What do you think?
Rate this book
Amish ABCs #2
B Is for Bonnet
In this heartwarming and inspiring new series from the beloved New York Times bestselling and award-winning author, four English-raised siblings take a genuine leap of faith when they return to their grandparents’ rural Ohio community with a plan to become Amish—and one by one, discover more about themselves, and about love, than they ever expected. For fans of Amish romance and wholesome fiction.
Raised by their divorced, lapsed-Amish father and English mother, siblings Jonny, Martin, Kelsey, and Beth can't wait to reinvent their lives. The four don't have much in common, but they long for the stable sense of family they felt when visiting their Old Order grandparents, Josiah and Sylvia Schrock, in peaceful Holmes County, Ohio. And the Schrocks couldn't be more surprised when the grandkids want to try living with them—and joining their faith . . .
When Jonny hears startling news about his health, he knows it's past time to change his life. Quitting college, he unexpectedly finds the fulfilling job of his dreams. And he's instantly smitten with cafe owner Treva Hershberger, whose baked goods are as warm and delicious as her lively personality. But no matter how hard Jonny tries, he can't seem to get past her secret sadness and distrust. Can he prove that his feelings for her are for real—and forever—in time?
A bad breakup left Treva heartbroken—and resolved to be independent without relying on anyone ever again. Exhausted from pouring everything she's got into her cafe, she’s stunned by Jonny’s easygoing ways—and drawn to his optimistic nature. But when she thinks his real interest is in becoming Amish, she's even more determined to stay focused—and keep her heart safe . . .
Soon, deep secrets and hidden family truths will test Jonny and Treva in unexpected ways. And with help from his warm-hearted grandparents, he and Treva might gain the happiness they secretly long for—with each other.
Raised by their divorced, lapsed-Amish father and English mother, siblings Jonny, Martin, Kelsey, and Beth can't wait to reinvent their lives. The four don't have much in common, but they long for the stable sense of family they felt when visiting their Old Order grandparents, Josiah and Sylvia Schrock, in peaceful Holmes County, Ohio. And the Schrocks couldn't be more surprised when the grandkids want to try living with them—and joining their faith . . .
When Jonny hears startling news about his health, he knows it's past time to change his life. Quitting college, he unexpectedly finds the fulfilling job of his dreams. And he's instantly smitten with cafe owner Treva Hershberger, whose baked goods are as warm and delicious as her lively personality. But no matter how hard Jonny tries, he can't seem to get past her secret sadness and distrust. Can he prove that his feelings for her are for real—and forever—in time?
A bad breakup left Treva heartbroken—and resolved to be independent without relying on anyone ever again. Exhausted from pouring everything she's got into her cafe, she’s stunned by Jonny’s easygoing ways—and drawn to his optimistic nature. But when she thinks his real interest is in becoming Amish, she's even more determined to stay focused—and keep her heart safe . . .
Soon, deep secrets and hidden family truths will test Jonny and Treva in unexpected ways. And with help from his warm-hearted grandparents, he and Treva might gain the happiness they secretly long for—with each other.
289 pages, Paperback
Published January 21, 2025
97 people are currently reading
3239 people want to read
About the author
Shelley Shepard Gray
126 books2,314 followersLibrarian Note: AKA Shelley Gray (Western Romance).
Shelley Shepard Gray has published over seventy novels. She currently writes Amish romances for Harper Collins, Kensington, and Simon & Schuster and contemporary women’s fiction for Blackstone Publishing.
Her novels have been Holt Medallion winners and Inspirational Readers Choice and Carol finalists. Shelley’s novels have appeared on both the New York Times and USA Today bestseller lists.
Her novels have been highlighted in the Philadelphia Enquirer, Washington Post, Time Magazine, and USA Today. She has also been interviewed on NPR as well as numerous regional radio stations.
Before writing romances, Shelley lived in Texas and Colorado, where she taught school and earned both her bachelor’s degree in English literature and elementary education and later obtained her master’s degree in educational administration. She currently lives in Colorado Springs and writes full time. Shelley is married, the mother of two young adults, and always has a dachshund by her side. She is an active member of her church, on Facebook and on Twitter. She also has a website, www.shelleyshepardgray.com.
t
Shelley Shepard Gray has published over seventy novels. She currently writes Amish romances for Harper Collins, Kensington, and Simon & Schuster and contemporary women’s fiction for Blackstone Publishing.
Her novels have been Holt Medallion winners and Inspirational Readers Choice and Carol finalists. Shelley’s novels have appeared on both the New York Times and USA Today bestseller lists.
Her novels have been highlighted in the Philadelphia Enquirer, Washington Post, Time Magazine, and USA Today. She has also been interviewed on NPR as well as numerous regional radio stations.
Before writing romances, Shelley lived in Texas and Colorado, where she taught school and earned both her bachelor’s degree in English literature and elementary education and later obtained her master’s degree in educational administration. She currently lives in Colorado Springs and writes full time. Shelley is married, the mother of two young adults, and always has a dachshund by her side. She is an active member of her church, on Facebook and on Twitter. She also has a website, www.shelleyshepardgray.com.
t
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews
January 16, 2025
B is for Bonnet is the second of the Amish ABC's series and the story continues with four adult siblings brought up English wanting to try living Amish with their Amish grandparents. In this book, Jonny, the youngest is living with his grandparents and working in a bike shop. All of the siblings have feelings of unhappiness from their childhood with their parents' divorce. As the story goes along, we see more reconciliation and healing with the simple life away from modern conveniences. Even their father decides to visit his parents. This is a nice series with wonderful characters experiencing forgiveness, faith and romance.
I received a copy in exchange for an honest review. These are my thoughts..
I received a copy in exchange for an honest review. These are my thoughts..
January 21, 2025
I loved everything about this delightful book from the colorful cover to the characters, the story and the books ending. I thought that the book had a smooth flow and was an easy read. This second book in the series focused on Jonny Schrock and Cafe owner Treva Kramer. Characters from book one are carried over to this book and the story continues from where it stopped in book one. The theme of the story is not to let the past keep you from being all you can be in the present. Readers get to meet the parents of the Schrock siblings. Matt Schrock, their father plays a strong presence in this book. Their mother makes a brief appearance close to the end of the book. A few new characters are introduced and add to the story. This was an entertaining and inspirational story. I enjoyed reading B is for Bonnet.
