'Arresting and distinctive... The four stories in this collection are extremely impressive. Each is narrated by a young man who has come to a critical juncture in his life, though in no case does he clearly recognize it as such. The question in each story is whether he will learn from the encounter--whether he will accept new risks and commitments--or whether he will simply retreat into his old defenses... Completely convincing.' - Jonathan Yardley, The Miami Herald
This collection of four short stories is expertly written but lacks feeling or focus. As you read you're like "okay, this is interesting" and after 20 or so pages it ends without any particular message, statement, or conclusion. They're solely character studies of characters in the mid 20th century, so from a historical point of view, I guess they're effective, but I wouldn't recommend them to anyone in particular.
Not impressed with these short stories. Liked the work of William Styron (A Tidewater Morning) and Amor Towles (Table for Two) much better. The story "Connaissance des Arts" was the best, but not that satisfying.
I liked it despite never feeling anything for any of the protagonists. I felt nothing for them, no interest for them; in fact, I found them annoying. Yet the writing kept me and enveloped me. Mr. Casey has an extraordinary ability to craft his thoughts into words but it's some of his thoughts that were not all that enticing. Nonetheless, throughout the four stories, Casey's writing is alluring, singular, textured and poking. My favorite story was that of the young lawyer; second, the naive Army enlistee.
I really enjoyed this collection of four stories by Casey. They read kind of slowly at first, but the further I got into the book, the more I enjoyed the style and prose. Very literary and academic; not at all like Spartina (which I also liked immensely). The last two stories (more like novellas) really made the collection. I only gave it 4 stars, but I still highly recommend this book to anyone interested in really good literature. The prose may not be for everyone though.
Voice, emotion, fluidity in story structure without ever being formula, canned or overly crafted. What a beautiful natural voice, that doesn't fit into any "short story" style I am aware of. You want to say "original" and yet the stories are crafted so that they seem not to have been crafted, as if there is no other way they could be told -- as if form is formless, style is invisible and pure.
Really enjoyed this short story collection, especially the novella, "Connaissance des Arts" and the title story "Testimony and Demeanor". I loved the thematic connection of the four protagonists, all young men reaching a poignant moment of maturity. Casey's writing is delightful.