What do you think?
Rate this book
Not Under the Law
Life became complicated for Joyce Radway when her beloved aunt died. Joyce was left to live with her cousin and his wife, who saw Joyce as a handy cook, maid and babysitter. But their oppressive and demanding way of treating Joyce drove her out of the house one night and onto the road--destitute and alone. Joyce narrowly escapes some criminals and ultimately proves just how resourceful she can be as she creates a new life for herself. Then the man who betrayed her in her neediest hour returns to vie for her heart. Is Joyce heading for another bitter heartbreak...or true love?
322 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 1925
45 people are currently reading
190 people want to read
About the author
Grace Livingston Hill
572 books564 followersalso wrote under the pseudonym Marcia MacDonald
also published under the name Grace Livingston Hill Lutz
A popular author of her day, she wrote over 100 novels and numerous short stories of religious and Christian fiction. Her characters were most often young female ingénues, frequently strong Christian women or those who become so within the confines of the story.
niece to Isabella MacDonald Alden
also published under the name Grace Livingston Hill Lutz
A popular author of her day, she wrote over 100 novels and numerous short stories of religious and Christian fiction. Her characters were most often young female ingénues, frequently strong Christian women or those who become so within the confines of the story.
niece to Isabella MacDonald Alden
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 37 reviews
May 20, 2019
As literature, to be honest, this is a 2 star book. As a fun, light, restful, elb0w-chair for the mind, with some fascinating details about daily life in the time period when it was written and making do, it's a five star. This is my go to kind of book when I am really sick, or in pain, or need to go to bed and pull the covers over my head and take a PTSD Is Too Much staycation, and this is one of my personal favourites of GLH- and the tiny home-making details- making mayonnaise, making shelves from old crates, making a bed from newspaper and flour sacks, I just love it all.
February 21, 2021
Joyce Radway has had enough. Since the death of her aunt, she's living out her very own Cinderella story, where she gets the play the part of the heroine - with no prince in sight. What I loved best here, was that as vile as the family was, Joyce had a certain amount of backbone to her, and when she was treated badly, quite simply...left.
Oh I love this book, mostly because I love her tiny house and how she manages so cleverly by herself. This is one of my favorite Grace Livingston Hill books, that I've read probably a half dozen times over the years. The adventure in the graveyard, the eventual romance though hero and heroine barely interact for most of the book - is all perfect, and again comes to a satisfying conclusion that leads the read to breath a happy sigh at the last page, and again feel their own resolve and faith strengthen as a result of reading such a lovely story.
Maybe I'm too much a fan to be impartial at this point, but I don't care. I love these books, and wish very much that other people could come to love them as much as I do.
Oh I love this book, mostly because I love her tiny house and how she manages so cleverly by herself. This is one of my favorite Grace Livingston Hill books, that I've read probably a half dozen times over the years. The adventure in the graveyard, the eventual romance though hero and heroine barely interact for most of the book - is all perfect, and again comes to a satisfying conclusion that leads the read to breath a happy sigh at the last page, and again feel their own resolve and faith strengthen as a result of reading such a lovely story.
Maybe I'm too much a fan to be impartial at this point, but I don't care. I love these books, and wish very much that other people could come to love them as much as I do.
November 4, 2024
I remember my Dad reading this book aloud and I read the first part about her setting up her house. It was like I had listened to him read it the day before. I love this story of a girl making do with little, making a new life, and overcoming the things people did to her.
I also love how both of the main characters grow in their faith.
A sweet read and well-narrated.
I also love how both of the main characters grow in their faith.
A sweet read and well-narrated.
July 10, 2022
Published a century ago. Book is in public domain. Audiobook narrated by the talented Anne Hancock. Available at Audible and at Spoken Realms. Cinderella has had enough. She leaves home and her horrible relatives. Makes a home for herself on a shoestring. A TINY HOME. Lots of fun with interior design, cooking, recipes. A strong flawed hero, too, who finds decency and courage when needed. A suspenseful court case. Christian message of forgiveness. All good.
See my review of Re-Creations for other old fixer-upper stories like this.
See my review of Re-Creations for other old fixer-upper stories like this.
September 9, 2021
Another heartwarming historical Christian romance with home-making themes, published about a century ago. This is a TINY HOUSE long before it was even a thing! And there are some interesting recipes in the story — mayonnaise, baked ham, etc. Strong characters: A girl with a backbone. Just say no. Gotta love it. And I liked the hero, too. Not your typical Hill hero. For more stories involving home-finding and fixer-uppers, see my review of Re-Creations, also by Hill.
November 30, 2023
I always admire Mrs. Hill's books because of the attention she pays to the art of homekeeping. The main character in this story blows them all away! She doesn't have a bed, and doesn't want to spend money on a cheap cot that won't be comfortable, so she makes her own mattress! The story that goes along with this is nice, not one of the best, but it gets 4 stars because of the girl's resourcefulness.
July 1, 2023
February 2023
Re-read. One of my top shelf all-time favorites by any author.
Chapter Three
Now in her great need she had the distinct realization of crying out to a God upon whom she relied and whom her faith of the years had tested. And just as distinctly she felt the surety that He was there. He had answered.
It was as if that cry for help was a surrender, a committing of her way to Him. As if she had said, "Here I am. I am Yours. However right or wrong I may have been to put myself into this situation I am here and helpless. If I am worth anything at all to You save me for I cannot save myself. I am giving my future into Your hands."
March 2021
Re-read. Still my favorite Grace Livingston Hill. I love this book so much. It is quickly gaining a place in my list of all time favorites (from any author). I really think this book came to me when I needed it in 2018 and am so thankful that it did.
Chapter Seventeen
"Once, a long time ago, when she was a little girl and was learning verses with her mother and her aunt, they had told her that these verses they were teaching her were to be stored up for a time of need, and that when any distress came, if they were safely in her heart and in her memory, they would come out to comfort her or show her the way out of a difficult situation. She had not thought much about it then, but now that all came back. She was in trouble and comfortless, and the verses were coming like a troop of angels to comfort her and guide her and help her through temptation - to show her that God was not a God afar off, but was nigh to each of us, even in our hearts."
March 2019
Re-read. Possibly my favorite GLH to date.
March 2018
How has it been so long since I've read a Grace Livingston Hill novel? Too long, apparently. Absolutely loved it - the old fashioned writing, Biblical encouragement, domestic details.
Re-read. One of my top shelf all-time favorites by any author.
Chapter Three
Now in her great need she had the distinct realization of crying out to a God upon whom she relied and whom her faith of the years had tested. And just as distinctly she felt the surety that He was there. He had answered.
It was as if that cry for help was a surrender, a committing of her way to Him. As if she had said, "Here I am. I am Yours. However right or wrong I may have been to put myself into this situation I am here and helpless. If I am worth anything at all to You save me for I cannot save myself. I am giving my future into Your hands."
March 2021
Re-read. Still my favorite Grace Livingston Hill. I love this book so much. It is quickly gaining a place in my list of all time favorites (from any author). I really think this book came to me when I needed it in 2018 and am so thankful that it did.
Chapter Seventeen
"Once, a long time ago, when she was a little girl and was learning verses with her mother and her aunt, they had told her that these verses they were teaching her were to be stored up for a time of need, and that when any distress came, if they were safely in her heart and in her memory, they would come out to comfort her or show her the way out of a difficult situation. She had not thought much about it then, but now that all came back. She was in trouble and comfortless, and the verses were coming like a troop of angels to comfort her and guide her and help her through temptation - to show her that God was not a God afar off, but was nigh to each of us, even in our hearts."
March 2019
Re-read. Possibly my favorite GLH to date.
March 2018
How has it been so long since I've read a Grace Livingston Hill novel? Too long, apparently. Absolutely loved it - the old fashioned writing, Biblical encouragement, domestic details.
September 28, 2012
Every GLH has a bete noir. In this one it's "modernism" to which the heroine had never before been exposed and is shocked to encounter. As far as I can tell, modernism means relativism and self esteem.
Cast alone upon the world, the heroine contrives to get by with the fifty dollars in her purse. She seems to subsist entirely on milk and crackers, finds a house which costs her nothing, and sleeps on a pile of newspapers that somehow sounds delightfully cozy. I don't remember reading this GLH before, but it's not like she didn't write variations on this theme dozens of times, and I remember when I was much younger -- and completely unclear on concepts like inflation -- concluding that I would manage just fine if I ever had to leave home because I could live on my babysitting money.
I read mostly my great aunt's editions from the 30s and my mother editions from the 70s, but when I was a teenager, a bunch of GLHs were reprinted with up-to-date-ish covers. (I always wondered what unsuspecting readers made of her books if they stumbled on them by accident. The blurb on the back of this one mentions faith, but not a word about God so the pages of sermon might come as something of a shock.) This copy of Not Under the Law is one of these reprints from 1986 and it got a cover that involves a dress with a sailor collar and a truly hideous brown and pink checked sweater vest. I guess those were the most moral outfits a 1980s cover artist could come up with.
Cast alone upon the world, the heroine contrives to get by with the fifty dollars in her purse. She seems to subsist entirely on milk and crackers, finds a house which costs her nothing, and sleeps on a pile of newspapers that somehow sounds delightfully cozy. I don't remember reading this GLH before, but it's not like she didn't write variations on this theme dozens of times, and I remember when I was much younger -- and completely unclear on concepts like inflation -- concluding that I would manage just fine if I ever had to leave home because I could live on my babysitting money.
I read mostly my great aunt's editions from the 30s and my mother editions from the 70s, but when I was a teenager, a bunch of GLHs were reprinted with up-to-date-ish covers. (I always wondered what unsuspecting readers made of her books if they stumbled on them by accident. The blurb on the back of this one mentions faith, but not a word about God so the pages of sermon might come as something of a shock.) This copy of Not Under the Law is one of these reprints from 1986 and it got a cover that involves a dress with a sailor collar and a truly hideous brown and pink checked sweater vest. I guess those were the most moral outfits a 1980s cover artist could come up with.
January 14, 2024
Grace Livingston Hill's "Not Under the Law" is a religious romantic read that is geared more to religious sentiment. I absolutely loved Joyce and her adhering to her so called "old fashion" ideas and the need to explain through science and modern man made ideas. Faith and believing in God/Christ is not out of date, miracles and the unexplained are not needed to be all known.
Story in short- Joyce decides to leave home after her aunt's death and the inability of her cousin's family to pursue her dream of being a teacher.
➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 239
“‘Enter ye in at the strait gate,’” began Joyce thoughtfully, “‘for wide is the gate, and broad is the way that leadeth to destruction, and many there be that go in thereat: Because strait is the gate and narrow is the way which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it.’” “And so you are actually priding yourself on being narrow!” gh(Yellow) | Page 3
To begin with, at the breakfast table Eugene had snarled at Joyce for keeping her light burning so long the night before. He told her he couldn’t afford to pay electric bills for her to sit up and read novels. This was most unjust since he knew that Joyce never had any novels to read, but that she was studying for an examination that would finish her last year of normal schoolwork and fit her for a teacher.
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 4
She had controlled the tears then that sprang to her eyes and tried to answer in a steady voice. “I’m sorry, Gene. I was studying; I wasn’t reading a novel. You know last night was the last chance I had to study. The examination is today. Maybe when I
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 4
get a school, I’ll be able to pay those electric light bills and some other things, too.” “Bosh!” said Eugene discourteously. “You’ll pay them a big lot, won’t you? That’s all rubbish, your trying to get a school, after a whole year out of school yourself. Much chance you’ll stand! And you may as well understand right now that I’m not going to undertake the expense of you lying around here idling and pretending to go to school for another whole year, so you better begin to make other plans.”
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 7
Nan might return sooner than she expected and would be sure to come to her room to look for her. It would only anger her if she found the door locked, and anyhow the spare room key fit her lock also. There was no privacy to be had in the house since Aunt Mary’s death.
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 7
At the schoolhouse she found to her dismay that the schedule had been changed and that three of her tests came successively that day. There would be no chance of getting through before half past three,
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 239
“‘Enter ye in at the strait gate,’” began Joyce thoughtfully, “‘for wide is the gate, and broad is the way that leadeth to destruction, and many there be that go in thereat: Because strait is the gate and narrow is the way which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it.’” “And so you are actually priding yourself on being narrow!”
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 8
perhaps later. Nan would be angry, but it could not be helped for this once. She would try to forget her until she was through and then hurry home. She resolved not to answer back nor get angry that night if anything mean was said to her, and perhaps things would calm down. So she put her mind on logarithms, Latin conjugations, and English poetry. These examinations offered the only way she knew to independence, and they must be taken.
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 11
Gene came into the dining room just as she set the hot coffeepot down on the table, and he looked at her with his cold blue eyes, a look that was like a long, thin blade of steel piercing to her very soul. She thought she had never before seen such a look of contempt and hate. She felt as if it were something tangible that he had inserted into her soul that
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 11
she would never be able to get out again. “Well, you’re a pretty one, aren’t you? Mother was always boasting about how dependable you were. I wonder what she would think of you now! I always knew you had it in you. You’re just like your contemptible father! Get an idea in your head and have to carry it out. Bullheaded. That’s what you are. That’s what he was. I remember hearing all about it. He wanted to study up some germ and make himself famous. Had to go and get into
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 12
some awful disease, subject himself to danger, and finally got the disease and died. Pretended he was doing a great thing for humanity at large but left his wife and child for her poor sister to support and saddled us all with a girl just like him to house and feed and clothe. Now, young lady, I want you to understand from this time forth that we’re done with nonsense, and whether you pass or whether you don’t pass, your place is right here in this house doing the work and taking the orders from my wife! I’ve got you
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 12
to look after, and I’ll do it, but I don’t intend to stand any more of your pranks. Do you hear? I won’t have anybody in my house that doesn’t obey me!”
❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌spoiler alert
When Joyce saw the mysterious man in the graveyard, it seemed like robbery or murder this did not look good for him. I was happy to know it was bootlegging and that he decided to give it all up, not having to go to jail. He saw in Joyce's eyes in judging which unsettled both, for she looked up to him. I loved her spunk in leaving and making the best of it, her little house was remarkable. At first I had thought Professor Harrington and Joyce would marry but when he belittled her beliefs and wanting her to go to the modern church so she could be his wife to satisfy what others expected. I was happy when Darcy had found Christ and that Joyce saved him in several ways. Joyce and Darcy will help others especially the kids to believe, Lib's prayers have already set her on the path. The mysterious package that Darcy left for Joyce with her nephew was never explained.
Story in short- Joyce decides to leave home after her aunt's death and the inability of her cousin's family to pursue her dream of being a teacher.
➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 239
“‘Enter ye in at the strait gate,’” began Joyce thoughtfully, “‘for wide is the gate, and broad is the way that leadeth to destruction, and many there be that go in thereat: Because strait is the gate and narrow is the way which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it.’” “And so you are actually priding yourself on being narrow!” gh(Yellow) | Page 3
To begin with, at the breakfast table Eugene had snarled at Joyce for keeping her light burning so long the night before. He told her he couldn’t afford to pay electric bills for her to sit up and read novels. This was most unjust since he knew that Joyce never had any novels to read, but that she was studying for an examination that would finish her last year of normal schoolwork and fit her for a teacher.
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 4
She had controlled the tears then that sprang to her eyes and tried to answer in a steady voice. “I’m sorry, Gene. I was studying; I wasn’t reading a novel. You know last night was the last chance I had to study. The examination is today. Maybe when I
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 4
get a school, I’ll be able to pay those electric light bills and some other things, too.” “Bosh!” said Eugene discourteously. “You’ll pay them a big lot, won’t you? That’s all rubbish, your trying to get a school, after a whole year out of school yourself. Much chance you’ll stand! And you may as well understand right now that I’m not going to undertake the expense of you lying around here idling and pretending to go to school for another whole year, so you better begin to make other plans.”
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 7
Nan might return sooner than she expected and would be sure to come to her room to look for her. It would only anger her if she found the door locked, and anyhow the spare room key fit her lock also. There was no privacy to be had in the house since Aunt Mary’s death.
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 7
At the schoolhouse she found to her dismay that the schedule had been changed and that three of her tests came successively that day. There would be no chance of getting through before half past three,
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 239
“‘Enter ye in at the strait gate,’” began Joyce thoughtfully, “‘for wide is the gate, and broad is the way that leadeth to destruction, and many there be that go in thereat: Because strait is the gate and narrow is the way which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it.’” “And so you are actually priding yourself on being narrow!”
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 8
perhaps later. Nan would be angry, but it could not be helped for this once. She would try to forget her until she was through and then hurry home. She resolved not to answer back nor get angry that night if anything mean was said to her, and perhaps things would calm down. So she put her mind on logarithms, Latin conjugations, and English poetry. These examinations offered the only way she knew to independence, and they must be taken.
