What do you think?
Rate this book
The Lost Photographs Of Captain Scott
Captain Scott perished with four of his fellow explorers on their return from the South Pole in March 1912. Almost immediately the myth was founded, based on Scott's diaries, turning him into an icon of courage in the face of impossible circumstances.
But during the final months of that journey Scott also took a series of breathtaking photographs: panoramas of the continent, superb depictions of mountains and formations of ice and snow, and photographs of the explorers on the polar trail. But these photos have never been seen - initially fought over, neglected, then lost - until now, that is. For the first time, they are resurrected and are a humbling testament to the men whose graves still lie unmarked in the vastness of the Great Alone.
But during the final months of that journey Scott also took a series of breathtaking photographs: panoramas of the continent, superb depictions of mountains and formations of ice and snow, and photographs of the explorers on the polar trail. But these photos have never been seen - initially fought over, neglected, then lost - until now, that is. For the first time, they are resurrected and are a humbling testament to the men whose graves still lie unmarked in the vastness of the Great Alone.
193 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2011
8 people are currently reading
392 people want to read
About the author
David M. Wilson
23 books7 followersDr. David M. Wilson, PhD (Essex), FZS, was born in 1963. Having an early career in the theatre, he moved on to study at the United World College of the Pacific and the Universities of York and Essex, where he trained as a philosopher. He is also a trained Counsellor. As well as a strong interest in Aboriginal cultures, he has wide natural history and ornithological interests. These led to ten years of working on expedition cruise ships, where he is in increasing demand both as an ornithological field guide and as an historian. He boasts numerous explorers and ornithologists on his family tree, which add a uniquely personal flavour to many of his talks. Not least amongst these is his great uncle, Dr. Edward Wilson, who died with Captain Scott and his party on their return from the South Pole in 1912. David spends much of his time working to promote our historic Antarctic heritage and is recently retired as Chairman of the Friends of the Scott Polar Research Institute in Cambridge, UK
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 19 of 19 reviews
May 30, 2014
A beautiful book. Not swamped with unnecessary information - after all those who are interested in Scott's expedition will have the relevant books already - but these images are, for the most part, heartbreaking.
Huge, double page photographs of ponies and dogs and the landscape.
Men striving to haul a huge sledge. The small intimacies of life: mending a sledge, chasing a pony, sketching a glacier, adjusting footwear.
The 'comments' are kept to the bare minimum and thus are all the more poignant.
'Many of the men in this image would return but not all. None of the ponies would: within a few days they would be shot.'
Huge, double page photographs of ponies and dogs and the landscape.
Men striving to haul a huge sledge. The small intimacies of life: mending a sledge, chasing a pony, sketching a glacier, adjusting footwear.
The 'comments' are kept to the bare minimum and thus are all the more poignant.
'Many of the men in this image would return but not all. None of the ponies would: within a few days they would be shot.'
October 10, 2011
Fantastic. Really fantastic. I wasn't sure what to expect from this one before I opened it up, but I suppose I assumed that the "Unseen Images from the Legendary Antarctic Expedition" would be accompanied by the usual retelling of Scott's last expedition and that there wouldn't really be much new to be learned from it, though I anticipated the photographs would be beautiful and haunting and, well, really interesting. Which they are. But what I really love, possibly even more than the images themselves, is the way that Wilson shows a different side of Scott's story, focusing on the use of photography at the time and the way Scott really kind of pioneered the use of it for scientific purposes in Antarctica. There's a narrative here, showing Scott's progression as a photographer over the course of the expedition under Herbert Ponting's tutelage, and Wilson does an excellent job of describing the significance of the pictures gathered here. He also discusses the various changes in Scott's reputation over the last 100 years, which is something I've always found really fascinating. And the presentation is gorgeous. Most definitely highly recommended for anyone interested in the history of Antarctic exploration or photography--well worth every penny and certainly a book I'll come back to again and again.
December 14, 2012
Some gorgeously haunting photographs -- even the one where Scott got his own shadow in the shot is beautiful in its way, a remnant of a man who you have to call remarkable, whatever your opinion of his endeavour and his execution thereof. Interesting detail with them, too, and accompanying maps and so on.
March 22, 2020
The British Discovery Expedition of 1911-1913 to Antarctica has been clouded by myths and misinformation for more than a century. The expedition was intended to be mostly scientific, but once the Norwegian explorer Roald Amundsen decided to try for the South Pole at the same time, a "race" for the pole was on. Robert Falcon Scott, famed British explorer, knew that the stakes were now exponentially high. If he lost the race for the pole, no one would remember or care about any scientific accomplishments his group might make.
