When I saw a Lois Lowry book on Netgalley, I jumped at the chance to read what I thought was a new release from her! Upon diving into this book, I realized that this book is actually a re-release of a standalone book that she wrote and published in 1987. I'm not sure what prompted the publisher to do this with this particular book.
Upon diving in, this book reads like it is historical fiction, and I suppose that it is now, given that from a few clues (the character's watch Karate Kid) that this book is set in the Mid to Late 1980's. But remove the few references to television and a specific movie, and this book actually feels much older. The things the characters talk about and do, the way that the Mom's mental health issues are treated, this book just feels more like something from the 1950's to me.
Lois Lowry is a master at getting reader's invested in her characters and immersed into a specific place. It all was such a clear picture in my mind of the 2 main girls as they are going through their life. This is very much a coming of age story. And we do see our characters grow and change over the course of it. However, a lot of it just feels like it almost wouldn't even be relatable to today's children on many levels. Here's some of the reasons why, Rabble's mother's name is Sweet Hosanna, however, throughout the book she is called Sweet-Ho, I can already hear the middle schoolers giggling over that alone. Mrs. Bigelow, the mother of the other FMC in the book seems to be suffering from post-partum depression, the family deals with this mostly by ignoring it and her, and having Sweet-Ho come in and take over everything. Then when the mother has a breakdown she is institutionalized in a hospital for the duration of the novel. The third thing that was off putting for me, was that there is a male character in the book who throws a rock at the female characters on Halloween when they are trick-or-treating and actually hits the 90-something year old woman who owns the house in the head, injuring her! This is explained off, as boy's do things like this to get girl's attention. And while, this boy as a character also grows, he really never has to face any consequences of his negative behavior. Also, that's not how we get people's attention when we like them. There is a weird dynamic between Mr. Bigelow, the dad, and Sweet-Ho, the live-in housekeeper as well, when the mom is in the hospital that just made it all a bit weird.
So while there were things that I liked, there were also things that were a miss for me.
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for an e-arc in exchange for my honest opinion.