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 11
Gene came into the dining room just as she set the hot coffeepot down on the table, and he looked at her with his cold blue eyes, a look that was like a long, thin blade of steel piercing to her very soul. She thought she had never before seen such a look of contempt and hate. She felt as if it were something tangible that he had inserted into her soul that
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 11
she would never be able to get out again. “Well, you’re a pretty one, aren’t you? Mother was always boasting about how dependable you were. I wonder what she would think of you now! I always knew you had it in you. You’re just like your contemptible father! Get an idea in your head and have to carry it out. Bullheaded. That’s what you are. That’s what he was. I remember hearing all about it. He wanted to study up some germ and make himself famous. Had to go and get into
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 12
some awful disease, subject himself to danger, and finally got the disease and died. Pretended he was doing a great thing for humanity at large but left his wife and child for her poor sister to support and saddled us all with a girl just like him to house and feed and clothe. Now, young lady, I want you to understand from this time forth that we’re done with nonsense, and whether you pass or whether you don’t pass, your place is right here in this house doing the work and taking the orders from my wife! I’ve got you
Highlight (Yellow) | Page 12
to look after, and I’ll do it, but I don’t intend to stand any more of your pranks. Do you hear? I won’t have anybody in my house that doesn’t obey me!”
❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌spoiler alert
When Joyce saw the mysterious man in the graveyard, it seemed like robbery or murder this did not look good for him. I was happy to know it was bootlegging and that he decided to give it all up, not having to go to jail. He saw in Joyce's eyes in judging which unsettled both, for she looked up to him. I loved her spunk in leaving and making the best of it, her little house was remarkable. At first I had thought Professor Harrington and Joyce would marry but when he belittled her beliefs and wanting her to go to the modern church so she could be his wife to satisfy what others expected. I was happy when Darcy had found Christ and that Joyce saved him in several ways. Joyce and Darcy will help others especially the kids to believe, Lib's prayers have already set her on the path. The mysterious package that Darcy left for Joyce with her nephew was never explained.
July 14, 2021
I was so excited to find this book. I'm always on the hunt for the GLH books I don't own. This might be one of my favorites now.
Like all of Hill's books it is a little sappy and predictable, but that's why I love them. What I liked about this book was the fact that not all the "bad" people are unredeemable. A lot of GLH's books have the bad characters that are almost ridiculous, where this one had people finding themselves and becoming better. I also liked that Janice, the main character is a strong and independent woman, which is not always the case in books written in that time. I definitely recommend this book to all Grace Livingston Hill fans
Like all of Hill's books it is a little sappy and predictable, but that's why I love them. What I liked about this book was the fact that not all the "bad" people are unredeemable. A lot of GLH's books have the bad characters that are almost ridiculous, where this one had people finding themselves and becoming better. I also liked that Janice, the main character is a strong and independent woman, which is not always the case in books written in that time. I definitely recommend this book to all Grace Livingston Hill fans
November 28, 2018
I love how Grace Livingston Hill's writings transport me to a different time. Simpler in many ways. more difficult in others. Timelessly relevent though i am sure many would poke fun at the prominent faith and values running through each story. Her books make me long for a community of people who live in neighbourhoods where people truly care about each other and simple gifts are treasured. I love how self-sufficient the heroine is while making it clear that she totally relies on God. She stands up for herself and makes her way as she follows God's leading to a happy ending. GLH at her finest.
December 29, 2017
Joyce is about one of the best characters you could ever read about. She is kind to a fault and constantly puts her faith in God. I loved how everything came together and couldn't put the book down as I came towards the end. I also loved Darcy's character and wished he would've been in the book a little more.
June 24, 2024
Grace Livingston Hill, a Christian writer from the United States, was the extremely prolific author of over 100 novels. Not Under the Law is the first book I’ve read by her. My mom, having enjoyed numerous audiobooks by Grace Livingston Hill, had been highly recommending this author to me.
I’ve only read one of her books, so far, but I feel a sense of kinship with the author. She writes not merely as a storyteller, but also as a mentor— sweet, but unapologetic, in conveying truth.
Scripture Connection
“He has told you, O man, what is good; and what does the Lord require of you but to do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your God?”
Micah 6:8
Spiritual Themes
Not Under the Law is simply saturated with spiritual truth. At the time of writing this review, it’s been quite awhile since I finished reading. Even if that weren’t the case, I think it would be hard to cover all of the truths shared. So, I’ll hit the major points I recall.
The protagonist, Joyce, is such a beautiful model of Christianity in a young person. She exemplifies Micah 6:8 in her desire to walk with humility, integrity and kindness. Her actions consistently reflect how much she loves the Lord. She loves selflessly, doesn’t take the highest seat at the table (I’m speaking somewhat metaphorically— Luke 14:7-11), and really walks with Jesus.
Also infused throughout the text are tender reminders of Jesus’ love, provision, and closeness!
What I Liked
I feel the need to use the word “exemplifies,” again, in the span of just a few sentences, because Not Under the Law exemplifies wholesomeness.
Joyce is a thoroughly likable character, much like the archetypal Cinderella. Not Under the Law isn’t a Cinderella story, but there are some strong similarities. Joyce had a beautiful relationship with her recently deceased aunt, who took her in after both of Joyce’s parents died. Now, Joyce’s cousin (accompanied by his wife and children) has taken up residence in Joyce’s childhood home. Joyce, who has been studying to be a teacher, is now expected to earn her keep by cooking and taking care of the children. Like Cinderella (I think especially of Lily James in the 2015 Disney adaptation), Joyce behaves with grace and kindness, in spite of challenging circumstances and unpleasant people.
In addition to the Cinderella resemblance (and also because of the distinct differences between this story and Cinderella), the novel is wholesome in its overt Christian themes. Grace Livingston Hill consistently weaves Scripture into the narrative, as Joyce seeks the Lord in her decisions. Every facet of her life is guided by her relationship with Him.
Because of how loving Joyce is, she has many friends, but, at the same time, she refuses to compromise her convictions in order to please people. The book was published almost 100 years ago, and in it, Joyce is pressured to adopt the modern values held by the young people around her. But, she maintains a lifestyle of propriety and innocence— making her a bit of an oddity among hee peers. About a century later, Joyce is a timeless role model: as excellent an example for today’s readers as she was for readers of the 1920s.
The novel is also wholesome in terms of romance. The romance thread is rather subtle, but certainly satisfying! And the faith element tied into that portion of the story is really neat, too.
One other wholesome element I’d like to mention is Joyce’s choice in where to worship. In addition to discussions on modernity with respect to the behavior of young people, Livingston Hill also explores modernity in the context of church. Joyce’s reaction to false teaching is both beautiful and refreshing. I appreciate the author’s willingness to take such a strong stance against false teachings about Jesus. Joyce is grieved by preaching that lies about her Lord. This topic, like other discussions of modernity, maintain immense relevance today.
Character Versatility
Livingston Hill does an excellent job with characterization— presenting in one book one of the most honorable, delightful characters I’ve ever experienced— and one of the most obnoxiously frustrating characters.
Romance
I don’t want to spoil the romance, but I will say that it was a thought-provoking romance, for me. I really like the angle the author took, in terms of presenting the connection between romantic relationship and relationship with God.
Content Notes
One use of “gee.”
Recommendation Status
Not Under the Law is truly a delightful novel. It’s a book I can easily, happily, and highly recommend. Plus, it’s in the public domain. I look forward to reading more of the author’s work!
I’ve only read one of her books, so far, but I feel a sense of kinship with the author. She writes not merely as a storyteller, but also as a mentor— sweet, but unapologetic, in conveying truth.
Scripture Connection
“He has told you, O man, what is good; and what does the Lord require of you but to do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your God?”
Micah 6:8
Spiritual Themes
Not Under the Law is simply saturated with spiritual truth. At the time of writing this review, it’s been quite awhile since I finished reading. Even if that weren’t the case, I think it would be hard to cover all of the truths shared. So, I’ll hit the major points I recall.
The protagonist, Joyce, is such a beautiful model of Christianity in a young person. She exemplifies Micah 6:8 in her desire to walk with humility, integrity and kindness. Her actions consistently reflect how much she loves the Lord. She loves selflessly, doesn’t take the highest seat at the table (I’m speaking somewhat metaphorically— Luke 14:7-11), and really walks with Jesus.
Also infused throughout the text are tender reminders of Jesus’ love, provision, and closeness!
What I Liked
I feel the need to use the word “exemplifies,” again, in the span of just a few sentences, because Not Under the Law exemplifies wholesomeness.
Joyce is a thoroughly likable character, much like the archetypal Cinderella. Not Under the Law isn’t a Cinderella story, but there are some strong similarities. Joyce had a beautiful relationship with her recently deceased aunt, who took her in after both of Joyce’s parents died. Now, Joyce’s cousin (accompanied by his wife and children) has taken up residence in Joyce’s childhood home. Joyce, who has been studying to be a teacher, is now expected to earn her keep by cooking and taking care of the children. Like Cinderella (I think especially of Lily James in the 2015 Disney adaptation), Joyce behaves with grace and kindness, in spite of challenging circumstances and unpleasant people.
In addition to the Cinderella resemblance (and also because of the distinct differences between this story and Cinderella), the novel is wholesome in its overt Christian themes. Grace Livingston Hill consistently weaves Scripture into the narrative, as Joyce seeks the Lord in her decisions. Every facet of her life is guided by her relationship with Him.
Because of how loving Joyce is, she has many friends, but, at the same time, she refuses to compromise her convictions in order to please people. The book was published almost 100 years ago, and in it, Joyce is pressured to adopt the modern values held by the young people around her. But, she maintains a lifestyle of propriety and innocence— making her a bit of an oddity among hee peers. About a century later, Joyce is a timeless role model: as excellent an example for today’s readers as she was for readers of the 1920s.
The novel is also wholesome in terms of romance. The romance thread is rather subtle, but certainly satisfying! And the faith element tied into that portion of the story is really neat, too.
One other wholesome element I’d like to mention is Joyce’s choice in where to worship. In addition to discussions on modernity with respect to the behavior of young people, Livingston Hill also explores modernity in the context of church. Joyce’s reaction to false teaching is both beautiful and refreshing. I appreciate the author’s willingness to take such a strong stance against false teachings about Jesus. Joyce is grieved by preaching that lies about her Lord. This topic, like other discussions of modernity, maintain immense relevance today.
Character Versatility
Livingston Hill does an excellent job with characterization— presenting in one book one of the most honorable, delightful characters I’ve ever experienced— and one of the most obnoxiously frustrating characters.
Romance
I don’t want to spoil the romance, but I will say that it was a thought-provoking romance, for me. I really like the angle the author took, in terms of presenting the connection between romantic relationship and relationship with God.
Content Notes
One use of “gee.”
Recommendation Status
Not Under the Law is truly a delightful novel. It’s a book I can easily, happily, and highly recommend. Plus, it’s in the public domain. I look forward to reading more of the author’s work!
