What do you think?
Rate this book
Catriona Winters #1
A Skeleton in Every House
Suffocated by the constraints of high society and yearning to prove herself as a journalist, Catriona Winters heads to the scene of a shocking crime: a marquess found slain, his body drifting off the Limehouse docks.
Her reporting throws her directly across the path of Scotland Yard inspector Thomas Marlowe, who is intent on keeping the details of his inquiry out of the headlines. But Catriona is no stranger to the murder victim, and as she delves ever deeper into the circumstances surrounding his death, she discovers a scheme of blackmail that creeps from the darkest slums to the parlours of the aristocracy.
When a second killing shocks London, leaving no one above suspicion, she and Marlowe must set aside their rivalry to unmask the killer before he strikes again—and before Catriona makes herself his next victim.
Her reporting throws her directly across the path of Scotland Yard inspector Thomas Marlowe, who is intent on keeping the details of his inquiry out of the headlines. But Catriona is no stranger to the murder victim, and as she delves ever deeper into the circumstances surrounding his death, she discovers a scheme of blackmail that creeps from the darkest slums to the parlours of the aristocracy.
When a second killing shocks London, leaving no one above suspicion, she and Marlowe must set aside their rivalry to unmask the killer before he strikes again—and before Catriona makes herself his next victim.
379 pages, Kindle Edition
Published April 1, 2024
446 people are currently reading
1801 people want to read
About the author
Isabella Duke
2 books63 followersIsabella Duke lives and writes in Sydney, Australia. For news on forthcoming books, visit her online at www.isabella-duke.com or connect with her on Instagram at isabelladuke.author.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews
January 31, 2025
I really really really wanted to like this book. But it collapsed under the weight of the unlikable heroine. Kitty is rude and careless with people's feelings throughout the entirety of this book. The only people she's civil to are her father and her best friend. Everyone else is treated to her biting remarks, putdowns and flippant replies. It's like she's incapable of having a conversation with anyone that doesn't involve insulting them and highlighting how much she's not like other girls. She's also completely reckless at every given turn. In a time where most women, especially women of a certain station, were still being escorted by men when out, she's traipsing unaccompanied all over the city getting into trouble. Should she go to the docks alone? An opium den? Stroll through the city at night alone? The answer is yes to all of those apparently. When anyone expresses concern over her welfare she becomes indignant as though crime doesn't exist for women in London in the late 19th century. She frequently withholds evidence in a murder investigation from the police because she feels superior as she knows best. Her need to solve the crime seems born of her own hubris rather than any sense of justice. She's supposed to be a journalist but only writes one story. She even smokes opium with a gangster randomly on a day when no one knows where she is just because he asks. For context this is like going to a crackhouse to ask a gangster questions, smoking some crack because he really wants you to try it, and then waking up later and being like 'Oh look at the time. I should get going'
The part about about her mother also rubbed me the wrong way. There is an underlying sense of shame that seeps into every thought she has about her. That shame coupled with her constant remarking on her eyes are dark but her complexion pale gave me the ick and seemed to be whispering that she was ashamed her mother was creole and that she didn't have the bright blue eyes her father did. There was something buried in the mother storyline that I just did not like. Something beyond her cause of death. Just my opinion but like I said it rubbed me the wrong way.
As for every man being endlessly captivated with her? I didn't see it. She was mean to everyone and they all were still so drawn to her. The plot was decent and the mystery compelling enough but even an ounce of likability could have gone a long way in making this character someone I could root for. Instead I found myself gritting my teeth and rolling my eyes every time she opened her mouth or did something stupid.
The part about about her mother also rubbed me the wrong way. There is an underlying sense of shame that seeps into every thought she has about her. That shame coupled with her constant remarking on her eyes are dark but her complexion pale gave me the ick and seemed to be whispering that she was ashamed her mother was creole and that she didn't have the bright blue eyes her father did. There was something buried in the mother storyline that I just did not like. Something beyond her cause of death. Just my opinion but like I said it rubbed me the wrong way.
As for every man being endlessly captivated with her? I didn't see it. She was mean to everyone and they all were still so drawn to her. The plot was decent and the mystery compelling enough but even an ounce of likability could have gone a long way in making this character someone I could root for. Instead I found myself gritting my teeth and rolling my eyes every time she opened her mouth or did something stupid.
December 22, 2022
I am not going to leave a gushy review. I am going to leave a very matter of fact review.
For a debut novel, this book was far beyond anything I expected. It was well written. It was period perfect. I could vividly imagine every scene and setting and conversation and even facial expressions. Each thing was well portrayed without being overly wordy or excessive. The grammar and punctuation were spot on.
The depiction of what happened to Catriona's mother was never fully fleshed out but it didn't need to be. You just knew what happened.
The detective in the story was very human, not sweet or overly hard. Catriona's father was distant and unrelatable but I believe he was meant to be portrayed as such.
I think some people might read this and hope that Catriona will end up with Nate, but that's not what I was (or am) hoping for. I can't see Catriona being a docile stay at home wife. I am much rather hoping that Kitty and Marlowe will end up together. I guess future books will see this played out..... I'm hoping!
I highly recommend this book. It's not a cozy. It's a true (although fictional!) murder mystery. Loved it.
I received an ARC of this book and am leaving my review voluntarily.
For a debut novel, this book was far beyond anything I expected. It was well written. It was period perfect. I could vividly imagine every scene and setting and conversation and even facial expressions. Each thing was well portrayed without being overly wordy or excessive. The grammar and punctuation were spot on.
The depiction of what happened to Catriona's mother was never fully fleshed out but it didn't need to be. You just knew what happened.
The detective in the story was very human, not sweet or overly hard. Catriona's father was distant and unrelatable but I believe he was meant to be portrayed as such.
I think some people might read this and hope that Catriona will end up with Nate, but that's not what I was (or am) hoping for. I can't see Catriona being a docile stay at home wife. I am much rather hoping that Kitty and Marlowe will end up together. I guess future books will see this played out..... I'm hoping!
I highly recommend this book. It's not a cozy. It's a true (although fictional!) murder mystery. Loved it.
I received an ARC of this book and am leaving my review voluntarily.
January 5, 2023
“One wonders why I’m needed at all,”
“For the pleasure of your company, of course.”
“My company or my revolver?”
A skeleton in Every House will guide you in the mist of Victorian London while we follow Catriona Winters, a young woman eager to prove herself a good journalist.
The beginning was a bit slow to get in, there are a few pre-established relationships that since are pre-book were difficult to get attached to, but once assessed to the environment the story flows.
Kitty is one of those characters that when is not looking for troubles, troubles follow her. She will find her personal life unexpectedly intertwined with the investigation.
“Because, Miss Winters, you make yourself quite impossible to ignore.”
In this dark London it’s not all murder and blood, there’s also a tiny bit of space for romance. We have a few eligible suitors. One you’ll notice straight away, his presence is a chaotic magnet, my heart is all team Inspector Marlow (which my mind cast as Henry Cavill’ Sherlock version), every times he and Kitty were almost brushing hands I was all heart eyes for them.
“So you are to stay in London?”
“I am. Are you sorry to hear it?”
“No. No, quite the opposite of that.”
If you’re a fan of show as ‘Miss Scarlet and the Duke’ or Miss Fisher murder mystery this may be the book for you
“For the pleasure of your company, of course.”
“My company or my revolver?”
A skeleton in Every House will guide you in the mist of Victorian London while we follow Catriona Winters, a young woman eager to prove herself a good journalist.
The beginning was a bit slow to get in, there are a few pre-established relationships that since are pre-book were difficult to get attached to, but once assessed to the environment the story flows.
Kitty is one of those characters that when is not looking for troubles, troubles follow her. She will find her personal life unexpectedly intertwined with the investigation.
“Because, Miss Winters, you make yourself quite impossible to ignore.”
In this dark London it’s not all murder and blood, there’s also a tiny bit of space for romance. We have a few eligible suitors. One you’ll notice straight away, his presence is a chaotic magnet, my heart is all team Inspector Marlow (which my mind cast as Henry Cavill’ Sherlock version), every times he and Kitty were almost brushing hands I was all heart eyes for them.
“So you are to stay in London?”
“I am. Are you sorry to hear it?”
“No. No, quite the opposite of that.”
If you’re a fan of show as ‘Miss Scarlet and the Duke’ or Miss Fisher murder mystery this may be the book for you
January 30, 2023
1880 London. Atherton Norris, Marquess of Stratton's body has been hauled out of the river, suicide, accident or murder. It is for newly arrived from Birmingham Detective Inspector Thomas Marlowe to investigate. Catriona Winters, journalist and daughter of the owner of the newspaper the Messanger also decides to investigate for a story.
I admit I really didn't take to the character of Catriona and wanted to know more about Marlowe's investigation.
Overall it was an enjoyable historical romance and mystery story. A decent start to this new series.
I received a complimentary copy of the book from the publisher via Library Thing and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I admit I really didn't take to the character of Catriona and wanted to know more about Marlowe's investigation.
Overall it was an enjoyable historical romance and mystery story. A decent start to this new series.
I received a complimentary copy of the book from the publisher via Library Thing and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Read
January 20, 2025Unrated
The premise of this book seemed interesting. I read a sample on KU and it was enough to make me give it a chance. So, I downloaded the book. Only several chapters in, I regretted my decision. About halfway through, I was seriously struggling to finish it. For me, it was pretty slow and quite boring. It was hard for me to like the heroine, Catriona Winters. My main issue with her (besides all the internal conflicts/musings and peculiar flashbacks), is that she was a hypocrite. Several times she pretty much demanded (or expected) Inspector Marlowe to brief her on his case! A reporter (besides near stranger). Uh, yeah-no. Why would he do that? Besides, she shared NOTHING of what she learned. There was no quid pro quo happening here. And there did NOT really seem to be a good reason for her silence. Anyways, the police had a ton of information to go through; suspects to eliminate. Some of her information would have been very helpful. But nope, she gave nada.
I also wondered if she really was a reporter/writer? Seem she only really dabbled in it. She did not really seem to do much of it in the book. And a murder would have been a big story that would have (realistically) gone to one of the senior staff (and male); then to her-- seeming junior (and novice) reporter. Also, as some other reviewers mentioned (and I noted as well) she had A LOT of freedom. She was constantly running around by herself. Oh, and she passes out (or nearly passes out) a lot. It happened close to half a dozen times I believe.
Additionally, multiple times a scene would fade out. Sometimes the continuation (aka what happened) would be mentioned in the next scene, sometimes not. Huh? Lastly, it seemed things were often being alluded to etc.
There were some things I liked. Although I guessed the villain pretty early, I liked that the person was not pure evil. Although this person was totally wrong in what they did, the reasoning was clear. In a lot of ways, the book held true to the time period. Additionally, I liked that Kitty did not immediately fall in love with the expected person.
I did not love this. For 2025, I am going to try and be gentler with my ratings. I am thinking 2 1/2 stars. Even with all this, I have already started reading book 2.
CONTENT:
Intimacy. No sex. Some kissing.
Violence: There's some murders. However, only light description given.
Language. No crude language used that I recall.
The premise of this book seemed interesting. I read a sample on KU and it was enough to make me give it a chance. So, I downloaded the book. Only several chapters in, I regretted my decision. About halfway through, I was seriously struggling to finish it. For me, it was pretty slow and quite boring. It was hard for me to like the heroine, Catriona Winters. My main issue with her (besides all the internal conflicts/musings and peculiar flashbacks), is that she was a hypocrite. Several times she pretty much demanded (or expected) Inspector Marlowe to brief her on his case! A reporter (besides near stranger). Uh, yeah-no. Why would he do that? Besides, she shared NOTHING of what she learned. There was no quid pro quo happening here. And there did NOT really seem to be a good reason for her silence. Anyways, the police had a ton of information to go through; suspects to eliminate. Some of her information would have been very helpful. But nope, she gave nada.
I also wondered if she really was a reporter/writer? Seem she only really dabbled in it. She did not really seem to do much of it in the book. And a murder would have been a big story that would have (realistically) gone to one of the senior staff (and male); then to her-- seeming junior (and novice) reporter. Also, as some other reviewers mentioned (and I noted as well) she had A LOT of freedom. She was constantly running around by herself. Oh, and she passes out (or nearly passes out) a lot. It happened close to half a dozen times I believe.
Additionally, multiple times a scene would fade out. Sometimes the continuation (aka what happened) would be mentioned in the next scene, sometimes not. Huh? Lastly, it seemed things were often being alluded to etc.
There were some things I liked. Although I guessed the villain pretty early, I liked that the person was not pure evil. Although this person was totally wrong in what they did, the reasoning was clear. In a lot of ways, the book held true to the time period. Additionally, I liked that Kitty did not immediately fall in love with the expected person.
I did not love this. For 2025, I am going to try and be gentler with my ratings. I am thinking 2 1/2 stars. Even with all this, I have already started reading book 2.
CONTENT:
Intimacy. No sex. Some kissing.
Violence: There's some murders. However, only light description given.
Language. No crude language used that I recall.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 4, 2025
4 1/2
A great debut novel. If now the little moments of beautiful, magnificent scenery were fleshed out more, given time to breath and connected to some deeper emotion I’d give it 5 stars.
A great debut novel. If now the little moments of beautiful, magnificent scenery were fleshed out more, given time to breath and connected to some deeper emotion I’d give it 5 stars.
January 24, 2025
Great book, I love the setting, and the characters. They're not perfect, including the main character, but given her back ground it makes sense she'd be a bit naïve. The author also did a good job of making me care for the side characters, they didn't feel like extras. I look forward to the next books in this series!
April 13, 2025
Just …okay. Some potential here with characters, etc. but also a lot of ominous and veiled warnings out of proportion to the plot. Also, stupid choices on the part of the heroine. Who, yes, sometimes just seems like she is seeking a morbid or thrilling adventure. She is rather unlikable, but somehow everyone is in love with her. We’ll see. Going to try the next.
