Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Petrie and Pettigrew #2

The Case of the Stolen Goddess

Rate this book
Flinders smiled. “Once more into the breach, my friend.”

Now famous after their previous quest to find Cleopatra’s tomb, detectives Flinders Petrie and Thomas Pettigrew begin their next adventure in search of a stolen statue of Aphrodite. Their pursuit takes them from the bowels of the British Museum to the barren desert of Syria and the glamorous bustle of Istanbul. At every step, they are confronted by two incredibly evil the Bulbul Pasha, a giant of a man who sings like a nightingale while he kills, and the Veiled One, a horribly disfigured monster who lives only for revenge. On the way, they meet T. E. Lawrence and Gertrude Bell, who are excavating a site in Syria. Lawrence leads them to a crusader castle and into a surreal battle with the Bulbul, but the statue still eludes them. With Gertrude’s help, the detectives enlist the aid of British Intelligence, which uses a ring of male and female belly dancers to track the statue to the Veiled One’s harem. Disguised as dancers, the detectives infiltrate it, setting up a climactic duel in the desert.

Set against the backdrop of an oncoming war, this book is a window into the lush complexity of the Ottoman Empire, the stark life of the desert bedouin, and steadily vanishing societies. Our protagonists enter a world of beauty and barbarity to find an artifact but find the hauntings of memory and perhaps a strange peace as well. The action that drives this unpredictable narrative will leave you eagerly awaiting the next installment in the Petrie and Pettigrew series.

239 pages, Kindle Edition

First published April 25, 2024

19 people are currently reading
2915 people want to read

About the author

John Amos

17 books16 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
6 (13%)
4 stars
14 (31%)
3 stars
15 (33%)
2 stars
8 (17%)
1 star
2 (4%)
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews
Profile Image for Ivonne Rovira.
2,551 reviews253 followers
February 17, 2025
It’s the mid-1910s, and Flinders Petrie and Thomas Pettigrew have come a long way from when they started in the detective business in 1885; they’re now relatively famous and solidly middle aged. But the bachelor detectives miss the adventure of the Middle East.

Enter the head of the British Museum, where a priceless statuette of Aphrodite has been stolen. There’s murder and mayhem to follow, and Petrie and Pettigrew head to Syria to get the stolen goddess back.

I’m glad to say that author John Amos found himself the editor and the proofreader he lacked on this series’ debut The Cleopatra Caper. The plot is much more concise and coherent, and the typos, misspellings and syntax errors are gone. I enjoyed The Case of the Stolen Goddess much more — just not so much as to give the third entry in the series a chance.
Profile Image for Reading With  Ghosty.
173 reviews76 followers
June 6, 2024
Well rounded and at times funny. The second book in the series. Honestly though wasn't my cup of tea.

Many thanks to Goodreads, River Grove Books and John Amos for a copy of the book. All opinions are of my own.
Profile Image for BONNIE SMITH.
443 reviews65 followers
June 7, 2024
What does a reading addict do when they find themselves on a plane and has accidentally packed their reading material in their checked bag?
They sigh in relief remembering the Kindle app on their phone!!

And so I found myself yesterday on a flight home, and decided this little nugget would be save me.
This is a great read for Indiana Jones and The Mummy fans for the anthropological and archeological aspects to this adventure.
Flinders Petrie and Thomas Pettigrew (how great are those names) are in search of the statue of Aphrodite, which inconveniently has been stolen. This trek will take them to exotic places and collaborating with the oddest of characters, including a group of bellydancers.
The antagonists are perfectly diabolical and the characters met along the way contribute to some downright silly moments.
After completing this I just knew I was missing something and found this is a follow up novel, which makes sense. The dynamic between our two detectives had some inside jokes I felt needed some insight on, so I do wish I had read the first, while this can stand alone easily.

I received this Kindle edition as a Goodreads giveaway, thank you to the author for a chance to read and review.
Profile Image for Tiera Aubrey.
Author 2 books78 followers
January 17, 2025
Thank you for choosing me to win this, Goodreads!

This is book 2 in the series and it was interesting and fun but sadly not my preferred writing style.

