Usually before writing a review, I have it perfectly outlined in my mind – not this time around.
While reading “Debts and Desires” I went back and forth between loving it, marveling about the ingenuity of the author and impatiently tapping my foot waiting for the story to end.
As with all other stories maybe it is best if we start at the beginning. I was spellbound by the first page, truly, couldn’t put it down. In the dark romance genre authors often run two risks:
1: Overdoing the smut
2: Underdoing the darkness
For the first 40% or so the main characters, Emogen and Carter, fornicate at a pace I have never come across before – and I’ve been on Wattpad since 2016. Yet, it still doesn’t get to much, because the smut is sort of the plot. Them going at it is vital for the plot to progress. I think this is nothing short of genius. Sometimes I feel like spicy scenes are constructed without minding the actual story but more as an afterthought under the title “This could be hot!” or as a weak attempt of providing a character with a personality by giving them a kink. This is certainly not the case here. At the beginning I loved the spice, but I must admit I was probably blinded by how it was woven into the storyline and later how it was specific to the environment of the story, rather than I enjoyed the actual smut.
I mean it was not bad, there was just a lot, which meant it became very much the same. And though I think the frequency decreased a bit, there were still too much, especially after the 40-50% mark where their relationship developed, and I would have preferred that the author put the sex on the back burner so other aspects of their relationship could shine through.
I know I sound like a total hypocrite complaining about the sheer amount of smut (and I know some of you freaks a probably gonna read it because I said there were too much 😉) and that’s okay. But don’t say I didn’t warn you.
Now, the second point on the agenda – not enough darkness. This book scarred me, because at the beginning it was dark in a way I have never seen before (Again I’d like to point out that I’ve been on Wattpad for 8 years).
Usually, the element of darkness derives from the psychopathic traits of the MMC, which is mirrored in his day-to-day profession (Crime lord, mercenary, English football player – the list goes on). Sometimes the MMC is not even that psychotic – he is just suppressing his emotions. Carter is a mechanic and a tow truck driver, meaning that he is the nice guy down the road that always saves your ass. His everyday life doesn’t involve murdering people that cross his territory or being a professional hot head. This book is veiled in darkness due to the social environment; it is dark because one can in fact be deranged soul with a normal day job. Like people like this could walk undetected among us.
Though it is still fiction, so a degree of unbelievability is allowed, I could totally see the conditioning of their agreement happening in real life. I do not include spoilers but lets just say that Emogen can’t pay with neither cash nor card and that leaves her with very few options, very little room for negotiation and Carter takes full advantage of that. To me this is a scary darkness, because it could happen. It made my skin crawl when Carter continued to find loopholes in their agreement and Emogen lulled herself into a sense of safety. As always the element of real life scares me more than fiction.
The, for me, new take on how to make a romance dark was (just like the smut) was better executed in the first bit of the story. In the later half… I mean crazy things happen, but nothing I really didn’t see coming. And because the pacing of the last 20% is very choppy, the erring creepy vibes the first half had don’t come across very well. I can’t quit decide if I think everything was solved a bit too fast or too slow. On one hand, the story really dragged on after the 50% mark for me, but on the other hand I don’t think the author succeeded with wrapping up all the loose ends in a way that made the first half justice. Just so there is no speculation on the matter; she did not forget parts of the plot everything is accounted for in the end – so no complaints there. But since the bulk of the non-smutty plot plays out in the end, the book progresses very fast. Up until this point the characters had been well developed in my eyes, but their ability to forgive and not get overwhelmed did not translate to perseverance but rather to a one-dimensionality.
Had this story ended before the majority of the non-sexual plot took place I would have given it 5 stars, but it didn’t. Truthfully, I think removing a few sex scenes from the second half and making the scenes important for the main plot longer, would up the rating for me, since this would reduce the pacing issue.
At the end of the day, this book still got a good rating – because I liked it – and because when I asked myself: “Would I tell my friends about it?” The answer where “Hell yeah!”
A wicked dark romance book with an actual plot and imaginative sex scenes in a mechanics shop (I learned a new thing or two about tools…) – it would be a crime to keep it all for myself.
I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.