that grey area even though he's the one leading us through the story. It was really impressive to see how Golden and Benson managed to accomplish this, without ever compromising the things that fans loved about him.
Hearing Anthony Head reprise his role as Rupert Giles was probably the most comforting aspect of this whole story he is the voice of reason, often the only adult in the room and a substitute father figure for the characters and many of the fans (including me.) I'm currently reading through the comics and at a bit of a shaky spot in terms of the Giles storyline (IYKYK), but I was so happy to hear him living his life with Olivia in London where they owned Fairweather Bookshop; it's absolutely the life I imagined for him. He'll always be our "stalwart standing-fast" and because of that he feels like a balancing presence in this new(ish) crew of world-savers. However, there was a moment at the very end that makes me so hopeful for a sequel so that we can see a different side of Giles.
Indira was a really welcome new addition to this world and kind of genius on the part of the writers because her youthfulness really provided the nostalgic energy of seasons 1-3. I really loved that she'd only just come into her Slayer powers but was also quite clued up on everything because she had been born into a world where Slayers were the norm - it also meant that they didn't have to waste valuable time in info-dumping for her. She kind of ended up being a mirror for the fans because she was such a fan of everyone else, and because of that it was really easy to feel a kinship with her straight away.
I really loved the new character of Miranda too. I kept trying to place her voice and it wasn't until the end credits that I realised she had been voiced by Juno Dawson (yes, that Juno Dawson!) I loved Danny Strong's cameo as ghost Jonathan and it did make me wish we could've gotten an Andrew/Tom Lenk cameo too because we all know he absolutely would've been up for it - perhaps we'll see him in a sequel!
I'm not the biggest fan of multiverse stories because when they're introduced into existing properties they often feel like an easy-out for writers who don't want to stick to canon, which can subsequently take me out of the story. However, multiverses and alternate universes have been an established part of the Buffyverse canon since season 3, episode 9 The Wish so it felt very in keeping with the worldbuilding that had already been established. It's still not my absolute favourite vehicle to tell a full story, but I do like they way that they interweaved "our" characters with the AU characters. The ending made it seem like we might by sticking around in this alternate universe for a while though so I have a little bit of trepidation about what that means for the storylines that played out in the series, if they do decide to make a sequel.
I could go on and on about this and even though this has turned into a much longer review than I intended, it still feels like I've barely scratched the surface. If you're a fan of the Buffyverse, you're in for a treat!