I knew she was trying to play it cool. We both felt this pull. It was dangerous. Forbidden. But I couldn't stop it if I wanted to. I'd tried for weeks to stay away. Yet here I was. With Saylor Woodson in my arms.
I'm sorry to tell you that I am really disappointed. I was so looking forward to this book! But that's the problem with high expectations, they are hard to meet.
So what do we have here? A charming playboy and his best friend's sister fall in love when she returns to town after a few years away at college. They fight their mutual attraction at first, but can't keep their hands off each other for long, of course. The story starts out cute and funny, unfortunately it got boring quickly when King and Saylor started to argue about the reasons why they can't be together (he's supposedly not good enough for her–the most pretextual argument ever) and then whether or not they should tell Saylor’s brother about their feelings. They spin around in circles, discussing stupid reasons over and over again. And again. And again.
The most stupid reason is Kingston's firm belief that his best friend (!) Hayes would never accept him, the "manwhore", on Saylor's side. Seriously, why??? I never get this point in "best friend's sister"-romances and it always annoys me. I mean, the guys are best friends, they like and respect and trust each other. They have a "bond". Kingston would never, ever risk that friendship if he wasn't serious about Hayes's sister. He's a good guy and a loyal friend, so there’s absolutely no question about that. And Hayes has to know that, so he should appreciate a relationship between the two most important people in his life. Ride or die, huh? (Maybe they repeat the Ride or die-mantra so irritatingly often because they don't believe in it themselves?)
While Saylor and King continue to discuss their options, they test the waters just to find out if the sex/chemistry is even worth the stress with Hayes. They also think they might be able to get "one another out of our systems" this way. Greatest idea ever. Not. Anyway, kissing and making out are allowed, but King may not stick "his sausage in her sauerkraut" (to paraphrase Rammstein). I don't know what to say to this kind of self-deception. It's probably necessary to include a lot of sex scenes in the book.
All in all, the plot is really flat and not much happens between the promising beginning and the eventful ending. The main characters are not especially deep, I liked them despite their somewhat childish behavior and questionable thinking just fine, though. I still love the Ride or die-group and their wives (in particular Ruby and, of course, ❤️River❤️, who still owns my heart and steals the show) and their chats. The way the secondary characters from the town are integrated is also great, so I will definitely return to Magnolia Falls for Nash's book. (Though with less high expectations because, unlike everyone else, I'm not the biggest fan of Beefcake or children in romance novels in general).
Overall rating: 2.5
Story: 2/5
Emotion: 2/5
King: 3/5
Saylor: 3/5
(There might be River and Magnolia Falls bonus points included.)
Bonus points removed on December, 9th. I can't rate it higher than Hayes' book, so I changed the rating from 3 to 2 stars.