I really enjoyed this book. It’s one of those stories you can’t put down, the kind you look forward to all day. As someone who reads mostly at night before bed, I found myself going to bed early just to dive back into it.
Living in Otago, New Zealand, I found the book incredibly relatable. The descriptions of the people, climate, and landscape resonated with me, making it easy to picture the events as they unfolded. The details about life during the Great Depression and the World Wars were eye-opening. Although the wars took place elsewhere, the book captures their impact on New Zealand, something I hadn’t considered in depth before. It felt like the author really did their research.
It also made me realize that I, as a townie, was completely romanticizing true self-sufficiency like Wilhelm’s. It’s a lot of grueling hard work and worry.
The author vividly describes the alternative gardening style introduced by Rudolph Steiner, diving into details without ever being boring or wordy. The writing is both beautiful and engaging.
The author also builds tension remarkably well. I constantly worried about Wilhelm and felt his loneliness throughout.
There was one detail I wonder about: when Wilhelm arrived on his boat, did he have to register or obtain residency? The book doesn’t mention it, and I wondered if such formalities existed back then (1928). It seems he simply sailed in and settled, which might have been more straightforward in those days, at least in terms of documentation.
I loved the detail and character building, especially Wilhelm. Some of the other characters felt a bit flat, a bit one-dimensional, but it didn’t take away from the story. Towards the last 30% of the book (I read it on Kindle), it started to feel more like a contemporary romance, which was a bit different from how it started, but I still enjoyed it.
In the end, it’s an easy five stars from me.
Now that I’ve finished, I’m excited to look up more about the author and see what others are saying about the book.