One star for many many reasons. It is disheartening to give such a poor review to an ARC, but I was given it in exchange for an honest review. I feel bad for this review because Dean is a debut author and I prefer to give debuts a better chance, but I have to give an honest review of the many issues I had with this book. I will be separating this review into themes (there are spoilers in the below):
World building
Characters and character development
Writing
Plot
The world building in this book was both over informative and underdeveloped. Many details of this book were inconsistent, didn’t make sense, or were never explained. For example, the dragons are asleep in a volcano and are only awake one day a year. It is never explained how the dragons at the school are awake all days of the year. It is also never explained why the dragons are only awake one day a year. The explanation for the lack of knowledge about dragons is that they have a magical shield preventing humans from going into their den. This makes no sense, as riders can communicate with dragons. So why not just ask your dragon for more information? Also, the dragons literally live in a volcano. Why would humans enter a volcano? They would, quite obviously, die before being able to enter the dragons’ den. As well, multiple times in this book a distance is referred to as “a dragon’s length”. Considering we’re given multiple dimensions for a variety of dragons, what exactly is “a dragon’s length”? Why do all the dragons have the dimensions of a square? Is there a reason their wingspan and length are all the same? There’s also been wars beyond World War 5, but never any discussion of the impact of these wars like how it impacted society and how they interact with the dragons. There’s also no discussion of the role dragons have played in society since they supposedly evolved during the triassic period, beyond their use in vaguely mentioned wars. Do leaders of major countries have dragons? Are they used as bodyguards for celebrities? Why are the only people with dragons mentioned the people at the school/Goldwings? There were so many ways we could have been given details that made the dragons feel like an integrated part of the story, but yet we were not given that.
For me, the hardest part to believe when it comes to worldbuilding was the setting. Setting a book about dragons in the PNW is kind of insane, considering the amount of forest there. I simply cannot imagine dragons flying across Portland and Seattle without any issues. During capture the flag, they’re told they can only play IN city limits. This is a HUGE liability. Why would you have dragons fighting IN the city? Every time they open their mouth, they’re likely to set something in the city on fire. How can you control a dragon if they’re attacked and drop out of the sky, wouldn’t they destroy a building? Some of these dragons are 50x50. Surely there’d be property damage during capture the flag, no matter the precautions taken. Also, the dragons having echolocation felt so ridiculous and unbelievable. How can they be stealthy if they’re constantly chirping all the time?
The characters in this book felt underdeveloped and unbelievable. My largest issue when it comes to characters is the way the MMC was written. He was, to be quite frank, disgusting. He viewed women as nothing more than sex objects and was mean to everyone around him. His inner dialogue was uncomfortable to read. He was incredibly unlikeable, and not in a way that is enjoyable. At no point was I rooting for him. In fact, I thought he was a whiny jerk. He did not deserve to have a dragon, and I felt he did not have the strength, endurance, or positive qualities to actually convince Mamba to let him be his rider at the end. That decision makes absolutely no sense, even though I saw it coming from a mile away, but I'll come to that point in the plot section of this review. He was uncurious and made many assumptions during his mission without solid evidence. Amira was solely a sex object and plot point. I think the fact that Markus didn’t have ANY friends was very telling. His focus in his relationships with other characters were all related to plot, and never for developing a relationship with others that supported his character traits and showed he was a real character. Amira was provided solely as a plot point, and I believe the only reason her character is Black is because it provided a reason for Tobias to not like Marcus. She also did not feel like a real person. Markus also never explains why he likes Amira beyond sex, but yet somehow falls in love with her. Further, the sex scenes between the two lacked chemistry and were uncomfortable to read. They felt absolutely pointless in this book, and added to meet the checkmark of people on tiktok loving spicy books instead of for relationship development. I think Amira deserved a whole lot better than Markus and I hope she dumps him in the next book. The other characters were also underdeveloped and consistently had awkward dialogue when interacting with Markus.
This leads me to the writing. I do not feel the writing encouraged plot progression or character development. The conversations between Markus and other characters felt awkward and they frequently felt underdeveloped. Conversations would happen where there would be a conflict of some sort, but then they’d immediately be solved, and Markus never had to solve any of these issues on his own. Conversations that should have been more in depth frequently felt cut short. Some sentences in this book and the way they were written made my jaw drop in shock, and not in a positive way. Some of the writing was cringe.
Plot. I have a lot of issues here, as well. The dragon lore is both under and over developed and the mission, the main point of this book, felt unbelievable. He walks in to the infirmary after failing to break a dragon and somehow his commander is like, “oh yes you failed but it’s alright because coincidentally we have this abandoned dragon and I have a mission you can do to stay in school”. There was no explanation as to why Markus was chosen for the mission and the discussion was done in front of a witness when it was supposed to be highly secretive. If there are semi trucks, why are there not planes? Couldn’t they have a plane fly overhead of the semi truck as extra protection if the obsidian is so valuable, and why weren’t they doing that the whole time? If the obsidian is so valuable, why didn’t they have plans for contingencies and setbacks, especially knowing that clans would be out to steal the, once again, very valuable obsidian? When it comes to the illegal dragon racing, once again, why are there no police planes? Wouldn’t that be a massive help in catching the racers considering there are only a few dragons used in the police force? Wouldn’t it be safer to transport the obsidian in a plane with weapons on it? Since it’s literally for military purposes? Also, the clans/gangs dynamic was never explained. What are they and why do they exist? What do they do? What’s the history between the two competing clans in this book and why are they at odds?
The explanation for the reason why the collars are used was also incredibly unbelievable. It connects neurons between the rider and dragon? That’s insane and makes no sense.
Oh I’m not done yet, either. Now I get to the main points that irritated me: the exploitation of Amira as a Black woman for plot purposes, and the way the book ended (with Markus “breaking” Mamba). Tobias explains that Amira, as a Black woman, could have been arrested for Katie’s death since she was almost found next to Katie’s mangled body. Tobias disliked Markus as he didn’t try to take Amira away from Katie’s body and because Markus didn’t consider what can happen to Black people when they interact with police. Somehow, however, the word “racism” is used once in this book, and is only used in a paragraph where Markus is trying to convince himself he stands up for “my girl” (she wasn’t his girl) and is not actually racist since he frequently “stands up” for her. Amira’s Blackness and connection to her culture is almost never relevant otherwise, except to explain why she wears headbands in traditional African patterns (which really only feels like it’s mentioned to remind the reader she’s Black). The fact that Tobias dislikes Markus primarily because Markus doesn’t understand the racism his sister faces feels like it was written in only to further the plot. Tobias had no other reason not to like Markus, but the book wouldn’t have been able to progress without a serious reason for Tobias to not want Markus around. It’s disappointing this serious reason is because of racism, and then the theme of racism is never explored. This is also interesting to me because, in the content warnings, the author expresses that there is both “implicit and explicit racism”. This implies to me that the author would explore racism, allyship, and potentially the dynamics of an interracial relationship. Yet, the ebook version I had was only 200 pages, demonstrating to me that the book had plenty of space to incorporate this theme more seriously. Following this, I felt I could not really identify any major themes in this book. In the Fast and the Furious movies, family is a MAJOR theme, yet Markus is not connected to his family. I will acknowledge family seems important to Tobias and Amira, but it’s also not explored and in fact gets shut down by Amira. I think the author may have tried to write in a theme of “you can overcome anything if you put your mind to it” with the way it ends, but considering Markus is pretty much handed his mission and his dragon, after failing to get his own dragon, he doesn’t really have to overcome much. This leads me to my most frustrating point. How was it possible for him to “break” Mamba, since Mamba burned every other person who entered his stall alive? What about Markus made Mamba trust him enough that he didn’t immediately burn him alive when Markus entered the stall? Markus does not have any remarkable character traits, a pleasant and calming personality, or any personal strength. I also knew the moment Mamba was introduced that Markus would try to break him. I expected some conflict to occur in that situation and for Markus to struggle to achieve his goal he wanted so badly, but for some reason Mamba almost immediately lets Markus collar him without issue. I was not rooting for Markus at any point during this book, and felt it was unbelievable that he was able to break one of the most volatile and dangerous dragons currently alive without issue or injury. He did not deserve to be able to break Mamba and it made absolutely no sense. I feel this is yet another thing that has been handed to him in life, with little effort or acknowledgement on his part. I think the author could have connected Markus being handed everything in life to Amira’s struggle to receive fair treatment due to racism, and that perhaps could have allowed her to explore both their characters more and their motivations. But even more than that, this is literally a fantasy book. Why did the author include racism? She got to make up the whole world and its social dynamics, yet chose to include it to further the plot. This is concerning considering there SHOULD be different social dynamics from our society in a culture where some people get to ride powerful and important dragons (and also use them as weapons), while others are not, and I feel that could have added an intriguing element to the story.
Ultimately, I feel this book is not actually ready for publication. It does not feel like this book had an editor at all. I personally think it needs a lot of work before it can be a fulsome novel. Considering the amount of low star reviews for this book, I know I’m not the only one who thinks this way. I think Dean has a lot of room for improvement and I hope to see her take the reader’s feedback seriously (while also acknowledging reviewers are for readers, not authors).