This book was a mixed bag, so I think a classic “Things I Liked” and “Things I Didn’t Like” list is the best way to explain my thoughts.
Things I Liked:
1. The photography and art design. This is book is simply beautiful. Designer Tai Blanche and photographer Christy Czajkowski did a fantastic job. Skimming through these pages is an exercise in total aesthetic delight.
2. The format. I like how the book is laid out, season by season, and how each chapter follows a pattern — description of the season, followed by rituals, and concluding with community action. It makes it a very easy book to digest and absorb.
3. The overall message of this book. Religion and faith practice is about many things, but the two main things (I think) are finding inner peace and guidance, and using that guidance to make this world a better place. That is also Erica Feldmann’s perspective, and this book does a good job elaborating on this.
Things I Didn’t Like
1. The lingo. I have never enjoyed books that use casual phraseology like “lol” or random all-caps words. It comes off more like a blog post than a published book. I know the author is going for a casual, approachable tone, but I think the “hey, girlfriend!” language serves to make her ideas sound cheap and unintelligent.
2. The broad, sweeping statements. I’m all about critiquing organized religion; I do it very often! But sometimes, Feldmann overgeneralizes, acting as though pre-Christian folk religion is all empowerment all the time and Judeo-Christian influence is all rules and restrictions. There’s truth in this binary, but it’s not so simple, and I found myself rolling my eyes more than a few times when this blunt dichotomy was expressed.
3. I don’t think paganism is for me. That’s not a critique of this book, but rather something I realized in reading this book. I absolutely love the vision and aesthetics of paganism, especially of the Celtic variety. But in modern times, it tends to lack a central focus, devolving into “just do what feels good and get connected with nature”. Which is a good thing! But it’s not enough for me to want to study it in-depth. I may still pick up texts like these to explore, especially texts as visually beautiful as this one. But as far as I can tell, modern Western paganism does not have any firm center that I can grasp onto and create a worldview from. It’s still fun, though.
This is a good book to pick up and read either very thoroughly and skim through, depending on your needs. Feldmann has a warm personality that shines through the text, and once again I’ll say, it’s just such a pretty book. If you see it on your library shelf, check it out.