Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Ed Delahanty in the Emerald Age of Baseball

Rate this book
Jerrold Casway’s fascinating biography of legendary baseball player Ed Delahanty (1867–1903) offers a compelling examination of the first “King of Swatsville’s” life and career, including the enigma surrounding his tragic and untimely death. Through Delahanty’s story, Casway traces the evolving character of major league baseball and its effect on the lives and ambitions of its athletes.

Delahanty’s career spanned the last decades of the nineteenth century during a time when the sons of post-famine Irish refugees dominated the sport and changed the playing style of America’s national pastime. In this “Emerald Age” of baseball, Irish-American players comprised 30–50 percent of all players, managers, and team captains. Baseball for Delahanty and other young Irishmen was a ticket out of poverty and into a life of fame and fortune. The allure and promise of celebrity and wealth, however, were disastrous for Delahanty. He found himself enmeshed in desperate contract dealings and a gambling addiction that drove him to alcohol abuse. The owner of the fourth highest lifetime batting average, Delahanty mysteriously disappeared and was found at the bottom of Niagara’s Horseshoe Falls.

This rich biography, which relies on previously unavailable family papers and court transcripts, as well as the colorful sports reporting of the period, will appeal to anyone interested in baseball, sports, or Irish history.

400 pages, Paperback

First published February 28, 2004

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
8 (18%)
4 stars
24 (55%)
3 stars
10 (23%)
2 stars
1 (2%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews
Profile Image for bup.
771 reviews74 followers
May 15, 2023
Jerrold Casway wants everyone to call the late 1800's version of baseball "the Emerald Age" for its Irish predominance. He's got a good case, I guess. He throws out lots of data about how prevalent Irish ancestry was in the players and managers of the day, especially first generation immigrants. But I'm not sure he's going to make fetch happen. I've never heard it called "the Emerald Age" outside this book. So that's a little odd.

Oh! Ed Delahanty. It's a book about Ed Delahanty. He comes across as a tragic figure, whose fatal flaw is that he's emotionally stunted, self-absorbed, untrustworthy, and impulsive. He's not even likeable as an anti-hero, like Old Hoss Radbourn or John McGraw. He's just a right jerk.

But he played baseball very, very well.
Profile Image for Josh Avery.
269 reviews
October 29, 2026
Book 59 of 2026:

When I was a young lad, there was a book I had that went through three generations of baseball, the players of the modern times (for the late eighties at least), the players of the generation prior and the old timers, the golden age players. This book identified around fifty or so players from each era, with a brief statistical profile and life story of each player. I read this book probably a thousand times, wearing the spine out of it. There was one profile of a golden age player that I always read about, and his story and tragic death (more on that in a bit), as well as his stats just stood out to me, his name was Ed Delahanty. When I started looking into finding old books, I was hopeful to find one about him. This book, was written by an Irish historian and has a focus not on just Ed Delahanty, but also the Irish players that defined baseball in the nineteenth century, the dominant ethnic group of that time, where as many as forty percent of major league baseball rosters were of Irish descent.

Ed Delahanty was the oldest, and by far the best baseball player of five sons who all played in the major leagues. He was the pre-eminent power hitter of the nineteenth century, known for his prodigious power in an era where home runs were not as prevalent due to what was referred to as the "deadball" era. Baseballs were rough, poorly stitched, usually covered in mud and tobacco juice as the spitball was legal at that time. The balls would not travel well at all, making home runs extremely rare. He was routinely rated amongst the legendary hitters of the time, right up there with legends like Cap Anson, Napoleon Lajoie and Sam Thompson. He hit well over .400 six times, and had the fourth highest career batting average in the history of baseball at the time of his premature death, which is the most fascinating thing about him.

When his career first started, he stayed away from the vices of the time, wanting to put his money away for the future. He was also an extremely competitive and anxious person. He would let failure sit on him and it would effect his focus for extended periods of time. It was assumed that he had a lot of anxiety and depression at a time when that was not anything that was in the zeitgeist. As he got to be a better player, he would hop from team to team, from league to league going where the most money was. He eventually got used to a lifestyle, along with his wife, that was unsustainable. He would play the ponies a lot, way too much actually, mixed with the drinking and his wife's desire to keep her high end socialite lifestyle and he ended up broke. His drinking became so much of a problem that he was not allowed to travel with his team most of the time.

When he was a member of the Washington Senators, he was traveling by Pullman car through Niagra Falls to meet them and he had too much to drink, was causing trouble and was forcefully removed from the train just short of the falls. During a cold and windy night, he was walking on the bridge where pedestrians were not allowed, and one of the station agents went to try and escort him across the tracks, but he took it as an attack and went after the station agent, but lost his footing and fell into the icy waters below. His body did not come ashore until 170 days later and his suit was no longer on him. His family thought foul play was the cause, but that was never able to be proven.

What I liked: The entire story of Ed Delahanty is fascinating. He was a flawed man who was unable to fight his demons. Had he not died so tragically and so young, his name would be mentioned right along with names like Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner and Shoeless Joe Jackson as legends of the game's early years.

What I didn't like: He spent way too much time discussing a lot of the labor fights that happened amongst the players and owners in that time and it really had no impact on the story of Ed Delahanty or the impact of the Irish in the early days of baseball.

You obviously have to be a baseball history nerd to appreciate this book, as well as the story of Ed Delahanty. I enjoyed it, but the labor strife stuff bogged it down a bit.

B-
Profile Image for Chris Witt.
326 reviews10 followers
December 2, 2017
For those interested in Delahanty, Irish ballplayers or baseball in the late 19th century, kind of hard to think you wouldn't enjoy this read.
Profile Image for Mike.
50 reviews1 follower
April 6, 2010
Satisfying as a biography of great 19th century ballplayer Ed Delahanty but less satisfying as a history of the Irish impact on early baseball, Casway's book is a well-researched quick read that I thoroughly enjoyed. The only problems were the author's attempts to fit snippets of Irish baseball history into straightforward biographical chapters, making some sections of the book a little clumsy and forced.
Profile Image for Fred.
17 reviews1 follower
January 7, 2013
This was a phenomenal read, giving insight into a player I knew very little about and an era I never fully understood was so impacted by the Irish. the only thing I really knew about Ed was his ending, but it turned out I didn't even know much about that. as I read, it seemed impossible to me that he'd be heading for that end until it was right upon him, and I assume that's about how it went for him as well.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews