2.50
If Book 2 already disappointed me some, Book 3 sealed that deal for me. What started as something very promising, with exciting intrigue and characters that were NOT AT ALL the sweet ne'er do bad heroes and heroines usual to fantasy novels, turned into a messy, confused mishmash where the only thing that made sense was the way the characters remained their old unlikeable selves.
Book 3 is very confused, very confusing and messily presented, both in terms of plot as in terms of writing, as well - it read like a mid-draft still in need of work, if only to see to the typos, the repetitions and the carelessly thrown in sentences. As in its predecessor, a large chunk is spent on laying the grounds for something that promises to happen later on, but that something, although it does come to pass, takes place off page. Mildly irritating, no? The plot is very confused and too much time is wasted on stuff that really makes no sense for me as a reader, almost as if the author's introducing a whole new cast of characters when this is the end of the trilogy - they're not new characters per se, but boy, do they feel like it... I particularly detested Kitty, while Sora had been one of my favourite, albeit never being properly explored, but that's the writer's prerogative: their favourite characters won't always match the readers' choices. Reading this final book in the trilogy felt like the author perhaps had room for 4 books instead of 3 but got tired of the whole lot and wanted to end it as soon as they could. The conclusion was rushed, though the entire book dragged, and the only reason I'm rounding it up to 3 stars is that last chapter, which was beautiful, beautifully written, poignant and felt like someone different from the one penning down the entire novel had written that bit.