What do you think?
Rate this book
The Carthage Chronicles #2
The Healer's Return: Time Travel Romance
Somewhere in time, your true love waits. How far would you go to save them?Against all odds, a brave woman must travel back in time if she is to save the man she loves . . . a man destined for martyrdom. But this time, the stakes are even higher.
Six years ago, impossible circumstances forced Dr. Lisbeth Hastings to leave behind the love of her life, not just in another country, but in another time. Her work as a top-notch epidemiologist and time spent raising their 5-year-old daughter helps dull her grief. But her sleep is haunted by the discovery she's made about the horrific fate of her beloved Cyprian.
Cyprian Thascius returns from his political exile a broken man. He has lost his faith, the love of his life, and his purpose. But the danger looming over Carthage forces him to move toward his destiny. When Cyprian’s true love suddenly reappears in the third century, his heart becomes as imperiled as the fledgling church he has sacrificed everything to save.
It seems the years that have kept Lisbeth and Cyprian apart have created a chasm too wide to bridge. When a new crisis arises, they must put their mistakes behind them and work together to save Carthage. But unless God provides a miracle, their love will be the most costly fatality.
Filled with gripping action and raw emotion, this spell-binding adventure of star-crossed lovers captivates with every turn of the page in the electric continuation of The Carthage Chronicles.Read the entire Carthage Chronicles 1. The Lost Healer of Carthage
2. The Healer's Return
3. The Healer's Daughter
4. Cave of the Swimmers (prequel)
Six years ago, impossible circumstances forced Dr. Lisbeth Hastings to leave behind the love of her life, not just in another country, but in another time. Her work as a top-notch epidemiologist and time spent raising their 5-year-old daughter helps dull her grief. But her sleep is haunted by the discovery she's made about the horrific fate of her beloved Cyprian.
Cyprian Thascius returns from his political exile a broken man. He has lost his faith, the love of his life, and his purpose. But the danger looming over Carthage forces him to move toward his destiny. When Cyprian’s true love suddenly reappears in the third century, his heart becomes as imperiled as the fledgling church he has sacrificed everything to save.
It seems the years that have kept Lisbeth and Cyprian apart have created a chasm too wide to bridge. When a new crisis arises, they must put their mistakes behind them and work together to save Carthage. But unless God provides a miracle, their love will be the most costly fatality.
Filled with gripping action and raw emotion, this spell-binding adventure of star-crossed lovers captivates with every turn of the page in the electric continuation of The Carthage Chronicles.Read the entire Carthage Chronicles 1. The Lost Healer of Carthage
2. The Healer's Return
3. The Healer's Daughter
4. Cave of the Swimmers (prequel)
385 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 6, 2015
111 people are currently reading
396 people want to read
About the author
Lynne Gentry
36 books208 followersThis girl who grew up on a Kansas dairy farm never wanted to be a writer, but she has always been a storyteller. Her mother called it "Selling wind in a bag." Lynne started out writing plays and skits. Then in a moment of sheer insanity, she decided to take a stab at writing full-length novels. Reinventing Leona was her first and it is no longer in print. The Carthage Chronicles are her time travel/sci-fi series. The Mt. Hope Southern Adventures series starting with WALKING SHOES and The Women of Fossil Ridge series starting with FLYING FOSSILS are her contemporary romantic comedy series. And GHOST HEART and PORT OF ORIGIN are part of her Agents of Mercy Medical Thriller series.
Lynne can milk a cow, drive a tractor, organize a banquet, prepare a kid for that first professional acting audition, or sit across the table and enjoy a cup of coffee with you.
She loves spending time with her family and medical therapy dog.
Lynne can milk a cow, drive a tractor, organize a banquet, prepare a kid for that first professional acting audition, or sit across the table and enjoy a cup of coffee with you.
She loves spending time with her family and medical therapy dog.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 85 reviews
January 1, 2016
Healer of Carthage, book one of the Carthage Chronicles, was a sure recipe for success – there was danger, intrigue, romance and great historical details. In Return to Exile, those details are back in all of their fascinating glory. Again I found myself engrossed by how Lisbeth takes her knowledge of modern medicine and molds it and improvises in Carthage. Everything is set up for a story that I would enjoy just as much as book one, however, I must admit that I didn’t enjoy this one nearly as much, and, at times, I felt disappointed while reading.
I think my initial disappointment started with the pace set in the beginning. I wanted to get back to the excitement, which for me was in the past. After about 50 pages of re-covering some of the ground from book one, I started to lose steam, which isn’t a good sign that early on in a story. Once Lisbeth returned to Carthage, my interest grew once again. I knew from the summary that the characters were going to make some decisions that I probably wouldn’t like. Even braced for this, it created a big disinclination in me for Cyprian, whose motivations are not explained, nor are his reactions to Lisbeth sympathetic. I found it hard to really sink in to the story because the characters didn’t deal with the emotions and baggage that came as a result of their poor decisions. Once this big issue is glossed over, a major plot point occurs that basically eradicates the problem, and they never truly resolve their personal issues. It just made things seem altogether too convenient for my reading tastes.
Although I didn’t care for this particular aspect of the story, once I came to terms with it, I was drawn into the latter half of the story, and read through it quickly as the drama played out. Lynne is great at keeping the stakes high, and the tension in many scenes is palpable. She has created a villain in this story that made my skin crawl on several occasions. Many scenes evoke a visceral, cinematic quality. Magdalena is still one of my favorite characters; her selflessness is truly something to be admired, and for me, she is the true hero in this series thus far. Though I didn’t appreciate all of their decisions, Cyprian and Lisbeth do make many admirable choices that put others before themselves and their own happiness. While they love each other, I think the truer love comes from that which they experience in their faith. Lynne’s portrayal of their struggles to wage war on their fate or trust God rang true for me, and I think it will resonate with many readers.
My displeasure in some aspect of the plot and characters is certainly not something that will affect every reader, and in fact, I’ve seen many great reviews of this story. If you enjoyed book one, be sure to read this one, too, as the character development and exciting moments are to be appreciated. I recommend reading them in order, as they don’t really work as standalones. Ultimately, I’m glad I read Return to Exile. The ending is quite the cliff-hanger, so I’m glad that I don’t have to wait to read the conclusion to Lisbeth’s story.
I think my initial disappointment started with the pace set in the beginning. I wanted to get back to the excitement, which for me was in the past. After about 50 pages of re-covering some of the ground from book one, I started to lose steam, which isn’t a good sign that early on in a story. Once Lisbeth returned to Carthage, my interest grew once again. I knew from the summary that the characters were going to make some decisions that I probably wouldn’t like. Even braced for this, it created a big disinclination in me for Cyprian, whose motivations are not explained, nor are his reactions to Lisbeth sympathetic. I found it hard to really sink in to the story because the characters didn’t deal with the emotions and baggage that came as a result of their poor decisions. Once this big issue is glossed over, a major plot point occurs that basically eradicates the problem, and they never truly resolve their personal issues. It just made things seem altogether too convenient for my reading tastes.
Although I didn’t care for this particular aspect of the story, once I came to terms with it, I was drawn into the latter half of the story, and read through it quickly as the drama played out. Lynne is great at keeping the stakes high, and the tension in many scenes is palpable. She has created a villain in this story that made my skin crawl on several occasions. Many scenes evoke a visceral, cinematic quality. Magdalena is still one of my favorite characters; her selflessness is truly something to be admired, and for me, she is the true hero in this series thus far. Though I didn’t appreciate all of their decisions, Cyprian and Lisbeth do make many admirable choices that put others before themselves and their own happiness. While they love each other, I think the truer love comes from that which they experience in their faith. Lynne’s portrayal of their struggles to wage war on their fate or trust God rang true for me, and I think it will resonate with many readers.
My displeasure in some aspect of the plot and characters is certainly not something that will affect every reader, and in fact, I’ve seen many great reviews of this story. If you enjoyed book one, be sure to read this one, too, as the character development and exciting moments are to be appreciated. I recommend reading them in order, as they don’t really work as standalones. Ultimately, I’m glad I read Return to Exile. The ending is quite the cliff-hanger, so I’m glad that I don’t have to wait to read the conclusion to Lisbeth’s story.
November 11, 2014
Thanks to Negalley and publishers for providing an advanced copy of this novel in exchange for my honest review.
I don't know how to rate this book. I LOVED Healer of Carthage, it's one of my favorite reads of 2014. But I put this book down in frustration and vowed that I just wouldn't finish it. I dislike not finished books, especially when I loved the first book, so I picked it back up and finished it.
Like the previous book, the writing is great and the historical details seem realistic and well-researched. My problem with this book was the story. I didn't like the characters and the stupid decisions they made.
With my issues about this book, my rating should be lower. But I thought about this book for an entire day. Stewed over the characters and their problems. And I had to finish it and see what happened, even though I was so mad. Any book that can bring me to those emotions and bring me to keep reading despite those emotions should get a couple stars for that alone. I finished it a couple nights ago and still am not certain what to say about it. I can't say that I liked it, but I couldn't put it down. And I will read the next book.
I don't know how to rate this book. I LOVED Healer of Carthage, it's one of my favorite reads of 2014. But I put this book down in frustration and vowed that I just wouldn't finish it. I dislike not finished books, especially when I loved the first book, so I picked it back up and finished it.
Like the previous book, the writing is great and the historical details seem realistic and well-researched. My problem with this book was the story. I didn't like the characters and the stupid decisions they made.
With my issues about this book, my rating should be lower. But I thought about this book for an entire day. Stewed over the characters and their problems. And I had to finish it and see what happened, even though I was so mad. Any book that can bring me to those emotions and bring me to keep reading despite those emotions should get a couple stars for that alone. I finished it a couple nights ago and still am not certain what to say about it. I can't say that I liked it, but I couldn't put it down. And I will read the next book.
February 16, 2015
Time travel books are a rarity on the Christian market, so this book intrigued me when I got the chance to review it. I requested it, did enough research to realize I should read the first book in the series before I read this second book, so I ordered book one, read it, and loved it. I then went onto this book.
In the books, the main character, Dr. Lisbeth Hastings, goes back in time to the 3rd century, A.D. The author does a fantastic job of describing the scenes and setting for what it might have been like at that time. Well done descriptions of places in books go a long way in setting the tone for a great book, and it was well done. Most of the same characters were back from the same book, good and bad, and I really like the characters in the book. Some of these people face impossible choices, all faced with the reality they could end up in the arena for daring to serve Christ. Although the book is fictional, it brought to mind how easy we have it here in America, and that many Christians through the ages and today face true persecution and death for serving God.
The books aren't the genre' I usually read, but I enjoyed both books and am looking forward to the third book, and eagerly wait to see how the author wraps things up. They are as page-turning books as the suspense I love to read. Highly recommended series.