March 13, 2025
The reason I gave it 1 star was because the writing was passable and I didn't feel the need to rewrite the novel in my head as I read.
The reasons it lost stars: MC, Catriona Winters, is not only insufferable, but also a Bad Person, and the characters have surface-level personalities. The thing is, being a bad person is NOT an end-all to my liking a book but the author seems to try to paint Catriona as a good person but her actions are pretty bad to me.
Catriona Winters is a journalist (supposedly) who gets caught up in a murder mystery and works to solve it. Supposedly, because she only writes like 2 articles in the entire novel.
**Light spoilers about characters ahead**
Setting some things straight: Catriona does not "get caught up in a murder mystery". She brute forces her way into one and expects everyone to spill their information to her if she asks. She interrupts the police while they work on the crime scene, demands information about the case, gets rejected, gets huffy, decides that the inspector is an aggravating, insufferable person (the call is coming from inside the house!!) because he's doing his job, and proceeds to be rude to him for the rest of the book.
She works to solve the mystery by asking a handful of people questions, tracing steps, and trying to find conclusions but make no mistake, she is NOT an investigator.
Now, why is Catriona insufferable? She is a hypocrite with no backbone, barely any genuine goodwill or caring towards others, a liar, and has a need to feel superior to others. I think the author tried to write a strong woman who does things on her own, but it becomes both not period appropriate and Catriona is a self-serving, stubborn, irrational, lying person. She runs around dangerous areas of London all on her own, as if this isn't 1880 and she has rights or something. Unfortunately, this is 1880, and I'm amazed she's still alive.
Catriona claims to be trying to solve the case to find the killers of people close to her friends, but she is consistently the reason for it being stuck. She is always withholding crucial information from the police and only gives it when forced to or when she thinks she's benefiting. She's trying to play detective and hero to her grieving friends, tells them she will help, then slows down the police investigation to find the culprit. Want to know the reason she withholds information?
GOOD LORD IT IS ABSURD. She is on an ego trip of being the person her friends look to to solve the case and the person with more information than the police. This is an ABSOLUTE self-serving reason to "take on this case". She is literally just trying to boost her already unworthily overinflated ego (I mean, who demands confidential case information from the police and gets mad they won't give it to you, as if you deserve it and they're supposed to bend over and kneel for you?) Personally, I don't think you can claim to be trying to solve the case while withholding damning information from the police. It really only proves that she had no intention of solving the case in the first place; she's just nosy and wants to feel superior to everyone else. Also, does this not show how little she genuinely cares about her friends and her promises???
Catriona also likes to make accusatory claims and then go back on them with absolutely no backbone whatsoever, in the most frustrating of ways. I'm of the belief that the author wanted to make her seem like she has this strong sense of justice, ethics, and morals, but all her actions are so, so contradictory.
The only time Catriona does show her spine is when Marlowe is telling her to stay inside for her safety. She goes "You aren't my keeper! You can't tell me what or what not to do! Do you think cause you're a man you're so much stronger and infallible and since I'm a woman I must stay inside and be coddled?" WHEN THE FUCK DID HE SAY THAT. WHEN THE FUCK. Being stubborn and irrational is NOT the same as being a strong woman.
Now, Catriona is also a liar, and for no good, justifiable, understandable reason. Catriona is disgustingly, unwarranted-ly prideful, and now she's also a liar.
The best thing? She thinks she and Marlowe have become friends. I would say the opium is getting to her senses, but she didn't really have much in the first place.
To address characters, practically every character's personality and story can be given to you in a handful of words since their personalities have the depth of a soggy piece of cardboard.
The reasons it lost stars: MC, Catriona Winters, is not only insufferable, but also a Bad Person, and the characters have surface-level personalities. The thing is, being a bad person is NOT an end-all to my liking a book but the author seems to try to paint Catriona as a good person but her actions are pretty bad to me.
Catriona Winters is a journalist (supposedly) who gets caught up in a murder mystery and works to solve it. Supposedly, because she only writes like 2 articles in the entire novel.
**Light spoilers about characters ahead**
Setting some things straight: Catriona does not "get caught up in a murder mystery". She brute forces her way into one and expects everyone to spill their information to her if she asks. She interrupts the police while they work on the crime scene, demands information about the case, gets rejected, gets huffy, decides that the inspector is an aggravating, insufferable person (the call is coming from inside the house!!) because he's doing his job, and proceeds to be rude to him for the rest of the book.
She works to solve the mystery by asking a handful of people questions, tracing steps, and trying to find conclusions but make no mistake, she is NOT an investigator.
Now, why is Catriona insufferable? She is a hypocrite with no backbone, barely any genuine goodwill or caring towards others, a liar, and has a need to feel superior to others. I think the author tried to write a strong woman who does things on her own, but it becomes both not period appropriate and Catriona is a self-serving, stubborn, irrational, lying person. She runs around dangerous areas of London all on her own, as if this isn't 1880 and she has rights or something. Unfortunately, this is 1880, and I'm amazed she's still alive.
Catriona claims to be trying to solve the case to find the killers of people close to her friends, but she is consistently the reason for it being stuck. She is always withholding crucial information from the police and only gives it when forced to or when she thinks she's benefiting. She's trying to play detective and hero to her grieving friends, tells them she will help, then slows down the police investigation to find the culprit. Want to know the reason she withholds information?
GOOD LORD IT IS ABSURD. She is on an ego trip of being the person her friends look to to solve the case and the person with more information than the police. This is an ABSOLUTE self-serving reason to "take on this case". She is literally just trying to boost her already unworthily overinflated ego (I mean, who demands confidential case information from the police and gets mad they won't give it to you, as if you deserve it and they're supposed to bend over and kneel for you?) Personally, I don't think you can claim to be trying to solve the case while withholding damning information from the police. It really only proves that she had no intention of solving the case in the first place; she's just nosy and wants to feel superior to everyone else. Also, does this not show how little she genuinely cares about her friends and her promises???
Catriona also likes to make accusatory claims and then go back on them with absolutely no backbone whatsoever, in the most frustrating of ways. I'm of the belief that the author wanted to make her seem like she has this strong sense of justice, ethics, and morals, but all her actions are so, so contradictory.
The only time Catriona does show her spine is when Marlowe is telling her to stay inside for her safety. She goes "You aren't my keeper! You can't tell me what or what not to do! Do you think cause you're a man you're so much stronger and infallible and since I'm a woman I must stay inside and be coddled?" WHEN THE FUCK DID HE SAY THAT. WHEN THE FUCK. Being stubborn and irrational is NOT the same as being a strong woman.
Now, Catriona is also a liar, and for no good, justifiable, understandable reason. Catriona is disgustingly, unwarranted-ly prideful, and now she's also a liar.
The best thing? She thinks she and Marlowe have become friends. I would say the opium is getting to her senses, but she didn't really have much in the first place.
To address characters, practically every character's personality and story can be given to you in a handful of words since their personalities have the depth of a soggy piece of cardboard.
