Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Is It Real?: The Loch Ness Monster

Rate this book
Put on your detective hat and prepare all your investigative tools, because you've been assigned a new case to solve: the mystery of the Loch Ness Monster!

Follow along as award-winning author Candace Fleming uses all of her nonfiction tools and storytelling prowess to investigate the enduring mystery surrounding the existence of the Loch Ness Monster.

Nestled in the lush green hills of the Scotland Highlands lies Loch Ness, a deep, murky lake with a storied history. It is also the home of the Loch Ness Monster. Numerous stories and photographs by people claiming to have spotted the mysterious monster have surfaced, often gaining immediate fame. But after decades of countless expeditions, documentaries, firsthand accounts, pictures, and videos, the mystery of Nessie continues to haunt us.

Now, Sibert Award-winning author Candace Fleming invites you to become a detective and to join the race to uncover the truth. You'll learn how real-life detectives and scientists conduct their investigations to solve the greatest mysteries as the principles of the Scientific Method and more tools for boosting critical thinking and analysis are introduced. You will consider the evidence, see if you can tell the difference between fact and fiction, and maybe you can answer this age-old question about the Loch Ness monster: Is it real?

160 pages, Paperback

Published March 4, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Candace Fleming

82 books685 followers
I have always been a storyteller. Even before I could write my name, I could tell a good tale. And I told them all the time. As a preschooler, I told my neighbors all about my three-legged cat named Spot. In kindergarten, I told my classmates about the ghost that lived in my attic. And in first grade I told my teacher, Miss Harbart, all about my family's trip to Paris, France.

I told such a good story that people always thought I was telling the truth. But I wasn't. I didn't have a three-legged cat or a ghost in my attic, and I'd certainly never been to Paris, France. I simply enjoyed telling a good story... and seeing my listener's reaction.

Sure, some people might have said I was a seven-year old fibber. But not my parents. Instead of calling my stories "fibs" they called them "imaginative." They encouraged me to put my stories down on paper. I did. And amazingly, once I began writing, I couldn't stop. I filled notebook after notebook with stories, poems, plays. I still have many of those notebooks. They're precious to me because they are a record of my writing life from elementary school on.

In second grade, I discovered a passion for language. I can still remember the day my teacher, Miss Johnson, held up a horn-shaped basket filled with papier-mache pumpkins and asked the class to repeat the word "cornucopia." I said it again and again, tasted the word on my lips. I tested it on my ears. That afternoon, I skipped all the way home from school chanting, "Cornucopia! Cornucopia!" From then on, I really began listening to words—to the sounds they made, and the way they were used, and how they made me feel. I longed to put them together in ways that were beautiful, and yet told a story.

As I grew, I continued to write stories. But I never really thought of becoming an author. Instead, I went to college where I discovered yet another passion—history. I didn't realize it then, but studying history is really just an extension of my love of stories. After all, some of the best stories are true ones — tales of heroism and villainy made more incredible by the fact they really happened.

After graduation, I got married and had children. I read to them a lot, and that's when I discovered the joy and music of children's books. I simply couldn't get enough of them. With my two sons in tow, I made endless trips to the library. I read stacks of books. I found myself begging, "Just one more, pleeeeease!" while my boys begged for lights-out and sleep. Then it struck me. Why not write children's books? It seemed the perfect way to combine all the things I loved: stories, musical language, history, and reading. I couldn't wait to get started.

But writing children's books is harder than it looks. For three years I wrote story after story. I sent them to publisher after publisher. And I received rejection letter after rejection letter. Still, I didn't give up. I kept trying until finally one of my stories was pulled from the slush pile and turned into a book. My career as a children's author had begun.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
57 (20%)
4 stars
128 (45%)
3 stars
89 (31%)
2 stars
7 (2%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 74 reviews
Profile Image for BooksNCrannies.
323 reviews153 followers
January 27, 2026
The Loch Ness monster — fact or fiction? Embark on a intriguing investigation of monstrous evidence....

✏️ Review ✏️

Is It Real? The Loch Ness Monster is a fun and engaging nonfiction read. This book puts the reader right into the role of investigator, allowing for a creative and memorable exploration of the many reports, sightings, and pictures of the famed yet mysterious Loch Ness monster. Effective visuals and interesting investigator technique sections further engage readers as they travel the trail of Loch Ness monster evidence from the A.D. 700s right to the mid-2020s.

This book is fun to read yet also quite educational. I learned many intriguing historical and contemporary facets pertaining to the Loch Ness monster — some fascinating stuff indeed. Presenting pictures, scientific findings, sightings, and past and modern investigations, Is It Real? The Loch Ness Monster allows readers to examine the evidence for and against the existence of a monster lurking beneath the waters of Loch Ness. Readers will examine the evidence and decide for themselves whether or not such a monstrous beast exists.... Happy investigating!

📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚

📊 A Quick Overview 📊

👍🏼 What I Liked:
• The engaging and creative presentation of the book's subject.
• The concise overview of the Loch Ness Monster sightings and reports through the centuries.
• The effective visuals — pictures, layout, text formatting, and background graphic design — used throughout the book.

👎🏼 What I Did Not Like:
• (Can't think of anything in particular atm.)

📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚

❓ To Read or Not To Read? ❓

— Would I recommend this book? Of course!*

— To whom? To those who enjoy fun and engaging nonfiction reads about mysterious creatures/phenomena.

*(Note: I leave it up to each individual to decide the maturity and discernment level required to read the books I recommend, based on my content warnings below [in my Book Breakdown]. My content warnings [if any] should always be considered alongside my recommendations when deciding who these books are best suited for.)

📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚

📖 BOOK BREAKDOWN 📖 (Overall: 4/5)
~Fundamentals {Nonfiction Version}: (1=worst; 5=best)
— 📑 Didactics: 3/5

— 📝 Writing: 3.5/5

— 👀 Engagement: 4/5

— 🧩 Clarity: 4/5

~Content: (0=none; 1=least; 5=most)

— 🤬 Language: 0/5

— ⚔️ Violence: 0/5

— ⚠️ Sexual: 0/5

📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚

📣 Random Comments 📣

• Content note: This book is written from the perspective of an evolutionist; therefore, some timelines, dates, and discussions of past events do reflect that worldview.

📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚📚

💬 Favorite Quotes 💬

• (None)
Profile Image for Jesse.
2,899 reviews
November 3, 2025
Candace Fleming’s presentation of nonfiction is somehow always easier for me to read than anyone else’s. In this case, while you are seeing all sides of the question of the existence of the Loch Ness monster, the reader also learns the difference between types of evidence, the reliability of sources, and how to draw your own conclusions by putting them all together. Honestly, that feels more valuable than any determination that might be made about Nessie. Timely and timeless, these skills should always be kept at the forefront of our minds.
Profile Image for Barb Middleton.
2,478 reviews154 followers
December 12, 2025
The author does a great job showing research skills that get the reader to a place where they can weigh the facts and decide for themselves if the Loch Ness is real or not. She’s one of my favorite middle grade nonfiction writers!
Profile Image for Terri.
306 reviews8 followers
January 25, 2026
A page turner! Is Nessie real? The evidence is gathered and examined thoroughly. Fleming gives an excellent explanation of the sightings and various scientific explanations. The back matter contains an extensive bibliography and source notes for each chapter.
Profile Image for Meg.
532 reviews29 followers
Read
January 27, 2026
Part 2 was specifically well done (and relevant), showing conspiracies vs opinions vs facts with tangible examples of what constitutes an expert and how to draw a conclusion.
Profile Image for Erika.
1,378 reviews
March 22, 2025
I love reading about mysterious and fascinating supernatural things—UFOs, Bigfoot, ghosts, and the Loch Ness monster. I love it all! This book goes into great depth from 1933-2024 about all the research, quests, photos, videos, and fun as people search for the unknown. There seems to be proof, it’s de-bunked, then more evidence comes forward. Knowing how little we know of so many undiscovered creatures in oceans, on mountaintops, and in rainforests, never say never!!
Profile Image for Samantha.
2,081 reviews43 followers
March 31, 2025
I have always been intrigued by the world's unsolved mysteries. I picked up this book at my school's book fair and dove right into it. This was more detail than I had previously been able to read on the subject, and being a middle grades book, kept the details easy and concise. I liked the style of this one and how it gave investigation tips as well. It was educational on multiple fronts.
Profile Image for C.J. Daley.
Author 5 books148 followers
December 9, 2024
Huge thanks to Scholastic and Scholastic Focus for the physical ARC! So cool to have one of these.

This is really cool. It’s set up as if you are the investigator, and with the help of your Black Swan Scientific Investigations Handbook you are prepared to research the existence of a prehistoric beast! Comb through the evidence, read through the witness accounts, and try hard not to form an opinion! I can see this being such a huge hit with kids and if their imagination is good, there’ll be no end to the fun they can have.

For me, the actual scientific research included was my favorite. From the first sighting all the way to the latest in 2024, the author has delivered an opinion free dissection of what’s been seen and recorded. Whether you’re a believer, or want to stick with the science, the information is so interesting that I think both sides can read for enjoyment.

Is it a prehistoric plesiosaur, that not only survived the last 66 million years undetected, but also survived the fact that the loch was frozen 18,000 years ago? Or is it a new species that has evolved since the loch thawed and perhaps is unrelated? Perhaps a giant eel? Perhaps even something invertebrate that wouldn’t leave huge bones behind to be found?

