What do you think?
Rate this book
Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor
Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None meets The Gilded Age in this delicious, suspenseful murder mystery.
When Lady Emma Grace Hastings receives a much-coveted invitation to the most auspicious Christmas party of the season—one that comes with a 10,000 pound prize for the winner of a mysterious game—she cannot believe her good fortune.
But as the guests are assembled at Mistlethwaite Manor, the chilling intent of the game is revealed. Each guest has cause for alarm, because all of them have secrets, and to win the prize money, those secrets must be exposed.
Things take a sinister turn when Emma Grace finds herself caught between her old love and her soon-to-be betrothed. Suspicions abound, and old wounds are opened. The dead body in the study does not help. Nor does the raging winter storm that prevents escape from the manor. Emma Grace must battle her heart, use her wits, and put her sleuthing skills to the test to survive the weekend alive.
Because there is a murderer among them.
And no one with secrets is safe.
When Lady Emma Grace Hastings receives a much-coveted invitation to the most auspicious Christmas party of the season—one that comes with a 10,000 pound prize for the winner of a mysterious game—she cannot believe her good fortune.
But as the guests are assembled at Mistlethwaite Manor, the chilling intent of the game is revealed. Each guest has cause for alarm, because all of them have secrets, and to win the prize money, those secrets must be exposed.
Things take a sinister turn when Emma Grace finds herself caught between her old love and her soon-to-be betrothed. Suspicions abound, and old wounds are opened. The dead body in the study does not help. Nor does the raging winter storm that prevents escape from the manor. Emma Grace must battle her heart, use her wits, and put her sleuthing skills to the test to survive the weekend alive.
Because there is a murderer among them.
And no one with secrets is safe.
210 pages, Kindle Edition
Published June 26, 2024
76 people are currently reading
278 people want to read
About the author
A.J. Skelly
37 books162 followersAJ Skelly (also writing as April J. Skelly) is an author, reader, and lover of all things fantasy, medieval, and fairy-tale-romance. And werewolves. She has a serious soft spot for them. As an avid life-long reader and a former high school English teacher, she's always been fascinated with the written word. She lives with her husband, children, and many imaginary friends who often find their way into her stories. They all drink copious amounts of tea together and stay up reading far later than they should.
You can read more of her short stories at www.ajskelly.com.
You can read more of her short stories at www.ajskelly.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 90 reviews
November 28, 2024
1 star ✨ (really disappointed that I didn’t care for this one!)
Really should have been called Murder s at Mistlethwaite Manor because there’s a lot of murders that happened through these 210 pages. 😅 I know the back cover says Agatha Christie-style, but all I could think about was the 1980s Clue movie, personally. Now, yes, Clue was inspired by Agatha Christie, so that all makes sense but I’m not super familiar with her books (having partially read And Then There We’re None before ultimately not finishing it due to feeling depressed while reading) so it was more of that movie (down to certain details) that really reminded me while reading with more characters. I did make use of the search feature in my Kindle to keep tract of who everyone was and their stories because ten party goers made for lots of information.
Unfortunately this was a miss for me. There was a bit too many sexual innuendoes (particularly relating to a couple having an affair and Emma Grace's intended's icky comments there at the end) which I didn’t care for reading at all. Also a heavy kiss and another one with a tongue which was…uncomfortable for this reader. 😬
I was disappointed that the riddle isn’t fully solved by our main character, but because she finds the notes/papers from the Master of the Manor. It kind of took the wind out of the sails in trying to figure it out, though, it was close to the end. She—and we, the readers—can guess a couple as the book continues, but the papers gave most of the others away and then the ending drama happens. I think this could have been fleshed out a bit better by being longer, but at the same time I’m not it wasn’t longer because of the content I mentioned above.
There was also quite a bit of repetition in how people, things, or events are described that got to be a little much. Such as Emma Grace correcting herself multiple times in the first handful of chapters about her former fiancé’s name or seeing stars/dots when something shocking happens. They both happened a lot and it started to get annoying. 😅
I had higher hopes for this book because of the Victorian murder mystery elements, but it was an unfortunate miss for me. I’m sure others will enjoy it, but I didn’t care for some of the content which greatly affected my enjoyment and rating. I dislike giving a low star to a new-to-me author and a smaller publisher, but I hope there’s maybe some constructive comments in this review. I will add that I liked that there were portraits of the cast of characters at the beginning of this book.
Main Content-
Someone says “God rest their souls”; A woman calls a man a “heathen” due to his comment; Some believe a man’s ghost is haunting them to take out his wrath on them; A few mentions of comments about the Manor being cursed; A mention of a woman crossing herself “as if to ward off evil”; A mention of something licking at Emma Grace like the “flaming tongues of the underworld”.
Finding and seeing murdered bodies (with describing their conditions plus a suicide), Seeing fights/fighting, Gunshots and seeing others shot, Pain, Injuries, Blood/Bleeding, & Throwing up (up to a handful of sentences on the bodies, lighter on her own injuries); There is a riddle showcasing all the party goers’ sins such as being illegitimate, having an affair, a woman without her innocence, and being fooled (it is the main point of this party to figure out which one everyone fits).
No major language but there are some insults said; Curses are said by side characters but not written out; “Hellish” is used to describe these events; “What in the blue blazes”, “Shove off”, “Hang/blast it all”, “Blasted”, “Thank heavens”, and “Saints preserve us” are said (the latter by a hateful woman); Some eye rolling & Sarcasm; Emma Grace recalls always being told that she is a “mere woman” and should let the men in her life make her decisions, but says no more to that and is determined to make her own course.
Many mentions of murders, the murderer, the bodies, how the murders happened (stabbing, strangulation, being hit over the head, being pushed down stairs, & also a suicide), blood/bleeding, brain matter, the weapons, pain, injuries, gunshots, & being shot (up to a few sentences in details); Many mentions of alcohol, drinking, & a party guest drinking a lot often throughout the book and being drunk; Mentions of suicides (including one that is discussed on-page); Mentions of stealing & thieves; mo threats & blackmail; Mentions of lies, lying, & liars; Mentions of throwing up; A few mentions of other deaths & grief; A few mentions of gambling.
1 hand kiss,
2 forehead kisses,
1 nose kiss,
2 kisses lasting a sentence,
2 kisses lasting a couple sentences,
2 kisses lasting 6+ sentences (one mentioning tongues),
1 kiss lasting 10+ sentences (three paragraphs),
Remembering kisses (up to a couple sentences); Desire & Longing; Staring a lips;
Touches, Embraces, Hand holding, Warmth, Shivers, Electricity, Nearness, Smelling, & Noticing (including muscles, up to a few sentences).