August 26, 2024
You know when you encounter an inconsistency in a book that just bugs you? Then you can't think of anything else while reading, but that one oversight and it kind of taints the rest of the experience for you? Yeah, that happened for me in this one. Not that it will for anyone else necessarily, and maybe no one else will even notice, or maybe I just completely read it wrong, but I'm pretty sure I didn't, and it bugged me. That, and I hate wishy washy, love triangley things. I mean, I went into this thinking Marlowe was our man, but color me surprised when our FMC is already in love with someone else. Aside from those two gripes, it was not bad. I wanted a historical mystery with a female lead, and that's exactly what this delivered. I'll be picking up the second book, if only to see if the whole romance debacle actually rights itself.
January 20, 2025
The murderer was obvious minutes after they walked into the story
That was a bummer. The characters were good. The “drama” was good. I look forward to how Catriona gets into trouble this time.
That was a bummer. The characters were good. The “drama” was good. I look forward to how Catriona gets into trouble this time.
February 9, 2025
A great start to the series
I enjoyed this start to a new historical mystery series. Lots of twists and turns and Catriona has her own secrets. She did annoy me a little in some of her decisions but it all worked out in the end.
I enjoyed this start to a new historical mystery series. Lots of twists and turns and Catriona has her own secrets. She did annoy me a little in some of her decisions but it all worked out in the end.
January 31, 2023
💉A Skeleton in Every House 🔫
Catriona Winters Book 1
✒️ Isabella Duke
https://www.isabella-duke.com/index.html
Release Date 01/01/2023
➪ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0BPHNW2RF?...
𝗕𝗹𝘂𝗿𝗯
A scandalous murder sparks mystery and romance in Victorian London.
Suffocated by the constraints of high society, Catriona Winters yearns to prove herself as a journalist. So when a nobleman is found slain, his body drifting off the Limehouse docks, she heads to the scene. There she clashes with the infuriating Inspector Thomas Marlowe, who is set on keeping the details of his inquiry out of the headlines.
Meanwhile, her childhood friend Nathaniel, heir of the Viscount Ashford, has returned from an unexplained sojourn in the country. The deeply buried attraction between them flares once more, but rumours swirl about his absence and a potential scandal his father seems determined to quash.
As Catriona struggles with her feelings for Nathaniel and her animosity towards Marlowe, she wades ever deeper into the secrets of Limehouse. But a second killing soon shocks London, leaving no one above suspicion. Catriona must unmask the murderer before he strikes again—and before she makes herself his next victim.
𝗥𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄
I have been curious about this book for some time, just the cover makes it stand out. It takes place after the Scotland Yard 1877’s scandal, and after reading Karen Odden’s Inspector Corravan series, an other story set in the aftermath of this affair is intriguing.
Yet as usual I waited the very end of my allowed time to read it, it is my very problem when I have a set date for an already published book, I do not feel the same hurry than with a book to be released. Well, but here we are and I do not regret one moment of my time spent with Catriona and cie.
I was a bit surprised by Catriona’s freedom to roam the city at will, I know the rules were a bit more relaxed in the last part of the XIXth century, before Jack The Ripper case, still for an unmarried miss of good breeding it was very progressive. But as she was in some way working for her father’s newspaper, it explained her ability to travel with few to no accountability.
The story, told from Catriona’s point of view, follows in some ways different timelines, the present with the murder at the dock and her dealings with Marlowe, Catriona’s history with Nate, her childhood friend and their romantic estrangement, and Catriona’s memories of her mother’s death.
Why the reader has to piece together the clues and hints distilled this and there to built the whole image of who is Catriona, a very flawed young woman with a shadowed side, many uncertainties but an iron core to dig out the truth.
I liked her even if at times in the story I was upset by her choices, by keeping most of her investigation to herself even when threatened, she put many times her safety in jeopardy. After it is understandable she wants to prove to herself first and others she is no liability but a voice to count on, what Marlowe comes to agree.
But it did not stop her to many times barge in first and weight only after the cost of her recklessness.
The plot is well crafted with a villain I only came to determine in the last quarter of the book, and the romantic narrative bordering the love triangle trope between Catriona, Nate and inspector Marlowe is intriguing, and while my heart is team Marlowe as the resilient enduring ex soldier would more acutely complete and temper Catriona’s wild side, Nate and his wounded soul has his moments but he comes from a world confining women to gilded cages, never letting them spread their wings, which would slowly extinguish Catriona’s fire.
4.5 stars
𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 kisses
I have been granted an advance copy by the author, here is my true and unbiased opinion.
https://www.instagram.com/reel/CoEzMl...
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?stor...
#bookstagram #historicalmystery #romance #romancebookblog #romancebookblogger #bookblog #romanceauthor #bookblogger #2023read #bookstagrammer #bookreview #romancebookreviewer #arcreader #isabelladuke #romancestagram #readersofinstagram
Catriona Winters Book 1
✒️ Isabella Duke
https://www.isabella-duke.com/index.html
Release Date 01/01/2023
➪ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0BPHNW2RF?...
𝗕𝗹𝘂𝗿𝗯
A scandalous murder sparks mystery and romance in Victorian London.
Suffocated by the constraints of high society, Catriona Winters yearns to prove herself as a journalist. So when a nobleman is found slain, his body drifting off the Limehouse docks, she heads to the scene. There she clashes with the infuriating Inspector Thomas Marlowe, who is set on keeping the details of his inquiry out of the headlines.
Meanwhile, her childhood friend Nathaniel, heir of the Viscount Ashford, has returned from an unexplained sojourn in the country. The deeply buried attraction between them flares once more, but rumours swirl about his absence and a potential scandal his father seems determined to quash.
As Catriona struggles with her feelings for Nathaniel and her animosity towards Marlowe, she wades ever deeper into the secrets of Limehouse. But a second killing soon shocks London, leaving no one above suspicion. Catriona must unmask the murderer before he strikes again—and before she makes herself his next victim.
𝗥𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄
I have been curious about this book for some time, just the cover makes it stand out. It takes place after the Scotland Yard 1877’s scandal, and after reading Karen Odden’s Inspector Corravan series, an other story set in the aftermath of this affair is intriguing.
Yet as usual I waited the very end of my allowed time to read it, it is my very problem when I have a set date for an already published book, I do not feel the same hurry than with a book to be released. Well, but here we are and I do not regret one moment of my time spent with Catriona and cie.
I was a bit surprised by Catriona’s freedom to roam the city at will, I know the rules were a bit more relaxed in the last part of the XIXth century, before Jack The Ripper case, still for an unmarried miss of good breeding it was very progressive. But as she was in some way working for her father’s newspaper, it explained her ability to travel with few to no accountability.
The story, told from Catriona’s point of view, follows in some ways different timelines, the present with the murder at the dock and her dealings with Marlowe, Catriona’s history with Nate, her childhood friend and their romantic estrangement, and Catriona’s memories of her mother’s death.