And while there is no concrete evidence to push forward as proof, there’s certainly nothing definitively proving it’s not real or possible… and if it’s not, why do people keep spotting it?

https://fanfiaddict.com/review-is-it-...
Profile Image for Amanda.
1,323 reviews21 followers
July 13, 2026
I read this in 1 sitting because it was a very accessible look into the history of the Loch Ness Monster. The book is structured as an investigation with the reader as the detective, and I think it's a great way to introduce kids into the research process and how to use critical thinking skills when examining the credibility of information.
Profile Image for Kennedy.
1,220 reviews48 followers
June 2, 2026
This book is about the Loch Ness Monster, but it’s also about critically thinking about things. This is a great book for teaching kids about viewing media with a healthy skepticism.
96 reviews1 follower
October 13, 2026
I would recommend this book to tweens. It had a very interesting format where it teaches children what to question/investigate the evidence/information that is presented to them. The reader needs to determine if it's fact and question the integrity or the reliability of the source. With this format it can be applied to other topics (not just if the Loch Ness Monster is real) and give children the basis to question topics for themselves.

In summary when investigating any information, the process includes looking at the evidence, drawing conclusions, and determining if the stories/information appear reasonable.

The first sighting of the Loch Ness Monster was in April 1933. Aldie and John MacKay were driving by when she first spotted a disturbance 3/4 of a mile offshore. It rolled and plunged into the water for a minute. It resembled a whale. Its final plunge created waves that were large enough to be from a ship. They reported this to the water bailiff who was also a reporter, so he wrote about it for the paper.

The second sighting was by George Spicer on July 22, 1933. He also was driving by with his wife and spotted a long snakelike creature(30 ft) covered in elephant skin crossing the road. Its neck was high in the air and turned to look at them. It's head was small and it carried a lamb in its mouth. He wrote a letter to the newspaper about his encounter. Scientist/writer Rupert Gould interviewed Spicer. Gould noticed that Spicer's story sounded like the dinosaur diplodocus in King Kong.

The third sighting was by Hugh Gray on November 12, 1933. While walking he saw something emerging from the water. He didn't see a head and there was considerable movement from the tail. He took 5 photos. The first 4 photos were blurry, but the 5th showed the monster. I personally believed the photo was to blurry and to difficult to reveal anything. The newspaper the Daily Record thought there was something, so it published the photo. Readers couldn't make out anything but other newspapers across the UK published the photo. Immediately people wanted more news, reporters were sent to the area, film crew, 100s of boy scouts, and outdoorsmen arrived.

In December 1933 big game hunter Mamaduke Wetherell arrived in Scottland. He was hired by the Daily Mail to track down the Loch Ness Monster. Radio broadcasters and newspaper reports covered Wetherell. He insisted he needed to scout it out without others there. He found footprints - 9 inches across and 2 inches deep. Wetherell made plaster casts of the footprints and shipped them to The Natural History Museum for identification. The scientists identified the footprints as hippopotamus. Since hippos don't live in Scotland, the prints were made by a mounted specimen. It made sense that a big game hunter like Wetherell would have such an object in his home and carried out this hoax. He denied it. He insisted that someone else made those tracks there for him to find. Why didn't Wetherell recognize those tracks? He spent years in Africa where hippos live, and he claimed to be a highly skilled tracker. He wouldn't answer the question instead he snuck out of Loch Ness at night and returned to his home in London and was to embarrassed to appear in public.

On April 21, 1934, a London surgeon was driving along the road. Dr. Robert Kenneth Wilson decided to get out of the car to stretch his legs when he noticed a commotion on the loch's surface 200 yds from shore. It was the head of a strange animal rising out of the water. He went back to his car and grabbed his camera. The 4th photo taken(known as the Surgeon's photograph) showed a long neck, curving forward and ending in a small head. That portion was reflected in the water. Behind the neck was something possibly breaking the surface of the water(monster's back)? The MD sent the photo and a letter detailing the story to the Daily Mail. The editor published the letter and a cropped version of the photo. Many people then believed a monster lived in the Loch Ness since he was a surgeon - professional man bound by science. Based on the image - the arched neck and small head people believed it to be a plesiosaur.

Then the book switches to helping the reader learn about evidence.
-Evidence is the testimony, signs, and objects that make someone believe something is true.
-Evidence is gathered to prove a fact. It could include footprints, fingerprints, samples of hair and blood, statements from witnesses, photos. One piece of evidence is not enough to prove the truth.

There are two kinds of evidence-
1) Direct Evidence-straightforward proof or disproof a fact. It can include confessions, video or audio, eyewitness testimony, footprints, fingerprints, hair and blood samples, photos. It is more than circumstantial evidence.

2) Circumstantial Evidence-A type of evidence that implies something happened but does not directly prove it. It requires the investigator to draw their own conclusions. The investigator must use questioning and reasoning to connect the evidence to the event or claim. This evidence is not as reliable as direct evidence.