One line of the riddle is about a young woman who isn’t innocent (meaning pure) and Emma Grace is concerned that it could be about her giving her first kiss away to a man she is no longer with (this is her thoughts for most of the book and comments from others question her or the other women’s’ innocence); Emma Grace’s intended asks another man Emma Grace was engaged to prior if she is still innocent (she thinks about how he is questioning her virginity); Emma Grace thinks about it being expected that a bride is completely pure on her wedding day and how she gave away her first kiss to a man and nows feels ruined because of no longer being with that man (and then a flashback to that first kiss happens); Two of the women believe that Emma Grace could be the murderer so they make her change her clothing in front of them (one calling her a sinful creature for not being embarrassed, saying that she’s wanton and a woman of loose morals, and one makes snide comments about her).
Emma Grace’s intended goes into her room and stares at the corset on her bed while licking his lips and touching it (he later tells her that he can’t wait to see her in it); Emma Grace and the others come across a woman who is half-dressed and more skin than acceptable at this time, implying a romance tryst (also adding about her and her lover having a moment and it being common for him to put his hands around her throat when they were intimate); Suggestions and sexual innuendoes towards a couple having an affair and towards Emma Grace (some of the comments about “married things” causes Emma Grace to blush).
Mentions of an affair and the couple being caught, plus hints to “carnal pleasure” about them (another man says it’s not any great offense when a gentleman has an affair as long as they aren’t caught); Mentions of someone born on the “wrong side of the sheets” (illegitimate) & Emma Grace is concerned it could be her; Mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of a man making unwanted and lascivious verbal advances towards Emma Grace.
Really should have been called Murder s at Mistlethwaite Manor because there’s a lot of murders that happened through these 210 pages. 😅 I know the back cover says Agatha Christie-style, but all I could think about was the 1980s Clue movie, personally. Now, yes, Clue was inspired by Agatha Christie, so that all makes sense but I’m not super familiar with her books (having partially read And Then There We’re None before ultimately not finishing it due to feeling depressed while reading) so it was more of that movie (down to certain details) that really reminded me while reading with more characters. I did make use of the search feature in my Kindle to keep tract of who everyone was and their stories because ten party goers made for lots of information.
Unfortunately this was a miss for me. There was a bit too many sexual innuendoes (particularly relating to a couple having an affair and Emma Grace's intended's icky comments there at the end) which I didn’t care for reading at all. Also a heavy kiss and another one with a tongue which was…uncomfortable for this reader. 😬
I was disappointed that the riddle isn’t fully solved by our main character, but because she finds the notes/papers from the Master of the Manor. It kind of took the wind out of the sails in trying to figure it out, though, it was close to the end. She—and we, the readers—can guess a couple as the book continues, but the papers gave most of the others away and then the ending drama happens. I think this could have been fleshed out a bit better by being longer, but at the same time I’m not it wasn’t longer because of the content I mentioned above.
There was also quite a bit of repetition in how people, things, or events are described that got to be a little much. Such as Emma Grace correcting herself multiple times in the first handful of chapters about her former fiancé’s name or seeing stars/dots when something shocking happens. They both happened a lot and it started to get annoying. 😅
I had higher hopes for this book because of the Victorian murder mystery elements, but it was an unfortunate miss for me. I’m sure others will enjoy it, but I didn’t care for some of the content which greatly affected my enjoyment and rating. I dislike giving a low star to a new-to-me author and a smaller publisher, but I hope there’s maybe some constructive comments in this review. I will add that I liked that there were portraits of the cast of characters at the beginning of this book.
Main Content-
Someone says “God rest their souls”; A woman calls a man a “heathen” due to his comment; Some believe a man’s ghost is haunting them to take out his wrath on them; A few mentions of comments about the Manor being cursed; A mention of a woman crossing herself “as if to ward off evil”; A mention of something licking at Emma Grace like the “flaming tongues of the underworld”.
Finding and seeing murdered bodies (with describing their conditions plus a suicide), Seeing fights/fighting, Gunshots and seeing others shot, Pain, Injuries, Blood/Bleeding, & Throwing up (up to a handful of sentences on the bodies, lighter on her own injuries); There is a riddle showcasing all the party goers’ sins such as being illegitimate, having an affair, a woman without her innocence, and being fooled (it is the main point of this party to figure out which one everyone fits).
No major language but there are some insults said; Curses are said by side characters but not written out; “Hellish” is used to describe these events; “What in the blue blazes”, “Shove off”, “Hang/blast it all”, “Blasted”, “Thank heavens”, and “Saints preserve us” are said (the latter by a hateful woman); Some eye rolling & Sarcasm; Emma Grace recalls always being told that she is a “mere woman” and should let the men in her life make her decisions, but says no more to that and is determined to make her own course.
Many mentions of murders, the murderer, the bodies, how the murders happened (stabbing, strangulation, being hit over the head, being pushed down stairs, & also a suicide), blood/bleeding, brain matter, the weapons, pain, injuries, gunshots, & being shot (up to a few sentences in details); Many mentions of alcohol, drinking, & a party guest drinking a lot often throughout the book and being drunk; Mentions of suicides (including one that is discussed on-page); Mentions of stealing & thieves; mo threats & blackmail; Mentions of lies, lying, & liars; Mentions of throwing up; A few mentions of other deaths & grief; A few mentions of gambling.
1 hand kiss,
2 forehead kisses,
1 nose kiss,
2 kisses lasting a sentence,
2 kisses lasting a couple sentences,
2 kisses lasting 6+ sentences (one mentioning tongues),
1 kiss lasting 10+ sentences (three paragraphs),
Remembering kisses (up to a couple sentences); Desire & Longing; Staring a lips;
Touches, Embraces, Hand holding, Warmth, Shivers, Electricity, Nearness, Smelling, & Noticing (including muscles, up to a few sentences).
One line of the riddle is about a young woman who isn’t innocent (meaning pure) and Emma Grace is concerned that it could be about her giving her first kiss away to a man she is no longer with (this is her thoughts for most of the book and comments from others question her or the other women’s’ innocence); Emma Grace’s intended asks another man Emma Grace was engaged to prior if she is still innocent (she thinks about how he is questioning her virginity); Emma Grace thinks about it being expected that a bride is completely pure on her wedding day and how she gave away her first kiss to a man and nows feels ruined because of no longer being with that man (and then a flashback to that first kiss happens); Two of the women believe that Emma Grace could be the murderer so they make her change her clothing in front of them (one calling her a sinful creature for not being embarrassed, saying that she’s wanton and a woman of loose morals, and one makes snide comments about her).
Emma Grace’s intended goes into her room and stares at the corset on her bed while licking his lips and touching it (he later tells her that he can’t wait to see her in it); Emma Grace and the others come across a woman who is half-dressed and more skin than acceptable at this time, implying a romance tryst (also adding about her and her lover having a moment and it being common for him to put his hands around her throat when they were intimate); Suggestions and sexual innuendoes towards a couple having an affair and towards Emma Grace (some of the comments about “married things” causes Emma Grace to blush).