October 5, 2021
Still slogging my way through all of Grace Livingston Hill's books...I think I might be 3/4 finished at this point! I'll have to double check though.
I quite enjoyed this one - not on my all-time favorites list, but probably worth a re-read at some point in the future. What I enjoyed most about this book was the fact that the main hero was definitely not living a good life at the beginning - and not just "I was not walking with Christ, I was selfish and prideful, blah blah blah". No, this man was a bootlegger who was defiantly breaking laws and was far far away from Christ, lawfulness, and any other traditionally moral behavior. BUT he was redeemed! Typically in GLH novels, the good characters are good, (even if they aren't following Christ, they are still morally good for the most part), the bad characters are bad, and there is never much crossover. So this was a very nice change of pace where you see some serious redemption.
I also really enjoyed the little tidbits of domestic life that were thrown in frequently throughout the book. I enjoyed reading about Joyce's cooking and her dressmaking and homemaking skills. I am definitely inspired to try my hand at more of those types of things (I always have had a secret ambition to be really "house-wifey"). I don't think I'd go so far as to try upholstering my own furniture, but I might try my hand at making condiments.
Another thing worth noting as well, is the fact that the heroine was not a pushover. Unlike other female characters who kind of wilt under pressure and need to be saved by an outside force (human or divine), Joyce was being mistreated by her cousin, so she left. She was being mistreated by her employer, so she finished her job to the best of her ability, and refused to be hired for another job. She didn't just lay down and let people walk all over her in the name of turning the other cheek. I really liked that.
Overall, I liked this book a lot and would definitely recommend it. Again, not my favorite of GLH's novels, but definitely worth a re-read in the future. (Although as I'm going back over all the positive things about this book, I'm wondering if I shouldn't have given it 5 stars...I mean a female character who isn't a pushover, a serious redemption arc, AND old fashioned cooking! What more could I ask for?)
I quite enjoyed this one - not on my all-time favorites list, but probably worth a re-read at some point in the future. What I enjoyed most about this book was the fact that the main hero was definitely not living a good life at the beginning - and not just "I was not walking with Christ, I was selfish and prideful, blah blah blah". No, this man was a bootlegger who was defiantly breaking laws and was far far away from Christ, lawfulness, and any other traditionally moral behavior. BUT he was redeemed! Typically in GLH novels, the good characters are good, (even if they aren't following Christ, they are still morally good for the most part), the bad characters are bad, and there is never much crossover. So this was a very nice change of pace where you see some serious redemption.
I also really enjoyed the little tidbits of domestic life that were thrown in frequently throughout the book. I enjoyed reading about Joyce's cooking and her dressmaking and homemaking skills. I am definitely inspired to try my hand at more of those types of things (I always have had a secret ambition to be really "house-wifey"). I don't think I'd go so far as to try upholstering my own furniture, but I might try my hand at making condiments.
Another thing worth noting as well, is the fact that the heroine was not a pushover. Unlike other female characters who kind of wilt under pressure and need to be saved by an outside force (human or divine), Joyce was being mistreated by her cousin, so she left. She was being mistreated by her employer, so she finished her job to the best of her ability, and refused to be hired for another job. She didn't just lay down and let people walk all over her in the name of turning the other cheek. I really liked that.
Overall, I liked this book a lot and would definitely recommend it. Again, not my favorite of GLH's novels, but definitely worth a re-read in the future. (Although as I'm going back over all the positive things about this book, I'm wondering if I shouldn't have given it 5 stars...I mean a female character who isn't a pushover, a serious redemption arc, AND old fashioned cooking! What more could I ask for?)
April 10, 2023
This story follows a similar pattern of many of GLH's books. A young girl, cast into the world on her own, must survive by her wits and her faith. This book was pretty involved; besides the main character's struggle, there was also some criminal bootlegging going on, and a secondary character is caught up in it.
Joyce Radway has finally had enough. Following the death of her beloved Aunt Mary, with whom she has lived for most of her life, Joyce has to endure the taking over of her home by her cousins, who want her to become their unpaid servant and babysitter. They refuse to allow her to take her examinations for her teaching certificate so that she can find work as a teacher. After enduring endless demands and abusive behavior, Joyce just walks out one night, certain that somehow she can find a better way to live. One of the first things she does is spend some time in the cemetery, beside the graves of her mother and aunt, as she weeps for what she has lost and ponders the future. But she is not alone in the cemetery - a gang of bootleggers is using it to bury contraband, and when they discover that she has seen them, they attempt to catch and kill her. She is able to escape, but discovers that one of the men is a person she had known as a child and always looked up to. She is very disappointed - their meeting only lasts a few seconds, just long enough for her to gasp, "What are you doing?" as she disappears again into the night. But that is just long enough for Darcy Sherwood to be brought face to face with what he has become.
Joyce meanwhile manages to find her way to a distant town, where she sets up housekeeping in a tiny house. She is incredibly resourceful and not only cares for her own needs, but begins to be in demand among others in the community for her services. But she is determined to become a teacher. And she is determined to pray for Darcy Sherwood, that he may be brought to a knowledge of his sin and his need of a Savior.
One of the things I really liked about this book is that it is filled with Scripture. Joyce has hidden God's Word in her heart, and it comes to her mind when she needs it, whether to guide, comfort, convict, or convince others.