A person can have evidence without having proof. Proof is when something is shown completely to be true through data, information, and fact. Proof establishes certainty and truth beyond a reasonable doubt.

Physical evidence are clues that can be seen or held.

Then the book applies the definitions above to the Loch Ness monster to determine if it is real. First start by looking at the physical evidence - The photos taken by Hugh Gray and Dr. Wilson. The plaster foot even though it is physical evidence is ruled out because Scottland is not a place where hippos live. Then ask is Wetherell believable? He loved attention and being famous and finding the Loch Ness monster would make him a celebrity around the world. Did he have access to a hippo foot? When searching on the computer there is a picture of a hippo foot ashtray once owned by Wetherell. This is evidence but not proof. It is impossible to have him confess now because he died. Gray's photo is poor quality but looking at it with an open mind reveals the phenomenon called pareidolia. It can reveal seeing more than one image in an item.

Pareidolia is a trick of the human brain where a person sees something significant in a random image. When pulling up on the computer the Surgeon's Photograph it is not the photo that was published in the Daily Mail. The photo on the computer shows the shoreline. With the shoreline the object appears smaller and therefore not a monster size. The Daily Mail photo was cropped to make it look more dramatic, skew its size, making the object appear bigger than it actually was.

When looking up Robert Kenneth Wilson + hoax on the computer, a newspaper article appears from the Sunday Telegraph from March 13, 1994. The article was regarding 93 yr old Christian Spurling(stepson of Wetherell). The stepson admitted that Wetherell resented the Daily Mail after they made him a laughingstock over the hippo tracks. He wanted revenge. Spurling and his stepbrother Ian Wetherell built a model monster. They created the head and neck of the monster and attached it to a windup toy submarine. Then Ian and his father drove to Loch Ness and found an inlet with tiny ripples that could be made to look like a full-size wave. Ian took a few photos before Marmaduke destroyed the model and it sunk in the lake. The photos were then given to Wetherell's hunting friend Maurice Chambers who gave it to Dr. Wilson. Dr. Wilson agreed to do it because he loved practical jokes.

It's helpful for kids to have these definitions when researching.
When a person sees something, it doesn't necessarily mean that it is true.
Fact: Something you can verify.
Opinion: A personal belief
Assumption: Something that is accepted as truth without proof. Assumptions might be true, they should always be questioned and doublechecked.
Lies: An untruth that is told on purpose.
Confusing the above may lead to the wrong conclusions.

Also important to know that human memory is faulty. Humans perceive things selectively. They miss important details, mix up other people's descriptions with their own, and sometimes add events that didn't happen. They speak what they think is the truth without realizing their memories are inaccurate.

When going back to John and Aldie MacKay's account that was written by Rupert Gould. Gould was the scientist and writer who talked with George Spicer. When Gould talked to Aldie her description was that she caught sight about 100 yds(length of a football field) a "violent commotion". She thought it was two ducks fighting. 100 yds is pretty far away. Other objects mistaken for the Loch Ness are Cormorant(bird), seals, logs, swimming ponies, and a dead whale.

Then she describes the commotion ending and she sees a big wake as if a ship passed by. Then in the middle of the Loch about 450 yards away(more than 3 football fields) two black humps moved in a line, the rear one larger moving in a forward rolling motion(like a whale or porpoise about 20 ft long). It continued to swim, then it swam in a half circle, and sank suddenly with a considerable amount of commotion. She said she didn't immediately report it to the newspapers and didn't want their names mentioned in the Inverness Courier article because she didn't want people to think that that they were self-advertising for their hotel.

Her first report and the second report are very different. Is it because of faulty memory or is she mixing up the details of her encounter with those of George Spicers? She sounded truthful but we will not know why the story changed. When given inconsistent stories their reliability must be questioned.

Experts - person who has skills, experience, or knowledge about a particular subject. They can explain information, supply facts, provide new data and studies, and an unique perspective.

People who appear to be an expert may not be one particularly if the topic is science or law where we do not know much about. They may manipulate technical sounding language and data. Fake experts are good at making nonsense sound logical. Good investigators make sure experts are reliable before contacting them.

When reaching out to an expert think carefully about the questions you want to ask. Ask for information you can't find anywhere else. In this case interviewing a limnologist would help. A limnologist is a scientist that studies lakes and examines the lake's biology, chemistry, and physics.

Principle of Occam's Razor-the simplest answer is often the correct one. It doesn't mean it is always the correct answer. Good investigators look at all the evidence. They should start with the answers that require the fewest assumptions.