Mentions of an affair and the couple being caught, plus hints to “carnal pleasure” about them (another man says it’s not any great offense when a gentleman has an affair as long as they aren’t caught); Mentions of someone born on the “wrong side of the sheets” (illegitimate) & Emma Grace is concerned it could be her; Mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of a man making unwanted and lascivious verbal advances towards Emma Grace.
July 6, 2025
3.5⭐️ rounded up.
I enjoyed this story despite it not being my usual genre. I listened to the audiobook, however, and I think I would have enjoyed a print copy more. I felt like the reader read the MC in a tone that was a bit too shrill, and it affected my enjoyment.
I rated it 3.5 rounded up, but due to a minor yet concerning CW (see below), I will downgrade to a 3⭐️ if I find out this book is YA.
CW (The last is a bit spoilery—read at your own risk past the 🚨): Obviously it’s a murder mystery, so there is some blood and very light descriptions of how the murders happened; two side characters are having an affair and it is revealed that he liked to “strangle” her “in their carnal pleasure.” (This is referred to one other time, but the sentence trails off. Something like, “He liked to put his hands around my neck when we…”); 🚨🚨🚨the MC has her virginity questioned in public and she is mortified by it. (She is a virgin, though she carries guilt for having kissed another man prior to the man she is currently seeing.)
I enjoyed this story despite it not being my usual genre. I listened to the audiobook, however, and I think I would have enjoyed a print copy more. I felt like the reader read the MC in a tone that was a bit too shrill, and it affected my enjoyment.
I rated it 3.5 rounded up, but due to a minor yet concerning CW (see below), I will downgrade to a 3⭐️ if I find out this book is YA.
CW (The last is a bit spoilery—read at your own risk past the 🚨): Obviously it’s a murder mystery, so there is some blood and very light descriptions of how the murders happened; two side characters are having an affair and it is revealed that he liked to “strangle” her “in their carnal pleasure.” (This is referred to one other time, but the sentence trails off. Something like, “He liked to put his hands around my neck when we…”); 🚨🚨🚨the MC has her virginity questioned in public and she is mortified by it. (She is a virgin, though she carries guilt for having kissed another man prior to the man she is currently seeing.)
August 4, 2024
And Then There Were None. Clue. The Hollow Man. And one of my family’s favorite quirky movies, Private Eyes (with the inimitable team of Don Knotts & Tim Conway). I love a good locked room mystery, and Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor by AJ Skelly is a delightful one! The Victorian era, the Christmas season, the winter storm, the English manor, the gathering of ten people with secrets who are competing for a 10,000 pound prize – if they are the first to figure out the puzzle constructed by the odious master of ceremonies…. and IF they can stay alive to do so. All of it created the perfect vibe for bundling up under a cozy blanket (after cranking the air conditioning to make it cold enough in this July heat) and reading this book straight through to the end.
A nice bonus in Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor is the romance! You know I’m always here for a good love story, and when it can be woven through a riveting mystery, all the better. Emma Grace finds herself in attendance at this twisted Christmas party with not only her current beau but her former fiance – the one who broke her heart after his family’s change of fortune. If you think that’s the recipe for a delicious amount of male posturing and longing looks and high amounts of romantic tension, then you would be exactly right, and I loved every minute of it! I had a definite favorite in this tug-of-war for Emma’s heart, a choice that provided plenty of opportunities for blissful sighing and happy swooning on my part. Oh and the kisses! Whew! Keep a fan handy.
Bottom Line: Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor by AJ Skelly combines an entertaining mix of characters, an atmospheric setting, and a twisty mystery with secrets and suspects around every corner. Emma Grace is a likeable narrator whose first person point of view allows us to feel as though we are skulking through the manor close on her heels, one hand on her shoulder for moral support. The whole mood of the novel is wonderfully gothic, and I loved trying to figure out whodunit (even though I was mostly wrong until just the last minute lol). The romance subplot had just the right amount of tension and spark without detracting from the mystery. Put on your deerstalker hat, grab your invitation, and get ready to follow the clues in this quick-but-engaging read!
(I voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book which I purchased for my own collection.)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
A nice bonus in Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor is the romance! You know I’m always here for a good love story, and when it can be woven through a riveting mystery, all the better. Emma Grace finds herself in attendance at this twisted Christmas party with not only her current beau but her former fiance – the one who broke her heart after his family’s change of fortune. If you think that’s the recipe for a delicious amount of male posturing and longing looks and high amounts of romantic tension, then you would be exactly right, and I loved every minute of it! I had a definite favorite in this tug-of-war for Emma’s heart, a choice that provided plenty of opportunities for blissful sighing and happy swooning on my part. Oh and the kisses! Whew! Keep a fan handy.
Bottom Line: Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor by AJ Skelly combines an entertaining mix of characters, an atmospheric setting, and a twisty mystery with secrets and suspects around every corner. Emma Grace is a likeable narrator whose first person point of view allows us to feel as though we are skulking through the manor close on her heels, one hand on her shoulder for moral support. The whole mood of the novel is wonderfully gothic, and I loved trying to figure out whodunit (even though I was mostly wrong until just the last minute lol). The romance subplot had just the right amount of tension and spark without detracting from the mystery. Put on your deerstalker hat, grab your invitation, and get ready to follow the clues in this quick-but-engaging read!
(I voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book which I purchased for my own collection.)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
August 25, 2024
Murder mystery kissing book alert.
This was FUN!
Okay, I did get a little scared and have to check my closet before going to sleep last night and I was a little disturbed by some of the descriptions of those murdered (as I was supposed to be), but the tension and name calling and the pompous sophistication was just so enjoyable!
Two minor things:
The kissing was a touch more descriptive than what I am used to reading, but only by a pinch or two.
Also, due to circumstances, one character had to undress in front of people of the same gender which was kinda humiliating in both the character's and my opinion, but in context, it unfortunately made sense as to why it happened. It wasn't too uncomfy.
Anyway, the characters were fun (or perfectly awful) and the story held my attention. It was awesome to read a story with the vibes of Clue, Christmas, and dashing romance!
This was FUN!
Okay, I did get a little scared and have to check my closet before going to sleep last night and I was a little disturbed by some of the descriptions of those murdered (as I was supposed to be), but the tension and name calling and the pompous sophistication was just so enjoyable!
Two minor things:
The kissing was a touch more descriptive than what I am used to reading, but only by a pinch or two.
Also, due to circumstances, one character had to undress in front of people of the same gender which was kinda humiliating in both the character's and my opinion, but in context, it unfortunately made sense as to why it happened. It wasn't too uncomfy.
Anyway, the characters were fun (or perfectly awful) and the story held my attention. It was awesome to read a story with the vibes of Clue, Christmas, and dashing romance!