Why the reader has to piece together the clues and hints distilled this and there to built the whole image of who is Catriona, a very flawed young woman with a shadowed side, many uncertainties but an iron core to dig out the truth.
I liked her even if at times in the story I was upset by her choices, by keeping most of her investigation to herself even when threatened, she put many times her safety in jeopardy. After it is understandable she wants to prove to herself first and others she is no liability but a voice to count on, what Marlowe comes to agree.
But it did not stop her to many times barge in first and weight only after the cost of her recklessness.
The plot is well crafted with a villain I only came to determine in the last quarter of the book, and the romantic narrative bordering the love triangle trope between Catriona, Nate and inspector Marlowe is intriguing, and while my heart is team Marlowe as the resilient enduring ex soldier would more acutely complete and temper Catriona’s wild side, Nate and his wounded soul has his moments but he comes from a world confining women to gilded cages, never letting them spread their wings, which would slowly extinguish Catriona’s fire.
4.5 stars
𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 kisses
I have been granted an advance copy by the author, here is my true and unbiased opinion.
https://www.instagram.com/reel/CoEzMl...
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?stor...
#bookstagram #historicalmystery #romance #romancebookblog #romancebookblogger #bookblog #romanceauthor #bookblogger #2023read #bookstagrammer #bookreview #romancebookreviewer #arcreader #isabelladuke #romancestagram #readersofinstagram
January 19, 2023
When I saw the cover of Skeleton In Every House I knew I had to read it. The woman on the cover with hair and dress, from another time standing in what looked like a thick fog seemed to invite me into her world. I accepted and never regretted the choice.
The stary is set in Victorian London among the glittering world of the high society in London The lady on the cover is named Catriona , a "modern", woman who is bored with the confined life of society and seeks to prove herself to be worthy of a reporter's position at her father's newspaper. There is a murder of a Lord that she decided to investigate and the decision brings her into many situations, grim and dangerous.
I loved this book! Catriona is a great character, a brilliant amateur sleuth, impulsive, yet mot above discussion of fashion with her cousin Beth. She could be a little snotty too but she was persistent in her goal. There is also a little romance but it doesn't over shadow the story which I personally appreciate
The book is well written, and Ms Duke paints the Victorian era that feels well researched and authentic.
Another discovery is that the author lives in Australia. I love Aussie mystery writers. They can write some really creepy tales and I am definitely a fan!
If you like historical mysteries, you definitely should read Skeleton In Every House. This is not a cozy but I think some cozy fans might enjoy it if you want to try a new type of mystery.
A huge thank you to Book Sirens and author Isabella Duke for giving me a copy. of tte book. I freely give my own opinion with great enthusiasm. I saw the cover of Skeleton In Every House I knew I had to read it. The woman on the cover with hair and dress, from another time standing in what looked like a thick fog seemed to invite me into her world. I accepted and never regretted the choice.
The stary is set in Victorian London among the glittering world of the high society in London The lady on the cover is named Catriona , a "modern", woman who is bored with the confined life of society and seeks to prove herself to be worthy of a reporter's position at her father's newspaper. There is a murder of a Lord that she decided to investigate and the decision brings her into many situations, grim and dangerous.
I loved this book! Catriona is a great character, a brilliant amateur sleuth, impulsive, yet mot above discussion of fashion with her cousin Beth. She could be a little snotty too but she was persistent in her goal. There is also a little romance but it doesn't over shadow the story which I personally appreciate
The book is well written, and Ms Duke paints the Victorian era that feels well researched and authentic.
Another discovery is that the author lives in Australia. I love Aussie mystery writers. They can write some really creepy tales and I am definitely a fan!
If you like historical mysteries, you definitely should read Skeleton In Every House. This is not a cozy but I think some cozy fans might enjoy it if you want to try a new type of mystery.
A huge thank you to Book Sirens and author Isabella Duke for giving me a copy. of tte book. I freely give my own opinion with great enthusiasm.
The stary is set in Victorian London among the glittering world of the high society in London The lady on the cover is named Catriona , a "modern", woman who is bored with the confined life of society and seeks to prove herself to be worthy of a reporter's position at her father's newspaper. There is a murder of a Lord that she decided to investigate and the decision brings her into many situations, grim and dangerous.
I loved this book! Catriona is a great character, a brilliant amateur sleuth, impulsive, yet mot above discussion of fashion with her cousin Beth. She could be a little snotty too but she was persistent in her goal. There is also a little romance but it doesn't over shadow the story which I personally appreciate
The book is well written, and Ms Duke paints the Victorian era that feels well researched and authentic.
Another discovery is that the author lives in Australia. I love Aussie mystery writers. They can write some really creepy tales and I am definitely a fan!
If you like historical mysteries, you definitely should read Skeleton In Every House. This is not a cozy but I think some cozy fans might enjoy it if you want to try a new type of mystery.
A huge thank you to Book Sirens and author Isabella Duke for giving me a copy. of tte book. I freely give my own opinion with great enthusiasm. I saw the cover of Skeleton In Every House I knew I had to read it. The woman on the cover with hair and dress, from another time standing in what looked like a thick fog seemed to invite me into her world. I accepted and never regretted the choice.
The stary is set in Victorian London among the glittering world of the high society in London The lady on the cover is named Catriona , a "modern", woman who is bored with the confined life of society and seeks to prove herself to be worthy of a reporter's position at her father's newspaper. There is a murder of a Lord that she decided to investigate and the decision brings her into many situations, grim and dangerous.
I loved this book! Catriona is a great character, a brilliant amateur sleuth, impulsive, yet mot above discussion of fashion with her cousin Beth. She could be a little snotty too but she was persistent in her goal. There is also a little romance but it doesn't over shadow the story which I personally appreciate
The book is well written, and Ms Duke paints the Victorian era that feels well researched and authentic.
Another discovery is that the author lives in Australia. I love Aussie mystery writers. They can write some really creepy tales and I am definitely a fan!
If you like historical mysteries, you definitely should read Skeleton In Every House. This is not a cozy but I think some cozy fans might enjoy it if you want to try a new type of mystery.
A huge thank you to Book Sirens and author Isabella Duke for giving me a copy. of tte book. I freely give my own opinion with great enthusiasm.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 9, 2023
1880. London. Catriona Winters is not simply a daughter of newspaper owner Sir Frederick Winters. Catriona began going to the offices of the "Messenger" after her father's decline in health. She knew she could be useful and do more than keep her father's desk organized. Convincing her father that it is safe to visit the scene of a murder at the Limehouse docks with police on the scene; there's no risk of danger. This is her opportunity to prove to her father she can contribute as a journalist.
I was captivated by Catriona from the first pages. I was drawn to her curiosity, kindness, confidence, and intellect, even though there are moments when her inquisitive determination overrules her common sense. I loved the rapport in her loving relationship with her father and her mutually caring friendship with Bethany. Then there is the triangle of romantic possibilities. The long-time friendship with Bethany's brother Nate, letters exchanged with Sidney Hampstead in America, and her frustration with Detective Inspector Thomas Marlowe equals his vexation with her.
