READ
i re-read this recently, but never did a review, nor the first time I finshed it, not the second, I didn't want to... well, din't want to recognise that I read this, stupid I know.
I still don't know how to tackle the review of this book, still don't know if I want to review this as a pastiche or as a movie novelization, because if you have to judge this book as one or the other, the callification differs, and it differ like by a lot.
so after much thining, I decided that I'm going to review this, but not going to give it any kind of goodreads score, but I give it mine in the text, both of them in fact, the pastiche and the movie adaptation.
Let's start with the bad, then with the good.
As a pastiche
score: 1 star
I think that the reason why is aone star is very much self explanatory.
The prose and the content.
But is a book for children... Sorry, that escuse isn't valid here, the original book is a book writen for children too, so if a child cannot understand the original, I think that you should start asking yourself what your kid is learning in school, maybe you shouldn't let him rot in fron of the TV or with a mobile phone.
The original don't treat them like they were retarded, have excellent prose and very powerful themes and messages that are mostly skipped in this one, also as a retelling is a very bad one, skipping most of the content and the original content that it adds in exchange isn't good or enough to fill the page count makign it like is filled with air.
As anovelization of the Disney Remake of 2016
score: 3 stars
As anovelization is a very solid one, though it a bit on the mid side by itself considering it like it's competition is... well...
As a novelization of the movie is very good, it could have been beter if it did like most novelization usually do like put it stuff from previous version of the draft or cut stuff of the current draft that didn't make into the final movie like cutted or extended scenes.
But it is like it is, it could have been better, sadly it isn't.