Scott was right, but the fallout was worse than he could have imagined. His failure to reach the pole first, and his death on the way back allowed for a number of misleading or self-serving narratives: Scott was a bungler; he was the epitome of the stoic Edwardian hero; the expedition was only about the pole.
As this book amply demonstrates, science was foremost on Scott's mind. While Amundsen cared only about the pole, Scott's team was consistently performing scientific tasks as they headed towards the pole. Surely they hoped to be first, but there would be no shortcuts to get there. One area in which the Discovery Expedition made enormous contributions to human understanding of the Antarctic was in the use of the nascent field of photography. Led by Herbert Ponting, who in turn taught Scott and other team members, the expedition's haunting images gave the public a true understanding of the travails, beauty and danger of polar exploration.
Until the early 2000s, most of the photography from the expedition was either missing or misidentified. This book corrects this great misfortune. Scott, as it turns out, was a very good photograper who took Ponting's lessons and amply demonstrated a keen eye for composition and technique. This book also makes an excellent companion to Apsley Cherry-Gerrard's eyewitness account of the expedition, otherwise known as "The Worst Journey in the World." The maps and photographs provide both welcome and appropriate context in illustrating the awesome scope of the Expedition's undertaking. No one who is interested in polar exploration should be without this book.
Scott was right, but the fallout was worse than he could have imagined. His failure to reach the pole first, and his death on the way back allowed for a number of misleading or self-serving narratives: Scott was a bungler; he was the epitome of the stoic Edwardian hero; the expedition was only about the pole.
As this book amply demonstrates, science was foremost on Scott's mind. While Amundsen cared only about the pole, Scott's team was consistently performing scientific tasks as they headed towards the pole. Surely they hoped to be first, but there would be no shortcuts to get there. One area in which the Discovery Expedition made enormous contributions to human understanding of the Antarctic was in the use of the nascent field of photography. Led by Herbert Ponting, who in turn taught Scott and other team members, the expedition's haunting images gave the public a true understanding of the travails, beauty and danger of polar exploration.
Until the early 2000s, most of the photography from the expedition was either missing or misidentified. This book corrects this great misfortune. Scott, as it turns out, was a very good photograper who took Ponting's lessons and amply demonstrated a keen eye for composition and technique. This book also makes an excellent companion to Apsley Cherry-Gerrard's eyewitness account of the expedition, otherwise known as "The Worst Journey in the World." The maps and photographs provide both welcome and appropriate context in illustrating the awesome scope of the Expedition's undertaking. No one who is interested in polar exploration should be without this book.
November 20, 2024
A robust defence of Scott - great stuff!
February 5, 2012
The Lost Photographs of Captain Scott by David M. Wilson, while based on the recent rediscovery of photographs taken during Robert Scott's ill-fated Antarctic expedition of 1910-1913, is really a meditation on reputation and remembrance.
"I am just going outside and may be some time". These words, uttered by expedition member Lawrence Oates before he sacrificed himself to save his companions on the trek back from the pole, have always chilled me. We know of this only because Scott wrote about the incident in his diary. Of course, Oates' sacrifice came to naught; Scott and his companions died just eleven miles short of the depot that could have saved their lives. From one point of view, this is all of piece: Scott failed to reach the pole before Amundsen; unlike Shackleton, he failed to keep his companions alive; and failed to keep himself alive. Racing to the South Pole may be the ultimate boy's own adventure, but Scott bungled it.
Or did he? For that matter, what was he racing towards? Wilson argues that there was no race, at least not one that Scott cared about. The polar expeditions of the 19th and early 20th centuries were undertaken for a variety of motives, with a tension between exploration qua adventure and exploration for scientific purposes. Scott conceived of his expedition as a scientific one; while it may have been necessary for fundraising and publicity to promote a goal of reaching the pole first and planting the King's flag on it, Scott was more interested in the geographic and scientific discoveries that the trip could reveal.
To that end, Scott hired Herbert Ponting as expedition photographer and gave him a free hand to equip the expedition with all of the photographic equipment necessary for scientific purposes. Ponting was perhaps one of Scott's best hires; not only did he innovate techniques for using very awkward photographic equipment under harsh conditions to produce gorgeous results, he trained Scott and other expedition members to be passable polar photographers as well. However, as Ponting was not up to the rigors of the run to the Pole, in 1912 he returned home to catalog the photographs and await Scott's return to mount an exhibition.
