The Revolutionary War is often celebrated as marking the birth of American republicanism, liberty, and representative democracy. Yet for the tens of thousands of British and Hessian troops sent 3,000 miles across the Atlantic Ocean to wage war under alien skies, such a progressive picture, as Vaughn Scribner reveals, could not have been further from the truth. In Under Alien Skies, Scribner illustrates how foreign soldiers' negative perceptions of the American environment merged with harsh wartime realities to elicit considerable physical, mental, and emotional anguish.
Whether trudging through alligator-infested swamps, nursing a comrade back to health in a rain-sodden tent, or digging trenches in a burned-out port city, most who fought in America under the British army’s flag ultimately deemed themselves strangers fighting in a strange land. For them, Revolutionary America looked nothing like the “happy land . . . blessed with every climate” that Revolutionary republicans so successfully promoted. Instead, the War of Independence descended into a quagmire of anxiety, destruction, and distress at the hands of the American environment—a “Diabolical Country,” as one British soldier opined, “which no Earthly Compensation can put me in Charity with.”
Parts of this book were really good, and as a whole, I'd recommend it.
However, it took me a long time to get through it, because the writing is repetitive and often bland. It seemed to me that he began and ended each chapter as if he were serializing the book, and had to catch the reader up to date.
Also, the book is only technically 250 pages. It's actually about 160, plus notes and bibliography.
I was primarily interested the main premise of the book - British/German troops struggling to live with the American environment. Especially living in New England, I greatly enjoyed the detailed struggles of the troops throughout the different seasons.
But particularly, I was very much interested in the last chapter or so. Hearing about the mental health struggles of these troops at a time where there was little to no support for such struggles, was eye opening and really provided a lot of context to the debilitating nature of war in a foreign environment.
Also, my favorite quote!!
“Watching as the Sixteenth Grenadier Regiment of British soldiers trudged back into Pensacola looking “like death”, Walden asserted that Florida was “certainly no place for human beings”.
A wonderful, qualitative, work from Dr.Scribner over the environmental history of the American Revolution and its impact on the conflict. Scribner does a fantastic service to the human element of the environmental conflict and highlights some key aspects of conflict that might otherwise be lost in the full historiography. A seminal work for Revolutionary environmental history to come.