As the story begins Jonny Schrock learns he has health issues and he will have to make some lifestyle changes. He reaches out to his father for help and advice. He starts his year of living with his Amish Grandparents and living the Amish plain life. He settles into a job and becomes smitten with a beautiful Amish Cafe owner. It isn’t just her lattes that keeps Jonny coming back to the Trailside Cafe. Will Jonny decide that the plain life of his Grandparents is what he wants for his future or will he go back to college when his year is up?
I highly recommend this book to readers of Amish Fiction and Romance, Christian Fiction and to those who have read book one in the ABCs series. I feel it is best to read A is for Amish before reading this book. B is for Bonnet is scheduled for release on 1/21/25.
I voluntarily read an advanced readers copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed here in this review are entirely my own
#BIsforBonnet #NetGalley
As the story begins Jonny Schrock learns he has health issues and he will have to make some lifestyle changes. He reaches out to his father for help and advice. He starts his year of living with his Amish Grandparents and living the Amish plain life. He settles into a job and becomes smitten with a beautiful Amish Cafe owner. It isn’t just her lattes that keeps Jonny coming back to the Trailside Cafe. Will Jonny decide that the plain life of his Grandparents is what he wants for his future or will he go back to college when his year is up?
I highly recommend this book to readers of Amish Fiction and Romance, Christian Fiction and to those who have read book one in the ABCs series. I feel it is best to read A is for Amish before reading this book. B is for Bonnet is scheduled for release on 1/21/25.
I voluntarily read an advanced readers copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed here in this review are entirely my own
#BIsforBonnet #NetGalley
October 16, 2024
Rating: 5 stars ~ Genre: Amish Fiction ~ Pages: Unknown at time of review ~ Publish Date: 21 Jan 2025
The second book in Gray’s “Amish ABCs” series continues the story of four siblings, raised “English”, but supposedly want to become Amish suddenly showing up at their grandparents’ home. [See “A is for Amish” review.] “B Is for Bonnet” focuses on Jonny Schrock and begins in a doctor’s office when he learns that his “cholesterol is through the roof”. Two months later, Jonny is living with his grandparents and on the path to becoming Amish.
The story centers around forgiveness. One of my first highlights when reading this DRC (digital review copy) was “Opting to live a life of unforgiveness is a miserable way to live.” which was given to Jonny when he went to see the Bishop. As the story developed, I understood the reasons various people felt as they did. Sometimes the person who needs forgiveness is ourselves.
The story flows from one rich scene to another. I’m drawn to stories that give animals personalities. There’s Alfred, a dog that goes crazy whenever he sees a chipmunk. I have a granddog who has the same issue with squirrels. Danny, the Great Dane. And a gelding named Arthur. These scenes always make me smile even though there may be a serious situation going on.
A genuine love shines through this story. The love of an Amish grandmother who just knows that a good woman is what Jonny needs. A certain shop where the coffee was just how he liked it or maybe it was the girl making the coffee.
You’ll enjoy “B Is for Bonnet”; however, I do believe you need to read “A is for Amish” first. Oh, and the next book coming out in winter 2026 is “C is for Courting”.
I received a complimentary DRC of “B Is for Bonnet” via NetGalley from the publisher, Kensington Publishing | Kensington. A positive review was not required; the opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Rating: 5 stars
Series: Amish ABCs
Cover: Pretty
Pages: Unknown at the time of this review
Publish Date: 21 January 2025
#BIsforBonnet #NetGalley #ShelleyShepardGray
The second book in Gray’s “Amish ABCs” series continues the story of four siblings, raised “English”, but supposedly want to become Amish suddenly showing up at their grandparents’ home. [See “A is for Amish” review.] “B Is for Bonnet” focuses on Jonny Schrock and begins in a doctor’s office when he learns that his “cholesterol is through the roof”. Two months later, Jonny is living with his grandparents and on the path to becoming Amish.
The story centers around forgiveness. One of my first highlights when reading this DRC (digital review copy) was “Opting to live a life of unforgiveness is a miserable way to live.” which was given to Jonny when he went to see the Bishop. As the story developed, I understood the reasons various people felt as they did. Sometimes the person who needs forgiveness is ourselves.
The story flows from one rich scene to another. I’m drawn to stories that give animals personalities. There’s Alfred, a dog that goes crazy whenever he sees a chipmunk. I have a granddog who has the same issue with squirrels. Danny, the Great Dane. And a gelding named Arthur. These scenes always make me smile even though there may be a serious situation going on.
A genuine love shines through this story. The love of an Amish grandmother who just knows that a good woman is what Jonny needs. A certain shop where the coffee was just how he liked it or maybe it was the girl making the coffee.
You’ll enjoy “B Is for Bonnet”; however, I do believe you need to read “A is for Amish” first. Oh, and the next book coming out in winter 2026 is “C is for Courting”.
I received a complimentary DRC of “B Is for Bonnet” via NetGalley from the publisher, Kensington Publishing | Kensington. A positive review was not required; the opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Rating: 5 stars
Series: Amish ABCs
Cover: Pretty
Pages: Unknown at the time of this review
Publish Date: 21 January 2025
#BIsforBonnet #NetGalley #ShelleyShepardGray
October 12, 2024
*****I received this free ARC from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review
The second book in this series. A wonderful Amish read. As the family navigates through deciding to return to the Amish life even after their parents raised them in the English world is a difficult one. These siblings are taking turns spending time living with their grandparents to help them make that decision. Relationships with the siblings, grandparents , English father as well as new friends and relationships makes this an enjoyable read.
The second book in this series. A wonderful Amish read. As the family navigates through deciding to return to the Amish life even after their parents raised them in the English world is a difficult one. These siblings are taking turns spending time living with their grandparents to help them make that decision. Relationships with the siblings, grandparents , English father as well as new friends and relationships makes this an enjoyable read.
January 23, 2025
Jonny Shrock is not sure that he wants to be Amish, but he is sure that he enjoys coffee, so every day he goes to Treva Hershberger’s coffee shop before he goes to the bicycle shop where he works. The attraction between the two is predictable, but so much fun to read. I was completely absorbed in the drama surrounding them, especially Treva’s former relationship that left her feeling unlovable and Jonny’s health issues that made him wonder how long a future he would have. I fell in love with the characters and the setting, but the plot kept me reading to find out how they would work out all of their problems together. My favorite character was a secondary one, Matt Schrock, Jonny’s dad, who is a man seeking his own second chance at love as well as reconciliation with his children and parents. I admired his determination and humility as well as his deep love for family. This story is heartwarming and a lovely romance that is a fast and enjoyable read.
Disclaimer
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley as a member of the author’s advanced review team. I was not required to write a positive review, and all opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16th CFR, Part 255, “Guidelines Concerning the Use of Testimonials and Endorsements in Advertising.”
Disclaimer
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley as a member of the author’s advanced review team. I was not required to write a positive review, and all opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16th CFR, Part 255, “Guidelines Concerning the Use of Testimonials and Endorsements in Advertising.”
September 28, 2024
I enjoy reading Shelley Shepherd Gray’s books because she usually intertwines faith and forgiveness throughout her storylines. Anytime you have a café or bakery in the book, and also a character who is thinking about becoming Amish, it makes for a cozy feeling. The personalities of the characters and the secrets that unfold, definitely peaked my interest and kept me reading.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book from Netgalley and the publisher. All words are my own.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book from Netgalley and the publisher. All words are my own.
January 26, 2025
B is for Bonnet by Shelley Shepard Gray (2025)
Amish ABCs #2
237-page Libby Ebook story pages 9-223
Genre: Christian Fiction > Amish Fiction, Inspirational; Romance > Contemporary Romance
Featuring: Series List for The Amish ABCs Series and The Amish of Apple Creek Series, Epigraph, June, Cleveland, Ohio; Health Scare, Siblings, Grandparents, Old Order Amish, Joining the Community Trope, English Mom, Former Amish Dad, Divorce, August, Bicycle Shop, Holmes County, Ohio; Walden, Ohio; Instalove, Café, Multiple POVs, Matchmaking, German, Second Chance Trope, Exes, Self-Actualization, September, Forgiveness, Family Dynamics, The Story Continues, Preview of C Is for Courting - Chapter 1, Cover Advertisements for A is for Amish, An Amish Cinderella, Happily Ever Amish, and Once Upon a Buggy,
Rating as a movie: PG
Books and Authors mentioned: Gospel of Matthew by Apostle Matthew, Harry Potter Series by J. K. Rowling
Memorable Quotes: His grandmother picked up her fork again. "All right, Jonny, I'll let this subject go. But I do hope you visit Trailside again."
"I probably will. The coffee was great."
"The owner is great, too. Give Treva a chance, dear. And eat your supper. You've hardly touched a thing." Reaching for the plate of fish, she said, "How about another piece?"
Jonny's stomach clenched. He had a feeling it was going to be easier to fall in love with Treva than to convince his grandmother to change her cooking habits.
"Pick your battles, son," his dawdi said as he reached for the plate of fish. "It will make suppertime a whole lot easier for you."
My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️½🅱️☕️🚲👴🏻👵
My thoughts: 🔖Page 132 of 237 Chapter 18 - I tried to stay awake but lost the fight a few hours ago. I'm enjoying the story although the last book was set in Millersburg, but this one is in Walden despite the location being the same, grandparents' house. This continues where the last book ends after Jonny's sister Kelsey's marriage. It's obvious who will end up together but there have been several wrenches that may be questioning the couplings. I still don't know who the dad, Matthew, will end up with.
I was a little confused as the pregnancy that was revealed early in the story wasn't mentioned near the end. Hopefully, it'll be mentioned again in Book 3. I wasn't expecting the father to get a POV, it was nice, maybe the mom, Helen, will get one in Book 3. I'm looking forward to the rest of this series.
Recommend to others: Yes, this is a fun and thoughtful series you need to read in order.
Amish ABCs
1. A is for Amish (2024)
2. B is for Bonnet (2025)
3. C is for Courting (2025)
Amish ABCs #2
237-page Libby Ebook story pages 9-223
Genre: Christian Fiction > Amish Fiction, Inspirational; Romance > Contemporary Romance
Featuring: Series List for The Amish ABCs Series and The Amish of Apple Creek Series, Epigraph, June, Cleveland, Ohio; Health Scare, Siblings, Grandparents, Old Order Amish, Joining the Community Trope, English Mom, Former Amish Dad, Divorce, August, Bicycle Shop, Holmes County, Ohio; Walden, Ohio; Instalove, Café, Multiple POVs, Matchmaking, German, Second Chance Trope, Exes, Self-Actualization, September, Forgiveness, Family Dynamics, The Story Continues, Preview of C Is for Courting - Chapter 1, Cover Advertisements for A is for Amish, An Amish Cinderella, Happily Ever Amish, and Once Upon a Buggy,
Rating as a movie: PG
Books and Authors mentioned: Gospel of Matthew by Apostle Matthew, Harry Potter Series by J. K. Rowling
Memorable Quotes: His grandmother picked up her fork again. "All right, Jonny, I'll let this subject go. But I do hope you visit Trailside again."
"I probably will. The coffee was great."
"The owner is great, too. Give Treva a chance, dear. And eat your supper. You've hardly touched a thing." Reaching for the plate of fish, she said, "How about another piece?"
Jonny's stomach clenched. He had a feeling it was going to be easier to fall in love with Treva than to convince his grandmother to change her cooking habits.
"Pick your battles, son," his dawdi said as he reached for the plate of fish. "It will make suppertime a whole lot easier for you."
My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️½🅱️☕️🚲👴🏻👵
My thoughts: 🔖Page 132 of 237 Chapter 18 - I tried to stay awake but lost the fight a few hours ago. I'm enjoying the story although the last book was set in Millersburg, but this one is in Walden despite the location being the same, grandparents' house. This continues where the last book ends after Jonny's sister Kelsey's marriage. It's obvious who will end up together but there have been several wrenches that may be questioning the couplings. I still don't know who the dad, Matthew, will end up with.
I was a little confused as the pregnancy that was revealed early in the story wasn't mentioned near the end. Hopefully, it'll be mentioned again in Book 3. I wasn't expecting the father to get a POV, it was nice, maybe the mom, Helen, will get one in Book 3. I'm looking forward to the rest of this series.
Recommend to others: Yes, this is a fun and thoughtful series you need to read in order.
Amish ABCs
1. A is for Amish (2024)
2. B is for Bonnet (2025)
3. C is for Courting (2025)
January 16, 2025
B is for Bonnets is a sweet and enjoyable read that kept a smile on my face until the very end. I thoroughly enjoyed Jonny and Treva's story, but I also enjoyed the secondary romance with Jonny's dad Matt and Kennedy. If you are looking for a light and sweet read, then this book will be for you.
*I was given a copy of this book by the publisher, and this is my honest opinion.
*I was given a copy of this book by the publisher, and this is my honest opinion.
January 22, 2025
Another awesome book by Shelley Shepard Gray! Not too heavy on the romance but just enough to keep you on your toes. The story keep me interested and I had to know what was coming next. I would highly suggest reading the first book in this series, "A is for Amish", as it gives the backstory before getting into "B is for Bonnet". I'm looking forward to reading the next book in the series, "C is for Courting", later next year.
I received a complimentary ARC of “B Is for Bonnet” via NetGalley from the publisher, Kensington Publishing | Kensington. A positive review was not required; the opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
I received a complimentary ARC of “B Is for Bonnet” via NetGalley from the publisher, Kensington Publishing | Kensington. A positive review was not required; the opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
August 24, 2024
Loved reading the inspirational and captivating story. Even though Jonny finds out he has to be careful what he eats, he still wants to try living Amish, gets a job selling electric bikes, and wants to spend more time with Treva. Meanwhile, Jonny's dad s has a long road ahead of him to try to make amends with his children, and Martin, Jonny's older brother, is still unsure about becoming Amish. Read the highly recommended, wonderfully written, and a must read riveting story by the phenomenal author, Shelley Shepard Gray. Can't wait to read the next story in the series!
May 6, 2025
Review to follow!
February 12, 2025
4.5 stars
“Opting to live a life of unforgiveness is a miserable way to live.”
I became hooked on this series and its unique premise in A is for Amish – four siblings who are seriously contemplating becoming Amish after craving the peace & purpose their Amish grandparents seem to have. As part of this ongoing experiment, they agree to take turns moving in with their grandparents and immersing themselves in the Amish life to make sure it’s really something they think they can do. The first book focused on the first two to try it – Martin and Kelsey – and in B is for Bonnet, we join Jonny with his own trial period already in progress. Out of all the siblings, he’s the youngest, the one who most appears to need the slower pace, and the one I predicted would most easily adjust to all things Amish. And as we watch him thrive at his new job and begin to build a relationship with the extremely-likable Treva, it seems that I was right. There are more layers to this plot than first meets the eye though, and I really enjoyed the different elements to Jonny’s story and to Treva’s, as well as that of one particular secondary character who took me pleasantly by surprise.
And that’s so delightfully typical of Shelley Shepard Gray’s novels – the charm and heart she brings to her characters, flaws and all. They always feel like real people, with all the same idiosyncracies and imperfections and strengths and joys as I have, and Jonny and his complicated family – and Treva and hers – are no exception. Even Jonny’s grandparents have some edges that would frustrate me in real life but are endearing to read about. Also characteristic of Gray’s novels? The secondary love story. I wasn’t expecting the one in B is for Bonnet to feature the couple it did, but I’m so glad the author chose them because this relationship added so much dimension to the story by default. Not directly because of the romance aspect, per se, but rather its indirect influence on some of the more fractured relationships in this series. I’m intrigued to see where Gray continues to take this restoration sub-theme in the next book!
Bottom Line: B is for Bonnet by Shelley Shepard Gray entertains you with its warmly-written characters, witty moments and sweet romance while at the same time touching your heart with its thoughtful exploration of forgiveness, both of others and of ourselves. I loved getting to know Jonny better in this book, and I enjoyed the time spent with the rest of his family too. I’m still curious about how Martin’s story will ultimately turn out, and after the ending of this book and the preview of the next I’m very impatiently waiting for Beth’s too! If you enjoy layered family dynamics, quaint rural communities, swoony love stories, and characters who feel like friends, then you definitely need to be reading Shelley Shepard Gray’s Amish ABCs!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
“Opting to live a life of unforgiveness is a miserable way to live.”
I became hooked on this series and its unique premise in A is for Amish – four siblings who are seriously contemplating becoming Amish after craving the peace & purpose their Amish grandparents seem to have. As part of this ongoing experiment, they agree to take turns moving in with their grandparents and immersing themselves in the Amish life to make sure it’s really something they think they can do. The first book focused on the first two to try it – Martin and Kelsey – and in B is for Bonnet, we join Jonny with his own trial period already in progress. Out of all the siblings, he’s the youngest, the one who most appears to need the slower pace, and the one I predicted would most easily adjust to all things Amish. And as we watch him thrive at his new job and begin to build a relationship with the extremely-likable Treva, it seems that I was right. There are more layers to this plot than first meets the eye though, and I really enjoyed the different elements to Jonny’s story and to Treva’s, as well as that of one particular secondary character who took me pleasantly by surprise.
And that’s so delightfully typical of Shelley Shepard Gray’s novels – the charm and heart she brings to her characters, flaws and all. They always feel like real people, with all the same idiosyncracies and imperfections and strengths and joys as I have, and Jonny and his complicated family – and Treva and hers – are no exception. Even Jonny’s grandparents have some edges that would frustrate me in real life but are endearing to read about. Also characteristic of Gray’s novels? The secondary love story. I wasn’t expecting the one in B is for Bonnet to feature the couple it did, but I’m so glad the author chose them because this relationship added so much dimension to the story by default. Not directly because of the romance aspect, per se, but rather its indirect influence on some of the more fractured relationships in this series. I’m intrigued to see where Gray continues to take this restoration sub-theme in the next book!
Bottom Line: B is for Bonnet by Shelley Shepard Gray entertains you with its warmly-written characters, witty moments and sweet romance while at the same time touching your heart with its thoughtful exploration of forgiveness, both of others and of ourselves. I loved getting to know Jonny better in this book, and I enjoyed the time spent with the rest of his family too. I’m still curious about how Martin’s story will ultimately turn out, and after the ending of this book and the preview of the next I’m very impatiently waiting for Beth’s too! If you enjoy layered family dynamics, quaint rural communities, swoony love stories, and characters who feel like friends, then you definitely need to be reading Shelley Shepard Gray’s Amish ABCs!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
January 21, 2025
B Is for Bonnetia another inspirational story written by Shelley Shepard Gray. This storyline moves along at a great pace and will definitely keep the readers interest. I enjoyed getting to know the characters and their part in the story. The cover really draws in interest from readers. Within this story there are several lessons to be learned. To me the best thing is that forgiveness is also comforting as well as healing. The author has done an excellant job developing a story for her readers enjoyment.
