What do you think?
Rate this book
Detective Karen Hart #10
In Plain Sight
A medieval torture device. An archaeological dig. Can DS Karen Hart unearth the truth?
In the dead of night, four teenagers taking a shortcut through an archaeological dig site find a woman’s lifeless body in a muddy trench, her hands and neck locked in a medieval device known as a Shrew’s Fiddle. It doesn’t take long to see that these are no ancient the woman was killed just hours earlier.
Called in to unearth the truth, DS Karen Hart learns that the victim, local woman Alison Poulson, was unpopular with the archaeologists and the TV crew filming the excavation. Digging further, she finds bitter colleagues, an angry farmer and an oddly unmoved husband. Then there’s the teenage girl who found the body, who seems to know more than she’s letting on…
After a second murder rocks the investigation, it seems the killer will stop at nothing to cover their tracks. Can Karen unravel the mystery before another life is lost?
In the dead of night, four teenagers taking a shortcut through an archaeological dig site find a woman’s lifeless body in a muddy trench, her hands and neck locked in a medieval device known as a Shrew’s Fiddle. It doesn’t take long to see that these are no ancient the woman was killed just hours earlier.
Called in to unearth the truth, DS Karen Hart learns that the victim, local woman Alison Poulson, was unpopular with the archaeologists and the TV crew filming the excavation. Digging further, she finds bitter colleagues, an angry farmer and an oddly unmoved husband. Then there’s the teenage girl who found the body, who seems to know more than she’s letting on…
After a second murder rocks the investigation, it seems the killer will stop at nothing to cover their tracks. Can Karen unravel the mystery before another life is lost?
360 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 21, 2025
916 people are currently reading
3299 people want to read
About the author
D.S. Butler
35 books898 followersAuthor of the Karen Hart series. Ex-biochemist turned crime-writer. Huge Queen fan. Loves to read crime fiction.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 100 reviews
November 14, 2024
In Plain Sight (Detective Karen Hart Book 10) by D.S. Butler
Synopsis /
In the dead of night, four teenagers taking a shortcut through an archaeological dig site find a woman’s lifeless body in a muddy trench, her hands and neck locked in a medieval device known as a Shrew’s Fiddle. It doesn’t take long to see that these are no ancient the woman was killed just hours earlier.
Called in to unearth the truth, DS Karen Hart learns that the victim, local woman Alison Poulson, was unpopular with the archaeologists and the TV crew filming the excavation. Digging further, she finds bitter colleagues, an angry farmer and an oddly unmoved husband. Then there’s the teenage girl who found the body, who seems to know more than she’s letting on…
After a second murder rocks the investigation, it seems the killer will stop at nothing to cover their tracks. Can Karen unravel the mystery before another life is lost?
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Thomas & Mercer Publishing, and author D.S. Butler, for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review. Publication date is currently set for January 21, 2025.
A medieval torture device. An archaeological dig. Can DS Karen Hart unearth the truth?
If the above tantalizing little titbit doesn’t awaken your literary senses, I don’t know what will.
It’s certainly shocked seasoned detective, DS Karen Hart and her team of investigators.
When the story opens, it’s the middle of the night, and a group of teenagers are walking home after a night out. When one of the group suggests taking a short-cut home by cutting through a neighbouring farmer’s field, the others follow along – thinking that they’ll save precious time – little do they know their night is about to change for the worse.
Bumbling along in the dark, one of the boys stumbles and falls into a trench which had been dug in the field. Stunned, but mostly unharmed, the boy looks around at the trench he’s fallen into trying to figure out how he’s going to climb out. That’s when he sees it. The body of a woman lying in the same trench, not far from where he’s sitting. Her head and arms are encased in some sort of trap device and her face has contorted into an agonising and painful expression. And she’s very definitely dead.
Detective Sergeant Karen Hart and her team are called to investigate. At the site, the team learn that the trench had been dug as part of an archaeological dig for a television show called Britain’s Biggest Treasure Hunt, a highly popular TV program about discovering ancient Roman remains hidden in the U.K. Hart quickly learns that the victim, Alison Poulson, was linked to the show and was not well liked by the rest of the show’s cast. From the outset the scales of justice weighed heavily with suspects and light on clues.
Yes, there were still challenges ahead; names like Rothwell and Chapman loomed large in their caseloads. But together the team navigated successes and setbacks and supported one another when cases took their toll.
In Plain Sight might be the tenth book in the series, but you can easily read this as a standalone – which is a tribute to D.S. Butler’s writing skills.
Crime Solving Stars:
🌟A refreshing take on the crime genre.
🌟A complex and well-paced tale with layers and twists that will keep you engaged.
🌟If you don’t mind the macabre, there are some shocking and disturbing scenes as the plot unfolds.
🌟The ending contains a surprise that caught me off-guard.
🌟Well developed characters.
🌟An excellent police procedural investigation (which focuses on the use of procedure and its team of officers).
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to publishers Thomas & Mercer for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for January 21, 2025.
Synopsis /
In the dead of night, four teenagers taking a shortcut through an archaeological dig site find a woman’s lifeless body in a muddy trench, her hands and neck locked in a medieval device known as a Shrew’s Fiddle. It doesn’t take long to see that these are no ancient the woman was killed just hours earlier.
Called in to unearth the truth, DS Karen Hart learns that the victim, local woman Alison Poulson, was unpopular with the archaeologists and the TV crew filming the excavation. Digging further, she finds bitter colleagues, an angry farmer and an oddly unmoved husband. Then there’s the teenage girl who found the body, who seems to know more than she’s letting on…
After a second murder rocks the investigation, it seems the killer will stop at nothing to cover their tracks. Can Karen unravel the mystery before another life is lost?
My Thoughts /
First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Thomas & Mercer Publishing, and author D.S. Butler, for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review. Publication date is currently set for January 21, 2025.
A medieval torture device. An archaeological dig. Can DS Karen Hart unearth the truth?
