Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Star-Spangled Heresy: Americanism

Rate this book
Americanism is a heresy which five different popes have condemned. But what is it? Perhaps the best characterization of Americanism was given by Leo XIII’s biographer Msgr. T’ “A spirit of independence which passed too easily from the political to the religious sphere.” “That the Church and State ought to be separated is an absolutely false and pernicious error ... It limits the action of the State exclusively to the pursuit of public prosperity during this life, though this is only the proximate raison d’etre of political societies.” – Pope St. Pius X in Vehementer “It is unlawful to follow one line of conduct in private life and another in public, respecting privately the authority of the Church, but publicly rejecting it; for this would amount to joining together good and evil, and to putting man in conflict with himself; whereas he ought always to be consistent, and never in the least point not in any condition of life to swerve from Christian virtue.” – Leo XIII in Immortale Dei “Believe me, the evil I denounce is more terrible than the Revolution, more terrible even than the Commune. I have always condemned liberal Catholicism, and I will condemn it forty times over if it be necessary!” – Pius IX

232 pages, Kindle Edition

First published January 1, 1993

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Solange Hertz

20 books8 followers
An established writer before the Second Vatican Council, Solange Hertz wrote for most Catholic periodicals and had five books to her credit, one a selection of the Catholic Literary Foundation. When she refused to adjust her theology to the new “Spirit of Vatican II,” her manuscripts almost overnight became unacceptable to her former editors. After a series of articles on feminine spirituality for the old Triumph magazine, she continued speaking for tradition by successfully producing The Thought of Their Heart and Sin Revisited on her own.

In 1973 she began writing the Big Rock Papers, published privately throughout the next decade and the source of the highly acclaimed Star Spangled Heresy: Americanism, published in 1992. Currently her articles can be found in The Remnant, and abroad in Apropos, Christian Order and Action Familiale et Scolaire. Mrs. Hertz is universally regarded as one of traditional Catholicism’s foremost writers.

Solange Hertz died on October 3, 2015 in Ashburn, VA. She was 95 years old. For more information on her life, visit http://solange.strikingly.com

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
16 (61%)
4 stars
7 (26%)
3 stars
1 (3%)
2 stars
1 (3%)
1 star
1 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews
Profile Image for Vincent.
67 reviews3 followers
June 13, 2013
The Good: fantastic quotes that shed a different light on American history; ends with a bang

The Bad: some dry topics; quizzical start

In the beginning of her book, Hertz rightly preps you for what you are about to read with some quotes from important people:

Henry Ford said history is bunk. Napoleon called it "a collection of lies statesmen have agreed upon." After the execution of the French king, Hebert told the French revolutionary assembly, "History will have to be re-written for the people," and it was.

She does this because the perspective on history that she is about to present to you will be markedly different from that of your textbooks and other sources. To begin, she links the ancient craft of alchemy and its occult roots to science.

Albert Pike, high priest of the Luciferians, knew whereof he spoke when he said, "At the bottom of magic ... was science!"

Her discussion on the history of alchemy as she tries to connect it to modern science and freemasonry is quizzical and tedious to read, exemplified by the following passage:

Others allege that Einstein's space/time continuum lay concealed for centuries in the obscure language of the eighth of the Emerald Tablets of Hermes Trismegistus, legendary founder of Alchemy, where it can be deciphered today by the initiate.

She goes on to say that the satanic purpose of science is to prove there is nothing supernatural, and that this coincides nicely with the Freemason state of mind. She then quotes Bernard Fay, who vividly recalls an interesting social event Benjamin Franklin was at. Talking with a friend, Franklin stated:

that the Biblical miracles no longer seemed like miracles to him, that he could calm the waters quite as easily as Jesus Christ.

As his guests surrounded him with curiosity, Franklin went to a small pond which rippled with currents. He waved his cane over the water in several mystical swoops, and after a few moments, the water became like glass. Upon seeing this, his guests were stunned. Franklin retreated with his friend, revealing to him that his cane was hollow, filled with oil, which is what he dispersed gently onto the pond to create the glass effect. After seeing the great commotion this caused among his guests, the two of them laughed. Thus, Franklin mocked Jesus' miracles, regarding them as cheap parlor tricks.

Hertz then continues documenting the country's Masonic roots with an eye-opening passage:

Any citizen doubting that the Old Religion of the alchemists is the state religion of the U.S. need only make a pilgrimage to the nation's capital, beginning with the Prayer Room established in the Capitol by joint resolution of Congress in 1954. He will find there for his devotion a small central altar flanked by two seven-branched candelabra, above which rises a stained glass window showing George Washington kneeling. Below the Father of his country is the Great Seal of the United States. Above him is the truncated pyramid surmounted by the eye of Horus which constitutes the seal of Masonry and the Illuminati.