With George Spicer's sighting it was the only one where he claimed to see Nessie up close and on land. He also was the 1st person to make the connection between the monster and a prehistoric creature. Spicer said it looked very much like the dinosaur-type creature in King Kong. Spicer's description was almost identical to the King Kong creature - rounded back, arched neck, and small head. The men in the movie monster's mouth look like a sheep just like Spicer's beast had a sheep in its mouth. Spicer almost exactly re-created this scene from the movie. Spicer said the monster crossed the road from left to right just like the monster did in King Kong. The movie monster had elephant skin just like Spicer's monster. In the movie the creatures' feet are not seen just like Spicer did not see the monster's feet either. Mrs. Spicer backed up her husband's story so were they both lying? Spicer got out of the car and looked for physical evidence and didn't see anything. Would he have seen plants trampled? There was no solid evidence to prove or disprove the story - only have circumstantial evidence.

Conclusions: based on decisions, emotions, past experiences, personal beliefs, and wishful thinking

Solid Conclusions should be:
1. Informed - based on good questions and a close examination of the answers
2. Logical - makes sense on the evidence gathered
3. Objective - free of opinions, assumptions, lies, and wishful thinking

To make a strong conclusion:
1. Look for connections - where does the evidence agree or disagree?
Have numerous eyewitnesses
2. Look for cause and effect - Has one event influenced another? Has one witness's testimony affected another's?
3. Compare your evidence against reliable sources.
4. Check your conclusions for assumptions, opinions, and wishful thinking.
5. Verify that your conclusion makes sense with the evidence you've uncovered
Conclusions that do not agree with the evidence will be weak
6. The strongest conclusion is one that makes the most sense and is based on the best evidence.

You may decide that a conclusion can't be reached because you need more evidence.

According to the Official Loch Ness Monster Sighting Register, there have been 1,157(now more) glimpses of Nessie. Most of these occurred after 1960. None in the 1940s because of WWII. When the war started in 1939 the British turned to fighting and away from Nessie.

In 1934, Sir Edward Montain(1st scientist) paid 20 men to stand at different locations around the loch. Each had binoculars and a camera. They watched for 2 wks in July. My question is why not year-round instead of 2 wks in July? More likely to miss Nessie because only collecting evidence for two weeks out of the year. The result was an ordinary photo showing some unusual waves. Sir Mountain claimed it was made by the monster.

Dr. Constance Whyte's patients told her tales of Nessie. She collected accounts of sightings and compiled them into a book - More Than a Legend: The Story of the Loch Ness Monster. The 1957 book reignited the public's fascination. She identified her witnesses by initials only. She left out dates, places, and times of sightings which made it impossible for researchers to verify. Witnesses were describing many different monsters. Could there be more than one kind?

In 1964, the Loch Ness Investigation Bureau used movie cameras to survey the water located in 12 places around the shore running from dawn to dusk, seven days a week, for 5 months a year. In 1974, after finding no monsters, the group disbanded.

In 1969, an American inventor and adventure, Dan Taylor brought a one man submarine he built to Loch Ness. It was 20 ft long and called the Viperfish. It could go faster than 8 miles an hr and could go near the bottom. He thought on one of the first runs the monster kicked up a large cloud of silt. He made 45 dives that summer. Unfortunately, there was limited visibility due to murkiness. In 1973, other submarines tried. In 1994 and 1995 tourist businesses tried to but the murky, silted water made visibility difficult.

Between 1958 and 1970, four separate expeditions occurred using sonar. Sonar was developed by the military to research underwater environments. In 1968, the University of Birmingham detected two large moving underwater objects. They returned the following year and found nothing.

From 1970s to the 1990s researchers used scoops, dredges, and core samples to find skeletal remains. No monster bones were found. Researchers did discover an invasive species of American flatworm thought to have been brought in on hunting equipment. What was discovered was that the deep, even, undisturbed sediment on the floor is a delicate and stratified geologic record of the region that goes back to the time of the glaciers. All dredging stopped. The lack of bones doesn't mean that Nessie isn't real. The monster may be boneless like a snail or octopus. Then the remains would be scavenged by fish or birds. Exposed bones would be dissolved and crumble in the slightly acidic environment of the loch.

Dr. Roy Mackal, a biochemist from the University of Chicago concluded that 90% of all sightings are identified as mistakes, misinterpretations, or fraud. Witnesses mistook objects or animals for Nessie. Birds, otters, dolphins, and seals are seen in the Loch. Otter's necks and heads resemble those of the plesiosaurs.

Dr. Neil Gemmell, a geneticist from the University of Otago in New Zealand tested the genetic material of DNA present in the water. He wouldn't have to capture any creatures but use water samples. He would collect small particles shed by the creatures and then sequence them. He would compare the DNA to an international data bank to figure out the species.

In June 2018, for 2 wks his team collected hundreds of water samples. The researchers found 3,000 species including fish, deer, pigs, birds, humans, bacteria, and eels. Lots of eels - most every sample had European eel. They found no evidence of any reptile DNA - no lizards, snakes, and turtles. They found no amphibians - frogs and toads.