It is a sparkling debut with atmospheric writing for historical setting, character depth, and layers of red herrings that twist to open new possibilities for the investigation. A well-written stand-alone with engaging characters, and all the more exciting knowing it is the beginning of a series. I welcome Isabella Duke to my automatic pre-order list of authors.
For all who love the historical mysteries with Kitty Weeks writing for New York's "Sentinel" in 1915, created by Radha Vatsal, you will adore her counterpart, Catriona Winters as an investigative reporter in an earlier time "across the pond."
I was lucky to receive an Advance Reader’s Edition of this title as an Early Reviewer from LibraryThing. The opinions expressed in the review are my own.
I was captivated by Catriona from the first pages. I was drawn to her curiosity, kindness, confidence, and intellect, even though there are moments when her inquisitive determination overrules her common sense. I loved the rapport in her loving relationship with her father and her mutually caring friendship with Bethany. Then there is the triangle of romantic possibilities. The long-time friendship with Bethany's brother Nate, letters exchanged with Sidney Hampstead in America, and her frustration with Detective Inspector Thomas Marlowe equals his vexation with her.
It is a sparkling debut with atmospheric writing for historical setting, character depth, and layers of red herrings that twist to open new possibilities for the investigation. A well-written stand-alone with engaging characters, and all the more exciting knowing it is the beginning of a series. I welcome Isabella Duke to my automatic pre-order list of authors.
For all who love the historical mysteries with Kitty Weeks writing for New York's "Sentinel" in 1915, created by Radha Vatsal, you will adore her counterpart, Catriona Winters as an investigative reporter in an earlier time "across the pond."
I was lucky to receive an Advance Reader’s Edition of this title as an Early Reviewer from LibraryThing. The opinions expressed in the review are my own.
February 4, 2023
A Riveting Debut
It was a great pleasure to win A Skeleton in Every House by Isabella Duke through a Goodreads Giveaway. This novel is the first historical mystery in a series featuring Cartiona Winters. The story is set in Victorian London and Catriona is a strong and independent young woman regardless of the societal standards of that time. Her father, Sir Frederick, owns a newspaper and Catriona is helping him there due to his health. When a man is found murdered near the Limehouse docks she sets out to get the story.
Her desire to investigate puts her in grave danger. The mystery devised by Ms Duke was dark and twisted. Thankfully, this is not a cosy mystery. I loved the cast of characters - Inspector Marlowe, Nate and Bethany, and Mr Tsang. Inspector Marlowe is mysterious and strong. Nate is the brother of Catriona's best friend and he is a brooding young man with secrets. Bethany is the best friend who is trying to navigate her impending marriage to Mr Bancroft. Mr Tsang is from the dark China and he runs an opium den in Limehouse. There is just enough romantic tension in the book, but the story was not overwhelmed by it. In fact, this reader is wondering if Catriona will choose any of the potential love interests or pursue a life of independence.
I can't wait for more in this new series. Isabella Duke has created a complex heroine whom readers will absolutely adore.
It was a great pleasure to win A Skeleton in Every House by Isabella Duke through a Goodreads Giveaway. This novel is the first historical mystery in a series featuring Cartiona Winters. The story is set in Victorian London and Catriona is a strong and independent young woman regardless of the societal standards of that time. Her father, Sir Frederick, owns a newspaper and Catriona is helping him there due to his health. When a man is found murdered near the Limehouse docks she sets out to get the story.
Her desire to investigate puts her in grave danger. The mystery devised by Ms Duke was dark and twisted. Thankfully, this is not a cosy mystery. I loved the cast of characters - Inspector Marlowe, Nate and Bethany, and Mr Tsang. Inspector Marlowe is mysterious and strong. Nate is the brother of Catriona's best friend and he is a brooding young man with secrets. Bethany is the best friend who is trying to navigate her impending marriage to Mr Bancroft. Mr Tsang is from the dark China and he runs an opium den in Limehouse. There is just enough romantic tension in the book, but the story was not overwhelmed by it. In fact, this reader is wondering if Catriona will choose any of the potential love interests or pursue a life of independence.
I can't wait for more in this new series. Isabella Duke has created a complex heroine whom readers will absolutely adore.
March 7, 2023
Note: I received a copy to review from BookSiren and I thank them and the author for the opportunity.
I wasn't sure what to make of this story at first even though I love stories that are set in England. London is my favorite city to read stories from and while I'm used to stories set in the past such as this one, I enjoy modern stories too. However certain parts were too much. Isabella Duke is also good with description. An example of this is the following line: "Conditions in the district were squalid, marked by chronic poverty and want." (4%). It is simple yet very effective for me as a reader when I picture the scene. Yet the main character, Catriona Winters is written like a character not of the time period. According to the beginning the book is set in 1880. I'm sure the author did their research, and I do understand that this is fiction, but something like that threw my whole disbelief out the window. While I enjoyed her as the MC, I struggled with the fact she was able to do as much as she could. The fact she was helping her father seems interesting yet not true to the time period. Being a reporter just doesn't seem something a woman could do at the time. Also, she might not be your average woman of the time however the line: "Had he felt the cold seeping through his clothes but been powerless to save himself, or had he been unconscious and simply drifted off into that endless darkness? (15%) just does not sit well. I understand that the author wants to highlight the idea she is not your average woman of this time, but reporter or not, a woman like Catriona does not seem like the type to go about caring about that type of thing. For me, it just did not fit with how her life played out in the story. I mean most of the friends the author mentioned her having seemed to be written as well bred, almost high class. She did seem very smart, and I liked that about her, but then there were lines like "Sidney was off having adventures in America whilst she was too cautious to chance another visit to the docks" (24%) and I wanted to face palm because of course she should be having second thoughts, she was a woman with no rights and who bad stuff could happen to all the time! I really enjoyed the story itself because it was fun watching Catriona solve the crime, but it was irritating too due the inaccuracies from that time period. Also, why did it take to the end of the book for the title to make sense? Surely, they could have dropped hints along the way instead of having a cute little saying at the end to tie everything into a neat little bow. I would recommend this book to other readers, but I would warn if inaccuracies might bother you like they do me, even with the story itself being fiction, then I would proceed with caution.