By the time Ponting reached England, Scott was already dead. Ponting's own plans came to naught. The absence of Scott, wrangling over the rights to the photographs, and the advent of World War I served to bury Ponting's photographs as well as the ones taken by Scott himself. Besides, why would the martyr's photographs be of more interest than the martyr himself? By the latter part of the 20th century, Scott's reputation had fallen under attack. Why would a bungler's pics be of any interest? Moreover, where was a competent archivist to be found? Nowhere.
Reality Rating B+: It, perhaps, was not until now, with recent efforts to rehabilitate or at least re-vision Scott's reputation that there was fertile ground for the rediscovery of these photographs. Wilson tells a tale that is bittersweet on many levels and places Scott and his final expedition in the center of some important dichotomies. The book is also visually stunning.
Caveat: My review copy of this book was a PDF from NetGalley. As it turned out, this is not a book that works well on current ebook readers. Attempting to read it on my iPad was a rather frustrating experience, and until Apple comes out with the iCoffeeTable or unless you have a very large monitor, if you buy this book ... get it in print.
"I am just going outside and may be some time". These words, uttered by expedition member Lawrence Oates before he sacrificed himself to save his companions on the trek back from the pole, have always chilled me. We know of this only because Scott wrote about the incident in his diary. Of course, Oates' sacrifice came to naught; Scott and his companions died just eleven miles short of the depot that could have saved their lives. From one point of view, this is all of piece: Scott failed to reach the pole before Amundsen; unlike Shackleton, he failed to keep his companions alive; and failed to keep himself alive. Racing to the South Pole may be the ultimate boy's own adventure, but Scott bungled it.
Or did he? For that matter, what was he racing towards? Wilson argues that there was no race, at least not one that Scott cared about. The polar expeditions of the 19th and early 20th centuries were undertaken for a variety of motives, with a tension between exploration qua adventure and exploration for scientific purposes. Scott conceived of his expedition as a scientific one; while it may have been necessary for fundraising and publicity to promote a goal of reaching the pole first and planting the King's flag on it, Scott was more interested in the geographic and scientific discoveries that the trip could reveal.
To that end, Scott hired Herbert Ponting as expedition photographer and gave him a free hand to equip the expedition with all of the photographic equipment necessary for scientific purposes. Ponting was perhaps one of Scott's best hires; not only did he innovate techniques for using very awkward photographic equipment under harsh conditions to produce gorgeous results, he trained Scott and other expedition members to be passable polar photographers as well. However, as Ponting was not up to the rigors of the run to the Pole, in 1912 he returned home to catalog the photographs and await Scott's return to mount an exhibition.
By the time Ponting reached England, Scott was already dead. Ponting's own plans came to naught. The absence of Scott, wrangling over the rights to the photographs, and the advent of World War I served to bury Ponting's photographs as well as the ones taken by Scott himself. Besides, why would the martyr's photographs be of more interest than the martyr himself? By the latter part of the 20th century, Scott's reputation had fallen under attack. Why would a bungler's pics be of any interest? Moreover, where was a competent archivist to be found? Nowhere.
Reality Rating B+: It, perhaps, was not until now, with recent efforts to rehabilitate or at least re-vision Scott's reputation that there was fertile ground for the rediscovery of these photographs. Wilson tells a tale that is bittersweet on many levels and places Scott and his final expedition in the center of some important dichotomies. The book is also visually stunning.
Caveat: My review copy of this book was a PDF from NetGalley. As it turned out, this is not a book that works well on current ebook readers. Attempting to read it on my iPad was a rather frustrating experience, and until Apple comes out with the iCoffeeTable or unless you have a very large monitor, if you buy this book ... get it in print.
March 3, 2016
The Terra Nova expedition (1910-1913) was Captain Robert F. Scott's second, and final (fatal), attempt at the South Pole. This time around, he brought along professional photographer Herbert Ponting to stay at the base camp and teach Scott, and several others, how to take and develop photographs in the harsh Antarctic environment so that the group could document their scientific endeavors. Not all of Scott's photographs survived, but Wilson gathers up as many as he can and does a solid job of placing them in context.
David Wilson is the great nephew of Edward A. Wilson, a doctor and artist, and the expedition's chief of scientific staff. Dr. Wilson died in 1912 on the return from the pole, and the author is perhaps not all that objective about Scott. One might argue he has a personal stake in Scott being a visionary, a "forward thinker"—as Wilson puts it—rather than a traditional one and the last of the great Victorian explorers, with his man-hauled sledges and dogged pursuit of science in the face of certain death. The author's defensive of Scott and his choices and gets downright bitchy about Shackleton at one point. But Scott's defenders often do, so he's not exactly alone in that. I've seen some nasty things said about Amundsen, too, as many of Scott's fans believe Amundsen stole the pole from him by...getting there faster.
