Stark's work helps to make the landscape of late 19th century North Indian publishing much less stark. This is a long awaited work on the most important publisher in 19th century India and his publishing house. She includes a great amount of helpful information on Newal Kishore's publishing history, the way in which he commercialized print and how he helped to shape new forms of knowledge production while preserving older literary, cultural and religious traditions. This is a great resource for anyone working on the history of the book in South Asia, late 19th century literary history, Hindi-Urdu walas, and historians of modern South Asia. While the book contains a plethora of information I think that Stark could have made better use of the material. For example, apart from showing the reader how Newal Kishore combated linguistic and religious secretarianism by publishing religious works from both Hindu and Islamic traditions she offers very few theoretical or historical insights. With the material she painstakingly collected I think she could have gone further in her analysis, venturing to make some larger historical and theoretical claims. That said it is still a great work of scholarship and is a must have for all scholars working on modern South Asia.