It has two friends looking back on adventures (very Holmes & Waston feel), but between the time hopping and the slower pacing style, I just got bored.
226 reviews4 followers
December 29, 2024
A small marble sculpture of Aphrodite was stolen from the British Museum. The curator, E. A. Wallis Budge, sought the help of the famous detectives on Baker Street. Maybe not the most famous detective, but after their success in Egypt, the capable and dynamic duo of Petrie And Pettigrew, Detectives. The team of Flinders Petrie and Doctor Thomas Pettigrew looked into the theft at the museum and discovered it to also include murder. With the high stakes and danger, only Flinders and Pettigrew were up to the challenge. The pair sailed to Syria and met up with T.E. Lawrance and Gertrude Bell. With their help, the detectives embarked on a thrilling journey to track down the mysterious Veiled One, who employed the assassins that stole the statue of the goddess.

The Case of the Stolen Goddess: A Petrie and Pettigrew Novel is a historical crime fiction by John Amos. A part glimpse into the enigmatic world of the pre-World War One Ottoman Empire and part detective novel, this book is two stories in one. Amos uses famous cultural personalities and places significant to the period unsparingly. Readers are given a window into a past and a place of great cultural relevance. Amos also pays tribute to the great detectives of literature. It is not hard to find references and reverence of Doyle’s Sherlock Homes, Chesterton’s Father Brown, and Christie’s Hercule Poirot. Though these Easter eggs add a certain level of fun, they seem to take away from the overall story.

As a historical fiction, Amos’ novel paints an impressive and accurate picture of the early 1900s Middle East, Eastern Europe, and Northern Africa and its importance in art and culture. From the once in vogue and barbaric practice of Mummy dissection to historic occult figures of the area, Amos brings to light a lot of forgotten histories. As a detective novel, unfortunately, this book falls short. The overall plot is often interrupted by internal dialogue and the historical Easter eggs, interrupting the pacing of this novel. I had such high hopes for this book because who doesn’t love a crime story about a stolen statue?

For readers looking for an entertaining and humorous historical fiction book, Amos’ book provides a great look into a fascinating time and place. Though the detective story has many holes, there is still plenty of intrigue and danger, along with many people and places from another time and place.

This Review was Originally Published at https://sandiegobookreview.com/produc...
Profile Image for Ana Beatriz.
247 reviews17 followers
April 22, 2024
Thank you to Net Galley for the arc. I want to start this review by acknowledging that there is a prequel to this book that I wasn’t aware of when I started reading and that some of my problems with this book might have something to do with that lack of context. 

First for the positives: The premise and setting were so interesting (like Sherlock meets Indiana Jones?? Sign me up). I loved the archeology part and that historical figures like Freud and Poe were mentioned. You can also tell that the author is very knowledgeable about the setting and it was interesting to learn about. I’ve never read anything like this and would definitely pick up similar books in the future. The story was gripping and it was a quick read.

My biggest problem was, by far, the writing. First of all, the book is written in a 3rd person perspective, but there were these (in my opinion) random paragraphs from the perspective of one of the main characters. I feel like that was an attempt to add depth to the character, but it just felt weird and unnecessary. We also have a serious case of “men writing women” syndrome. Out of the 5 women mentioned in the book (two of them not being actual characters and just mentioned when they talked about previous adventures), 3 were a sexual interest to the main character. We get the exact same scene of him sleeping and some woman lying next to him THREE TIMES. The female characters have no depth whatsoever and basically have the same personality. The last issue I had was that things simply were way too convenient. First, in the initial investigation, this supposedly impossible-to-catch guy just left scraps of fabric, footprints, and a full-on note about what he was doing with the stolen object. Then, the main character’s dad knows exactly who they’re dealing with. And in the battle scenes, you’re telling me that this middle-aged dude who used to mess around with swords in university simply beats a guy who is constantly described as a giant and has murdered entire villages?? I don’t think so.

The last comment I have is not about the book itself, but I think that the synopsis provided on Goodreads spoils pretty much the whole book.
Profile Image for ✨ ੈ✩‧April ♡ ʚ♡⃛ɞ✨.
470 reviews23 followers
June 18, 2024
John Amos's "The Case of the Stolen Goddess" is a thrilling and intricately plotted mystery that will captivate fans of the genre. Set against a backdrop of ancient artifacts and modern intrigue, this novel expertly weaves together suspense, adventure, and a touch of historical fascination.

