What do you think?
Rate this book
A Man Downstairs
What if the childhood you remember isn’t really what happened at all?
From the acclaimed author of An Unthinkable Thing and Hideaway, a breath-stopping novel of suspense about a woman tormented by memories of the past and threatened by long-held secrets in the present.
Molly Wynters has moved back to her small hometown to care for her father, recently felled by a stroke and no longer able to communicate. She is ready to make a fresh start with her son after her divorce, but is haunted by both old events and new realities in her childhood home.
What Molly recalls of her young life with her father is full of love and care, even though a violent trauma defined her when she was a young girl, she witnessed her mother’s murder, and her testimony – “There was a man downstairs” – sent a teenager to prison. This tragic episode is still very much alive in the culture of the town, and the more Molly remembers, the more she fears that what she said on the stand all those years ago might not have been the whole truth.
After Molly, a trained therapist, volunteers for a local helpline, the threats begin. At first they seem random, but soon Molly realizes that she is a target, and even those closest to her seem suspicious, especially as unsuspected links between them emerge. More than one life was destroyed on that horrific long-ago day, and now someone intends to hold Molly accountable.
With its gripping descent into the shadowy corners of the human psyche A Man Downstairs is both an edge-of-your-seat thrill ride and a masterful exploration of the fragile nature of memory.
From the acclaimed author of An Unthinkable Thing and Hideaway, a breath-stopping novel of suspense about a woman tormented by memories of the past and threatened by long-held secrets in the present.
Molly Wynters has moved back to her small hometown to care for her father, recently felled by a stroke and no longer able to communicate. She is ready to make a fresh start with her son after her divorce, but is haunted by both old events and new realities in her childhood home.
What Molly recalls of her young life with her father is full of love and care, even though a violent trauma defined her when she was a young girl, she witnessed her mother’s murder, and her testimony – “There was a man downstairs” – sent a teenager to prison. This tragic episode is still very much alive in the culture of the town, and the more Molly remembers, the more she fears that what she said on the stand all those years ago might not have been the whole truth.
After Molly, a trained therapist, volunteers for a local helpline, the threats begin. At first they seem random, but soon Molly realizes that she is a target, and even those closest to her seem suspicious, especially as unsuspected links between them emerge. More than one life was destroyed on that horrific long-ago day, and now someone intends to hold Molly accountable.
With its gripping descent into the shadowy corners of the human psyche A Man Downstairs is both an edge-of-your-seat thrill ride and a masterful exploration of the fragile nature of memory.
Audiobook
First published March 5, 2024
101 people are currently reading
10030 people want to read
About the author
Nicole Lundrigan
11 books440 followers“Lundrigan’s skillfully balanced blend of psychological thriller and haunting coming-of-age story is infused with creepy, small-town atmospheric suspense. . . . [Her] writing is both elegant and darkly humorous, delivering bareknuckle social commentary that will appeal to fans of Gillian Flynn, Karin Fossum, and Laura Lippman.”
Booklist, Starred review
Nicole is the author of eight novels including THE SUBSTITUTE, HIDEAWAY, and AN UNTHINKABLE THING. Her work has been selected as a Top 10 pick by Canada’s national newspaper the Globe & Mail, a top 100 on amazon.ca, a top 10 by Now Magazine, and was shortlisted for the Arthur Ellis Award (best crime novel).
If you'd like to connect with Nicole, you can do so through her website.
Booklist, Starred review
Nicole is the author of eight novels including THE SUBSTITUTE, HIDEAWAY, and AN UNTHINKABLE THING. Her work has been selected as a Top 10 pick by Canada’s national newspaper the Globe & Mail, a top 100 on amazon.ca, a top 10 by Now Magazine, and was shortlisted for the Arthur Ellis Award (best crime novel).
If you'd like to connect with Nicole, you can do so through her website.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 456 reviews
April 20, 2024
Writing: Minimalist | Plot: subtly spooky | Ending: normal
my opinion
Woolalaaaaaa! Taking a break from thrillers has done me good because the rare time I pick one up these days, I tend to enjoy it more. Was this perfect? Absolutely not. Molly loved to go full dumbass mode sometimes. But did I eat it up like a hungry dog? Yesssirrrr.
I actually started this one with my earholes (thanks Libro.fm for the ALC), but I was so intrigued I switched over to the ole eyeballs. If audiobooks are more your thing, definitely check it out. The female narrator gave me HBO True Detective vibes.
Despite it being on the chonky side, I felt the pacing was quite good. The spooky elements were subtle, but created a tense undercurrent. Yes, the baddie reveal was wholly predictable, but I'm partial to a tame ending vs a Hail Mary shock reveal that makes no damn sense.
I'm also a stan of multiple povs and dual timelines. Lundrigan really got into the head of the deranged mystery man and she did a solid job showing the deterioration of Gil's marriage in the wake of Edie's mental health struggles. It reminded me of Beneath Cruel Waters, which is an absolute favourite of mine.
As I said earlier, Molly's brain wasn't always firing on all cylinders. Should she have her psychologist license revoked? Most likely. And her son???? Omg. Maybe we do need to bring bullying back because he needed his ass checked ASAP. Honestly, he didn't need to be in the book at all. The conflict between him and Molly was never properly addressed nor solved, just shoved aside for the HEA. All he did was annoy me and then make me feel bad for wanting to bop a 15 yr old fictional character in the face.
Anyways, in no way shape or form do I recommend this with chest. I'm not sure what "type" of reader would enjoy this best. My radar is all wonky after I tried to recommend this to Karly, my reading twin, and she told me it was hot steaming two-star trash. Buuuuuuut I'll tell you right now the Freida Readah's (*shudders*) will most likely describe this as "boring" and "slow."
pros & cons
pros: dual timelines and multiple povs (not for everyone, but certainly for me), subtle spookiness that kept me engaged, good pacing... felt like something intriguing was happening every chapter, quick read despite the page length, GREAT epilogue (I never say this!!!), audiobook narrator was solid as well, reasonable ending (no crazy, OTT twists a la Freida McFadden)
cons: Molly made several poor decisions, there are probably some plot holes in there I didn't catch because I was too busy vibing so don't come for me in the comments
__
Check out my YouTube
my opinion
Woolalaaaaaa! Taking a break from thrillers has done me good because the rare time I pick one up these days, I tend to enjoy it more. Was this perfect? Absolutely not. Molly loved to go full dumbass mode sometimes. But did I eat it up like a hungry dog? Yesssirrrr.
I actually started this one with my earholes (thanks Libro.fm for the ALC), but I was so intrigued I switched over to the ole eyeballs. If audiobooks are more your thing, definitely check it out. The female narrator gave me HBO True Detective vibes.
Despite it being on the chonky side, I felt the pacing was quite good. The spooky elements were subtle, but created a tense undercurrent. Yes, the baddie reveal was wholly predictable, but I'm partial to a tame ending vs a Hail Mary shock reveal that makes no damn sense.
I'm also a stan of multiple povs and dual timelines. Lundrigan really got into the head of the deranged mystery man and she did a solid job showing the deterioration of Gil's marriage in the wake of Edie's mental health struggles. It reminded me of Beneath Cruel Waters, which is an absolute favourite of mine.
As I said earlier, Molly's brain wasn't always firing on all cylinders. Should she have her psychologist license revoked? Most likely. And her son???? Omg. Maybe we do need to bring bullying back because he needed his ass checked ASAP. Honestly, he didn't need to be in the book at all. The conflict between him and Molly was never properly addressed nor solved, just shoved aside for the HEA. All he did was annoy me and then make me feel bad for wanting to bop a 15 yr old fictional character in the face.
Anyways, in no way shape or form do I recommend this with chest. I'm not sure what "type" of reader would enjoy this best. My radar is all wonky after I tried to recommend this to Karly, my reading twin, and she told me it was hot steaming two-star trash. Buuuuuuut I'll tell you right now the Freida Readah's (*shudders*) will most likely describe this as "boring" and "slow."
pros & cons
pros: dual timelines and multiple povs (not for everyone, but certainly for me), subtle spookiness that kept me engaged, good pacing... felt like something intriguing was happening every chapter, quick read despite the page length, GREAT epilogue (I never say this!!!), audiobook narrator was solid as well, reasonable ending (no crazy, OTT twists a la Freida McFadden)
cons: Molly made several poor decisions, there are probably some plot holes in there I didn't catch because I was too busy vibing so don't come for me in the comments
__
Check out my YouTube
April 10, 2024
I must admit, it's been quite some time since I've encountered such a meticulously crafted character analysis and execution in a book, offering a refreshingly realistic and unadulterated perspective.