January 22, 2025
Loved it!
B is for Bonnet
As we go back into the lives of the Schrock family, the story starts off this time with Jonny. He seems more concerned than most people about his health, then the story moves to back to Amish country where he returns to. He finds a nice coffee shop nearby and finds the coffee delightful as well as the owner, Treva. Things really get interesting when an old boyfriend shows back up after ditching her as well as Jonny’s father showing up at his parent’s home. Find a cozy corner and fall into this wonderful story about the Schrock family and how their family have learned the meaning of the word, forgiveness.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher.
B is for Bonnet
As we go back into the lives of the Schrock family, the story starts off this time with Jonny. He seems more concerned than most people about his health, then the story moves to back to Amish country where he returns to. He finds a nice coffee shop nearby and finds the coffee delightful as well as the owner, Treva. Things really get interesting when an old boyfriend shows back up after ditching her as well as Jonny’s father showing up at his parent’s home. Find a cozy corner and fall into this wonderful story about the Schrock family and how their family have learned the meaning of the word, forgiveness.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher.
January 20, 2025
This both is about four siblings considering being Amish. It also involves their relationships with parents and each other. It’s an interesting story that kept me entertained. I highly recommend this book.
December 30, 2024
Once again, the author knocks it out of the park with this one. After the first chapter, I was instantly caught up into the life of Jonny and Treva. The other Schrock siblings also show up in this book as well as their dad and some of their mom. I love the forgiveness, the love, the patience and the joy you will find in this book. Jonny must decide whether he wants to live the plain lifestyle or not. This book makes you feel like you have a front row seat in the lives of Jonny and Treva as well as their families. I highly recommend reading this book, as well as the other books this author publishes.
November 13, 2024
Shelley Shepard Gray is one of my favorite authors. I have read many of her books. All her books are amazing. I give this book a 5 star rating!
B Is For Bonnet is the second book in the Amish ABCs Series. It comes out on January 21, 2025. Book one is A Is For Amish came out in June of 2024 and book three C Is For Courting comes out in Winter of 2026.
This second book B Is For Bonnet continues the story of four English children who want to live with their Amish grandparents in Ohio.
Their parents are divorced. Their father, Matt was raised Amish and left the community and their mother is English. The grandparents are very surprised that the four grandchildren want to try living Amish. Siblings Beth, Martin, Jonny, and Kelsey have decided they want a simpler life.
This second book centers around Jonny more so than the rest of his siblings. After receiving some bad health news from his doctor, he knows he needs to make changes in his lifestyle so he decides to go and live with his grandparents. He finds a job at a bicycle shop right there in town and works long hours. Jonny eventually starts having feelings for an Amish girl named Treva, who owns and operates her own café and does all her own baking.
Jonny’s father Matt comes back to visit family especially his children. Matt realizes how much better he feels as well while he’s there visiting each time and realizes how much he misses this quiet way of life.
Amish romance is one of my favorite genre. I like the peaceful feel I get when reading these books. This is a very good book. It is also going to be a wonderful series to read.
I would recommend this book.
Thank you, Netgalley and Kensington Publisher for the opportunity to read this ARC e-book and give my honest opinion .
B Is For Bonnet is the second book in the Amish ABCs Series. It comes out on January 21, 2025. Book one is A Is For Amish came out in June of 2024 and book three C Is For Courting comes out in Winter of 2026.
This second book B Is For Bonnet continues the story of four English children who want to live with their Amish grandparents in Ohio.
Their parents are divorced. Their father, Matt was raised Amish and left the community and their mother is English. The grandparents are very surprised that the four grandchildren want to try living Amish. Siblings Beth, Martin, Jonny, and Kelsey have decided they want a simpler life.
This second book centers around Jonny more so than the rest of his siblings. After receiving some bad health news from his doctor, he knows he needs to make changes in his lifestyle so he decides to go and live with his grandparents. He finds a job at a bicycle shop right there in town and works long hours. Jonny eventually starts having feelings for an Amish girl named Treva, who owns and operates her own café and does all her own baking.
Jonny’s father Matt comes back to visit family especially his children. Matt realizes how much better he feels as well while he’s there visiting each time and realizes how much he misses this quiet way of life.
Amish romance is one of my favorite genre. I like the peaceful feel I get when reading these books. This is a very good book. It is also going to be a wonderful series to read.
I would recommend this book.
Thank you, Netgalley and Kensington Publisher for the opportunity to read this ARC e-book and give my honest opinion .
January 26, 2025
I was thrilled that I didn't have to wait long after reading A is for Amish before starting B is for Bonnet. I highly recommend reading the series in order to avoid spoilers.
I am going to dive in by saying I was slightly disappointed that we did not get more of Martin's story in this book. I know the series is not over, but after the last book's ending, I wanted more of his story, LOL! He is in this story, so we learn a bit more, but this story focuses more on Jonny. I was also surprised that it also focused on his dad, Matt.
I liked Jonny and enjoyed getting his story. While he and Treva had an instant attraction, the story was not insta-love, which I appreciate. Their relationship grew throughout the book, and they were so sweet together.
I did not want to like Matt. With this being the second story, it's been pretty clear as to the kids' relationship with their parents. I did not respect him or the decisions that he made. However, he has a true desire to reconcile with his children and regrets his actions. He was a likable character, and I adored Kennedy as well. It did seem as if their relationship evolved fast or had missing pieces.
Overall, I enjoyed the story and the characters. I am sad the book is over and we have to wait so long for Beth's story in C is for Courting, especially with the bomb she dropped on her siblings at the end of the book! I don't know how many books will be in the series, but I am here for them all.
Thank you to the author for the opportunity to read this book. I was not required to provide a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I am going to dive in by saying I was slightly disappointed that we did not get more of Martin's story in this book. I know the series is not over, but after the last book's ending, I wanted more of his story, LOL! He is in this story, so we learn a bit more, but this story focuses more on Jonny. I was also surprised that it also focused on his dad, Matt.
I liked Jonny and enjoyed getting his story. While he and Treva had an instant attraction, the story was not insta-love, which I appreciate. Their relationship grew throughout the book, and they were so sweet together.
I did not want to like Matt. With this being the second story, it's been pretty clear as to the kids' relationship with their parents. I did not respect him or the decisions that he made. However, he has a true desire to reconcile with his children and regrets his actions. He was a likable character, and I adored Kennedy as well. It did seem as if their relationship evolved fast or had missing pieces.