Amos introduces readers to a compelling protagonist, a seasoned detective with a keen eye for detail and an unyielding determination to solve the case. The plot kicks off with the mysterious theft of a priceless statue, known as the Goddess, from a prestigious museum. As the detective delves into the investigation, he encounters a web of deceit, hidden motives, and unexpected twists that keep readers on the edge of their seats.

One of the strengths of "The Case of the Stolen Goddess" is Amos's ability to create a vivid and immersive setting. The descriptions of the museum, the ancient artifacts, and the various locations visited during the investigation are rich and evocative, adding depth to the story and making the world feel authentic and engaging.

The characters in the novel are well-developed and multifaceted, each with their own secrets and complexities. The interactions between the detective and the suspects are particularly well-crafted, filled with tension and intrigue. Amos does an excellent job of maintaining suspense throughout the novel, gradually revealing clues and red herrings that keep readers guessing until the very end.

While the pacing of the story is generally well-handled, there are moments where the narrative slows down, particularly during some of the more detailed historical explanations. However, these sections are informative and add an extra layer of depth to the story, even if they occasionally interrupt the momentum.

Overall, "The Case of the Stolen Goddess" is a thoroughly enjoyable mystery that combines historical elements with a modern detective story. John Amos's skillful storytelling and well-drawn characters make this a standout novel in the genre. It’s a must-read for mystery enthusiasts looking for a gripping and intellectually stimulating adventure.
53 reviews1 follower
June 15, 2024
**Giveaway**

John Amos's "The Case of the Stolen Goddess" is a thrilling mystery that evokes elements of both 007 and Indiana Jones, despite being firmly rooted in the mystery genre rather than espionage. Featuring an ensemble of striking female characters, the narrative sets up its detectives, Flinders Petrie and Thomas Pettigrew, as contemporaries who could rival Sherlock Holmes in their deductive prowess.

Initially, I found myself a bit lost, unaware that this book followed a predecessor. Understanding this earlier connection would have likely enriched my reading experience. Between the two detectives, although Flinders is presented in a more charismatic light, I personally found Thomas Pettigrew more compelling.

The novel itself is accessible and engaging, with an intense finale that leaves some questions tantalizingly open, including a pivotal decision by Pettigrew. To uncover the mysteries yourself, I recommend diving into the book. Reading the first book in the series beforehand might enhance your appreciation and understanding of the characters and their dynamics.
Profile Image for Theresa.
4,128 reviews16 followers
August 3, 2024
‘The Cleopatra Caper’ is before this one. This is the 2d of an unlabeled series.

Thomas Pettigrew and his friend Flinders Petrie are beginner detectives trying to copy Sherlock Holmes. They recently searched for the tomb of Cleopatra, but didn’t find it. But their search has brought them recognition that goes to Flinders head. Then they are sent to Istanbul to investigate the theft of a statue of Aphrodite.

Flinders is the adventurous, enthusiastic partner, while Pettegrew is negative and morose. But the spend too much time in silly conversation and empty arguments. Started to get bored listening to them talk about doing stuff and waiting for something to really happen.

Also I don’t like the old fashion custom of opening Egyptian mummies as a society event and don’t want to read about it. It’s inhumane and repulsive. So I skipped over all that. Went a little farther and still couldn’t get interested enough so I moved on to another book. This isn’t for me.

Fave Scenes: research mail and friendly questioning.
Profile Image for Rediswow.
60 reviews
August 25, 2024
The Case of the Stolen Goddess by John Amos a great mystery read. Throughout this book I felt as though I was missing something, big chucks of the story didn’t make sense. I figured out this is a follow up novel, while it can be read as a standalone I wish I would have known and read in order.
Detectives Flinders Petrie and Thomas Pettigrew begin their next adventure in search of a stolen statue of Aphrodite. They enter a world of beauty and barbarity to find an artifact but find the hauntings of memory and perhaps a strange peace as well.
Exotic places, silly moments, diabolical characters.
I received this Kindle edition as a Goodreads giveaway, thank you to the author for a chance to read and review.
Profile Image for Kim Layman.
201 reviews11 followers
April 22, 2024
This novel harkens back to the old fashioned British crime novels, and gives us two lovable detectives. One is self-confident and cocky, and the other is morose and introspective. Amos leads the reader on a chase through several countries on the hunt for a prized artifact, and possibly to the death of our crime-solving duo. Through engaging prose, the author takes us from a “whodunit” to a “can-they-catch-the-man-who-did-it?”, all while giving us humorous situations, and heart-breaking realities. It’s a well-rounded book that was enjoyable from start to finish, and I would recommend it to others.

