I really wanted to give this collection of DC Pride stories a higher review than I did, but it just fell short compared to the previous years’ collections. I think one of the problems was the lack of knowing who all the characters were. And I can admit that’s somewhat my fault (I should be better as a comic geek), but I wish the stories were meatier so I could get a better sense of who these characters are, other than being part of the LGBTQIA+ canon. And maybe that’s another bigger gripe I have with this collection. Previously issues felt like they were telling these stories because they had to be told, they were essential. The stories in this collection feel more fun and light hearted, like they were just randomly thrown together without thinking of the way they cohesively appear together. For instance, I thought the section where they had a tribute to trans trailblazer Rachel Pollack should’ve been at the very end, but for some reason the editors tacked it in the middle/kinda toward the end. It felt weird.
On a high note, that tribute to Rachel was beautiful and my favorite part of the collection. It was very real and struck a chord with me. A lot of the other stories felt like the characters were gay, trans or whatever just because they happened to be. It had no importance to the story or character sometimes which bugged me. For example, the story featuring Ghost-Maker and Catman just had two heroes boning and for what. They were gay for each other, but what is at stake, what was learned? I guess that they’ll always be there for each other, whether it’s for a quick fight or a quick bone. Is that the message? Is that who my people are? Maybe I’m reading too much into it. I just didn’t connect with a lot of the stories as a gay man personally.
I did like the story with Apollo and Midnighter (although it was a bit corny). I also was somewhat interested in the story at the end about Alan Scott (Green Lantern), but we barely got the story and instead it was the beginning of another storyline that we’ll never know the answer to (cause I probably won’t be checking GL out anytime soon). It just felt pointless, even though I was intrigued. The Nubia story was fun! I liked that she got to fight several different DC villains in a danger room style format. I also liked that the message of that story was finding strength as a unit by finding individual strengths in one another. It takes all types of people to make up a world. This story did a great job at using LGBTQIA+ characters, but not making anything feel forced. Another thing I really loved was the costume design for trans superhero Circuit Breaker. I thought it was smart to use the top surgery scars as part of the costume. It’s a way for the community to see beauty in a past that may sometimes be rooted in pain.
Overall, I appreciate what DC writers and editors are trying to do, but as the G in LGBTQIA+, this wasn’t completely it for me. It missed some marks, had some highs, and some many lows, but I’m not mad I read it. I’m absolutely floored that this comic even exists and I’m happy it does, even though it didn’t live up to my super high expectations. Either way it’s totally worth the read just to be exposed to other super heroes that are unknown and don’t get much time in the spotlight.