If the above tantalizing little titbit doesn’t awaken your literary senses, I don’t know what will.
It’s certainly shocked seasoned detective, DS Karen Hart and her team of investigators.
When the story opens, it’s the middle of the night, and a group of teenagers are walking home after a night out. When one of the group suggests taking a short-cut home by cutting through a neighbouring farmer’s field, the others follow along – thinking that they’ll save precious time – little do they know their night is about to change for the worse.
Bumbling along in the dark, one of the boys stumbles and falls into a trench which had been dug in the field. Stunned, but mostly unharmed, the boy looks around at the trench he’s fallen into trying to figure out how he’s going to climb out. That’s when he sees it. The body of a woman lying in the same trench, not far from where he’s sitting. Her head and arms are encased in some sort of trap device and her face has contorted into an agonising and painful expression. And she’s very definitely dead.
Detective Sergeant Karen Hart and her team are called to investigate. At the site, the team learn that the trench had been dug as part of an archaeological dig for a television show called Britain’s Biggest Treasure Hunt, a highly popular TV program about discovering ancient Roman remains hidden in the U.K. Hart quickly learns that the victim, Alison Poulson, was linked to the show and was not well liked by the rest of the show’s cast. From the outset the scales of justice weighed heavily with suspects and light on clues.
Yes, there were still challenges ahead; names like Rothwell and Chapman loomed large in their caseloads. But together the team navigated successes and setbacks and supported one another when cases took their toll.
In Plain Sight might be the tenth book in the series, but you can easily read this as a standalone – which is a tribute to D.S. Butler’s writing skills.
Crime Solving Stars:
🌟A refreshing take on the crime genre.
🌟A complex and well-paced tale with layers and twists that will keep you engaged.
🌟If you don’t mind the macabre, there are some shocking and disturbing scenes as the plot unfolds.
🌟The ending contains a surprise that caught me off-guard.
🌟Well developed characters.
🌟An excellent police procedural investigation (which focuses on the use of procedure and its team of officers).
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to publishers Thomas & Mercer for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for January 21, 2025.
November 2, 2024
This is the tenth in the DS Karen Hart series; it is the sixth I have read. It works well as a standalone.
Teenagers cutting through an archeological dig discover a grisly sight. A dead woman is at the bottom of a pit, with a medieval torture device called a Shrew’s Fiddle attached to her.As DS Karen Hart and her team investigate the limited clues and numerous suspects, a second brutal death occurs.
This is a fast paced, well written mystery. I enjoy the main character, as well as her supporting team. Karen is engaging, capable, empathetic, and doesn’t suffer fools gladly. She also displays a good sense of humor.
Fans of British police procedurals will enjoy this story, along with others in the series.
Thanks to #NetGalley and @amazonpublishing #ThomasandMercer for the DRC.
Teenagers cutting through an archeological dig discover a grisly sight. A dead woman is at the bottom of a pit, with a medieval torture device called a Shrew’s Fiddle attached to her.As DS Karen Hart and her team investigate the limited clues and numerous suspects, a second brutal death occurs.
This is a fast paced, well written mystery. I enjoy the main character, as well as her supporting team. Karen is engaging, capable, empathetic, and doesn’t suffer fools gladly. She also displays a good sense of humor.
Fans of British police procedurals will enjoy this story, along with others in the series.
Thanks to #NetGalley and @amazonpublishing #ThomasandMercer for the DRC.
September 7, 2025
Lat one (?) in the series: good murder story with excellent characters who started in Book 1. Brilliant series that returned to its roots for this one. Recommended
January 17, 2025
In Plain Sight by D.S. Butler is the 10th in the Detective Karen Hart series.
First, let me thank NetGalley, the publisher Thomas & Mercer, and of course the author, for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Series Background: (Warning – May contain spoilers from previous books)
DS Karen Hart lost her husband Josh and her daughter Tilly in a car accident. She later discovered it wasn't an accident, but it was covered up by some corrupt police officials. She currently works with DI Scott Morgan, DS Arnie Hodgson, DC Sophie Jones, and DC Rick Cooper. Their boss is DCI Churchill. She is dating Mike, who has also lost a child.
My Synopsis: (No major reveals, but if concerned, skip to My Opinions)
Karen is called to an archaeological dig site when four teens discover the dead body of a woman in a trench. Her neck and hands are locked into a medieval torture device called a Shrew's Fiddle.
It soon becomes evident that the victim, Alison Poulson, was not popular with either the archaeologists nor the film crew that were planning on documenting the finds. Not even her husband seemed that concerned.
Everyone seems to be hiding something, and the team does not solve the first murder, before someone else dies. Will they be in time to prevent a third death?
My Opinions:
This was a complex, interesting mystery. The plot was quite good. I did identify the killer early on, but the motive escaped me.
The characters had depth, and as always, Karen and the team were good. It was interesting to see Arnie in a different light.
My only complaint was the depiction of the Shrew's Fiddle. I had to google it, and upon researching it further, I was at odds with the author's descriptions. Yes, it would be horrendous if someone was in it for any length of time, but I can't see that it would lead you to being hunched over, thereby straining your neck and back. You could easily sit down with it on. If you found someplace to rest your elbows, it wouldn't be a big deal at all. It was mainly used as a punishment for people (often women) who were fighting, and each would have one put on, and be forced to look at each other and talk it through. It was also used to embarrass or mock someone in public. So, although this medieval device looks frightening, there were much worse instruments for torture.
That being said, it did segue well into one of the main topics of the story, misogyny. So, perhaps I'm being a little picky on the choice of a torture device.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book. It's a great addition to the series, and as always, a fast read.