I wasn't sure what to make of this story at first even though I love stories that are set in England. London is my favorite city to read stories from and while I'm used to stories set in the past such as this one, I enjoy modern stories too. However certain parts were too much. Isabella Duke is also good with description. An example of this is the following line: "Conditions in the district were squalid, marked by chronic poverty and want." (4%). It is simple yet very effective for me as a reader when I picture the scene. Yet the main character, Catriona Winters is written like a character not of the time period. According to the beginning the book is set in 1880. I'm sure the author did their research, and I do understand that this is fiction, but something like that threw my whole disbelief out the window. While I enjoyed her as the MC, I struggled with the fact she was able to do as much as she could. The fact she was helping her father seems interesting yet not true to the time period. Being a reporter just doesn't seem something a woman could do at the time. Also, she might not be your average woman of the time however the line: "Had he felt the cold seeping through his clothes but been powerless to save himself, or had he been unconscious and simply drifted off into that endless darkness? (15%) just does not sit well. I understand that the author wants to highlight the idea she is not your average woman of this time, but reporter or not, a woman like Catriona does not seem like the type to go about caring about that type of thing. For me, it just did not fit with how her life played out in the story. I mean most of the friends the author mentioned her having seemed to be written as well bred, almost high class. She did seem very smart, and I liked that about her, but then there were lines like "Sidney was off having adventures in America whilst she was too cautious to chance another visit to the docks" (24%) and I wanted to face palm because of course she should be having second thoughts, she was a woman with no rights and who bad stuff could happen to all the time! I really enjoyed the story itself because it was fun watching Catriona solve the crime, but it was irritating too due the inaccuracies from that time period. Also, why did it take to the end of the book for the title to make sense? Surely, they could have dropped hints along the way instead of having a cute little saying at the end to tie everything into a neat little bow. I would recommend this book to other readers, but I would warn if inaccuracies might bother you like they do me, even with the story itself being fiction, then I would proceed with caution.
February 7, 2023
Well done on this debut novel! The author has enticed me to continue reading the next installments, for sure. I enjoy historical fiction so I can learn a little something but still enjoy the relaxation of fiction, in general.
The main character, Catriona, is inquisitive, intelligent and definitely not afraid. Fortunately she is born into a societal class that allows freedom and movement so she can act upon such traits. In 1880s England, she is not only traipsing around town (and to some very unsavory parts) unaccompanied, but she's also actively working and writing for her family newspaper. What's not to love about this character?!
Murders, an opium den, new-fangled technology of photography, social class rules, and the reminder that drug addiction afflicts all classes are all entangled in this mystery. I like that a full family history is not fleshed out around Catriona, but small details sprinkled throughout the story. It keeps it interesting and unfolding slowly. I have a feeling we'll learn some more in book two.
Needless to say, Catriona solves not only the original murder the book opens with but another murder close to her as well as smuggling, drug dealing and attempted murder by the end of the story. I do look forward to more mysteries in this series and my continued education on historical England!
The main character, Catriona, is inquisitive, intelligent and definitely not afraid. Fortunately she is born into a societal class that allows freedom and movement so she can act upon such traits. In 1880s England, she is not only traipsing around town (and to some very unsavory parts) unaccompanied, but she's also actively working and writing for her family newspaper. What's not to love about this character?!
Murders, an opium den, new-fangled technology of photography, social class rules, and the reminder that drug addiction afflicts all classes are all entangled in this mystery. I like that a full family history is not fleshed out around Catriona, but small details sprinkled throughout the story. It keeps it interesting and unfolding slowly. I have a feeling we'll learn some more in book two.
Needless to say, Catriona solves not only the original murder the book opens with but another murder close to her as well as smuggling, drug dealing and attempted murder by the end of the story. I do look forward to more mysteries in this series and my continued education on historical England!
March 12, 2023
Catriona Winters, daughter of a newspaper owner, is eager to prove herself as a competent journalist. The scene of a slain nobleman brings her into conflict with Inspector Thomas Marlowe, who has no interest in her poking into his case. Battling the shadows of her own past, Catriona pursues the truth, wading deeper into the seedy side of the docks, never dreaming how close the danger really is to her family.
This was an entertaining mystery! Once I began, I found it hard to put down. I enjoyed Catriona’s no-nonsense attitude. It made sense that she, a young lady of good family, pursued journalism with her doting father owning the newspaper.
One thing that annoyed me was how every single gentleman apparently was attracted to Catriona: her childhood friend, the inspector, the opium den owner in the docks. I also would have liked a specific year, but everything was just Victorian. The details were enjoyable; the author clearly did her research. But given how much things changed in the Victorian era, I would have liked to have a specific reference point.
Overall, this was an intriguing start to a series. I am interested to know what happens next. I would recommend this to readers looking for a Victorian mystery.
I received a free copy from the author via LibraryThing Review program. All opinions expressed are my own.
This was an entertaining mystery! Once I began, I found it hard to put down. I enjoyed Catriona’s no-nonsense attitude. It made sense that she, a young lady of good family, pursued journalism with her doting father owning the newspaper.
One thing that annoyed me was how every single gentleman apparently was attracted to Catriona: her childhood friend, the inspector, the opium den owner in the docks. I also would have liked a specific year, but everything was just Victorian. The details were enjoyable; the author clearly did her research. But given how much things changed in the Victorian era, I would have liked to have a specific reference point.
Overall, this was an intriguing start to a series. I am interested to know what happens next. I would recommend this to readers looking for a Victorian mystery.
I received a free copy from the author via LibraryThing Review program. All opinions expressed are my own.
March 7, 2023
I got an early reader copy of this book, and this is my honest review. I very much enjoyed this book. After a few chapters, I was hooked and couldn't wait to get back to the book and read more. I LOVE it when this happens with a book. Catriona is a clever, down-to-earth young woman, but she is still a little flighty when it comes to men. Her growing relationship with Marlowe and her hot & cold relationship with Nate, then her "fiancé" Sidney. This could be frustrating, but it makes her a realistic person with weaknesses just like anybody else. I enjoyed the descriptions of the time period and the warm relationship with her friend Bethany. I wish there was a little more about Marlowe in the story, he intrigued me. Her mother is mentioned a bit, and the tragedy that caused her death is hinted to but never revealed. This leaves some more juicy details for the next book. I really enjoyed this read, it was a great first book for the a new series, and I look forward to reading the next one.
April 7, 2024
Despite having a number of cliches in this, it actually has heart and I enjoyed it greatly. I think the author's light touch saved the cliches. She hinted and never overstated. For instance, several of the women have reservations about their place in Victorian society once they get married, but it didn't come across as too ham fisted. I was nervous when I realized that this was a self published debut, but I actually find promise in the author's portrayal of people and making me believe in the ensemble cast of characters. I have already preordered the sequel because I am invested in the characters and how the potential relationships turn out.
One question though: how on EARTH does homegirl have THREE guys pining after her simultaneously?
One question though: how on EARTH does homegirl have THREE guys pining after her simultaneously?
October 13, 2024
The beginning was slow and a little confusing with the names and nicknames. Catriona/Kitty may have been an exception during the 1880's, and there definitely were some exceptions. However, the role of women in middle to upper classes seldom had the freedom that Catriona possessed(among other things, being allowed unescorted to even visiting friends). Yet, Catriona visits areas around the docks and even Limehouse, areas where even with an escort ladies would never go.
Catriona, who wants to be a reporter for her father's paper, somehow manages, and she is even able to report on a murder of a Marquess at the docks. So, if you can set aside your disbelief, the author manages to find a rhythm as the book continues.
Catriona, who wants to be a reporter for her father's paper, somehow manages, and she is even able to report on a murder of a Marquess at the docks. So, if you can set aside your disbelief, the author manages to find a rhythm as the book continues.