May 6, 2024
With mischief and mayhem around every corner, Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor is a novel that's difficult to put down! Skelly adds just enough intrigue to each character to keep the reader guessing as to who the murderer really is. This "whodunnit" story is an excellent beginning to hopefully more books by AJ Skelly in this genre.
December 21, 2024
Loved the mystery who dunnit vibes! This is such a great read for the Christmas/winter season. It will have you turning page after page wondering what is going to happen next and trying to solves the riddle along with the characters. Not only was it thrilling but there were definitely swoony pages in there too! Lady Hastings is our narrator and I loved her she was sharp and sweet I liked seeing the story from her eyes. This story reminded me of Agatha’s Christie’s and then there were none which is my all time favors Agatha book! Definitely recommend.
November 20, 2024
I didn’t know a holiday themed regency romance would be elevated so with societal scandal, twists and turns, and murder! This is a book with great pacing, a strong voice, and an intriguing “who dunnit” mystery that will hook readers immediately.
Perfect for fans of Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None, the classic board game Clue, and those who love swoony romance—AJ Skelly is the queen of swoon! She is able to write scenes in which we feel the characters’ fall in love, have their heart caught by true love, or dropped and shattered, too. I found myself equally invested in the love triangle of sorts as the main character found herself snow-trapped in a mansion with the man who broke who her heart and the man who was to be her intended and the enticing murder mystery—in which bodies kept falling.
One of the most fun parts of reading this books, is you find yourself putting clues together yourself which creates an immersive experience of sorts. I did correctly predict one key detail of the mystery but there were a couple of twists I did not.
Overall, I definitely recommend to sleuth-readers who love murder mystery as well as fans of sweet romances!
Perfect for fans of Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None, the classic board game Clue, and those who love swoony romance—AJ Skelly is the queen of swoon! She is able to write scenes in which we feel the characters’ fall in love, have their heart caught by true love, or dropped and shattered, too. I found myself equally invested in the love triangle of sorts as the main character found herself snow-trapped in a mansion with the man who broke who her heart and the man who was to be her intended and the enticing murder mystery—in which bodies kept falling.
One of the most fun parts of reading this books, is you find yourself putting clues together yourself which creates an immersive experience of sorts. I did correctly predict one key detail of the mystery but there were a couple of twists I did not.
Overall, I definitely recommend to sleuth-readers who love murder mystery as well as fans of sweet romances!
May 6, 2024
I used to read mysteries by the bunch, but have been more fantasy-focused over the past few years, so this was a treat to pick up! This story was fast-paced and action-packed and gripped me from the start. The clues are woven together in a way that doesn't make everything TOO obvious, but still leaves some crumbs for readers who like to puzzle things out. This made it a really fun read. Plus, there's romantic drama afoot, and I do love my romance! I definitely recommend this for anyone looking for a fun, intriguing mystery.
March 31, 2025
"Initially, I was hesitant about this one. The protagonist's naivety felt a bit overwhelming at the start, and I wasn't sure if I'd connect with the story. However, I'm glad I stuck with it! Once the whirlwind of characters and the compelling murder mystery kicked in, I was completely hooked. I found myself desperately needing to unravel the puzzle and discover the killer's identity.
The plot delivered a solid mystery, keeping me guessing until the very end. The intricate web of characters and their secrets added layers of intrigue, making it impossible to put down. And the narrator? Absolutely fantastic! Their performance brought the story to life and enhanced the overall experience.
If you're looking for a mystery that will surprise you and keep you on the edge of your seat, give this one a try. Don't let the initial impression deter you – the payoff is well worth it!"
June 5, 2024
2 words to describe this book… FUN and SHENANIGANS.
I loved the vibe and setting, the tone and elements were just what I needed at this time! I was about to hit a slump until I remembered I had this waiting for me! Kept me reading at night, wanting to sneak in more swipes (reading on my kindle app on the phone) during the day, had me guessing the whole time!
Content guide:
There is murder, not seen as it happens but the aftermath is described. It’s not gruesome but there is mention of blood.
I loved the vibe and setting, the tone and elements were just what I needed at this time! I was about to hit a slump until I remembered I had this waiting for me! Kept me reading at night, wanting to sneak in more swipes (reading on my kindle app on the phone) during the day, had me guessing the whole time!
Content guide:
There is murder, not seen as it happens but the aftermath is described. It’s not gruesome but there is mention of blood.
December 11, 2025
This was a delightful Victorian Christmas closed circle mystery. The main character, Grace Hastings, has been invited to an isolated country house for a Christmas party. Once there, she runs into an old love with whom she has a complicated history. The guests are then challenged to solve a riddle worth 10,000 pounds. The shocking twist is that the riddle is full of the guests' darkest secrets, and before the end of the evening, there is a murder. I ended up enjoying the story quite a bit as it kept my attention and kept me guessing as to whodunnit. I didn't like how melodramatic some of the writing was at times but other than that, it was good.
December 22, 2024
3.5🌟
I was intrigued when I heard this book was a Victorian/romance version of Agatha Christie's "And Then There Were None" overall it was enjoyable, if your not a fan of somewhat descriptive murder mysteries this probably won't be your cup of tea. Some of the murders seem to be a bit implausible and I could have done without some of the heavier kissing scenes and lascivious thoughts and comments of some of the male characters
I was intrigued when I heard this book was a Victorian/romance version of Agatha Christie's "And Then There Were None" overall it was enjoyable, if your not a fan of somewhat descriptive murder mysteries this probably won't be your cup of tea. Some of the murders seem to be a bit implausible and I could have done without some of the heavier kissing scenes and lascivious thoughts and comments of some of the male characters
May 23, 2024
This was so good! I read the whole thing in one sitting. I loved that it felt like reading an Agatha Christie book. It had the right amount of mystery and romance. I can see myself reading this again and enjoying it again.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
December 9, 2024
This was a fun mystery for this time of year! Although there were not a lot of Christmas vibes, the story is set during the Christmas season in the middle of a blizzard. It had a classic Clue feel to it, and I was working to figure out “who done it?” right alongside the main characters. With lots of twists and turns, this story will keep you guessing until the very end!
January 4, 2025
I read this book over Christmas and enjoyed it immensely! In addition to the And Then There Were None and Clue comparisons that many reviewers have made, I also detect a hint of Jane Austen in the book. Maybe it has to do with some of the societal conventions or maybe it's the FMC herself.
Speaking of the FMC, I found her fun and relatable, but it was very much the whodunnit/whydunnit element kept me turning pages. I love a good murder mystery! Overall a quick, fun holiday read with the right balance of coziness and intrigue!
Speaking of the FMC, I found her fun and relatable, but it was very much the whodunnit/whydunnit element kept me turning pages. I love a good murder mystery! Overall a quick, fun holiday read with the right balance of coziness and intrigue!
April 2, 2025
I normally love this author’s books but there were too many characters. Yes, I realize that this is a retelling of And Then There Were None but we still had all the characters present in the story until ~44% through the story.