Overall, I enjoyed the story and the characters. I am sad the book is over and we have to wait so long for Beth's story in C is for Courting, especially with the bomb she dropped on her siblings at the end of the book! I don't know how many books will be in the series, but I am here for them all.
Thank you to the author for the opportunity to read this book. I was not required to provide a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
November 23, 2024
Heartfelt
Jonny Schrock has just received some surprising news about his health that has him making some important and life-changing decisions. He is also faced with decisions regarding some of his family relationships. Then, when Treva Kramer becomes an unexpected but welcome inclusion in his life, Jonny's decisions have an even greater impact on him. As the relationship between him and Treva grows, a surprising situation for Treva arises. It has her making some important decisions of her own that will also affect her and Jonny. Along the way, more surprises show up that put some bumps in their growing relationship. But seeing it all play out is a sheer joy to watch.
Jonny and Treva's story is so heartfelt. Its themes of forgiveness, love, faith, family, and second chances flow through this story in a lovely and exceptional way that deeply touched my heart. It is a wonderful story of love that I highly recommend.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy of this book. All comments and opinions are voluntary and completely my own.
Jonny Schrock has just received some surprising news about his health that has him making some important and life-changing decisions. He is also faced with decisions regarding some of his family relationships. Then, when Treva Kramer becomes an unexpected but welcome inclusion in his life, Jonny's decisions have an even greater impact on him. As the relationship between him and Treva grows, a surprising situation for Treva arises. It has her making some important decisions of her own that will also affect her and Jonny. Along the way, more surprises show up that put some bumps in their growing relationship. But seeing it all play out is a sheer joy to watch.
Jonny and Treva's story is so heartfelt. Its themes of forgiveness, love, faith, family, and second chances flow through this story in a lovely and exceptional way that deeply touched my heart. It is a wonderful story of love that I highly recommend.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy of this book. All comments and opinions are voluntary and completely my own.
November 19, 2024
B is For Bonnet is the second book in Shelley Shepard Grey’s series Amish ABCs. I would recommend that you read A is for Amish first because it gives you the foundation for the Schrock children who were raised English but their Dad married and became English.
This second book is about the youngest son Jonny Schrock, who has a health scare sans decided it was time to take his turn at his Amish grandparent’s house to live and decide if he wants to become Amish. He meets Treva Kramer who owns a coffee shop. I am loving this series! As always, Mrs Grey weaves into her stories.. Love, Faith, Forgiveness, Hope and Family!
Thank you Shelley Shepard Grey, NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for this ARC book. This is my honest opinion. This is a must read!
#release date 1/21/2025 #B is for Bonnet #NetGalley
This second book is about the youngest son Jonny Schrock, who has a health scare sans decided it was time to take his turn at his Amish grandparent’s house to live and decide if he wants to become Amish. He meets Treva Kramer who owns a coffee shop. I am loving this series! As always, Mrs Grey weaves into her stories.. Love, Faith, Forgiveness, Hope and Family!
Thank you Shelley Shepard Grey, NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for this ARC book. This is my honest opinion. This is a must read!
#release date 1/21/2025 #B is for Bonnet #NetGalley
November 29, 2024
B Is for Bonnet by Shelley Shepard Gray is a sequel to A Is for Amish telling the saga of the Schrock siblings. As they continue searching their Amish roots, will Jonny stay English or decide to become Amish, as are his paternal grandparents? Can he relinquish his English life and embrace the Amish faith and lifestyle? Will his siblings and parents support him in this decision? Enter Treva. She has been devastated by a previous love. Will she continue to shield her heart, or will she rejoin life and love? B Is for Bonnet is filled with forgiveness, acceptance, and faith.
Releases Jan. 21st. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Releases Jan. 21st. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
September 6, 2024
It was so good to read about the four Schrock siblings. The additional characters of Treva, Kennedy and Matt were a great addition as well. This story centers around Jonny and whether or not he will choose the Amish faith. I loved the element of forgiveness that ran throughout the story
Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the arc. The opinions are my own
Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the arc. The opinions are my own
January 26, 2025
It feels so good to read one of Shelley Shepard Gray’s books. I really enjoyed the imperfect characters and how they navigated through life’s challenges, learning lessons along the way. The setting was fun, a coffee shop and bike shop. I liked that we got to know the dad more. Can’t wait for book#3 in this series.
February 26, 2025
Cute story but there were a couple of story lines that just seemed to disappear. The ex-boyfriend? Kelsey telling dad she was pregnant but no one else? Baby never mentioned. Also time seemed to go by without much development in the love stories and then they all suddenly love each other and get married.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 28, 2025
This is the second book in the series about four siblings, whose grandparents are Amish. They have all decided they want to come to the Amish community and try it out. This book centered around Johnny, who is living with the grandparents and he finds out that he has high cholesterol. He is also managing a bicycle store. He meets a girl and the story is about them. It is also about Johnny’s father who is divorced from his mother and has met a woman. I enjoyed the book very much and I’m looking forward to the third look in the series which will come out in the fall.
March 7, 2025
Confusing while reading
The chapters are about different characters so you can get confused if you don’t pay attention.
I would like the chapter at least be named after the character.
The author forgot a part in the story
There was a “fight “ between treva and jonny on the bike shop the first time she went in but by the next chapter it didn’t say anything about that.
They were fine like nothing happened .
The romance is nonexistent, 3 talks and apparently there’s something going on?
It gets better later in the book
I liked several quotes
I liked the story of jonny and his dad
The chapters are about different characters so you can get confused if you don’t pay attention.
I would like the chapter at least be named after the character.
The author forgot a part in the story
There was a “fight “ between treva and jonny on the bike shop the first time she went in but by the next chapter it didn’t say anything about that.
They were fine like nothing happened .
The romance is nonexistent, 3 talks and apparently there’s something going on?
It gets better later in the book
I liked several quotes
I liked the story of jonny and his dad
October 3, 2024
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book, given to me by Kensington Publishing via Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
A lovely story about straddling two different worlds “B is for Bonnet”, by Shelley Shepard Gray, is also a sweet love story between young and not so young people.
I liked the romance between Jonny and Treva, and Matt and Kennedy. They’re all basically honest with each other and navigate the new relationships with authenticity.
They make balancing two different worlds and lifestyles seem easy enough. I enjoyed the outlook on Amish culture.