For a more complete review of this book and others (including the reason I chose to read/review this book, as well as author information), please visit my blog: http://katlovesbooksblog.wordpress.com/
November 20, 2025
I love this series for the sole reason that it’s set in the same area that my grandparents lived lol is the series actually any good? Idk x
March 7, 2025
Brilliant series can't wait for the 11th book
November 7, 2024
A woman’s body is found in an archeological dig site, but this is no ancient burial. The victim was recently killed and her body was encased in a Shrew’s Fiddle. You will not forget its name because it’s brought up incessantly throughout the story. It’s described as this horrific, misogynistic ancient device but when I looked it up, it wasn’t even that bad! It’s not meant to kill you or even torture you, it’s a shaming device for being a nag or a shrew hundreds of years ago. Sure, it’s uncomfortable, but the description kept stating that it tightly bends the person’s neck at an unnatural angle and the thing is, it does not. A person can stand up perfectly straight in one, with their hands each having their own hole, one in front of the other. So once your arms get tired, then yes, you would be bent over, but there’s a clear difference between immediate suffering and eventual soreness.
And guess what? Nothing keeps the person standing, they can sit or lay down to alleviate the strain on their muscles. That’s a big issue I had with the story – the author tries too hard to make this an anti-woman death device. It’s an obnoxious mechanism, but I’d choose it over thumbscrews or an iron maiden any day. If you’re going to use an actual historical device, don’t exaggerate it as a horrendous torture tool akin to the rack when anyone can research it and see that it isn’t. Emphasize the degradation of women in general – that’s something that is and always has been true.
So, because the dig site was part of a reality archeology TV show there are plenty of suspects, and DS Karen Hart has to work with her team to stop the killer before more people suffer. Was it one of the crew? The local council? The experts brought in from the university? Or a family member or friend completely unrelated to the dig? You’ll have to read and find out. Just know there is a lot of unnecessary repetition, maybe to stretch out the length? Phrases and thoughts expressed multiple times by the same characters, enough that it stood out while reading. Whittling that down would help the flow of the story. Which I’m surprised wasn’t called The Shrew’s Fiddle.
And guess what? Nothing keeps the person standing, they can sit or lay down to alleviate the strain on their muscles. That’s a big issue I had with the story – the author tries too hard to make this an anti-woman death device. It’s an obnoxious mechanism, but I’d choose it over thumbscrews or an iron maiden any day. If you’re going to use an actual historical device, don’t exaggerate it as a horrendous torture tool akin to the rack when anyone can research it and see that it isn’t. Emphasize the degradation of women in general – that’s something that is and always has been true.
So, because the dig site was part of a reality archeology TV show there are plenty of suspects, and DS Karen Hart has to work with her team to stop the killer before more people suffer. Was it one of the crew? The local council? The experts brought in from the university? Or a family member or friend completely unrelated to the dig? You’ll have to read and find out. Just know there is a lot of unnecessary repetition, maybe to stretch out the length? Phrases and thoughts expressed multiple times by the same characters, enough that it stood out while reading. Whittling that down would help the flow of the story. Which I’m surprised wasn’t called The Shrew’s Fiddle.
January 19, 2025
In Plain Sight by D.S Butler is the 10th book in the Detective Karen Hart series. This can be read as a standalone but to get the full backstory on the protagonist you should read the rest of the books first.
Four teenagers cutting through an archaeological dig site discover the body of a woman. But this is no ancient burial, this kill is fresh. The woman is encased in a contraption called a Shrew's Fiddle. This is described as an ancient device that bends the wearer's neck in an unnatural angle, eventually leading to death. When a second body is discovered, Detective Hart must race to piece together the evidence to find this deadly serial killer before another victim is claimed.
Having not heard of the Shrew's Fiddle I did look it up and it seems that it is dramatized in the story probably for better shock value. It seems like this device is uncomfortable yes, but not immediately deadly. Other than that aspect I did enjoy this book on the whole as a crime fiction novel. I probably should have read books one through nine in preparation but that's just my personal choice.
Thank you to NetGalley, D.S Butler, and Thomas & Mercer for this ARC. Expected release day is January 21st 2025.
Four teenagers cutting through an archaeological dig site discover the body of a woman. But this is no ancient burial, this kill is fresh. The woman is encased in a contraption called a Shrew's Fiddle. This is described as an ancient device that bends the wearer's neck in an unnatural angle, eventually leading to death. When a second body is discovered, Detective Hart must race to piece together the evidence to find this deadly serial killer before another victim is claimed.
Having not heard of the Shrew's Fiddle I did look it up and it seems that it is dramatized in the story probably for better shock value. It seems like this device is uncomfortable yes, but not immediately deadly. Other than that aspect I did enjoy this book on the whole as a crime fiction novel. I probably should have read books one through nine in preparation but that's just my personal choice.
Thank you to NetGalley, D.S Butler, and Thomas & Mercer for this ARC. Expected release day is January 21st 2025.
January 6, 2025
4.5 stars
Teenagers discover a body at the site of an archeological dig. The victim had been tortured as well, but she is NOT an ancient Roman. Now it's up to Karen Hart and her team of detectives to find this dangerous killer. This is an engaging series with likable main characters, and this book in particular is fast-paced and suspenseful. This is the tenth book in the Detective Karen Hart series. I've read all of the prior books, but I really think this one also works well as a standalone mystery/thriller. Karen works well with her team and has learned to balance her job with her family life, which hasn't always been easy for her. The killer is very creepy and the mood is tense while the team tries to narrow down the suspects. The case has a satisfying resolution, and the overall ending of the book is fantastic. I highly recommend this book and the series.
I received an advance copy of this ebook for review consideration from NetGalley and Thomas and Mercer. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
Teenagers discover a body at the site of an archeological dig. The victim had been tortured as well, but she is NOT an ancient Roman. Now it's up to Karen Hart and her team of detectives to find this dangerous killer. This is an engaging series with likable main characters, and this book in particular is fast-paced and suspenseful. This is the tenth book in the Detective Karen Hart series. I've read all of the prior books, but I really think this one also works well as a standalone mystery/thriller. Karen works well with her team and has learned to balance her job with her family life, which hasn't always been easy for her. The killer is very creepy and the mood is tense while the team tries to narrow down the suspects. The case has a satisfying resolution, and the overall ending of the book is fantastic. I highly recommend this book and the series.
I received an advance copy of this ebook for review consideration from NetGalley and Thomas and Mercer. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
November 8, 2024
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my copy of this book.
A group of teenagers find a body in a dug trench resulting in Detective Karen Hart and her team being called in. With an old fashioned torture device being around the victim’s neck, a link to a tv show investigating buried treasure is quickly found. The victim wasn’t well liked and suspects are plentiful.
This was another great addition to this series. I enjoyed historical references, as well as the chance for other characters to be explored and find relationships. I enjoyed seeing thought processes through Karen’s eyes, especially that light bulb moment when she knew exactly who the killer was. One of the best bits about the book was that all the loose ends are eventually tied up! An enjoyable read and highly recommend.
A group of teenagers find a body in a dug trench resulting in Detective Karen Hart and her team being called in. With an old fashioned torture device being around the victim’s neck, a link to a tv show investigating buried treasure is quickly found. The victim wasn’t well liked and suspects are plentiful.
This was another great addition to this series. I enjoyed historical references, as well as the chance for other characters to be explored and find relationships. I enjoyed seeing thought processes through Karen’s eyes, especially that light bulb moment when she knew exactly who the killer was. One of the best bits about the book was that all the loose ends are eventually tied up! An enjoyable read and highly recommend.
March 9, 2025
Brilliant crime thriller
I love the Karen Hart series. I love all the characters. I enjoyed this book from beginning to end. It's so funny in parts of the book, too. Can't wait to read next in the series.
I love the Karen Hart series. I love all the characters. I enjoyed this book from beginning to end. It's so funny in parts of the book, too. Can't wait to read next in the series.
June 9, 2025
This is the first book that I have read in the series. Good story, moving at a steady pace. There are some references to earlier books but not so many that I felt lost. If you like Peter Robinson's stories, I think you will enjoy this book.
February 8, 2025
Really good gripping book.I hope DS Butler will be writing more.
September 22, 2025
KEEPS the quality of the previous 9 books. If you liked the other books you'll enjoy this one. Definitely not a book to miss!!
March 1, 2025
Outstanding
What can I say about this book to give it the praise it deserves.
Great writing and great story. I can say no more. Loved it.from page.one and to meet once again of Karen's team.. Thank you
D.S Butler.
What can I say about this book to give it the praise it deserves.
Great writing and great story. I can say no more. Loved it.from page.one and to meet once again of Karen's team.. Thank you
D.S Butler.
March 19, 2025
Detective Karen Hart and the team are horrified by the possibility of their latest murder being the work of a serial killer, but there's no doubt the circumstances of death were caused by only the most twisted and cruelest of criminal minds.
This was fantastic - although definitely disturbing. It was rather dark at some points, especially with the focus on torture and torture devices (also I'm sure google has point me and Tim on some sort of list now - although reading through the reviews - me, Tim and everyone else). But it was balanced with some good old fashioned lighthearted team moments, humorous bantering and DCI Churchill trying to get on television. Plus Tim (the SOCO) makes some amusing appearances and finds himself on the wrong side of the team. He should really invited to the after dinner drinks.
I really liked the investigation characters too. Christie was great and I would've been interested in seeing more of her thoughts and feelings. I loved her bravery in staying with her injured friend, Mason and the body. It was nice of her to see that he was terrified and stick around even though she was terrified too. I mean I also got why the others had to go call it in but good on her for volunteering.
I also loved Sylvie. Her flirting with Arnie was adorable and I loved his shy awkward reaction to it. I got why Karen said something about making him uncomfortable but she could've been a lot gentler in her approach. But it was good of her to stick up for him. I really like Arnie. He was such a sweetie to Sophie when she was struggling with coming back to work. We still don't really know a lot about Arnie so I liked the small insight into his past. I definitely want to see more romance between Arnie and Sylvie in future books. Since I'm speaking of romance, I like Mike. I am a bit annoyed that the continued mystery about his dad hasn't been cleared up or progressed any further though. The constant back and forth is just irritating. Still, it's a minor annoyance.
What I definitely didn't like was the supposed link between this crime and Quentin Chapman (who was the villain in the last few books). There's more than one criminal in the world. Was it really necessary to have a tenuous link to him? Again? Just felt ridiculous. I can only guess that the whole thing is being set up for future books. I liked Chapman, I don't really see why he had to be brought into it. But that's a problem down the line.
As for this mystery, I was hooked. I was flying through pages trying to peg who the criminal was. I was annoyed to find my clever theory was completely wrong. I thought I was so smart. Especially since I went back to double check Still even without guessing right, I enjoyed the fast paced crime thriller and look forward to future books in the series. 4.5 stars, rounded to 5 stars.
This was fantastic - although definitely disturbing. It was rather dark at some points, especially with the focus on torture and torture devices (also I'm sure google has point me and Tim on some sort of list now - although reading through the reviews - me, Tim and everyone else). But it was balanced with some good old fashioned lighthearted team moments, humorous bantering and DCI Churchill trying to get on television. Plus Tim (the SOCO) makes some amusing appearances and finds himself on the wrong side of the team. He should really invited to the after dinner drinks.
I really liked the investigation characters too. Christie was great and I would've been interested in seeing more of her thoughts and feelings. I loved her bravery in staying with her injured friend, Mason and the body. It was nice of her to see that he was terrified and stick around even though she was terrified too. I mean I also got why the others had to go call it in but good on her for volunteering.