December 13, 2024
Clue, but make it more festive. ❄️
I called the killer pretty quickly but still enjoyed this page-turning murder mystery/second-chance romance.
I called the killer pretty quickly but still enjoyed this page-turning murder mystery/second-chance romance.
December 29, 2024
Some minor issues, but a fun Christmas read. And Then There Were None vibes.
January 6, 2025
A delightfully atmospheric romp with twists and feels aplenty.
December 20, 2025
Great Book!
What a fantastic book! The characters, the story, the flow. I couldn't put it down. I highly recommend it, especially for those who like mysteries.
What a fantastic book! The characters, the story, the flow. I couldn't put it down. I highly recommend it, especially for those who like mysteries.
June 27, 2024
I may have stayed up into the wee hours to finish this one. It was absolutely worth it! This is such a good who-done-it with twists and turns around every corner. And when the villain was finally revealed I had that wonderful moment of “what? Oh of course!” That only the best writers pull off because they left you breadcrumbs throughout. Beautifully written! Loved the characters, loved the pacing, loved the setting and I especially loved the thought put into using period accurate expressions! Well done!
June 26, 2024
For all the historical cozy mystery fans out there, this is one to devour!
Visit the Victorian era version of CLUE where a group of individuals are invited together for a weekend at Mistlethwaite Manor for the most illustrious Christmas party of the year. It's a party that everyone has heard about and everyone wants to be invited. Especially because there's a $10,000 prize for the winner of the party - and remember this is 1895 - so $10,000 is a lot of money!
But little do they know that to be invited, means something different than what they may have been hoping. Someone knows all the invitees deepest secrets and exposes them all in a way that requires the guests to solve the riddle and determine who is who. Not to mention.. there's a murderer among them as well.
Emma Grace is a wonderful leading lady in this cozy mystery. She's intelligent, cunning and has her heart stuck between two of the men in attendance. Her former fiancé who lost his family's money, but still holds Emma's heart and her current beau who she is pretty sure is about to propose. The love triangle between these three was hilarious throughout the story.
"He hadn't strayed far from my side but gave the illusion of space to pacify Percy. While I appreciated his gesture, I was still caught in a tug of war between the two. My old love and my new almost-betrothed. Even if that was ridiculous. Or so my brain told me. My heart was having a different conversation."
What I loved most in this book was how Skelly dove right into the murder mystery aspect and threw the characters into immediate chaos. Keep in mind, there are A LOT of characters in this one and she does an astounding job of keeping their personalities represented in the midst of the chaos.
The main characters, in my opinion, were those involved in the love triangle though and they are the ones you get to see the most from throughout the story. Emma Grace, her former fiancé Andrew Harrigan, and her current soon-to-be-betrothed Percy Crofton. Emma's character is brave throughout this as well - not letting the overwhelming fear take control, but allowing herself time to contemplate and solve the mystery.
A great read for those that like a fun cozy murder mystery and a historical setting for all of it! There are depictions of some of the character deaths, but nothing overly graphic in my opinion, and it does contain some kissing on contact between some of the characters.
Visit the Victorian era version of CLUE where a group of individuals are invited together for a weekend at Mistlethwaite Manor for the most illustrious Christmas party of the year. It's a party that everyone has heard about and everyone wants to be invited. Especially because there's a $10,000 prize for the winner of the party - and remember this is 1895 - so $10,000 is a lot of money!
But little do they know that to be invited, means something different than what they may have been hoping. Someone knows all the invitees deepest secrets and exposes them all in a way that requires the guests to solve the riddle and determine who is who. Not to mention.. there's a murderer among them as well.
Emma Grace is a wonderful leading lady in this cozy mystery. She's intelligent, cunning and has her heart stuck between two of the men in attendance. Her former fiancé who lost his family's money, but still holds Emma's heart and her current beau who she is pretty sure is about to propose. The love triangle between these three was hilarious throughout the story.
"He hadn't strayed far from my side but gave the illusion of space to pacify Percy. While I appreciated his gesture, I was still caught in a tug of war between the two. My old love and my new almost-betrothed. Even if that was ridiculous. Or so my brain told me. My heart was having a different conversation."
What I loved most in this book was how Skelly dove right into the murder mystery aspect and threw the characters into immediate chaos. Keep in mind, there are A LOT of characters in this one and she does an astounding job of keeping their personalities represented in the midst of the chaos.
The main characters, in my opinion, were those involved in the love triangle though and they are the ones you get to see the most from throughout the story. Emma Grace, her former fiancé Andrew Harrigan, and her current soon-to-be-betrothed Percy Crofton. Emma's character is brave throughout this as well - not letting the overwhelming fear take control, but allowing herself time to contemplate and solve the mystery.
A great read for those that like a fun cozy murder mystery and a historical setting for all of it! There are depictions of some of the character deaths, but nothing overly graphic in my opinion, and it does contain some kissing on contact between some of the characters.
June 12, 2024
Endorsement:
A novella for the Agatha Christie fan in you looking through the next literary door for another dead body, Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor is a tale of intrigue written with Skelly's trademark swoon, heart-pounding moments, and a lovely dash of wit. As the mystery unravels, you'll be simultaneously wishing you could join the gathering at Mistlethwaite Manor—a delightfully gothic location plucked straight from the English moors and likely your favourite books—while also thanking your lucky stars that you missed this particular invitation, because though the setting is marvelous and the romance is lovely, there's scandal and danger afoot!
A novella for the Agatha Christie fan in you looking through the next literary door for another dead body, Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor is a tale of intrigue written with Skelly's trademark swoon, heart-pounding moments, and a lovely dash of wit. As the mystery unravels, you'll be simultaneously wishing you could join the gathering at Mistlethwaite Manor—a delightfully gothic location plucked straight from the English moors and likely your favourite books—while also thanking your lucky stars that you missed this particular invitation, because though the setting is marvelous and the romance is lovely, there's scandal and danger afoot!
August 2, 2024
MURDER AT MISTLETHWAITE MANOR
By AJ Skelly
Lady Emma Grace Hastings is thrilled. She's received a coveted invitation to a Christmas party at Mistlethwaite Manor. The exclusive event also involves a game with the winner receiving a 10,000 pound prize! But delight turns to horror when she discovers the identity of her host, and the fact that the game requires that sordid secrets be revealed. Worried about her own past Emma Grace also has to deal with the secrets of her fellow guests, which include the man she hopes to marry as well as her former fiancé. Before the night ends a dead body is discovered. As a winter storm rages outside Emma Grace will have to keep her wits about her even as the body count increases. Will she be able to survive or will hers be the next body to be found?