I liked the romantic characters and the supporting characters, too. I also liked how well Jonny and Treva fit into their professional occupations, their determination and work ethics.
I was a bit perplexed with some insensitivity in the beginning about Jonny’s health issues and the need to change diet habits.
But overall the goodness and generosity in these characters are heartwarming, although it’s still difficult to understand the Amish lifestyle.
A lovely story about straddling two different worlds “B is for Bonnet”, by Shelley Shepard Gray, is also a sweet love story between young and not so young people.
I liked the romance between Jonny and Treva, and Matt and Kennedy. They’re all basically honest with each other and navigate the new relationships with authenticity.
They make balancing two different worlds and lifestyles seem easy enough. I enjoyed the outlook on Amish culture.
I liked the romantic characters and the supporting characters, too. I also liked how well Jonny and Treva fit into their professional occupations, their determination and work ethics.
I was a bit perplexed with some insensitivity in the beginning about Jonny’s health issues and the need to change diet habits.
But overall the goodness and generosity in these characters are heartwarming, although it’s still difficult to understand the Amish lifestyle.
September 30, 2024
Quick easy read.
I’m enjoying the story line although I feel it is a little sloppy in the storyline.
I still look forward to book three. C is for Courting
Thank you Netgalley for an advanced copy for my honest review.
I’m enjoying the story line although I feel it is a little sloppy in the storyline.
I still look forward to book three. C is for Courting
Thank you Netgalley for an advanced copy for my honest review.
January 22, 2025
This was a little slower for me than the first book. We still don’t know what happens with Martin and Patti. They are just in limbo. I have mixed feelings about conflicts that aren’t being addressed but I know the Amish way is different. I’m too invested to leave it. I plan to read the last one and see. I do love a clean book and no cursing.
June 8, 2025
January 31, 2025
Dangit! I'm even more disappointed than the last book because I actually had expectations going into this one!
When I read A Is for Amish, I wasn't impressed for a variety of reasons. I felt like the romance was off, the characters didn't act in believable ways, and the story itself was just boring. But I liked Jonny (I'm going to call him Johnny). He was upbeat and optimistic, one of my favorite types of characters. And then I cracked open this book and all of it just fell through the floor!
Johnny, despite being portrayed as a happy-go-lucky kind of guy in the first book, was acting really odd in this book. He and Treva seemed to have a love-at-first-sight thing going, but then you get this scene where Johnny is really just being a jerk to her for absolutely no reason:
I liked that the grandparents, Mommi Sylvia and Dawdi Josiah, were more prominent in this book than in the first, but I still couldn't figure Mommi out. Does she just plow through people to get her way because that's just how things have always been, or does she kindly and considerately listen to other people and accommodate them? You'd think that it would be the latter because she not only opens her home to her grandchildren but also to her son who returns, but when Johnny reveals his health issues (by the way—that seemed contrived because it hardly comes up in the story at all) and need for a diet, she completely ignores him and continues serving delicious but not very healthy food because that's just what the Amish eat.
???
Now I've just got to talk about the editing. I don't know whether to fault the editors of this book for not catching all the errors or the author for writing them in the first place, but there were so many things that took me out of the story because they made me stop and think, "Wait... what?" The first error is the four siblings' father's name. In the first book, his name was Mark. Now his name is Matt. Did the author just forget what his name was??
There were a lot of times in the book where it felt like the author had written a scene, removed some of it, and then didn't bother to re-write the rest of it to make it flow seamlessly. Re-read the excerpt from above and notice the goofy transition into Treva saying that the conversation got off-track. Notice how Johnny asked for her opinion, she gave it, and then she's apologizing (in the most stilted, unrealistic dialogue possible!) for her words coming out wrong. As far as I can tell, she gave a perfectly sensible, valid response to his sensible, valid question—yet the conversation is described as seeming to be "going at cross-purposes" (whatever that means). Huh?
At one point in the book, Johnny is having dinner with Mommi and Dawdi, and Patti, Martin, and Kelsey have also come over. In this scene, they're talking about Treva because they think that she and Johnny might be a thing. But later in the book, Johnny stops by Treva's café, and Martin and Patti are there. Johnny says, "It's been too long since our paths crossed. I'm glad to see you, Patti." A little further down the page, Martin says, "I have to be honest. Patti and I were going to surprise you at supper, but then we got to talking to Treva here and discovered that you two know each other."
It's been too long, even though we just saw each other not too long ago, and I just discovered that you guys knew each other even though we talked about it at dinner the other day?
And then there's this line:
The romance between Johnny and Treva felt really awkward. I felt like they had zero chemistry. Like, none. At all. I found Mark ("Matt") and his relationship with Kennedy to be much more believable, their chemistry much stronger. I liked Kennedy. I do have to admit that I was taken aback at the end of the book when it mentions in the very last chapter that she was Mark's "bride of two months." I read that and was like: "THEY GOT MARRIED? Did I miss a chapter??" No proposal? No wedding planning? No breaking the news to the kids who have met this woman once?? And what about Helen, his ex-wife and the mother of his children? Mark had a phone call with her where they talked about Johnny for a bit, then reminisced about their days together when their kids were little. That had me thinking that they might try to get back together again, as unlikely as that seemed. But no... Of course he had to marry Kennedy.
That reminds me of another error. At the end of that call, the text states that Mark was thinking back on his life "fifteen or eighteen years ago" when he'd come home and the kids would plow over him and he'd embrace Helen. Johnny, the youngest, is twenty-two years old, and it's said that Mark and Helen divorced when Johnny was a toddler—I want to say two years old, but I'm not sure. He mentioned never having a memory of when his parents were happy and together. "Fifteen to eighteen years ago" would be when Johnny was four to seven years old. By that point, Mark and Helen were already divorced, so Mark wouldn't be coming home to loud kids and a loving wife.
I wanted to love this book, I really did, but I can't look past its glaring flaws. I will say that it is infinitely better than the monstrosity that is Brave New World (which I am currently required to read for AP Literature). I'd take this book any day of the week over that filth.
A note from June 7, 2025: As a Christian book, I don't think that this should be advertising divorce and remarriage to someone else as a good thing. It's still adultery, and to prop it up in a Christian book rubbed me the wrong way.
Dangit! I'm even more disappointed than the last book because I actually had expectations going into this one!
When I read A Is for Amish, I wasn't impressed for a variety of reasons. I felt like the romance was off, the characters didn't act in believable ways, and the story itself was just boring. But I liked Jonny (I'm going to call him Johnny). He was upbeat and optimistic, one of my favorite types of characters. And then I cracked open this book and all of it just fell through the floor!
Johnny, despite being portrayed as a happy-go-lucky kind of guy in the first book, was acting really odd in this book. He and Treva seemed to have a love-at-first-sight thing going, but then you get this scene where Johnny is really just being a jerk to her for absolutely no reason:
"Well, there's been talk. But not in a bad way."Don't you just love it when the author character-assassinates people to manufacture tension in a story that otherwise would have very little? Johnny has been described as relaxed and easygoing. Him crapping on Treva for literally no reason does not fit his character at all. There was no setup for Johnny acting like this. What the heck?
"Gossip." He frowned. "What do you think about what we're doing?"
"About becoming Amish?" When he nodded, she said, "If you want the truth, I think that it sounds really hard. Deciding to be baptized into the faith isn't an easy decision, even for someone raised in an Amish home."
Yet again, their conversation seemed to be going at cross-purposes. "Johnny, I'm sorry, but once again the words that I say seem to be coming across in ways I never intended. I didn't mean to say that I thought what you were doing was wrong. I only wanted to help."
"How? Do you think that I need more advice about how to be a better Amish person?"
"Of course not."
His sarcastic tone continued. "Or maybe you don't think that my grandparents are good-enough role models?"
He wasn't letting it go—and seemed to be intentionally twisting and turning her words around. It wasn't fair, and he didn't think that it was very nice, either. "I meant nothing of the kind."
"Or what about my new preacher brother-in-law? Is Richard Miller lacking in some way of which you know?"
She stepped backward. It felt as if all of the anger and sarcasm that was shooting out of his mouth was taking a physical form and slicing her skin. Or maybe it was simply her heart? All she did know was that it was time to get away from him. His words were hurting her. "I'm going to leave."
He raised his eyebrows. "What's your hurry? You could probably give me an Amish lesson now. There's no one in the shop."
She was near tears. "You know, Johnny Schrock, you might not need any advice about being Amish, but you sure could use some help when it comes to being a good person. I can't believe that you just attacked me for offering my friendship."
Unbelievably, he acted like she'd just made that up. "That isn't what just happened."
I liked that the grandparents, Mommi Sylvia and Dawdi Josiah, were more prominent in this book than in the first, but I still couldn't figure Mommi out. Does she just plow through people to get her way because that's just how things have always been, or does she kindly and considerately listen to other people and accommodate them? You'd think that it would be the latter because she not only opens her home to her grandchildren but also to her son who returns, but when Johnny reveals his health issues (by the way—that seemed contrived because it hardly comes up in the story at all) and need for a diet, she completely ignores him and continues serving delicious but not very healthy food because that's just what the Amish eat.
???
Now I've just got to talk about the editing. I don't know whether to fault the editors of this book for not catching all the errors or the author for writing them in the first place, but there were so many things that took me out of the story because they made me stop and think, "Wait... what?" The first error is the four siblings' father's name. In the first book, his name was Mark. Now his name is Matt. Did the author just forget what his name was??
There were a lot of times in the book where it felt like the author had written a scene, removed some of it, and then didn't bother to re-write the rest of it to make it flow seamlessly. Re-read the excerpt from above and notice the goofy transition into Treva saying that the conversation got off-track. Notice how Johnny asked for her opinion, she gave it, and then she's apologizing (in the most stilted, unrealistic dialogue possible!) for her words coming out wrong. As far as I can tell, she gave a perfectly sensible, valid response to his sensible, valid question—yet the conversation is described as seeming to be "going at cross-purposes" (whatever that means). Huh?
At one point in the book, Johnny is having dinner with Mommi and Dawdi, and Patti, Martin, and Kelsey have also come over. In this scene, they're talking about Treva because they think that she and Johnny might be a thing. But later in the book, Johnny stops by Treva's café, and Martin and Patti are there. Johnny says, "It's been too long since our paths crossed. I'm glad to see you, Patti." A little further down the page, Martin says, "I have to be honest. Patti and I were going to surprise you at supper, but then we got to talking to Treva here and discovered that you two know each other."
It's been too long, even though we just saw each other not too long ago, and I just discovered that you guys knew each other even though we talked about it at dinner the other day?
And then there's this line:
Why couldn't their father have kept his mouth shut? Immediately, shame coursed through him. That wasn't fair, and it was selfish of him to only be thinking of himself.It's not like "selfish" means to only be thinking of oneself... It's just redundant. That reminds me of another Shelley Shepard Gray book that I started reading where she describes a character who "took care to carefully clear away each stray piece of Spanish moss" off the porch. We can infer that this character took care because she's sweeping carefully.
The romance between Johnny and Treva felt really awkward. I felt like they had zero chemistry. Like, none. At all. I found Mark ("Matt") and his relationship with Kennedy to be much more believable, their chemistry much stronger. I liked Kennedy. I do have to admit that I was taken aback at the end of the book when it mentions in the very last chapter that she was Mark's "bride of two months." I read that and was like: "THEY GOT MARRIED? Did I miss a chapter??" No proposal? No wedding planning? No breaking the news to the kids who have met this woman once?? And what about Helen, his ex-wife and the mother of his children? Mark had a phone call with her where they talked about Johnny for a bit, then reminisced about their days together when their kids were little. That had me thinking that they might try to get back together again, as unlikely as that seemed. But no... Of course he had to marry Kennedy.
That reminds me of another error. At the end of that call, the text states that Mark was thinking back on his life "fifteen or eighteen years ago" when he'd come home and the kids would plow over him and he'd embrace Helen. Johnny, the youngest, is twenty-two years old, and it's said that Mark and Helen divorced when Johnny was a toddler—I want to say two years old, but I'm not sure. He mentioned never having a memory of when his parents were happy and together. "Fifteen to eighteen years ago" would be when Johnny was four to seven years old. By that point, Mark and Helen were already divorced, so Mark wouldn't be coming home to loud kids and a loving wife.
I wanted to love this book, I really did, but I can't look past its glaring flaws. I will say that it is infinitely better than the monstrosity that is Brave New World (which I am currently required to read for AP Literature). I'd take this book any day of the week over that filth.
A note from June 7, 2025: As a Christian book, I don't think that this should be advertising divorce and remarriage to someone else as a good thing. It's still adultery, and to prop it up in a Christian book rubbed me the wrong way.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews