What do you think?
Rate this book
War of the Underhill #1
Heartsong
San Francisco, Present day
A gargoyle warrior unprepared for the modern world…
Fifteen hundred years ago, Frey and all his kind were cursed by the vicious fae queen, their magick stolen and their bodies rendered stone. It has been a hellish existence, frozen in time as the world changes around them. A proud warrior ready for a mate, Frey rages against his stone prison, but with every year that passes, hope slips away that the curse will ever be broken.
That is, until he and some of his kin are placed in an odd little museum. And she walks through the door.
A modern woman not ready for a medieval male…
Anna Kincaid has just gotten back on her feet. After struggling with student debt, chronic migraines, a serial-dater mother, and Bay Area rent for years, she’s finally landed a job that will help with all of it. It feels too good to be true—full health care with dental and helping manage a museum full of exquisite artifacts? Her heart and history degree are thrilled, but something about the museum is…odd. The owners are a mysterious, if kind couple who call the collection the clan. And the collection is…well, monstrous. Huge, savage-looking statues from the late Celtic period.
Magick stolen can be reclaimed, and curses cast can be broken…
When the museum is stormed by masked commandos one night, it isn’t even the weirdest thing to happen. No, she could wrap her head around organized art theft—what defies belief is one of the big gray behemoths springing to life to save her. And that he flies off with her. And when he tucks her into his big body and growls mate. Fans of Lisette Marshall, SL Prater, and the Gargoyles Disney show will love this monster romance novel. Title includes several heavier themes as well as open-door spice.
A gargoyle warrior unprepared for the modern world…
Fifteen hundred years ago, Frey and all his kind were cursed by the vicious fae queen, their magick stolen and their bodies rendered stone. It has been a hellish existence, frozen in time as the world changes around them. A proud warrior ready for a mate, Frey rages against his stone prison, but with every year that passes, hope slips away that the curse will ever be broken.
That is, until he and some of his kin are placed in an odd little museum. And she walks through the door.
A modern woman not ready for a medieval male…
Anna Kincaid has just gotten back on her feet. After struggling with student debt, chronic migraines, a serial-dater mother, and Bay Area rent for years, she’s finally landed a job that will help with all of it. It feels too good to be true—full health care with dental and helping manage a museum full of exquisite artifacts? Her heart and history degree are thrilled, but something about the museum is…odd. The owners are a mysterious, if kind couple who call the collection the clan. And the collection is…well, monstrous. Huge, savage-looking statues from the late Celtic period.
Magick stolen can be reclaimed, and curses cast can be broken…
When the museum is stormed by masked commandos one night, it isn’t even the weirdest thing to happen. No, she could wrap her head around organized art theft—what defies belief is one of the big gray behemoths springing to life to save her. And that he flies off with her. And when he tucks her into his big body and growls mate. Fans of Lisette Marshall, SL Prater, and the Gargoyles Disney show will love this monster romance novel. Title includes several heavier themes as well as open-door spice.
392 pages, Paperback
First published March 29, 2024
305 people are currently reading
7208 people want to read
About the author
S.E. Wendel
22 books807 followersS.E. Wendel is a graduate of the MA Creative Writing program at the University of California, Davis. She loves maps, magic, and making epic fantasy worlds with romance thrown in. She has been writing fantasies since before she could even type (thankfully her mother was kind and patient enough to take dictation, but is relieved she can type for herself now)! From her first stories about raccoons hunting treasure on a haunted island to her latest sweeping epics, she loves to write strong heroines and noble heroes.
S.E. is a technical editor by day and in the evening loves to lose herself in her fantasy worlds and the stories of other amazing authors. She is currently working on the second part of the Broken Wings Duet. She loves her domineering orange tabby cat, true crime docs, tiramisu, pink nail polish, and swoony romantasies!
S.E. is a technical editor by day and in the evening loves to lose herself in her fantasy worlds and the stories of other amazing authors. She is currently working on the second part of the Broken Wings Duet. She loves her domineering orange tabby cat, true crime docs, tiramisu, pink nail polish, and swoony romantasies!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 461 reviews
March 21, 2024
ARC review - received copy from author for honest review.
This was my first book by this author and I really enjoyed it! Anna was grumpy, isolated, and jaded. Frey was also grumpy, isolated, and jaded, but more open to love and the mate bond. The growly back and forth between them was awesome and I’m somewhat obsessed with Frey’s purring. I appreciated the chronic illness rep as well. As someone who has migraines, it’s nice to see a MC who has a lot of the same struggles I do.
The world building was well done, with interesting lore. The side characters all had motivations and their own backstories that made them engaging as well. I wanted to drop kick Anna’s mom and Titania.
Most of the book had cozy vibes, although there were some high stakes moments.
Spice: 4/5
Triggers: kidnapping, violence, mild gore, mentions of poverty, stalking (not by MC), grief
This was my first book by this author and I really enjoyed it! Anna was grumpy, isolated, and jaded. Frey was also grumpy, isolated, and jaded, but more open to love and the mate bond. The growly back and forth between them was awesome and I’m somewhat obsessed with Frey’s purring. I appreciated the chronic illness rep as well. As someone who has migraines, it’s nice to see a MC who has a lot of the same struggles I do.
The world building was well done, with interesting lore. The side characters all had motivations and their own backstories that made them engaging as well. I wanted to drop kick Anna’s mom and Titania.
Most of the book had cozy vibes, although there were some high stakes moments.
Spice: 4/5
Triggers: kidnapping, violence, mild gore, mentions of poverty, stalking (not by MC), grief
April 9, 2024
I am GAGGED at how AMAZING this book truly is!
Heartsong had me in the feels, seriously 😭 Anna was definitely difficult at first when it came to Frey. Seeing her warm up to him and eventually opening up was 🤌🤌 So so good. Getting scenes with Carys and Gavren was such a treat. Them still being absolutely in love with each other made me giddy kekfiekekdnd.
Heartsong had me in the feels, seriously 😭 Anna was definitely difficult at first when it came to Frey. Seeing her warm up to him and eventually opening up was 🤌🤌 So so good. Getting scenes with Carys and Gavren was such a treat. Them still being absolutely in love with each other made me giddy kekfiekekdnd.
March 24, 2024
"I care for you, my Anna. I should like to love you, too."
Ok before I start the rest of my review I'm going to mention one thing that I feel will convince you to read this. TIGHT GRAY SWEATPANTS. SWOONY GARGOYLE IN TIGHT GRAY SWEATPANTS.
Now that I've got your attention...😆 I loved this book. In the words of Frey, it was most excellent. SE had me guessing the whole time to who was causing all the trouble for the museum and Anna and being able to see Carys and Gavren again was great. They're so adorable and totally BA!
One part I did wish had been written differently was when they had begun a physical relationship and Anna mentioned she wanted Frey to use condoms because she wanted to be extra sure (on top of her birth control) that she didn't get pregnant. He immediately tried to talk her out it and gave the excuse that they were both clean and that he would "be extra careful" because he wanted to feel her while doing it. That did give me a bit of icky feelings and it felt sort of out of character for how caring and accepting Frey had been in the rest of the book.
Frey was the perfect surly and moody MMC. I loved his flirty banter! He had me cracking up reading about him preening and striking a pose for her to show off his strength and big wings. And Anna was so strong and independent. I was very happy when she didn't immediately accept the mate bond business and was very upfront with Frey that it made her uncomfortable. Knowing the trauma she experienced in her childhood really helped with understanding her reservations and feelings about moving into a romantic relationship with Frey. I immediately related to her when I read "Her truest form came with stretchy lounge pants and a cozy fleece hoodie with deep pockets." Same girl. Same.
Can't forget to mention the star of the book, Captain. Protect that fur baby at all costs!
Loved the epilogue! It has me so excited to read the next book. 👀 And that last spice scene?? SO HOT!!!
Ok before I start the rest of my review I'm going to mention one thing that I feel will convince you to read this. TIGHT GRAY SWEATPANTS. SWOONY GARGOYLE IN TIGHT GRAY SWEATPANTS.
Now that I've got your attention...😆 I loved this book. In the words of Frey, it was most excellent. SE had me guessing the whole time to who was causing all the trouble for the museum and Anna and being able to see Carys and Gavren again was great. They're so adorable and totally BA!
One part I did wish had been written differently was when they had begun a physical relationship and Anna mentioned she wanted Frey to use condoms because she wanted to be extra sure (on top of her birth control) that she didn't get pregnant. He immediately tried to talk her out it and gave the excuse that they were both clean and that he would "be extra careful" because he wanted to feel her while doing it. That did give me a bit of icky feelings and it felt sort of out of character for how caring and accepting Frey had been in the rest of the book.
Frey was the perfect surly and moody MMC. I loved his flirty banter! He had me cracking up reading about him preening and striking a pose for her to show off his strength and big wings. And Anna was so strong and independent. I was very happy when she didn't immediately accept the mate bond business and was very upfront with Frey that it made her uncomfortable. Knowing the trauma she experienced in her childhood really helped with understanding her reservations and feelings about moving into a romantic relationship with Frey. I immediately related to her when I read "Her truest form came with stretchy lounge pants and a cozy fleece hoodie with deep pockets." Same girl. Same.
Can't forget to mention the star of the book, Captain. Protect that fur baby at all costs!
Loved the epilogue! It has me so excited to read the next book. 👀 And that last spice scene?? SO HOT!!!
November 2, 2025
3.5 rounded up. I absolutely loved the Goliath /Elise vibes and this scratched an itch Gargoyles gave me. At times it felt repetitive but overall a really enjoyable gargoyle read. Loved the migraine rep and the mystery backstory. Thanks to Netgalley, the author and the publisher for this advanced copy 💜
May 1, 2024
This was rough.
On the one hand, there's so much to like:
- Heroine has chronic migraines and . Not at all surprised that the author mentions battling migraines, herself. You 100% see the self-insert, but I think it's forgivable in light of how few FMCs I've seen balancing plot and a chronic condition.
- There's proof of research. I wouldn't say it's heavy research, but the author clearly did some advanced Googling on Welsh history and Irish folklore. I saw a few snatches of specificity when I think a lesser novel would have chosen to gloss over any allusions and stick to generalities.