Data scientist Floe Foxon examined Gemmell theory that maybe the monster was an eel. Foxon studied the number of eels(20K) caught in Loch Ness and other lakes in Europe - eels length, weight, and frequency of catches to calculate the odds of finding a giant one. It came to 0. Even finding one 3 feet long was low so the eel theory was discarded.

In August 2023, 100 volunteers from around the world were on land(17 locations) and in boats with hydrophones listening underwater and using surveying equipment and sonar. Drones were used with infrared cameras. Three hundred people monitored live stream. Researchers heard strange noises beneath the surface. A volunteer photographed a large shadow circling the water. A few sightings of hump shaped objects moving in and out of the loch and an eel-like creature on the surface. None could be verified as Nessie. Some could be explained and others couldn't.

*** In summary, no definitive evidence has been found, and people continue to look and see what they believe to be Nessie.














.




31 reviews
January 22, 2025
From a middle school teacher’s perspective, this book feels like a win for several reasons: (1) It’s under 150 pages and super accessible, (2) it’s about a topic that students are inherently intrigued by, and (3) it is written in a non-traditional format that is ripe for discussion, reflection, and engagement. For anyone looking to introduce more information literacy into their own lives or the lives of others, this is a fabulous (and fun) place to start!

It also seems like this might become part of a series, which I would love to see.

I’m going to have some of my students read it this month and will be curious to see how they engage with it! Stay tuned!
Profile Image for Ms. Yingling.
4,729 reviews660 followers
September 23, 2024
E ARC provided by Edelweiss Plus

Starting in 1933, there were a number of people who have reported seeing "something" in Loch Ness. Some of these, like Aldie and John MacKay, seemed more credible, since they alerted not the news media, but rather the water bailiffs, when they saw a "commotion". Others, like Marmaduke Wetherell, staged things like footprints that were made with a hippopotamus foot ashtray! Some people, like George Spicer, might have been influenced by movies. The interesting thing about this Scholastic Focus book is that Fleming invites readers to look at the different occurrences in a critical manner, and teaches them how people's thinking can be influenced by things like popular culture. This is somewhat similar to her Crash From Outer Space or Curse of the Mummy in that it debunks myths, but adds much more information about investigative techniques than these two books. It talks about different kinds of evidence, and even walks the reader through how the early stories might be critically assessed. It helps that there is a ton of information presented from lots of sources; I didn't know that there weren't any sightings during WWII, or that there was an exhaustive study done in 2023. I did have my own theory about whey there weren't really many sightings before 1933 even though there was a road around the loch; before that time, there might have been more horse drawn vehicles, which might have lead to fewer travelers, or one's who had more important things to pay attention to than roiling water! In the end, Flemind presents evidence of some very good hoaxes, although it seems unlikely that there has ever been a creature living in the loch. This will be well received by my students, and is more middle grade friendly in the formatting than Siegel's recent Loch Ness Discovered.
Profile Image for Alicia.
9,331 reviews167 followers
April 24, 2025
This one is set apart from others that can be compared to it (if this becomes a series in some way) that take an event or topic and give the background in a bite-sized but information-laden narrative nonfiction for middle grade. The reason this one is different is that Fleming is presenting the information but putting the reader in a "meta" investigator role where Fleming is teaching them about fact, fiction, evidence, testimony, and research guide a reader to determining whether the topic (in this case the Loch Ness Monster) is real or not.

So I doubly love the book and Fleming in general because of the approach. I think the seed was planted when she wrote books like Crash from Outer Space: Unraveling the Mystery of Flying Saucers, Alien Beings, and Roswell and The Curse of the Mummy: Uncovering Tutankhamun's Tomb.

I love when I can learn new things and this one did it.

"There is a scientific reason for seeing all this. It is a phenomenon called pareidolia. Pareidolia is a trick of the human brain in which a person sees something significant in a random image. It's the reason people have seen [picture] A teddy bear on the surface of Mars [picture] A face in the dish sink."
Profile Image for Ryan.
1,023 reviews
April 30, 2025
Nessie, or the Loch Ness Monster, is probably the most famous of sea monsters/cryptids. Ever since its brief mentions in the 1930s, theories & sightings of its existence significantly increased in the following decades afterwards. Loch Ness has become integrated into pop culture with its increasing popularity as a tourist spot for anyone lucky to catch a glimpse of Nessie. Despite this, there has been many debates as to whether or not such a monster can exist. Candace Fleming takes readers on a detective history to learn about the origins and debate that is the Loch Ness Monster.

Relatively short, Fleming does get into thorough details in the history of the Loch Ness Monster. She covers many points, including certain aspects, I never heard of related to Nessie: origins, witnesses, the infamous photograph, research expeditions, and much more. The book is written like a detective case being reviewed, I'm sure for the kids, but it does emphasize the mystery of Loch Ness. What I did enjoy was the brief geographic history of Loch Ness, the manipulation of an original testimony of a witness, the recent studies on the water samples, and the notoriety of the first King Kong movie. And while the author doesn't say it outright, it seem to imply that Nessie is unlikely to be a plesiosaur let alone even exist. Fleming encourages readers to keep researching and do a proper investigation while using Occam's razor to truly make a new discovery about Nessie, as many are still invested in uncovering the truth. I, for one, find this book to be quite refreshing on the subject and very informative for those who want to start a light dive into the famous sea monster.
Profile Image for Natalie.
319 reviews10 followers
March 2, 2025
“Is It Real? The Loch Ness Monster” does two things well. First, it tells the story of the modern history of the Loch Ness Monster (aka Nessie). Second, it guides the reader through the process of analyzing the evidence for the case that Nessie exists.

On the one hand this is a history book, with Nessie sightings placed firmly in the context of the time. For example, I did not know that modern Loch Ness Monster sightings began shortly after the release of the movie “King Kong” which featured…dinosaurs with long necks.

On the other hand this is a book about evidence analysis using a fun mystery. In the discussion about the influence of “King Kong,” author Candace Fleming asks the reader to consider the potential influence of the movie on people who experienced sightings. While it isn’t a step-by-step guide, Fleming asks key questions about the evidence for the reader to consider. In an age where we need to develop critical analysis skills, this book is an excellent vehicle.

This book is great for upper elementary and middle school readers. It would be appropriate for high school students who are interested in the mystery of the Loch Ness Monster.

I received an advance review copy for free from Netgalley and Scholastic Focus, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Profile Image for Marinda (rindasreads).
546 reviews34 followers
February 24, 2025
This book is a fantastic middle-grade offering for kids who can't get enough of mysteries and science. In Is It Real? The Loch Ness Monster, Candice Fleming not only examines every facet of the case for and against the existence of Nessie, she also uses the case as a way to teach readers how to sift through evidence to reach their own conclusions.

I loved all the pictures and the layout of the book. From medieval illustrations to pictures of scientists searching Loch Ness in 2023, every facet of the mystery was outlined and illustrated as a "clue" to the mystery Fleming invites her readers to solve. The use of second person "you" language was a fun change from the normal third person voice, allowing me to really become part of the investigation. I'm excited to hand this one off to my kids, especially my curious-minded third grader.

Some parts of the book didn't engage me as much as others, and I thought the ending felt abrupt, but overall I did enjoy this book and I hope there will be more "Is It Real" mystery cases in the future!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me an advanced copy to review. I was not required to post a positive review and all opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Debra.
2,165 reviews
October 5, 2025
I listened to this book in my car using Hoopla from my public library account.

WOW! I am so happy I have listened to it and intend to buy it in hardcover for my two elementary schools now! This book lays out how to do research in a way I love. The accumulation of resources, the notetaking, the casefiles, and the recognition of phony versus provable as a reader is actually engaged with this book is so needed right now in schools. I cannot wait to get the book and delve into the vocabulary used to guide the readers on how scientific study is completed, how theories are going to require data to prove, and how data can be mismanaged or lost (as in the lifetimes of the original folks studying Nessie) is simply riveting.

I am not usually that interested in Loch Ness (though I do love a good story), but I was hooked from the beginning on this one. (Now we need Area 51, Big Foot, and UFO's.)
Profile Image for Pamela.
923 reviews7 followers
June 19, 2026
The narrator takes you on a scientific journey to determine if the Loch Ness monster is most likely real or not real. Introduced as a case file addressed to “you,” the reader, the author gives us photos and eyewitness accounts to review first. Part Two has “you” investigating by considering the strength of the evidence, pointing out pitfalls like wishful thinking, comparing reports, examining the trustworthiness of the witnesses, consulting w experts, and considering what’s most likely by discussing Occam’s Razor. Part Three concludes w modern scientists’ attempts to proof the existence (or falsehood) of the Loch Ness monster once and for all. Read this book for an excellent examination of the persistent belief that this lake may be home to a yet-unidentified creature or to learn how investigators study artifacts and people’s experiences to determine likely reasons for observed phenomenons.
Profile Image for Julia Bilderback.
224 reviews4 followers
July 19, 2026
This author discredits herself in the book by telling readers to be aware of the credentials of people, and this woman has no credentials relating to this topic. Also it is very obvious that she cherry picked examples to support the conclusion she wanted readers to come to. Cherry picking is one of the worst things a person can do if they want to be taken seriously. She picked all things that had already been debunked, but none of the info that hadn't been. Plus she just quickly mentions the longer history of the monster in the Loch, but then entirely ignores it. This book was designed to teach kids critical thinking, but it was written by a person that clearly lacks those skills herself. This book is a great example of just how anyone can write a book even if they shouldn't and lack all skill in the subject matter. Avoid this book and from this book I would say avoid the author entirely. She proved herself untrustworthy and manipulative.
Profile Image for Miriam Kahn.
2,237 reviews75 followers
March 12, 2025
For kids of all ages.