A dream party turns into a nightmare for our protagonist Lady Emma Grace. She makes an innocent foil to pretty much everybody else at the party. While she is innocent, she also possesses a good mind which helps her work through the murderous events. It’s interesting to follow her mind, and her heart, as she considers the actions of her would be fiancé to that of her former fiancé. As for the other guests…and the host…what a group! For the most part people you’d prefer never to engage with, all making for great suspects. And more than one big surprise awaits as the evening continues.
Depravity and devious machinations make for a complex mystery fraught with tension. I really enjoyed this thrilling mystery. Skillfully blending historical ambiance and romance this suspenseful mystery with periodic horrific events kept me reading well past my bedtime. I commiserated with Emma Grace, hoping she’d come to the same conclusion as I as to her future happiness and appreciated that she didn’t take anything for granted.
While MURDER AT MISTLETHWAITE MANOR is described as a historical cozy mystery, I would say that it is a traditional mystery and not a cozy. While the violence does occur offstage its descriptions are quite vivid. The resulting verisimilitude makes for exciting reading and certainly ups the stakes…and danger level. In addition to our amateur sleuths, it is cozy like in that in the end justice is meted out. We also get the happy ending found in romance novels; an ending that certainly made me smile!
Dastardly characters and evil acts committed in a snowbound secluded manor create a powder keg that is MURDER AT MISTLETHWAITE MANOR.
By AJ Skelly
Lady Emma Grace Hastings is thrilled. She's received a coveted invitation to a Christmas party at Mistlethwaite Manor. The exclusive event also involves a game with the winner receiving a 10,000 pound prize! But delight turns to horror when she discovers the identity of her host, and the fact that the game requires that sordid secrets be revealed. Worried about her own past Emma Grace also has to deal with the secrets of her fellow guests, which include the man she hopes to marry as well as her former fiancé. Before the night ends a dead body is discovered. As a winter storm rages outside Emma Grace will have to keep her wits about her even as the body count increases. Will she be able to survive or will hers be the next body to be found?
A dream party turns into a nightmare for our protagonist Lady Emma Grace. She makes an innocent foil to pretty much everybody else at the party. While she is innocent, she also possesses a good mind which helps her work through the murderous events. It’s interesting to follow her mind, and her heart, as she considers the actions of her would be fiancé to that of her former fiancé. As for the other guests…and the host…what a group! For the most part people you’d prefer never to engage with, all making for great suspects. And more than one big surprise awaits as the evening continues.
Depravity and devious machinations make for a complex mystery fraught with tension. I really enjoyed this thrilling mystery. Skillfully blending historical ambiance and romance this suspenseful mystery with periodic horrific events kept me reading well past my bedtime. I commiserated with Emma Grace, hoping she’d come to the same conclusion as I as to her future happiness and appreciated that she didn’t take anything for granted.
While MURDER AT MISTLETHWAITE MANOR is described as a historical cozy mystery, I would say that it is a traditional mystery and not a cozy. While the violence does occur offstage its descriptions are quite vivid. The resulting verisimilitude makes for exciting reading and certainly ups the stakes…and danger level. In addition to our amateur sleuths, it is cozy like in that in the end justice is meted out. We also get the happy ending found in romance novels; an ending that certainly made me smile!
Dastardly characters and evil acts committed in a snowbound secluded manor create a powder keg that is MURDER AT MISTLETHWAITE MANOR.
September 9, 2024
Move over Agatha Christie—AJ Skelly has penned another fabulous whodunnit in Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor. Christmas holiday weekend guests, recipients of an envied and highly sought-after invitation by the ton, are invited to Mistlethwaite Manor by an unknown and mysterious host who promises a merry holiday weekend. The anonymous host also promises that the guest who can successfully solve a puzzle he created will be the winner of a 10,000-pound prize.
Emma Grace Hastings (Lady Hastings) is thrilled to receive an invitation to the holiday soiree that is the talk of the ton. What better opportunity to impress Percy Crofton, from whom she expects a marriage proposal any day? Marrying Percy would assure her a safe, stable place in society. Upon her arrival, Emma Grace is shocked to discover that not only is Percy in attendance but so is Andrew Harrigan, the man to whom she gave her heart over a year ago. They had plans to marry until Andrew’s family suddenly lost their fortune and status in society. Andrew quickly broke off their engagement, leaving a heartbroken Emma Grace in his wake.
As the remainder of the guests become known and the poem’s riddle to be solved is read, the cast of outlandish and often irritating fellow guests find themselves dwindling as one after the other is found dead under mysterious and shadowy circumstances. All the while, Percy and Andrew vie for Emma Grace’s attention and opportunities to keep her safe from harm. The battle of wills escalates until their focus is seemingly more on each other than on discovering the potential murderer until . . . the murderer’s dastardly hand is shockingly revealed.
With outstanding writing by AJ Skelly and incredible and dramatically effective world-building, the extraordinary and powerfully wrought characters evolve with a fantastic plot that slowly and purposefully unfolds, as seen through the alert and terrified Emma Grace, who is torn between what’s safe in Percy Crofton and what her heart truly desires in Andrew Harrigan. Will the murderer succeed in tearing her from either, or both, of them at Mistlethwaite Manor, or will the unforeseen revelation of the murderer’s identity be a shock she simply can’t overcome?
Gothic murder mysteries just don’t get any better—this is a breathtaking read of the highest order. The pages just simply can’t be turned and read fast enough. If you read one murder mystery all year, it should be Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor. ~ Lindy for Novels Alive
Emma Grace Hastings (Lady Hastings) is thrilled to receive an invitation to the holiday soiree that is the talk of the ton. What better opportunity to impress Percy Crofton, from whom she expects a marriage proposal any day? Marrying Percy would assure her a safe, stable place in society. Upon her arrival, Emma Grace is shocked to discover that not only is Percy in attendance but so is Andrew Harrigan, the man to whom she gave her heart over a year ago. They had plans to marry until Andrew’s family suddenly lost their fortune and status in society. Andrew quickly broke off their engagement, leaving a heartbroken Emma Grace in his wake.
As the remainder of the guests become known and the poem’s riddle to be solved is read, the cast of outlandish and often irritating fellow guests find themselves dwindling as one after the other is found dead under mysterious and shadowy circumstances. All the while, Percy and Andrew vie for Emma Grace’s attention and opportunities to keep her safe from harm. The battle of wills escalates until their focus is seemingly more on each other than on discovering the potential murderer until . . . the murderer’s dastardly hand is shockingly revealed.
With outstanding writing by AJ Skelly and incredible and dramatically effective world-building, the extraordinary and powerfully wrought characters evolve with a fantastic plot that slowly and purposefully unfolds, as seen through the alert and terrified Emma Grace, who is torn between what’s safe in Percy Crofton and what her heart truly desires in Andrew Harrigan. Will the murderer succeed in tearing her from either, or both, of them at Mistlethwaite Manor, or will the unforeseen revelation of the murderer’s identity be a shock she simply can’t overcome?
