What do you think?
Rate this book
The Last Scarecrow
*** Wattpad Winner 2021 ***
When the human race faces extinction, the scarecrows will rise.
Erin loved to build scarecrows. She made a dozen in all. Her Pa showed her how. But he’s dead now. Everyone is dead. Well… almost.
The Many Years Storm flooded the world, swept Erin’s brother out to sea, and turned her hilltop farm into a rapidly shrinking island. While hope remains, Erin must take her chances on the open ocean and find her brother. But she doesn’t have the knowledge to build a raft and there’s no one to ask except the last and most terrifying of all her scarecrows–Number Twelve.
Erin needs help. Scratch that. Erin needs a miracle.
'Return to Oz' meets 'The Nightmare Before Christmas' in Neil J Hart’s award-winning adorably terrifying fantasy adventure where climate change has flooded the earth, destroyed humanity, and ushered in a grave new world!
When the human race faces extinction, the scarecrows will rise.
Erin loved to build scarecrows. She made a dozen in all. Her Pa showed her how. But he’s dead now. Everyone is dead. Well… almost.
The Many Years Storm flooded the world, swept Erin’s brother out to sea, and turned her hilltop farm into a rapidly shrinking island. While hope remains, Erin must take her chances on the open ocean and find her brother. But she doesn’t have the knowledge to build a raft and there’s no one to ask except the last and most terrifying of all her scarecrows–Number Twelve.
Erin needs help. Scratch that. Erin needs a miracle.
'Return to Oz' meets 'The Nightmare Before Christmas' in Neil J Hart’s award-winning adorably terrifying fantasy adventure where climate change has flooded the earth, destroyed humanity, and ushered in a grave new world!
312 pages, Paperback
Published June 4, 2024
20 people are currently reading
53 people want to read
About the author
Neil J Hart
5 books15 followersNeil J Hart has won awards for his haunting YA fantasy adventure novels 'Sadie Madison and the Boy in the Crimson Scarf' ('His Dark Materials' meets 'City of Ghosts') and ‘The Last Scarecrow’ ('Return to Oz' meets 'The Wild Robot').
The first book in the SpiralVerse Saga, 'Harper Hale and the Crystal of Shadows' is a YA sci-fi mystery inspired by the adventure of Star Wars and magic of Harry Potter.
He is currently working on sequels to all a three series as well as a MG horror series and a stand alone YA ghost story.
Neil also works as a graphic designer and a musician. He fosters for Cats Protection. Relies on coffee. Adores a perfectly made cheese and cucumber sandwich. And collects Tomb Raider memorabilia.
The first book in the SpiralVerse Saga, 'Harper Hale and the Crystal of Shadows' is a YA sci-fi mystery inspired by the adventure of Star Wars and magic of Harry Potter.
He is currently working on sequels to all a three series as well as a MG horror series and a stand alone YA ghost story.
Neil also works as a graphic designer and a musician. He fosters for Cats Protection. Relies on coffee. Adores a perfectly made cheese and cucumber sandwich. And collects Tomb Raider memorabilia.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 32 reviews
May 18, 2024
Well I never thought I'd be crying over a scarecrow! This book was surprisingly emotional. Like, really emotional. I was a little unsure of where this story was going to go at first, since, well, live scarecrows and talking birds (and mannequins and wickerpeople, oh my!) were a large part of the story, but it all tied together really nicely. This was a great adventure book with a lot of excitement, despair, and some horror. There's something for everyone. The authors imagination really came through with this one. I would highly recommend giving this a read if you're in the mood for an adventure.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
June 4, 2024
This novel is like no other I’ve ever read. It’s hard to compare it to anything I can think of which made it a blast to read. Erin has lost both parents and her brother to the Many Years Storm. Earth has changed and humans are dying. What is left are strange occurrences such as maniquíes that appear to be alive, scarecrows that can move and talk and even the birds are talking. In this topsy turvy world Erin leaves her little island farm into the endless blue to find her brother along with Scarecrow #12. The adventure is perilous. Erin finds Marshall a human boy who joins her. At times things are bleak but as Pa always said you have to be tested to know what you can actually endure and oh boy Erin and the others are tested. I fell in love with Scarecrow #12 even though her appearance is quite unsettling. This story made me laugh, cry, despair, rejoice and hope for a better future. The Last Scarecrow can be for middle grade up to adult. His story is so bizarre that you want to know what happens next.
October 14, 2024
4.25 stars
I greatly enjoyed this book. It was well written and engaging, and it kept me interested all the way through. The characters were well written, and though not much development took place, it was still a very good read.
The only thing that I didn’t like a whole lot about this book was that there was just a lot of stuff going on. Most of it was vital to the story, as it introduced us to necessary characters, but some I just didn’t understand.
Other than that, this was overall a very good book, and I look forward to read the next as soon as it comes out!!!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I greatly enjoyed this book. It was well written and engaging, and it kept me interested all the way through. The characters were well written, and though not much development took place, it was still a very good read.
The only thing that I didn’t like a whole lot about this book was that there was just a lot of stuff going on. Most of it was vital to the story, as it introduced us to necessary characters, but some I just didn’t understand.
Other than that, this was overall a very good book, and I look forward to read the next as soon as it comes out!!!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
May 13, 2024
In "The Last Scarecrow" by Neil J Hart, the timeless childhood symbol of the scarecrow takes on a chilling and compelling new form, thrusting readers into a post-apocalyptic world where the very survival of humanity hangs in the balance. Hart's ability to breathe life into the scarecrow, transforming it from a mere inanimate object into a formidable and haunting presence, is a testament to his skill as a storyteller.
From the moment Erin's world is ravaged by the cataclysmic Many Years Storm, readers are plunged into a gripping tale of resilience, courage, and hope against all odds. As Erin grapples with the loss of her family and the rapidly shrinking island that was once her home, she must summon the courage to venture into the unknown, facing not only the treacherous open ocean but also the enigmatic and terrifying Number Twelve, the last of her handmade scarecrows.
Hart's narrative sweeps readers off their feet, immersing them in a world of heart-stopping adventure, pulse-pounding suspense, and unexpected twists and turns. Through Erin's eyes, we experience the full spectrum of human emotion – from fear and desperation to determination and hope. Hart's portrayal of Erin's journey is both poignant and exhilarating, capturing the essence of what it means to confront one's deepest fears and forge ahead in the face of unimaginable adversity.
What sets "The Last Scarecrow" apart is its ability to transcend the boundaries of young adult fiction while remaining accessible and engaging to readers of all ages. Hart seamlessly blends elements of fantasy, dystopia, and coming-of-age themes, crafting a story that is as thought-provoking as it is thrilling.
In conclusion, "The Last Scarecrow" is a captivating and thought-provoking tale that will leave readers spellbound until the very end. Neil J Hart has crafted a world that is equal parts terrifying and mesmerizing, inviting readers to embark on an unforgettable journey of discovery and self-discovery. This is a book that will stay with you long after you've turned the final page, a testament to the enduring power of storytelling at its finest.
From the moment Erin's world is ravaged by the cataclysmic Many Years Storm, readers are plunged into a gripping tale of resilience, courage, and hope against all odds. As Erin grapples with the loss of her family and the rapidly shrinking island that was once her home, she must summon the courage to venture into the unknown, facing not only the treacherous open ocean but also the enigmatic and terrifying Number Twelve, the last of her handmade scarecrows.
Hart's narrative sweeps readers off their feet, immersing them in a world of heart-stopping adventure, pulse-pounding suspense, and unexpected twists and turns. Through Erin's eyes, we experience the full spectrum of human emotion – from fear and desperation to determination and hope. Hart's portrayal of Erin's journey is both poignant and exhilarating, capturing the essence of what it means to confront one's deepest fears and forge ahead in the face of unimaginable adversity.
What sets "The Last Scarecrow" apart is its ability to transcend the boundaries of young adult fiction while remaining accessible and engaging to readers of all ages. Hart seamlessly blends elements of fantasy, dystopia, and coming-of-age themes, crafting a story that is as thought-provoking as it is thrilling.
In conclusion, "The Last Scarecrow" is a captivating and thought-provoking tale that will leave readers spellbound until the very end. Neil J Hart has crafted a world that is equal parts terrifying and mesmerizing, inviting readers to embark on an unforgettable journey of discovery and self-discovery. This is a book that will stay with you long after you've turned the final page, a testament to the enduring power of storytelling at its finest.
Currently reading
January 6, 2026Thank you to the narrator for providing a free review copy of this audiobook.
November 6, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Tense, eerie, and absolutely unforgettable
The Last Scarecrow is one of those rare stories that feels like a myth you’ve known your whole life, yet somehow entirely new. I adored this book. It carries the same strange, unsettling magic as Return to Oz—that blend of whimsy and dread, of childlike wonder tucked inside something much darker—and it does it beautifully.
Erin is a compelling, resilient protagonist, holding onto a sliver of hope in a flooded world where almost everything has been taken from her. The scarecrows she built with her father aren’t just background set pieces—they’re haunting, imaginative, and alive in ways that are deeply emotional and deeply creepy. Number Twelve, especially, is an unforgettable character: eerie, endearing, and terrifying all at once.
The horror elements are handled so well—subtle when they need to be, and sharp when they strike. The worldbuilding feels dreamlike and apocalyptic in equal measure, with the rising waters and decaying civilization painting a backdrop that’s both tragic and strangely beautiful.
What really stayed with me is how the story balances darkness with heart. It’s spooky, yes, but also tender. It’s about grief and resilience, fear and trust, and what it means to hold onto hope when the world has literally washed away.