I also loved Sylvie. Her flirting with Arnie was adorable and I loved his shy awkward reaction to it. I got why Karen said something about making him uncomfortable but she could've been a lot gentler in her approach. But it was good of her to stick up for him. I really like Arnie. He was such a sweetie to Sophie when she was struggling with coming back to work. We still don't really know a lot about Arnie so I liked the small insight into his past. I definitely want to see more romance between Arnie and Sylvie in future books. Since I'm speaking of romance, I like Mike. I am a bit annoyed that the continued mystery about his dad hasn't been cleared up or progressed any further though. The constant back and forth is just irritating. Still, it's a minor annoyance.
What I definitely didn't like was the supposed link between this crime and Quentin Chapman (who was the villain in the last few books). There's more than one criminal in the world. Was it really necessary to have a tenuous link to him? Again? Just felt ridiculous. I can only guess that the whole thing is being set up for future books. I liked Chapman, I don't really see why he had to be brought into it. But that's a problem down the line.
As for this mystery, I was hooked. I was flying through pages trying to peg who the criminal was. I was annoyed to find my clever theory was completely wrong. I thought I was so smart. Especially since I went back to double check Still even without guessing right, I enjoyed the fast paced crime thriller and look forward to future books in the series. 4.5 stars, rounded to 5 stars.
June 1, 2025
*In Plain Sight* by D. S. Butler is a compelling addition to the DS Karen Hart series. This installment delivers a well-crafted police procedural with a strong female lead, clever plotting, and just enough twists to keep you turning the pages late into the night.
The story kicks off with the discovery of a body in a quiet village—nothing is ever as peaceful as it seems—and from there, the investigation dives deep into a community full of secrets. DS Karen Hart is, as always, sharp and determined, balancing her personal challenges with her professional duties. The dynamics between her and DI Scott Morgan add a layer of tension and complexity that really enriches the story.
What I appreciate most about Butler’s writing is the way she keeps the pace moving without sacrificing character development. The mystery unfolds methodically, and while seasoned crime readers might guess a few turns ahead, there are still plenty of satisfying reveals.
My only minor gripe is that some secondary characters could have been fleshed out a bit more. Still, the tight plotting and strong lead make this a standout in the series.
If you enjoy British crime fiction with a strong female detective and plenty of suspense, *In Plain Sight* is well worth a read.
The story kicks off with the discovery of a body in a quiet village—nothing is ever as peaceful as it seems—and from there, the investigation dives deep into a community full of secrets. DS Karen Hart is, as always, sharp and determined, balancing her personal challenges with her professional duties. The dynamics between her and DI Scott Morgan add a layer of tension and complexity that really enriches the story.
What I appreciate most about Butler’s writing is the way she keeps the pace moving without sacrificing character development. The mystery unfolds methodically, and while seasoned crime readers might guess a few turns ahead, there are still plenty of satisfying reveals.
My only minor gripe is that some secondary characters could have been fleshed out a bit more. Still, the tight plotting and strong lead make this a standout in the series.
If you enjoy British crime fiction with a strong female detective and plenty of suspense, *In Plain Sight* is well worth a read.
May 31, 2025
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this eARC.
"In Plain Sight" by D. S. Butler is a gripping crime thriller that expertly balances suspense, meticulous investigation, and deeply developed character.
At its heart, the novel delivers an absorbing mystery, pulling the reader into a world where every detail matters. The protagonist, a sharp and determined detective, navigates a labyrinth of clues, misdirection, and unexpected revelations. Butler’s ability to weave tension through seemingly ordinary interactions is a standout feature—there’s a sense that danger and deception are lurking just beneath the surface.
The pacing is finely tuned, never rushing through the unraveling of the case but maintaining a steady build toward an impactful climax. The dialogue is crisp and purposeful, avoiding unnecessary exposition while revealing layers of personality and conflict. The investigative process feels authentic, showcasing both the frustrations and triumphs of detective work.
Beyond the central mystery, Butler crafts an engaging emotional landscape, where relationships—whether strained, professional, or deeply personal—add weight to the unfolding drama. The setting, vividly drawn without excessive description, enhances the atmosphere, making readers feel as though they are shadowing the detective’s every move.
For fans of methodical crime fiction, "In Plain Sight" delivers an experience that is both immersive and thought-provoking. It is a novel that rewards keen observation and critical thinking, offering twists that feel earned rather than forced. Whether you’re drawn to procedural precision or unpredictable storytelling, this book makes a strong case for staying vigilant—because the truth might be hiding in plain sight.
"In Plain Sight" by D. S. Butler is a gripping crime thriller that expertly balances suspense, meticulous investigation, and deeply developed character.
At its heart, the novel delivers an absorbing mystery, pulling the reader into a world where every detail matters. The protagonist, a sharp and determined detective, navigates a labyrinth of clues, misdirection, and unexpected revelations. Butler’s ability to weave tension through seemingly ordinary interactions is a standout feature—there’s a sense that danger and deception are lurking just beneath the surface.
The pacing is finely tuned, never rushing through the unraveling of the case but maintaining a steady build toward an impactful climax. The dialogue is crisp and purposeful, avoiding unnecessary exposition while revealing layers of personality and conflict. The investigative process feels authentic, showcasing both the frustrations and triumphs of detective work.
Beyond the central mystery, Butler crafts an engaging emotional landscape, where relationships—whether strained, professional, or deeply personal—add weight to the unfolding drama. The setting, vividly drawn without excessive description, enhances the atmosphere, making readers feel as though they are shadowing the detective’s every move.
For fans of methodical crime fiction, "In Plain Sight" delivers an experience that is both immersive and thought-provoking. It is a novel that rewards keen observation and critical thinking, offering twists that feel earned rather than forced. Whether you’re drawn to procedural precision or unpredictable storytelling, this book makes a strong case for staying vigilant—because the truth might be hiding in plain sight.
February 4, 2025
Nobody deserves the brutality of mediaeval torture served out to hapless victims for the pleasure of a narcissistic psychopath. What an appalling way to die. It’s a harrowing discovery that starts the plot. A dead girl encased in a brutal mediaeval contraption, a shrew’s fiddle. It is excruciatingly painful and employed for control and misogynistic intent, but it didn’t kill her. There is a significant blow to the head that killed her to ensure his identity was unknown.
The author writes with captivating panache. She weaves a macabre but unusual, gripping tale for DS Karen’s congenial team to solve in the face of gruesome finds at an archaeological site. The team has a great rapport and is likeable with their idiosyncracies, humour, backgrounds, and flaws. You feel as if you know them. Sophie would make an excellent Profiler, and DS Karen Hart is on the same page. The author doesn’t waste time on lengthy descriptions and screeds of introspection. She moves seamlessly through the plot at a commendable pace in my favourite third-person chronological format. This gives scope to learn what other characters think, act or have suffered. There’s an excellent balance between narrative and dialogue, which provides depth and complements its authenticity. It’s a predictable story, but it doesn’t lose its fascination. Motive? Why is Christie so unnerved? Who can be trusted? Who is lying? How will the team resolve the crimes?
Thank you to Thomas & Mercer and NetGalley.
The author writes with captivating panache. She weaves a macabre but unusual, gripping tale for DS Karen’s congenial team to solve in the face of gruesome finds at an archaeological site. The team has a great rapport and is likeable with their idiosyncracies, humour, backgrounds, and flaws. You feel as if you know them. Sophie would make an excellent Profiler, and DS Karen Hart is on the same page. The author doesn’t waste time on lengthy descriptions and screeds of introspection. She moves seamlessly through the plot at a commendable pace in my favourite third-person chronological format. This gives scope to learn what other characters think, act or have suffered. There’s an excellent balance between narrative and dialogue, which provides depth and complements its authenticity. It’s a predictable story, but it doesn’t lose its fascination. Motive? Why is Christie so unnerved? Who can be trusted? Who is lying? How will the team resolve the crimes?
Thank you to Thomas & Mercer and NetGalley.
January 3, 2025
In Plain Sight
D.S. Butler
January 21, 2025
The four teens who were riding the bus home were breaking rules that irritated the driver. It was close to midnight and although Christieś new friends collaborated in violating the directives posted on entrance to the vehicle, she tried to join. When the driver pulled over he told the students to get off the bus. Phones didn't respond, so the group started walking the long path through the field. Although the guys ran ahead in glee, the girls hoped they would make it home.
Thus begins the very unique suspense-filled tale of Detective Karen Hart´s latest tale in book #10 of D.S. Butlerś series. In Plain Sight will be published by Thomas & Mercer on January 21, 2025. I was honored to be selected to read the ARC of Butler´s latest novel via NetGalley. This latest Detective Karen Hart investigation of a tale into the pre-production of a British Historical Treasure TV series. Itś extremely well written in details that keep the reader on edge. Who did this - and how did it happen? I have become a true fan of D.S. Butlerś books working on reading the other 6 books in the series. This latest is one suspense-readers should not miss!
D.S. Butler
January 21, 2025
The four teens who were riding the bus home were breaking rules that irritated the driver. It was close to midnight and although Christieś new friends collaborated in violating the directives posted on entrance to the vehicle, she tried to join. When the driver pulled over he told the students to get off the bus. Phones didn't respond, so the group started walking the long path through the field. Although the guys ran ahead in glee, the girls hoped they would make it home.
Thus begins the very unique suspense-filled tale of Detective Karen Hart´s latest tale in book #10 of D.S. Butlerś series. In Plain Sight will be published by Thomas & Mercer on January 21, 2025. I was honored to be selected to read the ARC of Butler´s latest novel via NetGalley. This latest Detective Karen Hart investigation of a tale into the pre-production of a British Historical Treasure TV series. Itś extremely well written in details that keep the reader on edge. Who did this - and how did it happen? I have become a true fan of D.S. Butlerś books working on reading the other 6 books in the series. This latest is one suspense-readers should not miss!
January 19, 2025
“In Plain Sight” is the 10th book in the Detective Karen Hart series by author DS Butler. This is an excellent series that I have followed from the start and this latest offering is another gripping crime thriller .An intriguing plot that surrounds the discovery of a woman’s body in a medieval device, resulting with a tense investigation led by Detective Sergeant Karen Hart.
Four teenagers discover the dead body of Alison Poulson at an archaeological dig site locked in a Shrew’s Fiddle, a medieval restraining device. A medieval style murder that has been committed a few hours prior to it’s discovery.
An intriguing case for DS Karen Hart and her team to solve, lots of suspects that includes the victim’s colleagues, her husband, and a teenager who discovered the body. The case becomes more intense when a second murder is discovered and DS Hart must solve the mystery before more deaths occur.
I enjoy the writing of DS Butler, well developed characters, intriguing plots and fast paced. An archaeological dig makes a good setting for the case and this is an excellent addition to the series.
I would like to thank both Netgalley and Thomas & Mercer for supplying a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
Four teenagers discover the dead body of Alison Poulson at an archaeological dig site locked in a Shrew’s Fiddle, a medieval restraining device. A medieval style murder that has been committed a few hours prior to it’s discovery.
An intriguing case for DS Karen Hart and her team to solve, lots of suspects that includes the victim’s colleagues, her husband, and a teenager who discovered the body. The case becomes more intense when a second murder is discovered and DS Hart must solve the mystery before more deaths occur.
I enjoy the writing of DS Butler, well developed characters, intriguing plots and fast paced. An archaeological dig makes a good setting for the case and this is an excellent addition to the series.
I would like to thank both Netgalley and Thomas & Mercer for supplying a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
February 9, 2025
D.S. Butler delivers another gripping installment in the DS Karen Hart series with In Plain Sight. This book was packed with tension, well-paced twists, and had compelling investigative work that kept me turning the pages.
Karen Hart is a strong, and very relatable protagonist, and her determination to uncover the truth makes for an engaging read. The writing is immersive, with just the right balance of procedural detail and character development. D.S Butler excels at creating a small-town setting where secrets lurk beneath the surface, adding to the suspense.
While the mystery unfolds in an intriguing way, a few elements felt slightly predictable, which is why I’m giving it four stars instead of five. However, that didn’t take away from my overall enjoyment. The plot is well structured, and the ending is satisfying, leaving me eager to continue the series (I can’t believe we’re on book number 10 already!!)
I loved reading about Sophie’s struggles with anxiety and doubt after her attack, I’m looking forward to finding out if she decides to stick with the police or not.
If you love crime thrillers with solid investigative storytelling and a strong lead detective, In Plain Sight is definitely worth a read!
Karen Hart is a strong, and very relatable protagonist, and her determination to uncover the truth makes for an engaging read. The writing is immersive, with just the right balance of procedural detail and character development. D.S Butler excels at creating a small-town setting where secrets lurk beneath the surface, adding to the suspense.
While the mystery unfolds in an intriguing way, a few elements felt slightly predictable, which is why I’m giving it four stars instead of five. However, that didn’t take away from my overall enjoyment. The plot is well structured, and the ending is satisfying, leaving me eager to continue the series (I can’t believe we’re on book number 10 already!!)
I loved reading about Sophie’s struggles with anxiety and doubt after her attack, I’m looking forward to finding out if she decides to stick with the police or not.
If you love crime thrillers with solid investigative storytelling and a strong lead detective, In Plain Sight is definitely worth a read!
November 24, 2024
This is #10 in the DS Karen Hart series but it can easily be read as a standalone.
It was great to be back with DS Karen and her colleagues.
Late at night, after an evening out, four friends are thrown off a bus due to their tipsy behaviour and take a shortcut across fields. Their route takes them past a current archaeological dig and they discover a body in a trench. This isn’t an ancient burial, it’s a woman who had clearly only been dead a short time. She is wearing a medieval torture device, called a Shrew’s Violin, around her neck.
One of the group thinks she recognises the dead woman but she decides to keep quiet in case she incriminates anyone.
DS Karen discovers the identity of the woman but she doesn’t appear to have been very popular with the archaeologists or the television team who are filming for a programme. Then a second body is discovered so the team needs to find the perpetrator before they can strike for a third time.
A brilliant storyline with plenty of unexpected twists and turns.
Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer for an advance reader copy in return for an honest review.
It was great to be back with DS Karen and her colleagues.
Late at night, after an evening out, four friends are thrown off a bus due to their tipsy behaviour and take a shortcut across fields. Their route takes them past a current archaeological dig and they discover a body in a trench. This isn’t an ancient burial, it’s a woman who had clearly only been dead a short time. She is wearing a medieval torture device, called a Shrew’s Violin, around her neck.
One of the group thinks she recognises the dead woman but she decides to keep quiet in case she incriminates anyone.
DS Karen discovers the identity of the woman but she doesn’t appear to have been very popular with the archaeologists or the television team who are filming for a programme. Then a second body is discovered so the team needs to find the perpetrator before they can strike for a third time.
A brilliant storyline with plenty of unexpected twists and turns.
Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer for an advance reader copy in return for an honest review.
June 3, 2025
Unexpected
A woman’s body is found in a trench at an archeological dig with a medieval torture device in her mouth and it’s up to DS Karen Hart and her team to find out who was responsible
This book was gripping with all kinds of unexpected twists and turns that had me hooked from the beginning. I think a big part of that was because the type of murder was so different to the usual ones in most detective fiction but I also enjoyed Karen and her team, they came across as real people who were a big part of the story
I wasn’t a huge fan of some of the dialogue jumping between the chapters instead of just at normal chapter breaks as some of it felt a little harsh and broke the story up a bit for me but that’s just a little thing
Although this book is part of a series, I hadn’t read the other books but I could follow the story and the characters. I missed some of the backstory for certain characters but it was covered well enough for me to be able to bond with the characters and see them as real people
I would recommend this book to those who enjoy a murder mystery with a bit of a twist and characters who will keep you on your toes
A woman’s body is found in a trench at an archeological dig with a medieval torture device in her mouth and it’s up to DS Karen Hart and her team to find out who was responsible
This book was gripping with all kinds of unexpected twists and turns that had me hooked from the beginning. I think a big part of that was because the type of murder was so different to the usual ones in most detective fiction but I also enjoyed Karen and her team, they came across as real people who were a big part of the story
I wasn’t a huge fan of some of the dialogue jumping between the chapters instead of just at normal chapter breaks as some of it felt a little harsh and broke the story up a bit for me but that’s just a little thing
Although this book is part of a series, I hadn’t read the other books but I could follow the story and the characters. I missed some of the backstory for certain characters but it was covered well enough for me to be able to bond with the characters and see them as real people
I would recommend this book to those who enjoy a murder mystery with a bit of a twist and characters who will keep you on your toes
October 31, 2024
Another good sortie in this series, which doesn't need to be read in order. More police procedural this time than focusing on personal relationships of existing characters.
This series works well without mention of DS Hart's romance with Mike, or DC Jones's with Harinder. The storyline focuses on the first gruesome murder, and at first it seems as if it's a one- off, but the second adds confusion and potentially another suspect/s to the tale.
I suspected who the killer was, and whilst his explanation fell a bit flat, it sort of did work because of the sometimes-stereotyped character he was (trying not to Spoiler!). I also wondered why some of the team would start something and leave it incomplete, which could've led to the murderer before, but hey, we're human.
It ends with DC Jones in a better place than in the last book, and with DS Hart's life taking a new direction, and that she sees her worth and has the support of her colleagues. I liked that there wasn't TMI, just characters acting like the grown-ups they are.
This series works well without mention of DS Hart's romance with Mike, or DC Jones's with Harinder. The storyline focuses on the first gruesome murder, and at first it seems as if it's a one- off, but the second adds confusion and potentially another suspect/s to the tale.