So while the scholarship is questionable (and I caught at least one factual error), the photos are interesting, and they're carefully identified and cross-referenced. The paper's thick and glossy, and the black and white photographs look beautiful. Each photo has a caption to identify (or guess at) landmarks and figures, with a catalogue number and date, if known.
This is a large book, almost a foot square. It shows the photos to their best advantage, but the text is in two columns per page, and is sometimes split across several pages with full-page photographs in between, making it difficult to read. There's no index for the text, but there is a picture index with thumbnails and captions, and relevant page numbers. The text makes good use of end notes with citations for every quote, and when photographs are referenced in the text, the author gives a page number where you can find the photo. I was really impressed with how well the photographs are linked to the text. There was never a moment where I thought to myself, angrily, "What picture is he talking about?!" because without fail Wilson points the reader right to it.
While Wilson's prose is a bit melodramatic, and potentially biased, this is a remarkable visual record of the expedition's day-to-day life at Cape Evans and the camps between it and the pole, as well as the unique challenge of taking photographs in an environment where you get instant frostbite if you take off your gloves, and if you accidentally touch your metal camera with your bare skin, that part of you now belongs to the camera. Knowing what these men went through to take these photographs makes them all the more remarkable, and Wilson encourages the reader to pick up a copy of Scott's diary, often published as Scott's Last Expedition, as a companion to this book; he quotes from it frequently to provide context for the photographs.
David Wilson is the great nephew of Edward A. Wilson, a doctor and artist, and the expedition's chief of scientific staff. Dr. Wilson died in 1912 on the return from the pole, and the author is perhaps not all that objective about Scott. One might argue he has a personal stake in Scott being a visionary, a "forward thinker"—as Wilson puts it—rather than a traditional one and the last of the great Victorian explorers, with his man-hauled sledges and dogged pursuit of science in the face of certain death. The author's defensive of Scott and his choices and gets downright bitchy about Shackleton at one point. But Scott's defenders often do, so he's not exactly alone in that. I've seen some nasty things said about Amundsen, too, as many of Scott's fans believe Amundsen stole the pole from him by...getting there faster.
So while the scholarship is questionable (and I caught at least one factual error), the photos are interesting, and they're carefully identified and cross-referenced. The paper's thick and glossy, and the black and white photographs look beautiful. Each photo has a caption to identify (or guess at) landmarks and figures, with a catalogue number and date, if known.
This is a large book, almost a foot square. It shows the photos to their best advantage, but the text is in two columns per page, and is sometimes split across several pages with full-page photographs in between, making it difficult to read. There's no index for the text, but there is a picture index with thumbnails and captions, and relevant page numbers. The text makes good use of end notes with citations for every quote, and when photographs are referenced in the text, the author gives a page number where you can find the photo. I was really impressed with how well the photographs are linked to the text. There was never a moment where I thought to myself, angrily, "What picture is he talking about?!" because without fail Wilson points the reader right to it.
While Wilson's prose is a bit melodramatic, and potentially biased, this is a remarkable visual record of the expedition's day-to-day life at Cape Evans and the camps between it and the pole, as well as the unique challenge of taking photographs in an environment where you get instant frostbite if you take off your gloves, and if you accidentally touch your metal camera with your bare skin, that part of you now belongs to the camera. Knowing what these men went through to take these photographs makes them all the more remarkable, and Wilson encourages the reader to pick up a copy of Scott's diary, often published as Scott's Last Expedition, as a companion to this book; he quotes from it frequently to provide context for the photographs.
February 11, 2017
Nearly a century after his death during the ill-fated Terra Nova expedition to the South Pole, Captain Robert Falcon Scott remains a figure of controversy. Though initially lionized, Scott was later criticized by historians for a lack of preparation and foresight. Now David M. Wilson (Edward Wilson's Nature Notebooks), the great-nephew of an expedition member, uses Scott's own recovered photographs to recount the deadly journey.
Scott, who had been trained in photography by the expedition's official cameraman, captured eerily beautiful images of the alien Antarctic panorama. Ponies struggle through crusted snow while small supply camps stand alone against the bright, frosty horizon. Wilson's accompanying text uses the words of Scott and his crew to recreate the choices and hardships that led them to their doom. More than an adventure story, The Lost Photographs is an artifact from the dawn of photography as art, suitable for historians and photography enthusiasts alike.