Gothic murder mysteries just don’t get any better—this is a breathtaking read of the highest order. The pages just simply can’t be turned and read fast enough. If you read one murder mystery all year, it should be Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor. ~ Lindy for Novels Alive
May 8, 2025
From a writing craft perspective, this book was fine. If memory serves me right it was weirdly missing a few words from the beginning or middle of sentences, but I get it, it happens. The plot inconsistencies/story holes, though, were what made me knock Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor down to two stars.
First, what happens to Mrs. Leonard's body? She's discovered dead in the library, I remember no mention of any character moving her body, yet when the guests revisit that room a day or two later, there's no mention of it still being there.
Also, the Wentworths have multiple problems. One, either Mr. Wentworth hung himself (per the beginning of the book) or he shot himself (per Mrs. Wentworth later in the book when justifying why she brought a gun to the manor). Also, the gun itself presents a problem. Mrs. Wentworth claims she brought it to make the host shoot himself just like the host led her husband to shoot himself. Except no one knew who the host was before arriving at the manor. So, what, she carries a gun everywhere she goes in case she runs into this man?
Another thing about the gun. Andrew says he found it sticking out of someone's luggage, which implies he took it shortly after the guests' arrival at the manor. Which would also mean he took it before there was a murder. Why steal a gun if no one has been killed yet?
One final example: before her untimely demise, Mrs. Leonard tells Emma Grace the men's rooms are on one side of the hallway and the women's rooms are on the other. How, then, does a secret passageway behind the rooms alternately pass a man's room, then a woman's room, then a man's room, and so on? Based on the earlier description of room arrangements, it would pass all the women's rooms first, then when they crossed to the other side of the hall it would pass all the men's rooms.
There are more examples I could list, though they are small inconsistencies that don't really affect the plot. However, all together they made for a disappointing read. I don't say all this to be rude, but so mainly other readers can know if they had the same reading experience as I did, they're not alone, and to help potential readers make a decision in whether they want to give the book a try anyway.
First, what happens to Mrs. Leonard's body? She's discovered dead in the library, I remember no mention of any character moving her body, yet when the guests revisit that room a day or two later, there's no mention of it still being there.
Also, the Wentworths have multiple problems. One, either Mr. Wentworth hung himself (per the beginning of the book) or he shot himself (per Mrs. Wentworth later in the book when justifying why she brought a gun to the manor). Also, the gun itself presents a problem. Mrs. Wentworth claims she brought it to make the host shoot himself just like the host led her husband to shoot himself. Except no one knew who the host was before arriving at the manor. So, what, she carries a gun everywhere she goes in case she runs into this man?
Another thing about the gun. Andrew says he found it sticking out of someone's luggage, which implies he took it shortly after the guests' arrival at the manor. Which would also mean he took it before there was a murder. Why steal a gun if no one has been killed yet?
One final example: before her untimely demise, Mrs. Leonard tells Emma Grace the men's rooms are on one side of the hallway and the women's rooms are on the other. How, then, does a secret passageway behind the rooms alternately pass a man's room, then a woman's room, then a man's room, and so on? Based on the earlier description of room arrangements, it would pass all the women's rooms first, then when they crossed to the other side of the hall it would pass all the men's rooms.
There are more examples I could list, though they are small inconsistencies that don't really affect the plot. However, all together they made for a disappointing read. I don't say all this to be rude, but so mainly other readers can know if they had the same reading experience as I did, they're not alone, and to help potential readers make a decision in whether they want to give the book a try anyway.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 6, 2025
interesting story
Perhaps not the best written novel I’ve ever read, but the plot and the premise of what gathers everyone together for this Christmastime–related event hold a great deal of promise. It was for this reason that I plodded along. The writing is OK, though in some ways, it moves too quickly because there is very little supporting detail. Some detail is important to set the mood and to provide easy transitions in conversation and scene changes. Many of these things were handled a little more abruptly than I was comfortable with, making the story feel a little choppy. The story is a little confusing with all of the different characters, but in the end, it does not rob the story of the mystery and the surprises the author has in store for the reader. As a whodunit, there is definitely surprise in discovering the answer to who is responsible for all of the murders. Surprisingly, Emma Grace settles into the woman she wants to be, and makes a decision to have a say in her fate. This story has romance in it, which is handled very sweetly. There is no vulgarity, no sex (just some racey kissing), and no gore. There are murders, but there is not a great deal of detail. (There is one instance of suicide.)
This was a nice little read. Without a lot of detail, the plot moved along rather swiftly. I would probably give it 3.5 stars, however, I bumped it up to four for its entertainment value (and because we can’t leave half-star reviews). The only thing that aggravated me was Emma Grace‘s use of “An-Mr. Harrigan” instead of “Andrew“ much too frequently before she finally says something like “blast it, Andrew,“ and stops stumbling over his name. It took much too long for that to happen. (A small thing.)
The previews liken this to Agatha Christie’s story “And Then There Were None,” but I definitely felt the story was much like the game of Clue, though not as playful.
If you’re looking for something relatively light with suspense and romance, this might be just the thing, and it won’t take very long to read it.
Perhaps not the best written novel I’ve ever read, but the plot and the premise of what gathers everyone together for this Christmastime–related event hold a great deal of promise. It was for this reason that I plodded along. The writing is OK, though in some ways, it moves too quickly because there is very little supporting detail. Some detail is important to set the mood and to provide easy transitions in conversation and scene changes. Many of these things were handled a little more abruptly than I was comfortable with, making the story feel a little choppy. The story is a little confusing with all of the different characters, but in the end, it does not rob the story of the mystery and the surprises the author has in store for the reader. As a whodunit, there is definitely surprise in discovering the answer to who is responsible for all of the murders. Surprisingly, Emma Grace settles into the woman she wants to be, and makes a decision to have a say in her fate. This story has romance in it, which is handled very sweetly. There is no vulgarity, no sex (just some racey kissing), and no gore. There are murders, but there is not a great deal of detail. (There is one instance of suicide.)
This was a nice little read. Without a lot of detail, the plot moved along rather swiftly. I would probably give it 3.5 stars, however, I bumped it up to four for its entertainment value (and because we can’t leave half-star reviews). The only thing that aggravated me was Emma Grace‘s use of “An-Mr. Harrigan” instead of “Andrew“ much too frequently before she finally says something like “blast it, Andrew,“ and stops stumbling over his name. It took much too long for that to happen. (A small thing.)
The previews liken this to Agatha Christie’s story “And Then There Were None,” but I definitely felt the story was much like the game of Clue, though not as playful.
If you’re looking for something relatively light with suspense and romance, this might be just the thing, and it won’t take very long to read it.
August 8, 2024
I am a huge fan of historical mysteries and am always on the hunt for a new favorite. When I saw the cover for Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor by AJ Skelly and then read the first line of the book summary (“Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None meets The Gilded Age in this delicious, suspenseful murder mystery.”) I knew I had to read this so I loaded it up on my kindle intending to read it right away. I read this page-turning mystery in one giant gulp, ignoring everyone and everything around me.
This was SO good. I mean…so so so good. First, there’s the intriguing cover that captured my attention immediately. Then the author includes a character sheet, but just not a list – a page of pictures of characters in fancy frames. Sprinkled throughout the mystery there are more pictures (such as a picture of an invitation) and these touches elevated my reading experience. It’s the perfect amount that it doesn’t disrupt the reading.
This locked room mystery kicks off almost right away, and hold onto your hats, because it is a wild, mysterious ride with murder almost around every corner. Similar in plot structure to the movie Clue, but with a more serious vibe. The winter/Christmas time setting and being trapped by a snowstorm added to the drama of the story. I think I suspected everyone in this story as I tried to follow the clues, but then something else would happen and I’d throw all my theories out the window. I loved following Emma Grace through the manor house, holding my breath as she was trapped with an eclectic group of citizens. Who could she trust? There was also a little bit of romance here for our Emma Grace and it mixed perfectly with the mystery. This was so well done – such an entertaining read. My first read by AJ Skelly, but not my last! @quill.and.flame.publishers
This was SO good. I mean…so so so good. First, there’s the intriguing cover that captured my attention immediately. Then the author includes a character sheet, but just not a list – a page of pictures of characters in fancy frames. Sprinkled throughout the mystery there are more pictures (such as a picture of an invitation) and these touches elevated my reading experience. It’s the perfect amount that it doesn’t disrupt the reading.
This locked room mystery kicks off almost right away, and hold onto your hats, because it is a wild, mysterious ride with murder almost around every corner. Similar in plot structure to the movie Clue, but with a more serious vibe. The winter/Christmas time setting and being trapped by a snowstorm added to the drama of the story. I think I suspected everyone in this story as I tried to follow the clues, but then something else would happen and I’d throw all my theories out the window. I loved following Emma Grace through the manor house, holding my breath as she was trapped with an eclectic group of citizens. Who could she trust? There was also a little bit of romance here for our Emma Grace and it mixed perfectly with the mystery. This was so well done – such an entertaining read. My first read by AJ Skelly, but not my last! @quill.and.flame.publishers
Read
January 21, 2025Tired of the same old Hallmark stories at Christmas but still want a Christmas read? Do you like romance AND mystery? This would fit the bill! Honestly, I love a good Christmas novel, and I'm not against even a bit of a cliche story if it's Christmas story, BUT Skelly's Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor is not your cliche Christmas novel!
She wove beloved tropes (locked room mystery, second chance romance, whodunnit, heiress, secrets--so many secrets--and more) together into a fresh tale full of a quirky, intriguing cast of characters pitted against each other. The novel's "cat and mouse game" kept me guessing at every turn. The romantic arc gave me all the feels and was well-integrated into the storyline without taking it over or feeling like a side story either. I enjoyed every detailed historical minute in the gilded age mansion with its wintry festive holiday backdrop.
AJ Skelly's writing style is evocative and fast paced, rich with verbs that aid the pacing and immersive reader experience. She does "swoon" well, no spice, and, personally as a historical fiction fan, I was pleased to see her weave in fun historical tidbits while deftly avoiding long description, exposition, or other historical heavy-handedness. Some romance authors will sacrifice historical authenticity for the romantic storyline, but I felt like the romance was fairly represented for the era, considering the circumstances and setting. Skelly struck an excellent balance of a mystery romance in a historical setting with Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor. And all in a “Christmas novel” too! Definitely worth reading and don’t wait until next Christmas!
She wove beloved tropes (locked room mystery, second chance romance, whodunnit, heiress, secrets--so many secrets--and more) together into a fresh tale full of a quirky, intriguing cast of characters pitted against each other. The novel's "cat and mouse game" kept me guessing at every turn. The romantic arc gave me all the feels and was well-integrated into the storyline without taking it over or feeling like a side story either. I enjoyed every detailed historical minute in the gilded age mansion with its wintry festive holiday backdrop.
AJ Skelly's writing style is evocative and fast paced, rich with verbs that aid the pacing and immersive reader experience. She does "swoon" well, no spice, and, personally as a historical fiction fan, I was pleased to see her weave in fun historical tidbits while deftly avoiding long description, exposition, or other historical heavy-handedness. Some romance authors will sacrifice historical authenticity for the romantic storyline, but I felt like the romance was fairly represented for the era, considering the circumstances and setting. Skelly struck an excellent balance of a mystery romance in a historical setting with Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor. And all in a “Christmas novel” too! Definitely worth reading and don’t wait until next Christmas!
August 1, 2024
If you love a good closed room mystery, you’ll love Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor by AJ Skelly. It’s a Victorian era cozy mystery set during a Christmas season snowstorm at Mistlethwaite Manor. Mistlethwaite Manor is where everyone who’s anyone wants to be invited for the party. No one who has been to a party there says anything about it. Outsiders don’t even know who the Master of the Manor is which makes this an even more sought after party invitation.
I love this type of mystery because you’ve got a small pool of suspects from whom to choose, and those start dropping like flies, which gives it the And Then There Were None vibe. Since the point of the game that the master has insisted they play is to figure out who each line of a scathing poem relates to, that puts everyone in the spotlight. Some secrets…well, the murderer has decided his or hers is scandalous enough to kill to keep quiet.
Like Lady Emma Grace Hastings, I’d definitely want an invitation to this party if I didn’t know any better! You’d expect good food and entertainment! Who goes to a party where the host is a monster who loves to play with people’s lives?! No one. Hence, the secrets. I love the time period, the manor setting, and the snowstorm! I thought that everything about the set up for this mystery was brilliant, and the pacing was very good. I enjoyed trying to figure out who the murderer was and why this person was killing people.
I highly recommend Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor for its interesting and well-written characters, closed room-like setting, and suspenseful mystery!
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
I love this type of mystery because you’ve got a small pool of suspects from whom to choose, and those start dropping like flies, which gives it the And Then There Were None vibe. Since the point of the game that the master has insisted they play is to figure out who each line of a scathing poem relates to, that puts everyone in the spotlight. Some secrets…well, the murderer has decided his or hers is scandalous enough to kill to keep quiet.
Like Lady Emma Grace Hastings, I’d definitely want an invitation to this party if I didn’t know any better! You’d expect good food and entertainment! Who goes to a party where the host is a monster who loves to play with people’s lives?! No one. Hence, the secrets. I love the time period, the manor setting, and the snowstorm! I thought that everything about the set up for this mystery was brilliant, and the pacing was very good. I enjoyed trying to figure out who the murderer was and why this person was killing people.
I highly recommend Murder at Mistlethwaite Manor for its interesting and well-written characters, closed room-like setting, and suspenseful mystery!
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 90 reviews