Have you ever wondered if the Loch Ness Monster is real? How would we know? What steps would you take to learn the truth?

Candace Fleming’s “Is It Real” is very clever and creative. It takes on the myth and investigates it step by step.

Candace Fleming provides newspaper accounts, scientific studies, photographs, and more to provide clues as to the Loch Ness Monster’s existence.

Follow the case or investigation by writing the clues and answers in your journal. Compare your conclusions with those in the book. In the end, you decide “Is It Real?”

This creative non-fiction book is geared for tweens and teens. Perfect for groups of kids. No guidance from parents needed!

Thanks to Scholastic Focus http://www.scholastic.com for an ARC to read and review.
Profile Image for Shella.
1,222 reviews2 followers
August 5, 2025
If you have a younger reluctant reader- esp. for nonfiction- give this title a go. I hope this becomes a series exploring these topics. This is broken into short chapters with terrific nonfiction text elements. It models critical thinking and evaluation of sources in a way that keep a young reader’s attention. Flemming is a master author for a wide range of ages. Nonfiction is usually ignored for Newbery consideration. I hope the committee gives this title a hard look and a nod. I would highly recommend this title for a classroom read or book club. So much more interesting than dry articles that have seem to be taking over reading curriculums. This title is unique in the fact that it will be interesting to all levels of readers.
Profile Image for Dawn.
1,629 reviews13 followers
January 4, 2026
Candace Fleming’s latest is all about the elusive Loch Ness Monster. This book examines the various sightings, expeditions, and “evidence” surrounding the monster. The book is narrated by a fictional investigator from the Black Swan Scientific Investigation team who goes through the various sightings while relaying investigation techniques. Direct vs circumstantial evidence, facts vs assumptions, expert testimony, and Occam’s razor are all explained in relation to the Loch Ness monster. Many theories are disproven, but the book concludes by asking readers what they think. Backmatter includes a bibliography, source notes, and photo credits. A great book to teach kids about investigative principles!
955 reviews8 followers
July 14, 2026
Written in 2nd person this non-fiction book challenges the reader to become a detective. Presenting facts, evidence and information about Scotland's Loch Ness monster conspiracy the reader has to decide if Nessie is real.
The text structure is well done with information on how to read a case file, considering if evidence is real (one piece of evidence does not suffice) or fabricated. The images and captions help move the text along and are engaging.
The topic is super mysterious and spans decades so the reader is constantly questioning what they read.
I loved this format and topic. Great way to introduce and engage students in a non-fiction topic.
Recommended: grades 4+
Topics: detective, Scotland, Fact vs Fiction, Loch Ness Monster, Tools of the science world
Profile Image for Chrissy.
1,021 reviews18 followers
March 1, 2025
I did not expect to find an investigation of the Loch Ness Monster to be so informative, but I was pleasantly surprised. The author uses the investigation as an opportunity to teach readers how to analyze information, from media sources, from online sources, and from personal accounts. This feels like an important skill for everyone. I appreciate that the digital searches made in the book are specifically of the organizations database rather than the internet at large. I'm not sure young readers will pick up the difference, but I noticed that searches were from a dependable source. Using Nessie as a topic is a great way to grab student's attention while imparting important skills.
Profile Image for Beverly.
6,332 reviews4 followers
October 14, 2025
This book helps the young reader be the researcher in investigating whether the LNM is real or not.
The author provided some of the stories of eyewitness "sightings" of the monster, from the 1930s to the present time. She outlines numerous scientific studies of the lake and searches for giant creatures. She also includes (as a sort of handbook) tips and facts to help the young researcher. In the end, she does not state whether the LNM is real or not, she allows the reader/researcher to draw their own conclusions. Backmatter includes an extensive bibliography and source notes for each chapter. The book lacks an index, and probably could have used one.
Profile Image for Jill.
299 reviews
July 23, 2025
*Read this for a children's literature class. By their nature, unsolved mysteries are already super fascinating, and the story of the Loch Ness monster is one of the most well-known. As soon as I finished reading, my mind was brainstorming how it could be used in a classroom setting because of the format in which it is written. Fleming sets up the story as if the reader is an investigator trying to analyze evidence and draw conclusions. The concise writing and shorter length make this so accessible to middle-grade students.
Profile Image for Tracie.
1,883 reviews47 followers
April 4, 2025
Casting the reader as a private investigator of paranormal activity, this book engagingly walks you through the research process and challenges you to challenge your assumptions as you try to determine whether the Loch Ness Monster is fact or fiction.

These kinds of skills--being able to vet information and identify biases--are more important than ever these days. Maybe adults should read this too.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 74 reviews