What do you think?
Rate this book
The Real Mackay: Walter Scott’s Favourite Comedian
Night after night jostling crowds clamour for entry to Edinburgh’s Theatre Royal with one name on their the Real Mackay. But who is he? The answer leaps off the page in this meticulously researched historical novel which plunges the reader into the weird and wonderful golden era of Scottish national drama, seen through the eyes of Charles Mackay and his family. Walter Scott’s favourite comedian dazzles and delights packed audiences across nineteenth-century Scotland for decades, bringing laughter to thousands, including the king. But behind his hilarious stage antics is a man grieving for the women he loses, all of them dying tragically young – his mother, his wife, his daughter. In the grip of unstoppable momentum, his extraordinary popularity casting long shadows over those he loves, will he be forced to choose between fame and family?
346 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 11, 2024
2 people are currently reading
7 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 16 of 16 reviews
June 2, 2024
4.5⭐️
Firstly thank you so much to Helen Graham for my proof copy of this book - I was delighted to be able to read it in advance of the publication date!
I havent read too much historical fiction, particularly Scottish historical fiction, but I feel this may be a springboard for me into the genre as I really found the scene setting and character development so interesting!
This book focuses on the character of Charles Mackay, a nineteenth century comedic theatre actor, and his life across many decades and stages.
I loved the immersive setting of this book and really felt like I was in Edinburgh with the Mackay family and their friends during the periods focused on. This book is clearly incredibly well researched and allows the reader to engage so well with Charles - but also with the theatre setting and the atmosphere these drove. Helen Graham has absolutely done her ancestor proud with this writing!
I thought the character development was great throughout and loved Charles in his later life reflecting on his earlier days in the theatre and his relationships with his wife, children and friends. I also really loved some of the female characters such as Charles's wife Charlotte (who I thought was a wonderful powerhouse), Bella, Dorothy, Charles's mum and his granddaughter Lottie. There were a lot of strong females in Charles's life and I loved how their stories were interwoven. However, these characters are also used to explore the realities of inequality and the difference between men and women during this time really thoughtfully, alongside other difficult topics covering loss, love and family in a sensitive engaging way, that enables you to be there with the characters. This is even more impressive when recognising that the majority of these were based on real people!
I really enjoyed immersing myself in this story and would really recommend for those interested in historical fiction - especially focused on Scotland and the theatre - but I also think its a really well written accessible story for all.
Firstly thank you so much to Helen Graham for my proof copy of this book - I was delighted to be able to read it in advance of the publication date!
I havent read too much historical fiction, particularly Scottish historical fiction, but I feel this may be a springboard for me into the genre as I really found the scene setting and character development so interesting!
This book focuses on the character of Charles Mackay, a nineteenth century comedic theatre actor, and his life across many decades and stages.
I loved the immersive setting of this book and really felt like I was in Edinburgh with the Mackay family and their friends during the periods focused on. This book is clearly incredibly well researched and allows the reader to engage so well with Charles - but also with the theatre setting and the atmosphere these drove. Helen Graham has absolutely done her ancestor proud with this writing!
I thought the character development was great throughout and loved Charles in his later life reflecting on his earlier days in the theatre and his relationships with his wife, children and friends. I also really loved some of the female characters such as Charles's wife Charlotte (who I thought was a wonderful powerhouse), Bella, Dorothy, Charles's mum and his granddaughter Lottie. There were a lot of strong females in Charles's life and I loved how their stories were interwoven. However, these characters are also used to explore the realities of inequality and the difference between men and women during this time really thoughtfully, alongside other difficult topics covering loss, love and family in a sensitive engaging way, that enables you to be there with the characters. This is even more impressive when recognising that the majority of these were based on real people!
I really enjoyed immersing myself in this story and would really recommend for those interested in historical fiction - especially focused on Scotland and the theatre - but I also think its a really well written accessible story for all.