- The FMC and MMC have time together. I know it's not everyone's jam, but I appreciate it when I can find a novel that doesn't toss its protagonists into a Plot Tornado and leave me dizzy. A lot of this book is just vibes, and that's unique in a way that suits my interests.
- Fun paranormal romance plot. Woman awakens gargoyle; gargoyle gets to navigate life in a modern world when he's been "asleep" for a 1,000 years.
- I liked that the FMC was a bit skeptical of the bond and had to be won over. She's won over on a timeline that felt realistic.
- Author's a good writer. Everything flows. There's switch-up in syntax. She balances inner/outer worlds really well. Is it a literary masterpiece? No. But it's not claiming to be.
On the other hand:
- This is my second Wendel novel and I'm sniffing a trend where the MMC is just bonkers obsessed with his "mate." It's arguably manageable until she's on board, and then it's just mate, mate, mate, mate, I'm so in love with you, you can do no wrong, let me kiss your kneecaps, my mate. And I said it in my last review for Halfing (also by this author): I aDORE the fated soulmates trope, but I don't like it when it's laid on too thick. You can write about two people willing to rip the world apart to save each other—you can write about navigating the idea of a destined partner (do I have to love this person, and if I do, what does that say about consent and free will?)—without veering into a place that reeks of cheese. Some possessiveness/obsession? Hot. Too much possessiveness/obsession? Free me from this sugar-walled prison. Of course, YMMV.
- So, I do enjoy Just Vibes, and I liked that the couple spent so much time together...but they spent so much time together doing the same. exact. things. in the same. exact. place. Anna goes to work and Frey frets for her safety and wants her to quit; Anna returns to Frey cooking dinner; Anna and Frey either A) bond or B) argue; Anna is carried to bed; Frey turns to stone at daybreak. I'm all for domesticity (and fat chunks of it), but there was too much sameness. It was the same repeated problems.
- The characterization was aggravating. I was sympathetic to Anna's fears regarding Frey's claim. It's cool to explore the "but if you're obligated to be with me, isn't it damning if I manage to push you away?" avenue. But there wasn't a whole lot of rumination (at least at first) for any of his comfort, which...I feel like any decent person would care about? Even if he was just a friend? He's trapped in a one-bedroom apartment in a land he's never been to in a time he doesn't understand without a single contact and not once (to my memory) does Anna think, "How can I smuggle you to a park?" I didn't believe the "...and we bonded over ___" moments because...who wouldn't feel aggravated after being treated like a on-site maid? But Frey soaks it up because it's Anna and Anna is his life. There's some backstory to help you understand how Anna became Anna, but those details ended up feeling too shallow to matter. They're brought up a few times and then never again.
- So, to sum up: Frey wasn't meant to be a doormat (I think the author described him as hardheaded, which he is in terms of thinking about soulmates), but he felt like a doormat. Anna wasn't unlikable, but also wasn't easy to love. She wasn't the kind of obnoxious FMC that makes your hackles immediately rise (despite everything, she IS a good person; that's clear), but she never won me over.
--
This author's still on my radar. She has the potential to be a gem in the PNR genre; I'm just looking for something slightly different than this.
On the one hand, there's so much to like:
- Heroine has chronic migraines and . Not at all surprised that the author mentions battling migraines, herself. You 100% see the self-insert, but I think it's forgivable in light of how few FMCs I've seen balancing plot and a chronic condition.
- There's proof of research. I wouldn't say it's heavy research, but the author clearly did some advanced Googling on Welsh history and Irish folklore. I saw a few snatches of specificity when I think a lesser novel would have chosen to gloss over any allusions and stick to generalities.
- The FMC and MMC have time together. I know it's not everyone's jam, but I appreciate it when I can find a novel that doesn't toss its protagonists into a Plot Tornado and leave me dizzy. A lot of this book is just vibes, and that's unique in a way that suits my interests.
- Fun paranormal romance plot. Woman awakens gargoyle; gargoyle gets to navigate life in a modern world when he's been "asleep" for a 1,000 years.
- I liked that the FMC was a bit skeptical of the bond and had to be won over. She's won over on a timeline that felt realistic.
- Author's a good writer. Everything flows. There's switch-up in syntax. She balances inner/outer worlds really well. Is it a literary masterpiece? No. But it's not claiming to be.
On the other hand:
- This is my second Wendel novel and I'm sniffing a trend where the MMC is just bonkers obsessed with his "mate." It's arguably manageable until she's on board, and then it's just mate, mate, mate, mate, I'm so in love with you, you can do no wrong, let me kiss your kneecaps, my mate. And I said it in my last review for Halfing (also by this author): I aDORE the fated soulmates trope, but I don't like it when it's laid on too thick. You can write about two people willing to rip the world apart to save each other—you can write about navigating the idea of a destined partner (do I have to love this person, and if I do, what does that say about consent and free will?)—without veering into a place that reeks of cheese. Some possessiveness/obsession? Hot. Too much possessiveness/obsession? Free me from this sugar-walled prison. Of course, YMMV.
- So, I do enjoy Just Vibes, and I liked that the couple spent so much time together...but they spent so much time together doing the same. exact. things. in the same. exact. place. Anna goes to work and Frey frets for her safety and wants her to quit; Anna returns to Frey cooking dinner; Anna and Frey either A) bond or B) argue; Anna is carried to bed; Frey turns to stone at daybreak. I'm all for domesticity (and fat chunks of it), but there was too much sameness. It was the same repeated problems.
- The characterization was aggravating. I was sympathetic to Anna's fears regarding Frey's claim. It's cool to explore the "but if you're obligated to be with me, isn't it damning if I manage to push you away?" avenue. But there wasn't a whole lot of rumination (at least at first) for any of his comfort, which...I feel like any decent person would care about? Even if he was just a friend? He's trapped in a one-bedroom apartment in a land he's never been to in a time he doesn't understand without a single contact and not once (to my memory) does Anna think, "How can I smuggle you to a park?" I didn't believe the "...and we bonded over ___" moments because...who wouldn't feel aggravated after being treated like a on-site maid? But Frey soaks it up because it's Anna and Anna is his life. There's some backstory to help you understand how Anna became Anna, but those details ended up feeling too shallow to matter. They're brought up a few times and then never again.
- So, to sum up: Frey wasn't meant to be a doormat (I think the author described him as hardheaded, which he is in terms of thinking about soulmates), but he felt like a doormat. Anna wasn't unlikable, but also wasn't easy to love. She wasn't the kind of obnoxious FMC that makes your hackles immediately rise (despite everything, she IS a good person; that's clear), but she never won me over.
--
This author's still on my radar. She has the potential to be a gem in the PNR genre; I'm just looking for something slightly different than this.
March 23, 2024
He'd rolled up the sleeves of the flannel and it wasn't okay.
He also never bothered to button it, so it was just all rippling muscles on display all night, which also wasn't okay.
For her state of mind.
For her sanity.
For her libido. And therefore state of mind.
Statues aren't sexy. Sure, they could be beautiful, moving, arresting. You had to be dead inside not to be moved by Michelangelo's David or Pietà. But you weren't supposed to feel things for statuary.
Just call me Pygmalion. Great, now she was thinking about his rippling chest and making art history jokes to herself. This was bad.
(4-4.5⭐️)
Sometimes, a girl just needs a cozy, yet angsty romance about a wounded, independent-to-a-fault heroine and the hulking cinnamon roll gargoyle that saves her from danger and then announces that she is his mate. And oh boy, does S.E. Wendel deliver on the coziness and the angst. Heartsong was a delightful slow-burn of a read, made even better by the fact that there's some intense action early on, and then we're just left to simmer in our anxiety as things gradually make their way up to a full boil at the climax.
I really enjoyed Anna and Frey as characters (and as a couple) - Frey was the ultimate protective-yet-sweet MMC, but Anna was the one that got the deepest under my skin. This woman has been through a lot - from a tumultuous upbringing and emotionally abusive, neglectful, and narcissistic mother, to an adulthood practically defined by the phrase "barely managing to scrape by." Our girl is hurting (quite literally, too, with the chronic migraines), but it's that deep, aching loneliness she ends up having to face head on that damn near broke my heart.
In Anna's experience, men rarely lived up to the hype. Not that there was anything normal about Frey. He wasn't even really a man, a human man at least. Nothing about him or the situation was normal. They couldn't really date. They couldn't even go out during the day. Still, whatever could happen would be serious.
And Anna... was terrified of that.
It scared her how easily a monstrous man from the sixth century had eased into her life. Sure, there had been growing pains those first days, and yea there were moments she wanted to just be by herself in her own apartment. But those moments were far outweighed and outnumbered by the joy growing like a weed inside her each time she came home to him. To his smiles and flirting and curiosity. Even if it was just dinner and some TV before bed, her evenings felt full.
Sometimes the depths of loneliness weren't apparent until the burden had been eased a little.
She had Captain. She had things she enjoyed doing. But Frey drove out the worst of her loneliness. He had her looking forward to things again.
Did that all mean she could accept being someone's soulmate? Choosing to give his promises a chance and see what came of them?
She wasn't sure.
Because what if he regrets it? What if, after he's stuck with me as a mate, he gets buyer's remorse?
That she couldn't accept, and so all the rest went with it.
I think what I appreciated most about this book was how realistic Anna was as a character/heroine. Her reactions to the things happening around her were always believable and very much in character. She's carrying around a lifetime of emotional baggage and trauma, so of course she's not just going to drop that at Frey's feet the minute he shows up. It does happen, but it happens by degrees.
Frey is very much the same with his understandable "fish out of water" situation as he struggles to acclimate to a totally new world and time, but also to the insecurities of having a mate who isn't just throwing herself into his arms without question. Their relationship was very organic, and I found that refreshing.
It was in living the day-to-day (or rather, night-to-night) with one another that trust, affection, and love truly had a chance to bloom between them. And it was never just a one and done deal - which was something I also appreciated. These two have some very believable hiccups in their relationship, but when they're good together, they are good.
And I'm not just talking about the sexual chemistry. The emotional connection, especially at one point where Anna is literally at the end of her rope... it was so poignant and moving, it made me cry.
"Let me help you, Anna. Please."
