Carolina Isle was a very, very weird book to me...
Let me explain. This book should not be advertised as "romance" or a story where cousins switch identities. I read the back of the book, which claimed Ms. Deveraux's novel was about Ariel and Sara switching their roles, and I read the actual book, which spent relatively no time on that at all! I think this would upset many people—myself included—to advertise it as such, when about 80% of the novel is actually of the mystery/thriller genre.
R.J. says himself that the switch of identities for the two women didn't last five minutes—and it really didn't.
I hated the beginning. It was unbelievable, boring, and bland. I expected it to be about a Carolina Isle—explaining the beauty of the ocean, giving a taste of classic love, and explaining Sara's connection to Arundel. But from Page 2 on, I realized that this book was nothing like the cover implies.
I will admit that I began to enjoy the novel as it went along. By the time the four member group made it to the titular Isle, I realized how hooked I was. Jude Deveraux isn't the best writer, but she definitely has skill, and I enjoyed the story. I loved the mystery, I loved wondering what was going on, but then again: I signed up to read this thinking it was about cousins switching places? Like a North Carolina version of The Parent Trap? Yeah, not what I expected.
Meanwhile character development did suffer quite a bit. I hated everyone until mid-novel, where I really, really enjoyed the relationship between R.J. and Sara. But in the end, everything ceases in a lightning-quick motion, and it was all completely predictable—unlike the story's main portion.
That being said, I almost put the book down at page 30. But I kept going and was pleasantly surprised that this book kept me focused long enough to finish it. The beginning deserved a meager star, but the middle boosted my rating. The ending though, let's just say...nothing.