***This review originally appeared in Shelf Awareness Readers Edition. Sign up for this free and awesome newsletter at http://www.shelf-awareness.com for the latest news and reviews! This review refers to an ARC provided by Shelf Awareness.***
Scott, who had been trained in photography by the expedition's official cameraman, captured eerily beautiful images of the alien Antarctic panorama. Ponies struggle through crusted snow while small supply camps stand alone against the bright, frosty horizon. Wilson's accompanying text uses the words of Scott and his crew to recreate the choices and hardships that led them to their doom. More than an adventure story, The Lost Photographs is an artifact from the dawn of photography as art, suitable for historians and photography enthusiasts alike.
***This review originally appeared in Shelf Awareness Readers Edition. Sign up for this free and awesome newsletter at http://www.shelf-awareness.com for the latest news and reviews! This review refers to an ARC provided by Shelf Awareness.***
January 17, 2012
Not a lot of new information in here for anyone who's familiar with Antarctic exploration, though there are some interesting notes about what happened in later years to some members of the expedition, particularly Ponting. The main reason to check this out is the photos, which really help the reader understand what the conditions were like. I think the most notable pictures are several photos of a group man-hauling a sledge up the Beardmore Glacier; the photos demonstrate how awful and difficult man-hauling really was. Another favorite is a photo of Dr. Wilson sketching a line of mountains on the Beardmore, with a copy of his actual sketch juxtaposed on the page for reference. The photo shows how amazingly accurate his sketches were. (Side note: the book's author is Wilson's great nephew.)
Definitely worth leafing through for anyone interested in Scott's expedition, but if you're looking for details about the expedition there are much better books out there. I recommend The Last Place on Earth: Scott and Amundsen's Race to the South Pole.
Definitely worth leafing through for anyone interested in Scott's expedition, but if you're looking for details about the expedition there are much better books out there. I recommend The Last Place on Earth: Scott and Amundsen's Race to the South Pole.
December 10, 2014
This beautiful book compiles photos of Scott's ill-fated journey to the South Pole in 1912. The expedition photographer, Herbert Ponting, did not accompany Scott's team to the pole, so Ponting taught Scott to use his camera. Previous expeditions had relied on artists to draw landscapes and geological features. Scott was not an expert photographer, but captured details of the journey that bring the people and ponies to life. The photos of men hauling sledges through deep snow and ice show how incredibly difficult the conditions were. When I bought this book, I was already reading Apsley Cherry-Garrard's 'The worst journey in the world' and found the two to be excellent companions. 'The lost photographs of Captain Scott' includes several maps which help with understanding Cherry-Garrard's account, and Cherry-Garrard's book describes some events (such as the desperate sledge-hauling) that Scott captured in photos.
Read
March 13, 2013Robert F. Scott was as poor a photographer as he was an expedition leader. Nevertheless, his work in both fields remains of not inconsiderable historical value and great interest to Antarctic enthusiasts. This new book publishes previously unknown photographic plates taken by Scott during theTerra Nova Expedition (1910-1912) on which he died. The "coffee table book" has a bad reputation among genuine students if polar history, but I found this one to be an exception to the rule. Several good essays and the unusual provenance of the photographs make for a well-done illustrated account of the expedition. A bit pricey but truly unique.
May 21, 2012
3 stars/Non-Fiction; Photography
I enjoyed this little walk back into history to read about Captain Scott and view some of his images of his expedition to Antartica in the early 1900's. Unfortunately, he underestimated the conditions of the environment he was working in and perished as a result of it.
This book gives you a glimpse of what Captain Scott and his team endured throughout their journey to capture the images. It is apparent through the information presented that they were all very brave to have attempted such a trip.
I enjoyed this little walk back into history to read about Captain Scott and view some of his images of his expedition to Antartica in the early 1900's. Unfortunately, he underestimated the conditions of the environment he was working in and perished as a result of it.
This book gives you a glimpse of what Captain Scott and his team endured throughout their journey to capture the images. It is apparent through the information presented that they were all very brave to have attempted such a trip.
October 19, 2011
Beautiful pictures! I shared the book with my family and we sat together while looking at the pictures. Truly amazing!
July 2, 2012
I couldn't resist. The moment I saw it I knew I had to get it. It's wonderful! And the photos are AMAZING :D
Read
January 3, 2013Also couldn't resist
February 2, 2015
Captain Scott and his team are heroes with tragedy.
April 24, 2015
Pretty dang cool book. If you like this kind of thing (historical photos along with diary entries), you'll be intrigued and engrossed.
September 28, 2016
This book has been beautifully put together. I knew in the end that Captain Scott did not survive but I kept hoping that his story had a better ending.
April 23, 2017
This was a great book. It really expands on the Scott expedition and sheds new light on it, without going outside of its purview. The images were amazing, and I loved the details about the difficulties in photographing in the polar regions during that era.
Displaying 1 - 19 of 19 reviews