If you love stories that are slightly off-kilter, atmospheric, emotionally rich, and deliciously eerie—this is a must-read. The Last Scarecrow is haunting in the best possible way. It will sit with me for a long, long time.
The Last Scarecrow is one of those rare stories that feels like a myth you’ve known your whole life, yet somehow entirely new. I adored this book. It carries the same strange, unsettling magic as Return to Oz—that blend of whimsy and dread, of childlike wonder tucked inside something much darker—and it does it beautifully.
Erin is a compelling, resilient protagonist, holding onto a sliver of hope in a flooded world where almost everything has been taken from her. The scarecrows she built with her father aren’t just background set pieces—they’re haunting, imaginative, and alive in ways that are deeply emotional and deeply creepy. Number Twelve, especially, is an unforgettable character: eerie, endearing, and terrifying all at once.
The horror elements are handled so well—subtle when they need to be, and sharp when they strike. The worldbuilding feels dreamlike and apocalyptic in equal measure, with the rising waters and decaying civilization painting a backdrop that’s both tragic and strangely beautiful.
What really stayed with me is how the story balances darkness with heart. It’s spooky, yes, but also tender. It’s about grief and resilience, fear and trust, and what it means to hold onto hope when the world has literally washed away.
If you love stories that are slightly off-kilter, atmospheric, emotionally rich, and deliciously eerie—this is a must-read. The Last Scarecrow is haunting in the best possible way. It will sit with me for a long, long time.
February 17, 2025
Beautifully written. From the start I found the characters very charming and lovable, and the setting very intriguing. I spent my time reading this book wanting to know more about this world and the cast inside, what kind of adventures and troubles awaited them. The world building is very clever, too, and all in all this was a very rewarding read. I can definitely see myself rereading this book in the future.
That said, though, I'll admit it did take me some time to really get into this book. I was enjoying the journey, but at first I wasn't entirely sure if or when I'd actually get hooked. I had lingering curiosity about what was going to happen next - along with affection for the characters - keeping me going, but I didn't really feel attached to what I was reading until further along in the story than I would have liked. However, when I did get hooked, I fell so deeply in love with this story, and its poignant ending wrecked my emotions so deliciously.
I look forward to reading the other books in this series when they release, and I've already bought Sadie Madison and the Boy in the Crimson Scarf with full intentions of reading that, as well!
September 25, 2025
I had no idea what to expect when starting this but 'return to Oz meets nightmare on elm street' is a line used in its own bio and I whole heartedly agree.
Set in a post apocolypic world due to the rise in water levels because of climate change your set on a whimsical adventure in a new world of horrors. Erin survives the many years storm and now hopes to find her brother. Alone she turns to the last of her terrifying scarecrows she herself made.
Wild creatures, insane events and talking birds fill this story with a strange intrigue as you journey through the ever changing world and experience a wild variety of characters. All wrapped up with some heartbreaking conclusions.
Clever, unique, writing and I think it's worthy of your time. The it, I can't truly explain how stylistically unique it felt.
Set in a post apocolypic world due to the rise in water levels because of climate change your set on a whimsical adventure in a new world of horrors. Erin survives the many years storm and now hopes to find her brother. Alone she turns to the last of her terrifying scarecrows she herself made.
Wild creatures, insane events and talking birds fill this story with a strange intrigue as you journey through the ever changing world and experience a wild variety of characters. All wrapped up with some heartbreaking conclusions.
Clever, unique, writing and I think it's worthy of your time. The it, I can't truly explain how stylistically unique it felt.
June 21, 2024
I loved reading this book! It wasn’t what I expected but in a good way!
This was such a fun, easy read full of adventure, beautiful friendships, scarecrows, wicker-men and talking birds! It has a found family trope and there were even some moments where I had a lump in my throat.
If you like teen fantasy’s full of adventure with characters that get you emotional invested, then you should read The Last Scarecrow.
This was such a fun, easy read full of adventure, beautiful friendships, scarecrows, wicker-men and talking birds! It has a found family trope and there were even some moments where I had a lump in my throat.
If you like teen fantasy’s full of adventure with characters that get you emotional invested, then you should read The Last Scarecrow.
July 2, 2024
I did enjoy this story. The first part grabbed me & I thought great! Then the pace seemed to slow a little & I found the levels of angst a little high for my tastes. The last part once again picked up & I found myself wanting to see how it finished. Over all a good read.
May 28, 2024
Absolutely loved it! The plot was so different it just held me in suspense. I don't want to give anything away about this one except - if you like an adventure unlike anything else read it. Loved the characters, their loyalty and interactions with one another was a great part of the story.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 4, 2024
I got this book for free in exchange for an honest review via Book Sirens.