The narrative seamlessly navigates between past and present, employing three distinct points of view in third person narration, while interweaving the enigmatic musings of a character simply referred to as "him" through first person narration. This intricate storytelling technique, coupled with a well-paced, puzzle-like structure, invites readers to piece together the intricate web surrounding the fate of Edie Wynters. Is the man lurking downstairs truly the culprit, or merely a scapegoat? What could have led Edie to amass such a host of enemies intent on harming her? And who was she truly? A hapless mother brutally slain by a disturbed teenager, or a figure harboring a plethora of dark secrets that incited those around her to unspeakable acts?
This thriller grips you from the outset, compelling you to engage your cognitive faculties in unraveling its mysteries, formulating hypotheses, only to abandon them in favor of new theories as the plot thickens. Yet, the true strength of the narrative lies in its impeccable characterization. None of the characters are easily categorized as wholly likable or detestable; rather, they are imbued with imperfections, vulnerabilities, and internal struggles, mirroring the complexities of real life. This nuanced portrayal lends an authenticity to their actions and motivations, allowing readers to empathize with even the most morally dubious among them, who, in their own twisted logic, harbor justifications for their deeds. In this story, moral boundaries are blurred, and the characters inhabit the murky gray area between righteousness and villainy.
At its core, the tale centers around Molly Wynters, a recently divorced therapist returning to her hometown to care for her ailing father following his stroke. As Molly grapples with her own familial and personal struggles, including a troubled teenage son embroiled in a social media scandal, she is confronted with a haunting legacy of her past: the unsolved murder of her mother decades earlier. Complicating matters further, an anonymous caller accuses Molly of wrongful testimony, casting doubt on the conviction of the teenager she once identified as her mother's killer. Determined to uncover the truth behind that fateful night forty years ago, Molly finds herself embroiled in a perilous quest that threatens to unravel the fabric of her existence.
In conclusion, this psychological thriller is a masterfully balanced and intricately constructed narrative that firmly establishes the author as one to watch in the realm of suspense fiction.
I extend my sincere gratitude to NetGalley and Penguin Random House Canada / Viking for graciously providing me with a digital review copy of this captivating thriller in exchange for my honest appraisal.
medium.com
instagram
facebook
twitter
The narrative seamlessly navigates between past and present, employing three distinct points of view in third person narration, while interweaving the enigmatic musings of a character simply referred to as "him" through first person narration. This intricate storytelling technique, coupled with a well-paced, puzzle-like structure, invites readers to piece together the intricate web surrounding the fate of Edie Wynters. Is the man lurking downstairs truly the culprit, or merely a scapegoat? What could have led Edie to amass such a host of enemies intent on harming her? And who was she truly? A hapless mother brutally slain by a disturbed teenager, or a figure harboring a plethora of dark secrets that incited those around her to unspeakable acts?
This thriller grips you from the outset, compelling you to engage your cognitive faculties in unraveling its mysteries, formulating hypotheses, only to abandon them in favor of new theories as the plot thickens. Yet, the true strength of the narrative lies in its impeccable characterization. None of the characters are easily categorized as wholly likable or detestable; rather, they are imbued with imperfections, vulnerabilities, and internal struggles, mirroring the complexities of real life. This nuanced portrayal lends an authenticity to their actions and motivations, allowing readers to empathize with even the most morally dubious among them, who, in their own twisted logic, harbor justifications for their deeds. In this story, moral boundaries are blurred, and the characters inhabit the murky gray area between righteousness and villainy.
At its core, the tale centers around Molly Wynters, a recently divorced therapist returning to her hometown to care for her ailing father following his stroke. As Molly grapples with her own familial and personal struggles, including a troubled teenage son embroiled in a social media scandal, she is confronted with a haunting legacy of her past: the unsolved murder of her mother decades earlier. Complicating matters further, an anonymous caller accuses Molly of wrongful testimony, casting doubt on the conviction of the teenager she once identified as her mother's killer. Determined to uncover the truth behind that fateful night forty years ago, Molly finds herself embroiled in a perilous quest that threatens to unravel the fabric of her existence.
In conclusion, this psychological thriller is a masterfully balanced and intricately constructed narrative that firmly establishes the author as one to watch in the realm of suspense fiction.
I extend my sincere gratitude to NetGalley and Penguin Random House Canada / Viking for graciously providing me with a digital review copy of this captivating thriller in exchange for my honest appraisal.
medium.com
May 18, 2024
After her father’s debilitating stroke, Molly Wynters returns to her small hometown of Aymes to care for him in his broken state. Now merely the shell of the man she remembers, she is forced to watch him sit in his wheelchair and stare out of the windows of her childhood home. No longer able to communicate, all she has to go on are her memories of the man she adored growing up. Loving and devoted, he was the perfect father. If only she could ask his advice following her divorce and recent troubles with her teenage son, Alex.
At the same time, however, there are darker recollections that reside both in Molly’s hometown and her childhood home. At only four years of age, she witnessed her mother’s murder in their very own garage. Tasked with giving evidence at the killer’s trial, her testimony alone sent a young teenage boy to prison. Despite forty years since that life-changing event, she’s never second guessed what she said on the stand. The longer she’s in town, however, the more details seem to become clear and Molly wonders if it’s possible that she has never actually know the full truth of that fateful day.
It isn’t until Molly decides to assist with the local help line, though, that her deepest fear seems to take hold. One night during a call, she receives a distressing threat when a mysterious voice wants to know what she remembers about her mother’s death. As Molly starts to look closer at those around her, they each seem suspicious. From the local cop to her own landlord, there are more connections to the past than she would like. More worrisome, however, is the realization that her words as a child just might have consequences on her life now. After all, someone seems intent on making sure that she pays for her actions.
Wow. That’s all I can say about A Man Downstairs. An eerily dark drama embedded with foreboding and suspense, I was spellbound throughout the four hundred pages. And while I was anticipating a more hard-hitting thriller, the realization that it was actually an exploration of the more human side of a small town’s very worst event somehow still satisfied my thriller loving core. Adept at spinning a captivating tale, Lundrigan revealed herself as a master of immersive storytelling that kept my fingers quickly flipping the pages.
Much more a character-driven plot than action-packed with surprises, the fully fleshed out personas kept me on the back foot throughout. Told from multiple POVs and dual timelines, the plot was slowly revealed through its multitude of layers. Piece by piece, revelations were unfurled until the timely, pulse-pounding climax exploded all of my expectations with a truth that was shocking in the extreme. Hard to wrap my head around, but also entirely believable, Lundrigan nailed it in one.
As for those characters, each and every one of them were just a little bit morally gray. With plenty of disturbing motivations and long hidden secrets, my distrust meter was off the chart as I questioned every single individuals’ true plans and goals. From the creepy landlord to the all too helpful live-in nurse, there was even an anonymous narrator who made me squirm with distaste. All together, I looked at each with more than suspicion. And, IYKYK, but second guessing all involved is one of the hallmarks of a truly great author for any mystery/thriller.
All said and done, while the plot was anything but fast-paced, this epic slow burn revealed dark truths about society as well as providing a riveting tale of suspense. With multiple subplots that all revolved around a deep understanding of human nature, I was simply gobsmacked by the time I closed the cover. Even better, the evocative prose made me feel as if I were there as the past came calling. But the best bit? That was easily the conclusion, which led me to deeply want a sequel to the perfectly plotted finale. Rating of 4 stars.
Thank you to Nicole Lundrigan, Viking Books, and Thriller Book Lovers Promotions for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: March 5, 2024
Trigger warning: aftermath of a stroke, type one diabetes, death of a parent, psychosis, burglary, mania, threatening calls, kidnapping, drug use, mention of: peeping tom, blackmail, postpartum depression
At the same time, however, there are darker recollections that reside both in Molly’s hometown and her childhood home. At only four years of age, she witnessed her mother’s murder in their very own garage. Tasked with giving evidence at the killer’s trial, her testimony alone sent a young teenage boy to prison. Despite forty years since that life-changing event, she’s never second guessed what she said on the stand. The longer she’s in town, however, the more details seem to become clear and Molly wonders if it’s possible that she has never actually know the full truth of that fateful day.
It isn’t until Molly decides to assist with the local help line, though, that her deepest fear seems to take hold. One night during a call, she receives a distressing threat when a mysterious voice wants to know what she remembers about her mother’s death. As Molly starts to look closer at those around her, they each seem suspicious. From the local cop to her own landlord, there are more connections to the past than she would like. More worrisome, however, is the realization that her words as a child just might have consequences on her life now. After all, someone seems intent on making sure that she pays for her actions.
Wow. That’s all I can say about A Man Downstairs. An eerily dark drama embedded with foreboding and suspense, I was spellbound throughout the four hundred pages. And while I was anticipating a more hard-hitting thriller, the realization that it was actually an exploration of the more human side of a small town’s very worst event somehow still satisfied my thriller loving core. Adept at spinning a captivating tale, Lundrigan revealed herself as a master of immersive storytelling that kept my fingers quickly flipping the pages.
Much more a character-driven plot than action-packed with surprises, the fully fleshed out personas kept me on the back foot throughout. Told from multiple POVs and dual timelines, the plot was slowly revealed through its multitude of layers. Piece by piece, revelations were unfurled until the timely, pulse-pounding climax exploded all of my expectations with a truth that was shocking in the extreme. Hard to wrap my head around, but also entirely believable, Lundrigan nailed it in one.
As for those characters, each and every one of them were just a little bit morally gray. With plenty of disturbing motivations and long hidden secrets, my distrust meter was off the chart as I questioned every single individuals’ true plans and goals. From the creepy landlord to the all too helpful live-in nurse, there was even an anonymous narrator who made me squirm with distaste. All together, I looked at each with more than suspicion. And, IYKYK, but second guessing all involved is one of the hallmarks of a truly great author for any mystery/thriller.
All said and done, while the plot was anything but fast-paced, this epic slow burn revealed dark truths about society as well as providing a riveting tale of suspense. With multiple subplots that all revolved around a deep understanding of human nature, I was simply gobsmacked by the time I closed the cover. Even better, the evocative prose made me feel as if I were there as the past came calling. But the best bit? That was easily the conclusion, which led me to deeply want a sequel to the perfectly plotted finale. Rating of 4 stars.
Thank you to Nicole Lundrigan, Viking Books, and Thriller Book Lovers Promotions for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: March 5, 2024
Trigger warning: aftermath of a stroke, type one diabetes, death of a parent, psychosis, burglary, mania, threatening calls, kidnapping, drug use, mention of: peeping tom, blackmail, postpartum depression
March 19, 2024
When Molly was only 4 years old she witnessed the murder of her mother. Her testimony of "a man downstairs" sent a local teenager to prison. Her loving father, Gil, did everything he could to make sure Molly was loved and cared for throughout her life.
Molly, now a therapist, has returned home to care for her father that suffered a debilitating stroke leaving him in need of around the clock care. The last time he called her he mentioned he had something to tell her but she never returned the call in time to find out what it was and now he is unable to speak or communicate leaving Molly to wonder.
While home she decides to volunteer for a local helpline. All is well until she starts to receive anonymous threats from a caller. Someone hasn't forgotten Molly, her mother, or her mother's murder and they want Molly to finally tell the truth of what happened all those years ago.
Having really enjoyed her 2022 novel, An Unthinkable Thing, I was excited to check out more of Lundrigan's work so I wasted no time in requesting this novel through NetGalley. The writing was as great as I remember and I was immediately enmeshed in the story. This is one shady town with a lot of shady people. I felt like anyone and everyone could be a suspect and I loved that aspect. So while we have a current timeline and a past timeline we also get chapters from an unknown to us creepy and very delusional narrator. His chapters had my skin crawling. Eek! 😳
I know I mentioned a lot of shady characters but as I read on it became very clear to me of who the guilty party was and how this was going to shake down so that was kind of a bummer.
BUT....
I did not figure out our mysterious narrator and let me tell you that was the cherry on the sundae! 🍒
And that final page. *Chefs kiss* 👌 4 stars!
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House Canada for my complimentary copy.
Molly, now a therapist, has returned home to care for her father that suffered a debilitating stroke leaving him in need of around the clock care. The last time he called her he mentioned he had something to tell her but she never returned the call in time to find out what it was and now he is unable to speak or communicate leaving Molly to wonder.
While home she decides to volunteer for a local helpline. All is well until she starts to receive anonymous threats from a caller. Someone hasn't forgotten Molly, her mother, or her mother's murder and they want Molly to finally tell the truth of what happened all those years ago.
Having really enjoyed her 2022 novel, An Unthinkable Thing, I was excited to check out more of Lundrigan's work so I wasted no time in requesting this novel through NetGalley. The writing was as great as I remember and I was immediately enmeshed in the story. This is one shady town with a lot of shady people. I felt like anyone and everyone could be a suspect and I loved that aspect. So while we have a current timeline and a past timeline we also get chapters from an unknown to us creepy and very delusional narrator. His chapters had my skin crawling. Eek! 😳
I know I mentioned a lot of shady characters but as I read on it became very clear to me of who the guilty party was and how this was going to shake down so that was kind of a bummer.
BUT....
I did not figure out our mysterious narrator and let me tell you that was the cherry on the sundae! 🍒
And that final page. *Chefs kiss* 👌 4 stars!
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House Canada for my complimentary copy.
February 29, 2024
Molly Wynters has moved back to her small hometown to care for her father who suffered a stroke and is no longer able to communicate. When she was a young girl Molly witnessed her mother’s murder and her testimony sent a teenager to prison.
I've really enjoyed previous books by Nicole Lundrigan so was happy to get in on the Netgalley "Read Now for the first 200 members" for this one. As with previous books by this author, I was immersed in the story and my imagination was in overdrive as I tried to guess where the story was going. The novel is narrated in "Then" and "Now" chapters by Molly, Molly’s father and someone just called “Him”. His identity isn't revealed until the very end. The characters are well defined and Molly's flashbacks to the time of her mother's murder raised many questions. Molly was only 3 at the time so realistically I'm not sure how much she'd remember. Sometimes an epilogue works and sometimes it doesn't but in my opinion it was necessary in this case in order to tie up all the loose ends. I can't wait to see what this author does next.
My thanks to Penguin Random House Canada via Netgalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this novel. All opinions expressed are my own.
Publication Date: March 5, 2024
I've really enjoyed previous books by Nicole Lundrigan so was happy to get in on the Netgalley "Read Now for the first 200 members" for this one. As with previous books by this author, I was immersed in the story and my imagination was in overdrive as I tried to guess where the story was going. The novel is narrated in "Then" and "Now" chapters by Molly, Molly’s father and someone just called “Him”. His identity isn't revealed until the very end. The characters are well defined and Molly's flashbacks to the time of her mother's murder raised many questions. Molly was only 3 at the time so realistically I'm not sure how much she'd remember. Sometimes an epilogue works and sometimes it doesn't but in my opinion it was necessary in this case in order to tie up all the loose ends. I can't wait to see what this author does next.
My thanks to Penguin Random House Canada via Netgalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this novel. All opinions expressed are my own.
Publication Date: March 5, 2024
January 10, 2024
A MAN DOWNSTAIRS by Nicole Lundrigan
Other Books I Enjoyed by This Author: AN UNTHINKABLE THING which blew me away
Affiliate Link: https://bookshop.org/a/7576/978073524...
Release Date: March 5th, 2024
General Genre: Thrillers, Suspense, Psychological, Murder Mystery/Crime
Sub-Genre/Themes: Small town, teenage boys, marriage, infidelity, memories, ailing parents, neighbors, mental illness, motherhood, high school, buried secrets
Writing Style: Dual timelines and multiple POVs, character-driven, intricately plotted, short chapters, clever/stylish/compelling
What You Need to Know: The author saw me recommending AN UNTHINKABLE THING on social media and offered me a NetGalley widget for this book.
My Reading Experience: Much like my introduction to Lundrigan’s work (An Unthinkable Thing), I was immediately caught up in the intricate web the author so expertly weaves. A quality psychological thriller eases the reader into the lives of the protagonists slowly, allowing time to get to know everything we need to before the suspense changes the mood/tone and before our minds start developing theories.
Dual timelines and multiple POVs can be tricky. If one of the narratives is more compelling than the others, it’s difficult to transition out of the one that is holding your attention just to meander through something that doesn’t feel as interesting. But that is not the case with this book. There are essentially three main POVs and all of them had me glued to the page. This author is particularly skilled in dropping breadcrumbs–just little pieces of information that seem innocuous all on their own but triggering enough to alert the reader to hang on to the little crumb for later.
The characters are colorful and vivid. Not all of them are likable, and every single one of them is flawed. This works in the reader’s favor, trust me. In fact, I hate when a thriller tries to win me over with morally wholesome characters, it’s too unrealistic. The story unravels like a movie in my mind. I had this one perfectly cast. All the major players are clearly defined with unique, easily distinguishable, fully developed personalities. The female protagonists are especially complex and unpredictable.
A perfect cast of suspicious people against the backdrop of an idyllic small-town setting where everyone knows everything about everyone and there is too much history. Loved every minute of this.
Final Recommendation: Perfect for readers who enjoy complex, psychological murder mysteries set in a small town and featuring a main character who must return to their childhood home (the scene of a crime) to take care of an ailing parent or an inherited estate. The traumatic past of being involved in a small-town murder investigation catches up to them forcing the MC to wrestle with details of the crime they have ignored for so long.
Comps: Dark Places by Gillian Flynn, In the Woods by Tana French, Mare of Eastown (2021) TV show
Other Books I Enjoyed by This Author: AN UNTHINKABLE THING which blew me away
Affiliate Link: https://bookshop.org/a/7576/978073524...
Release Date: March 5th, 2024
General Genre: Thrillers, Suspense, Psychological, Murder Mystery/Crime
Sub-Genre/Themes: Small town, teenage boys, marriage, infidelity, memories, ailing parents, neighbors, mental illness, motherhood, high school, buried secrets
Writing Style: Dual timelines and multiple POVs, character-driven, intricately plotted, short chapters, clever/stylish/compelling
What You Need to Know: The author saw me recommending AN UNTHINKABLE THING on social media and offered me a NetGalley widget for this book.
My Reading Experience: Much like my introduction to Lundrigan’s work (An Unthinkable Thing), I was immediately caught up in the intricate web the author so expertly weaves. A quality psychological thriller eases the reader into the lives of the protagonists slowly, allowing time to get to know everything we need to before the suspense changes the mood/tone and before our minds start developing theories.
Dual timelines and multiple POVs can be tricky. If one of the narratives is more compelling than the others, it’s difficult to transition out of the one that is holding your attention just to meander through something that doesn’t feel as interesting. But that is not the case with this book. There are essentially three main POVs and all of them had me glued to the page. This author is particularly skilled in dropping breadcrumbs–just little pieces of information that seem innocuous all on their own but triggering enough to alert the reader to hang on to the little crumb for later.
The characters are colorful and vivid. Not all of them are likable, and every single one of them is flawed. This works in the reader’s favor, trust me. In fact, I hate when a thriller tries to win me over with morally wholesome characters, it’s too unrealistic. The story unravels like a movie in my mind. I had this one perfectly cast. All the major players are clearly defined with unique, easily distinguishable, fully developed personalities. The female protagonists are especially complex and unpredictable.
A perfect cast of suspicious people against the backdrop of an idyllic small-town setting where everyone knows everything about everyone and there is too much history. Loved every minute of this.
Final Recommendation: Perfect for readers who enjoy complex, psychological murder mysteries set in a small town and featuring a main character who must return to their childhood home (the scene of a crime) to take care of an ailing parent or an inherited estate. The traumatic past of being involved in a small-town murder investigation catches up to them forcing the MC to wrestle with details of the crime they have ignored for so long.
Comps: Dark Places by Gillian Flynn, In the Woods by Tana French, Mare of Eastown (2021) TV show
February 11, 2024
Cold Case Homecoming
Review of the upcoming Penguin Random House Canada paperback/eBook/audiobook (March 5, 2024) read via a NetGalley Kindle ARC (downloaded February 1, 2024).
Single mother Molly and her troubled teen son return to her home town in order to be close to her aged father Gil who has suffered a debilitating stroke. Molly’s job of counselling does allow her to work remotely online. She also volunteers for a local telephone help line. Molly’s mother Edie was murdered when Molly herself was only 3 years-old and a local teen had been convicted of the crime, but after a period of imprisonment had been released. Although the suspect was apparently guilty there is still doubt about the circumstances and Molly’s own childhood memory is uncertain.
Although Molly’s father brought her up believing in an idyllic childhood with a loving mother, we begin to learn in flashback scenes that Gil and Edie’s marriage was not so ideal after all. We also learn that Edie had a mysterious stalker whose relationship with her could have been part fantasy or part reality. In the present day, Molly begins to have her own online stalker through an anonymous caller to the help line. Could this be the actual murderer of her mother who has been triggered by Molly’s return due to a mother - daughter resemblance? There are suspects aplenty in the town and although many are friendly and forthcoming on the surface there is a rising tension and doubt that not all are as they seem.
This was well crafted psychological thriller that had me guessing right to the end. Even when the actual culprit became clear, there were still some surprising twists to come.
My thanks to author Nicole Lundrigan, publisher Penguin Random House Canada / Viking and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this preview ARC, in exchange for which I provide this honest review.
Trivia and Link
Read an excerpt from A Man Downstairs at author Nicole Lundrigan’s own website here.
Review of the upcoming Penguin Random House Canada paperback/eBook/audiobook (March 5, 2024) read via a NetGalley Kindle ARC (downloaded February 1, 2024).
Single mother Molly and her troubled teen son return to her home town in order to be close to her aged father Gil who has suffered a debilitating stroke. Molly’s job of counselling does allow her to work remotely online. She also volunteers for a local telephone help line. Molly’s mother Edie was murdered when Molly herself was only 3 years-old and a local teen had been convicted of the crime, but after a period of imprisonment had been released. Although the suspect was apparently guilty there is still doubt about the circumstances and Molly’s own childhood memory is uncertain.
Although Molly’s father brought her up believing in an idyllic childhood with a loving mother, we begin to learn in flashback scenes that Gil and Edie’s marriage was not so ideal after all. We also learn that Edie had a mysterious stalker whose relationship with her could have been part fantasy or part reality. In the present day, Molly begins to have her own online stalker through an anonymous caller to the help line. Could this be the actual murderer of her mother who has been triggered by Molly’s return due to a mother - daughter resemblance? There are suspects aplenty in the town and although many are friendly and forthcoming on the surface there is a rising tension and doubt that not all are as they seem.
This was well crafted psychological thriller that had me guessing right to the end. Even when the actual culprit became clear, there were still some surprising twists to come.
My thanks to author Nicole Lundrigan, publisher Penguin Random House Canada / Viking and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this preview ARC, in exchange for which I provide this honest review.
Trivia and Link
Read an excerpt from A Man Downstairs at author Nicole Lundrigan’s own website here.
March 27, 2024
This was so captivating. The author was flinging red herrings everywhere like "Lookie, there" and I couldn't help, but lookie.
July 3, 2024
Nicole Lundrigan is the most slept on author in the thriller genre!
The Man Downstairs is the third book that I have read from this author that blew me away. If you have not read The Substitute or An Unthinkable Thing, you need to download all three of these to your Kindle ASAP!
Lundrigan has the ability to instantly connect with her readers and draw them into her storylines. The Man Downstairs is expertly plotted and filled with such beautifully flawed characters. I got lost in Molly, Gil, and ‘his’ storylines for hours, patiently savoring every minute with them, and desperately attempting to connect the dots.
Even the epilogue is stellar, containing an unbelievable twist. I didn’t want this book to end!
Highly, highly recommend!
4.5/5 stars rounded up
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House Canada for the ARC of The Man Downstairs in exchange for an honest review.
The Man Downstairs is the third book that I have read from this author that blew me away. If you have not read The Substitute or An Unthinkable Thing, you need to download all three of these to your Kindle ASAP!
Lundrigan has the ability to instantly connect with her readers and draw them into her storylines. The Man Downstairs is expertly plotted and filled with such beautifully flawed characters. I got lost in Molly, Gil, and ‘his’ storylines for hours, patiently savoring every minute with them, and desperately attempting to connect the dots.
Even the epilogue is stellar, containing an unbelievable twist. I didn’t want this book to end!
Highly, highly recommend!
4.5/5 stars rounded up
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House Canada for the ARC of The Man Downstairs in exchange for an honest review.
May 7, 2024
A Man Downstairs follows our FMC Molly and the tragic events of her mother’s passing that have haunted the duration of her life, stemming from a young girl to present day.
The story is told over past and present timelines and narrated from multiple POV, Molly, her father and a mysterious person tell their own stories as the timelines collide into each other eventually giving us the big picture as events of that night unfold.
This is a dark, psychological thriller where the “evil” is unclear. Is the bad guy one specific person or is it the small knit community harbouring disturbing secrets and decades old murders.
This is definitely the kind of book where not only one single person is at fault, but instead the various decisions and reactions of multiple people making one big mess and having unforeseen consequences.
This is definitely the type of book that makes you think deeply and ask yourself questions about morality and the psychological nature of people.
Thank you to Nicole Lundrigan, Penguin random house and NetGalley for the ARC!
The story is told over past and present timelines and narrated from multiple POV, Molly, her father and a mysterious person tell their own stories as the timelines collide into each other eventually giving us the big picture as events of that night unfold.
This is a dark, psychological thriller where the “evil” is unclear. Is the bad guy one specific person or is it the small knit community harbouring disturbing secrets and decades old murders.
This is definitely the kind of book where not only one single person is at fault, but instead the various decisions and reactions of multiple people making one big mess and having unforeseen consequences.
This is definitely the type of book that makes you think deeply and ask yourself questions about morality and the psychological nature of people.
Thank you to Nicole Lundrigan, Penguin random house and NetGalley for the ARC!
March 20, 2024
this may be the best "back
to hometown" trope story ever:
full of perfectly drawn characters
and dialogue, heartbreaking twists,
neurodiversity and lots of drama.
to hometown" trope story ever:
full of perfectly drawn characters
and dialogue, heartbreaking twists,
neurodiversity and lots of drama.
December 21, 2023
A dark, disturbing drama suffused with gritty suspense, A MAN DOWNSTAIRS is gorgeously written. With astute and terrifying insights into the human condition, Nicole Lundrigan expertly weaves a gripping tale about fractured relationships and the secrets swirling around a small community, rocked by a decades-old murder. The multiple POVs are mesmerizing and the prose is poetic in this intensely captivating and unforgettable read.
March 15, 2024
When Molly was 3 she witnessed her mother’s murder. As an eyewitness, she was the key piece of evidence that put the teenaged perpetrator away. But when Molly returns to her home town as an adult to take care of her recently incapacitated father, she begins to wonder if her memories of that day are real. The book follows the point of view of Molly in the present, her father in the years before the murder, and “him,” a teen boy who had an unnatural obsession with Molly’s mother.
This book was captivating. Every time I thought someone was a suspect, something happened that made me question my suspicion. I think I suspected every single person in this book at one point or another. It’s a great psychological thriller for those who are looking for a book that they can’t put down.
Thank you to netgalley, Penguin Random House, and Nicole Lundrigan for the arc in exchange for my honest review.
This book was captivating. Every time I thought someone was a suspect, something happened that made me question my suspicion. I think I suspected every single person in this book at one point or another. It’s a great psychological thriller for those who are looking for a book that they can’t put down.
Thank you to netgalley, Penguin Random House, and Nicole Lundrigan for the arc in exchange for my honest review.
April 29, 2024
A Man Downstairs
by Nicole Lundrigan is a gripping thriller that skillfully weaves together dual timelines and multiple perspectives to create a captivating narrative.
When Molly Wynters was three years old, she witnessed the murder of her mother. Now recently divorced and trying to start life anew, she must return to her hometown with her son to care for her father, who has recently had a stroke. A qualified therapist, Molly volunteers on the local helpline, where she begins to get threats about what she witnessed as a child in her mom's murder. The tragedy of Molly's mother, Edie, still lives on in Aymes, and as Molly's stay extends, she begins to question if she did see "a man downstairs."
The pacing keeps you hooked from start to finish, with suspense expertly maintained throughout, culminating in a satisfying climax. I found Molly's son, Alex, quite annoying due to his entitled and ungrateful behaviour. The other characters added depth to the story, and I was particularly interested in him. I kept turning the pages to figure out who him was faster than I could piece things together. I particularly enjoyed Edie and Gil's story and felt extremely sad for them. Lundrigan's adept handling of suspense and pacing compels readers to keep turning the pages to unravel the mystery of 'whodunnit.'
Quotes for thought:
Just because a person has a shitty life, it doesn't mean they're a liar...just because someone lives a decent life, doesn't mean they're always honest.
If a person made a statement, why must it be associated with an emotion? Ire or bliss. Why couldn't it just be the truth?
Though my path to understanding has been rife with despair and heartache, I finally know what real devotion is. Generosity, without expectation of reciprocity. My way of caring may not be loud. It may not include a garish display or verbose declarations. Love can be subtle. Invisible. Entirely singular. And still completely authentic.
Thank you to Netgalley and Viking for the ARC!
When Molly Wynters was three years old, she witnessed the murder of her mother. Now recently divorced and trying to start life anew, she must return to her hometown with her son to care for her father, who has recently had a stroke. A qualified therapist, Molly volunteers on the local helpline, where she begins to get threats about what she witnessed as a child in her mom's murder. The tragedy of Molly's mother, Edie, still lives on in Aymes, and as Molly's stay extends, she begins to question if she did see "a man downstairs."
The pacing keeps you hooked from start to finish, with suspense expertly maintained throughout, culminating in a satisfying climax. I found Molly's son, Alex, quite annoying due to his entitled and ungrateful behaviour. The other characters added depth to the story, and I was particularly interested in him. I kept turning the pages to figure out who him was faster than I could piece things together. I particularly enjoyed Edie and Gil's story and felt extremely sad for them. Lundrigan's adept handling of suspense and pacing compels readers to keep turning the pages to unravel the mystery of 'whodunnit.'
Quotes for thought:
Just because a person has a shitty life, it doesn't mean they're a liar...just because someone lives a decent life, doesn't mean they're always honest.
If a person made a statement, why must it be associated with an emotion? Ire or bliss. Why couldn't it just be the truth?
Though my path to understanding has been rife with despair and heartache, I finally know what real devotion is. Generosity, without expectation of reciprocity. My way of caring may not be loud. It may not include a garish display or verbose declarations. Love can be subtle. Invisible. Entirely singular. And still completely authentic.
Thank you to Netgalley and Viking for the ARC!
February 27, 2024
Molly’s mother, Edie, was brutally murdered when Molly was three years old, and Molly’s testimony about “a man downstairs” helped convict a local teenager of the crime. Years later, Molly and her teenage son return to her small hometown to help out her aging dad, Gil, after he’s suffered a debilitating stroke. Molly is a therapist, so she volunteers for a local helpline. She immediately starts receiving threats that make her question everything she thinks she knows.
This slow-burn psychological thriller is told in dual timelines and multiple POVs, which reveal that the story Molly has been told her whole life about her parents and their marriage isn’t nearly as rosy as she’d been led to believe. Everyone in this creepy little town is suspicious and they are all hiding something. My favorite POV was from the dude who is obsessed with Molly’s mom and has a *VIVID* delusional fantasy life where they are together - it was super disturbing, and I loved it. I wasn’t quite sure where this was going until the end, which was fun, and I loved how the truth was slowly unspooled. And then there was that last bit at the very end ???!!!??? YIKES!
I’d love to see this book made into a movie or show and am excited to read more of Lundrigan’s books!
* Thanks so much to Thriller Book Lovers Promotions & Penguin Random House Canada & the author for the NetGalley review copy. A MAN DOWNSTAIRS publishes March 5, 2024.
This slow-burn psychological thriller is told in dual timelines and multiple POVs, which reveal that the story Molly has been told her whole life about her parents and their marriage isn’t nearly as rosy as she’d been led to believe. Everyone in this creepy little town is suspicious and they are all hiding something. My favorite POV was from the dude who is obsessed with Molly’s mom and has a *VIVID* delusional fantasy life where they are together - it was super disturbing, and I loved it. I wasn’t quite sure where this was going until the end, which was fun, and I loved how the truth was slowly unspooled. And then there was that last bit at the very end ???!!!??? YIKES!
I’d love to see this book made into a movie or show and am excited to read more of Lundrigan’s books!
* Thanks so much to Thriller Book Lovers Promotions & Penguin Random House Canada & the author for the NetGalley review copy. A MAN DOWNSTAIRS publishes March 5, 2024.
March 5, 2024
As a child of three, Molly Wynters witnessed the murder of her mother. Her testimony helped put the murderer away. Now, forty years later, she has returned to her small hometown to help care for her father, Gil, who has suffered a debilitating stroke, leaving him unable to communicate. When Molly volunteers for a local help line, she begins to get threatening messages accusing her of not telling the truth. She begins to doubt her own memories of what really happened to her mother, especially after she finds evidence that someone has been in her dad’s basement, searching through boxes containing her mom’s old clothes and papers.
A Man Downstairs by Nicole Lundrigan is a slowburn thriller about obsession, memory, and guilt. The story is split between two timelines, NOW which is told in third person from Molly’s perspective and THEN, split between the third voice narration of Gil, and another character, identified only as HIM, speaking in first voice. The story is well-written and interesting. The characters, and there are a lot, are well-fleshed out and complex. The mystery is compelling with plenty of red herrings to keep the reader guessing. Nothing is quite as straightforward as it seems. A very entertaining thriller with an ending that, well, leaves a lot for the reader to think about.
Thanks to Netgalley and Penguin Random House Canada for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review
A Man Downstairs by Nicole Lundrigan is a slowburn thriller about obsession, memory, and guilt. The story is split between two timelines, NOW which is told in third person from Molly’s perspective and THEN, split between the third voice narration of Gil, and another character, identified only as HIM, speaking in first voice. The story is well-written and interesting. The characters, and there are a lot, are well-fleshed out and complex. The mystery is compelling with plenty of red herrings to keep the reader guessing. Nothing is quite as straightforward as it seems. A very entertaining thriller with an ending that, well, leaves a lot for the reader to think about.
Thanks to Netgalley and Penguin Random House Canada for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review
March 5, 2024
“Eventually they all end up together anyway. Predators and their prey.”
This intense psychological mystery thriller follows Molly Wynters, a single mother who has moved back to her small town to care for her elderly father. The town where she grew up holds warm childhood memories of her father’s unconditional love but also painful memories of her mother’s murder. Molly remembers taking the stand—at too young an age—and giving testimony that the man who’d killed her mother had been in their basement. This accusation sent a teenager to prison. Now in present day, as Molly continues to mother her son, care for her father, and work as a volunteer therapist for a local helpline, she encounters tiny clues to a blurry and traumatic past and wonders if her memory had truly been accurate about her mother’s killer.
The dual timelines and multi-perspective storytelling were an excellent way for the author to misdirect readers and keep them guessing with every chapter. As the book progresses, we learn that the circumstances leading up to murder were not in simple black and white. I was fully engaged in this thrill ride filled with twists, turns, revelations, and one hell of an ending!!!
This author has gained a new fan and I'm super excited to read more!
(Thank you to Viking Press and Nicole Lundrigan for my #gifted review copy!)
This intense psychological mystery thriller follows Molly Wynters, a single mother who has moved back to her small town to care for her elderly father. The town where she grew up holds warm childhood memories of her father’s unconditional love but also painful memories of her mother’s murder. Molly remembers taking the stand—at too young an age—and giving testimony that the man who’d killed her mother had been in their basement. This accusation sent a teenager to prison. Now in present day, as Molly continues to mother her son, care for her father, and work as a volunteer therapist for a local helpline, she encounters tiny clues to a blurry and traumatic past and wonders if her memory had truly been accurate about her mother’s killer.
The dual timelines and multi-perspective storytelling were an excellent way for the author to misdirect readers and keep them guessing with every chapter. As the book progresses, we learn that the circumstances leading up to murder were not in simple black and white. I was fully engaged in this thrill ride filled with twists, turns, revelations, and one hell of an ending!!!
This author has gained a new fan and I'm super excited to read more!
(Thank you to Viking Press and Nicole Lundrigan for my #gifted review copy!)
March 17, 2024
A MAN DOWNSTAIRS a twisted psychological thriller by the acclaimed author Nicole Lundrigan.
Her Novels Include:
Unraveling Arva (2003)
Thaw (2005)
The Seary Line (2008)
Glass Boys (2011)
The Widow Tree (2014)
The Substitute (2017)
Hideaway (2019)
An Unthinkable Thing (2022)
A Man Downstairs (2024)
This is my review of A Man Downstairs.
Molly Wynters, a psychologist and single mom with her teenage son, Alex have moved back to her small hometown to care for her father, Dr. Gil Wynters a retired pharmacist who recently had a massive stroke and is no longer able to communicate or look after himself. Molly is ready to make a fresh start with her son after her divorce.
Molly is haunted by her childhood memories when she had witnessed her mother’s death when she was a child, and had testified at the trial. The killer, Terry Kage, a teenager was convicted in the death of her mother, Edie Wynters.
“There was a man downstairs…”
Being back in her family home with her father brings back a flood of memories. But were Molly’s memories of the past accurate? Could her testimony on the stand might not have been the whole truth?
But when Molly, a trained therapist, volunteers for a local helpline, she starts to receive personal threats. Now Molly is a target and someone wants to hold Molly accountable for her actions in the past.
This is a well written novel with well-developed characters told in multiple POVs, and in different timelines. This twisty novel will keep you guessing until the very end. A great read!
Many thanks to the author, Penguin Random House Canada and Netgalley for my digital copy.
Her Novels Include:
Unraveling Arva (2003)
Thaw (2005)
The Seary Line (2008)
Glass Boys (2011)
The Widow Tree (2014)
The Substitute (2017)
Hideaway (2019)
An Unthinkable Thing (2022)
A Man Downstairs (2024)
This is my review of A Man Downstairs.
Molly Wynters, a psychologist and single mom with her teenage son, Alex have moved back to her small hometown to care for her father, Dr. Gil Wynters a retired pharmacist who recently had a massive stroke and is no longer able to communicate or look after himself. Molly is ready to make a fresh start with her son after her divorce.
Molly is haunted by her childhood memories when she had witnessed her mother’s death when she was a child, and had testified at the trial. The killer, Terry Kage, a teenager was convicted in the death of her mother, Edie Wynters.
“There was a man downstairs…”
Being back in her family home with her father brings back a flood of memories. But were Molly’s memories of the past accurate? Could her testimony on the stand might not have been the whole truth?
But when Molly, a trained therapist, volunteers for a local helpline, she starts to receive personal threats. Now Molly is a target and someone wants to hold Molly accountable for her actions in the past.
This is a well written novel with well-developed characters told in multiple POVs, and in different timelines. This twisty novel will keep you guessing until the very end. A great read!
Many thanks to the author, Penguin Random House Canada and Netgalley for my digital copy.
January 20, 2024
Wow this book had me guessing, and captivated from the start. The complexity and the way it’s told from past and present, everything weaves together for some big plot twists at the end. Sometimes multiple POV can be confusing and take a while to follow however they were such different characters it was easy to pick up and remember who was who.
A Man Downstairs is a psychological thriller about Molly Wynters returning to her home town with her son to care for her father after he had a stroke. However secrets from the past start haunting her as soon as she arrives. Molly had witnessed her mothers murder at age three. She had testified and sent a teenage boy to prison. The murder still haunts the small town and someone is trying to dig up the past. But is what she testified the truth or is it a fabricated story?
Through out the book details from the different timelines/POV had me looking in all different directions as to what/who was behind everything. When I thought I figured it out something happened and I was wrong. This book is so well written and the details were amazing.
ARC received via NetGalley
March 23, 2024
This is a hard book to review! The synopsis tells us pretty much everything that isn’t a spoiler, and much like the ratings I’ve seen, my feelings on this book are all over the place.
Molly’s father has recently had a stroke, so she moves to a tiny town called Aymes to help take care of him. This is the town she grew up in, and she’s avoided it throughout her adulthood because something awful happened there - when she was three years old, she witnessed her mother’s death, and her toddler testimony led to the conviction of a young man who later killed himself in prison.
To get into any other characters would be a bit spoiler-ish, but I will say that all of the characters were written very well. You can tell the author spent a lot of time on developing these characters, and that made the first half of the book quite enjoyable. There is a lot of drama to unpack in this town, and Molly is uncomfortable with the attention she still receives all these years later. I did find it slightly implausible that people are angry with her for what she saw and said when she was but a toddler - people are threatening her because of something that happened when she was three. Who does that?
The second half of the book slowed down a lot, and that’s where I started to get to a point where I just wanted to find out the ending. We have dual timelines, and words from a mystery person, and those were good. The ending was fine, but there were only so many ways it could end, so there was no giant twist (in the end - there are a couple of big ones throughout the book). Overall, I liked this story a lot, but it could have kept the character development without becoming a slow burn with a somewhat lackluster ending and epilogue. 3.5 stars.
(Thank you to Viking Press, Nicole Lundrigan and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my review.)
Molly’s father has recently had a stroke, so she moves to a tiny town called Aymes to help take care of him. This is the town she grew up in, and she’s avoided it throughout her adulthood because something awful happened there - when she was three years old, she witnessed her mother’s death, and her toddler testimony led to the conviction of a young man who later killed himself in prison.
To get into any other characters would be a bit spoiler-ish, but I will say that all of the characters were written very well. You can tell the author spent a lot of time on developing these characters, and that made the first half of the book quite enjoyable. There is a lot of drama to unpack in this town, and Molly is uncomfortable with the attention she still receives all these years later. I did find it slightly implausible that people are angry with her for what she saw and said when she was but a toddler - people are threatening her because of something that happened when she was three. Who does that?
The second half of the book slowed down a lot, and that’s where I started to get to a point where I just wanted to find out the ending. We have dual timelines, and words from a mystery person, and those were good. The ending was fine, but there were only so many ways it could end, so there was no giant twist (in the end - there are a couple of big ones throughout the book). Overall, I liked this story a lot, but it could have kept the character development without becoming a slow burn with a somewhat lackluster ending and epilogue. 3.5 stars.
(Thank you to Viking Press, Nicole Lundrigan and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my review.)
February 26, 2024
A tightly plotted slow-burn psychological thriller read told in multiple POVs, including a creepy “Him” perspective and in different timelines. Filled with lies, secrets, troubled characters and a great ending with the epilogue revealing the final eerie twist. This one kept me guessing! I also liked the fact that the characters were morally grey, doing questionable things, burdened by secrets of the past. Well-executed, recommended for slow-burn thriller lovers!
Thanks to Thriller Book Lover Promotions and Netgalley for this complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
Thanks to Thriller Book Lover Promotions and Netgalley for this complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
February 18, 2024
Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free, electronic ARC of this novel received in exchange for an honest review.
Expected publication date: March 5, 2024
When Molly Wynters was three years old, she saw a local teenager murder her mother. Now, as an adult, she has returned to her hometown with her teenaged son in order to care for her ailing father, who suffered a debilitating stroke. But Molly doesn’t exactly get the welcome she expects; cryptic messages and phone calls plague Molly since her arrival, telling her to admit the truth to what happened the night of her mother’s death. Molly’s memories from that night are vague and foggy at best, but she was convinced that a local teenager had committed the crime and even though the teen was eventually acquitted, his suicide was a direct result of the allegations against him. Now, Molly’s family is in danger and Molly is forced to battle with the memories from that night, regardless of the consequences.
“A Man Downstairs” by Nicole Lundrigan is tense, taut and absolutely engaging. The novel is narrated by Molly in the present time, by Molly’s father in the past and by an unknown entity labeled “him”, in both the past and the present, whose identity is kept secret until the final pages. Through all of these perspectives, the reader understands what happened to Molly’s mother just as Molly begins to understand it herself, and Lundrigan pulls the reader through a series of suspenseful twists and turns until finally delivering a powerful ending that leaves a mark. As Molly rekindles friendships with those from her pasts, more suspects are drawn into the plot, and, although I had some ideas, the final reveal caught me off guard in the best way.
Molly is a social worker and single parent who is left caring for her father after a stroke. She is utterly likable and it was easy to root for her and form a quick rapport. Her son, Alex, has diabetes and Molly’s mother suffered from bipolar disorder before her untimely death. “Downstairs” is just as emotional as it is suspenseful, and Lundrigan writes her characters in a completely human and relatable way.
Lundrigan is a new author to me, although I know she has other books under her belt. I was intrigued by the cover of this book and by the premise, and I’m really pleased to say that “Downstairs” met my expectations. I have found a new author to follow, and I will be checking out Lundrigan’s other novels, both past and future!
Expected publication date: March 5, 2024
When Molly Wynters was three years old, she saw a local teenager murder her mother. Now, as an adult, she has returned to her hometown with her teenaged son in order to care for her ailing father, who suffered a debilitating stroke. But Molly doesn’t exactly get the welcome she expects; cryptic messages and phone calls plague Molly since her arrival, telling her to admit the truth to what happened the night of her mother’s death. Molly’s memories from that night are vague and foggy at best, but she was convinced that a local teenager had committed the crime and even though the teen was eventually acquitted, his suicide was a direct result of the allegations against him. Now, Molly’s family is in danger and Molly is forced to battle with the memories from that night, regardless of the consequences.
“A Man Downstairs” by Nicole Lundrigan is tense, taut and absolutely engaging. The novel is narrated by Molly in the present time, by Molly’s father in the past and by an unknown entity labeled “him”, in both the past and the present, whose identity is kept secret until the final pages. Through all of these perspectives, the reader understands what happened to Molly’s mother just as Molly begins to understand it herself, and Lundrigan pulls the reader through a series of suspenseful twists and turns until finally delivering a powerful ending that leaves a mark. As Molly rekindles friendships with those from her pasts, more suspects are drawn into the plot, and, although I had some ideas, the final reveal caught me off guard in the best way.
Molly is a social worker and single parent who is left caring for her father after a stroke. She is utterly likable and it was easy to root for her and form a quick rapport. Her son, Alex, has diabetes and Molly’s mother suffered from bipolar disorder before her untimely death. “Downstairs” is just as emotional as it is suspenseful, and Lundrigan writes her characters in a completely human and relatable way.
Lundrigan is a new author to me, although I know she has other books under her belt. I was intrigued by the cover of this book and by the premise, and I’m really pleased to say that “Downstairs” met my expectations. I have found a new author to follow, and I will be checking out Lundrigan’s other novels, both past and future!
July 24, 2024
Oh, the twists and turns! What a great “coming home” story filled with interesting characters and suspense up to the very end! I wasn’t fully satisfied with the plot line and felt that some ends were left untied, but it was a great read!
March 5, 2024
Nicole Lundrigan just got categorized amongst my favourite authors with her latest crime thriller, A Man Downstairs.
One of my goals for 2024 was to read more from authors I love, and after being blown away by Lundrigan's An Unthinkable Thing last year, I jumped at the opportunity to read and review her new release. This book truly solidified what I already expected from her writing: a suspenseful and mysterious plot that held me in its tight grasp, narrators that have me questioning their reliability and deceptively sneaky writing making my mind spin. As an added bonus: unrivaled epilogue usage.
This one is told in three perspectives: Molly, Gil, and "Him" from both now and then timelines, with deliberate similarities among each. For some inexplicable reason, I was drawn to the intrigue of Gil's story line the most, although none of the three were at all lacking in depth. As the story continued to progress, my curiosity continued to be peaked, and I raced through, needing to understand how everything was linked together, all while trying to predict potential outcomes. Multiple times, I found my hand flying to my mouth to cover a gasp, and the next second, I was back to devouring the book.
I consumed this book with a ferocious appetite, thought about it non-stop as I tried to locate the missing puzzle pieces, and every time I thought I had everything figured out, (or at least parts of it), it slipped through my grasp once again; what was constantly niggling in the back of my mind continued to be just out of reach to firmly hold onto.
After the outcome was revealed, and I looked at each of the characters in a new light I wondered if the cost of protecting those we love really helps long-term; who's really the villain in this small town's web of deceit and mistruths?
Thank you NetGalley, Penguin Random House Canada and Viking for the complimentary copies to read and review.
One of my goals for 2024 was to read more from authors I love, and after being blown away by Lundrigan's An Unthinkable Thing last year, I jumped at the opportunity to read and review her new release. This book truly solidified what I already expected from her writing: a suspenseful and mysterious plot that held me in its tight grasp, narrators that have me questioning their reliability and deceptively sneaky writing making my mind spin. As an added bonus: unrivaled epilogue usage.
This one is told in three perspectives: Molly, Gil, and "Him" from both now and then timelines, with deliberate similarities among each. For some inexplicable reason, I was drawn to the intrigue of Gil's story line the most, although none of the three were at all lacking in depth. As the story continued to progress, my curiosity continued to be peaked, and I raced through, needing to understand how everything was linked together, all while trying to predict potential outcomes. Multiple times, I found my hand flying to my mouth to cover a gasp, and the next second, I was back to devouring the book.
I consumed this book with a ferocious appetite, thought about it non-stop as I tried to locate the missing puzzle pieces, and every time I thought I had everything figured out, (or at least parts of it), it slipped through my grasp once again; what was constantly niggling in the back of my mind continued to be just out of reach to firmly hold onto.
After the outcome was revealed, and I looked at each of the characters in a new light I wondered if the cost of protecting those we love really helps long-term; who's really the villain in this small town's web of deceit and mistruths?
Thank you NetGalley, Penguin Random House Canada and Viking for the complimentary copies to read and review.
March 16, 2024
A Man Upstairs is a slow burn immersive thriller. Told in multiple POVs and alternative timelines, the story slowly unfolded, keeping me interested every step of the way.
This is a character driven novel, centered around Molly and her dad. I loved her dad Gil in the flashbacks. He was an incredible father, and his family first parenting transferred to Molly in how she raised her son.
The characters truly make this book. Some are wonderful, some are awful, dark and dirty. It was a perfect balance.
This is a character driven novel, centered around Molly and her dad. I loved her dad Gil in the flashbacks. He was an incredible father, and his family first parenting transferred to Molly in how she raised her son.
The characters truly make this book. Some are wonderful, some are awful, dark and dirty. It was a perfect balance.
April 24, 2024
★ 4 Stars ★
"A Man Downstairs" is a mysterious tale set in a small town that left me questioning what I had just read. Although there are some odd and suspicious characters, there is no single person that I can identify as the sole antagonist. It is told in dual timelines from multiple perspectives. One of the POVs is a creepy and eerie unknown character that kept me gripped.
The majority of the townsfolk made poor decisions that set off a chain of events leading to the tragic death of Edie. Despite being the victim, Edie is not entirely innocent. I'm not blaming her for what happened. She was a young woman who enjoyed life, and I don't believe she had any ill intentions when making her choices. However, her decisions were motivated by the wrong reasons, and the consequences were not hers alone.
The story isn't heartbreaking, but it is somber and depressing. It was a slow burn that kept me engaged, but it left me feeling gloomy.
Thanks to Penguin Random House Canada for providing copies of this book through NetGalley and Libro.fm. As always, all opinions are my own and left voluntarily.
#AManDownstairs #NicoleLundrigan #NetGalley #ARC #PRHCanada #LibroFM # #honestreview #thriller #bookreviewer #thrillerbookloverspromotions #thrillerfriendsunite #thrillerobsessedbookishclub #ReadersOfTheLateArc #TalkWordyToMeTeam #lovetoread #bookworm #lovebooks #booknerd #readaholic #bookstagrammer
"A Man Downstairs" is a mysterious tale set in a small town that left me questioning what I had just read. Although there are some odd and suspicious characters, there is no single person that I can identify as the sole antagonist. It is told in dual timelines from multiple perspectives. One of the POVs is a creepy and eerie unknown character that kept me gripped.
The majority of the townsfolk made poor decisions that set off a chain of events leading to the tragic death of Edie. Despite being the victim, Edie is not entirely innocent. I'm not blaming her for what happened. She was a young woman who enjoyed life, and I don't believe she had any ill intentions when making her choices. However, her decisions were motivated by the wrong reasons, and the consequences were not hers alone.
The story isn't heartbreaking, but it is somber and depressing. It was a slow burn that kept me engaged, but it left me feeling gloomy.
Thanks to Penguin Random House Canada for providing copies of this book through NetGalley and Libro.fm. As always, all opinions are my own and left voluntarily.
#AManDownstairs #NicoleLundrigan #NetGalley #ARC #PRHCanada #LibroFM # #honestreview #thriller #bookreviewer #thrillerbookloverspromotions #thrillerfriendsunite #thrillerobsessedbookishclub #ReadersOfTheLateArc #TalkWordyToMeTeam #lovetoread #bookworm #lovebooks #booknerd #readaholic #bookstagrammer
March 10, 2024
I admire the way Lundrigan switched her writing style to fit her “then” and “now” viewpoints, making the “then” dialogue and narration sound fitting for the 1970s. The anonymous viewpoint of “him” kept the story intriguing and had me constantly guessing who “he” was. I enjoyed the storyline, but the pace was too slow for my personal liking. The ending brought everything together, but I was hoping for more of a twist. Overall, this was okay but I wouldn’t necessarily recommend it.
*Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House Canada for this ARC*
*Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House Canada for this ARC*
March 26, 2024
Perfectly serviceable thriller. Kept me listening, but wasn’t anything earth shattering and I suspect I will forget it relatively quickly.
March 5, 2024
•••HAPPY PUB DAY!!•••
Molly moves back to her childhood home along with her son to care for her father who has suffered a debilitating stroke. When she was three, she witnessed her mother being killed and gave testimony in court that helped convict a teenager. Being back where she was raised, brings up memories of when she was a child. A seed of doubt begins to grow as Molly questions if her memory of that tragic night is accurate. Meanwhile, since she’s a therapist, Molly volunteers for a local helpline, but starts receiving threatening phone calls. It seems someone else doubts Molly’s memory. Did they convict the right person?
I was sucked in to A Man Downstairs immediately. Nicole Lundgrin has the ability to weave an intricate story with multiple moving parts and the psychological depth of human nature. Molly’s reminiscing invoked nostalgia and resonated with me. I too, had Boggle competitions with a parent, watched The Jetsons on the ‘boob tube’ and got Mr. Bubble poured in my bath! Nicole’s writing style and descriptive word choices made me feel as if I was THERE, in the moment, reliving the eighties. Yes, it WAS quite satisfying to slam a phone down. (IYKYK!) How appropriate that a novel about childhood memories, generated several for me!
Along with the dual timelines and multiple POVs of Molly and her father, there’s a creepy anonymous narrator that made me uncomfortable and squirm in my seat. I could’ve done with slightly less time in his warped mind. Otherwise, this slow burn domestic thriller with hints of a mystery was STELLAR. Secrets, lies and betrayals in a small town that never forgets, make A Man Downstairs a dark and twisted yet complex tale. I’ll be first in line for Nicole’s next novel!
Thank you Thriller Book Lovers Promotions for my spot on the tour, and Nicole Lundgrin, Viking Books, Penguin Random House CA and NetGalley for the gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
Scroll down for potential spoiler trigger warnings.
⚠️Infidelity, language, sexual situations, stalking, postpartum depression, mental illness, drug use, prescription drug abuse, death and mention of suicide
Molly moves back to her childhood home along with her son to care for her father who has suffered a debilitating stroke. When she was three, she witnessed her mother being killed and gave testimony in court that helped convict a teenager. Being back where she was raised, brings up memories of when she was a child. A seed of doubt begins to grow as Molly questions if her memory of that tragic night is accurate. Meanwhile, since she’s a therapist, Molly volunteers for a local helpline, but starts receiving threatening phone calls. It seems someone else doubts Molly’s memory. Did they convict the right person?
I was sucked in to A Man Downstairs immediately. Nicole Lundgrin has the ability to weave an intricate story with multiple moving parts and the psychological depth of human nature. Molly’s reminiscing invoked nostalgia and resonated with me. I too, had Boggle competitions with a parent, watched The Jetsons on the ‘boob tube’ and got Mr. Bubble poured in my bath! Nicole’s writing style and descriptive word choices made me feel as if I was THERE, in the moment, reliving the eighties. Yes, it WAS quite satisfying to slam a phone down. (IYKYK!) How appropriate that a novel about childhood memories, generated several for me!
Along with the dual timelines and multiple POVs of Molly and her father, there’s a creepy anonymous narrator that made me uncomfortable and squirm in my seat. I could’ve done with slightly less time in his warped mind. Otherwise, this slow burn domestic thriller with hints of a mystery was STELLAR. Secrets, lies and betrayals in a small town that never forgets, make A Man Downstairs a dark and twisted yet complex tale. I’ll be first in line for Nicole’s next novel!
Thank you Thriller Book Lovers Promotions for my spot on the tour, and Nicole Lundgrin, Viking Books, Penguin Random House CA and NetGalley for the gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
Scroll down for potential spoiler trigger warnings.
⚠️Infidelity, language, sexual situations, stalking, postpartum depression, mental illness, drug use, prescription drug abuse, death and mention of suicide
March 23, 2024
Thank you to #partner Thriller Book Lovers Promotions, Viking and LibroFM for the copies to review!
An interesting read, I thought this was very well done and the suspense was slow building until the end which was very intense. The audio was excellent and only enhanced the experience. I thought I had this one figured out and was wrong, and was surprised by the ending. This was my first read by this author and cannot wait to read more of her books.
An interesting read, I thought this was very well done and the suspense was slow building until the end which was very intense. The audio was excellent and only enhanced the experience. I thought I had this one figured out and was wrong, and was surprised by the ending. This was my first read by this author and cannot wait to read more of her books.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 456 reviews