When I was a child, I thought Lord Soth was the coolest anti-hero. Between his appearances as well as the Ravenloft series, he always was the most bad ass. Now, years later, I picked up the book again to remember the tale of Soth's fall as a far wider read reader with a far more critical mind.
The first thing I noticed about Lord Soth is the fact that we are treated to a hero that is cursed completely due to his father's actions. Since the first page to the last, we are told that Soth can't escape his father's curses and actions, and that Soth (and his son) would forever pay for their parent's actions. This creates a sense of hopelessness throughout the book, one that I think drowns out any sort of conflict that could arise. We expect Soth to behave like his father, after all, he hasn't really been given any sort of choice on the matter according to all the talk about curses. It takes any and all dramatic tension out of the story. There is no higher struggle, no real noble deeds of Soth from which to fall.
It makes for a very boring read.
There is a fair bit of good writing involving Soth's rise to power and the path that leads to his fall. Parts of it are really well done. His infidelity is well handled and his choices to have the elf around realistic. In fact a lot of the behaviors of the characters are realistic, except for Soth's rage. Only twice do we see Soth rage to a point where he is blind to anything else, and though this works well with the plot, we never really ever see this rage come up anywhere else. If it was known that Soth had a temper, then his two cruelest moments would make sense, but alas, no such points occur in the book. This makes his rage seem out of character for him.
All in all, this is a very brutal story as to why Soth became the dead knight he is known as. We see how he was cursed, we see how he became who he became, all with some pretty brutal parts. Which makes me look back at the child version of myself and wonder just why I thought he was a cool character. (or why others think he's so cool)
If you like Lord Soth, then read this book. It broadens his characters and definatly gives you insight into who he was, the good and the bad. If you have no previous knowledge of Soth, Krynn, and are reading this simply because it's a fantasy book, then I don't recommend it. A lot of the material in this book relies on the fact that you know about Krynn and the character of Soth.
In the end, not the best written book set in the world of Krynn, but neither the worst.