Another in my continuing search for good YA books. This one I didn't hold out much hope for. The back cover blurb suggested to me a girl desperate for romance and a potential new boyfriend gone very badly.
Not at all. The voice of the 'secret admirer' is true to who he actually is. Holly is curious about romance but not to the point of disgusting silliness. Her voice seems true as well. The counterpoint with her friend Ella and the vast differences (and a surprising similarity) of their two families offers a nice way to clarify Holly's feelings.
Holly's real boyfriend was a surprise as well and I wish we had seen a bit more of him. Though I thought his reaction to Holly getting these presents was a bit over the top, perhaps it is true to relationships among young people in the new millennium. But I liked him best when he 'wanted something more' with Holly and yet allowed her to say no and leave. It felt honest, and gave a model for our youth to follow in such situations. It is not automatically 'parents aren't expected home, we must take advantage of the situation'; we do have choices.
And speaking of parents, most of the portrayal of hers rang true as well, except Holly's reaction and blazing out in anger at her mother 'when all is revealed'. I can't imagine speaking to someone that way with whom I had such a wonderful relationship previously. But maybe that works as well -- the feeling of betrayal could be that strong. My favorite part of the book and the one I felt draws it all together is the revelation by Holly's -- biological but real -- father. He gave the situation perspective. Even the best of us can have reasons to deceive, and good reasons too.
The book ended well too simply, with closure, hope, and a widening of Holly's future.