I'm giving this book four stars, not because of any literary merit - it is written very much as the author speaks, plain and direct - but because of the story it tells.
With more crashes than an F1 race, more injuries than a Bruce Willis movie and more amazing comebacks than John Farnham, Battle Scars is an exciting and enjoyable read. I highly recommend it to cycling fans for the first person accounts of the best and worst moments of cycling in the past thirty years.
Although the blurb paints the picture of a career brought low in its final moments by revelations of doping, in fact the book is written chronologically, so what it really tells is the story of a career at its lowest moment in 1998 as a young man making the stupidest decision of his life. After twenty years of riding hard, and crashing hard, and riding even harder, the book ends with Stuey's brave decision to come clean about his doping.
The real ending of the story, though, is the one in the reader's mind after closing the book: after the retirement, the confession, the media mess that surrounded cycling in 2012 and 2013 Stuart O'Grady capped his career as a professional cyclist by writing a book in which he takes full responsibility for his own actions, blaming nobody but himself for his stupid decision, and describing his own shame and guilt when he finally told his teammates and his family.
I particularly recommend this book to kids as the story of a man who made a really stupid mistake early on, and fought very hard to achieve so much riding clean. Stuey is determined, tough, loyal to his teammates and has something good to say about everyone, even the people he had disagreements with or maybe didn't get along with. By the end of his cycling career he was highly respected as a smart team captain, a generous mentor to younger riders and a nice guy off the bike.