In the books, the main character, Dr. Lisbeth Hastings, goes back in time to the 3rd century, A.D. The author does a fantastic job of describing the scenes and setting for what it might have been like at that time. Well done descriptions of places in books go a long way in setting the tone for a great book, and it was well done. Most of the same characters were back from the same book, good and bad, and I really like the characters in the book. Some of these people face impossible choices, all faced with the reality they could end up in the arena for daring to serve Christ. Although the book is fictional, it brought to mind how easy we have it here in America, and that many Christians through the ages and today face true persecution and death for serving God.
The books aren't the genre' I usually read, but I enjoyed both books and am looking forward to the third book, and eagerly wait to see how the author wraps things up. They are as page-turning books as the suspense I love to read. Highly recommended series.
January 2, 2015
This was another great read from Lynne in the Carthage Chronicles. I'm not really into any kind of medical issues, but I was so fascinated with the medical side of things in this one. Amazing what Lisbeth and her Mom did for people in third-century Carthage (well even in today Dallas too).
One thing I was surprised by concerning this novel was the emotional turmoil. I didn't expect some of the decisions that characters made and the effects of those decisions on others.
Maggie was by far one of my favorite characters! I love her attitude and her bravery (even if she thinks she's not)! Ruth is a quick second as her faith and attitude was very inspiring.
The message was great and one I needed to hear of how we can't let fear dictate our lives nor can we control everything.
I am giving "Return to Exile" 4 stars because there were a few situations that irked me and felt a little bit repetitive from book one.
Overall, another great read from Lynne that has me eagerly looking forward to the final novel in the series!
*(I did receive this novel from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts expressed are my own and I was not required to write a positive review.)*
One thing I was surprised by concerning this novel was the emotional turmoil. I didn't expect some of the decisions that characters made and the effects of those decisions on others.
Maggie was by far one of my favorite characters! I love her attitude and her bravery (even if she thinks she's not)! Ruth is a quick second as her faith and attitude was very inspiring.
The message was great and one I needed to hear of how we can't let fear dictate our lives nor can we control everything.
I am giving "Return to Exile" 4 stars because there were a few situations that irked me and felt a little bit repetitive from book one.
Overall, another great read from Lynne that has me eagerly looking forward to the final novel in the series!
*(I did receive this novel from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts expressed are my own and I was not required to write a positive review.)*
February 23, 2015
Historical fiction is just fascinating sometimes. I love that Return to Exile had the fantasy aspect of Lisbeth (a modern day doctor/scientist) time traveling back to the first half of the 200s AD. I just find the blending of historical facts meshed together with fictional story. It always just leaves me with a truer than fiction feel… even with the unbelievable time travel aspect. I find myself looking for information about Cyprian to compare to the story. The true details that are woven into the story are just fascinating.
Return to Exile was particularly interesting to read right now since measles and vaccinations are so prevalent in the news today. Lisbeth is a doctor in current day fighting a measles outbreak. Her thoughts really brought to light for me the details of how dangerous measles can be. One mother’s infection surrounding the time her family boards and airplane and spends a week at Disney before coming down with symptoms… and the slow spread… were just frightening. And then… to have her travel to a time dealing with the plague… which Lisbeth has diagnosed as an original measles outbreak (which whether true or not I’m not sure of) just really had me thinking about the devastation of an untreated communicable disease. The idea that if one generation of a disease can be eradicated through vaccination in 200 AD would mean it wouldn’t ever effect people in 2015 in just overwhelming to think about. And then coming forward to think if everyone in 2015 would follow through with vaccinations would mean that people in 2815 would never have to suffer…. it just pushing home how truly amazing science and medicine are in the history of people.
Add the romance of Cyprian and Lisbeth… an Return to Exile could be considered a tragedy. Their love, and suffering, and during a time of such devastation (political, medical, emotional….) made for an amazing story. I didn’t read book 1 (although I was able to catch up with the story). The ending of book 2 (and the sneak peek at book 3) have me on the edge of my seat wondering what will happen next with Lisbeth and Cyprian… and their families and friends.
Return to Exile was particularly interesting to read right now since measles and vaccinations are so prevalent in the news today. Lisbeth is a doctor in current day fighting a measles outbreak. Her thoughts really brought to light for me the details of how dangerous measles can be. One mother’s infection surrounding the time her family boards and airplane and spends a week at Disney before coming down with symptoms… and the slow spread… were just frightening. And then… to have her travel to a time dealing with the plague… which Lisbeth has diagnosed as an original measles outbreak (which whether true or not I’m not sure of) just really had me thinking about the devastation of an untreated communicable disease. The idea that if one generation of a disease can be eradicated through vaccination in 200 AD would mean it wouldn’t ever effect people in 2015 in just overwhelming to think about. And then coming forward to think if everyone in 2015 would follow through with vaccinations would mean that people in 2815 would never have to suffer…. it just pushing home how truly amazing science and medicine are in the history of people.
Add the romance of Cyprian and Lisbeth… an Return to Exile could be considered a tragedy. Their love, and suffering, and during a time of such devastation (political, medical, emotional….) made for an amazing story. I didn’t read book 1 (although I was able to catch up with the story). The ending of book 2 (and the sneak peek at book 3) have me on the edge of my seat wondering what will happen next with Lisbeth and Cyprian… and their families and friends.
December 10, 2014
This past weekend I sat in my comfy chair and allowed Lynne Gentry to take me on a journey back in time. Return to Exile, the second book in her Chronicles of Carthage series, packs loads of drama with a sprinkling of adventure.
Gentry thoroughly conveys the plight of the church in Carthage, a sign of great research. She then infuses modern medicine into the plague riddled city in such a way that I was reminded of a time that I worked alongside Army corpsman. Just as the corpsman showed incredible skill in field medicine and improvisation, Lisbeth and her mother also had to pool their knowledge in order to treat their burgeoning patient load. I was intrigued by the church’s willingness to serve their persecutors thereby demonstrating the love of Christ to their enemies.
When Lisbeth returns to Carthage there is a surprising plot twist. It was so profound that it created in me a lasting distaste for Cyprian, Lisbeth’s husband. It wasn’t how he handled the situation but rather his inaction and lack of sympathy for those involved that put me at odds with his character. Later, I was disappointed that this man was nominating himself into church leadership while he had unresolved personal issues. Pride and ambition were definitely his weaknesses.
Initially I felt that the story was muddled by the author’s attempt to reestablish ground work which was laid in book one. However, once Dr. Hastings steps back in time, the storyline comes into focus and the tempo picks up. For me, the last quarter of the book whizzed by.
By the end both Cyprian and Lisbeth’s demonstrated a great deal of character growth. Even though they sought to control their own fates; God gradually shows them who is control... Him.
I received this book free from the publisher through the NetGalley review program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Gentry thoroughly conveys the plight of the church in Carthage, a sign of great research. She then infuses modern medicine into the plague riddled city in such a way that I was reminded of a time that I worked alongside Army corpsman. Just as the corpsman showed incredible skill in field medicine and improvisation, Lisbeth and her mother also had to pool their knowledge in order to treat their burgeoning patient load. I was intrigued by the church’s willingness to serve their persecutors thereby demonstrating the love of Christ to their enemies.
When Lisbeth returns to Carthage there is a surprising plot twist. It was so profound that it created in me a lasting distaste for Cyprian, Lisbeth’s husband. It wasn’t how he handled the situation but rather his inaction and lack of sympathy for those involved that put me at odds with his character. Later, I was disappointed that this man was nominating himself into church leadership while he had unresolved personal issues. Pride and ambition were definitely his weaknesses.
Initially I felt that the story was muddled by the author’s attempt to reestablish ground work which was laid in book one. However, once Dr. Hastings steps back in time, the storyline comes into focus and the tempo picks up. For me, the last quarter of the book whizzed by.
By the end both Cyprian and Lisbeth’s demonstrated a great deal of character growth. Even though they sought to control their own fates; God gradually shows them who is control... Him.
I received this book free from the publisher through the NetGalley review program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
February 11, 2015
I really loved this second book in the series. Here's some of my thoughts:
Lisbeth faces some unexpected surprises and twists when she returns to Carthage. The story is so fast-paced, you have moments to get used to her new reality before the adventure changes and she’s pulled deeper into commitments in the past.
Lynne’s writing style is so easy to read, almost a conversational tone. Although a good portion of the story takes place in ancient Carthage, I never felt distracted by that fact or by the unique blend of modern characters in that ancient time. I was anxious to see how Lisbeth and Cyprian’s stories would continue. Lynne doesn’t disappoint! We get to see their worlds collide again, with a new child in the middle.
One thing I loved about the first book was Lynne’s way of reminding the reader that Lisbeth is from modern day but stuck in the 3rd century. She continues this with subtle humor and mentions of culture (Disney princesses!) and technology, while staying relevant to the story.
This story is one that will keep you on your toes, with drama that reads at times like a medical thriller. The themes of the story, though, are most important: letting go of fears, loving your enemies, and holding on to faith when it’s hard. This is shown through the drama of the early church’s challenges in culture and politics. Also, through a picture of the importance of family, no matter what boundaries and obstacles may separate them for a time.
Thanks a ton to Lynne Gentry and to Howard Books for the free review copy in exchange for my honest review. I’m so glad I was able to be on your team!
Lisbeth faces some unexpected surprises and twists when she returns to Carthage. The story is so fast-paced, you have moments to get used to her new reality before the adventure changes and she’s pulled deeper into commitments in the past.
Lynne’s writing style is so easy to read, almost a conversational tone. Although a good portion of the story takes place in ancient Carthage, I never felt distracted by that fact or by the unique blend of modern characters in that ancient time. I was anxious to see how Lisbeth and Cyprian’s stories would continue. Lynne doesn’t disappoint! We get to see their worlds collide again, with a new child in the middle.
One thing I loved about the first book was Lynne’s way of reminding the reader that Lisbeth is from modern day but stuck in the 3rd century. She continues this with subtle humor and mentions of culture (Disney princesses!) and technology, while staying relevant to the story.
This story is one that will keep you on your toes, with drama that reads at times like a medical thriller. The themes of the story, though, are most important: letting go of fears, loving your enemies, and holding on to faith when it’s hard. This is shown through the drama of the early church’s challenges in culture and politics. Also, through a picture of the importance of family, no matter what boundaries and obstacles may separate them for a time.
Thanks a ton to Lynne Gentry and to Howard Books for the free review copy in exchange for my honest review. I’m so glad I was able to be on your team!
August 29, 2015
So many middle novels in a trilogy can be a letdown after a big opening but Return to Exile does not fit into that mould. It builds on the foundations of the excellent Healer of Carthage and gives us more drama and enhanced characters. What appeals to me the most are the spiritual challenges that Gentry raises: the nature of sacrificial love, letting go of what we love, and exercising faith in the presence of extreme fear.
This episode in the trilogy mostly revolves around Lisbeth and Cyprian. Even though not too much time has passed since the end of the first episode, Carthage and its leader Aspasius are disease-ridden, Cyprian has snuck back into town unannounced and believing he will never see Lisbeth makes a big decision that will shock her greatly on her return.
Gentry writes beautifully and her theatrical background is clearly evident with how she so masterfully manages multiple POVs and showcases all the horror and tragedy of the disease-riddled city. Even though there is great darkness (and Aspasius is truly a nasty antagonist), we see the light of God's love and hope demonstrated through the very relatable faith journeys of Lisbeth and Cyprian. They both make mistakes, are torn between their own selfish desires and trusting in God.
I'm so looking forward to reading the final instalment which fortunately for me isn't too long away from being released.
This episode in the trilogy mostly revolves around Lisbeth and Cyprian. Even though not too much time has passed since the end of the first episode, Carthage and its leader Aspasius are disease-ridden, Cyprian has snuck back into town unannounced and believing he will never see Lisbeth makes a big decision that will shock her greatly on her return.
Gentry writes beautifully and her theatrical background is clearly evident with how she so masterfully manages multiple POVs and showcases all the horror and tragedy of the disease-riddled city. Even though there is great darkness (and Aspasius is truly a nasty antagonist), we see the light of God's love and hope demonstrated through the very relatable faith journeys of Lisbeth and Cyprian. They both make mistakes, are torn between their own selfish desires and trusting in God.
I'm so looking forward to reading the final instalment which fortunately for me isn't too long away from being released.
February 17, 2015
I received this book from Litfuse Publicity for no charge in exchange for my honest review of this book. The opinions expressed here are my own.
Book Description:
How far would you go to save the ones you love?
Six years ago, impossible circumstances forced Dr. Lisbeth Hastings to leave behind the love of her life, not just in another country, but in another time. Her work as a top-notch epidemiologist and parenting her little girl helps alleviate the pain, but at night when her exhausted head hits the pillow, images of her beloved Cyprian haunt her sleep.
Cyprian Thascius returns from political exile a broken man. He’s lost his faith, the love of his life, and his purpose. He attempts to move on, to face the danger that is looming over Carthage, but when Cyprian’s true love suddenly reappears, his heart becomes as imperiled as the fledgling church he seeks to save.
Have the years that kept Lisbeth and Cyprian apart created too wide a chasm to bridge? In the midst of a new epidemic and rising oppression, will their love be the most costly fatality? Filled with gripping action and raw emotion, this spell-binding adventure of star-crossed lovers captivates with every turn of the page in this electric continuation of The Carthage Chronicles.
My Thoughts:
Return To Exile is the second book in Lynne Gentry's Carthage Chronicles series and it is fantastic! I read the first book, Healer of Carthage as one of the few books I have in my every growing TBR pile and it was a hit so I knew I had to find out what came next! Return To Exile takes place six years after the Healer of Carthage ends. Dr. Lisbeth Hastings in back in Texas working as a epidemiologist, the top in her field, and raising the daughter she had with Cyprian Thascius, her husband from 3rd Century Carthage. Cyprian Thascius has been in political exile for six years and returns to Carthage a broken man, losing his faith and his purpose. Not long after he returns to his life and tries to move on, Lisbeth shows back up with their daughter in tow, because Lisbeth feels compelled to save Cyprian from his impending death that she read about in the history books. Armed with 21st century medicine she comes back to find out that Cyprian, Ruth, her Mother, and her brother have all moved on with their lives. Cyprian and Ruth have been married and are expecting their first child. As they struggle to work out the personal stuff, they work to also rid Carthage of another epidemic that is killing the rich and poor alike.
Return To Exile is a fantastic book in this great series by Lynne Gentry. As a huge fan of Christian Historical Fiction, I was drawn to this book and this series. This book takes readers back to 3rd Century Carthage where Ruth, Lisbeth's mother Magdalena, and other survivors of the measles are caring for any new break outs of measles trying to keep it under control. Lynne Gentry writes with authority about 3rd Century Carthage and other parts of the world at this time, diseases and disease control in the present and in 3rd Century, and the history of Carthage, and the history of Christianity. As I read this book, I felt like I was time traveling with Lisbeth and Maggie, transported to another time and place. I really felt like I was there with them experiencing the life and times of Carthage. The characters are wonderfully written and I think my favorites are Magdalena and Lawrence, Lisbeth's Mom and half brother. The love they have for one another and the way they give of themselves for the welfare of others is inspiring. Magdalena and Lawrence's faith gives them the strength to endure what they have had to endure. I could not put this book down, from the first page this book grabbed a hold and wouldn't let go. This is a fast paced, action filled book that keeps you guessing until the end and leaves you wanting to know more of this cast of characters. I recommend reading The Healer of Carthage first to fully understand the story lines. They are both worth the read! I highly recommend this book and series to anyone who enjoys Christian Historical Fiction, you will NOT be disappointed. I cannot wait to read Valley of Decision, the third and final book in this trilogy. Added bonus: there is an excerpt from this book at the end of Return To Exile. I give this book 5 STARS.
Book Description:
How far would you go to save the ones you love?
Six years ago, impossible circumstances forced Dr. Lisbeth Hastings to leave behind the love of her life, not just in another country, but in another time. Her work as a top-notch epidemiologist and parenting her little girl helps alleviate the pain, but at night when her exhausted head hits the pillow, images of her beloved Cyprian haunt her sleep.
Cyprian Thascius returns from political exile a broken man. He’s lost his faith, the love of his life, and his purpose. He attempts to move on, to face the danger that is looming over Carthage, but when Cyprian’s true love suddenly reappears, his heart becomes as imperiled as the fledgling church he seeks to save.
Have the years that kept Lisbeth and Cyprian apart created too wide a chasm to bridge? In the midst of a new epidemic and rising oppression, will their love be the most costly fatality? Filled with gripping action and raw emotion, this spell-binding adventure of star-crossed lovers captivates with every turn of the page in this electric continuation of The Carthage Chronicles.
My Thoughts:
Return To Exile is the second book in Lynne Gentry's Carthage Chronicles series and it is fantastic! I read the first book, Healer of Carthage as one of the few books I have in my every growing TBR pile and it was a hit so I knew I had to find out what came next! Return To Exile takes place six years after the Healer of Carthage ends. Dr. Lisbeth Hastings in back in Texas working as a epidemiologist, the top in her field, and raising the daughter she had with Cyprian Thascius, her husband from 3rd Century Carthage. Cyprian Thascius has been in political exile for six years and returns to Carthage a broken man, losing his faith and his purpose. Not long after he returns to his life and tries to move on, Lisbeth shows back up with their daughter in tow, because Lisbeth feels compelled to save Cyprian from his impending death that she read about in the history books. Armed with 21st century medicine she comes back to find out that Cyprian, Ruth, her Mother, and her brother have all moved on with their lives. Cyprian and Ruth have been married and are expecting their first child. As they struggle to work out the personal stuff, they work to also rid Carthage of another epidemic that is killing the rich and poor alike.
Return To Exile is a fantastic book in this great series by Lynne Gentry. As a huge fan of Christian Historical Fiction, I was drawn to this book and this series. This book takes readers back to 3rd Century Carthage where Ruth, Lisbeth's mother Magdalena, and other survivors of the measles are caring for any new break outs of measles trying to keep it under control. Lynne Gentry writes with authority about 3rd Century Carthage and other parts of the world at this time, diseases and disease control in the present and in 3rd Century, and the history of Carthage, and the history of Christianity. As I read this book, I felt like I was time traveling with Lisbeth and Maggie, transported to another time and place. I really felt like I was there with them experiencing the life and times of Carthage. The characters are wonderfully written and I think my favorites are Magdalena and Lawrence, Lisbeth's Mom and half brother. The love they have for one another and the way they give of themselves for the welfare of others is inspiring. Magdalena and Lawrence's faith gives them the strength to endure what they have had to endure. I could not put this book down, from the first page this book grabbed a hold and wouldn't let go. This is a fast paced, action filled book that keeps you guessing until the end and leaves you wanting to know more of this cast of characters. I recommend reading The Healer of Carthage first to fully understand the story lines. They are both worth the read! I highly recommend this book and series to anyone who enjoys Christian Historical Fiction, you will NOT be disappointed. I cannot wait to read Valley of Decision, the third and final book in this trilogy. Added bonus: there is an excerpt from this book at the end of Return To Exile. I give this book 5 STARS.
February 10, 2015
About the Book:
A twenty-first-century doctor travels back in time to third-century Carthage to rescue her husband, but the arrival of a deadly epidemic forces her to make an impossible choice in this fast-paced second novel in The Carthage Chronicles series.
Dr. Lisbeth Hastings salvaged two things from her accidental trip to the third century: her mother's stethoscope and her child. Making a life for her daughter Maggie back in the present is difficult, but returning to ancient Carthage is impossible. However, when Lisbeth learns her husband is slated to die a martyr's death, she must find a way around the impossible to save him.
Cyprian Thascius returns from political exile a broken man. He's lost his faith, the love of his life, and his purpose. When Ruth, an old friend, proposes he marry her to restore his position and protect his estate, the disgraced nobleman accepts. But when Cyprian's true love suddenly reappears, his heart becomes as imperiled as the fledgling church.
As Lisbeth and Cyprian reunite to battle a new epidemic and save the oppressed community of Christians, the chasm between the two of them seems too wide to bridge. But when Maggie contracts typhoid, Lisbeth must choose: stay and save the man she loves, or return home and save her daughter?
Filled with gripping action and raw emotion, this incredibly compelling adventure of star-crossed lovers will keep you engrossed with every turn of the page.
About the Author:
Lynne Gentry has written for numerous publications. Her new series, The Carthage Chronicles is a time travel, historical romance, adventure. She is a professional acting coach, theater director, and playwright with several full-length musicals plus a Chicago children's theater curriculum to her credit. Lynne is an inspirational speaker and dramatic performer. She loves spending time with her family or working the hospital oncology wards with her medical therapy dog Roman.
My Review:
After having to leave her true love behind in another era, Dr. Lisbeth Hastings began working as a doctor in the 21st century in Houston, Texas. Taking care of her daughter and staying busy with work, kept Lisbeth from focusing on all the pain and sadness in her heart. But all of that starts to change when her daughter starts asking about her father. And it also turns out that in Carthage, there is need for her to find a cure for the sick, and Maggie's father is there as well.
In Carthage, Cyprian Thascius returns from political exile to find that his wife is gone and that his life has been turned upside down. As this disease reeks havoc all around him , Cyprian must decide where his priorities lie, especially when Lisbeth returns and she has a companion---their daughter Maggie.
Lisbeth returns to find that many things have changed with her husband. But soon the disease hits close to home and everything seems to be moving downhill quickly. Because of this the two of them will have to do some quick thinking before their beloved is lost forever.
While the two different story line's coming together could confuse me at times, I still liked the book. It has action and intrigue flowing constantly throughout, which makes a great page turner.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from Litfuse Publicity.
A twenty-first-century doctor travels back in time to third-century Carthage to rescue her husband, but the arrival of a deadly epidemic forces her to make an impossible choice in this fast-paced second novel in The Carthage Chronicles series.
Dr. Lisbeth Hastings salvaged two things from her accidental trip to the third century: her mother's stethoscope and her child. Making a life for her daughter Maggie back in the present is difficult, but returning to ancient Carthage is impossible. However, when Lisbeth learns her husband is slated to die a martyr's death, she must find a way around the impossible to save him.
Cyprian Thascius returns from political exile a broken man. He's lost his faith, the love of his life, and his purpose. When Ruth, an old friend, proposes he marry her to restore his position and protect his estate, the disgraced nobleman accepts. But when Cyprian's true love suddenly reappears, his heart becomes as imperiled as the fledgling church.
As Lisbeth and Cyprian reunite to battle a new epidemic and save the oppressed community of Christians, the chasm between the two of them seems too wide to bridge. But when Maggie contracts typhoid, Lisbeth must choose: stay and save the man she loves, or return home and save her daughter?
Filled with gripping action and raw emotion, this incredibly compelling adventure of star-crossed lovers will keep you engrossed with every turn of the page.
About the Author:
Lynne Gentry has written for numerous publications. Her new series, The Carthage Chronicles is a time travel, historical romance, adventure. She is a professional acting coach, theater director, and playwright with several full-length musicals plus a Chicago children's theater curriculum to her credit. Lynne is an inspirational speaker and dramatic performer. She loves spending time with her family or working the hospital oncology wards with her medical therapy dog Roman.
My Review:
After having to leave her true love behind in another era, Dr. Lisbeth Hastings began working as a doctor in the 21st century in Houston, Texas. Taking care of her daughter and staying busy with work, kept Lisbeth from focusing on all the pain and sadness in her heart. But all of that starts to change when her daughter starts asking about her father. And it also turns out that in Carthage, there is need for her to find a cure for the sick, and Maggie's father is there as well.
In Carthage, Cyprian Thascius returns from political exile to find that his wife is gone and that his life has been turned upside down. As this disease reeks havoc all around him , Cyprian must decide where his priorities lie, especially when Lisbeth returns and she has a companion---their daughter Maggie.
Lisbeth returns to find that many things have changed with her husband. But soon the disease hits close to home and everything seems to be moving downhill quickly. Because of this the two of them will have to do some quick thinking before their beloved is lost forever.
While the two different story line's coming together could confuse me at times, I still liked the book. It has action and intrigue flowing constantly throughout, which makes a great page turner.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from Litfuse Publicity.
January 6, 2015
I really enjoyed reading the first book in The Carthage Chronicles, and was eager for the release of its sequel, Return to Exile. The idea of having a 21st century doctor go back in time to ancient Carthage was one that I thought had great potential, and was very unique. However, sadly I think that I enjoyed the first book in this series, Healer of Carthage a lot more than I enjoyed Return to Exile.
I've always been a fan of historical fiction that involves time travel, and always jump at the chance to read these kinds of books, since there aren't many out there. However I felt like there was just something that didn't work for me with this novel. I read the first 50 or so pages and the story just didn't seem to be going anywhere. I felt like the exciting part of the story should have already started (which would the the main character finally going back to ancient Carthage). I quickly became disinterested in the story, making it very hard for me to complete the novel having given it my full attention. I was sad that this is the way I reacted to the story, as I had hopes that I'd enjoy it as much as I enjoyed the first story. While the story did pick up after a while, I felt like by the time it did, I had already lost interest.
Despite the fact that I had a hard time getting "into" the story, I did enjoy reading the parts that did got exciting, although I felt like they were few and far between. While there weren't many parts that I felt really kept my interest, I will say that the few ones that did were really unexpected and really surprised me! I enjoyed the historical details of this story, and seeing the main character and how her lives were different in both time periods. It was neat continuing her story, I just wish it would have grabbed my attention more. However I by no means want to discourage anyone from giving this novel a try! Fans of historical fiction with time travel interwoven should check out this series!
D I S C L A I M E R :: I received a free copy of Return to Exile from the publisher for the sole purpose of this review. I was not paid to write this review or promote this book, and all thoughts expressed are my own, completely honest and unbiased.
I've always been a fan of historical fiction that involves time travel, and always jump at the chance to read these kinds of books, since there aren't many out there. However I felt like there was just something that didn't work for me with this novel. I read the first 50 or so pages and the story just didn't seem to be going anywhere. I felt like the exciting part of the story should have already started (which would the the main character finally going back to ancient Carthage). I quickly became disinterested in the story, making it very hard for me to complete the novel having given it my full attention. I was sad that this is the way I reacted to the story, as I had hopes that I'd enjoy it as much as I enjoyed the first story. While the story did pick up after a while, I felt like by the time it did, I had already lost interest.
Despite the fact that I had a hard time getting "into" the story, I did enjoy reading the parts that did got exciting, although I felt like they were few and far between. While there weren't many parts that I felt really kept my interest, I will say that the few ones that did were really unexpected and really surprised me! I enjoyed the historical details of this story, and seeing the main character and how her lives were different in both time periods. It was neat continuing her story, I just wish it would have grabbed my attention more. However I by no means want to discourage anyone from giving this novel a try! Fans of historical fiction with time travel interwoven should check out this series!
D I S C L A I M E R :: I received a free copy of Return to Exile from the publisher for the sole purpose of this review. I was not paid to write this review or promote this book, and all thoughts expressed are my own, completely honest and unbiased.
September 10, 2016
I expected more excitement after reading the first book. But it took ages for things to move on and I lost interest and had to go back to it after a time. Not half as good as the first book and these books are more expensive than most so not sure I will buy the next one.
January 31, 2015
Oh my goodness! I am so loving this series!!! What fun it is to visit Carthage in the 3rd Century and be a part of their lives.
I can hardly wait for the next book in the series to release in September!
I can hardly wait for the next book in the series to release in September!
September 4, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Wow-what a ride! Return to Exile is the kind of second book that keeps the trilogy momentum going strong. Lisbeth’s return to Carthage brings shocking twists, unexpected betrayals, and moments that made my heart ache.
I loved the mix of fast-paced drama with quieter moments of faith and family. Gentry makes the 3rd century come alive with all its danger, but she also ties in just enough modern touches through Lisbeth to keep it relatable
Themes: loving your enemies, trusting God when everything feels uncertain, and holding fast to faith in the darkest places.
Cyprian made me crazy at times, but that tension also made the story more layered and real. By the end, I appreciated the growth in both him and Lisbeth as they learned that God, not ambition or control, is the true anchor.
This sequel raises the stakes, deepens the character journeys, and leaves you eager to see how the final book will bring everything full circle.
⚠️⚠️ spoilers ahead
Ending Recap:
Carthage is battling not only measles but also typhoid. Lisbeth’s sudden reappearance brings tension into Cyprian’s home and strains his new marriage. Meanwhile, Aspasius longs for his healer as his condition worsens and his health continues to decline.
Tragedy strikes when Ruth and her unborn son is killed in an accident, deepening the rift between Lisbeth and Cyprian. Yet in the aftermath, Ciprian turns back to his first wife, Lisbeth, and they rekindle their bond. Soon after, Cyprian uncovers dangerous deceit, Felicissimus and that Aspasius plots to kill him.
Realizing the increasing hostility and the risks of remaining in Carthage-especially after their daughter Maggie contracts typhoid- Cyprian convinces Lisbeth and Maggie to return to the 21st century, never to return. The family shares a final, heartbreaking goodbye as they step back into their own time.
Wow-what a ride! Return to Exile is the kind of second book that keeps the trilogy momentum going strong. Lisbeth’s return to Carthage brings shocking twists, unexpected betrayals, and moments that made my heart ache.
I loved the mix of fast-paced drama with quieter moments of faith and family. Gentry makes the 3rd century come alive with all its danger, but she also ties in just enough modern touches through Lisbeth to keep it relatable
Themes: loving your enemies, trusting God when everything feels uncertain, and holding fast to faith in the darkest places.
Cyprian made me crazy at times, but that tension also made the story more layered and real. By the end, I appreciated the growth in both him and Lisbeth as they learned that God, not ambition or control, is the true anchor.
This sequel raises the stakes, deepens the character journeys, and leaves you eager to see how the final book will bring everything full circle.
⚠️⚠️ spoilers ahead
Ending Recap:
Carthage is battling not only measles but also typhoid. Lisbeth’s sudden reappearance brings tension into Cyprian’s home and strains his new marriage. Meanwhile, Aspasius longs for his healer as his condition worsens and his health continues to decline.
Tragedy strikes when Ruth and her unborn son is killed in an accident, deepening the rift between Lisbeth and Cyprian. Yet in the aftermath, Ciprian turns back to his first wife, Lisbeth, and they rekindle their bond. Soon after, Cyprian uncovers dangerous deceit, Felicissimus and that Aspasius plots to kill him.
Realizing the increasing hostility and the risks of remaining in Carthage-especially after their daughter Maggie contracts typhoid- Cyprian convinces Lisbeth and Maggie to return to the 21st century, never to return. The family shares a final, heartbreaking goodbye as they step back into their own time.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 30, 2014
Another 5 star book from Lynne Gentry!
Return to Exile is the second book in Lynne Gentry’s The Carthage Chronicles. It continues the story of Lisbeth Hastings and Cyprian Thascius, six years after the first book left off. I loved the first book and had very high expectations for this one. I can happily say that it met them all!
I was quickly drawn into the story and couldn’t put it down! As I have come to expect, Lynne did an excellent job with the historical and medical details, as well as the descriptions. She brings Carthage and third century Rome to life so vividly that I had trouble pulling myself away from it. I could picture it so clearly and often felt as though I was actually there. One of the things I love/hate most about this book and Lynne’s writing is the realism. If you’re looking for a feel good, happily ever after story, then I don’t recommend this book. It will challenge you, change the way you view things, and leave you thinking about it for days. It may also leave you wanting to pitch it against a wall after you read the last page. That’s pretty much a given with her books. She is one of the few authors that can evoke such an emotional reaction from me.
I loved seeing how much Lisbeth and Cyprian have changed and grown since the last book. The changes weren’t always positive, but that’s true in life too, and I enjoyed following them through the pages of another book. Lisbeth Hastings has spent the last six years trying to move on with her life, while also feeling chained to something she can’t explain and doesn’t understand. She is still stubborn and very strong willed, maybe even more so now that she has a child to care for. She is also a bit impulsive, though she tends over thinks things after the fact. She definitely isn’t the stereotypical heroine and would not be mistaken for sweet or overly gentle, except with her daughter. She has built walls to protect herself from hurt and they have caused her to be a bit harsh in her view of the world and sometimes of others.
Cyprian Thascius has returned from exile to find he isn’t the man he was before. His heart has hardened and his faith is on shaky ground. He is still strong and stubborn, which he needs to keep up with Lisbeth. The changes in him are more obvious than in Lisbeth. He used to be kind and gentle, but is now more apathetic than anything. When pushed to reach out to the Church he once loved, he questions if he’s the right man for the job. Counted a coward by many, he feels he has something to prove to Carthage, but more importantly, to himself.
Their story started out a little slowly, as we catch up on the time between books, but it quickly picked up speed and kept me captivated until the end. I was a little surprised with how much I still hated Aspasius; I couldn’t even begin to feel sorry for him. But as the story proceeds, I found myself growing and learning along with Lisbeth and Cyprian, as they learn what it means to love their enemies and live as Jesus did.
If you’re expecting a romance when you pick up this book, you may be a bit disappointed. While there is a touch of romantic tension here and there, it isn’t a central part of the story. There are so many other things going on that I believe it would have detracted from the story had Lynne incorporated more. Lisbeth and Cyprian find themselves remembering their past love for each other, but having not seen one another in years, and believing their love lost through time, they spend a decent amount of the book trying to rebuild the relationship they thought lost.
I found myself very challenged with the spiritual side of the story. I’ve always heard that the Bible is a living book, always relevant throughout the years and that fact is clearly shown in this story. I was able to empathize with both Cyprian and Lisbeth’s struggles. Cyprian has lost his faith, his heart has hardened, and he can’t hear God. He tells Ruth at one point that he can hear nothing but the wind. In the meantime, Lisbeth has found faith, but still struggles with control and trying to make everything right. There is a quote that caught my attention, “All this time, she’d believed the reason for her travels into this harsh world a simple one: she was meant to rewrite history. But now she knew she’d been dropped into the middle of these struggles so the past could rewrite her.” - Lisbeth Hastings, page 343 There are many other quote-worthy moments, but that one snagged my attention and would not let go. It shows so clearly the change that occurs for Lisbeth and illustrates one of the main themes - even though we may not know God’s will or understand why, He always has a perfect plan.
I do caution anyone who is sensitive to violence or medical descriptions, this may not be the book for you. While I loved how the Lynne’s writing drew me in, this book is set in third century Rome during a plague and religious persecution. There are mentions of executions, though not in detail, and detailed medical procedures.
I very much enjoyed the many twists and turns throughout the book that left me stunned and trying to guess what might happen next. Lynne does a great job of building the suspense and giving the reader just enough information to have a general idea what would come next, without actually giving anything away. I also loved how each character had a very unique voice and stood apart from the rest when it changed to their point of view. I quickly knew who was speaking, before it said their name. I was sorry to say goodbye to the characters, though I know I will see many of them again in the next book. They become like family and I don’t want the books to end.
I highly recommend this book if you’re looking for a suspenseful story that will challenge you and leave you begging the author for the next one.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for my honest review, which I have given. I was not required to write a positive review and have not been compensated for it in any way. All opinions expressed are my own.
*Quotation used with permission from the author. All rights reserved.
Return to Exile is the second book in Lynne Gentry’s The Carthage Chronicles. It continues the story of Lisbeth Hastings and Cyprian Thascius, six years after the first book left off. I loved the first book and had very high expectations for this one. I can happily say that it met them all!
I was quickly drawn into the story and couldn’t put it down! As I have come to expect, Lynne did an excellent job with the historical and medical details, as well as the descriptions. She brings Carthage and third century Rome to life so vividly that I had trouble pulling myself away from it. I could picture it so clearly and often felt as though I was actually there. One of the things I love/hate most about this book and Lynne’s writing is the realism. If you’re looking for a feel good, happily ever after story, then I don’t recommend this book. It will challenge you, change the way you view things, and leave you thinking about it for days. It may also leave you wanting to pitch it against a wall after you read the last page. That’s pretty much a given with her books. She is one of the few authors that can evoke such an emotional reaction from me.
I loved seeing how much Lisbeth and Cyprian have changed and grown since the last book. The changes weren’t always positive, but that’s true in life too, and I enjoyed following them through the pages of another book. Lisbeth Hastings has spent the last six years trying to move on with her life, while also feeling chained to something she can’t explain and doesn’t understand. She is still stubborn and very strong willed, maybe even more so now that she has a child to care for. She is also a bit impulsive, though she tends over thinks things after the fact. She definitely isn’t the stereotypical heroine and would not be mistaken for sweet or overly gentle, except with her daughter. She has built walls to protect herself from hurt and they have caused her to be a bit harsh in her view of the world and sometimes of others.
Cyprian Thascius has returned from exile to find he isn’t the man he was before. His heart has hardened and his faith is on shaky ground. He is still strong and stubborn, which he needs to keep up with Lisbeth. The changes in him are more obvious than in Lisbeth. He used to be kind and gentle, but is now more apathetic than anything. When pushed to reach out to the Church he once loved, he questions if he’s the right man for the job. Counted a coward by many, he feels he has something to prove to Carthage, but more importantly, to himself.
Their story started out a little slowly, as we catch up on the time between books, but it quickly picked up speed and kept me captivated until the end. I was a little surprised with how much I still hated Aspasius; I couldn’t even begin to feel sorry for him. But as the story proceeds, I found myself growing and learning along with Lisbeth and Cyprian, as they learn what it means to love their enemies and live as Jesus did.
If you’re expecting a romance when you pick up this book, you may be a bit disappointed. While there is a touch of romantic tension here and there, it isn’t a central part of the story. There are so many other things going on that I believe it would have detracted from the story had Lynne incorporated more. Lisbeth and Cyprian find themselves remembering their past love for each other, but having not seen one another in years, and believing their love lost through time, they spend a decent amount of the book trying to rebuild the relationship they thought lost.
I found myself very challenged with the spiritual side of the story. I’ve always heard that the Bible is a living book, always relevant throughout the years and that fact is clearly shown in this story. I was able to empathize with both Cyprian and Lisbeth’s struggles. Cyprian has lost his faith, his heart has hardened, and he can’t hear God. He tells Ruth at one point that he can hear nothing but the wind. In the meantime, Lisbeth has found faith, but still struggles with control and trying to make everything right. There is a quote that caught my attention, “All this time, she’d believed the reason for her travels into this harsh world a simple one: she was meant to rewrite history. But now she knew she’d been dropped into the middle of these struggles so the past could rewrite her.” - Lisbeth Hastings, page 343 There are many other quote-worthy moments, but that one snagged my attention and would not let go. It shows so clearly the change that occurs for Lisbeth and illustrates one of the main themes - even though we may not know God’s will or understand why, He always has a perfect plan.
I do caution anyone who is sensitive to violence or medical descriptions, this may not be the book for you. While I loved how the Lynne’s writing drew me in, this book is set in third century Rome during a plague and religious persecution. There are mentions of executions, though not in detail, and detailed medical procedures.
I very much enjoyed the many twists and turns throughout the book that left me stunned and trying to guess what might happen next. Lynne does a great job of building the suspense and giving the reader just enough information to have a general idea what would come next, without actually giving anything away. I also loved how each character had a very unique voice and stood apart from the rest when it changed to their point of view. I quickly knew who was speaking, before it said their name. I was sorry to say goodbye to the characters, though I know I will see many of them again in the next book. They become like family and I don’t want the books to end.
I highly recommend this book if you’re looking for a suspenseful story that will challenge you and leave you begging the author for the next one.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for my honest review, which I have given. I was not required to write a positive review and have not been compensated for it in any way. All opinions expressed are my own.
*Quotation used with permission from the author. All rights reserved.
August 19, 2020
This book is part 2 of The Carthage Chronicles which lives up to it title. Cyprian has been put into exile. As we return to that place one finds out the empire has decided to release him and so he ends up at Carthage again going back to use his house as a makeshift hospital. Though this time there are complications because measles has led to a breakout of typhoid.
Back in the 20th century Dr. Lisbeth Hastings goes to her practice while studying ancient Roman history and infectious diseases. She also discovers she is pregnant and gives birth to a daughter she names after her mother who is 1/2 Roman, 1/2 American.
Lisbeth stocking up on medical supplies decides to travel back to 3rd Century Carthage. Though her daughter Maggie is told to stay behind Maggie doesn't listen not wanting to be separated from her mother so both go back in time. What complications result? Find out as you read this sequel.
Back in the 20th century Dr. Lisbeth Hastings goes to her practice while studying ancient Roman history and infectious diseases. She also discovers she is pregnant and gives birth to a daughter she names after her mother who is 1/2 Roman, 1/2 American.
Lisbeth stocking up on medical supplies decides to travel back to 3rd Century Carthage. Though her daughter Maggie is told to stay behind Maggie doesn't listen not wanting to be separated from her mother so both go back in time. What complications result? Find out as you read this sequel.
April 5, 2018
THIS IS THE WORST BOOK I HAVE EVER READ.
There, three years of frustration finally relieved. If only I could give .01/5 stars...I'm not going to write a lengthy list of everything that was so very wrong with this book:
a.) It would be ridiculously long. Seriously.
b.) I cannot bear to relive the torment again.
Seriously, save yourself the trouble/pain. Especially if you read and enjoyed the first book, as I did.
PS: Well...I will say this: I have never hated a "leading man" character so much. Such a pity, since he was so well written the first time. They all were. Such a shame.
There, three years of frustration finally relieved. If only I could give .01/5 stars...I'm not going to write a lengthy list of everything that was so very wrong with this book:
a.) It would be ridiculously long. Seriously.
b.) I cannot bear to relive the torment again.
Seriously, save yourself the trouble/pain. Especially if you read and enjoyed the first book, as I did.
PS: Well...I will say this: I have never hated a "leading man" character so much. Such a pity, since he was so well written the first time. They all were. Such a shame.
July 15, 2024
I honestly almost quit reading this book. I went from loving Cyprian in the first book to being angry with him for the second one. I hated how he remarried Ruth right after returning from exile. It made me feel as though he didn’t truly love Lisbeth, I mean she waited 6 years in her time for him and he couldn’t wait even 6 months. I was honestly hoping for a happy ending for them together. I am glad I finished the book, and I’m glad it’s keeping with factual information about his death. But, why did he have to be that away fictionally. She couldn’t he have waited for Lizbeth’s return or just not remarried ever because he loved her so much?!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 18, 2022
This book does a wonderful job of demonstrating how no one can control fate. Despite her best attempts, Lisbeth leaves Carthage knowing that she is leaving her husband to the executioner. The twists and turns these two lovers (Lisbeth and Cyprian) face are so suspenseful, with secrets, death, and love around every corner. Faith is both questioned and strengthened. Despite it all their love remains and nothing can tear apart these two people who were meant for each other.
June 27, 2024
A Love Story?
Sorry I can’t give this 5 stars like Carthage Chronicles I. For me the whole book was depressing! Too much death, sadness and no love or HEA! If you are in any way depressed, don’t read this. I know it was hard on Christians during that time, but I read fiction as an escape from this time. I hope #3 will be better, but don’t hold much hope.
Sorry I can’t give this 5 stars like Carthage Chronicles I. For me the whole book was depressing! Too much death, sadness and no love or HEA! If you are in any way depressed, don’t read this. I know it was hard on Christians during that time, but I read fiction as an escape from this time. I hope #3 will be better, but don’t hold much hope.
June 19, 2018
All kinds of action and suspence wiht two horrific plagues, time travel, evil pagans, and struggling Christians in 3rd century Carthage. I've ordered the third in the series as the journey continues.
January 6, 2015
There are some disadvantages to reading series. I guess for me is that it is often so long between books, that you have to reread the first or hope that the author provides enough insight at the beginning of the second or third books to help you remember where you left off. Another is how they end. I personally hate cliff hanger endings, but as a writer myself, I know that is just how I would leave each book in the series. Kinda like the television or movie series we see. It makes you disappointed at first, but then hungry for more. You just have to come back to see how it all turns out.
If you love time travel, romance or historical fiction, or like me, a bit of all three, you will want to pick up The Carthage Chronicles from best-selling author Lynne Gentry. Her first novel in the series, Healer of Carthage is about a 21st century doctor whose father has a love for archaeology. Couple that with a bit of mysterious paintings in a cave in Egypt, known simply as the Cave of Swimmers. Dr. Lisbeth Hastings lost her mother in the Cave of Swimmers and never knew what happened to her until she herself fell into the watery cavern. Turns out it transports people back into the third century in Rome, not the place you'd want to be as a woman.
In Return to Exile, we pick the series back up after Lisbeth had returned back to the 21st century at the conclusion of the first novel, in love with a man she left behind as her husband. In order to protect her, she was thrown back into the cistern which took her back to present time, where she learned she was pregnant with Cyprian's child. Knowing her daughter is extremely claustrophobic, she knows taking her daughter Maggie back in time, won't be easy. Her father insists on accompanying her to see the wife he thought died so long ago. Turns out she has become infamous for her healing abilities and remains the slave/wife to a cruel dictator named Aspasius, whose goal is to control all the Christians still dwelling in the providence. He has successfully exiled Cyprian and during Lisbeth's escape, her mother managed to flee into the hills where she remains hidden trying to control the spread of measels which is becoming a pandemic of epic portions.
Just as Lisbeth realizes she can't take her daughter with her in time, Maggie jumps into her arms at the last moment, just as the watery portal takes them both back to Rome. Her father didn't have the chance to make it. This time when Lisbeth returns to Rome armed with medical supplies to help her mother control the diseases killing the poor, she learns the despite keeping her heart open to loving Cyprian again and sharing the joy of his first child with him, she learns he didn't believe she was coming back and has married her best friend Ruth. Does Lisbeth stay or will she take Maggie and head back to the life she left behind in Dallas? You'll have to pick this one up to find out.
I received Return to Exile by Lynne Gentry compliments of Howard Books, a division of Simon and Schuster Publishers for my honest review. I did not receive any monetary compensation for a favorable review and the opinions expressed here are strictly my own personal opinion. I was so thrilled to see what the outcome would be for Lisbeth and Cyprian and was not prepared for what Lisbeth had to face heading back to Rome. I felt so sorry for her and completely understood how difficult things would be on both ends. I am super excited to see what the outcome will be when the next novel comes out Valley of Decision, and be warned this one does leave you with a bit of a cliff hanger ending but also a sneak peek into the next novel to help calm your nerves a bit. For me, I LOVE this series and this one rates a 5 out of 5 stars in my opinion. A Reader Discussion Guide is included as well as a Q and A with the author at the conclusion of this novel.
If you love time travel, romance or historical fiction, or like me, a bit of all three, you will want to pick up The Carthage Chronicles from best-selling author Lynne Gentry. Her first novel in the series, Healer of Carthage is about a 21st century doctor whose father has a love for archaeology. Couple that with a bit of mysterious paintings in a cave in Egypt, known simply as the Cave of Swimmers. Dr. Lisbeth Hastings lost her mother in the Cave of Swimmers and never knew what happened to her until she herself fell into the watery cavern. Turns out it transports people back into the third century in Rome, not the place you'd want to be as a woman.
In Return to Exile, we pick the series back up after Lisbeth had returned back to the 21st century at the conclusion of the first novel, in love with a man she left behind as her husband. In order to protect her, she was thrown back into the cistern which took her back to present time, where she learned she was pregnant with Cyprian's child. Knowing her daughter is extremely claustrophobic, she knows taking her daughter Maggie back in time, won't be easy. Her father insists on accompanying her to see the wife he thought died so long ago. Turns out she has become infamous for her healing abilities and remains the slave/wife to a cruel dictator named Aspasius, whose goal is to control all the Christians still dwelling in the providence. He has successfully exiled Cyprian and during Lisbeth's escape, her mother managed to flee into the hills where she remains hidden trying to control the spread of measels which is becoming a pandemic of epic portions.
Just as Lisbeth realizes she can't take her daughter with her in time, Maggie jumps into her arms at the last moment, just as the watery portal takes them both back to Rome. Her father didn't have the chance to make it. This time when Lisbeth returns to Rome armed with medical supplies to help her mother control the diseases killing the poor, she learns the despite keeping her heart open to loving Cyprian again and sharing the joy of his first child with him, she learns he didn't believe she was coming back and has married her best friend Ruth. Does Lisbeth stay or will she take Maggie and head back to the life she left behind in Dallas? You'll have to pick this one up to find out.
I received Return to Exile by Lynne Gentry compliments of Howard Books, a division of Simon and Schuster Publishers for my honest review. I did not receive any monetary compensation for a favorable review and the opinions expressed here are strictly my own personal opinion. I was so thrilled to see what the outcome would be for Lisbeth and Cyprian and was not prepared for what Lisbeth had to face heading back to Rome. I felt so sorry for her and completely understood how difficult things would be on both ends. I am super excited to see what the outcome will be when the next novel comes out Valley of Decision, and be warned this one does leave you with a bit of a cliff hanger ending but also a sneak peek into the next novel to help calm your nerves a bit. For me, I LOVE this series and this one rates a 5 out of 5 stars in my opinion. A Reader Discussion Guide is included as well as a Q and A with the author at the conclusion of this novel.
November 14, 2014
I received this book from Netgalley for my honest review.
Grrrrr... Another cliffhanger!!! Noooooo!!!!!
I liked it, really! It was almost better than the first one.
It starts where the first book ended. Lisbeth is back in her own time. She finished her studies and work as a doctor in a hospital, facing death due to a virulent disease. She's now a mother of a girl, Maggie, who desperately want her father, who, as we know, is Cyprian.
Lisbeth is torn because she doesn't know how to explain what happened to a 5 years old. She's missing Cyprian and researches history to find out what happened to him. She discovers that Cyprian will be beheaded in the arena. Horrified, she and her father decide to try to return her in Cyprian time to try to save him and all the people who are dying there.
When they arrive at the cave, Maggie jumps with Lisbeth and they're both transported back in time.
But not everything is as she's been expecting! Cyprian has married Ruth!!! WOW!!!
Well, I'll stop here before I disclose too many spoilers!
Let me say that I could understand Cyprian's choices, even if I didn't liked them. I also could understand Lisbeth disappointed. I think that I will feel the same... It is a tragic situation and Maggie's presence is making everything worse, because Ruth is pregnant too! WOW, what a complicated situation!!!!
Here we have much less romance and much more angst. There's too many things to fight: Aspasius, the disease, the persecution, the betrayals, the anger...
I enjoyed reading about the many things that were happening, but I didn't enjoy at all how Maggies behaved! I understand that she's 5 years old, but her action were really stupid. I perceived her as a complete brat. She didn't obey, she was too mouthy, too headstrong and she put everybody in danger for stupid things. She seemed unaware that they were not at home, but in a very dangerous place!
I also didn't like how Lisbeth reacted to Maggie's antics. She never tried to correct her behaviour, never looked with hawk eye at her, and never even yelled at her when she put everybody in danger! In my opinion, that's not how a mother should educate a child!!!
I also didn't like how Cyprian fronted the situation. He was too doormat. He didn't act at all, but just wallowed in his insecurities....
I still liked Magdalena! She didn't change from the previous book! I even liked Ruth, because she at least understood the situation everybody was in and tried to help in her own way.
I will definitely read the next book because I'm awfully curious to know how they'll extricate themselves from the very intricate situation!
Please Ms. Gentry, don't write another book with a cliffhanger!!! ;)
Grrrrr... Another cliffhanger!!! Noooooo!!!!!
I liked it, really! It was almost better than the first one.
It starts where the first book ended. Lisbeth is back in her own time. She finished her studies and work as a doctor in a hospital, facing death due to a virulent disease. She's now a mother of a girl, Maggie, who desperately want her father, who, as we know, is Cyprian.
Lisbeth is torn because she doesn't know how to explain what happened to a 5 years old. She's missing Cyprian and researches history to find out what happened to him. She discovers that Cyprian will be beheaded in the arena. Horrified, she and her father decide to try to return her in Cyprian time to try to save him and all the people who are dying there.
When they arrive at the cave, Maggie jumps with Lisbeth and they're both transported back in time.
But not everything is as she's been expecting! Cyprian has married Ruth!!! WOW!!!
Well, I'll stop here before I disclose too many spoilers!
Let me say that I could understand Cyprian's choices, even if I didn't liked them. I also could understand Lisbeth disappointed. I think that I will feel the same... It is a tragic situation and Maggie's presence is making everything worse, because Ruth is pregnant too! WOW, what a complicated situation!!!!
Here we have much less romance and much more angst. There's too many things to fight: Aspasius, the disease, the persecution, the betrayals, the anger...
I enjoyed reading about the many things that were happening, but I didn't enjoy at all how Maggies behaved! I understand that she's 5 years old, but her action were really stupid. I perceived her as a complete brat. She didn't obey, she was too mouthy, too headstrong and she put everybody in danger for stupid things. She seemed unaware that they were not at home, but in a very dangerous place!
I also didn't like how Lisbeth reacted to Maggie's antics. She never tried to correct her behaviour, never looked with hawk eye at her, and never even yelled at her when she put everybody in danger! In my opinion, that's not how a mother should educate a child!!!
I also didn't like how Cyprian fronted the situation. He was too doormat. He didn't act at all, but just wallowed in his insecurities....
I still liked Magdalena! She didn't change from the previous book! I even liked Ruth, because she at least understood the situation everybody was in and tried to help in her own way.
I will definitely read the next book because I'm awfully curious to know how they'll extricate themselves from the very intricate situation!
Please Ms. Gentry, don't write another book with a cliffhanger!!! ;)
February 17, 2015
Lynne Gentry in her new book, “Return To Exile” Book Two in The Carthage Chronicles series published by Howard Books continues the story of Dr. Lisbeth Hastings.
From the back cover: How far would you go to save the ones you love?
Six years ago, impossible circumstances forced Dr. Lisbeth Hastings to leave behind the love of her life, not just in another country, but in another time. Her work as a top-notch epidemiologist and parenting her little girl helps alleviate the pain, but at night when her exhausted head hits the pillow, images of her beloved Cyprian haunt her sleep.
Cyprian Thascius returns from political exile a broken man. He’s lost his faith, the love of his life, and his purpose. He attempts to move on, to face the danger that is looming over Carthage, but when Cyprian’s true love suddenly reappears, his heart becomes as imperiled as the fledgling church he seeks to save.
Have the years that kept Lisbeth and Cyprian apart created too wide a chasm to bridge? In the midst of a new epidemic and rising oppression, will their love be the most costly fatality? Filled with gripping action and raw emotion, this spellbinding adventure of star-crossed lovers captivates with every turn of the page in this electric continuation of The Carthage Chronicles.
Lynne Gentry has given us one of the most imaginative and clever series that I have encountered. Historical fiction and time travel. Two elements that if not handled correctly can spell doom for the reader. Have no fear Ms. Gentry is an expert crafts-person and puts them together perfectly. “Return To Exile” is a great ride! Like a great play this is the second act and all second acts are a bit dark and end with a cliffhanger. Lisbeth has gone back in time again with Maggie, Lisbeth’s and Cyprian’s daughter. There is all kinds of danger, the church is in chaos, Cyprian is in danger and to protect himself he may marry someone he doesn’t love and there is typhoid. Ms. Gentry has given us an action adventure tale that will get your nerves all jangled as you read furiously trying to keep up with the story. And there is the romance. Plus this is a thriller that just drips with suspense so be prepared. I guarantee you, you will not be disappointed in reading this book. The characters are marvelous and they live and breathe on these pages. I am glad I found this wonderful author and I am so looking forward to book three!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Litfuse Publicity Group. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
From the back cover: How far would you go to save the ones you love?
Six years ago, impossible circumstances forced Dr. Lisbeth Hastings to leave behind the love of her life, not just in another country, but in another time. Her work as a top-notch epidemiologist and parenting her little girl helps alleviate the pain, but at night when her exhausted head hits the pillow, images of her beloved Cyprian haunt her sleep.
Cyprian Thascius returns from political exile a broken man. He’s lost his faith, the love of his life, and his purpose. He attempts to move on, to face the danger that is looming over Carthage, but when Cyprian’s true love suddenly reappears, his heart becomes as imperiled as the fledgling church he seeks to save.
Have the years that kept Lisbeth and Cyprian apart created too wide a chasm to bridge? In the midst of a new epidemic and rising oppression, will their love be the most costly fatality? Filled with gripping action and raw emotion, this spellbinding adventure of star-crossed lovers captivates with every turn of the page in this electric continuation of The Carthage Chronicles.
Lynne Gentry has given us one of the most imaginative and clever series that I have encountered. Historical fiction and time travel. Two elements that if not handled correctly can spell doom for the reader. Have no fear Ms. Gentry is an expert crafts-person and puts them together perfectly. “Return To Exile” is a great ride! Like a great play this is the second act and all second acts are a bit dark and end with a cliffhanger. Lisbeth has gone back in time again with Maggie, Lisbeth’s and Cyprian’s daughter. There is all kinds of danger, the church is in chaos, Cyprian is in danger and to protect himself he may marry someone he doesn’t love and there is typhoid. Ms. Gentry has given us an action adventure tale that will get your nerves all jangled as you read furiously trying to keep up with the story. And there is the romance. Plus this is a thriller that just drips with suspense so be prepared. I guarantee you, you will not be disappointed in reading this book. The characters are marvelous and they live and breathe on these pages. I am glad I found this wonderful author and I am so looking forward to book three!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Litfuse Publicity Group. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
January 7, 2015
This is the second title in The Carthage Chronicles and is a continuation of the story begun in Healer of Carthage. I strongly recommend reading that book first or little in Return to Exile will make sense.
It’s been one year since Cyprian was exiled from the great city of Carthage by his enemy, Proconsul Aspasius Paternus. But a proconsul must also enforce edicts from Rome, and Emperor Valerian has demanded that Cyprian be allowed to return home. Another edict, however, may help Aspasius permanently defeat Cyprian and his Christian friends. That’s if Aspasius can stay alive long enough to do so, and a debilitating medical issue may prevent that. Meanwhile, six years have passed for Cyprian’s wife, Lisbeth. She’s the single parent to their daughter, Maggie, and holding down a full time job as a doctor at a busy hospital. She’s also facing a disease she last saw in third century Carthage. Maggie, meanwhile, wants a daddy, and Lisbeth’s father thinks his granddaughter deserves to know the truth.
Return to Exile is a tense affair. The reader is never quite sure who will live and who will die. The Christian community faces persecution and disease, with the proconsul believing they are responsible for the epidemic in Carthage. Lisbeth’s reappearance gives them additional ways of fighting the sickness, but also provides unforeseen complications, including a personal one that I thought came across as awkward and perhaps unnecessary to the plot. I also could have done without the vivid descriptions of Aspasius’s ailments. I was, however, unprepared for the resolution of his story since it contradicts established history.
Fans of alternative history and science fiction would appreciate this novel, if they’ve read Healer of Carthage first. There’s a contemplation of time travel paradoxes after Lisbeth discovers the fate of the historical Cyprian. What would it mean for history if she could change that? Was Aspasius’s fate a result of her time traveling? Perhaps time travel fans can also understand why time passes at a different speed for Lisbeth and Cyprian in their separate lives, because it’s not something I comprehended.
Don’t expect a neatly wrapped up ending. This is the middle book of The Carthage Chronicles and it does feel like filler at times. It’s another episode of Lisbeth down the Tunisian rabbit hole. I do expect, however, for there to be full resolution in book three. Valley of Decision will be released in September 2015.
Thank you to Howard books for my complimentary copy of Return to Exile, which I received in exchange for an honest review.
It’s been one year since Cyprian was exiled from the great city of Carthage by his enemy, Proconsul Aspasius Paternus. But a proconsul must also enforce edicts from Rome, and Emperor Valerian has demanded that Cyprian be allowed to return home. Another edict, however, may help Aspasius permanently defeat Cyprian and his Christian friends. That’s if Aspasius can stay alive long enough to do so, and a debilitating medical issue may prevent that. Meanwhile, six years have passed for Cyprian’s wife, Lisbeth. She’s the single parent to their daughter, Maggie, and holding down a full time job as a doctor at a busy hospital. She’s also facing a disease she last saw in third century Carthage. Maggie, meanwhile, wants a daddy, and Lisbeth’s father thinks his granddaughter deserves to know the truth.
Return to Exile is a tense affair. The reader is never quite sure who will live and who will die. The Christian community faces persecution and disease, with the proconsul believing they are responsible for the epidemic in Carthage. Lisbeth’s reappearance gives them additional ways of fighting the sickness, but also provides unforeseen complications, including a personal one that I thought came across as awkward and perhaps unnecessary to the plot. I also could have done without the vivid descriptions of Aspasius’s ailments. I was, however, unprepared for the resolution of his story since it contradicts established history.
Fans of alternative history and science fiction would appreciate this novel, if they’ve read Healer of Carthage first. There’s a contemplation of time travel paradoxes after Lisbeth discovers the fate of the historical Cyprian. What would it mean for history if she could change that? Was Aspasius’s fate a result of her time traveling? Perhaps time travel fans can also understand why time passes at a different speed for Lisbeth and Cyprian in their separate lives, because it’s not something I comprehended.
Don’t expect a neatly wrapped up ending. This is the middle book of The Carthage Chronicles and it does feel like filler at times. It’s another episode of Lisbeth down the Tunisian rabbit hole. I do expect, however, for there to be full resolution in book three. Valley of Decision will be released in September 2015.
Thank you to Howard books for my complimentary copy of Return to Exile, which I received in exchange for an honest review.
February 14, 2015
Return to Exile is the second installment to the Carthage Chronicles. This is the Outlander of Christian fiction that has all the time travel and romance elements that leave the readers happy. From the beautiful book cover to the rich writing, this book will leave you excited for the next one.
My Thoughts
Well written, engaging and exciting to read! Grab this book and be ready to be transported in time!
So, I didn't read the first novel in this series and wish that I did. I feel there was character development and the building of relationships between characters that I missed in the first one that hindered my ability as a reader with connecting. That didn't in any way stop me from reading this book and marveling at the beautiful writing and plot development, just made me wish I had more as a reader with these characters.
I love time travel books. This book reminded me of Lisa T. Bregren's River of Time Series, just a little more adult friendly in the sense that the main characters are adults and not teenagers. I always find it fascinating when christian authors write with time travel involved and then still use God as an element in their writing. I mean who wouldn't want to go back in time? I'm not entirely well-versed in the history or time period that this book is based in, but it felt very authentic.
I loved the relationship between Baek and Maggie, the two children. It was very fun to read their interactions with one another, and how they started to form a bond despite their differences of age and life experiences.
(Warning minor spoiler alert! Skip to next paragraph!)
To be honest, the one thing I didn't entirely understand was Ruth marrying Cyprian, and then to have her die... I felt that this was just a way for Cyprian to be with Lisabeth again...even though he was married to Lisabeth... I don't know if maybe the author wanted to have the characters go through tension, or figure out their grief? But it felt almost unnecessary. Then again it could be because I missed out on the first book I missed why this happened.
(END OF SPOILER)
The relationship between Lisabeth and Cyprian is great to read too. They both have big responsibilities to accomplish and hurdles of issues to figure out when they are reunited. The book ends on a cliffhanger leaving me begging to know what is going to happen to Lisabeth and Cyprian!? I guess that means I will have to read the next one!
Rating: 4 out of 5 bookshelves
Disclaimer: I received a free copy for an honest review from Litfuse Publicity Group.
My Thoughts
Well written, engaging and exciting to read! Grab this book and be ready to be transported in time!
So, I didn't read the first novel in this series and wish that I did. I feel there was character development and the building of relationships between characters that I missed in the first one that hindered my ability as a reader with connecting. That didn't in any way stop me from reading this book and marveling at the beautiful writing and plot development, just made me wish I had more as a reader with these characters.
I love time travel books. This book reminded me of Lisa T. Bregren's River of Time Series, just a little more adult friendly in the sense that the main characters are adults and not teenagers. I always find it fascinating when christian authors write with time travel involved and then still use God as an element in their writing. I mean who wouldn't want to go back in time? I'm not entirely well-versed in the history or time period that this book is based in, but it felt very authentic.
I loved the relationship between Baek and Maggie, the two children. It was very fun to read their interactions with one another, and how they started to form a bond despite their differences of age and life experiences.
(Warning minor spoiler alert! Skip to next paragraph!)
To be honest, the one thing I didn't entirely understand was Ruth marrying Cyprian, and then to have her die... I felt that this was just a way for Cyprian to be with Lisabeth again...even though he was married to Lisabeth... I don't know if maybe the author wanted to have the characters go through tension, or figure out their grief? But it felt almost unnecessary. Then again it could be because I missed out on the first book I missed why this happened.
(END OF SPOILER)
The relationship between Lisabeth and Cyprian is great to read too. They both have big responsibilities to accomplish and hurdles of issues to figure out when they are reunited. The book ends on a cliffhanger leaving me begging to know what is going to happen to Lisabeth and Cyprian!? I guess that means I will have to read the next one!
Rating: 4 out of 5 bookshelves
Disclaimer: I received a free copy for an honest review from Litfuse Publicity Group.
February 16, 2015
I've been a time travel nut for years, but I've never read one as unique and detailed as this! We usually make our time travelers visit the romantic times in history - the times of knights and castles or the Wild West with cowboys and ladies in prairie plaid, but Gentry has taken a whole new approach. She's taken romance to a new level by inserting it into a time travel story between the ultimate modern lady - a doctor - and a real historical figure in Cyprian, a Christian martyr.
The fact that Cyprian has such a seemingly pious life might make one think the story would be dull, but it's the complete opposite. With multiple plagues, treason, slavery, and a class war going on, this story is full of intrigue and excitement. It is the second in the series, and so it took me a few pages to figure out exactly who everyone was, but Gentry does a great job of filling in the backstory, and I was soon up to speed and running with it.
I used to think that the early church history was boring. Wasn't it all about super-smart people preaching all the time? Except, as Gentry expertly shares, it wasn't. It was about, as it is now, putting Jesus' teachings into action, and those should be carried out in deed as well as in prayer and study. At this time in history, it was about sharing and surviving and being brave enough to face death for your choices. For Jesus. It was about putting your faith on the line for all to see, and since we aren't in that same situation here in the States, we often forget just what other people must put on the line for their faith.
I loved the contrast between Lisbeth's desire to help and her initial willingness to put everything on the line. Between her desire to control and her desire to sacrifice. Between her desire for the man she loves and the One she's declared Lord of all. The characters are real and the problems honest. While we're probably not going to drop into another century anytime soon, we are called to live out our faith in myriads of ways every day - and like others around the world, the time may come when those decisions have life-and-death consequences. What will you choose? How will you make that choice?
Return to Exile is both provocative and exciting. I can't wait to read the rest of the series.
I hope you do, too.
I received a free copy of this book from LitFuse Publicity in exchange for an honest review.
The fact that Cyprian has such a seemingly pious life might make one think the story would be dull, but it's the complete opposite. With multiple plagues, treason, slavery, and a class war going on, this story is full of intrigue and excitement. It is the second in the series, and so it took me a few pages to figure out exactly who everyone was, but Gentry does a great job of filling in the backstory, and I was soon up to speed and running with it.
I used to think that the early church history was boring. Wasn't it all about super-smart people preaching all the time? Except, as Gentry expertly shares, it wasn't. It was about, as it is now, putting Jesus' teachings into action, and those should be carried out in deed as well as in prayer and study. At this time in history, it was about sharing and surviving and being brave enough to face death for your choices. For Jesus. It was about putting your faith on the line for all to see, and since we aren't in that same situation here in the States, we often forget just what other people must put on the line for their faith.
I loved the contrast between Lisbeth's desire to help and her initial willingness to put everything on the line. Between her desire to control and her desire to sacrifice. Between her desire for the man she loves and the One she's declared Lord of all. The characters are real and the problems honest. While we're probably not going to drop into another century anytime soon, we are called to live out our faith in myriads of ways every day - and like others around the world, the time may come when those decisions have life-and-death consequences. What will you choose? How will you make that choice?
Return to Exile is both provocative and exciting. I can't wait to read the rest of the series.
I hope you do, too.
I received a free copy of this book from LitFuse Publicity in exchange for an honest review.
March 20, 2015
I have to say, I didn't like this book as much as its predecessor, but I don't think that has anything to do with the quality of it; rather, it has to do with the realism of it: I was discomfited that the story did not continue in the way I wanted/expected it to. Gentry truly deserves props for this: I was so invested in the story that I was affronted on behalf of our protagonist, Lisbeth, when things did not turn out the way they thought she would.
The huge twist about halfway through is both devastating and very well done. It was practically telegraphed at an earlier point in the book, but Gentry cleverly played it off and then came back and hit the reader with it. It has dramatic repercussions for the star-crossed Cyprian and Lisbeth, and my heart went out to all the characters involved. I could see only one way that circumstances could be changed in Lisbeth's favor, and in that way the book was predictable, but I don't fault Gentry for that, as it still felt consistent with the overall setting and story.
I enjoyed meeting Lisbeth's daughter and liked the added dimension that she brought to the story. Lisbeth no longer has just herself to think of when she makes decisions, and it weighs on her and forces her to make some painful choices. As with Healer of Carthage, I also felt that by reading this book I learned a little more about communicable diseases and the danger of epidemics. I'm always up for a small dose of education with my fiction!
I was a little disappointed that Lisbeth (and her father, too) seemed to have become a Christian in between this book and Healer of Carthage, but at the same time it felt realistic: for many, the journey to faith is gradual and there is no dramatic come-to-Jesus moment. Lisbeth clearly became more open to Christianity in the first book, living with the Christian community in Carthage and watching God work through them. Lisbeth herself notes that it was Cyprian's sacrifice for her that pushed her most strongly into the Lord's arms. Disappointment aside, I was happy for this development and found it very interesting to observe how Lisbeth's new-found faith affected her thoughts, her actions, and her decisions.
Another great read from Lynne Gentry. Just as good as Healer of Carthage, though grittier and grimmer. I can't wait for book three!
The huge twist about halfway through is both devastating and very well done. It was practically telegraphed at an earlier point in the book, but Gentry cleverly played it off and then came back and hit the reader with it. It has dramatic repercussions for the star-crossed Cyprian and Lisbeth, and my heart went out to all the characters involved. I could see only one way that circumstances could be changed in Lisbeth's favor, and in that way the book was predictable, but I don't fault Gentry for that, as it still felt consistent with the overall setting and story.
I enjoyed meeting Lisbeth's daughter and liked the added dimension that she brought to the story. Lisbeth no longer has just herself to think of when she makes decisions, and it weighs on her and forces her to make some painful choices. As with Healer of Carthage, I also felt that by reading this book I learned a little more about communicable diseases and the danger of epidemics. I'm always up for a small dose of education with my fiction!
I was a little disappointed that Lisbeth (and her father, too) seemed to have become a Christian in between this book and Healer of Carthage, but at the same time it felt realistic: for many, the journey to faith is gradual and there is no dramatic come-to-Jesus moment. Lisbeth clearly became more open to Christianity in the first book, living with the Christian community in Carthage and watching God work through them. Lisbeth herself notes that it was Cyprian's sacrifice for her that pushed her most strongly into the Lord's arms. Disappointment aside, I was happy for this development and found it very interesting to observe how Lisbeth's new-found faith affected her thoughts, her actions, and her decisions.
Another great read from Lynne Gentry. Just as good as Healer of Carthage, though grittier and grimmer. I can't wait for book three!
February 6, 2015
4.5
I really enjoyed Healer of Carthage, it helped fill the void of another time traveling, historical romance I enjoy. I was thrilled that I didn't have to wait too awfully long to read the second book in the series, Return to Exile...and goodness! I liked this book even more then the first!
This story took me everywhere! The past, the present, Dallas, Texas, Tunisia, and Carthage. Then once the travel had ended, we weren't done yet. The twists and turns took this story even deeper into the characters lives...and wow! The twists that this book had. I couldn't believe where it went several times. I had to re-read a few parts to make sure through the surprise, I had read it right.
This book takes place 5 years after the end of Healer of Carthage. Much has happened in Lisbeth's life since the end. However, one thing that hasn't changed is Lisabeth's desire to help people and use her knowledge of healing. She has moved forward with her education and tries to use it as much as she can.
Cyprian also has dealt with so much change since the end of the last book. The struggle has aged him a bit, but he tries to push forward despite the battles he wages inside of his mind and from others.
Ruth, kind and gentle Ruth is still around and she hasn't been unphased by all of the events, time has made her a little older, as with everyone else, and tired. She has kept the hospital that Lisbeth has set up for the community and has watched over all the ones who have asked for help. Her character is very gentle, but smart. After this book, she reminds me a bit of Melanie Hamilton from Gone with the Wind. She is a quiet and kind character, who care for those around her, no matter what is going on. Those characters are a wonderful addition to a story.
I can't wait for Valley of Decision, especially after reading the snip-it at the end of the book. So much to come!
Thank you to Litfuse and Howard Books, I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest review.
This review was originally posted @ http://wordsfromabookaholic.blogspot....
I really enjoyed Healer of Carthage, it helped fill the void of another time traveling, historical romance I enjoy. I was thrilled that I didn't have to wait too awfully long to read the second book in the series, Return to Exile...and goodness! I liked this book even more then the first!
This story took me everywhere! The past, the present, Dallas, Texas, Tunisia, and Carthage. Then once the travel had ended, we weren't done yet. The twists and turns took this story even deeper into the characters lives...and wow! The twists that this book had. I couldn't believe where it went several times. I had to re-read a few parts to make sure through the surprise, I had read it right.
This book takes place 5 years after the end of Healer of Carthage. Much has happened in Lisbeth's life since the end. However, one thing that hasn't changed is Lisabeth's desire to help people and use her knowledge of healing. She has moved forward with her education and tries to use it as much as she can.
Cyprian also has dealt with so much change since the end of the last book. The struggle has aged him a bit, but he tries to push forward despite the battles he wages inside of his mind and from others.
Ruth, kind and gentle Ruth is still around and she hasn't been unphased by all of the events, time has made her a little older, as with everyone else, and tired. She has kept the hospital that Lisbeth has set up for the community and has watched over all the ones who have asked for help. Her character is very gentle, but smart. After this book, she reminds me a bit of Melanie Hamilton from Gone with the Wind. She is a quiet and kind character, who care for those around her, no matter what is going on. Those characters are a wonderful addition to a story.
I can't wait for Valley of Decision, especially after reading the snip-it at the end of the book. So much to come!
Thank you to Litfuse and Howard Books, I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest review.
This review was originally posted @ http://wordsfromabookaholic.blogspot....
Displaying 1 - 30 of 85 reviews