November 21, 2024
Well Written Victorian Period Detective Novel
I have rarely read a detective story that captures the societal restrictions and rules of the Victorian era so well. Beautifully written on multiple levels including how disconcerting it is to absorb the stilted speech and restrained thoughts Catriona and Beth, plus the characters around them, have. Catriona, expected to behave in such the modest, restricted manner her role in society demands, has an unquenchable thirst for finding answers to questions about why two men she knows have been murdered and who did it. Utterly fearless, she goes where women of propriety usually dare not go. I thoroughly enjoyed the characters and the journey…great debut novel.
I have rarely read a detective story that captures the societal restrictions and rules of the Victorian era so well. Beautifully written on multiple levels including how disconcerting it is to absorb the stilted speech and restrained thoughts Catriona and Beth, plus the characters around them, have. Catriona, expected to behave in such the modest, restricted manner her role in society demands, has an unquenchable thirst for finding answers to questions about why two men she knows have been murdered and who did it. Utterly fearless, she goes where women of propriety usually dare not go. I thoroughly enjoyed the characters and the journey…great debut novel.
February 9, 2025
"Women are not children, yet they are often treated as such by men."
This is one of the few books I've read that perfectly reflects that issue. Women in the novel are not extraordinary or atypical, they are not portrayed as rebellious or immune to scandal, as is so often the case in similar stories. They feel constricted by their role in society and aim, almost unconsciously, to loosen the threads that bind them to the rules of social decorum.
The characters are three-dimensional, flawed, and endearing. Easy to understand even from the 21st-century viewpoint.
Usually, I get irritated by the main characters' headless traipsing into risky situations, however, given the MFC's struggle with depression and overall numbness caused by restrictions put upon her by her father and society in general, her flirtations with deadly situations are easier to understand.
This is one of the few books I've read that perfectly reflects that issue. Women in the novel are not extraordinary or atypical, they are not portrayed as rebellious or immune to scandal, as is so often the case in similar stories. They feel constricted by their role in society and aim, almost unconsciously, to loosen the threads that bind them to the rules of social decorum.
The characters are three-dimensional, flawed, and endearing. Easy to understand even from the 21st-century viewpoint.
Usually, I get irritated by the main characters' headless traipsing into risky situations, however, given the MFC's struggle with depression and overall numbness caused by restrictions put upon her by her father and society in general, her flirtations with deadly situations are easier to understand.
January 8, 2023
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I like historical mysteries, which was why I was interested in this, and I thought it was a very nicely written historical mystery. The writing style was simple but elegant.
I liked the protagonist, and the way she interacted with some of the other characters. In terms of her personality, she reminded me slightly of Philip Pullman's Sally Lockhart. I would be interested to know what happened next for this character, so if there are going to be more books featuring her as the protagonist, I would be interested in them.
Thank you to Booksirens and the author for a free copy to review.
I like historical mysteries, which was why I was interested in this, and I thought it was a very nicely written historical mystery. The writing style was simple but elegant.
I liked the protagonist, and the way she interacted with some of the other characters. In terms of her personality, she reminded me slightly of Philip Pullman's Sally Lockhart. I would be interested to know what happened next for this character, so if there are going to be more books featuring her as the protagonist, I would be interested in them.
Thank you to Booksirens and the author for a free copy to review.
January 12, 2023
Living in days when women were looking for a prosperous marriage proposal as their life goal, being a little more astute in your surroundings might not be a good thing. But when you are the only daughter of a Newspaper Man, you can have some ideas that might not be welcome in genteel society. Catriona, is pushing her agenda to become a good investigative journalist and her father is not stopping her.
This book is a wonderful read and reminds us just how far women have gotten in the quest for being more than a homemaker or gold digger as the case may be!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This book is a wonderful read and reminds us just how far women have gotten in the quest for being more than a homemaker or gold digger as the case may be!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
December 9, 2024
Entitled
Wow Catriona acts like a woman of today not of the 1800Or the late late 1800s. Her attitude of belittling men and then using seduction to get what she wants or female games was beyond what I believe would have been allowed by other women in her class.or by her father. The book made Marlowe look like he had never investigated a murder and was lost without her, a young woman who has barely written a story goes on to cover an ongoing murder and investigate it.Solves it but keeps vital evidence from the police!
Catriona was just to in your face,demanding , rude, and expected people to just do as she commands.
She doesn’t fit the time.
Wow Catriona acts like a woman of today not of the 1800Or the late late 1800s. Her attitude of belittling men and then using seduction to get what she wants or female games was beyond what I believe would have been allowed by other women in her class.or by her father. The book made Marlowe look like he had never investigated a murder and was lost without her, a young woman who has barely written a story goes on to cover an ongoing murder and investigate it.Solves it but keeps vital evidence from the police!
Catriona was just to in your face,demanding , rude, and expected people to just do as she commands.
She doesn’t fit the time.
May 10, 2025
This author's debut novel is exceptional!
A great storyline, although I confess, I had the bad guy nailed early on! A wonderful cast of characters and a slow, simmering attraction between the MCs with roadblocks too many to count.
I closed the cover on this one and immediately downloaded book 2, not because of any cliffhanger, but because I was truly captivated by these characters and the author's storytelling...I had to have more!
And just look at this cover...it beautiful and poignant.
This new author has certainly found a fan in me...I'll be watching very closely for upcoming releases!
A great storyline, although I confess, I had the bad guy nailed early on! A wonderful cast of characters and a slow, simmering attraction between the MCs with roadblocks too many to count.
I closed the cover on this one and immediately downloaded book 2, not because of any cliffhanger, but because I was truly captivated by these characters and the author's storytelling...I had to have more!
And just look at this cover...it beautiful and poignant.
This new author has certainly found a fan in me...I'll be watching very closely for upcoming releases!
April 30, 2024
Isabella Duke grabs your attention from the beginning and keeps you hooked. I can't wait for the second book in the series. I'm intrigued with Catriona, the central character, and the Scotland Yard detective, Inspector Marlowe, and their relationship. What contributed a lot to my enjoyment was that I am very fond of period pieces. I love going into the past and imagining how people lived their lives and expressed their thoughts. Of course, the opium dens in the London docks area, circa 1880, are a perfect setting for that sort of exploration.
September 30, 2024
Good book
Not quite as enthralling as Raybourn but a pleasant read. The setting and characters are true to their time and the main character is relatable.
Something I find lacking in regency mystery romance is a desire for home and motherhood. I have seen women, who I consider intelligent and ambitious, who choose home and family as their career. And they are successful in very valid and important ways. I am tired of this role being relegated to unimportant and unsatisfying status. Adventure is found in every decision a man or a woman makes and parenting is a valid choice.
Not quite as enthralling as Raybourn but a pleasant read. The setting and characters are true to their time and the main character is relatable.
Something I find lacking in regency mystery romance is a desire for home and motherhood. I have seen women, who I consider intelligent and ambitious, who choose home and family as their career. And they are successful in very valid and important ways. I am tired of this role being relegated to unimportant and unsatisfying status. Adventure is found in every decision a man or a woman makes and parenting is a valid choice.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews