I wanted to like this; I love a good werewolf novel, I knew what I was getting into with the age gap—it's in the title on Kindle— but there was so much about the character dynamic that was non-consentual, that I can't responsibly rate it higher.
It lost a star for each of these:
1. The dominance kink was never properly discussed between them, so there were no boundaries set of the MMC's behaviour, and we can tell as readers that the FMC wants his protection not only as a role play in safe settings but genuine in violent ones. His reactions after those are not kind & compassionate nor with pre-established permissions to insult or hit her. The problem I had is that he's supposed to be this protective figure in her life, but even knowing she's come from a background of domestic violence, and knowing she has anxiety, and also never having discussed how they should navigate her panic attacks, his immediate reaction to her being terrified of malevolent ghost is to call her names, slap her, and smack her.
2. There were far to many instances that were coercive rather than consentual. I can't count them all but there were a few occasions she told him to stop and he agreed, "and then he..." etc. Or he used her own arousal as reason to continue without her express permission. She's telling him she doesn't think this is a good idea, and then it all goes ahead anyway. If they'd established their own code of acceptable consentual non-consent I wouldn't be complaining about this, but it made these interactions off putting and exploitative of her lack of assertiveness, rather than a dynamic that benefits both of them equally in different roles.
3. The writing style isn't for me, there's a lot of repetitive phrases, and I got really bored of hearing about her boobs honestly, and I found some of the phrasing quite clunky. Again, I did really want to like this story, and I think it could, with a bit of editing, and a healthier relationship dynamic, be an enjoyable escapism, but to often I found myself putting it down and unwilling to continue.
4. Aside from him completely disregarding her verbal instructions to leave her alone, he chases her down in the woods when it states clearly she was terrified of him. I'm really uncomfortable with this, especially with Maddy being 19, we need to stop normalising being afraid of the men who, mere pages later, are taking complete physical advantage.
5. I just didn't like Maddy, which isn't her fault, just at 19 I had nothing in common with her personality, although her life; working a job while in education and caring for abusive people, was a parallel, I couldn't quite relate to her complete naivety in certain areas. There was so much potential her for me to have felt kinship, but it just didn't pan out, she seemed to swing to vastly between the responsibilities of a late teen, and also immaturity. She didn't feel like even a confused character, but an ill established one, and came off maybe more like a 16 year old (I accept there's a lot of cultural differences though, which might be why she seems so young at 19.)
6. Lastly, I know it's a werewolf book and violence is to be expected, but we shouldn't as a result expect the main character to accept witnessing several murders and just be fine with that, when she doesn't come from a culture where murder is permitted. The book itself was quite long but the timescale she's expected to accept all this is rediculously short, even of we had maybe a week or two of her regular life implied in a paragraph between chapters just to make it feel less rushed.
So it lost 6 stars, but there were parts I liked, and I've been harsh on it in the hope that feedback might improve future books or at least warn anyone who will be triggered by themes like abuse, coercive control, degrading language without prior consent, etc. to avoid it for their wellbeing.
Things I liked:
Bea. I think she's a really intriguing character, and I want to know more about her. They did suffer a bit from speaking mainly about boys and men whenever they talk, and it would have been nice to see them have more of a friendship outwith the menfolk. Very intregued by how she, and Gareth's mother could be expanded on as individuals.
Becca. Her concerns were completely valid and I'm glad someone expressed them.
The part where he was teaching her to drive. She's clearly very sensitive to criticism, and has serious anxiety. That part was handled well, and I got to really like Gareth during that scene, which is partly why I was disappointed by his reaction later in the haunted house, and in general by the lack of prior conversation around informed consent, precautions, aftercare etc. He goes from physically laying hands on her and name calling, to being so caring when they're exiting the haunted house it's tempting to forgive him, but overall it just feels Maddy is never given the choices she deserves in how she wants to be treated. If she's had just a couple of paragraphs earlier saying being slapped in the face is how she would like to be brought out of a panic attack, and she's into it, that would be different. Or if he'd hugged her then and taken her calmly outside like he does later, also fine.
If you got this far, thanks for reading, I hope if it was before you read the book I've only given info to make an informed choice on whether it's your cup of tea.