This is book three-of-five of the Lighthouse Lovers series and the most important thing I can say is read these books in order! It is a really clever approach to a big story, broken down into five interconnecting pieces. The downside is that I don’t think you can get full and proper enjoyment from these novels unless you have all of them to read, all together.
My Rating: "C+"
GoodReads: 3-stars
I liked this novel, and this series so far. This entry tackled some heavier and more serious topics and did so very well. The protagonists were cute together and I liked their overall dynamic. I have been waiting for these two since the first novel and am glad that we got to them! This novel/series isn’t my favorite thing I have read (you can tell by the rating) however at the same time I will 100% be reading the next two novels so that is certainly an endorsement there. These novels are entertaining, and I want to know what else happens next!
Highlights:
-The protagonists, particularly Gemma, were very supportive and sweet with each other. I liked their relationship, particularly the beginning stages. Reading buddies for the win!
-This novel handled a certain character’s sexuality and journey of self-discovery very well. It read as genuine, and it was written with sensitivity. I think this part of the novel was some great representation all-around.
-Plenty of good emotions here. Happy-to-sad, everything was represented, and this novel certainly wasn’t one-note.
-Great handling of grief and addressing the dynamic of moving on with new relationships in the wake of the death of a spouse. This entire topic was handled very well, and with a great amount of sensitivity. I hate it when “getting over them” is put forward as the correct and proper main goal.
Nitpicks:
-This novel is obviously part of a series (which I have read) but it doesn’t sufficiently stand on its own. Maybe this is just my opinion, but you should be able to read each novel in a series on their own without feeling too lost or confused. I found that this novel wouldn’t work without not only reading the prior two, but having them fresh in your mind (not just the general idea). There were a lot of references to scenes that didn’t take place in this novel that left me confused because I didn’t remember exactly what happened, and the timelines of each novel don’t align very easily either. For example, in one of the other ones there was the bachelorette party that seemed to pup up out of nowhere, and in this one they discussed planning it but we never got to see it (because we already did I guess?). It feels disjointed. Some characters also pop up from the other novels without being introduced in this one, once again leaving me confused as to who they are and how they fit into the story. I am loving the overall series but disliking the fragmented way that I am reading it. This would work better if it was a giant franken-novel, but I realize that isn’t practical.
-Piggybacking off the above point: I like how this is one big story broken down into five novels that are all interconnected, but something about the execution is hitting me the wrong way. I read these first three novels very close together, yet I am still having a lot of trouble keeping the timelines straight; who knows what, what has taken place at any given time from the other novels, etc. At times I was annoyed that characters didn’t know things which I have already seen them learn in the other novels. Each novel also seems to end at a somewhat random point. For this novel it didn’t seem to be a good ending point for the overall plot (because we are not at the end obviously) but also for this novels sub-plot (I assume we will see more of them in future novels). The author might as well have ended with “To Be Continued” because there wasn’t really an ending here.
-The writing just didn’t quite do it for me. I like the plot, and lots of scenes were delightful, but there was also a lot of telling-not-showing or very plain descriptions of characters going through the mundane motions of their days (that didn’t contribute to the story or do much else in my opinion).
Nitpicks (that didn’t affect my rating at all, especially as this is an ARC that is subject to change):
-Ok, so it might just be me, but I have never seen a spicy scene describe things as sounding like “stirring mac n cheese”. I have heard teenage boys say this, but never read it like this. Took me right out of that scene!
-Switched narrator POV halfway through the final chapter without warning. This was so jarring it was funny. I assume it will be fixed for the final novel.
-Various errors, like in one scene a physical book turns into a kindle in the next paragraph. Once again, I assume this will be fixed.
-I feel extra nitpicky here and depending on the next novels I might have to revise this, but that extra bonus scene that you only get by signing up for a newsletter was far to important to leave out of the main novel. The idea that someone with a physical copy wouldn’t get to see that epilogue is wild.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.