The tiredness and pain pulled at her face, and he could see that right now, she had nothing left. She was at her wit's end - but she had him. a mate who would take care of her.
For that's what his Anna needed. Care. Tenderness. She wasn't a battle to win, nor a fortress to breach. He shouldn't be sharpening his blade against her hard exterior, nor trying to crack it with his brute strength. She wasn't a challenge nor a prize. Anna was a woman, one with a sharp tongue and stubborn mind and a large heart. And she was his mate.
Mates deserved care and compassion. It was their due. In his haste and desperation to finally form and solidify their bond, he'd forgotten this important tenet.
Her voice wobbled again when she finally agreed. "O-Okay."
... Being Anna's mate was to be Anna's partner. Her support. Not just her sword but her shield, her sustenance, her home. She didn't just need the strength of his arm and wing but his heart and his compassion. She would test him. try him. and likely vex him again and again - but always would she be worth it.
The climax and reveal at the end brought on one twist I didn't see coming, but the rest had had the hints and foundations already laid out, so it was easy to guess where we were going. Regardless, though, I'm still very curious to see how things proceed from here - with our big bad and his "prisoner", but also June... the woman intrigues me. And I do love a good intrigue.
Seeing Carys and Gavriel again was a pleasure - especially during the climax. Carys in particular had me in stitches a few times - girl just can't be bothered. But I forgot how much I love and admire her tenderness and empathy. The reunion with Frey made my heart hurt.
All in all, a solid story. If you're in the mood for a cozy slow-burn, Heartsong just might scratch that itch!
TROPES:
- "Monster"/Human relations
- Ancient Curses
- Fated Mates
- Close Proximity
- Fish out of water
- Adorable fur-baby sidekick
- Low-ish stakes, but solid on the angst
- Guaranteed HEA with some setup for the next installments
God, she really did love him, so much it hurt. But then, growth usually came with some growing pains, and Frey had expanded her heart, her life. She'd had her reasons to avoid anything serious with him, but those reasons had long since gone silent. Did it mean she wasn't scared? Hell no. This was so big, and there was still the very real threat of [SPOILER] out there. Who knew what [SPOILER]'s plans were or when [they] might reappear. And now she'd been pulled into a world of magick and fae and gargoyles - definitely not for the faint of heart.
And Anna wasn't. She wasn't faint of heart.
Because Frey was her heart.
November 10, 2025
heartsong
⌗ nov. 6 - nov. 7
⤿ 3.5 stars [rounded up]
༉ initial thoughts- spoiler review
i’m going to be honest and say i didn’t expect the amount of plot in this book but i am in no way disappointed.
i found the story to be so captivating especially with the magic aspect of it. frey’s pov while he was still stone as well as when we was actually able to move was such a great move, it seemed like the reader was there stuck with him.
i was not expecting an art heist at the beginning but it added a substantial part of the story. the plot was so interesting but i was not a mega fan of the cliffhanger in the end. we got a bit of closure but the last chapter but the main storyline is left unresolved.
that being said i honestly would love to keep reading about this story and see its resolution.
༉ characters - spoilers ahead
📜 anna kincaid - i loved her background in history, i think it added a lot to her character and also connected her to frey. i got a bit frustrated with her and the van cause like it was mega suspicious and she was just like “oh it’s just the police” like girl… aside from that little part i had a lot of fun with her character.
🪨 frey - once again i really enjoyed getting his pov both from when he was a stone and when he was free of the curse. also the statues being able to hear and keep up with society in that way was such an intriguing part of their existence. he had a heartbreaking back story and i really want to see him succeed in his quest to free his clan.
༉ final thoughts- spoilers ahead
i’m looking forward to what the author will do to resolve the plot. both of these character were likable and the set up for the next book was pretty interesting and well done. the academic side of this story is something that i really enjoyed and hope to keep seeing that portrayed in these books.
༉‧₊˚. pre - read
do i read monster romances often? no, but alas here i am. the blurb was very interesting so im looking forward to this book !!
ⓘ thank you netgalley & avon and harper voyager for this arc in exchange for an honest review
⌗ nov. 6 - nov. 7
⤿ 3.5 stars [rounded up]
༉ initial thoughts- spoiler review
i’m going to be honest and say i didn’t expect the amount of plot in this book but i am in no way disappointed.
i found the story to be so captivating especially with the magic aspect of it. frey’s pov while he was still stone as well as when we was actually able to move was such a great move, it seemed like the reader was there stuck with him.
i was not expecting an art heist at the beginning but it added a substantial part of the story. the plot was so interesting but i was not a mega fan of the cliffhanger in the end. we got a bit of closure but the last chapter but the main storyline is left unresolved.
that being said i honestly would love to keep reading about this story and see its resolution.
༉ characters - spoilers ahead
📜 anna kincaid - i loved her background in history, i think it added a lot to her character and also connected her to frey. i got a bit frustrated with her and the van cause like it was mega suspicious and she was just like “oh it’s just the police” like girl… aside from that little part i had a lot of fun with her character.
🪨 frey - once again i really enjoyed getting his pov both from when he was a stone and when he was free of the curse. also the statues being able to hear and keep up with society in that way was such an intriguing part of their existence. he had a heartbreaking back story and i really want to see him succeed in his quest to free his clan.
༉ final thoughts- spoilers ahead
i’m looking forward to what the author will do to resolve the plot. both of these character were likable and the set up for the next book was pretty interesting and well done. the academic side of this story is something that i really enjoyed and hope to keep seeing that portrayed in these books.
༉‧₊˚. pre - read
do i read monster romances often? no, but alas here i am. the blurb was very interesting so im looking forward to this book !!
ⓘ thank you netgalley & avon and harper voyager for this arc in exchange for an honest review
March 25, 2024
— 4.5 stars
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
"I care for you, my Anna. I should like to love you, too."
📖 | 457 pages
👤 | author S.E. Wendel
🏢 | published independently
📅 | release date 29 March 2024
What you can expect:
— Adult Monster Romance
— Second Instalment In A Series
— First-Person POV
— Dual-POV
— Medieval Meets Modern
— Fated Mates
— He Falls First
— Chronic Pain Rep
— Grumpy X Grumpy
— Slow Burn Romance
— Forced Proximity
— Animal Companion
— Morally Grey Heroine X Moody Winged Hero
Trigger & Content Warnings include: sexually explicit content, chronic pain & migraines, kidnapping, stalking, minor blood and gore, violence.
Heartsong is the second instalment in the War of the Underhill series by author S.E. Wendel. Fifteen hundred years ago, Frey and all his kind were cursed by the vicious fae queen, their magick stolen and their bodies rendered stone. A proud warrior ready for a mate, Frey rages against his stone prison, but with every year that passes, hope slips away that the curse will ever be broken. That is, until he and some of his kin are placed in an odd little museum... and she walks through the door. Anna Kincaid has just gotten back on her feet. After struggling with student debt, chronic migraines, a serial-dater mother, and Bay Area rent for years, she’s finally landed a job that will help with all of it. It feels too good to be true—full health care with dental and helping manage a museum full of exquisite artifacts? Her heart and history degree are thrilled, but something about the museum is… odd. The owners are a mysterious, if kind couple who call the collection the clan. When the museum is stormed by masked commandos one night, it isn’t even the weirdest thing to happen. No, she could wrap her head around organized art theft—what defies belief is one of the big grey behemoths springing to life to save her as he flies off with her and tucks her into his big body as he growls "mate." Can a modern woman allow a medieval male to whisk her away and claim her well guarded heart? Or will sinister forces seek to drive them apart before they can ever begin?
This is my third read by author S.E. Wendel and I've come to truly adore and anticipate her style of writing. Wendel possesses a unique and compelling narrative voice that drives the storyline and leaves the reader enraptured and enthralled from beginning to end. There's very few authors that I have found leaves me with this true feeling of contentment and I'm thrilled to add another to the very short list. Heartsong is a love letter to those who fiercely guard their heart whilst yearning for love and companionship. That it's okay to lower your walls and welcome somebody else in. That it is not weakness to lean on other's during times of struggle and pain. With it's steady pacing, a mysterious on-going plot and a strong cast of characters, this is not a story to be missed for fans of the Monster Romance genre.
Anna Kincaid is my favourite kind of main character as she is somebody that I find myself truly resonating with and seeing pieces of myself in. With an unstable upbringing moving from one place to the next, as she witnessed her mother stuck in a vicious cycle of falling in love to ultimately get her heart broken... Anna guards her heart with an iron will and a determination to never let another claim in. All she has seen is the ultimate heartbreak that comes at the end of a short-lived love affair, so her doubt and apprehension is as understandable as it heart-breaking. I felt so bad for Anna during her emotional turmoil as she battled with her loneliness and chronic pain. After spending much of her life taking care of herself, Anna doesn't know how to let anybody in. Least of all a grumpy, overbearing gargoyle who is centuries years old and is making grand claims about his intentions towards her. Whilst I admit to sometimes feeling frustrated towards Anna and her actions, her mistrust in Frey is valid and I'm glad that she took the time to establish boundaries as she progressed at a pace that felt safe for herself. I ended the book feeling really proud of Anna's development, and I hope other readers will come to share my sentiment.
Frey is a grumpy and assertive gargoyle who we meet as he wants to claim his Mate on an instinctive and primal level. From the very beginning I loved how despite what his base nature was compelling him to do, Frey desperately wished to earn Anna's love and affection on his own. His overall patience and keenness to please Anna was honestly really sweet and endearing to witness in contrast to his otherwise surly personality. I loved watching as Frey came to life the more Anna seemed open to their connection. His flirty banter and boastful nature was hilarious as he is clearly a proud male who may not have much to offer in this new modern era, but he knows who he is and is willing that to be enough. Also I never anticipated enjoying a purring gargoyle that struts about in low-hanging grey sweatpants... be here I am. I felt for Frey during his moments of defeat and impatience as he sought to gain Anna's approval, and I'm truly glad that these moments were included as it added a sense of realness to his character. Despite Frey's good and well-meaning intentions, he's not always going to get things right and that's okay. What mattered the most is the aftermath of these moments when Frey and Anna would come together and maturely discuss what went wrong. I loved the development in their communication, and this made the progression of their relationship all the more realistic and true. I adore Frey and Anna as a couple, and I particularly enjoyed their moments of independent development which only went to strengthen them as a couple.
Outside of the main characters and their development as a couple... I'm utterly obsessed with the lore of the world? I love how author S.E. Wendel inserts real life history and weaves it into the world of Fantasy that we are introduced to. It's such a fun and unique take on key moments of history, and I cannot wait to see what comes next in the War of the Underhill series. That ending? I have so many questions that I desperately need answers to. Also to those that read the prequel to this story, Stone Heart... Carys and Gavriel are everything. I adore those two with everything I am. I cannot wait to see their continued role in the plot as the series continues to progress.
Thank you to the author for the eARC to read and review prior to release day.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
"I care for you, my Anna. I should like to love you, too."
📖 | 457 pages
👤 | author S.E. Wendel
🏢 | published independently
📅 | release date 29 March 2024
What you can expect:
— Adult Monster Romance
— Second Instalment In A Series
— First-Person POV
— Dual-POV
— Medieval Meets Modern
— Fated Mates
— He Falls First
— Chronic Pain Rep
— Grumpy X Grumpy
— Slow Burn Romance
— Forced Proximity
— Animal Companion
— Morally Grey Heroine X Moody Winged Hero
Trigger & Content Warnings include: sexually explicit content, chronic pain & migraines, kidnapping, stalking, minor blood and gore, violence.
Heartsong is the second instalment in the War of the Underhill series by author S.E. Wendel. Fifteen hundred years ago, Frey and all his kind were cursed by the vicious fae queen, their magick stolen and their bodies rendered stone. A proud warrior ready for a mate, Frey rages against his stone prison, but with every year that passes, hope slips away that the curse will ever be broken. That is, until he and some of his kin are placed in an odd little museum... and she walks through the door. Anna Kincaid has just gotten back on her feet. After struggling with student debt, chronic migraines, a serial-dater mother, and Bay Area rent for years, she’s finally landed a job that will help with all of it. It feels too good to be true—full health care with dental and helping manage a museum full of exquisite artifacts? Her heart and history degree are thrilled, but something about the museum is… odd. The owners are a mysterious, if kind couple who call the collection the clan. When the museum is stormed by masked commandos one night, it isn’t even the weirdest thing to happen. No, she could wrap her head around organized art theft—what defies belief is one of the big grey behemoths springing to life to save her as he flies off with her and tucks her into his big body as he growls "mate." Can a modern woman allow a medieval male to whisk her away and claim her well guarded heart? Or will sinister forces seek to drive them apart before they can ever begin?
This is my third read by author S.E. Wendel and I've come to truly adore and anticipate her style of writing. Wendel possesses a unique and compelling narrative voice that drives the storyline and leaves the reader enraptured and enthralled from beginning to end. There's very few authors that I have found leaves me with this true feeling of contentment and I'm thrilled to add another to the very short list. Heartsong is a love letter to those who fiercely guard their heart whilst yearning for love and companionship. That it's okay to lower your walls and welcome somebody else in. That it is not weakness to lean on other's during times of struggle and pain. With it's steady pacing, a mysterious on-going plot and a strong cast of characters, this is not a story to be missed for fans of the Monster Romance genre.
Anna Kincaid is my favourite kind of main character as she is somebody that I find myself truly resonating with and seeing pieces of myself in. With an unstable upbringing moving from one place to the next, as she witnessed her mother stuck in a vicious cycle of falling in love to ultimately get her heart broken... Anna guards her heart with an iron will and a determination to never let another claim in. All she has seen is the ultimate heartbreak that comes at the end of a short-lived love affair, so her doubt and apprehension is as understandable as it heart-breaking. I felt so bad for Anna during her emotional turmoil as she battled with her loneliness and chronic pain. After spending much of her life taking care of herself, Anna doesn't know how to let anybody in. Least of all a grumpy, overbearing gargoyle who is centuries years old and is making grand claims about his intentions towards her. Whilst I admit to sometimes feeling frustrated towards Anna and her actions, her mistrust in Frey is valid and I'm glad that she took the time to establish boundaries as she progressed at a pace that felt safe for herself. I ended the book feeling really proud of Anna's development, and I hope other readers will come to share my sentiment.
Frey is a grumpy and assertive gargoyle who we meet as he wants to claim his Mate on an instinctive and primal level. From the very beginning I loved how despite what his base nature was compelling him to do, Frey desperately wished to earn Anna's love and affection on his own. His overall patience and keenness to please Anna was honestly really sweet and endearing to witness in contrast to his otherwise surly personality. I loved watching as Frey came to life the more Anna seemed open to their connection. His flirty banter and boastful nature was hilarious as he is clearly a proud male who may not have much to offer in this new modern era, but he knows who he is and is willing that to be enough. Also I never anticipated enjoying a purring gargoyle that struts about in low-hanging grey sweatpants... be here I am. I felt for Frey during his moments of defeat and impatience as he sought to gain Anna's approval, and I'm truly glad that these moments were included as it added a sense of realness to his character. Despite Frey's good and well-meaning intentions, he's not always going to get things right and that's okay. What mattered the most is the aftermath of these moments when Frey and Anna would come together and maturely discuss what went wrong. I loved the development in their communication, and this made the progression of their relationship all the more realistic and true. I adore Frey and Anna as a couple, and I particularly enjoyed their moments of independent development which only went to strengthen them as a couple.
Outside of the main characters and their development as a couple... I'm utterly obsessed with the lore of the world? I love how author S.E. Wendel inserts real life history and weaves it into the world of Fantasy that we are introduced to. It's such a fun and unique take on key moments of history, and I cannot wait to see what comes next in the War of the Underhill series. That ending? I have so many questions that I desperately need answers to. Also to those that read the prequel to this story, Stone Heart... Carys and Gavriel are everything. I adore those two with everything I am. I cannot wait to see their continued role in the plot as the series continues to progress.
Thank you to the author for the eARC to read and review prior to release day.
May 1, 2025
I want to love this author so bad. She writes really beautiful romances, has amazing concepts and great potential. However, i find she tends to write fluff romance with little to no plot until things crack off at the end and considering her books are around 400 pages that really doesnt cut it for me.
If this book was 300 pages or less i think it would've been a 5 star, but it's repetitive and i think a good 60 consecutive pages were smut and fluff.
The whole book is a wash rinse repeat of our fmc going to work, eating mmc food, cuddling then sex then back to work a couple arguements thrown in there...
I just am not sure this author is for me which is a shame because i love her writing and concepts but the content doesnt justify the page count for me. And even though the end with the next fmc sounded really good i just dont think i can continue trying this authors work.
Safety&Info:
Dual 3rd person Pov
Spice:🔥🔥🔥🔥 or more
Romance meter:💚🧡/5
Magic meter:✨️/5
◇Ow drama: none
◇Om drama: none
◇No cheating/sharing/love triangle
◇ 3rd act breakup: no?
◇Seperation: 1 day or so
◇fmc not a v, mmc not sure
◇Ages: ????
◇Protection: birth control
◇HEA
If this book was 300 pages or less i think it would've been a 5 star, but it's repetitive and i think a good 60 consecutive pages were smut and fluff.
The whole book is a wash rinse repeat of our fmc going to work, eating mmc food, cuddling then sex then back to work a couple arguements thrown in there...
I just am not sure this author is for me which is a shame because i love her writing and concepts but the content doesnt justify the page count for me. And even though the end with the next fmc sounded really good i just dont think i can continue trying this authors work.
Safety&Info:
Dual 3rd person Pov
Spice:🔥🔥🔥🔥 or more
Romance meter:💚🧡/5
Magic meter:✨️/5
◇Ow drama: none
◇Om drama: none
◇No cheating/sharing/love triangle
◇ 3rd act breakup: no?
◇Seperation: 1 day or so
◇fmc not a v, mmc not sure
◇Ages: ????
◇Protection: birth control
◇HEA
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
2026
October 21, 2025Halloween TBR
Valentine's Day TBR
📱 Thank you to NetGalley and Avon a
Valentine's Day TBR
📱 Thank you to NetGalley and Avon a
September 7, 2025
I was so pleasantly surprised by this book. I was expecting a smutty monster romance, and this was so much more than that.
The MMC, Frey, is a gargoyle (technically a grotesque) who’s been cursed since the sixth century, and because of this, he’s trapped in a stone body. The FMC, Anna, is his heartsong (which is the most beautiful word for soulmate/mate) and is the key to breaking his curse.
Frey manages to escape his stone prison, but all of the other gargoyles from his clan are still imprisoned. I’ll be looking forward to the next book to find out what happens to the rest of the clan.
I thought the relationship between Anna and Frey was truly moving. Anna has a rough background, is used to taking care of herself, and has trouble opening up to Frey. Frey is stubborn in the best way and manages to pursue Anna without becoming too pushy or overbearing.
—Thank you to NetGalley, S.E. Wendel, and Avon and Harper Voyager for the ARC copy of Heartsong—
The MMC, Frey, is a gargoyle (technically a grotesque) who’s been cursed since the sixth century, and because of this, he’s trapped in a stone body. The FMC, Anna, is his heartsong (which is the most beautiful word for soulmate/mate) and is the key to breaking his curse.
Frey manages to escape his stone prison, but all of the other gargoyles from his clan are still imprisoned. I’ll be looking forward to the next book to find out what happens to the rest of the clan.
I thought the relationship between Anna and Frey was truly moving. Anna has a rough background, is used to taking care of herself, and has trouble opening up to Frey. Frey is stubborn in the best way and manages to pursue Anna without becoming too pushy or overbearing.
—Thank you to NetGalley, S.E. Wendel, and Avon and Harper Voyager for the ARC copy of Heartsong—
April 1, 2024
4.5 ⭐️/5
3.0 🌶️/5
This is book two in the War of the Underhill series from S. E. Wendel and it touches every part of my heart and feelings. 🥹
Again, S.E. Wendel created another MMC that is perfect (Orek from Halfling totally captured my heart first 🥹). Frey is my newest book boyfriend, and I definitely am not biased because I’m telling you that he can do no wrong. 😉☺️ If you’re looking for a character whose declarations of love is pure poetry, Frey is the guardian for you.
I love how Frey is a centuries old being who is trying to navigate the present day. He’s a warrior guardian from another time, who has found his heartsong but he is alone and vulnerable in a world he can no longer dominate on sheer strength. Anna, is Frey’s heartsong, and a modern independent human woman who is finally finding stability from a very unstable past. I completely relate to Anna’s suffering from chronic migraines, and it’s such a relief to see on page something that I struggle with being put into words in a way I find hard to describe.
While not required, I definitely recommend reading Stone Hearts before Heartsong to get the fullest appreciation of the series. Stone Hearts sets up the world of the series and I cannot wait to see what happens next. I love Carys and Gavriel and their adventures through hundreds and hundreds and of years.
If you love mates, Welsh ancient lore and legend, fated mates, MMCs who fall first and hard, lots of spice and heat, FMCs who take some convincing, read Stone Hearts and Heartsong.
Thank you SE Wendel for the ARC. My thoughts/opinions are my own and my review is voluntary.
3.0 🌶️/5
This is book two in the War of the Underhill series from S. E. Wendel and it touches every part of my heart and feelings. 🥹
Again, S.E. Wendel created another MMC that is perfect (Orek from Halfling totally captured my heart first 🥹). Frey is my newest book boyfriend, and I definitely am not biased because I’m telling you that he can do no wrong. 😉☺️ If you’re looking for a character whose declarations of love is pure poetry, Frey is the guardian for you.
I love how Frey is a centuries old being who is trying to navigate the present day. He’s a warrior guardian from another time, who has found his heartsong but he is alone and vulnerable in a world he can no longer dominate on sheer strength. Anna, is Frey’s heartsong, and a modern independent human woman who is finally finding stability from a very unstable past. I completely relate to Anna’s suffering from chronic migraines, and it’s such a relief to see on page something that I struggle with being put into words in a way I find hard to describe.
While not required, I definitely recommend reading Stone Hearts before Heartsong to get the fullest appreciation of the series. Stone Hearts sets up the world of the series and I cannot wait to see what happens next. I love Carys and Gavriel and their adventures through hundreds and hundreds and of years.
If you love mates, Welsh ancient lore and legend, fated mates, MMCs who fall first and hard, lots of spice and heat, FMCs who take some convincing, read Stone Hearts and Heartsong.
Thank you SE Wendel for the ARC. My thoughts/opinions are my own and my review is voluntary.
May 4, 2024
Absolutely adorable! I loved these two main characters, they are so different from each other and it is lovely to see them grow together. Really great action, cannot wait to see where the story goes next. Loved Carys and Gavren in the modern world! And who doesn’t love a black cat animal sidekick! Great modern day monster romance!
April 10, 2024
I was swept away by this heart-melting romance! The world building was top-notch. I fell in love with the writing style from the very beginning; I could totally believe the MMC was not from modern times. His story and that of his kind was a tear-jerker; it was that well-told. The FMC was a strong, believable and relatable character. Seeing their relationship develop had me giggling, cheering, and swooning; the dangers they faced had be holding my breath - when you're that invested in a book, you know it's good! The schmexy times were the cherry on top. In short, I LOVED this book!
December 22, 2025
My rating: 3.75 ⭐⭐⭐✨
Tropes:
— fated mates
— he falls first
— close proximity
— moody winged hero
— fish out of water
— medieval meets modern
— hurt/comfort
It was an interesting story that reminded me a bit of the movie Night at the Museum and the Gargoyles animated series. I enjoyed the beginning and the ending, but the middle felt a bit slow and lost my attention. Nevertheless, I'm looking forward to reading the next part.
It's perfect for fans of the Gargoyles animated series who want to feel nostalgic while enjoying a more mature version of the story.
Thank you to Avon a and NetGalley for providing this eARC in exchange for an honest review.
Tropes:
— fated mates
— he falls first
— close proximity
— moody winged hero
— fish out of water
— medieval meets modern
— hurt/comfort
It was an interesting story that reminded me a bit of the movie Night at the Museum and the Gargoyles animated series. I enjoyed the beginning and the ending, but the middle felt a bit slow and lost my attention. Nevertheless, I'm looking forward to reading the next part.
It's perfect for fans of the Gargoyles animated series who want to feel nostalgic while enjoying a more mature version of the story.
Thank you to Avon a and NetGalley for providing this eARC in exchange for an honest review.
September 10, 2025
dnf 25%
I could not get into this. I loved the beginning, but I struggled with Frey and Anna's dynamic. I was quickly exhausted of her woe is me I am not lovable attitude. I disliked him telling her what she could not do or breaking her medication.
I could not get into this. I loved the beginning, but I struggled with Frey and Anna's dynamic. I was quickly exhausted of her woe is me I am not lovable attitude. I disliked him telling her what she could not do or breaking her medication.
November 2, 2025
You can find this review of Heartsong on my blog Heart's Content!
A big shout out and thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with a complimentary copy of Heartsong in exchange for an honest review!
From the first moment I glimpsed the cover of Heartsong, there was something about it that was just so enthralling to me. I’m not sure if it’s the colours or the style of art, or the way the characters are depicted… but there was something about it. I remember even after the book landed on my Kobo, I stared at it for a while, enjoying it so much. Shout out to the Kobo team for the colours in the device. No, this is not sponsored. Ha, I wish, though.
The blurb of course, adds a wonderful layer of intrigue to the cover that only further piqued my interest. Usually, when I see the word ‘fated mates’ and I’m sold, add in a bit of magical realism, paranormal and I’m sat. Immediately so.
My favourite, favourite aspect about Heartsong—which might sound extremely contradictory to the theme at its heart—is how real the book feels. I think with most books that balance the line between reality and fantasy (which is classified into an extremely enjoyable genre called magical realism), it’s how the author draws the readers into the world, that’s filled with mythical creatures and folklore even while keeping in mind the bills that need to be paid and the cameras that needs to be avoided, that makes the genre/book what it is. It’s this sense of having one foot in both worlds and finding a way to survive it that needs to be done extremely well to capture the readers. Wendel with her writing achieves that balance fantastically.
This book had what I can describe as one of the most rooted-to-reality progression arcs. This quality of Wendel’s work infiltrates every other aspect of the book and ensures that all of them hold hands and walk together, keeping steady pace and advancing in equal measure, while ensuring that no one element develops faster or slowly than another. Nothing is rushed, nothing feels like it could have been established better or slower or lesser or more. They all fit perfectly in place beside one another and ensure the reader too keeps steady pace with the story.
This is especially perceived in the relationship between the main characters. Despite following a fated mates trope, the book ensures that the bond between the characters is built and nurtured and with that, comes the ups and downs of facing one’s own fears and doubts and addressing and understanding your partners requirements and feelings. Wendel does allthis! So so sweetly. Interestingly, she achieved this between extremely flawed individuals and never hides their flaws to the readers, but somehow your heart just … melts for them and you’re on their side before you realise it. I think choosing to depict a relationship that requires work from both sides, instead of one that exists in its perfect form immediately, really adds to how well done the book feels.
There was a really interesting element of mystery to this book that keeps a subtle sense of tension and high stakes going throughout the whole book. What was interesting was that the mystery and tension were in both the supernatural sense and in a very real world sense. Again, the author has ensured that her book perfectly reflects what it’s like to have to straddle the reality between magic and modern times—and she’s done this on multiple levels.
To narrate this book with alternating perspectives was such a wonderful decision to make from a writing stand-point. It perfectly portrays the stark contrast between the thoughts, cultures and situations of both MCs. Their priorities and personalities were wonderfully highlighted—especially when placed beside one another. I enjoyed watching them grow to understand and love one another and adjust to the ideologies of some aspects of the other’s world.
I personally can’t think of a single thing in this book that I struggled with. The only thing I cannot wholly comment on is the historical representation. If it was represented well, or if there were some artistic liberties taken in interpretation (I mean of course, but still) because I do not know much about it. Outside of this one aspect I’m ignorant in, to me, this book was extremely well-rounded, romantic, heart-felt and enthralling!
Happy happy reading. As always please check trigger warnings!
A big shout out and thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with a complimentary copy of Heartsong in exchange for an honest review!
From the first moment I glimpsed the cover of Heartsong, there was something about it that was just so enthralling to me. I’m not sure if it’s the colours or the style of art, or the way the characters are depicted… but there was something about it. I remember even after the book landed on my Kobo, I stared at it for a while, enjoying it so much. Shout out to the Kobo team for the colours in the device. No, this is not sponsored. Ha, I wish, though.
The blurb of course, adds a wonderful layer of intrigue to the cover that only further piqued my interest. Usually, when I see the word ‘fated mates’ and I’m sold, add in a bit of magical realism, paranormal and I’m sat. Immediately so.
My favourite, favourite aspect about Heartsong—which might sound extremely contradictory to the theme at its heart—is how real the book feels. I think with most books that balance the line between reality and fantasy (which is classified into an extremely enjoyable genre called magical realism), it’s how the author draws the readers into the world, that’s filled with mythical creatures and folklore even while keeping in mind the bills that need to be paid and the cameras that needs to be avoided, that makes the genre/book what it is. It’s this sense of having one foot in both worlds and finding a way to survive it that needs to be done extremely well to capture the readers. Wendel with her writing achieves that balance fantastically.
This book had what I can describe as one of the most rooted-to-reality progression arcs. This quality of Wendel’s work infiltrates every other aspect of the book and ensures that all of them hold hands and walk together, keeping steady pace and advancing in equal measure, while ensuring that no one element develops faster or slowly than another. Nothing is rushed, nothing feels like it could have been established better or slower or lesser or more. They all fit perfectly in place beside one another and ensure the reader too keeps steady pace with the story.
This is especially perceived in the relationship between the main characters. Despite following a fated mates trope, the book ensures that the bond between the characters is built and nurtured and with that, comes the ups and downs of facing one’s own fears and doubts and addressing and understanding your partners requirements and feelings. Wendel does allthis! So so sweetly. Interestingly, she achieved this between extremely flawed individuals and never hides their flaws to the readers, but somehow your heart just … melts for them and you’re on their side before you realise it. I think choosing to depict a relationship that requires work from both sides, instead of one that exists in its perfect form immediately, really adds to how well done the book feels.