Thank you NetGalley and River Grove for my ARC. My opinion is my own.
32 reviews1 follower
August 21, 2024
I had a hard time getting into this book. A stream of conscience- like remembrance of past events would interrupt the flow of the narrative. It felt intrusive rather than giving a greater context to what was currently happening. The previous adventure was hinted at and seemed more interesting then the current mystery they were embroiled in. I didn’t realize that this was the 2nd book in a series and that the previous book should have been read before this one. Even knowing that the 1st book covers the mystery referred to, I’m not sure I would go back and read it.
Thank you to Goodreads for providing me with an advanced review copy for free, and I am reviewing this voluntarily
142 reviews15 followers
July 1, 2024
The Case of the Stolen Goddess by John Amos is an enthralling and masterfully crafted mystery that keeps readers on the edge of their seats from start to finish. Amos's knack for intricate plotting and vivid character development shines through in this captivating tale of intrigue and adventure. The story is a perfect blend of suspense, wit, and clever twists that will delight mystery enthusiasts. Amos's engaging writing style and the richly detailed setting make this book an absolute page-turner. Highly recommended for anyone who loves a good whodunit with a dash of historical allure!
2 reviews
September 30, 2024
Interesting and used a lot of history to draw the reader

Good read and was interesting with reference to Ottoman history. Details kept the story line flowing. It was a learning experience for me about another time and people. Good story line. Did need some more background on some of the characters referenced in the character’s thoughts. I did notice at end of the book there was book about Cleopatra so that maybe where the characters I didn’t know were.
Profile Image for Anastasia.
12 reviews
October 22, 2024
Thank you Goodreads for the Giveaways copy of this book.
Detectives Flinders Petrie and Thomas Pettigrew search for a stolen statue of Aphrodite through Syria and Istanbul. The Bulbul Pasha and the Veiled One fight their progress. The detectives encounter many people along the way who aid their progress and change their thinking of the world.
The story was a bit hard for me to follow. I definitely got into it at times but it was hard to keep the characters straight.
Profile Image for Ashleigh Pressy.
79 reviews1 follower
May 24, 2024
Enjoyed but at times felt lost

I won this Kindle edition through a Goodreads giveaway, thanks for the giveaways because they expand my reading horizons!

Throughout this book from the beginning I felt as though I was missing big chunks of the story and yes, I figured it must be part of a series! Yes I was correct and me myself not being a series gal wouldn't have entered this particular giveaway. With all that being said I did finish in a day and it got me out if a major reading slump!

I felt like I was getting The Mummy or Indiana Jones vibes but no there are is no mummy. Investigation into mysterious items and into distant areas was enough to keep me reading.
Profile Image for Jeanette Marie.
182 reviews5 followers
October 25, 2024
Flinders and Pettigrew are at it again! They’re on the case of retrieving a stolen statue! I enjoyed this one, almost as much as The Cleopatra Caper! I’d recommend reading The Cleopatra Caper first prior to reading this one, as this book does have character flashbacks. Overall a great book, would love to see more books of these two!
795 reviews34 followers
March 25, 2025
The Case of the Stolen Goddess

This story started out very interesting. Then it turned into another book with its own plot. Then it finished up sounding like the first book. For me, it was difficult to follow along and make sense of it. It seemed like it was trying to represent every genre there is in writing, but the at expense of the story.

#GoodreadsGiveaway
Profile Image for Lycett T.
36 reviews2 followers
July 6, 2025
DNF

I didn't start with the first book in this series and it showed - the characters were hard to keep straight. There were a ton of minor characters that all ran together and the female ones felt like they were just there to check boxes or be love interests. I tried to get into it but this book just wasn't my thing.

*Giveaway copy received by Goodreads*
Profile Image for AMAO.
1,927 reviews45 followers
July 14, 2024
✍️✍🏼✍🏽
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Riley K. .
840 reviews14 followers
September 24, 2024
Really enjoyed the plot and the characters. Thought it was well written. Will recommend to others.
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.