Joyce Radway has finally had enough. Following the death of her beloved Aunt Mary, with whom she has lived for most of her life, Joyce has to endure the taking over of her home by her cousins, who want her to become their unpaid servant and babysitter. They refuse to allow her to take her examinations for her teaching certificate so that she can find work as a teacher. After enduring endless demands and abusive behavior, Joyce just walks out one night, certain that somehow she can find a better way to live. One of the first things she does is spend some time in the cemetery, beside the graves of her mother and aunt, as she weeps for what she has lost and ponders the future. But she is not alone in the cemetery - a gang of bootleggers is using it to bury contraband, and when they discover that she has seen them, they attempt to catch and kill her. She is able to escape, but discovers that one of the men is a person she had known as a child and always looked up to. She is very disappointed - their meeting only lasts a few seconds, just long enough for her to gasp, "What are you doing?" as she disappears again into the night. But that is just long enough for Darcy Sherwood to be brought face to face with what he has become.
Joyce meanwhile manages to find her way to a distant town, where she sets up housekeeping in a tiny house. She is incredibly resourceful and not only cares for her own needs, but begins to be in demand among others in the community for her services. But she is determined to become a teacher. And she is determined to pray for Darcy Sherwood, that he may be brought to a knowledge of his sin and his need of a Savior.
One of the things I really liked about this book is that it is filled with Scripture. Joyce has hidden God's Word in her heart, and it comes to her mind when she needs it, whether to guide, comfort, convict, or convince others.
December 22, 2024
More often than not, Grace Livingston Hill's novels get dumped into the romance category. Sure, they usually all have some sort of a romance in them, but it's always a tertiary plot and never the primary or secondary.
The same is true for "Not Under the Law." The main theme is how a young lady rebuilds her life after her aunt dies and the other relatives take the property from her that her aunt willed to her. They treat her almost like a Cinderella-type servant and don't want her to continue her education at the teacher's college. In true GLH fashion, the main character sets out on her own and finds a way to reach her goals. She flees to a new town, finds a job, and even buys a cheap house which she fixes up on her own. I like how GLH's heroine's always use their brains and ingenuity to live through difficult situations and make the best of things--and always learn something in the process.
The secondary plot always has a Christian theme. Same thing in this novel. The Christian message about no longer being under the law takes a front seat to any romance, which is minimal.
Although these novels today read like historical fiction, when they were written, they were at the top of modern technology. I think that's why I keep reading them.
The same is true for "Not Under the Law." The main theme is how a young lady rebuilds her life after her aunt dies and the other relatives take the property from her that her aunt willed to her. They treat her almost like a Cinderella-type servant and don't want her to continue her education at the teacher's college. In true GLH fashion, the main character sets out on her own and finds a way to reach her goals. She flees to a new town, finds a job, and even buys a cheap house which she fixes up on her own. I like how GLH's heroine's always use their brains and ingenuity to live through difficult situations and make the best of things--and always learn something in the process.
The secondary plot always has a Christian theme. Same thing in this novel. The Christian message about no longer being under the law takes a front seat to any romance, which is minimal.
Although these novels today read like historical fiction, when they were written, they were at the top of modern technology. I think that's why I keep reading them.
June 17, 2023
I love Grace Livingston Hill's style of writing. She creates gorgeous descriptive phrases that draw you into the experience of the character. But I felt that 99% of this story was the main character shopping or housekeeping... Although I typically enjoy the intimate day-to-day details that the author includes in her stories, the bulk of this book seemed to be a side-quest while the plot we were introduced to waited somewhere off the page.
I missed the level of peril and intrigue that a Grace Livingston Hill book typically provides.
I missed the level of peril and intrigue that a Grace Livingston Hill book typically provides.
September 10, 2020
A lovely story, well written. I love how the author wove all the details together in the end. It made for a satisfying happy ending. I loved all the descriptions of nature, and I loved the characters Joyce Radway and Lib Knox. They really had some spunk. I will be searching out other books by this author.
December 10, 2023
This book is probably really only 3.5 stars if you consider only the writing and preachiness in a lot of it, BUT it gets 5 stars from me because I read it probably twenty years ago and always remembered it and am delighted to finally have found it again. It has such amazing historical daily life facts and I am always drawn in by books about girls making the best of what they have.
January 22, 2022
This was a great book. The lessons that could be learned by reading this book is immeasurable. The author did a great job detailing the abusive living conditions of one of the characters.
August 18, 2023
GLH is a legend!
My mom recommended this book to me a while ago and I'm so glad I picked it up! Great read with a crazy plot!
My mom recommended this book to me a while ago and I'm so glad I picked it up! Great read with a crazy plot!
October 24, 2023
This one is going on my list of GLH favorites!
April 25, 2024
a good read. I do wish there was a recipe section in Grace's books, I'd like to make some of her dishes
May 1, 2024
Another fine story!
You will not go wrong reading a book from Grace Livingston Hill. I just love her stories!! I love how they honor God.
You will not go wrong reading a book from Grace Livingston Hill. I just love her stories!! I love how they honor God.
October 7, 2024
Another wonderful story by this author. I love how much God plays a role in her character's lives.
November 7, 2025
Started decently , although SO unrealistic. I would describe it almost like the Boxcar Children but for adults. I lost interest once Joyce finished outfitting her tiny home and put the book away.
June 22, 2021
Great book
Spunky, creative, resourceful heroine. Inspiring story. Full of wonderful songs and Bible verses. Easy to recommend! One of Hill’s best.
Spunky, creative, resourceful heroine. Inspiring story. Full of wonderful songs and Bible verses. Easy to recommend! One of Hill’s best.
December 27, 2012
Grace Livingston Hill in her new book, “Not Under The Law” Book Eleven in the Love Endures series published by Barbour Publishing, Inc. takes us into the life of Joyce Radway.
From the back cover: “She was paralyzed with fear…Who knew what desperate criminals these might be? Grave robbers would not hesitate to dig a new grave.”
