This is an amazing book. In many ways it tells me why my exposure to the so called mental health profession has, with one or two exceptions, been a waste of time at best and destructive in ways that simply aggravated the problem at worst. The lack of answers, the lack of guidance, the lack of anything to provide insight into my own suffering and the dependence on western models of psychotherapy, (including the use of medication) almost killed me through despair. Perhaps things for me are more complex than for most people,childhood abuse, alcoholism, war realted ptsd and all the spin off derangement that flowed from them. My instinct is that this is probably not so, people don't end up in a psychiatrists office, a clinic, a mental instiution or a psychologists plastic chair because they are suffering from mild discomfort. They arrive after they have hit the wall, whatever that means to them and they have no more options.
David Brazier explores the world of Buddhist psychology in a clear though needfully limited fashion given the size of the book and the scope of the subject. What does become clear however is that all the fads that have evolved as the basis for most of western pschiatry and psychological exploration have all been covered some 2,500 years ago. What the west has done is reinvent the wheel in pieces. I remember clearly when positive thinking was the rage, Gestalt Therapy had its day along with CBT; the Inner Child had us digging around in all the pain and slating it all home to our parents; the psychboabble of TM and EST and Eckhardt Tolle all captured the attention of we who needed to be fixed somehow. The remarkable thing is that all of these "answers" contained some element of Buddhist pyschology, however they only focussed narrowly on one element, they generally lacked context and internal consistency and integrity or worse they warped the teachings towards commercial gain thereby simply becoming an integral part of the problem.
Refreshingly, the Zen approach to psychotherapy as presented by Brazier rightly points to the emphasis on the separate, discrete ego serving distraction of the sense of self and moves towards the use of process to align with the reality of life; and through that to allow the client to untangle the pain of the knotted sense of self done to, done by or messed up in some other way. The Zen idea of the flow of energy and our need to align with it, has more currency now than ever as the desperate driven need to serve discrete and self serving interest at the expense of connection and community drive the world and its various societies towards destruction of the very planet.
This book should be required reading for anyone in the field or indeed anyone failed by the field. There is new hope here even if in the end it means being able to watch with equanmity the rest of humanity dump our world down the toilet.