This is a review of the audiobook, so I need to get a big complaint out of the way. The narrator was doing some sort of accent for the characters in this small town in Minnesota, and I don't know what it is, but it did not sound Minnesotan at all. I am from Minnesota, albeit the Twin Cities, not rural Minnesota like this book is set, and this just sounded off to me. Now, I don't think I would have noticed or had any particular complaint had the narrator not tried to do any kind of accent, but since the dialogue was read noticeably differently than the rest of the text, obviously she was. The main feature of this "Minnesota" accent seemed to be dropping the g on every single -ing word. Some words, sure, but this is not some kind of stereotypical Minnesota thing, and it didn't sound right to me. I would describe it as maybe she was doing a Southern accent without the twang? I don't know if I could even put my finger on exactly what else was wrong with it, it just sounded off, and I think perhaps it was that mainly she just dropped her g's and then didn't try to do anything Minnesota-y with her vowels and inflection? It was super distracting to me and consequently I spent a large portion of the audiobook waiting for her to say "bag" so I could judge how Minnesotan it was (spoiler: not at all!) It got me very riled up and at one point I shouted "I think you mean hot dish!" when she said the word "casserole", and then remembered I couldn't blame the word choice on the narrator 😅
However, if you are not from here or if you are less prone to obsessing over such details, you will probably not mind this accent, whatever it is, and other than that the narration was fine--nothing outstanding, but fine.
As for the story, this is the beginning of a series about a widowed 40-something female sheriff in a rural Minnesota county. In the dead of winter, amid multiple snowstorms, she is looking for a missing girl and trying to find the source of some mysterious--possibly drug-related--money. She also has some personal matters going on that lead to the reader getting more background about her late husband and father-in-law, both former sheriffs of the same county.
I thought Red was a fairly likable character. She does her job, goes home to her small dog, and goes to poker night with a group of women in the town. She does go off on political tangents every now and then, which mostly have little to do with the story, but I guess mostly are there to establish Red's character. While I did think they stood out to me as not really flowing well in a few cases, they were generally things I was in total agreement with her about, so it was not anything I minded, but conservative readers who seek to avoid that kind of thing may end up riled up by this book. These political rambles generally ended up with Red thinking about how she had better not mention THAT to the conservative townspeople whose votes she needs, so maybe the point was also to establish how a sheriff is a political animal and needs to behave that way.
The mystery for me, was so-so--I didn't find myself all that invested in what happened to Missy, where the money came from, who killed an unidentified man several decades ago. Red's investigating mostly involved asking everyone she ran into if they'd ever heard of a person named Coke, so I guess the sleuthing was just all right for me too. There was also an unexpectedly vivid birth (or, I guess, pre-birth) scene, and the image of a "throbbing" umbilical cord emerging before the baby is probably the part of the book that will stick with me the longest! 👀 This story did keep me engaged though, but I'm not sure it was enough that I'd pick up the next in the series, unless the plot sounds especially good. I did enjoy the small town setting and all the snow, however, and I would be interested to see how Red progresses as a character over further books.
All in all, I'd say check this one out if you think the plot sounds intriguing or you like books set in Minnesota (maybe don't do the audio though...), but it isn't one of the top mysteries I'd recommend.
Thanks to NetGalley and Tantor Audio for allowing me to review an ARC of this audiobook.