In a moment of frustration, Joyce Radway walks out on her cousins, determined never to return and give into their selfish demands that she serve them rather than follow her dream of becoming a teacher. But in her haste to leave town, Joyce unwittingly stumbles on some men out to cover up their actions in a cemetery plot.
Joyce is both stunned and afraid—especially when she recognizes her childhood friend among the men—but she narrowly escapes, unaware that as she builds her new life she’s being followed.
Ruthless and swarthy, Tyke is out to silence the only witness to his crime. His partner, Darcy, is out to silence the guilt that plagues his heart. As their determined searches bring them closer and closer to Joyce, will God’s law protect her against men who are a law unto themselves?
When Grace Livingston Hill’s first husband died he left her with two young daughters to raise. In an effort to support her family she turned to writing. However, Ms. Hill just didn’t want to write just anything she wanted to write stories of faith. Nothing blows up, there are no car chases and the future of the world is not in jeopardy yet “Not Under the Law” is very exciting. Originally written in 1934 “Not Under the Law” is a wonderful story of how God can take our circumstances and change them to the better. Joyce Radway has very bad luck. Not only does she witness a crime but the they see her and know who she is. Now they are out to hunt her down and eliminate her as the only witness even though she is trying to start a new life for herself. The only one who is really going to help her get out of this is God. How this story is all going to work out is what makes for really delightful reading. I think “Not Under the Law” is a suspenseful thriller and a wonderful romance that will keep you reading as to what happens next. Ms. Hill knows how to tell a great story and while it may be old it still is a powerful story.
If you would like to listen to interviews with other authors and professionals please go to www.kingdomhighlights.org where they are available On Demand.
To listen to 24 hours non-stop, commercial free Christian music please visit our internet radio station www.kingdomairwaves.org
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Barbour Publishing, Inc. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 : “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
From the back cover: “She was paralyzed with fear…Who knew what desperate criminals these might be? Grave robbers would not hesitate to dig a new grave.”
In a moment of frustration, Joyce Radway walks out on her cousins, determined never to return and give into their selfish demands that she serve them rather than follow her dream of becoming a teacher. But in her haste to leave town, Joyce unwittingly stumbles on some men out to cover up their actions in a cemetery plot.
Joyce is both stunned and afraid—especially when she recognizes her childhood friend among the men—but she narrowly escapes, unaware that as she builds her new life she’s being followed.
Ruthless and swarthy, Tyke is out to silence the only witness to his crime. His partner, Darcy, is out to silence the guilt that plagues his heart. As their determined searches bring them closer and closer to Joyce, will God’s law protect her against men who are a law unto themselves?
When Grace Livingston Hill’s first husband died he left her with two young daughters to raise. In an effort to support her family she turned to writing. However, Ms. Hill just didn’t want to write just anything she wanted to write stories of faith. Nothing blows up, there are no car chases and the future of the world is not in jeopardy yet “Not Under the Law” is very exciting. Originally written in 1934 “Not Under the Law” is a wonderful story of how God can take our circumstances and change them to the better. Joyce Radway has very bad luck. Not only does she witness a crime but the they see her and know who she is. Now they are out to hunt her down and eliminate her as the only witness even though she is trying to start a new life for herself. The only one who is really going to help her get out of this is God. How this story is all going to work out is what makes for really delightful reading. I think “Not Under the Law” is a suspenseful thriller and a wonderful romance that will keep you reading as to what happens next. Ms. Hill knows how to tell a great story and while it may be old it still is a powerful story.
If you would like to listen to interviews with other authors and professionals please go to www.kingdomhighlights.org where they are available On Demand.
To listen to 24 hours non-stop, commercial free Christian music please visit our internet radio station www.kingdomairwaves.org
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Barbour Publishing, Inc. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 : “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
November 12, 2012
NOT UNDER THE LAW by Grace Livingston Hill is a classic inspirational fiction. "Love Endures" series. What a wonderful classic. Follow, Joyce Radway on a journey of discovery,secrets,grief,faith,family,intrigue,suspense,deception,hurt,forgiveness,healing and love. A fast paced story that will have you turning pages. From America's best loved storyteller,"Not Under The Law",is updated for a new generation of readers. While,Ms. Livingston Hill is no longer with us her stories live on in our hearts. Fast paced and enduring with a thought provoking message. A must for any romance reader who enjoys a good,sound read with engaging,strong-minded characters that will lift your heart and spirit.Received for an honest review from the publisher. Details can be found at Barbour Publishing and My Book Addiction and More.
RATING: 4
HEAT RATING: SWEET
REVIEWED BY: AprilR, My Book Addiction and More/My Book Addiction Reviews
RATING: 4
HEAT RATING: SWEET
REVIEWED BY: AprilR, My Book Addiction and More/My Book Addiction Reviews
August 30, 2025
This is not the sort of book to start half an hour before bedtime! The mystery was riveting ... right to the end of the book, really. I spent a second night "reading" (listening to Anne Hancock's superb narration) until 2 am because I just had to know how it all came out.
The mystery really gripped me, but so did the little house makeover and the theological discussions. If you resent the latter, this may not be the book for you. But for me, it was the most realistic part of the book - discussions I have had, or sometimes should have had, with friends and other people in my life. The book was written almost 100 years ago, but I think the discussion transfers well to today and Christians facing Woke and other modern ideologies.
This is definitely a book I would like to share. Looking for hard copy.
The mystery really gripped me, but so did the little house makeover and the theological discussions. If you resent the latter, this may not be the book for you. But for me, it was the most realistic part of the book - discussions I have had, or sometimes should have had, with friends and other people in my life. The book was written almost 100 years ago, but I think the discussion transfers well to today and Christians facing Woke and other modern ideologies.
This is definitely a book I would like to share. Looking for hard copy.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 37 reviews