Tiddas
I had such high expectations of this book that I actually paid top dollar for it at a city bookstore because I didn't want to wait, and the blurb convinced me that it was everything I liked in a book...I couldn't wait to get started.
So it's with much real regret that I say, that to my mind, this book was nothing like the blurb "suggested".
Yes it did have all of those characters and yes it did talk about their respective lives, loves and various challenges, and their sisterhood...and I wanted to hear all about it...but for the main part it only touched ever so briefly on those things while trying (unsuccessfully) to incorporate strong messages on social and political issues regarding Indigenous Australians...albeit important messages, but not altogether within the context of this supposed work of fiction.
The story lacked structure, and kept skipping from one thing to the next without following through, leaving me wondering when the actual story was going to begin and, in fact, what it was really going to be about...
...Because of the strong emphasis throughout on real Aboriginal issues and history, I felt that the author at times, was overstating a point to the extent that it got a bit overbearing, or appeared to be pushing an agenda which was not entirely relevant to the moment, thus spoiling the moment every time.
I felt the story was fragmented, with potentially good issues being raised and then going nowhere??...left hanging with unanswered questions.
Now and again I would get excited as the story seems to pick up a bit of pace and appears to be heading in a particular direction, as though it is taking us somewhere...then it just stops dead.
Like when all the Tiddas meet up to have dinner or a Book Club meeting, and they all greet one another with comments and asides, often raising some significant issue involving one of them that promises further exploration, or "intervention" then without further explanation, it has jumped one or two days later doing something completely different...like you've missed a page or something??
You suddenly find you are into a new and totally unrelated paragraph starting on a new event with a feeling of still wanting to know the outcome of the previous event....which, by the way never does eventuate.
It's like bits of padding that don't quite fill the bill. Very frustrating and very disappointing.
I liked Izzy, she's quite a character and doesn't take things as seriously as some of her Tiddas.
All of the characters were strong and likeable in their various ways, and I think there was lots of unexplored scope for more about their individual lives without bogging it down...which is what I thought the book was going to be about...it seems to me that the author got a little too carried away with wanting to platform Aboriginal issues and forgot about the necessary structure of the promised storyline.
Given the original storyline of five Tiddas who grew up together in Mudgee, all of the above mentioned issues could easily have been more realistically incorporated into the story without losing the readers' interest. However, I think it failed to come across in the intended way and unfortunately lost the plot very early on.
As it is, it comes across as only half baked.
The upside of this book are it's strong characters and storyline, the downside is the failure to exploit those two strong points.
I have laboured over this review as for me it's pretty harsh, but I have to tell it like I see it.
A disappointing, 2*s.