I want to start by saying that I truly respect the strangeness and vision of this tale. The end of the world as we know it has occurred and there is only one remaining girl who discovers that birds can talk and humanoid objects, specifically her creepy af scarecrows, have suddenly become sentient? Alright, I'm game to see where this goes. It aimed big and had a lot of action packed into a relatively short novel. It touched on loss and grief, braving the elements, the psychological impacts of being a human soul in a non-human body, teamwork, betrayal, and friendship. I found the timeline to be a tad confusing though, how long was she adventuring and what was she eating? How did she not starve after spending all that energy fighting at every turn? How old is this girl again? The devil is in the details, and while I imagine time and meals are easy to lose track of given the many-years storm, it left me feeling a bit frustrated not being able to pin down things of that nature. The main reason for my 3 stars is for the lack of those critical details- the transitions seemed a bit jarring, and I often had to re-read because I missed something mentioned that furthered the plot without realizing it. The characters were endearing and interesting, but I wanted more, they just came off a little flat to me. Seriously, if this book had dedicated a little bit more to rounding out the context, details, and characters I probably would have loved it- as it stands, I liked it but I needed more pages with more development to give it a higher rating.
I want to start by saying that I truly respect the strangeness and vision of this tale. The end of the world as we know it has occurred and there is only one remaining girl who discovers that birds can talk and humanoid objects, specifically her creepy af scarecrows, have suddenly become sentient? Alright, I'm game to see where this goes. It aimed big and had a lot of action packed into a relatively short novel. It touched on loss and grief, braving the elements, the psychological impacts of being a human soul in a non-human body, teamwork, betrayal, and friendship. I found the timeline to be a tad confusing though, how long was she adventuring and what was she eating? How did she not starve after spending all that energy fighting at every turn? How old is this girl again? The devil is in the details, and while I imagine time and meals are easy to lose track of given the many-years storm, it left me feeling a bit frustrated not being able to pin down things of that nature. The main reason for my 3 stars is for the lack of those critical details- the transitions seemed a bit jarring, and I often had to re-read because I missed something mentioned that furthered the plot without realizing it. The characters were endearing and interesting, but I wanted more, they just came off a little flat to me. Seriously, if this book had dedicated a little bit more to rounding out the context, details, and characters I probably would have loved it- as it stands, I liked it but I needed more pages with more development to give it a higher rating.
August 23, 2025
Haunting, Heroic, Unforgettable — The Dystopia of Your Dreams (and Nightmares), Led by the Voice that Commands the Tempest.
In The Last Scarecrow — WATTY’S WINNER 2021 and the spellbinding first entry in Scarecrows of Coldharbour Farm — Neil J Hart drenches you in a post‑apocalyptic world swallowed by an endless, wrathful storm. Strange new species rise, familiar ones evolve into marvels or terrors, and the atmosphere crackles with eerie beauty. The prose is as rich and haunting as the tempest it conjures, while Samantha Norbury’s audiobook performance is nothing short of alchemy — each voice so vivid and distinct, you’ll forget it’s one narrator and not a full cast breathing life into these characters. Twelve, Raven, The Blue King… they don’t just inhabit the story; they stake a claim in your imagination.
Though this is only book one, the conclusion lands with such elegance it could stand alone — yet you’ll find yourself craving the sequel like rain after a drought. Cinematic, fast‑paced, and brimming with emotion, it’s a tale of found family, loyalty, resilience, and the stubborn spark to truly live. Perfect for teens, irresistible to adults — if you love dystopian fantasy, haunting world‑building, or simply an audiobook crafted with rare excellence, this is one you cannot miss.
In The Last Scarecrow — WATTY’S WINNER 2021 and the spellbinding first entry in Scarecrows of Coldharbour Farm — Neil J Hart drenches you in a post‑apocalyptic world swallowed by an endless, wrathful storm. Strange new species rise, familiar ones evolve into marvels or terrors, and the atmosphere crackles with eerie beauty. The prose is as rich and haunting as the tempest it conjures, while Samantha Norbury’s audiobook performance is nothing short of alchemy — each voice so vivid and distinct, you’ll forget it’s one narrator and not a full cast breathing life into these characters. Twelve, Raven, The Blue King… they don’t just inhabit the story; they stake a claim in your imagination.
Though this is only book one, the conclusion lands with such elegance it could stand alone — yet you’ll find yourself craving the sequel like rain after a drought. Cinematic, fast‑paced, and brimming with emotion, it’s a tale of found family, loyalty, resilience, and the stubborn spark to truly live. Perfect for teens, irresistible to adults — if you love dystopian fantasy, haunting world‑building, or simply an audiobook crafted with rare excellence, this is one you cannot miss.
July 22, 2024
This was so so SO good.
The Last Scarecrow follows Erin, a girl who has been left orphaned by a massive rainstorm that has flooded the entire world. One day, a scarecrow she created comes to life, and the two set out together to find Erin’s missing brother.