July 11, 2024
This is the fictionalised story of a wee lad from the Lawnmarket in Edinburgh who became one of the biggest stars of the Scottish stage. Helen Graham portrayed Charles first as a lively young boy who loved music and was fascinated by acting. She brought the streets of the late 18th and early 19th century Edinburgh to life for me as Charles visited churches, theatres, shops and other streets, much of which are still familiar.
I particularly enjoyed the stories of Charles’ life on stage from small beginnings to becoming such a famous actor commanding sell-out audiences on stages across the UK. It is incredible to me as an Edinburgh resident to think of the theatres which are no longer around such as The Pantheon in Broughton Street and The Theatre Royal in Shakespeare Square. I only heard of Shakespeare’s Square fairly recently in another book and having looked at photos of the buildings there and of the theatres, it’s hard to believe how different that part of Edinburgh now looks.
One particularly vivid scene for me was reading about the crowds on people on Calton Hill waiting to get a glimpse of King George IV’s procession from the docks in Leith up Leith Walk with the city spread out before them. Its a very different city from now of course but people still flock to Calton Hill for the stunning views of Edinburgh, down to Leith and across the Forth to Fife. Nineteenth century Edinburgh has been vibrantly depicted by Helen Graham.
Charles unwavering commitment to his family is clear throughout the novel. From the devotion of a wee boy for his mother to the great passion he had for his wife Charlotte, from the love he showed his children to the affection he has for his grandchildren, we see how big-hearted Charles was. His love for his family is matched only by his love of the theatre and the arts.
Charles Mackay may largely have been forgotten by the general public, even though his friend and contemporary Sir Walter Scott remains a household name, but Helen Graham has brought her five times great uncle back to life through her words. His name lives on in the phrase ‘The Real Mackay’ and you’ll read about the origins of that in the book. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book about an enthralling era in Scottish theatre history and a fascinating man who deserves to be remembered.
I particularly enjoyed the stories of Charles’ life on stage from small beginnings to becoming such a famous actor commanding sell-out audiences on stages across the UK. It is incredible to me as an Edinburgh resident to think of the theatres which are no longer around such as The Pantheon in Broughton Street and The Theatre Royal in Shakespeare Square. I only heard of Shakespeare’s Square fairly recently in another book and having looked at photos of the buildings there and of the theatres, it’s hard to believe how different that part of Edinburgh now looks.
One particularly vivid scene for me was reading about the crowds on people on Calton Hill waiting to get a glimpse of King George IV’s procession from the docks in Leith up Leith Walk with the city spread out before them. Its a very different city from now of course but people still flock to Calton Hill for the stunning views of Edinburgh, down to Leith and across the Forth to Fife. Nineteenth century Edinburgh has been vibrantly depicted by Helen Graham.
Charles unwavering commitment to his family is clear throughout the novel. From the devotion of a wee boy for his mother to the great passion he had for his wife Charlotte, from the love he showed his children to the affection he has for his grandchildren, we see how big-hearted Charles was. His love for his family is matched only by his love of the theatre and the arts.
Charles Mackay may largely have been forgotten by the general public, even though his friend and contemporary Sir Walter Scott remains a household name, but Helen Graham has brought her five times great uncle back to life through her words. His name lives on in the phrase ‘The Real Mackay’ and you’ll read about the origins of that in the book. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book about an enthralling era in Scottish theatre history and a fascinating man who deserves to be remembered.
May 28, 2024
THE REAL MACKAY
Walter Scott’s Favourite Comedian
Author: Helen Graham
Genre: Historical fiction
Quote: "You always said we were two halves of an orange, Charles - and so we are, my dear, so we are."
Synopsis:
'Night after night jostling crowds clamour for entry to Edinburgh’s Theatre Royal with one name on their lips: the Real Mackay. But who is he?'
Review:
It was brilliant to return to Edinburgh after a 4 year hiatus, albeit it was 18th century Edinburgh, exploring the highs and lows of one of the most famous Scottish actors of the time!
It's been a wee while since I last read historical fiction but this was so easy to dip in and out of. I loved how incredibly well-researched the plot was, everything was enshrined in a stark level of reality. I felt like I was following closely behind Charles Mackay's every foot step!
I thought there was some really interesting commentary on the inequality between female actors and their male counterpart. Mackay's wife, Charlotte, in particular, countlessly proves herself as a serious and talented actress but is held back from an illustrious career by what is heralded as 'women's problems'. Despite only having one episode of ill health strike whilst onstage (which she manages in a very professional manner), she is constantly dismissed from playing bigger parts. In contrast, Charles waits until last minute, whilst ill, before cancelling his appearance in a performance which causes the company a great deal of stress. Despite this, he never receives repercussions, showing the vast inequality in the way men and women's illnesses were treated.
Charles relationship to his family and his dedication to the theatre is a striking force throughout the novel. I especially loved the later chapters depicting his relationship with his Granddaughter. Her love of the theatre really blooms from Charles' own love and devotion to the arts.
Thank you so much to @helengrahamwriter for the lovely proof copy, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this!
The Real Mackay is publishing TODAY!
Walter Scott’s Favourite Comedian
Author: Helen Graham
Genre: Historical fiction
Quote: "You always said we were two halves of an orange, Charles - and so we are, my dear, so we are."
Synopsis:
'Night after night jostling crowds clamour for entry to Edinburgh’s Theatre Royal with one name on their lips: the Real Mackay. But who is he?'
Review:
It was brilliant to return to Edinburgh after a 4 year hiatus, albeit it was 18th century Edinburgh, exploring the highs and lows of one of the most famous Scottish actors of the time!
It's been a wee while since I last read historical fiction but this was so easy to dip in and out of. I loved how incredibly well-researched the plot was, everything was enshrined in a stark level of reality. I felt like I was following closely behind Charles Mackay's every foot step!
I thought there was some really interesting commentary on the inequality between female actors and their male counterpart. Mackay's wife, Charlotte, in particular, countlessly proves herself as a serious and talented actress but is held back from an illustrious career by what is heralded as 'women's problems'. Despite only having one episode of ill health strike whilst onstage (which she manages in a very professional manner), she is constantly dismissed from playing bigger parts. In contrast, Charles waits until last minute, whilst ill, before cancelling his appearance in a performance which causes the company a great deal of stress. Despite this, he never receives repercussions, showing the vast inequality in the way men and women's illnesses were treated.
Charles relationship to his family and his dedication to the theatre is a striking force throughout the novel. I especially loved the later chapters depicting his relationship with his Granddaughter. Her love of the theatre really blooms from Charles' own love and devotion to the arts.
Thank you so much to @helengrahamwriter for the lovely proof copy, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this!
The Real Mackay is publishing TODAY!
May 31, 2024
A carefully researched historical novel about the life of Charles Mackay who was perhaps Sir Walter Scott’s favourite comedian. This was an immersive evocative read that wonderfully wraps the reader in the charged atmosphere of Scottish theatre. Charles’s talent was evident from his younger days and propelled him towards roles that were much sought after. The world he is thrown into is vibrant and competitive but the audiences are fickle and so are the critics. As challenging as things seem for Charles your heart can’t help but go out to the women in his life. A large part of his success is a result of the unconditional love and support that he received from them especially when they were trying to overcome their own grief. Charlotte is perhaps the kindest and most giving character I have ever come across.
The sights and sounds of 18th and 19th century Edinburgh are so vividly described and are paired perfectly with the sensibilities of the people at the time. I highly recommend this for fans of Scottish historical fiction and theatre and look forward to Helen’s next project.
The sights and sounds of 18th and 19th century Edinburgh are so vividly described and are paired perfectly with the sensibilities of the people at the time. I highly recommend this for fans of Scottish historical fiction and theatre and look forward to Helen’s next project.
June 16, 2024
This is such a great historical fiction novel.
Meticulous research, a great story and an engaging writing style combine beautifully and I devoured this book across an afternoon - I couldn’t put it down.
Following the life of the now little known actor and comedian Charles Mackay, the book traces his story from his boyhood in Edinburgh, to his start in acting, to his place as a national icon. The book paints a vivid picture of the world of theatre across the UK but particularly in Edinburgh in the 19th century.
Helen has done a great job of drawing Charles as a likeable but fallible person. A man who undoubtedly loved his family but who perhaps put his career to the fore. His story is wonderfully woven with real people and events of the day and I loved reading about his friendship with Walter Scott and the preparations for the visit of King George IV in 1822.
I was as throughly entertained by this book as those long ago audiences were by the man himself.
Thank you to the author for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
Meticulous research, a great story and an engaging writing style combine beautifully and I devoured this book across an afternoon - I couldn’t put it down.
Following the life of the now little known actor and comedian Charles Mackay, the book traces his story from his boyhood in Edinburgh, to his start in acting, to his place as a national icon. The book paints a vivid picture of the world of theatre across the UK but particularly in Edinburgh in the 19th century.
Helen has done a great job of drawing Charles as a likeable but fallible person. A man who undoubtedly loved his family but who perhaps put his career to the fore. His story is wonderfully woven with real people and events of the day and I loved reading about his friendship with Walter Scott and the preparations for the visit of King George IV in 1822.
I was as throughly entertained by this book as those long ago audiences were by the man himself.
Thank you to the author for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
June 4, 2024
This book was a joyful read. Thank you so much to @helengrahamwriter for sending me a copy.
Historical fiction set in Edinburgh is a favourite of mine. I love learning about buildings that no longer exist or their use has changed. Walking to work, I can now see where the theatres of the Real Mackay's time used to be. This book has opened up a whole new world of learning about Edinburgh.
Mostly, though, the book excels in its story of Charles Mackay and the family he loves so much. The relationships with his wife and later his granddaughter are beautifully laid out in this book.
Tomorrow, I'll walk past the Scott Monument and nod to Sir Walter, knowing I have learned so much more about his favourite comedian.
Historical fiction set in Edinburgh is a favourite of mine. I love learning about buildings that no longer exist or their use has changed. Walking to work, I can now see where the theatres of the Real Mackay's time used to be. This book has opened up a whole new world of learning about Edinburgh.
Mostly, though, the book excels in its story of Charles Mackay and the family he loves so much. The relationships with his wife and later his granddaughter are beautifully laid out in this book.
Tomorrow, I'll walk past the Scott Monument and nod to Sir Walter, knowing I have learned so much more about his favourite comedian.
November 17, 2024
I've not heard of Charles 'The Real' Mackay before, but I thought I'd give this a go to learn some Scottish history.
This is a fictionalised tale of a real person, written by one of his distant relatives, and I think that must be a very difficult task to undertake, so the author should be applauded.
I found the start of the tale slow going and oftentimes repetitive. It wasn't until Charles was in his ageing years and had his grandchildren around him that I really felt I understood him. From that point, I raced through the remainder of the tale.
I don't tend to read historical fiction, but this having a touch of reality to it made it more attractive to me.
For those interested in Scottish history, or indeed The Real Mackay himself, I'm sure you will enjoy this.
This is a fictionalised tale of a real person, written by one of his distant relatives, and I think that must be a very difficult task to undertake, so the author should be applauded.
I found the start of the tale slow going and oftentimes repetitive. It wasn't until Charles was in his ageing years and had his grandchildren around him that I really felt I understood him. From that point, I raced through the remainder of the tale.
I don't tend to read historical fiction, but this having a touch of reality to it made it more attractive to me.
For those interested in Scottish history, or indeed The Real Mackay himself, I'm sure you will enjoy this.