I suspected who the killer was, and whilst his explanation fell a bit flat, it sort of did work because of the sometimes-stereotyped character he was (trying not to Spoiler!). I also wondered why some of the team would start something and leave it incomplete, which could've led to the murderer before, but hey, we're human.
It ends with DC Jones in a better place than in the last book, and with DS Hart's life taking a new direction, and that she sees her worth and has the support of her colleagues. I liked that there wasn't TMI, just characters acting like the grown-ups they are.
November 5, 2024
Teenagers taking a short cut through a field stumble on an archeological site. One of the boys falls drunkenly into a trench only to find a body in it. No, not an ancient corpse, a fresh corpse wearing a medieval torture device called a Shrew's Fiddle.
One of the teenager's recognises the victim, but doesn't mention it. She is protecting her family.
DS Karen Hart is shocked at the brutality of the crime.
Soon, there is another killing, just as savage, and Sophie is proved right with her prediction of a serial killer being on the loose.
Another fantastic DS Karen Hart book. I love the way the team work together and recognise each other's flaws, but still get on with the job.
The writing flows beautifully, and the plot keeps the reader on the edge of their seat.
I am pleased that this can be read as a standalone, even though it is the tenth book in the series. I really want to read more of the books.
Thanks to Netgalley and Thomas & Mercer for the opportunity to read this book.
One of the teenager's recognises the victim, but doesn't mention it. She is protecting her family.
DS Karen Hart is shocked at the brutality of the crime.
Soon, there is another killing, just as savage, and Sophie is proved right with her prediction of a serial killer being on the loose.
Another fantastic DS Karen Hart book. I love the way the team work together and recognise each other's flaws, but still get on with the job.
The writing flows beautifully, and the plot keeps the reader on the edge of their seat.
I am pleased that this can be read as a standalone, even though it is the tenth book in the series. I really want to read more of the books.
Thanks to Netgalley and Thomas & Mercer for the opportunity to read this book.
November 25, 2024
Someone went medieval on a woman and DS Hart is on the case. After ten volumes, longtime readers know the characters and take it personally when one of them may be getting played by a suspect. Every turn, every dead end, every injury takes a toll and makes this an extra-suspenseful one. Not a longtime reader? No problem, since the dynamics between the characters are clearly established and there is a bit of recap that doesn’t fall into repetition. The plot was very entertaining, as usual, even if the baddie was maybe not as unexpected as I would have hoped, but the motive did surprise me. The part that I most enjoyed was the personal lives of the characters. Karen and her relationship with Mike, Sophie and her slow recovery after her brush with death and, especially, one of my favorites in a great side story. The ending tied most of the loose ends, leaving a little for a future volume. Can’t wait!
I chose to read this book and all opinions in this review are my own and completely unbiased. Thank you, NetGalley/Thomas & Mercer.
I chose to read this book and all opinions in this review are my own and completely unbiased. Thank you, NetGalley/Thomas & Mercer.
January 12, 2025
In the dead of night, four teenagers taking a shortcut through an archaeological dig site find a woman’s lifeless body in a muddy trench, her hands and neck locked in a medieval device known as a Shrew’s Fiddle. It doesn’t take long to see that these are no ancient remains - the woman was killed just hours earlier. Called in to unearth the truth, DS Karen Hart learns that the victim, local woman Alison Poulson, was unpopular with the archaeologists and the TV crew filming the excavation. Then there’s another murder.
The tenth book in the series & it could be read on its own. I really like Karen who is down to earth, she works well with her team & I like the balance between her home & work life. The case was intriguing & as you would expect there are twists & turns as well as plenty of suspects. I thoroughly enjoyed the book & look forward to the next one
I voluntarily read and reviewed a special copy of this book; all thoughts and opinions are my own
The tenth book in the series & it could be read on its own. I really like Karen who is down to earth, she works well with her team & I like the balance between her home & work life. The case was intriguing & as you would expect there are twists & turns as well as plenty of suspects. I thoroughly enjoyed the book & look forward to the next one
I voluntarily read and reviewed a special copy of this book; all thoughts and opinions are my own
August 14, 2025
DS Karen Hart has a new case that presents some intriguing possibilities. When some teens out drinking stumble upon a body in a trench at an archeological dig site, Kare is called to the scene. The deceased was the person who had responsibility for approving the filming of a "true story" show at the dig. Not only is the woman deceased, but she is fastened in a torture device. One of the teens who discovered the body is the daughter of the professor who is part of the archeological project. As Karen and her team investigate the murder, there are some unexpected twists. When another woman is found dead attached to a whipping post, the crew of the "true story" show becomes fearful about who might be next. While Karen is involved in the case, she is also trying to be a supportive spouse as her husband deals with the mystery of his birth father, whose identity his mom does not want to discuss. It's an exciting read with lots of unexpected turns. I look forward to the next Karen Hart book.
November 11, 2024
D. S. Butler is back with another sensational story about DS Hart and her team of police officers. This is book 10 in a fabulous series, however it can be read as a standalone as D. S. Butler leaves no loose ends when referring back to previous books, recapping where necessary without overdoing it for readers who have read the books.
This is your comfy chair and cup of tea thriller, it has a shocking murder and a concise descriptive timeline of clues and hunches until the crime and its perpetrator is revealed. I cannot find any fault in the DS Hart series, each book is a joy to read and usually read in one sitting. The sprinkles of hints and suggestive words are genius to keep the reader in their toes.
5 star read … just brilliant!
#inplainsight #netgalley #favauthor #thrillerreads
This is your comfy chair and cup of tea thriller, it has a shocking murder and a concise descriptive timeline of clues and hunches until the crime and its perpetrator is revealed. I cannot find any fault in the DS Hart series, each book is a joy to read and usually read in one sitting. The sprinkles of hints and suggestive words are genius to keep the reader in their toes.
5 star read … just brilliant!
#inplainsight #netgalley #favauthor #thrillerreads
Displaying 1 - 30 of 100 reviews