I had never heard of this author and saw it on the BookSirens website. The cover intrigued me so I decided to give it a go and I am so so SO glad I did. This was FANTASTIC.
The writing:
The book has an almost deceptive writing style. I think it can appeal to a very wide audience because of it. To explain, it reads a lot like a middle grade book. However, the subject matter is pretty dark, and there are dark enough moments where I think it appeals well to an older audience as well.
The world:
I think this was the most unique world building I’ve ever seen. From our titular talking scarecrow, to talking birds, to mannequins come to life, to men made of sticks, this author created some insanely cool and memorable characters. My personal favorite location, besides the farm, was Clifftop. All the birds there were delightfully strange.
The plot:
This book had a nonstop plot that made it almost impossible to put down. We follow our characters to what feels like every corner of the earth in not that many pages, yet it never feels rushed. I think the perfect amount of time was spent in each new location, enough to flesh it out without it getting boring.
Overall, I will be 100% picking up the next book in this series and will definitely be keeping my eyes out for future works by this author.
5/5 stars for a delightfully creative book i will never forget!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The Last Scarecrow follows Erin, a girl who has been left orphaned by a massive rainstorm that has flooded the entire world. One day, a scarecrow she created comes to life, and the two set out together to find Erin’s missing brother.
I had never heard of this author and saw it on the BookSirens website. The cover intrigued me so I decided to give it a go and I am so so SO glad I did. This was FANTASTIC.
The writing:
The book has an almost deceptive writing style. I think it can appeal to a very wide audience because of it. To explain, it reads a lot like a middle grade book. However, the subject matter is pretty dark, and there are dark enough moments where I think it appeals well to an older audience as well.
The world:
I think this was the most unique world building I’ve ever seen. From our titular talking scarecrow, to talking birds, to mannequins come to life, to men made of sticks, this author created some insanely cool and memorable characters. My personal favorite location, besides the farm, was Clifftop. All the birds there were delightfully strange.
The plot:
This book had a nonstop plot that made it almost impossible to put down. We follow our characters to what feels like every corner of the earth in not that many pages, yet it never feels rushed. I think the perfect amount of time was spent in each new location, enough to flesh it out without it getting boring.
Overall, I will be 100% picking up the next book in this series and will definitely be keeping my eyes out for future works by this author.
5/5 stars for a delightfully creative book i will never forget!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 14, 2024
I bought a copy of this book from Birmingham Book Extravaganza after being spellbound by the cover design and having a great chat with the author. When I got home, I cracked open the book to give it a go - and I don't remember anything else I did with the rest of my day or the next. I finished this book, cover to cover, in under 48 hours and I loved absolutely every second of it!
It's beautiful and tragic but also immensely hopeful and inspiring. Erin is the last girl alive, facing unimaginable new horrors after The Many Years Storm has subsided. Her scarecrow, the delightfully terrifying Twelve, has come to life and the two misfits decide to set out and find what they've lost. This is a story of found family at the end of the world, and doesn't shy from being truly horrifying at times (and I love that it does!) with the perils Erin, Twelve, and their friends and enemies face. I was gripped by several twists and the ending made me cry. But it was beautiful, so beautiful and hopeful as well as sad. I cannot wait for book 2!
It's beautiful and tragic but also immensely hopeful and inspiring. Erin is the last girl alive, facing unimaginable new horrors after The Many Years Storm has subsided. Her scarecrow, the delightfully terrifying Twelve, has come to life and the two misfits decide to set out and find what they've lost. This is a story of found family at the end of the world, and doesn't shy from being truly horrifying at times (and I love that it does!) with the perils Erin, Twelve, and their friends and enemies face. I was gripped by several twists and the ending made me cry. But it was beautiful, so beautiful and hopeful as well as sad. I cannot wait for book 2!
July 30, 2024
I loved this original, enthralling, important tale from Neil J Hart. From the first page to the last, The Last Scarecrow’s great success lies in the way it keeps you rooting for its heroes while cleverly evoking anxieties we’ve almost all shared in its villains, settings and never-far-away crises.
The influence of Hart’s namesake Neil Gaiman looms large in the stoic resilience of protagonist Erin and the dread Patchwork Woman, while the macabre invention and pacy set-pieces evoke Iain Banks’ The Wasp Factory. This is a book that will delight readers of all ages.
Through Erin, deuteragonist Scarecrow Twelve and their supporting cast, Hart creates a sense that - no matter how seemingly futile - rolling up your sleeves and getting on with it, facing your fears, and believing in kindness, are all noble and worthwhile endeavours, particularly in a world full of uncertainty and peril.
A fantastic novel fully deserving of all its plaudits. I can’t wait to read Hart’s next work.