There was a really interesting element of mystery to this book that keeps a subtle sense of tension and high stakes going throughout the whole book. What was interesting was that the mystery and tension were in both the supernatural sense and in a very real world sense. Again, the author has ensured that her book perfectly reflects what it’s like to have to straddle the reality between magic and modern times—and she’s done this on multiple levels.
To narrate this book with alternating perspectives was such a wonderful decision to make from a writing stand-point. It perfectly portrays the stark contrast between the thoughts, cultures and situations of both MCs. Their priorities and personalities were wonderfully highlighted—especially when placed beside one another. I enjoyed watching them grow to understand and love one another and adjust to the ideologies of some aspects of the other’s world.
I personally can’t think of a single thing in this book that I struggled with. The only thing I cannot wholly comment on is the historical representation. If it was represented well, or if there were some artistic liberties taken in interpretation (I mean of course, but still) because I do not know much about it. Outside of this one aspect I’m ignorant in, to me, this book was extremely well-rounded, romantic, heart-felt and enthralling!
Happy happy reading. As always please check trigger warnings!
March 30, 2024
”You are my heartsong, Anna. There is no changing this. I swear to you that I will ever strive to be a good mate. Matehood is a choice. Those that work are by choice. I will always choose you, my Anna. I will always care for you and provide for you, for that’s what it is to be a mate.” Frey was a proud male, but smart males knew when to bend. And when to beg. “Please, fy nghân. Let me be your mate.”
—
Rating: 4.5/5
Spice: 2/5
Anyone up for a road trip to the museum in SF?
Anna Kincaid has made a life for herself, away from her mother and her parade of endless boyfriends. A small apartment, a cat named Captain, and a job she loves with good health benefits? Yes, please. If only those migraines could leave her alone. She is content with the routine she has set in her life so the last thing she expects is to be involved in a robbery at the museum and be carried away by her favourite stone statue.
Frey has spent centuries as a stone gargoyle, having been cursed and stripped of the magick that gave him life. His only solace was the shared consciousness with his kin in the museum. Until he felt the touch of his heartsong, his fated mate.
Finding himself in a much more modern civilization is the least of his problems when his mate is more than reluctant to accept him and the bond. Not to mention that he returns to his stone state at sunrise.
Frey and Anna were amazing characters. Our gargoyle was definitely overprotective but how determined he was to care for our FMC was a major winner (and the gray sweatpants and open shirts). With the childhood she had, I could not blame Anna for being wary of Frey and his talk of mates. But after a while, she was starting to frustrate me. She wasn’t even trying to meet Frey halfway and just let him give and give. I was glad she realized that though and I loved the timing of their love confession. The longer epilogue was great and served the overall pacing of the story well.
I appreciated that even magick couldn’t make Anna’s migraines disappear completely, but was a temporary solution. It was so good to see Carys and Gav again, Carys is my baby girl!
I am ready for June and Alaric!!!
I leave you with this unhinged Frey:
[…]
—
Rating: 4.5/5
Spice: 2/5
Anyone up for a road trip to the museum in SF?
Anna Kincaid has made a life for herself, away from her mother and her parade of endless boyfriends. A small apartment, a cat named Captain, and a job she loves with good health benefits? Yes, please. If only those migraines could leave her alone. She is content with the routine she has set in her life so the last thing she expects is to be involved in a robbery at the museum and be carried away by her favourite stone statue.
Frey has spent centuries as a stone gargoyle, having been cursed and stripped of the magick that gave him life. His only solace was the shared consciousness with his kin in the museum. Until he felt the touch of his heartsong, his fated mate.
Finding himself in a much more modern civilization is the least of his problems when his mate is more than reluctant to accept him and the bond. Not to mention that he returns to his stone state at sunrise.
Frey and Anna were amazing characters. Our gargoyle was definitely overprotective but how determined he was to care for our FMC was a major winner (and the gray sweatpants and open shirts). With the childhood she had, I could not blame Anna for being wary of Frey and his talk of mates. But after a while, she was starting to frustrate me. She wasn’t even trying to meet Frey halfway and just let him give and give. I was glad she realized that though and I loved the timing of their love confession. The longer epilogue was great and served the overall pacing of the story well.
I appreciated that even magick couldn’t make Anna’s migraines disappear completely, but was a temporary solution. It was so good to see Carys and Gav again, Carys is my baby girl!
I am ready for June and Alaric!!!
I leave you with this unhinged Frey:
So Frey bided his time. And snatched up one of his mate’s underthings to sniff to soothe the worst of his frustration.
[…]
Chewing her cheek, she turned back into the apartment, only to find Frey already a step outside her bedroom door, angrily chewing the last of his steak and inexplicably clutching one of her bras.
July 20, 2025
5/5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ | 2.5/5 chili peppers 🌶️🌶️½
First, a big thank you to S.E. Wendel, Avon and Harper Voyager, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read Heartsong as an ARC. All thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.
Okay, confession time: I’m a millennial who grew up obsessed with Disney’s Gargoyles, and when I saw the cover of this book, I didn’t even hesitate to request it. I’m still salty that show never got a proper ending (seriously—why were so many shows back then denied finales?!), and Heartsong felt like the emotional balm my inner child didn’t know she still needed.
Let’s talk about the story. I didn’t realize I was a monster romance girly until recently—and I definitely carried the (mistaken) belief that monster romances were all steam and no substance. Turns out, I was very wrong. Heartsong delivers both the heart-melting romance and the depth of plot I crave.
Anna and Frey gave me all the nostalgic feels. I mean...tell me this doesn’t feel like Goliath and Elisa 2.0 in the best possible way. I literally squealed multiple times while reading—actual squeals. That’s how invested I was. And Frey? Total cinnamon roll with a dangerous streak. Soft-hearted but with serious “touch her and die” energy. I was swooning.
What I especially loved is that this isn’t a one-and-done fantasy. The worldbuilding is rich and clearly designed for a series. While Heartsong wraps up Anna and Frey’s arc beautifully, the final chapter hints that the next book will follow a new couple (and I am already counting down the days). I was a little disappointed not to have the sequel ready to binge immediately, but I will definitely be diving into the prequel about Carys and Gavren in the meantime.
If you love sweet, heartfelt romances with a touch of spice, deeply emotional characters, and gargoyle protectors who are just as tender as they are fierce—do not sleep on this book. Trust me. It’s everything I didn’t know I needed.
First, a big thank you to S.E. Wendel, Avon and Harper Voyager, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read Heartsong as an ARC. All thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.
Okay, confession time: I’m a millennial who grew up obsessed with Disney’s Gargoyles, and when I saw the cover of this book, I didn’t even hesitate to request it. I’m still salty that show never got a proper ending (seriously—why were so many shows back then denied finales?!), and Heartsong felt like the emotional balm my inner child didn’t know she still needed.
Let’s talk about the story. I didn’t realize I was a monster romance girly until recently—and I definitely carried the (mistaken) belief that monster romances were all steam and no substance. Turns out, I was very wrong. Heartsong delivers both the heart-melting romance and the depth of plot I crave.
Anna and Frey gave me all the nostalgic feels. I mean...tell me this doesn’t feel like Goliath and Elisa 2.0 in the best possible way. I literally squealed multiple times while reading—actual squeals. That’s how invested I was. And Frey? Total cinnamon roll with a dangerous streak. Soft-hearted but with serious “touch her and die” energy. I was swooning.
What I especially loved is that this isn’t a one-and-done fantasy. The worldbuilding is rich and clearly designed for a series. While Heartsong wraps up Anna and Frey’s arc beautifully, the final chapter hints that the next book will follow a new couple (and I am already counting down the days). I was a little disappointed not to have the sequel ready to binge immediately, but I will definitely be diving into the prequel about Carys and Gavren in the meantime.
If you love sweet, heartfelt romances with a touch of spice, deeply emotional characters, and gargoyle protectors who are just as tender as they are fierce—do not sleep on this book. Trust me. It’s everything I didn’t know I needed.
January 11, 2026
My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️ (slow burn)
Format: 📱 & 📖
I knew going into Heartsong a few things about S.E. Wendel’s writing style, having read Halfling & Ironling previously - she makes a cosy romance come off the page in a believable way, and she can write a really intense spicy scene 😏 I was excited to discover how she writes PNR (paranormal romance), as all her previous work has been pure fantasy in a more medieval sort of setting.
I did not know about the prequel novella, Stone Hearts, until about halfway through the book but I will be reading soon for the Carrie/Gavin backstory!
Frey has a lot of similarities with the MMCs in her other books, a wonderful protective male who is completely obsessed with their mate. Anna was a bit refreshing, as she suffers from chronic migraines (a trait I too suffer from), so she had to do all the badass FMC stuff all the while living in absolute agony. It was really relatable for me.
I will be looking forward to book 2, I am assuming she will follow her prior pattern of switching characters as MCs in the prequel, so I assume June is going to take center stage for that.
Notable tropes & themes ——
🦇 Paranormal Romance/Urban Fantasy
🐈⬛ Chronic Illness Representation
🦇 Gargoyle MMC
🐈⬛ Monster Romance
🦇 Ancient Fae & Druids in modern times
🐈⬛ Mate bond/Fated Mates
🦇 Forced Proximity
🐈⬛ Black cat sidekick
I received both the eARC and a physical ARC of Heartsong, gifted by AVON as an opportunity to read and give my honest review. #avonpartner
Spice: 🌶️🌶️ (slow burn)
Format: 📱 & 📖
I knew going into Heartsong a few things about S.E. Wendel’s writing style, having read Halfling & Ironling previously - she makes a cosy romance come off the page in a believable way, and she can write a really intense spicy scene 😏 I was excited to discover how she writes PNR (paranormal romance), as all her previous work has been pure fantasy in a more medieval sort of setting.
I did not know about the prequel novella, Stone Hearts, until about halfway through the book but I will be reading soon for the Carrie/Gavin backstory!
Frey has a lot of similarities with the MMCs in her other books, a wonderful protective male who is completely obsessed with their mate. Anna was a bit refreshing, as she suffers from chronic migraines (a trait I too suffer from), so she had to do all the badass FMC stuff all the while living in absolute agony. It was really relatable for me.
I will be looking forward to book 2, I am assuming she will follow her prior pattern of switching characters as MCs in the prequel, so I assume June is going to take center stage for that.
Notable tropes & themes ——
🦇 Paranormal Romance/Urban Fantasy
🐈⬛ Chronic Illness Representation
🦇 Gargoyle MMC
🐈⬛ Monster Romance
🦇 Ancient Fae & Druids in modern times
🐈⬛ Mate bond/Fated Mates
🦇 Forced Proximity
🐈⬛ Black cat sidekick
I received both the eARC and a physical ARC of Heartsong, gifted by AVON as an opportunity to read and give my honest review. #avonpartner
April 5, 2024
Stone heart was the first ever SE Wendel book I read and will forever have an extra special place for me. So, imagine my joy when we got Heartsong! Another book in this incredible world!
Frey and Anna were just such a breath of fresh air. Although arrogant and a little cocky, Frey knew exactly how to compromise to get his Heartsong.
“Frey was a proud male, but smart males knew when to bend. And when to beg.”
I loved him so much. Considering he was a baby in the modern world, he adapted and learned so quickly- everything to be a worthy mate to his Anna.
“My Anna.”
Anna was a difficult character to relate to. She’s real and has flaws and can be a bit mean and self destructive. But as Frey finds patience to slowly lure her in and get her to see her worth, we get to see it too along with her and end up loving her for her character development.
Seeing Carys and her hunky fae was just the cherry on top. I love them and would read another book of just them!
And the ending! Ahhhhh! How much longer do I need to wait for June’s book?!
I deducted a star because at times the pace was a little slow with very little action. I just wish the action with Glendower was a little more prolonged and had happened sooner.
On the topic of Glendower- wtf. I need to know what’s happening to our poor poor Dragan. I’m willing to volunteer to be his heroine. Just sayin’.
Frey and Anna were just such a breath of fresh air. Although arrogant and a little cocky, Frey knew exactly how to compromise to get his Heartsong.
“Frey was a proud male, but smart males knew when to bend. And when to beg.”
I loved him so much. Considering he was a baby in the modern world, he adapted and learned so quickly- everything to be a worthy mate to his Anna.
“My Anna.”
Anna was a difficult character to relate to. She’s real and has flaws and can be a bit mean and self destructive. But as Frey finds patience to slowly lure her in and get her to see her worth, we get to see it too along with her and end up loving her for her character development.
Seeing Carys and her hunky fae was just the cherry on top. I love them and would read another book of just them!
And the ending! Ahhhhh! How much longer do I need to wait for June’s book?!
I deducted a star because at times the pace was a little slow with very little action. I just wish the action with Glendower was a little more prolonged and had happened sooner.
On the topic of Glendower- wtf. I need to know what’s happening to our poor poor Dragan. I’m willing to volunteer to be his heroine. Just sayin’.
July 3, 2025
I knew I wanted to read Heartsong from the moment I saw the gorgeous cover. By the time I finished the blurb, I was hooked. I love a sexy paranormal romance with fated mates and a swoon-worthy MMC, which made this the perfect read for me!
Both Anna and Frey have interesting backstories that very much define them. A migraine sufferer with an unstable upbringing and tentative healthcare throughout her life, Anna is hurting in more ways than one. I can understand why she's so careful with her trust and feelings, considering what she's experienced, and it made her relationship with Frey so special.
I absolutely loved Frey, and if you like strong, ancient, cursed warriors who fall first and fall hard, you’ll love him too. He is so devoted to Anna, and he is not afraid to show it. To him, their bond is everything, and he proves it to her over and over, which is great, because it takes some time to win the more resistant Anna over. Their romance is positively swoon-worthy, from the gentle and thoughtful ways he takes care of her to the sexy and passionate things he says and does. My word, Frey is the kind of MMC that makes you melt!
I really enjoyed this suspenseful and romantic read. The characters are great, the found family vibes are fabulous, the stakes are high and suspenseful, and the love story is gorgeous. I did wish for a different outcome with Anna’s mother, but other than that I loved the story, and I’m looking forward to continuing the series. There was a twist that made me eager for the next love story and to find out what happens when certain characters find our MCs. Plus, I have to know what happens to the other Guardians still suffering under the curse! Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy of the book. All thoughts are my own.
Both Anna and Frey have interesting backstories that very much define them. A migraine sufferer with an unstable upbringing and tentative healthcare throughout her life, Anna is hurting in more ways than one. I can understand why she's so careful with her trust and feelings, considering what she's experienced, and it made her relationship with Frey so special.
I absolutely loved Frey, and if you like strong, ancient, cursed warriors who fall first and fall hard, you’ll love him too. He is so devoted to Anna, and he is not afraid to show it. To him, their bond is everything, and he proves it to her over and over, which is great, because it takes some time to win the more resistant Anna over. Their romance is positively swoon-worthy, from the gentle and thoughtful ways he takes care of her to the sexy and passionate things he says and does. My word, Frey is the kind of MMC that makes you melt!
I really enjoyed this suspenseful and romantic read. The characters are great, the found family vibes are fabulous, the stakes are high and suspenseful, and the love story is gorgeous. I did wish for a different outcome with Anna’s mother, but other than that I loved the story, and I’m looking forward to continuing the series. There was a twist that made me eager for the next love story and to find out what happens when certain characters find our MCs. Plus, I have to know what happens to the other Guardians still suffering under the curse! Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy of the book. All thoughts are my own.
November 3, 2025
I'm as shocked as you are that I'm five-starring this. Monster romances are NOT for me, yet here I was, sat.
Things I loved:
🦇 Chronic pain representation!!! My migraines can be so debilitating, and I felt so seen in my struggles
🦇 Curvy FMC who I found funny. She was kind of a complaining bitch, but so am I, so how can I judge?
🦇 A respectful yet still medieval MMC. I liked watching him grow into becoming a modern man fitting her needs as a modern woman
🦇 The burn was the perfect amount. Watching him go from wanting his mate to wanting HER, and watching her overcome her hesitation about it all was lovely
🦇 Tight gray sweatpants
🦇 THE CAT
🦇 Welsh history research. Granted, I don't know how much is fully accurate (I didn't look anything up, just blindly trusted) but I do feel like I was sort of learning while reading, especially with the chapter notes.
🦇 Some cozy hangouts. I liked them watching Netflix and eating dinner together a lot. Some may find it repetitive, I found it comforting. Plot still went on in the background but it was nice coming back to it
Definitely want to read more!!! This was a hidden gem!
𝑻𝒉𝒂𝒏𝒌 𝒚𝒐𝒖 𝒕𝒐 𝙃𝙖𝙧𝙥𝙚𝙧 𝘾𝙤𝙡𝙡𝙞𝙣𝙨, 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝒂𝒖𝒕𝒉𝒐𝒓, 𝒂𝒏𝒅 𝑵𝒆𝒕𝒈𝒂𝒍𝒍𝒆𝒚 𝒇𝒐𝒓 𝒈𝒊𝒗𝒊𝒏𝒈 𝒎𝒆 𝒕𝒉𝒊𝒔 𝙥𝙝𝙮𝙨𝙞𝙘𝙖𝙡 𝙖𝙣𝙙 𝙚𝙡𝙚𝙘𝙩𝙧𝙤𝙣𝙞𝙘 𝑨𝑹𝑪 𝒊𝒏 𝒆𝒙𝒄𝒉𝒂𝒏𝒈𝒆 𝒇𝒐𝒓 𝒎𝒚 𝒉𝒐𝒏𝒆𝒔𝒕 𝒓𝒆𝒗𝒊𝒆𝒘. 𝑨𝒍𝒍 𝒐𝒑𝒊𝒏𝒊𝒐𝒏𝒔 𝒂𝒓𝒆 𝒎𝒚 𝒐𝒘𝒏 ✮⋆˙
Things I loved:
🦇 Chronic pain representation!!! My migraines can be so debilitating, and I felt so seen in my struggles
🦇 Curvy FMC who I found funny. She was kind of a complaining bitch, but so am I, so how can I judge?
🦇 A respectful yet still medieval MMC. I liked watching him grow into becoming a modern man fitting her needs as a modern woman
🦇 The burn was the perfect amount. Watching him go from wanting his mate to wanting HER, and watching her overcome her hesitation about it all was lovely
🦇 Tight gray sweatpants
🦇 THE CAT
🦇 Welsh history research. Granted, I don't know how much is fully accurate (I didn't look anything up, just blindly trusted) but I do feel like I was sort of learning while reading, especially with the chapter notes.
🦇 Some cozy hangouts. I liked them watching Netflix and eating dinner together a lot. Some may find it repetitive, I found it comforting. Plot still went on in the background but it was nice coming back to it
Definitely want to read more!!! This was a hidden gem!
𝑻𝒉𝒂𝒏𝒌 𝒚𝒐𝒖 𝒕𝒐 𝙃𝙖𝙧𝙥𝙚𝙧 𝘾𝙤𝙡𝙡𝙞𝙣𝙨, 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝒂𝒖𝒕𝒉𝒐𝒓, 𝒂𝒏𝒅 𝑵𝒆𝒕𝒈𝒂𝒍𝒍𝒆𝒚 𝒇𝒐𝒓 𝒈𝒊𝒗𝒊𝒏𝒈 𝒎𝒆 𝒕𝒉𝒊𝒔 𝙥𝙝𝙮𝙨𝙞𝙘𝙖𝙡 𝙖𝙣𝙙 𝙚𝙡𝙚𝙘𝙩𝙧𝙤𝙣𝙞𝙘 𝑨𝑹𝑪 𝒊𝒏 𝒆𝒙𝒄𝒉𝒂𝒏𝒈𝒆 𝒇𝒐𝒓 𝒎𝒚 𝒉𝒐𝒏𝒆𝒔𝒕 𝒓𝒆𝒗𝒊𝒆𝒘. 𝑨𝒍𝒍 𝒐𝒑𝒊𝒏𝒊𝒐𝒏𝒔 𝒂𝒓𝒆 𝒎𝒚 𝒐𝒘𝒏 ✮⋆˙
March 24, 2024
In the heart of San Francisco, we meet Captain, a delightful void monster much like my BLT, the companion of Anna, a character whose life is a mosaic of modern struggles—from the all-too-familiar burden of student debt and chronic migraines to the bizarre yet unique challenge of managing a museum harboring deep secrets. Her path crosses with Frey, a gargoyle warrior who is cursed into stone, yet is still alive with the fierce hope and longing of a heart undimmed by centuries and longing to find his mate. Their connection is one that is sparked amidst chaos in the unlikeliest of meetings when Frey saves Anna, and unfolds into a journey of healing one’s trauma, discovery, and the unshakable power of fated love.