As we know from one of her previous books, "the Old Religion" refers to devil worship, which she alleges is at the heart of Freemasonry. Hertz goes on to detail the overwhelming influence of Freemasons on the United States, listing off all the Presidents which were Freemasons:

According to material published by the Masonic Service Association, Masons who succeeded Washington in the Presidency were Jefferson, Madison, Monroe, Jackson, Polk, Buchanan, Johnson, Garfield, McKinley, Theodore Roosevelt, Taft, Harding, Franklin D. Roosevelt and Truman, to which list we must add Dwight Eisenhower and Gerald Ford. An impressive roster.

However, the blame for Americanism is not totally placed on the Freemasons, but also on the Catholic hierarchy which was tainted with Masonic principles. Notable figures in the Americanist movement include Archbishop Carroll and his two brothers, as well as Bishop Ireland, Bishop Keane, and Cardinal Gibbons.

The chapters on the Americanist clergy are sprinkled with various quotes from popes who in all honesty do a better job than Hertz at enunciating how the many aspects of Americanism are in conflict with Catholicism. Clearly Rome recognized what was happening in America. To combat it, in Vatican I the dogma of Papal Infallibility was defined which gave the pope a sharp weapon to wield in upholding the traditions of the Catholic Church. Using this weapon, Pius IX wrote ex cathedra his Syllabus of Errors, categorically and authoritatively condemning Americanist principles such as "separation of Church and state." But this proved ineffective simply because it was disregarded by American bishops. Indeed, it's a funny thing how a truckload of papal pronouncements condemning Americanism can be hidden so well. Perhaps it's because our founders were so successful at creating a system that would protect us from the dangers of "foreign influence."

There is also some material on the Civil War as well as the cultural diffusion which took place for the sake of the Americanist cause. In total, half of the book is composed of historical events related to the Americanist movement, which makes it a somewhat drier read. Nevertheless, these areas still have plenty of merit for the unique light they shine on American history.

In the last quarter of the book, the gloves finally come off. Hertz lets loose a barrage of absolutely vicious points like the following:

In the very heart of the Passion [Jesus] was pleased to show us "democracy" in action, manipulated by the instruments of Satan. Pilate, turning to the people in hopes of saving the Prisoner he knew to be innocent, asks, "What, then, am I to do with Jesus who is called Christ?" And they answered, prompted by their leaders, "Let him be crucified!" (Matt. 27:22-23) and elected Barabbas. Thus was our Lord's death demanded and ratified by Jews who had espoused the democratic process, preferring human rule to God's. Let there be no mistake. The real objective of the liberty, equality and fraternity touted by the forces of humanism is always the death of God.

Has there ever been a Catholic apologist who has written with such teeth as Solange Hertz? Upon finishing Star-Spangled Heresy, it will be undeniable to the reader that Americanist principles are in conflict with Catholicism, which is the ultimate objective Hertz sought to achieve.
Profile Image for JW.
275 reviews10 followers
February 2, 2022
A traditionalist Catholic critique of both the United States of America and the American Catholic Church (as opposed to the Catholic Church in America). A strength of the book, and something which should have been developed more, was Hertz’s focus on the ethnic dimension in the development of the Church in the USA. Specifically, the dominance of the Irish over other European immigrant groups. Hertz acknowledges that not all Irish churchmen were “Americanists”, but she does cast Irish prelates as the promoters of American values in Catholicism. Hertz presents the Irish as opposed to the formation of ethnically based parishes; for example, German language churches. She feels that such groups would have resisted Hibernian “Americanism”. But would they have? And anyways, many parishes were ethnically identified. A parish formed by Polish immigrants, for example, would be staffed by Polish religious and would offer services in that language.
But whether you agree with her thesis or not, Hertz does have a point. Americanism, or just call it modern liberal democracy, is in many ways a successor faith to humanity’s older beliefs. You can believe in any religion, or no religion, but you must conform your beliefs to liberal tolerance. The old Catholic belief that the Church defined truth is no longer a socially valid truth claim.
Profile Image for James Hazeldean.
32 reviews4 followers
May 5, 2024
Another very interesting book, this time on the origins of liberal Catholicism. In this it is noted that it is originally an Irish Catholic heresy, with the Irish Catholics in America embracing liberalism in the colonies to free themselves from British persecution.

It also makes the point that the Irish have no history of self governance, and so when set free to do so they immediately floundered.
83 reviews7 followers
July 12, 2019
I can't say that I understood everything or agreed with everything, but this book certainly offers a lot to think about especially in light of what continues to develop in this country and around the world.
Profile Image for Donald Dudley.
64 reviews2 followers
January 19, 2014
I thought the book could have been 100 pages shorter and still make the point. As a catholic and American I was left after reading not really buying into it all. I can certainly see how the progressive secularists want to achieve her fears but I do not see how that coopts American style democracy or the predominantly Christian people of America.

I found the writing style to be too laborious as well. Perhaps that colored my opinion.
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews