Not a Thing is a beautifully heartfelt small-town romance that perfectly blends emotional depth, humor, and healing. Susan Henshaw has once again written a story that feels both warm and raw a tale of two people who have been burned by the past but somehow find exactly what they didn’t know they needed in each other. This book isn’t just about love; it’s about forgiveness, self-worth, and the courage to start over. Christy and Holden’s story had me completely hooked from the start equal parts tender, frustrating, and deeply emotional the kind of love story that sneaks up on you and stays in your heart long after it ends.
The Story
Christy Thornbury thought she’d left her small Wyoming hometown for good along with the pain, the gossip, and her family’s toxic expectations. But when she’s asked to return as the new high school principal, she reluctantly agrees, determined to rebuild her life on her own terms. Enter Holden Dupree: charming, infuriating, and a serial heartbreaker who’s made a habit of keeping things light. When Christy’s sisters hatch a humiliating matchmaking plan, Holden steps in breaking his own rule to never get involved and suddenly, they’re fake dating in a town that thrives on gossip. What starts as a pretend relationship quickly turns into something achingly real as both are forced to confront old wounds, deep secrets, and the possibility that love might actually be worth the risk.
What I Loved
✔️ A perfectly executed fake dating trope with real emotional stakes
✔️ The slow build of trust and affection between Christy and Holden
✔️ Beautifully handled family dynamics and personal growth
✔️ Henshaw’s knack for writing love stories with substance heartfelt, emotional, and mature
✔️ That balance between small-town charm, light humor, and deeper, healing moments
✔️ Closed-door intimacy that focuses on emotional connection over spice
🎧 Narration
Narrated by Summer Roberts and Andrew Gibson, the audiobook is an absolute treat. Summer’s narration captures Christy’s mix of strength and vulnerability with such authenticity, while Andrew gives Holden a perfect blend of charm and quiet intensity. Their chemistry comes through effortlessly the pacing, tone, and emotion make every scene feel alive. Together, they bring the story’s tension, tenderness, and humor to life in a way that makes it impossible to stop listening.
Tropes & Vibes
✔️ Fake Dating
✔️ Small Town Romance
✔️ Second Chances
✔️ Forbidden Love
✔️ Emotional, Closed-Door Romance
✔️ Healing from the Past
✔️ Family Drama & Found Strength
Final Thoughts
Not a Thing is a touching and emotional romance that proves you don’t need spice to feel the heat. Christy and Holden’s journey is full of heart from witty banter and quiet vulnerability to moments that make you smile through tears. Susan Henshaw has a gift for writing stories that explore love’s softer, more complex side the kind that feels lived-in and real. If you love small-town settings, emotional slow burns, and characters who earn their happy ending the hard way, this book will absolutely capture your heart.