There is a perfect balance of attraction yet fear as Anna and Frey explore this bond between them. Anna’s scared soul takes time and work to heal, and, as a fellow trauma and guarded heart girlie, there’s an appreciation for not insta-love overpowering the trauma approach. However, I would be hard pressed to not instantly fall in love too between Frey’s protectiveness and care for Anna—and did I also mention not only does he purr, but he also gives Captain the love and attention he deserves? What more could you ask for?
As someone that also suffers from chronic illness, the care that is placed into the representation through Anna's character is both meticulous and validating while offering a mirror to readers who rarely see their own struggles depicted with such authenticity.
On a personal note, I love SE Wendel’s knowledge and extensive research and care put into the history used, and appreciate the The lore of the gargoyles who are bound by ancient curses and battles of will against fae adversaries provides a backdrop that's as compelling as the story's emotional core. Moments of tension and danger are deftly woven into the fabric of a narrative that, at its heart, feels like a warm embrace—a testament to the way she always delivers a cozy, low-angst atmosphere I trust and love.
‘Heartsong’ is a tender symphony of love’s healing power as hurt, humor, and the magic of finding your one true mate against all odds harmonize into a beautiful melody. It manages to be both fantastical and profoundly human, a story to give even the stoniest of hearts hope in the face of love.
There is a perfect balance of attraction yet fear as Anna and Frey explore this bond between them. Anna’s scared soul takes time and work to heal, and, as a fellow trauma and guarded heart girlie, there’s an appreciation for not insta-love overpowering the trauma approach. However, I would be hard pressed to not instantly fall in love too between Frey’s protectiveness and care for Anna—and did I also mention not only does he purr, but he also gives Captain the love and attention he deserves? What more could you ask for?
As someone that also suffers from chronic illness, the care that is placed into the representation through Anna's character is both meticulous and validating while offering a mirror to readers who rarely see their own struggles depicted with such authenticity.
On a personal note, I love SE Wendel’s knowledge and extensive research and care put into the history used, and appreciate the The lore of the gargoyles who are bound by ancient curses and battles of will against fae adversaries provides a backdrop that's as compelling as the story's emotional core. Moments of tension and danger are deftly woven into the fabric of a narrative that, at its heart, feels like a warm embrace—a testament to the way she always delivers a cozy, low-angst atmosphere I trust and love.
‘Heartsong’ is a tender symphony of love’s healing power as hurt, humor, and the magic of finding your one true mate against all odds harmonize into a beautiful melody. It manages to be both fantastical and profoundly human, a story to give even the stoniest of hearts hope in the face of love.
October 9, 2025
⭐⭐⭐.25 | 3.25 rounded down
I was in the mood for a fun monster romance as a palate cleanser and this book definitely served that purpose. I loved the concept of an ancient gargoyle warrior bwing woken up by a 21st century museum work in San Francisco, and I appreciated the Whelsh lore and world that the author created. I also really loved the represenation of chronic pain throughout.
I enjoyed the comic relief that Frey brought to the story, but I didn't like how he felt like a bit of a doormat throughout. I wanted him to have a slightly more of a backbone with Anna, even with their mate bond. I also wanted to see Anna work harder to resolve issues triggered by her childhood trauma instead of letting it rule her life and behave poorly.
Additionally, the anatomical verbiage (a weird mix of scientific terminology and crass phrases) the author used in spicy scenes was confusing and bit offputting to me, which dragged me out of the story.
Overall, I had a good time but I don't know if I'd pick up the next book.
Thank you to NetGalley and Avon and Harper Voyager | Avon a for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.
I was in the mood for a fun monster romance as a palate cleanser and this book definitely served that purpose. I loved the concept of an ancient gargoyle warrior bwing woken up by a 21st century museum work in San Francisco, and I appreciated the Whelsh lore and world that the author created. I also really loved the represenation of chronic pain throughout.
I enjoyed the comic relief that Frey brought to the story, but I didn't like how he felt like a bit of a doormat throughout. I wanted him to have a slightly more of a backbone with Anna, even with their mate bond. I also wanted to see Anna work harder to resolve issues triggered by her childhood trauma instead of letting it rule her life and behave poorly.
Additionally, the anatomical verbiage (a weird mix of scientific terminology and crass phrases) the author used in spicy scenes was confusing and bit offputting to me, which dragged me out of the story.
Overall, I had a good time but I don't know if I'd pick up the next book.
Thank you to NetGalley and Avon and Harper Voyager | Avon a for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.
March 29, 2024
***ARC review in exchange for an honest review***
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
🌶️🌶️
This was a spectacular book and I’m so glad that we’re diving back into the lore of the Underhill! Taking place in modern day San Francisco, Anna is working at a museum full of… intriguing statues 👀 and ends up with a stony new roommate. I loved seeing Frey get reacquainted to society and trying his best to woo his heartsong. Anna is a no BS kinda girl and I admired her resistance to Frey’s advances. It was realistic and made the slow burn all the better. The representation for chronic illness was done perfectly and respectfully. It was great seeing “Carrie” and “Gavin” and having them be continued part of the story. I can’t wait to see what’s in store for this series!
*please note it’s definitely recommended to read Stone Hearts before diving into Heartsong as there’s a ton of background information that helps!*
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
🌶️🌶️
This was a spectacular book and I’m so glad that we’re diving back into the lore of the Underhill! Taking place in modern day San Francisco, Anna is working at a museum full of… intriguing statues 👀 and ends up with a stony new roommate. I loved seeing Frey get reacquainted to society and trying his best to woo his heartsong. Anna is a no BS kinda girl and I admired her resistance to Frey’s advances. It was realistic and made the slow burn all the better. The representation for chronic illness was done perfectly and respectfully. It was great seeing “Carrie” and “Gavin” and having them be continued part of the story. I can’t wait to see what’s in store for this series!
*please note it’s definitely recommended to read Stone Hearts before diving into Heartsong as there’s a ton of background information that helps!*
July 20, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for providing this ARC!
I genuinely enjoyed this book, though I’m not surprised, as Hafling has long been one of my favorite cozy romance reads. S.E. Wendell has a talent for crafting sweet, soft, comforting stories that still manage to weave in a solid plot. The story had just enough high-stakes drama in the background to keep things engaging. I went into this for the vibes of an easy romance but I ended up getting invested in the mystery surrounding the museum where the FMC works.
Wendell also did a fantastic job portraying chronic illness and the isolation that can come with it. It felt very authentic, and the MMC’s support was heartwarming.
Overall, this was a very enjoyable read!
I genuinely enjoyed this book, though I’m not surprised, as Hafling has long been one of my favorite cozy romance reads. S.E. Wendell has a talent for crafting sweet, soft, comforting stories that still manage to weave in a solid plot. The story had just enough high-stakes drama in the background to keep things engaging. I went into this for the vibes of an easy romance but I ended up getting invested in the mystery surrounding the museum where the FMC works.
Wendell also did a fantastic job portraying chronic illness and the isolation that can come with it. It felt very authentic, and the MMC’s support was heartwarming.
Overall, this was a very enjoyable read!
December 20, 2025
The execution just wasn’t working here in my opinion, despite the enjoyable elements. The fantasy worldbuilding felt rushed and hard to track, especially when describing the seemingly epic events that led to our story. And the modern romance didn’t work much better for me, it felt one note most of the time. I wanted more than him obsessing over his ‘heartsong’ and her defeatist resisting over and over. I’ve just read some other fated tropes that do it much more convincingly. It’s like I can tell there was attempts to give them depth and emotion but it just didn’t materialize.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
4.25 🌟
While the novel has a little bit of a slow burn, once the romance and the action both pick up, it gets good and spicy. I loved the world building and the fact that the MMC and FMC are both feisty and stubborn. Interestingly, I guessed the villain but much of the other plot points surprised me. After finishing the story, I realized that there is a prequel, so I'll be going to start it next.
While the novel has a little bit of a slow burn, once the romance and the action both pick up, it gets good and spicy. I loved the world building and the fact that the MMC and FMC are both feisty and stubborn. Interestingly, I guessed the villain but much of the other plot points surprised me. After finishing the story, I realized that there is a prequel, so I'll be going to start it next.
March 24, 2024
*ARC Review*
Heartsong is a cozy and delightful combination of Paranormal Romance and Fantasy vibes set in modern San Francisco. The romance is a heartfelt (and spicy!) exploration of the feelings of being drawn to another person but knowing that giving into that draw also means risking possible heartbreak, even between fated mates.
This story depicts themes of chronic illness and traumatic pasts with care and compassion that make the story feel deep and genuine. While neither the MMC or FMC are perfect, they are able to work through their individual struggles to find a relationship that feels perfect for them, which was a delight to get to experience through their perspectives.
I’d happily recommend Heartsong to anyone who enjoys earnest love stories, monster romance, and/or spending time in fictional worlds that feel like a snuggly warm blanket (with dangers and all).
Heartsong is a cozy and delightful combination of Paranormal Romance and Fantasy vibes set in modern San Francisco. The romance is a heartfelt (and spicy!) exploration of the feelings of being drawn to another person but knowing that giving into that draw also means risking possible heartbreak, even between fated mates.
This story depicts themes of chronic illness and traumatic pasts with care and compassion that make the story feel deep and genuine. While neither the MMC or FMC are perfect, they are able to work through their individual struggles to find a relationship that feels perfect for them, which was a delight to get to experience through their perspectives.
I’d happily recommend Heartsong to anyone who enjoys earnest love stories, monster romance, and/or spending time in fictional worlds that feel like a snuggly warm blanket (with dangers and all).
Displaying 1 - 30 of 461 reviews