The influence of Hart’s namesake Neil Gaiman looms large in the stoic resilience of protagonist Erin and the dread Patchwork Woman, while the macabre invention and pacy set-pieces evoke Iain Banks’ The Wasp Factory. This is a book that will delight readers of all ages.
Through Erin, deuteragonist Scarecrow Twelve and their supporting cast, Hart creates a sense that - no matter how seemingly futile - rolling up your sleeves and getting on with it, facing your fears, and believing in kindness, are all noble and worthwhile endeavours, particularly in a world full of uncertainty and peril.
A fantastic novel fully deserving of all its plaudits. I can’t wait to read Hart’s next work.
June 9, 2024
A fascinating post-apocalyptic fairy tale. Climate change has melted the icy wastes of the North & South poles, the world has flooded and all that’s left is a years long cyclone.
Erin has survived the loss of her family, clinging alone to the island that is all that remains of her home, Coldharbor Farm.
But all that changes one morning when she wakes to the sound of voices.
Full of spirits, myth and new darker magiks, ‘The Last Scarecrow’ is both fairy tale and somber warning.
Adored it!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Erin has survived the loss of her family, clinging alone to the island that is all that remains of her home, Coldharbor Farm.
But all that changes one morning when she wakes to the sound of voices.
Full of spirits, myth and new darker magiks, ‘The Last Scarecrow’ is both fairy tale and somber warning.
Adored it!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
October 27, 2024
**I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This novel was incredibly engaging from the very opening. The story does have quite a bit going on, but it was easy to keep track of things. All in all, it was a captivating horror tale.
This novel was incredibly engaging from the very opening. The story does have quite a bit going on, but it was easy to keep track of things. All in all, it was a captivating horror tale.
May 31, 2024
I received a review copy for free via BookSirens and I am leaving this honest review voluntarily.
This is a clever and exciting adventure fantasy aimed at younger readers but I found it kept my 50+ brain engaged. Borrowing from literature classics is a device I always enjoy when done well and it is done very well here. I'm sure there are some references I missed (possibly due to my age) but this just made me think more which is also a sign of a good read. Great characters, packed with feeling and adventure, brilliantly paced, original….I'd give a 4.5 if possible. It just missed out on 5 stars because there are a few errors which jump out in a book that is so competently written otherwise. Also, given that there's a section at the back for school discussion, I feel it's even more important that correct terminology and grammar are used. I would have loved this in my reading list at school and highly recommend it to readers of all ages with a caveat that it might be quite scary for the youngest who could read at this level.
This is a clever and exciting adventure fantasy aimed at younger readers but I found it kept my 50+ brain engaged. Borrowing from literature classics is a device I always enjoy when done well and it is done very well here. I'm sure there are some references I missed (possibly due to my age) but this just made me think more which is also a sign of a good read. Great characters, packed with feeling and adventure, brilliantly paced, original….I'd give a 4.5 if possible. It just missed out on 5 stars because there are a few errors which jump out in a book that is so competently written otherwise. Also, given that there's a section at the back for school discussion, I feel it's even more important that correct terminology and grammar are used. I would have loved this in my reading list at school and highly recommend it to readers of all ages with a caveat that it might be quite scary for the youngest who could read at this level.
June 9, 2024
Oh this book had me in tears! What a wonderful (and slightly crazy at times) story of sisterhood. I have fallen in love with Twelve ☠️😍
Can’t wait to read your next story.
Can’t wait to read your next story.
November 5, 2024
A great read, inventive and fun. Thoroughly enjoyed it. Can’t wait for more books by this author.
January 16, 2026
Another AMAZING book! This was my second book by **Neil J Hart**, the first being *Harper Hale and the Crystal of Shadows* — and once again, I absolutely loved it. *The Last Scarecrow* was magical, creepy, adventurous, and genuinely exciting.
There’s such a strong sense of atmosphere in his writing and his books have become my new favourite form of escapism! I can’t wait to read more.
There’s such a strong sense of atmosphere in his writing and his books have become my new favourite form of escapism! I can’t wait to read more.
November 17, 2024
A unique dystopian tale. Equal parts horrifying and moving. Filled with friendship, betrayal, and battles.
November 15, 2025
The Last Scarecrow was a fun, easy read full of adventure, friendships, scarecrows, wicker-men and talking birds! It has a distinct family trope and there were even some moments where I had a lump in my throat. I hadn't expected that. The book carries the same strange, unsettling magic as Return to Oz and blends of whimsy and dread, of childlike wonder tucked inside something darker and it is beautifully done.
Erin is a compelling protagonist, who resiliently holds onto a sliver of hope in a flooded world where so much has gone. The scarecrows she enjoyed building scarecrows with her father and these become haunting and alive in ways that are both emotional and creepy. Number Twelve, especially, is unforgettable. It is eerie, endearing, and terrifying all at once.
However, the horror elements are well handled. They are subtle when they need to be, and sharp for effect as necessary.
Hart's worldbuilding feels dreamlike and apocalyptic in equal measure, with the rising waters and decaying civilization painting a backdrop that’s not just tragic but also strangely beautiful. What really stayed with me is how the story balances darkness with heart. It’s spooky, yes, but also tender. It’s about grief and resilience, fear and trust, and what it means for the characters to hold onto hope when the world has been washed away.
If you love stories that are atmospheric, and eerieHart's book is well worth a try. The Last Scarecrow is haunting in the best possible way and not just for kids.
Erin is a compelling protagonist, who resiliently holds onto a sliver of hope in a flooded world where so much has gone. The scarecrows she enjoyed building scarecrows with her father and these become haunting and alive in ways that are both emotional and creepy. Number Twelve, especially, is unforgettable. It is eerie, endearing, and terrifying all at once.
However, the horror elements are well handled. They are subtle when they need to be, and sharp for effect as necessary.
Hart's worldbuilding feels dreamlike and apocalyptic in equal measure, with the rising waters and decaying civilization painting a backdrop that’s not just tragic but also strangely beautiful. What really stayed with me is how the story balances darkness with heart. It’s spooky, yes, but also tender. It’s about grief and resilience, fear and trust, and what it means for the characters to hold onto hope when the world has been washed away.
If you love stories that are atmospheric, and eerieHart's book is well worth a try. The Last Scarecrow is haunting in the best possible way and not just for kids.
July 31, 2024
A BIG thank you to BookSirens and Fragile Publishing for an ARC of this novel. You ever just pick a book by the title and not the synopsis? This was one of those cases for me and I have NEVER done that, I saw the word scarecrow and was like yup! I imagined a horror novel because who doesn't associate scarecrows and associate absolute terror... this novel was way different than that, its macabre sure, but it has so much more to offer than that.
Erin and her mother, father and brother Clyde are swept away in what is now known at the Many Great Years Storm. She is the sole survivor having buried her parents on her homestead called Coldharbour Farm. Clyde, her older brother is still missing. Erin's hobby of Scarecrow making was a regular occurence until the event. She has made twelve scarecrows in all, naming them aptly but number. She awakens one morning to find out that number twelve is alive and talking with a blackbird. I don't want to give too much away because it's just an incredible adventure that all three set out on to find her brother and twelve's other "siblings". There is an island inhabited by birds, an other by mannequins. All humans no more, Erin being the last. This novel is so beautifully written, it kept me enamored and I read it less than twelve hours (love the irony) in reading the end and seeing there will be another one, well I am beyond thrilled over that. There is so much more to know and read involving these wonderfully brought to life characters.
Erin and her mother, father and brother Clyde are swept away in what is now known at the Many Great Years Storm. She is the sole survivor having buried her parents on her homestead called Coldharbour Farm. Clyde, her older brother is still missing. Erin's hobby of Scarecrow making was a regular occurence until the event. She has made twelve scarecrows in all, naming them aptly but number. She awakens one morning to find out that number twelve is alive and talking with a blackbird. I don't want to give too much away because it's just an incredible adventure that all three set out on to find her brother and twelve's other "siblings". There is an island inhabited by birds, an other by mannequins. All humans no more, Erin being the last. This novel is so beautifully written, it kept me enamored and I read it less than twelve hours (love the irony) in reading the end and seeing there will be another one, well I am beyond thrilled over that. There is so much more to know and read involving these wonderfully brought to life characters.
June 24, 2025
A Hauntingly Beautiful Tale of Survival, Hope, and Some Unlikely Guardians
The Last Scarecrow is an unforgettable blend of eerie fantasy and heartfelt adventure that left me both chilled and deeply moved. Neil J Hart has crafted a world ravaged by climate catastrophe, yet pulsing with imagination and raw emotional depth.
At the heart of the story is Erin, a brave and resilient young girl whose love for building scarecrows becomes her unlikely salvation. Her journey—from an isolated hilltop farm to the great unknown—is propelled not only by the desperate hope of finding her lost brother but by the companionship (and occasional menace) of Number Twelve, the final scarecrow and perhaps the most enigmatic character of them all.
The writing has a cinematic quality, with shades of Return to Oz and The Nightmare Before Christmas, but the story stands entirely on its own. Hart walks the line between whimsy and horror with remarkable grace, never shying away from darkness, yet always leaving room for light.
This is more than a dystopian fantasy—it's a story about holding onto love when the world washes away. For readers who enjoy bold storytelling, eerie magic, and characters that linger in your heart long after the final page, The Last Scarecrow is a must-read.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ — A triumph of imagination and emotion.
The Last Scarecrow is an unforgettable blend of eerie fantasy and heartfelt adventure that left me both chilled and deeply moved. Neil J Hart has crafted a world ravaged by climate catastrophe, yet pulsing with imagination and raw emotional depth.
At the heart of the story is Erin, a brave and resilient young girl whose love for building scarecrows becomes her unlikely salvation. Her journey—from an isolated hilltop farm to the great unknown—is propelled not only by the desperate hope of finding her lost brother but by the companionship (and occasional menace) of Number Twelve, the final scarecrow and perhaps the most enigmatic character of them all.
The writing has a cinematic quality, with shades of Return to Oz and The Nightmare Before Christmas, but the story stands entirely on its own. Hart walks the line between whimsy and horror with remarkable grace, never shying away from darkness, yet always leaving room for light.
This is more than a dystopian fantasy—it's a story about holding onto love when the world washes away. For readers who enjoy bold storytelling, eerie magic, and characters that linger in your heart long after the final page, The Last Scarecrow is a must-read.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ — A triumph of imagination and emotion.
April 25, 2025
I picked this book up with my 11 year old daughter, convinced by her that she would be ok with the horror. Parts of it are scary - and some a little gruesome - but in my daughter's words, "that's why I loved it so much!" I read it after her, and she kept asking me which part I was up to, eager for me to reach her favourite parts.
The characters are really well developed, there is magic and whimsy, horror, adventure, triumph and devastation. Really, everything you could ever wish for in a middle-grade novel. Absolutely excellent.
I wouldn't have guessed that a story about a living scarecrow could get me so emotionally invested but...well...here we are. It's difficult to say more without giving away spoilers, but if you like classic children's stories with a pinch of horror, look no further!
The characters are really well developed, there is magic and whimsy, horror, adventure, triumph and devastation. Really, everything you could ever wish for in a middle-grade novel. Absolutely excellent.
I wouldn't have guessed that a story about a living scarecrow could get me so emotionally invested but...well...here we are. It's difficult to say more without giving away spoilers, but if you like classic children's stories with a pinch of horror, look no further!
October 9, 2025
The Last Scarecrow by Neil J. Hart is a wickedly brilliant heroine’s journey that had me rushing to turn the page and find out what eerie encounter Erin and her scarecrow protector, Number Twelve, would confront next.
The Many Years Storm has flooded the world but Erin, the last human girl, uses her cleverness, spunk, and grief to push herself to survive. Alone, heartbroken, and surrounded by the Endless Blue, her only hope is for her brother’s return. That is until the day something magical happens - birds start to talk and the most terrifying scarecrow on Coldharbour Farm comes alive! And so begins the adventure of Erin and Number Twelve.
This dark and beautiful, dystopian story was such an enjoyable read. There are so many things to love: Erin’s fierce heart and macabre sense of creativity, Number Twelve’s strength and love for Erin, the unique and grisly cast of characters, and the grim yet charming world building.
I would recommend this book to readers young and old alike who enjoy a darker fantasy adventure with a lot of heart.
The Many Years Storm has flooded the world but Erin, the last human girl, uses her cleverness, spunk, and grief to push herself to survive. Alone, heartbroken, and surrounded by the Endless Blue, her only hope is for her brother’s return. That is until the day something magical happens - birds start to talk and the most terrifying scarecrow on Coldharbour Farm comes alive! And so begins the adventure of Erin and Number Twelve.
This dark and beautiful, dystopian story was such an enjoyable read. There are so many things to love: Erin’s fierce heart and macabre sense of creativity, Number Twelve’s strength and love for Erin, the unique and grisly cast of characters, and the grim yet charming world building.
I would recommend this book to readers young and old alike who enjoy a darker fantasy adventure with a lot of heart.
May 4, 2024
r/Fantasy 2024 Book Bingo Challenge | Self-Published or Indie Publisher
What a pleasant surprise!
I was looking for a book to fill my “Self or Indie Published” space on Fantasy Bingo, and I found this ARC on BookSirens. The Wattpad Winner for Horror award intrigued me, and I can say it is well deserved! The story is captivating from the beginning, I easily sunk hours into reading this. For a horror book, this was surprisingly wholesome! I highly recommend giving this book a read :)
Thank you to BookSirens for this ARC.
What a pleasant surprise!
I was looking for a book to fill my “Self or Indie Published” space on Fantasy Bingo, and I found this ARC on BookSirens. The Wattpad Winner for Horror award intrigued me, and I can say it is well deserved! The story is captivating from the beginning, I easily sunk hours into reading this. For a horror book, this was surprisingly wholesome! I highly recommend giving this book a read :)
Thank you to BookSirens for this ARC.
June 9, 2024
I've been a fan of this book ever since reading it on Wattpad, and it is absolutely deserving of all its accolades! The Last Scarecrow takes you on a mesmerizing and emotional middle grade/YA journey with a unique plot, lovable characters, and imaginative (and perhaps a bit prophetic...) post-apocalyptic setting. Five stars!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 32 reviews