The utility in this book is 4*, but I knocked the overall score down, because Cole waaaaay overdoes affirmation for the reader. Not only does this annoy the living daylights out of me, but it is very counterproductive. More on that later.
The intro to this book was SUPER uncomfortable, because it emphasized so much that 1) the reader didn't do anything wrong (how can the author know this?) and is all about "self love" expounding on how caring for others needs to take a back burner to self care.
I recognize that the point of this book is to help those who have self-sacrificed their lives into misery, but that means there's not a balance in their life - not that it's absurd to consider someone else's needs before your own or not to "stay on your side of the street." She walks through this concept later and explains more of what she means. I agree with her insofar as when you want to force your unwanted, unsolicited help on others, you need to stay on your own side of the street. When you try to circumvent feelings others might feel at the sacrifice of your own well-being, you've tried to control what someone else may feel, which is absurd, impossible, etc. Yes.
To be fair, therapy talk and phrases really grind on me with their fluffiness - particularly when it's female to female, (i.e. self-healing, transformational journey, "coming home to your soul," beauty, richness, knowing yourself on a deeper level, "loving reminders," etc.) It kind of gags me, but I understand that's just a personal preference. I also really struggle with the self-promotion: "using my proven self-awareness techniques....this book is for YOU," and perhaps worst of all, "You're AMAZING, by the way." It all hit me like a wave of nausea.
There are a lot of great tools in this book, including framing references, how to reclaim hold of your own life, how to establish boundaries, and what to expect while you heal. I find a vast majority of her self-refection questions at the end of chapters particularly useful and productive. For these things alone, the book is certainly worth picking up. I mostly picked it up out of curiosity, and I certainly learned some things about myself and others. I definitely have some of the tendencies she shares - particularly in certain relationships.
I struggled with Cole's assertions on humility. She claims that we're taught to be humble so people will like us. (That was a completely unmentioned byproduct of why I was taught to be humble.) Later, Cole says she'd always chalked up her own success to luck, but her therapist pointed out that Cole had worked really hard. Cole then agreed that she had worked hard and added, "And I did it by myself." Really? The extremes here really put me off. Why does it have to be one end of the spectrum or the other?
Whether we choose to acknowledge God or not, He still has an enormous hand in our lives. Even for the atheist or agnostic, it is absurd to claim that any human did anything completely on our own. Nobody does everything in their lives themselves. We can work hard, have self-respect, humility, and awareness that we worked hard without claiming we did it ALL ourselves and without claiming it was all luck.
I agree with Cole that we can politely accept praise without being boastful or dismissive of the person offering it. This took a long time for me to learn, because I never struggled with self-esteem. In my youth, if someone offered a compliment, I just couldn't accept it. I felt like accepting was saying, "Yes, you're right! I'm awesome!" which was sooo uncomfortable. It took years to understand how to simply accept a compliment. And I still sometimes struggle with the discomfort of it.
Affirmation statements are not for me, and self-help books drown you in them. Why do therapy authors take it as a given that all of the readers of the their books are amazing and wonderful, etc.? While I realize that the book is geared towards a certain population of people, not everyone - not even all HFCs - thinks they're worthless before they pick up a self-help book, nor is everyone who picks up this type of book an awesome person.
Lastly, it drives me absolutely insane how women chronically over-validate other women, no matter what. In the author's case, even though you've never met and never will meet the reader! Cole gushes, "Remember how strong, capable, and loving you are!" What?! EVERY single woman is ALL of those things? No, we're not! Not even close! Those can be weaknesses also, but we can work on those too if they're recognized. Instead, it's all just glossed over as though it's a given. We (men and women) need to self-assess and judge where we are in all areas. Judgment on things we need to do better doesn't automatically equal self-condemnation.
It seems that nearly every female-written therapy book I read is does this - spends paragraphs telling the (presumably female) reader how amazing and wonderful and incredible they are as if there's nothing to fix except all the self-sacrificing they've been doing for other people. The reader is always the victim. While this book offers some great counsel on how to avoid people pleasing and gearing your life around other people, the freely given over-validation immediately causes these therapists to lose credibility.
Despite the cons, this is still a book I'd recommend to anyone who is miserable with their life or aspects of their life, because they consume themselves overdoing, overthinking, and over-worrying for others.