November 20, 2024
I love historical fiction books, especially about time periods or people I am not familiar with and the Real MacKay was an enjoyable one. This book follows the life and career of Charles MacKay, a comedic actor in nineteenth-century Scotland. It immerses readers in the time period, Scotland, and the world of the theater. The struggle to find parts and become part of the theater was well written, for both Charles and his wife Charlotte. I felt for Charlotte and how she was forced to live in her husband’s shadow and never really got to show the extent of her talent. The tragedies in Charles' life were so at odds with the comedic characters he portrayed and it touched my heart. I recommend this book to readers that enjoy historical fiction or the theater.
November 22, 2024
I love fiction that is written around or based upon a real person and so I was so intrigued by this book. I didn't know much about Charles Mackay I have heard of him briefly through some work I had to do for uni but I knew next to nothing so I was excited to delve in and learn more.
This book is well written and I love that the author is a distant relative as you can really see it has been researched and written with a lot of diligence and care. The story line is both interesting and compelling and the characters were really well developed and I found myself wanted to know more and more.
If you love historical fiction especially ones that are based upon real people then I think you will love this.
This book is well written and I love that the author is a distant relative as you can really see it has been researched and written with a lot of diligence and care. The story line is both interesting and compelling and the characters were really well developed and I found myself wanted to know more and more.
If you love historical fiction especially ones that are based upon real people then I think you will love this.
October 26, 2025
Author Helem Graham has done an excellent job in bringing to life this character who was a celebrity in his day and a firm favourite of Sir Walter Scott whose characters he famously brought to life on the stage. I particularly enjoyed the exploration of MacKays humble origins. The depiction of 18th and early 19th century Scotland is meticulously researched while the dialogue is lively and realistic.
It was a real eye-opener to learn about the actor's life and how difficult it was for women to gain a footing. I related very much to Mackay's wife Charlotte but this book is more than a love story. In fact it celebrates a whole family, and the times they lived in, in an entertaining and moving story.
It was a real eye-opener to learn about the actor's life and how difficult it was for women to gain a footing. I related very much to Mackay's wife Charlotte but this book is more than a love story. In fact it celebrates a whole family, and the times they lived in, in an entertaining and moving story.
November 29, 2024
This was such an entertaining and compelling story. I was hooked. For anyone with an interest in theatre, and for anyone who loves historical stories, this should go straight to the top of your Christmas wish list. There is so much detail and information in this book, I can’t begin to imagine how many hours of research were poured into it. The hard work paid off. This is a treasure of a book, one that shines a spotlight on the double life of a comedy entertainer - smiling on stage but crying in the wings. A really good, solid read.
Hard to reconcile that what I have just read is a debut novel.
Hard to reconcile that what I have just read is a debut novel.
November 20, 2024
I read this over 2 sittings and it had me engrossed from page one, I don't know if it was the richly vibrant locations, mentions of the areas that I live near or the charismatic characters that did it. Maybe it was a combination of all three. This was a story of love, loss, family and passions ... and the author did not disappoint on making you feel every emotion that the characters were feeling. I am actually waiting on what she brings out next as I think it will be something that I will want to pick up.
November 19, 2024
The Real Mackay: Walter Scott’s Favourite Comedian by Helen Graham.
This was a good read. I did like the cover. I had to get used to the writing style. The Scottish dialect is something I'm not used to. There were some parts I didn't know the phrases or words. Helen has researched this very well. How nice to discover she was part of the family tree. In some parts, it was sad. I could feel it. This was very well written. I did enjoy the story of Charles Mackay.
This was a good read. I did like the cover. I had to get used to the writing style. The Scottish dialect is something I'm not used to. There were some parts I didn't know the phrases or words. Helen has researched this very well. How nice to discover she was part of the family tree. In some parts, it was sad. I could feel it. This was very well written. I did enjoy the story of Charles Mackay.
August 6, 2024
I was completely engaged by this wonderful story centring around the life of the author's five-times great-uncle, the comedian Charles Mackay. Set in 18/19th century Edinburgh, this well-researched novel taught me much I didn't know about my home town, but for me it was the beautifully-drawn characters and the relationships between them that really made it sing!
July 17, 2024
BLOG TOUR - THE REAL MACKAY by HELEN GRAHAM 📚 🏴
Firstly I am so grateful to the author for gifting me a proof copy of her debut novel, which I absolutely adored.
Historical fiction isn’t my number one genre, to be even more niche, local historical fiction is even further down the pile. However, I surprised myself by being totally pulled in and amerced in this well put together and researched novel focusing around Sir Walter Scott’s favourite comedian’s life inside and outside of the theatre. Helen Graham has done her ancestor, Charles Mackay, very proud.
There are many things I loved, especially the relationships between Charles and the women in his life. The first being his mother, then his wife Charlotte and finally with his Granddaughter Lottie. The love and emotion oozes from the pages. My other notes include the descriptions of Edinburgh and the local history. I’ve learned so much about a period of time and its people that I knew nothing about. Finally, the references to the joy of books and stories just hit me in the heart. I related hard with this element as every piece of love the characters showed towards books is how I feel about books today.
I can’t recommend this book enough.
Favourite Quotes:
‘He had curled his body round her and muttered into her hair be safe, my darling girl, be well and safe.’
‘His books were like old friends and must be treated with respect.’
‘…only the tops of the trees in Drummond Place Gardens poked their heads above the persistent haar still rolling in from the Forth like a wispy white sea.’
As an extra little snippet into my thoughts, here are few questions my partner, Callum, asked me during our discussions about this book.
Q: Would it be a good adaption into a tv series or film?
A: I think so! I can see it translated well into a film or play.
Q: Who is your favourite character?
A: Charlotte! I was rooting for her so much, and felt very strongly for her.
Q: Do you need to like historical fiction to enjoy this book?
A: Not at all. If you love a good story, you’ll enjoy it.
Rating: 4.5⭐️
Firstly I am so grateful to the author for gifting me a proof copy of her debut novel, which I absolutely adored.
Historical fiction isn’t my number one genre, to be even more niche, local historical fiction is even further down the pile. However, I surprised myself by being totally pulled in and amerced in this well put together and researched novel focusing around Sir Walter Scott’s favourite comedian’s life inside and outside of the theatre. Helen Graham has done her ancestor, Charles Mackay, very proud.
There are many things I loved, especially the relationships between Charles and the women in his life. The first being his mother, then his wife Charlotte and finally with his Granddaughter Lottie. The love and emotion oozes from the pages. My other notes include the descriptions of Edinburgh and the local history. I’ve learned so much about a period of time and its people that I knew nothing about. Finally, the references to the joy of books and stories just hit me in the heart. I related hard with this element as every piece of love the characters showed towards books is how I feel about books today.
I can’t recommend this book enough.
Favourite Quotes:
‘He had curled his body round her and muttered into her hair be safe, my darling girl, be well and safe.’
‘His books were like old friends and must be treated with respect.’
‘…only the tops of the trees in Drummond Place Gardens poked their heads above the persistent haar still rolling in from the Forth like a wispy white sea.’
As an extra little snippet into my thoughts, here are few questions my partner, Callum, asked me during our discussions about this book.
Q: Would it be a good adaption into a tv series or film?
A: I think so! I can see it translated well into a film or play.
Q: Who is your favourite character?
A: Charlotte! I was rooting for her so much, and felt very strongly for her.
Q: Do you need to like historical fiction to enjoy this book?
A: Not at all. If you love a good story, you’ll enjoy it.
Rating: 4.5⭐️
Read
October 14, 2024If you are viewing this on the page of Helen Graham professor of Modern Spanish history, it is not my author page and I'm doing all I can to get it taken down from this page. My author page has the Goodreads author symbol by my name and a number of reviews and ratings.
Helen Graham, author of The Real Mackay
Helen Graham, author of The Real Mackay
Displaying 1 - 16 of 16 reviews